Why the Scots die younger: Synthesizing the evidence

Public Health

Volumn 126, Issue 6, 2012, Pages 459-470

  McCartney, G ^a   Collins, C ^b   Walsh, D ^c   Batty, G D ^d,e  

^a NHS HEALTH SCOTLAND   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST OF SCOTLAND   (United Kingdom)

^c Glasgow Centre for Population Health   (United Kingdom)

^d UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^e MEDICAL RESEARCH COUNCIL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Causality; Glasgow; Glasgow effect; Mortality; Scotland; Scottish effect; Synthesis

Indexed keywords

CULTURE; EPIDEMIOLOGY; HEALTH STATUS; LITERATURE REVIEW; MOBILITY; MORTALITY; POLICY IMPLEMENTATION; POPULATION DYNAMICS;

ARTICLE; CAPITAL; CAUSE OF DEATH; CHILD PARENT RELATION; CULTURAL ANTHROPOLOGY; EMPLOYMENT; EPIDEMIOLOGY; EUROPE; GENDER; GENETICS; HEALTH BEHAVIOR; HEALTH CARE AVAILABILITY; HEALTH CARE NEED; HOUSING; HUMAN; MIGRATION; MORTALITY; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY; POLITICS; PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICE; SELF CONCEPT; SUBSTANCE ABUSE; UNITED KINGDOM;

AGED; AGED, 80 AND OVER; CHRONIC DISEASE; EUROPE; FEMALE; HEALTH STATUS DISPARITIES; HUMANS; LIFE EXPECTANCY; MALE; MORTALITY; POLITICS; SCOTLAND;

SCOTLAND; UNITED KINGDOM;

EID: 84862186610     PISSN: 00333506     EISSN: 14765616     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.puhe.2012.03.007     Document Type: Article

References (119)

1. Life expectancy for areas in Scotland 2011, National Records of Scotland, Edinburgh, Available at:, 2008-2010, [last accessed 15 November 2011]. http://www.gro-scotland.gov.uk/statistics/theme/life-expectancy/scottish-areas/2008-2010/index.html.
2. Norman P., Boyle P., Exeter D., Feng Z., Popham F. Rising premature mortality in the UK's persistently deprived areas: only a Scottish phenomenon?. Soc Sci Med 2011, 73:1-10.
3. Leon D., Morton S., Cannegieter S., McKee M. Understanding the health of Scotland's population in an international context: a review of current approaches, knowledge and recommendations for new research directions 2003, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine & Public Health Institute for Scotland, London, Available at:, [last accessed 20 April 2010]. http://www.scotpho.org.uk/home/Comparativehealth/InternationalComparisons/int_mortality_comparisons.asp.
4. McCartney G, Walsh D, Whyte B, Collins C. Has Scotland always been the 'sick man' of Europe?. Eur J Public Health. doi:10.1093/eurpub/ckr136.
5. Hanlon P., Lawder R., Buchanan D., Redpath A., Walsh D., Wood R. Why is mortality higher in Scotland than in England & Wales? Decreasing influence of socioeconomic deprivation between 1981 and 2001 supports the existence of a 'Scottish effect'. J Public Health 2005, 27:199-204.
6. Hanlon P., Walsh D., Whyte B. Let Glasgow flourish 2006, Glasgow Centre for Population Health, Glasgow.
7. Leyland A., Dundas R., McLoone P., Boddy F. Cause-specific inequalities in mortality in Scotland: two decades of change. A population-based study. BMC Public Health 2007, 7.
8. Davies C., Dundas R., Leyland A. Increasing socioeconomic inequalities in first acute myocardial infarction in Scotland, 1990-92 and 2000-02. BMC Public Health 2009, 9.
9. Walsh D., Taulbut M., Hanlon P. The aftershock of deindustrialization - trends in mortality in Scotland and other parts of post-industrial Europe. Eur J Public Health 2010, 20:58-64.
10. Walsh D., Taulbut M., Hanlon P. The aftershock of deindustrialisation - trends in mortality in Scotland and other parts of post-industrial Europe 2008, Glasgow Centre for Population Health, Glasgow.
11. Whyte B. Scottish mortality in a European context 1950-2000: an analysis of comparative mortality trends 2007, Scottish Public Health Observatory, Edinburgh, Available at:, [last accessed 20 April 2010]. http://www.scotpho.org.uk/nmsruntime/saveasdialog.asp?lID=3591&sID=3079.
12. Walsh D., Bendel N., Jones R., Hanlon P. Investigating a 'Glasgow effect': why do equally deprived UK cities experience different health outcomes 2010, Glasgow Centre for Population Health, Glasgow.
13. Walsh D., Bendel N., Jones R., Hanlon P. It's not 'just deprivation': why do equally deprived UK cities experience different health outcomes?. Public Health 2010, 124:487-495.
14. Carstairs V., Morris R. Deprivation: explaining differences in mortality between Scotland and England and Wales. BMJ 1989, 299:886-889.
15. The Scottish effect? 1998, Scottish Council Foundation Healthy Public Policy Network, Edinburgh.
16. Hill A. The environment and disease: association or causation?. Proc R Soc Med 1965, 58:295-300.
17. Navarro V., Muntaner C., Borrell C., Benach J., Quiroga á., Rodríguez-Sanz M., et al. Politics and health outcomes. Lancet 2006, 1033-1037.
18. how should we decide what to believe and when to take action? 2007, Identifying the environmental causes of disease, Academy of Medical Sciences, London.
19. Weiss N.S. Can the 'specificity' of an association be rehabilitated as a basis for supporting a causal hypothesis?. Epidemiology 2001, 13:6-8.
20. Dahlgren G., Whitehead M. Policies and strategies to promote social equity in health 1991, Institute of Futures Studies, Stockholm.
21. Evans R., Stoddart G. Producing health, consuming health care. Soc Sci Med 1990, 31:1347-1363.
22. Lynch J. Socio-epidemiology: some observations the past, present and future. Australas Epidemiol 2000, 7:7-15.
23. Link B., Phelan J. McKeown and the idea that social conditions are fundamental causes of disease. Am J Public Health 2002, 92:730-732.
24. Rose G. Sick individuals and sick populations. Int J Epidemiol 1985, 14:32-38.
25. McLaren L., McIntyre L., Kirkpatrick S. Rose's population strategy of prevention need not increase social inequalities in health. Int J Epidemiol 2010, 39:372-377.
26. Williams H. Hegel, Heraclitus, and Marx's dialectic. Harvester Wheatsheaf 1989.
27. Hegel G. Hegel's science of logic 1812, Allen & Unwin, London.
28. Hunter D.J. Leading for health and wellbeing: the need for a new paradigm. J Public Health 2009, 31:202-204.
29. McCartney G., Collins C., Walsh D., Batty G.D. Accounting for Scotland's excess mortality: towards a synthesis 2011, Glasgow Centre for Population Health, Glasgow, Available at:, [last accessed 15 November 2011]. http://www.gcph.co.uk/assets/0000/1080/GLA147851_Hypothesis_Report__2_.pdf.
30. George S. It's not just deprivation - or is it?. Public Health 2010, 124:196-197.
31. Reid J. Excess mortality in the Glasgow conurbation: exploring the existence of a Glasgow effect 2008, University of Glasgow, Glasgow.
32. Boffeta P., Brennan P., Saracci R. Neoplasms. Oxford textbook of public health 2004, 1156. Oxford University Press, Oxford. R. Detels, J. McEwan, R. Beaglehole, H. Tanaka (Eds.).
33. Craig C. The tears that made the Clyde - well-being in Glasgow 2010, Argyll Publishing, Glendaruel.
34. Devine T.M. The Scottish nation 1999, Penguin, London.
35. Popham F., Boyle P.J., Norman P. The Scottish excess in mortality compared to the English and Welsh. Is it a country of residence or country of birth excess?. Health Place 2010, doi:10.1016/j.healthplace.2010.03.007.
36. Wild S., McKeigue P. Cross sectional analysis of mortality by country of birth in England and Wales, 1970-92. BMJ 1997, 314:705-710.
37. Bhala N., Bhopal R., Brock A., Griffiths C., Wild S. Alcohol-related and hepatocellular cancer deaths by country of birth in England and Wales: analysis of mortality and census data. J Public Health 2009, 31:250-257.
38. Wannamethee S., Shaper A., Whincup P., Walker M. Migration within Great Britain and cardiovascular disease: early life and adult environmental factors. Int J Epidemiol 2002, 31:1054-1060.
39. Popham F., Boyle P., O'Reilly D., Leyland A. Selective internal migration. Does it explain Glasgow's worsening mortality record? Scottish Longitudinal study (SLS) research working paper series 2009, GRO Scotland, Edinburgh.
40. Exeter D., Boyle P., Feng Z., Boyle M. Shrinking areas and mortality: an artefact of deprivation effects in the West of Scotland?. Health Place 2009, 15:399-401.
41. Exeter D., Feng Z., Flowerdew R., Boyle P. Shrinking areas and mortality: an artefact of deprivation effects?. J Epidemiol Commun Health 2005, 59:924-926.
42. Brimblecombe N., Dorling D., Shaw M. Migration and geographical inequalities in health in Britain. Soc Sci Med 2000, 50:861-878.
43. Brimblecombe N., Dorling D., Shaw M. Mortality and migration in Britain, first results from the British household Panel survey. Soc Sci Med 1999, 49:981-988.
44. World drug report 2010 2010, United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, New York.
45. Bloor M., Gannon M., Hay G., Jackson G., Leyland A. Contribution of problem drug users' deaths to excess mortality in Scotland: secondary analysis of cohort study. BMJ 2008, 337:a478.
46. Gray L. Comparisons of health-related behaviours and health measures between Glasgow and the rest of Scotland 2007, Glasgow Centre for Population Health, Glasgow.
47. Gray L. Is the 'Glasgow effect' of cigarette smoking explained by socio-economic status? A multilevel analysis. BMC Public Health 2009, 9.
48. Hart C., Hole D., Gillis C., Smith G., Watt G., Hawthorne V. Social class differences in lung cancer mortality: risk factor explanations using two Scottish cohort studies. Int J Epidemiol 2001, 30:268-274.
49. Gruer L., Hart C.L., Gordon D.S., Watt G.C. Effect of tobacco smoking on survival of men and women by social position: a 28 year cohort study. BMJ 2009, 338:b480.
50. Gillis C., Hole D., Boyle P. Cigarette smoking and male lung cancer in an area of very high incidence. I Report of a case-control study in the West of Scotland. J Epidemiol Commun Health 1988, 42:38-43.
51. Gillis C., Hole D., Hawthorne V. Cigarette smoking and male lung cancer in an area of very high incidence. II Report of a general population cohort study in the West of Scotland. J Epidemiol Commun Health 1988, 42:44-48.
52. Mitchell R., Fowkes G., Blane D., Bartley M. High rates of ischaemic heart disease in Scotland are not explained by conventional risk factors. J Epidemiol Commun Health 2005, 59:565-567.
53. Shelton N. Regional risk factors for health inequalities in Scotland and England and the 'Scottish effect'. Soc Sci Med 2009, 69:761-767.
54. Gray L., Leyland A. A multilevel analysis of diet and socio-economic status in Scotland: investigating the 'Glasgow effect'. Public Health Nutr 2008, 12:1351-1358.
55. Gordon R., Heim D., MacAskill S., Angus K., Dooley J., Merlot R., et al. Snapshots of drinking: a rapid review of drinking cultures and influencing factors: australia, Canada, France, Germany, Spain, Sweden and the United Kingdom and Scotland 2008, NHS Health Scotland, Edinburgh.
56. Durkheim E. The division of labour in society 1984, The Free Press, New York.
57. Durkheim E. Suicide 1951, The Free Press, New York.
58. Marx K. Estranged labour. Economic and philosophic manuscripts of 1844 2007, Dover Publications, New York.
59. Buckingham A. Is there an underclass in Britain?. Br J Sociol 1999, 50:49-75.
60. MacDonald R., Marsh J. Employment, unemployment and social polarization. Renewing class analysis 2000, Blackwell, Oxford. R. Crompton, F. Devine, M. Savage, J. Scott (Eds.).
61. Marshall G., Roberts S., Burgoyne C. Social class and underclass in Britain and the USA. Br J Sociol 1996, 47:22-44.
62. Dean M. Christmas, The poor, and the development of a UK underclass. Lancet 1989, 334:1536-1537.
63. ending the costs of social breakdown 2008, Breakthrough Glasgow, Centre for Social Justice, London.
64. Craig C. Women and children last. Scott Rev Books 2010, 6:4-6.
65. Donnelly P. Explaining the Glasgow effect: could adverse childhood experiences play a role?. Public Health 2010, 124:498-499.
66. Hughes A. Working class culture, family fife and domestic violence on Clydeside, c1918-1939: a view from below. Scott Trad 2002.
67. Hughes A. Representation and counter-representations of domestic violence on Clydeside between the two World Wars. Labour Hist Rev 2004, 69:169-184.
68. O'Neill R. Experiments in living: the fatherless family 2002, Civitas, London.
69. Britain Breakdown Interim report on the state of the nation 2006, Social Justice Policy Group, London.
70. Rowthorn R., Webster D. Male worklessness and the rise of lone parenthood in Great Britain. Camb J Regions Econ Soc 2008, 1:69-88.
71. Bell D., Blanchflower D.G. The Scots may be brave but they are neither healthy nor happy 2005, Institute for the Study of Labor, Bonn.
72. Gilhooly M., Hanlon P., Cullen B., Macdonald S., Whyte B. Successful ageing in an area of deprivation: part 2 - a quantitative exploration of the role of personality and beliefs in good health in old age. Public Health 2007, 121:814-821.
73. Stuckler D., King L., McKee M. Mass privatisation and the post-communist mortality crisis: a cross-national analysis. Lancet 2009, 373:399-407.
74. Sectarianism in Glasgow - final report 2003, NFO Social Research, Edinburgh.
75. Craig C. The Scots' crisis of confidence 2005, Big Thinking, Glasgow.
76. Currie C., Todd J. Mental well-being among schoolchildren in Scotland: age and gender patterns, trends and cross-national comparisons 2003, Child & Adolescent Health Research Unit, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh.
77. Williams R. Britain's regional mortality: a legacy from disaster in the Celtic periphery?. Soc Sci Med 1994, 39:189-199.
78. Abbots J., Williams R., Sweeting H., West P. Poor but healthy? The youngest generation of Irish catholics in west Scotland. Health Bull 2001, 59:373-380.
79. Mullen K., Williams R., Hunt K. Irish descent, religion and food consumption in the West of Scotland. Appetite 2000, 34:47-54.
80. Abbots J., Williams R., Smith G. Association of medical, physiological, behavioural and socio-economioc factors with elevated mortality in men of Irish heritage in West Scotland. J Public Health 1999, 21:46-54.
81. Haynes R. Inequalities in health and health service use: evidence from the general household survey. Soc Sci Med 1991, 33:361-368.
82. Mercer S., Watt G. The inverse care law: clinical primary care encounters in deprived and affluent areas of Scotland. Ann Fam Med 2007, 5:503-510.
83. McLean G., Sutton M., Guthrie B. Deprivation and quality of primary care services: evidence for persistence of the inverse care law from the UK Quality and Outcomes Framework. J Epidemiol Commun Health 2006, 60:917-922.
84. Smith C. Equity in the distribution of health and welfare services: can we rely on the state to reverse the 'inverse care law'?. Soc Sci Med 1986, 23:1067-1078.
85. Sutherland K., Coyle N. Quality in healthcare in England, Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland: an intra-UK chartbook 2009, Health Foundation, London.
86. Connolly S., Bevan G., Mays N. Funding and performance of healthcare systems in the four countries of the UK before and after devolution 2010, Nuffield Trust, London.
87. McLaren J., Armstrong J., Harris R. Spending on health. Scottish Government budget options 2010, Centre for Public Policy for Regions in Association with KPMG, Glasgow.
88. Sridharan S., Tunstall H., Lawder R., Mitchell R. An exploratory spatial data analysis approach to understanding the relationship between deprivation and mortality in Scotland. Soc Sci Med 2007, 65:1942-1952.
89. Wilkinson R. The impact of inequality: how to make sick societies healthier 2005, Routledge, Abingdon.
90. Wilkinson R., Pickett K. The spirit level: why more equal societies almost always do better 2009, Penguin, London.
91. Weich S., Lewis G., Jenkins S. Income inequality and self rated health in Britain. J Epidemiol Commun Health 2002, 56:436-441.
92. Gravelle H., Sutton M. Income, relative income and self-rated health in Britain 1979-2000 2006, Centre for Health Economics, York.
93. Households below average income (HBAI) 1994/95-2007/08 2009, Department for Work and Pensions, London.
94. Grainger S., Stewart S. Income distribution in Scotland. Scottish economic statistics 2007, Scottish Executive, Edinburgh.
95. McLoone P., Boddy F. Deprivation and mortality in Scotland, 1981 and 1991. BMJ 1994, 309:1465-1470.
96. Hills J., Brewer M., Jenkins S., Lister R., Lupton R., Machin S., et al. Anatomy of economic inequality in the UK: report of the National Equality Panel 2010, London.
97. Turok I., Edge N. The jobs gap in Britain's cities: employment loss and labour market consequences 1999, Policy Press, Bristol.
98. Owen D., Gillespie A., Coombes M. 'Job shortfalls' in British local labour market areas: a classification of labour supply and demand trends, 1971-1981. Region Stud 1984, 18:469-488.
99. McCormack C. The wee yellow butterfly 2009, Argyll Publishing, Glasgow.
100. Collins C., McCartney G. Is a 'political attack' an explanation for the 'Scottish effect' in health outcomes?. Int J Health Serv 2011, 41.
101. Leon D., Chenet L., Shkolnikov V., Zakharov S., Shapiro J., Rakhmanova G., et al. Huge variation in Russian mortality rates 1984-1994: artefact, alcohol, or what?. Lancet 1997, 350:383-388.
102. Shkolnikov V., McKee M., Leon D. Changes in life expectancy in Russia in the mid-1990s. Lancet 2001, 357:917-921.
103. Birch K., Mykhnenko V. Varieties of neoliberalism? Restructuring in large industrially dependent regions across Western and Eastern Europe. J Econ Geog 2009, 9:355-380.
104. Phillips J. The industrial politics of devolution: Scotland in the 1960s and 1970s 2008, Manchester University Press;, Manchester.
105. Gray N. The tyranny of rent. Variant 2010, 37:37-43.
106. Boyle M., McWilliams C., Rice G. The spatialities of actually existing neoliberalism in Glasgow, 1977 to present. Geografiska Annaler Ser B Hum Geog 2008, 90:313-325.
107. Gillie O. Scotland's health deficit: an explanation and a plan 2008, Health Research Forum Publishing, London.
108. Hypponen E., Power C. Hypovitaminosis D in British adults at age 45y: nationwide cohort study of dietary and lifestyle predictors. Am J Clin Nutr 2007, 85:860-868.
109. Howieson S., Hogan M. Multiple deprivation and excess winter deaths in Scotland. J R Soc Promot Health 2005, 125:18-22.
110. Bowie N., Jackson G. The raised incidence of winter deaths 2002, Occasional paper no. 7, General Registrar's Office for Scotland, Edinburgh.
111. Foster J. The economic restructuring of the west of Scotland: 1945-2000. Restructuring regional and global economics: towards a comparative study of Scotland and upper Silesia 2003, Ashgate, Aldershot. G. Blazyca (Ed.).
112. Foster J. The Twentieth century. The new Penguin history of Scotland 2001, Penguin, London. R. Houston, W. Knox (Eds.).
113. Barker D., Eriksson J., Forsén T. Fetal origins of adult disease: strength of effects and biological basis. Int J Epidemiol 2002, 31:1235-1239.
114. McDowell I. From risk factors to explanation in public health. J Public Health 2008, 30:219-223.
115. Coggon D., Martyn C. Time and chance: the stochastic nature of disease causation. Lancet 2005, 365:1434-1437.
116. McPherson K. Wider 'causal thinking in the health sciences'. J Epidemiol Commun Health 1998, 52:612-618.
117. Thomas B., Dorling D., Smith G.D. Inequalities in premature mortality in Britain: observational study from 1921 to 2007. BMJ 2010, 341:c3639.
118. Stuckler D., Basu S., McKee M. Budget crises, health, and social welfare programmes. BMJ 2010, 340:c3311.
119. Human mortality database: University of California, Berkeley & Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research. Available at: [last accessed 4 June 2010]. http://www.mortality.org.