Uses of a pandemic: Forging the identities of influenza and virus research in interwar Britain

Social History of Medicine

Volumn 25, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 400-424

  Bresalier, Michael ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

1918 19 influenza pandemic; Experimental pathology; Interwar scientific medicine; Medical Research Council; Virus research

Indexed keywords

EID: 84860487626     PISSN: 0951631X     EISSN: 14774666     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/shm/hkr162     Document Type: Review

References (120)

1. Abrahams A. et al. 1919, 'A Further Investigation into Influenzo-pneumococcal and Influenzo-streptococcal Septicaemia: Epidemic Influenzal "Pneumonia" of Highly Fatal Type and its Relation to "Purulent Bronchitis"', Lancet, 4 January, 1-11.
2. Alter P. 1987, The Reluctant Patron: Science and the State in Britain 1850-1920, Oxford: Berg.
3. Andrewes F. W. 1920, 'The Bacteriology of Influenza', in Ministry of Health, Report on the Pandemic of Influenza, 1918-19, London: HMSO, 110-25.
4. Arkwright J. A. 1919, 'A Criticism of Certain Recent Claims to Have Discovered and Cultivated the Filter-passing Virus of Trench fever and of Influenza', British Medical Journal, 23 August, 233-5.
5. Austoker J. 1988, A History of the Imperial Cancer Research Fund, 1902-1986, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
6. Austoker J. 1989, 'Walter Morley Fletcher and the Origins of a Basic Biomedical Research Policy', in Austoker J. and Bryder L. (eds), Historical Perspectives on the Role of the MRC: Essays in the History of the MRC of the United Kingdom and its Predecessor, the Medical Research Committee, 1913-1953, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 22-33.
7. Austoker J. and Bryder L. 1989, 'The National Institute for Medical Research and Related Activities of the MRC, in Austoker J. and Bryder L. (eds), Historical Perspectives on the Role of the MRC: Essays in the History of the MRC of the United Kingdom and its Predecessor, the Medical Research Committee, 1913-1953, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 39-52.
8. Bradford J. R., Bashford E. F. and Wilson J. A. 1919a, 'Preliminary Report on the Presence of a Filter-Passing Virus in Certain Diseases with special reference to Trench Fever, Influenza and Nephritis', Lancet, 1 February, 169.
9. Bradford J. R., Bashford E. F. and Wilson J. A. 1919b, 'The Filter-passing Virus of Influenza', Quarterly Journal of Medicine, 12, 259-306.
10. Bresalier M. 2008, 'Neutralizing flu: "Immunological Devices" and the Making of a Virus Disease', in Kroker K, Keelan J. and Mazumdar P. M. H. (eds), Crafting Immunity: Working Histories of Clinical Immunology, Basingstoke: Ashgate, 107-44.
11. Bresalier M. 2010, 'Transforming Flu: Medical Science and the Making of a Virus Disease in London, 1890-1939', PhD Dissertation, University of Cambridge.
12. Bresalier M. 2011, 'Fighting Flu: Military Pathology, Vaccines, and the Conflicted Identity of the 1918-19 Pandemic in Britain', Journal of the History of Medicine and the Allied Sciences, September 11 [Epub ahead of print] doi:10.1093/jhmas/jrr041.
13. Brown R. J. 2003, 'The Great War and the Great Flu pandemic of 1918', Wellcome History, 24, 5-7.
14. Burnet F. M. and Clark E. 1942, Influenza: A Survey of the Last 50 Years in the Light of Modern Work on Virus of Epidemic Influenza, Melbourne: Macmillan.
15. Byerly C. R. 2005, Fever of War: The Influenza Epidemic in the U.S. Army during World War I, New York: New York University Press.
16. Cameron H. C. 1940-41, 'Patrick Playfair Laidlaw', Guy's Hospital Reports, 90, 1-14.
17. Coles A. C. 1904, Clinical Diagnostic Bacteriology, London: J&A Churchill.
18. Cooter R. 2003, 'Of War and Epidemics: Unnatural Couplings, Problematic Conceptions', Social History of Medicine 16, 283-302.
19. Creager A. N. H. 2002, The Life of a Virus: Tobacco Moasaic Virus as an Experimental Model, 1930-65, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
20. Creager A. N. H. 2008, 'Mobilizing Biomedicine: Virus Research Between Lay Health Organizations and the U.S. Federal Government, 1935-1955', in Hannaway C. (ed.), Biomedicine in the Twentieth Century: Practices, Policies, and Politics, Amsterdam: IOS Press, 171-202.
21. Crookshank F. G. 1922, Influenza: Essays by Several Authors, London: Heinemann.
22. Crosby A.W. 1989, America's Forgotten Pandemic-The Influenza of 1918, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
23. Cummins S. L. 1919a, 'Major H.G. Gibson', British Medical Journal, 8 March, 294-5.
24. Cummins S. L. 1919b, Studies of Influenza in Hospitals of the British Armies in France, MRC, Specia Report Series No. 36 London: HMSO.
25. Dale H. H. 1941, 'Patrick Playfair Laidlaw', Obituary Notices of Fellows of The Royal Society, 3, 427-47.
26. Deutschman Z. 1953, 'Trends of Influenza Mortality During the Period 1920-1951', Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 8, 633-45.
27. DigbyA. 1999, The Evolution of British General Practice, 1850-1948, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
28. Donaldson R. 1922, 'The Bacteriology of Influenza-With Special Reference to Pfeiffer's Bacillus', in Crookshank F. G. (ed.), Influenza: Essays by Several Authors, London: William Heinemann, 139-213.
29. Dunkin G. W. and Laidlaw P. P. 1926, 'Studies in Dog-Distemper. II. Experimental Distemper in the Dog', Journal of Comparative Pathology and Therapeutics, 39, 201-13.
30. Editorial 1918, 'The Utilisation of Vaccine for the Prevention and Treatment of Influenza', Lancet, 26 October, 565.
31. Editorial 1922, 'Bacteriology of Influenza', Lancet, ii, 516-18.
32. Eyler J. M. 2006, 'De Kruif's Boast: Vaccine Trials and the Construction of a Virus', Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 80, 409-38.
33. Fildes P. 1920, 'Unititled Editorial', British Journal of Experimental Pathology, 1, i-ii.
34. Fildes P. and McIntosh J. 1920, 'The Aetiology of Influenza', British Journal of Experimental Pathology, 2, 159-174.
35. Fildes P. 1949, 'James McIntosh 1882-1948', Journal of Pathology and Bacteriology, 61, 285-99.
36. Fildes P. and Ledingham J. C. G. 1930, 'Viruses and Virus Diseases', in Fildes P. et al., (eds), A System of Bacteriology in Relation to Medicine, London: HMSO.
37. Fildes P. and McIntosh J. 1920, 'The Aetiology of Influenza', British Journal of Experimental Pathology, II, 159-74.
38. Fisher D. 1978a, 'The Rockefeller Foundation and the Development of Scientific Medicine in Britain', Minerva, 16, 20-41.
39. Fisher D. 1978b, 'Rockefeller Philanthropy and the British Empire: The Creation of the London Schoo of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine', History of Education, 7, 129-43.
40. French H. 1919, 'Influenza, Guy's Hospital Gazette, XXXIII, 118-27.
41. Garrod L. P. 1954, 'Mervyn H. Gordon 1872-1953', Obituary Notices of Fellows of the Royal Society, 9, 153-63.
42. Gibson H. G., Bowman F. B. and Connor J. I. 1918, 'A Filtrable Virus as the Cause of the Early Stage of the Present Epidemic of Influenza', British Medical Journal, 14 December, 645-6.
43. Gibson H. G., Bowman F. B. and Connor J. I. 1919, 'The Etiology of Influenza: A Filterable Virusas the Cause', in MRC Studies of Influenza in Hospitals of the British Armies in France, 1918, London: HMSO, 19-36.
44. Gladstone G. P., Knight C. J. G. and Wilson G. 1973, 'Paul Gordon Fildes, 1882-1971', Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society, 19, 317-74.
45. Gordon M. H. 1911-1912, 'Notes on Acute Poliomyelitis with Reference to its Etiology, Histology, and Immunity', Reports of Local Government Board, Medical Officer, London: HMSO, 115-21.
46. Gordon M. H. 1914, 'On Experimental Investigations in Relation to Mumps or Epidemic Parotitis,' Reports of Local Government Board, Public Health, 96, London: HMSO.
47. Gordon M. H. 1922a, 'The Filter Passer of Influenza', Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps, 39, 1-12.
48. Gordon M. H. 1922b, 'The Filter Passer of Influenza', Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps, 39, 400-01.
49. Hamer W. H. 1927, 'The Influenzal Constitution', Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 20, 1349-68.
50. Honigsbaum M. 2010, 'The Great Dread: Cultural and Psychological Impacts and Responses to the "Russian" Influenza in the United Kingdom, 1889-1893', Social History of Medicine 23, 299-319.
51. HorderT. S. 1918, 'Influenza and Preventive Inoculation', Lancet, 9 November, 642.
52. nfluenza Committee of the Advisory Board to the D.G.A.M.S. 1918, 'The Influenza Epidemic in British Armies in France, 1918', British Medical Journal, 9 November, 50.
53. Johnson N. P. A. S. 2002, 'The Overshadowed Killer: Influenza in Britain in 1918-19', in Phillips H. and Killingray D. (eds), The Spanish Influenza of 1918-1919: New Perspectives, London: Routledge, 132-54.
54. Johnson N. P. A. S. and Mueller J. 2002, 'Updating the Accounts: Global Mortality of the 1918-1920 "Spanish" Influenza Epidemic', Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 76, 105-15.
55. Kirk R. G. W. 2008, '"Wanted-Standard Guinea Pigs": Standardisation and the Experimental Anima Market in Britain ca. 1919-1947', Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 39, 280-91.
56. Kitasato S. 1892, 'On the Influenza Bacillus and the Mode of Cultivating It', British Medical Journal, 16 January, 128.
57. Klein E. 1892, 'Some Remarks on the Influenza Bacillus', British Medical Journal, 23 January, 171.
58. Klein E. 1893, 'Report on Influenza in its Clinical and Pathological Aspects', Local Government Board, Further Report and Papers on Epidemic Influenza, 1889-92 London: HMSO, 85-153.
59. Kohler R. E. 1978, 'Walter Fletcher, F.G. Hopkins, and the Dunn Institute of Biochemistry: A Case Study in the Patronage of Science', Isis, 69, 331-55.
60. Kohler R. E. 1985, 'Bacterial Physiology: The Medical Context', Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 59, 54-74.
61. Kruse W. 1914, 'Die Erreger v. Husten und Schnupfen', Münchenermedizinische Wochenschrift, 65, 1228.
62. Laidlaw P. P. 1930, 'Dog Distemper', in Fildes P. and Ledingham J. C. G. (eds), A System of Bacteriology, London: HMSO.
63. Laidlaw P. P. 1938, Virus Diseases and Viruses, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
64. Laidlaw P. P. and Dunkin G. W. 1926, 'Studies in Dog-Distemper. III. The Nature of the Virus', Journal of Comparative Pathology and Therapeutics, 29, 222.
65. Laidlaw P. P. and Dunkin G. W. 1927, 'Studies in Dog Distemper. IV. The Immunization of Ferrets against Dog Distemper', Journal of Comparative Pathology and Therapeutics, 41, 1-16.
66. Laidlaw P. P. and Dunkin G. W. 1928a, A Report Upon the Cause and Prevention of Dog Distemper, Distemper Research Committee.
67. Laidlaw P. P. and Dunkin G. W. 1928b, 'Studies in Dog Distemper. V. The Immunization of Dogs', Journal of Comparative Pathology and Therapeutics, 41, 209-27.
68. Langford C. 2002, 'The Age Pattern of Mortality in the 1918-19 Influenza Pandemic: An Attempted Explanation Based on Data for England and Wales', Medical History, 46, 1-20.
69. Lawrence C. 2006, Rockefeller Money, the Laboratory, and Medicine in Edinburgh, 1919-1930: New Science in an Old Country, Rochester: University of Rochester Press.
70. Leishman W. B. 1923, 'Organization of the Pathological Service', in MacPherson W. G., Leishman W. B. and Cummins S. L. (eds), History of the Great War Based on Official Documents. Medical Services. Pathology. London: HMSO, 1-31.
71. McIntosh J. 1918, 'The Incidence of Bacillis Influenzae (Pfeiffer) in the Present Influenza Epidemic', Lancet, 23 November, 695-7.
72. McIntosh J. 1922, Studies in the Aetiology of Epidemic Influenza, MRC Special Report Series, no. 63, London: HMSO.
73. Maitland H. B. and Cameron G. C. 1921, 'The Aetiology of Epidemic Influenza: A Critical Review', Canadian Medical Association Journal, XI, 485-92.
74. Maitland H. B. et al. 1921, The Aetiology of Epidemic Influenza: Experiments in Search of a Filter-passing Virus. Toronto: The University Library.
75. Matthews J. 1918, 'Influenza and Preventive Inoculation', Lancet, 2 November, 602.
76. MRC 1919, Studies of Influenza in Hospitals of the British Armies in France, 1918, London: HMSO.
77. MRC 1921, Report of the Medical Research Council for the Year 1919-1920, London: HMSO.
78. MRC 1923, Report of the Medical Research Council for the Year 1921-1922, London: HMSO.
79. MRC 1924, Report of the Medical Research Council for the Year 1922-1923, London: HMSO.
80. MRC 1927, Report of the Medical Research Council for the Year 1925-1926, London: HMSO.
81. MRC 1930, Report of the Medical Research Council for the Year 1928-1929, London: HMSO.
82. MRC 1932, Report of the Medical Research Council for the Year 1930-1931, London: HMSO.
83. MRC 1933, Report of the Medical Research Council for the Year 1931-1932, London: HMSO.
84. Mendelsohn J. A. 1998, 'From Eradication to Equilbrium: How Epidemics Became Complex after World War I', in Lawrence C. and Weisz G. (eds), Greater than the Parts: Holism in Biomedicine, 1921-1950, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 303-31.
85. Ministry of Health 1920, Report on the Pandemic of Influenza, 1918-19, London: HMSO.
86. Ministry of Health 1927, Memorandum on Influenza (rev. edn), London: HMSO.
87. Ministry of Health 1930, Eleventh Annual Report, 1929-1930, London: HMSO.
88. Morens D. M. and Taubenberger J. K. 2009, 'Understanding Influenza Backwards', Journal of the American Medical Association, 302, 679-80.
89. NewsholmeA. 1918-1919, 'Discussion on Influenza', Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 12, 1-102.
90. Noguchi H. 1911, 'A Method for the Pure Cultivation of Pathogenic Treponema pallidum (Spirochata Pallida)', Journal of Experimental Medicine, 14, 99-108.
91. Olitsky P. and Gates F. L. 1920, 'Experimental Study of the Nasopharyngeal Secretions from Influenza Patients: Preliminary Report', Journal of the American Medical Association, 74, 1497-9.
92. Olitsky P. and Gates F. L. 1921a, 'Experimental Studies of Nasopharyngeal Secretions from Influenza Patients: IV. Anaerobic Cultivation', Journal of Experimental Medicine, 33, 713-29.
93. Olitsky P. and Gates F. L. 1921b, 'Studies of the Nasopharyngeal Secretions from Influenza Patients: Preliminary Report on Cultivation Experiments', Journal of the American Medical Association, 76, 640-1.
94. Olitsky P. and Gates F. L. 1922, 'Methods for the Isolation of Filter-passing Anaerobic Organisms: From Nasopharyngeal Secretions', Journal of the American Medical Association, 78, 1020-2.
95. Oxford J. S. 2001, 'The So-called Great Spanish Influenza Pandemic of 1918 May Have Originated in France in 1916', Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, B, 336, 1857-9.
96. Pfeiffer R. 1892, 'Preliminary Communication on the Exciting Causes of Influenza', British Medical Journal, 16 January, 128.
97. Pfeiffer R. 1893, 'Die Aetiologie der Influenza', Zeitschrift für Hygiene, 12, 357-86.
98. Pfeiffer R. and Beck M. 1892, 'Weitere Mittheilungen über den Influenza-Erreger', Deutsche Medici-nische Wochnenschrift, 18, 465.
99. Prüll C.-R. 1998, 'Pathology and Surgery in London and Berlin 1800-1930: Pathological Theory and Clinical Practice,' in Prüll C. R. (ed.), Pathology in the 19th and 20th Centures: The Relationship between Theory and Practice, Sheffield: European Association for the History of Medicine and Health Publications, 71-100.
100. Prüll C.-R. 1999, 'Pathology at War 1914-1918: Germany and Britain in Comparison', in Cooter R., Harrison M. and Sturdy S. (eds), Medicine and Modern Warfare, Amsterdam: Rodopi, 131-62.
101. Rivers T. M. 1928, 'Some General Aspects of Filterable Viruses', in Rivers T. M. (ed.), Filterable viruses, London: Bailliere, Tindall & Cox, 3-52.
102. Shope R. E. 1931, 'Swine Influenza. III. Filtration Experiments and Etiology', Journal of Experimental Medicine, 54, 373-85.
103. Smith W., Andrewes C. H. and LaidlawP. P. 1933, 'A Virus Obtained from Influenza Patients', Lancet, 8 July, 66-68.
104. Soltau A. B. 1919, 'Discussion on Influenza', Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 12, 27-8.
105. Sturdy S. 1998, 'War as Experiment: Physiology, Innovation and Administration in Britain, 1914-1918: The Case of Chemical Warfare', in Cooter R., Harrison M. and Sturdy S. (eds), War, Medicine and Modernity, London: Sutton, 65-84.
106. Tanner A. 2002, 'The Spanish Lady Comes to London: The Influenza Pandemic 1918-1919', London Journal, 27, 51-76.
107. Tansey E. M. 1994, 'Protection Against Dog Distemper and Dogs Protection Bills: The Medica Research Council and Anti-vivisectionist Protest, 1911-1933', Medical History, 38, 1-26.
108. Thomson A. L. 1973, 1975, Half a Century of Medical Research. Origins and Policy of the Medical Research Council (UK), Vols. 1 & 2. London: HMSO.
109. Thomson A. P. 1951, 'A History of the Ferret', Journal of the History of Medicine, VI, 471-80.
110. Thomson D. and Thomson R. 1933, 1934, 'Influenza', Annals of the Pickett-Thomson Research Laboratory, Parts I & 2, London: Bailliere, Tindall and Cox.
111. Tognotti E. 2003, 'Scientific Triumphalism and Learning from Facts: Bacteriology and the "Spanish Flu" Challenge of 1918', Social History of Medicine, 16, 97-110.
112. Tomkins S.M. 1992, 'The Failure of Expertise: Public Health Policy in Britain during the 1918-19 Influenza Epidemic', Social History of Medicine, 5, 435-54.
113. Twort F. W. 1915, 'An Investigation of the Nature of Ultramicroscopic Viruses', Lancet, 4 December, 1241-3.
114. Van Helvoort T. 1993, 'A Bacteriological Paradigm in Influenza Research in the First Half of the Twentieth Century', History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences, 15, 3-21.
115. Van Helvoort T. 1994, 'History of Virus research in the Twentieth Century: The Problem of Conceptua Continuity', History of Science, XXXII, 185-235.
116. Waterson A. P. and Wilkinson L. 1978, An Introduction to the History of Virology, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
117. Weatherall M. 2000, Gentlemen, Scientists, and Doctors: Medicine at Cambridge, 1800-1940, Rochester, NY: Boydell Press.
118. Wilkinson L. 1978, 'Animal viruses, Veterinary Pathology, and the Formulation of Ideas Concerning Filterable Viruses', Historia Medicinae Veterinariae, 3, 1-15.
119. Wilkinson L. 2000, 'Burgeoning Visions of Global Public Health: the Rockefeller Foundation, the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, and the "hookworm connection"', Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 31, 397-407.
120. Wilkinson L. et al. 2001, Prevention and Cure: The London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine: a 20th Century Quest for Global Public Health, London: Kegan Paul.