Estimating the risks of acquiring a kidney abroad: A meta-analysis of complications following participation in transplant tourism

Clinical Transplantation

Volumn 26, Issue 3, 2012, Pages

  Anker, Ashley E ^a   Feeley, Thomas H ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY AT BUFFALO   (United States)

Author keywords

Commercial transplant; Kidney transplantation; Living donors; Organ trade; Organ trafficking; Organ transplantation

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CHINA; COMPARATIVE STUDY; CYTOMEGALOVIRUS; DIABETES MELLITUS; EFFECT SIZE; GRAFT SURVIVAL; HEALTH CARE UTILIZATION; HEPATITIS B; HUMAN; HUMAN IMMUNODEFICIENCY VIRUS INFECTION; INDIA; KIDNEY GRAFT; MEDICAL TOURISM; META ANALYSIS; PAKISTAN; PATIENT EDUCATION; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RISK ASSESSMENT; SAUDI ARABIA; SURVIVAL RATE; TAIWAN; WOUND INFECTION;

COMMUNICABLE DISEASES; GRAFT REJECTION; HUMANS; KIDNEY TRANSPLANTATION; MEDICAL TOURISM; PROGNOSIS; RISK ASSESSMENT; SURVIVAL RATE; TISSUE AND ORGAN PROCUREMENT; TISSUE DONORS; WAITING LISTS;

EID: 84862240344     PISSN: 09020063     EISSN: 13990012     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1399-0012.2012.01629.x     Document Type: Article

References (62)

1. Shimazono Y. The state of the international organ trade: a provisional picture based on integration of available information. Bull World Health Organ 2007: 85: 955.
2. Frenkel S. Organ-trafficking laws in key countries. Christ Sci Monit 2004: Available at, Accessed March 12 2012.
3. World Health Organization. WHO proposes global agenda on transplantation, 2007. Available at Accessed August 25, 2011.
4. Canales MT, Kasiske BL, Rosenberg ME. Transplant tourism: outcomes of United States residents who undergo kidney transplantation overseas. Transplantation 2006: 82: 1658.
5. Shu K-H, Wu M-J, Chen C-H, Lian J-D. Outcome of kidney transplantation using organs from executed prisoners: is it justified beyond the ethical issue? J Chin Med Assoc 2007: 70: 193.
6. Danovitch GM, Shapiro ME, Lavee J. The use of executed prisoners as a source of organ transplants in China must stop. Am J Transplant 2011: 11: 426.
7. Naqvi SAA, Ali B, Mazhar F, Zafar MN, Rizvi SAH. A socioeconomic survey of kidney vendors in Pakistan. Transplant Int 2007: 20: 934.
8. Abouna GM, Kumar MSA, Samhan M, Dadah SK, John P, Sabawi NM. Commercialization in human organs: a Middle Eastern perspective. Transplant Proc 1990: 22: 918.
9. Gill J, Madhira BR, Gjertson D et al. Transplant tourism in the United States: a single-center experience. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 2008: 8: 1820.
10. Scheper-Hughes N. Organs without borders. Foreign Policy 2005: 146: 26.
11. United Network for Organ Sharing. Data reports. Available at Accessed August 25, 2011.
12. Merion RM, Barnes AD, Lin M et al. Transplants in foreign countries among patients removed from the US transplant waiting list. Am J Transplant 2008: 8: 988.
13. Al-Wakeel J, Mitwalli AH, Tarif N et al. Living unrelated renal transplant: outcome and issues. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl 2000: 11: 553.
14. Coker A, Ok E, Tokat Y, Hoscoskun C, Kaplan H, Yararbas O. Evaluation of patients transplanted in countries other than Turkey. Transplant Proc 1994: 26: 2455.
15. Ackoundou-N'Guessan C, Gnionsahe DA, Dekou AH, Tia WM, Guei CM, Moudachirou AM. Outcomes of renal patients from the Ivory Coast transplanted abroad: time for a local kidney transplantation program. Transplant Proc 2010: 42: 3517.
16. Chien YS, Hsieh HH, Hsu KT. Clinical analysis of 100 renal transplant recipients back from the People's Republic of China to Taiwan. Transplant Proc 2000: 32: 1819.
17. Ben Hamida F, Abdallah TB, Goucha R et al. Outcome of living unrelated (commercial) renal transplantation: report of 20 cases. Transplant Proc 2001: 33: 2660.
18. Kennedy SE, Shen Y, Charlesworth JA et al. Outcome of overseas commercial kidney transplantation: an Australian perspective. Med J Aust 2005: 182: 224.
19. Ivanovski N, Popov Z, Cakalaroski K, Masin J, Spasovski G, Zafirovska K. Living-unrelated (paid) renal transplantation - ten years later. Transplant Proc 2005: 37: 563.
20. Morad Z, Lim TO. Outcome of overseas kidney transplantation in Malaysia. Transplant Proc 2000: 32: 1485.
21. Sajjad I, Baines LS, Patel P, Salifu MO, Jindal RM. Commercialization of kidney transplants: a systematic review of outcomes in recipients and donors. Am J Nephrol 2008: 28: 744.
22. Ghods AJ, Savaj S. Iranian model of paid and regulated living-unrelated kidney donation. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 2006: 1: 1136.
23. Declaration of Istanbul on Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism. Definitions. Available at Accessed October 25, 2011.
24. Borenstein M, Hedges L, Higgins J, Rothstein H. Comprehensive Meta-Analysis. [Computer Program]. Version 2.0. Englewood, NJ: Biostat, 2005.
25. Field AP. Meta-analysis of correlation coefficients: a monte carlo comparison of fixed- and random-effects methods. Psychol Methods 2001: 6: 161.
26. Hedges LV, Vevea JL. Fixed- and random-effects models in meta-analysis. Psychol Methods 1998: 3: 486.
27. Anker AE, Reinhart AM, Feeley TH. Meta-analysis of meta-analyses in communication: comparing fixed- and random-effects models. Commun Quart 2010: 58: 1.
28. Lipsey MW, Wilson DB. Practical meta-analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2001.
29. DerSimonian R, Laird N. Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Control Clin Trials 1986: 7: 177.
30. Freeman MF, Tukey JW. Transformations related to the angular and the square root. Ann Math Stat 1950: 21: 607.
31. Al Shohaib S. Organ trading: a medical or ethical mistake? Nephron 1996: 73: 106.
32. Sun C-Y, Lee C-C, Chang C-T, Hung C-C, Wu M-S. Commercial cadaveric renal transplant: an ethical rather than medical issue. Clin Transplant 2006: 20: 340.
33. Bramstedt KA. Probing transplant and living donor candidates about their participation in organ vending. Prog Transplant 2010: 20: 292.
34. Parmar MKB, Torri V, Stewart L. Extracting summary statistics to perform meta-analyses of the published literature for survival endpoints. Stat Med 1998: 17: 2815.
35. Duchateau L, Collette L, Sylvester R, Pignon J-P. Estimating number of events from the Kaplan-Meier curve for incorporation in a literature-based meta-analysis: What you don't see you can't get! Biometrics 2000: 56: 886.
36. Alghamdi SA, Nabi ZG, Alkhafaji DM et al. Transplant tourism outcome: a single center experience. Clin Transl Res 2010: 90: 184.
37. Chaballout A, Said R, Duarte R, Nezamuddin N. Living related-cadaveric-living-unrelated kidney transplants: a comparison study at Kind Fahad hospital, Riyadh. Transplant Proc 1992: 24: 1836.
38. Cheng IKP, Lai KN, Au TC, Chan PSF, Poon GP, Chan YT. Comparison of the mortality and morbidity rate between proper and unconventional renal transplantation using organs from executed prisoners. Transplant Proc 1991: 23: 2533.
39. Higgins R, West N, Fletcher S, Stein A, Lam F, Kashi H. Kidney transplantation in patients travelling from the UK to India or Pakistan. Nephrol Dial Transplant 2003: 18: 851.
40. Hsu C-C, Lee C-H, Hwang S-J et al. Outcomes of overseas kidney transplantation in chronic haemodialysis patients in Taiwan. Nephrology 2011: 16: 341.
41. Ivanovski N, Masin J, Rambabova-Busljetic I et al. The outcome of commercial kidney transplant tourism in Pakistan. Clin Transplant 2011: 25: 171.
42. Krishnan N, Cockwell P, Devulapally P et al. Organ trafficking for live donor kidney transplantation in Indoasians resident in the West Midlands: high activity and poor outcomes. Clin Transl Res 2010: 89: 1456.
43. Kucuk M, Sever MS, Turkmen A et al. Demographic analysis and outcome features in a transplant outpatient clinic. Transplant Proc 2005: 37: 743.
44. Mansy H, Khalil A, Aly TF et al. Outcome of commercial renal transplantation: two years follow-up. Nephron 1996: 74: 613.
45. Onwubalili JK, Obineche EN, Assuhaimi A, Bassiouni M. Outcome of bought living non-related donor kidneys followed up at a single centre. Transplant Int 1994: 7: 27.
46. Prabhakar KS, Vathsala A, Woo KT. Long-term outcome of living-unrelated donor kidney transplantation. Transplant Proc 2000: 32: 1807.
47. Prasad GVR, Shukla A, Huang M, D'A Honey RJ, Zaltzman JS. Outcomes of commercial renal transplantation: a Canadian experience. Transplantation 2006: 82: 1130.
48. Qunibi W. Commercially motivated renal transplantation: results in 540 patients transplanted in India. Clin Transplant 1997: 11: 536.
49. Rizvi SAH, Naqvi SAA, Zafar MN et al. Commercial transplants in local Pakistanis from vended kidneys: a socio-economic and outcome study. Transplant Int 2009: 22: 615.
50. Turkmen A, Sever M, Ecder T et al. Posttransplant malaria. Transplantation 1996: 62: 1521.
51. Akpolat T, Ozturk M. Commerce in renal transplantation. Transplant Proc 1998: 30: 710.
52. Al AsfariR, Hadidy S, Yagan S. Results of kidney transplantation from living unrelated donors. Transplant Proc 1995: 27: 2591.
53. Colakoglu M, Yenicesu M, Akpolat T et al. Nonrelated living-donor kidney transplantation: medical and ethical aspects. Nephron 1998: 79: 447.
54. Friedlaender MM, Gofrit O, Eld A. Unrelated-living-donor kidney transplantation. Lancet 1993: 342: 1061.
55. Geddes CC, Henderson A, Mackenzie P, Rodger SC. Outcome of patients from the West of Scotland traveling to Pakistan for living donor kidney transplants. Transplantation 2008: 85: 1143.
56. Hussein MM, Mooiji JMV, Roujouleh H, El-Sayed H. Commercial living-nonrelated renal transplantation: observations on early complications. Transplant Proc 1996: 28: 1941.
57. Johny KV, Nesim J, Namboori N, Gupta RK. Values gained and lost in live unrelated renal transplantation. Transplant Proc 1990: 22: 915.
58. Kwon CHD, Lee S-K, Ha J. Trend and outcome of Korean patients receiving overseas solid organ transplantation between 1999 and 2005. J Korean Med Sci 2011: 26: 17.
59. Lei C, Abdullah K, Morad Z, Suleiman AB. Surgical complications of living unrelated kidney transplantations in a third-world country. Transplant Proc 1992: 24: 1815.
60. Salahudeen AK, Woods HF, Pingle A et al. High mortality among recipients of bought living-unrelated donor kidneys. Lancet 1990: 336: 725.
61. Sever MS, Ecder T, Aydin AE et al. Living unrelated (paid) kidney transplantation in third-world countries: high risk of complications besides ethical problem. Nephrol Dial Transplant 1994: 9: 350.
62. Sever MS, Kazancioglu R, Yildiz A et al. Outcome of living unrelated (commercial) renal transplantation. Kidney Int 2001: 60: 1477.