Cost-benefit analysis of a socio-technical intervention in a Brazilian footwear company

Applied Ergonomics

Volumn 43, Issue 5, 2012, Pages 948-957

  Guimarães, L B de M ^a   Ribeiro, J L D ^a   Renner, J S ^b  

^a FEDERAL UNIVERSITY OF RIO GRANDE DO SUL   (Brazil)

^b UNIVERSIDADE FEEVALE   (Brazil)

Author keywords

Cost benefit analysis; Participative ergonomics; Shoes manufacturing; Socio technical system; Work organization

Indexed keywords

COSTS; ERGONOMICS; INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE; JOB SATISFACTION; METAL DRAWING; OCCUPATIONAL DISEASES; SHOE MANUFACTURE;

BENEFIT TO COST RATIOS; INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT; MULTISKILLED WORKERS; PRODUCTION IMPROVEMENT; QUALITY OF WORK LIFE; SOCIOTECHNICAL SYSTEMS; WORK ORGANIZATION; WORK-RELATED MUSCULOSKELETAL DISORDERS;

COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS;

ABSENTEEISM; ANXIETY; ARTICLE; BRAZIL; CONSULTATION; COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS; COST CONTROL; ERGONOMICS; HUMAN; LONGITUDINAL STUDY; MUSCULOSKELETAL DISEASE; OCCUPATIONAL ACCIDENT; OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH; PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT; PROCESS DESIGN; PROCESS DEVELOPMENT; PRODUCTIVITY; QUALITY OF WORKING LIFE; SHOE INDUSTRY; WELLBEING; WORK ENVIRONMENT;

EID: 84861190036     PISSN: 00036870     EISSN: 18729126     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.apergo.2012.01.003     Document Type: Article

References (107)

1. Abicalçados Statistical Review 2009 2009, Available from:, (accessed 30.04.11.). http://www.abical%26ccedil;ados.com.br.
2. Abicalçados Statistical Primer 2011 [online] 2011, Abicalçados, Available from:, (accessed 20.07.11.). http://www.abicalcados.com.br/estatisticas.html.
3. Abicalçados Pesquisa/Polos Produtores [online] 2011, Available from:, (accessed 15.06.11.). http://www.abicalcados.com.br/polos-produtores.html.
4. Abrahamsson L. Production economics analysis of investment initiated to improve working environment. Applied Ergonomics 2000, 31:1-7.
5. Adair J.G. The Hawthorne effect: a reconsideration of the methodological artifact. Journal of Applied Psychology 1984, 69(2):334-345.
6. Agnesi R., Dal Vecchio L., Todros A., Sparta S. Neuropatia del nervo ulnare a livello del gomito in addette all'uso di macchine per cucire a colonna: casistica e follow-up. La Medicina del Lavoro 1993, 84(2):147-161.
7. Amano M., Umeda G., Nakajima H., Yatsuki K. Characteristics of work actions of shoe manufacturing assembly line workers and a cross-sectional factor-control study on occupational cervicobrachial disorders. Japanese Journal of Industrial Health 1988, 30(1):3-12.
8. Anderson E.R. Economic evaluation of ergonomic solutions: part II - The scientific basis. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 1992, 10:173-178.
9. Banco L., Lapidus G., Monopoli J., Zavoski R. A safe teen work project: a study to reduce cutting injuries among young and inexperienced workers. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 1997, 31:619-622.
10. Barefoot Economics . The economics of health, safety and well being: assessing the economic value of developing an healthy work environment Available from:, (accessed 28.04.11.). http://www.ilo.org/%20public/english/protection/safework/econo/barefoot.pdf.
11. Beevis D. Ergonomics - Costs and benefits revisited. Applied Ergonomics 2003, 34(5):491-496.
12. Bell J.L., Collins J.W., Wolf L., Grönqvist R., Chiou S., Chang W.-R., Sorock G.S., Courtney T.K., Lombardi D.A., Evanoff B. Evaluation of a comprehensive slip, trip and fall prevention programme for hospital employees. Ergonomics 2008, 51(12):1906-1925.
13. Berggren C. Alternatives to Lean Production: Work Organization in the Swedish Auto Industry 1992, ILR Press, Ithaca, NY.
14. Bidassie B., McGlothlin J.D., Goh A., Feyen R.G., Barany J.W. Limited economic evaluation to assess the effectiveness of a university-wide office ergonomics program. Applied Ergonomics 2010, 41(3):417-427.
15. Black J.T. The Design of the Factory with a Future 1991, McGraw-Hill, New York;Toronto.
16. Braverman H. Labor and Monopoly Capital: the Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century 1998, Monthly Review Press, New York.
17. Brown O. Marketing participatory ergonomics: current trends and methods to enhance organisational effectiveness. Ergonomics 1990, 33:601-604.
18. Brown O. On the relationship between participatory ergonomics, performance and productivity in organisational systems. The Ergonomics of Manual Work 1993, 495-498. Taylor and Francis, London. W. Marras, W. Karwowski, J. Smith, L. Pacholski (Eds.).
19. Burton N.C., MacDonald L.A., Estill C.F. Health Hazard Evaluation Report HETA 94-0245-2577 1996, Hanover Shoe Company, Franklin, West Virginia.
20. Carayon P., Smith M.J., Haims M.C. Work organization, job stress, and work-related musculoskeletal disorders. Human Factors 1999, 41(4):644-663.
21. Carrivick P.J.W., Lee A.H., Yau K.K.W. Consultative team to assess manual handling and reduce the risk of occupational injury. Occupational and Environmental Medicine 2001, 58:339-344.
22. Carrivick P.J.W., Lee A.H., Yau K.K.W. Effectiveness of a workplace risk assessment team in reducing the rate, cost and duration of occupational injury. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine 2002, 44:155-159.
23. An Ergonomics Honor Roll: Case Studies of Results-oriented Programs, Red Wing Shoes 1995, Center for Workplace Health Information, CTD news special report: best ergonomic practices, p. 2-3.
24. Chhokar R., Engst C., Miller A., Robinson D., Tate R.B., Yassi A. The three-year economic benefits of a ceiling lift intervention aimed to reduce healthcare worker injuries. Applied Ergonomics 2005, 36:223-229.
25. Clegg C.W. Sociotechnical principles for system design. Applied Ergonomics 2000, 31:463-477.
26. Cole D.C., Wells R.P., Kerr M.S., Laing A.C. Methodological issues in evaluating workplace interventions to reduce work-related musculoskeletal disorders through mechanical exposure reduction. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health 2003, 29:396-405.
27. Croitoru C., Gradinariu F., Ghitescu M., Bohosievici M., Danulescu E., Danulescu R., Scutaru B., Hurduc V., Gaina L., Maftei A., Alexandrescu I., Cazuc V., Havârneanu D. Assessment of risk factors and their impact on workers' health status in a medium size footwear factory. Journal of Preventive Medicine 2007, vol. 15:136-191. Iasi, Romania.
28. Cybernetic Manufacturing Systems (2006-2008). Available from: , click on CyberManS (accessed 28.04.11.). http://www.crfproject-eu.org/.
29. De Looze M.P., Vink P., Koningsveld E.A.P., Kuijt-Evers L., Van Rhijn G.J.W. Cost-effectiveness of ergonomic interventions in production. Human Factors and Ergonomics in Manufacturing and Service Industries 2010, 20(4):316-323.
30. Dejours C. Travail: usure mentale 1980, Le Centurion, Paris.
31. Del Bianco M., Oliveti G., De Donato S.R., Ricciotti M., Campana A. Rischi da vibrazioni al sistema mano-braccio e cumulative trauma desorders nel settore calzaturiero: descrizione di un caso clinico. La Medicina del Lavoro 1993, 84(4):306-310.
32. DeRango K., Amick B., Robertson M., Rooney T., Moore A., Bazzani L. The Productivity Consequences of Two Ergonomic Interventions 2003, Institute for Work & Health, Toronto, ON, Working Paper #222.
33. Drummond M., O'Brien B.J., Stoddart G.L., Torrance G.W. Methods for the Economic Evaluation of Health Care Programmes 1997, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK. third ed.
34. Drury C.G., Wick J. Ergonomic applications in the shoe industry. Proceedings of the International Conference on Occupational Ergonomics 1984, vol. 1:489-493. Toronto.
35. Elkington J. Canibals with Forks: the Triple Bottom Line of 21st Century Business 1999, Capstone, Oxford.
36. Emery F. Characteristics of Sociotechnical Systems. Doc. 527 1959, Tavistock Institute of Human Relations, London.
37. Evanoff B.A., Bohr P.C., Wolf L.D. Effects of a participatory ergonomics team among hospital orderlies. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 1999, 35:358-365.
38. Fischer, D., 2000. Transformation of a linear system into a cellular one according to the micro and macro aspects of ergonomics. Dissertation (MEng.) Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul.
39. Friedman G. Le travail en miettes: spécialisation et loisirs 1967, Gallimard, Paris.
40. Gold M.R., Siegel J.E., Russel L.B., Weinstein M.C. Cost-effectiveness in Health and Medicine 1996, Oxford University Press, New York.
41. Gorini A.F., Siqueira S.G. The Leather-shoe Complex 1999, ACINH, Novo Hamburgo.
42. Grandjean E. Fitting the Task to the Man: an Ergonomic Approach 1981, Taylor & Francis, London.
43. Guimarães L.B.de M. Ergonomic approach: the macroergonomic method. (org.) Ergonomics in Production 1999, vol. 1. FEENG, Porto Alegre, [Chapter 1.1]. fourth ed.
44. Guimarães, L.B.de M., Castro, B.H.V.de., 2003. Evaluation of the Accidents in the Shoe Manufacturing Sector of Rio Grande do Sul from 1995 to 2000. Porto Alegre: Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul. Unpublished report.
45. Guimarães L.B.de M., Diehl C., Fischer D., Ely F. Evaluation of productivity before and after an ergonomic intervention. Proceedings of the International Ergonomics Association, 14th Triennial Meeting, San Diego 2000, vol. 2:292-294. Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Santa Monica, CA.
46. Guimarães L.B.de M., Fischer D., Pastre T.M. Ergonomics in an electrical meter assembly plant. Proceedings of the International Ergonomics Association, 14th Triennial Meeting, San Diego 2000, vol. 327. Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Santa Monica, CA.
47. Guimarães L.B.de M., Anzanello M.J., Renner J.S. A learning curve-based method to implement multifunctional work teams in the Brazilian footwear sector. Applied Ergonomics 2012, 43(3):541-547.
48. Haines H., Wilson J., Vink P., Koningsveld E. Validating a framework for participatory ergonomics. Ergonomics 2002, 45:309-327.
49. Halpern C.A., Dawson K.P. Design and implementation of a participatory ergonomics program for machine sewing tasks. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 1997, 20:429-440.
50. Hendrick H.W. Macroergonomics: a conceptual model for integrating human factors with organizational design. Human Factors in Organizational Design and Management-II. North-Holland 1986, 467-477. Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. O. Brown, W. Hendrick Hall (Eds.).
51. Hendrick H.W. Good Ergonomics is Good Economics 1996, Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Santa Monica, CA.
52. Hendrick H.W. Lowering costs through ergonomics. Ergonomics in Manufacturing: Raising Productivity Through Workplace Improvement 1998, 29-41. Society of manufacturing Engineers, Engineering & Management Press, Dearborn, MI, [Chapter 3]. W. Karwowsky, G. Salvendy (Eds.).
53. Hendrick H.W. Determining the cost-benefits of ergonomics projects and factors that lead to their success. Applied Ergonomics 2003, 34:419-427.
54. Hendrick H.W., Kleiner B.M. Macroergonomics: an Introduction to Work System Design 2001, Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Santa Monica, CA.
55. Herrera S.H., Huatuco L. Macroergonomics intervention programs: recommendations for their design and implementation. Human Factors and Ergonomics in Manufacturing and Service Industries 2011, 21(3):227-243.
56. Holden J. Hawthorne effects and research into professional practice. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 2001, 7(1):65-70.
57. IEA (International Ergonomics Association), 2011. Available from: . (accessed 10.12.11.). http://www.iea.cc/01_what/What%20is%20Ergonomics.html.
58. Azaleia, a Frustrating Case. Adital 13.05.11 2011, IHU (Instituto Humanitas Unisinos), Available from:, (accessed 20.07.11.). http://www.adital.com.br/site/noticia_imp.asp?lang=PT&img=N&cod=56445.
59. Jensen P. Can participatory ergonomics become 'the way we do things in this firm' - The Scandinavian approach to participatory ergonomics. Ergonomics 1997, 40:1078-1087.
60. Jones S.R.G. Was there a Hawthorne effect?. American Journal of Sociology 1992, 98(3):451-468.
61. Kemmlert K. Economic impact of ergonomic intervention - Four case studies. Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation 1996, 6:17-32.
62. Kondo Y., et al. Occupational diseases in man-paced work: an investigation of shoe making female workers. Japanese Journal of Industrial Health 1984, 26(7):708.
63. Lahiri S., Gold J., Levenstein C. Estimation of net-costs for prevention of occupational low back pain: three case studies from the U.S. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 2005, 48:530-541.
64. Laing A., Frazer M., Cole D.C., Kerr M., Wells R., Norman R. Study of the effectiveness of a participatory ergonomics intervention in reducing worker pain severity through physical exposure pathways. Ergonomics 2005, 48:150-170.
65. Lanoie P., Tavenas S. Costs and benefits of preventing workplace accidents: the case of participatory ergonomics. Safety Science 1996, 24:181-196.
66. Mody A., Suri R., Sanders J., Van Zoest D. International Competition in the Footwear Industry: Keeping Pace with Technological Change 1991, The World Bank, Washington, DC.
67. Moore J.S., Garg A. The effectiveness of participatory ergonomics in the red meat packing industry: evaluation of a corporation. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 1998, 21:47-58.
68. Mossink J.C.M. Understanding and Performing Economic Assessments at the Company Level 2002, TNO and World Health Organization, Geneva.
69. Nagamachi M. Requisites and practices of participatory ergonomics. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 1995, 15:371-377.
70. Nagamachi M. Relationship between job design, macroergonomics, and productivity. Human Factors and Ergonomics in Manufacturing 1996, 6(4):309-322.
71. Nagamachi M., Imada A.S. A macroergonomic approach for improving safety and work design. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 36th Meeting 1992, 859-861. HFES, Santa Monica, CA.
72. Nakaseko M., et al. Ergonomic aspect of workstation design factors in man-paced assembly line work. Japanese Journal of Industrial Health 1984, 26(7):709.
73. Neumann W.P., Eklund J., Hansson B., Lindbeck L. Effect assessment in work environment interventions: a methodological reflection. Ergonomics 2010, 53(1):130-137.
74. Elements of Ergonomics Programs: a Primer Based on Workplace Evaluations of Musculoskeletal Disorders, DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 97-117 1997, NIOSH (National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health), National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Cincinnati.
75. Oxenburgh M., Marlow P., Oxenburgh A. Increasing Productivity and Profit Through Health & Safety 2004, CRC Press, London. second ed.
76. Piccinini, V., 1990. L'industrie de la chaussure brésilienne face aux mutations internationalies: stratégies et politique du personal des entreprises de la región de " Vale dos Sinos" . 1990. Thesis (Dr.) Université de Grenoble.
77. Piccinini V. New ways of work organization in the shoe manufacturing. Revista de Administração 1992, 27(2):33-40.
78. Prochnick V. Spurious Flexibility: Technical Modernization and Social Inequalities in the Brazilian Footwear Industry 1992, Working paper, World Employment Programme, International Labor Office, Geneve.
79. Rempel D.M., Krause N., Goldberg R., Benner D., Hudes M., Goldner G.U. A randomised controlled trial evaluating the effects of two workstation interventions on upper body pain and incident musculoskeletal disorders among computer operators. Occupational and Environmental Medicine 2006, 63:300-306.
80. Renner, J.S., 2002. Postural Costs of the standing, sitting and standing and sitting positions at the sewing workstations of the shoe manufacturing. Dissertation (M.Eng.) Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul.
81. Renner, J.S., 2007. Proposal of a new work design for the shoe manufacturing under the socio-technical approach. Thesis (Dr.) Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul.
82. Renner J.S., Guimarães L.B.de M., Oliveira P.A.B. Work accidents according to the workers: a case study of the shoe manufacturing. Proceedings of the XV Ergonomics Brazilian Congress 2008, Porto Seguro (BA).
83. Ridyard D.T., Hathaway J. The three dimensions of an ergonomics program. Occupational Hazards 2000, 62:41-44.
84. Rivilis I., Cole D.C., Frazer M.B., Kerr M.S., Wells R.P., Ibrahim S. Evaluation of a participatory ergonomic intervention aimed at improving musculoskeletal health. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 2006, 49:801-810.
85. Rivilis I., Van Eerda D., Cullena K., Cole D.C., Irvina E., Tysonc J., Mahood Q. Effectiveness of participatory ergonomic interventions on health outcomes: a systematic review. Applied Ergonomics 2008, 39:342-358.
86. Rooney E.F., Morency R.R., Herrick D.R. Macroergonomics and total quality management at L. L. Bean: a case study. Advances in Industrial Ergonomics and Safety V 1993, 493-498. Taylor & Francis, London. N.R. Neilson, K. Jorgensen (Eds.).
87. Roquelaure Y., Mariel J., Fanello S., Boissière J.-C., Chiron H., Dano C., Bureau D., Penneau-Fontbonne D. Active epidemiological surveillance of musculoskeletal disorders in a shoe factory. Occupational and Environmental Medicine 2002, 59(7):452-458.
88. Ruas R. Notes about the implementation of quality and productivity programmes in Brazilian industrial sectors. Proceedings of the French Latinamerican Studies on Innovation and New Management Methods 1992, Buenos Aires.
89. Scott P.A. Sustainability: an ergonomics watchword for the twenty-first century. Ergonomics in Developing Countries: Needs and Applications 2009, 437-444. [Chapter 34]. P.A. Scott (Ed.).
90. Serratos-Perez J.N., Mendiola-Anda C. Musculoskeletal disorders among male sewing machine operators in shoemaking. Ergonomics 1993, 36(7):793-800.
91. Simpson G.C. The economic justification for ergonomics. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 1988, 2:157-163.
92. St-Vincent M., Chicoine D., Beaugrand S. Validation of a participatory ergonomic process in two plants in the electrical sector. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 1998, 21:11-21.
93. Straker L.M. Work-associated back problems: collaborative solutions. Journal of the Society of Occupational Medicine 1990, 40:75-79.
94. Straker L.M., Burgess-Limerick R., Pollock C., Egeskov R. A randomized and controlled trial of a participative ergonomics intervention to reduce injuries associated with manual tasks: physical risk and legislative compliance. Ergonomics 2004, 47(2):166-188.
95. Stubbs D.A. Ergonomics and occupational medicine: future challenges. Occupational Medicine 2002, 50:277-282.
96. Tompa E., Culyer A.J., Dolinschi R. Economic Evaluation of Interventions for Occupational Health and Safety: Developing Good Practice 2008, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
97. Tompa E., Dolinschi R., de Oliveira C. Practice and potential of economic evaluation of workplace-based interventions for occupational health and safety. Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation 2006, 16:375-400.
98. Tompa E., Dolinschi R., Laing A. An economic evaluation of a participatory ergonomics process in an auto parts manufacturer. Journal of Safety Research 2009, 40:41-47.
99. Tompa E., Dolinschi R., de Oliveira C., Irvin E. A Systematic Review of OHS Interventions with Economic Evaluations 2007, Institute for Work & Health, Toronto, ON.
100. Vink P., Imada A.S., Zink K.J. Defining stakeholder involvement in participatory design processes. Applied Ergonomics 2008, 39(4):519-526.
101. Volinn E. Do workplace interventions prevent low-back disorders? If so, why? A methodological commentary. Ergonomics 1999, 42(1):258-272.
102. Westgaard R.H., Winkel J. Ergonomic intervention research for improved musculoskeletal health: a critical review. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 1997, 20:463-500.
103. Westgaard R.H., Winkel J. Occupational musculoskeletal and mental health: Significance of rationalization and opportunities to create sustainable production systems - A systematic review. Applied Ergonomics 2011, 42(2):261-296.
104. Wick J.L. Postural improvement due to changes in an overedge sewing machine workstation: a case study. Advances in Industrial Ergonomics and Safety III 1991, 427-432. Taylor & Francis, New York. W. Karwowski, J.W. Yates (Eds.).
105. Wickström G., Bendix T. The " Hawthorne effect" what did the original Hawthorne studies actually show?. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health 2000, 26(4):363-367.
106. Wilson J.R. Ergonomics and participation. Evaluation of Human Work 1999, Taylor & Francis, London. J.R. Wilson, E. Nigel Corlett (Eds.).
107. Wilson J.R., Haines H.M. Participatory ergonomics. Handbook of Human Factors and Ergonomics 1997, 490-513. Wiley, New York. second ed. G. Salvendy (Ed.).