A review of uncertainties in technology experience curves

Energy Economics

Volumn 34, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 762-771

  Yeh, Sonia ^a   Rubin, Edward S ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^b CARNEGIE MELLON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Endogenous technological change; Energy economic models.; Experience curve; Learning curve; Learning by doing; Uncertainties

Indexed keywords

ENDOGENOUS TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE; ENERGY-ECONOMIC MODEL; EXPERIENCE CURVES; LEARNING CURVES; LEARNING-BY-DOING; UNCERTAINTIES;

COST REDUCTION; ECONOMICS; INVESTMENTS; MATHEMATICAL MODELS; REGRESSION ANALYSIS; TECHNOLOGY; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS;

COMMERCIALIZATION; ENERGY EFFICIENCY; LEARNING; MODELING; TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

EID: 84859726600     PISSN: 01409883     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eneco.2011.11.006     Document Type: Article

References (110)

1. Anada H.R., King M.F., Seskus A.P., Sears J.T. Feasibility and Economics of By-Product CO2 Supply for Enhanced Oil Recovery. Final Report, DOE/MC/08333-3, Vol. 1: Technical Report. U.S. DOE, Springfield, Virginia 1982.
2. Argote L. Organizational Learning Curves: Persistence, Transfer and Turnover. Int. J. Technol. Manage. Spec. Publ. Learn. Unlearning 1996, 11:759-769.
3. Argote L. Organizational Learning: Creating, Retaining and Transferring Knowledge 1999, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Norwell, Massachusetts.
4. Argote L., Epple D. Learning curves in manufacturing. Science 1990, 247:920-924.
5. Arrow K. The Economic Implications of Learning by Doing. Rev. Econ. Stud. 1962, 29:155-173.
6. Asher H. Cost-Quantity Relationships in the Airframe Industry 1956, The RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, CA.
7. Azar C., Dowlatabadi H. A review of technical change in assessment of climate policy. Annu. Rev. Energy Env. 1999, 24:513-544.
8. Bahn O., Kypreos S. Incorporating different endogenous learning formulations in MERGE. Int. J. Global Energy Issues 2003, 19:333-358.
9. Barreto L., Klaassen G. Emissions trading and the role of learning-by-doing spillovers in the "bottom-up" energy-systems ERIS model. Int. J. Energy Technol. Policy 2004, 2:70-95.
10. Barreto L., Kypreos S. Emission trading and technology development in an energy-systems "bottom-up" model with technology learning. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 2004, 158:243-261.
11. Barreto L., Kypreos S. Endogenizing R&D and market experience in the "bottom-up" energy-systems ERIS model. Technovation 2004, 24:615-619.
12. Bass F.M. The relationship between diffusion rates, experience curves, and demand elasticities for consumer durable technological innovations. J. Bus. 1980, 53:S51-S67.
13. Battelle Stack Gas Treatment 1973, Batelle Columbus Laboratory, Columbus, OH.
14. Bell R.M., Scott-Kemmis D. The mythology of learning-by-doing in World War II airframe and ship production. Science Policy Research Unit, University of Sussex 1990.
15. Berndt E.R. The Practice of Econometrics: Classic and Contemporary 1991, Addison-Wesley, New York.
16. Boeing, n.d. The Experience Curve and Improvement Curve Study. Boeing Airplane Company, Wichita, Kansas.
17. Boston Consulting Group Perspectives on Experience 1968, Boston Consulting Group Inc.
18. Cantor R., Hewlett J. The economics of nuclear-power. Further evidence on learning, economics of scale, and regulatory effects. Resour. Energy 1988, 10:315-335.
19. Capros P., Panos V., Argiri E., Criqui P., Mima S., Menanteau P., Kypreos S., Barreto L., Schrattenholzer L., Turton H., Totschnig G., Klaassen G., Jaskolski M.A., Miketa A., Blesl M., Ohl M., Das A., Fahl U., Rout U.K., Smekens K., Martinus G., Lako P., Seebregts A., Regemorter D.V. System Analysis for Progress and Innovation in Energy Technologies for Integrated Assessment 2005.
20. Carr G.W. Peacetime cost estimating requires new learning curves. Aviation 1946, 45:76-77.
21. 2 from Flue Gases: Commercial Trends. Canadian Society of Chemical Engineers Annual Meeting, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada 1999.
22. Claeson Colpier U. Using the experience curve to analyze the cost development of the combined cycle gas turbine. Proceedings of the IEA International Workshop Experience Curves for Policy Making: The Case of Energy Technologies, Stuttgart, Germany 1999.
23. Claeson Colpier U., Cornland D. The Economics of the Combined Cycle Gas Turbine - an Experience Curve Analysis. Energy Policy 2002, 30:309-316.
24. Clarke L., Weyant J., Birky A. On the sources of technological change: Assessing the evidence. Energy Econ. 2006, 28:579-595.
25. Cohen W. Empirical Studies of Innovative Activity. Handbook of Economics of Innovation and Technological Change 1995, 182-264. Blackwell, Cambridge, Mass. P. Stoneman (Ed.).
26. Cohen W.M., Klepper S. Firm size and the nature of innovation within industries: The case of process and product R&D. Rev. Econ. Stat. 1996, 78:232-243.
27. Conway R.W., Schultz A. The manufacturing progress function. J. Ind. Eng. 1959, 39-54. X.
28. 2 removal. 2000 Gasification Technologies Conference, San Francisco, California 2000.
29. Dutton J.M., Thomas A. Treating Progress Functions as a Managerial Opportunity. Acad. Manag. Rev. 1984, 9:235-247.
30. Dutton J.M., Thomas A., Butler J.E. The History of Progress Functions as a Managerial Technology. Bus. Hist. Rev. 1984, 58:204-233.
31. EPA US Flue Gas Desulfurization Installations and Operations. Office of Enforcement and General Counsel 1974, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C.
32. EPA US National Public Hearings on Power Plant Compliance with Sulfur Oxide Air Pollution Regulations 1974, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D. C
33. Ferioli F., van der Zwaan B.C.C. Learning in Times of Change: A Dynamic Explanation for Technological Progress. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43:4002-4008.
34. Ferioli F., Schoots K., van der Zwaan B.C.C. Use and limitations of learning curves for energy technology policy: A component-learning hypothesis. Energy Policy 2009, 37:2525-2535.
35. Fischer C., Newell R. Environmental and technology policies for climate mitigation. J. Environ. Econ. Manage. Int. Rev. 2008, 55:142-162.
36. Gillingham K., Newell R.G., Pizer W.A. Modeling endogenous technological change for climate policy analysis. Energy Econ. 2008, 30:2734-2753.
37. Goldemberg J., Coelho S.T., Nastari P.M., Lucon O. Ethanol learning curve-the Brazilian experience. Biomass Bioenergy 2004, 26:301-304.
38. Grubb M., Carraro C., Schellnhuber J. Endogenous Technological Change and the Economics of Atmospheric Stabilisation. Energy J. 2006, 1-16.
39. Grubler A., Gritsevskii A. A model of endogenous technological change through uncertain returns on learning (R&D and investments). Conf. Induc. Technol. Change Environ. International Institute of Applied System Analysis, Laxenburg, Austria 1997.
40. Guibert P. Mathematical Studies of Aircraft Construction 1945, Central Air Documents Office, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Dayton, Ohio.
41. Hettinga W.G., Junginger H.M., Dekker S.C., Hoogwijk M., McAloon A.J., Hicks K.B. Understanding the reductions in US corn ethanol production costs: An experience curve approach. Energy Policy 2009, 37:190-203.
42. Hewlett J. Economic and regulatory factors affecting the maintenance of nuclear power plants. Energy J. 1996, 17:1-31.
43. Ibenholt K. Explaining Learning Curves for Wind Power. Energy Policy 2002, 30:1181-1189.
44. IEA/OECD Experience Curves for Energy Technology Policy 2000, International Energy Agency, Paris, France.
45. IPCC IPCC Special Report on Carbon dioxide Capture and Storage. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Geneva, Switzerland 2005, B. Metz OD, OD (Eds.).
46. Jamasb T. Technical change theory and learning curves: patterns of progress in electricity generation technologies. Energy J. 2007, 28:51-72.
47. Joskow P.I., Rose N.L. The effects of technological change, experience, and environmental regulation on the construction cost of coal-burning generating units. RAND J. Econ. 1985, 16:1-27.
48. Junginger M., Visser Ed, Hjort-Gregersen K., Koornneef J., Ravenc R., Faaija A., Turkenburg W. Technological learning in bioenergy systems. Energy Policy 2006, 34.
49. Klaassen G., Miketa A., Larsen K., Sundqvist T. The Impact of R&D on Innovation for Wind Energy in Denmark, Germany, and the United Kingdom. Ecol. Econ. 2005, 54:227-240.
50. Klepper S., Graddy E. The Evolution of New Industries and the Determinants of Market Structure. RAND J. Econ. 1990, 21:27-44.
51. Klepper S., Simons K. The making of an oligopoly: Firm survival and technological change in the evolution of the US tire industry. J. Polit. Econ. 2000, 108:728-760.
52. Kypreos S. CO2 emission control in Switzerland using mathematical programming. Infor 1992, 30:194-206.
53. Lindman, A., Soderholm, P., in press. Wind power learning rates: A conceptual review and meta-analysis. Energy Economics. doi:10.1016/j.eneco.2011.05.007.
54. Manne A., Richels R. Buying Greenhouse Insurance: The Economic Costs of CO2 Emission Limits 1992, MIT, Cambridge, MA.
55. Maxwell J.D., Humphries L.R. Evaluation of the Advanced Low-NOx Burner, Exxon, and Hitachi Zosen DeNOx Processes 1981, Report # EPA-600/7-81-120, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development.
56. Maxwell J.D., Burnett T.A., Faucett H.L. Preliminary Economic Analysis of NOx Flue Gas Treatment Processes. EPA/600/7-80/021 1980, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C.
57. McDonald A., Schrattenholzer L. Learning rates for energy technologies. Energy Policy 2001, 29:255-261.
58. McDonald A., Schrattenholzer L. Learning curves and technology assessment. Int. J. Technol. Manag. 2002, 23:718-745.
59. Merrow E.W., McDonnell L., Argüden R.Y. Understanding the Outcomes of Megaprojects : a Quantitative Analysis of Very Large Civilian Projects 1988, RAND Corp, Santa Monica, CA.
60. Messner S., Golodnikov A., Gritsevskii A. A stochastic version of the dynamic linear programming model MESSAGE III. Energy 1996, 21:775-784.
61. Mobley J.D. Status of EPA's NOx flue gas treatment program. Proceedings: Second NOx Control Technology Symposium 1978, EPRI, Denver, Colorado. J.E. Cichanowicz (Ed.).
62. Neij L. Use of Experience Curves to Analyze the Prospects for Diffusion and Adoption of Renewable Energy Technology. Energy Policy 1997, 23:1099-1107.
63. Neij L. Cost dynamics of wind power. Energy 1999, 24:375-389.
64. Neij L., Andersen P.D., Durstewitz M. Experience curves for wind power. Int. J. Energy Technol. Policy 2004, 2:15-32.
65. Nemet G.F. Beyond the learning curve: factors influencing cost reductions in photovoltaics. Energy Policy 2006, 34:3218-3232.
66. Nordhaus W.D. Managing the Global Commons: The Economics of Climate Change 1994, MIT Press, Cambridge.
67. Nordhaus W. The Perils of the Learning Model For Modeling Endogenous Technological Change. National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper Series 2009.
68. Ostwald P., Reisdoft J. Measurement of technology progress and capital-cost for nuclear, coal-fired, and gas-fired power-plants using the learning curve. Eng. Process. Econ. 1979, 4:435-453.
69. Papineau M. An economic perspective on experience curves and dynamic economies in renewable energy technologies. Energy Policy 2006, 34:422-432.
70. 2 for Enhanced Oil Recovery in Appalachia 1976, Department of Chemical Engineering, West Virginia University, Morgantown, West Virginia.
71. Prinn R., Jacoby H., Sokolov A., Wang C., Xiao X. Integrated global system model for climate policy assessment: Feedbacks and sensitivity studies. Clim. Chang. 1999, 41:469-546.
72. Rao A.B. A Technical, Environmental, and Economic Assessment of Amine-Based Carbon Capture Technologies for Greenhouse Gas Control 2003, Department of Engineering and Public Policy, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA.
73. Rao A.B., Rubin E.S. A Technical, Economic, and Environmental Assessment of Amine-Based CO2 Capture Technology for Power Plant Greenhouse Gas Control. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2002, 36:4467-4475.
74. Rao A.B., Rubin E.S., Keith D.W., Granger Morgan M. Evaluation of potential cost reductions from improved amine-based CO2 capture systems. Energy Policy 2006, 34:3765-3772.
75. Riahi K., Rubin E.S., Taylor M., Schrattenholzer L., Hounshell D.A. Technological Learning for Carbon Capture and Sequestration Technologies. Energy Econ. 2004, 26:539-564.
76. Riahi K., Barreto L., Rao S., Rubin E.S. Towards Fossil-Based Electricity Systems with Integrated CO2 Capture: Implications of an Illustrative Long-Term Technology Policy. Peer-Reviewed Papers and Overviews 2005, Volume I:921-929. Elsevier.
77. Rose N.L., Joskow P.I. The diffusion of new technologies: evidence from the electricity utility industry. RAND J. Econ. 1990, 21:354-373.
78. Rubin E.S., Yeh S., Taylor M.R., Hounshell D.A. Experience curves for power plant emission control technologies. Int. J. Energy Technol. Policy 2004, 2:52-69.
79. Rubin E.S., Hounshell D.A., Yeh S., Taylor M., Schrattenholzer L., Riahi K., Barreto L., Rao S. The Effect of Government Actions on Environmental Technology Innovation: Applications to the Integrated Assessment of Carbon Sequestration Technologies. Final Report of Award No. DE-FG02-00ER63037 from Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA to Office of Biological and Environmental Research 2004, U.S. Department of Energy, Germantown, MD, 153p.
80. Rubin E.S., Antes M., Yeh S., Berkenpas M. Estimating the Future Trends in the Cost of CO2 Capture Technologies. Report No. 2006/6 2006, IEA Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme (IEA GHG), Cheltenham, UK.
81. Rubin E.S., Yeh S., Antes M.K., Berkenpas M.B. Use of experience curves to estimate the future cost of power plants with CO2 capture. Int. J. Greenhouse Gas Control 2007, 1:188-197.
82. Schaeffer G.J. Experience curves as policy tool - the case of PV, EXCETP-EXTOOL workshop, Paris 2003.
83. Schoots K., Ferioli F., Kramer G.J., van der Zwaan B.C.C. Learning Curves for Hydrogen Production Technology: an Assessment of Observed Cost Reductions. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2008, 33:2630-2645.
84. Seebregts A., Kram T., Schaeffer G.J., Bos A. Endogenous learning and technology clustering: analysis with MARKAL model of the Western European energy system. Int. J. Global Energy Issues 2000, 14:289-319.
85. Simbeck D.R., McDonald M. Existing Coal Power Plant Retrofit CO2 Control Options Analysis. Fifth Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies (GHGT-5), Cairns, Australia 2000.
86. Sinclair G., Klepper S., Cohen W. What's experience got to do with it? sources of cost reduction in a large specialty chemical producer. Manag. Sci. 2000, 46:28-45.
87. Skopp A. Fluid Bed Studies of the Limestone Based Flue Gas Desulfurization Process. Esso Research and Engineering Company prepared under contract No. PH 86-67-130 for National Air Pollution Control Administration 1969.
88. Söderholm P., Klassen G. Wind power in Europe: a simultaneous innovation-diffusion model. Environ. Resour. Econ. 2007, 36:163-190.
89. Söderholm P., Sundqvist T. Empirical challenges in the use of learning curves for assessing the economic prospects of renewable energy technologies. Renewable Energy 2007, 32:2559-2578.
90. Spaite P.W. SO2 control: status, cost and outlook. Power Engineering 1972, 34-37.
91. SRI An Improved Rational and Mathematical Explanation of the Progress Curve in Airframe Production 1949, Stanford Research Institute, Stanford, California.
92. SRI Relationships for Determining the Optimum Expansibility of the Elements of a Peacetime Aircraft Procurement Program 1949, Stanford Research Institute, Prepared for Air Materiel Command, USAF, Stanford, California.
93. Sturm R. Nuclear-power in eastern Europe - learning or forgetting curves. Energy Econ. 1993, 15:183-189.
94. Taylor M. The Influence of Government Actions on Innovative Activities in the Development of Environmental Technologies to Control Sulfur Dioxide Emissions from Stationary Sources, Department of Engineering and Public Policy 2001, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA.
95. 2 control. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2003, 37:4527-4534.
96. Taylor M.R., Rubin E.S., Hounshell D.A. Control of SO2 Emissions from Power Plants: A Case of Induced Technological Innovation in the U.S. Technol. Forecast Soc. Chang. 2005, 72:697-718.
97. The M.W.Kellogg Company Evaluation of SO2 - Control Processes. Task #5 Final Report. Submitted to Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Air Programs. Contract No. CPA 70-68 1971, The M. W. Kellogg, Piscataway, NJ.
98. Thornton R.A., Thompson P. Learning from experience and learning from others. An exploration of learning and spilllovers in wartime shipbuilding. Am. Econ. Rev. 2001, 91:1350-1368.
99. U.S.NRC Information Digest 2003 Edition (NUREG-1350, Vol. 15) 2003, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C.
100. van der Zwaan B.C.C., Rabl A. Prospects for PV: a learning curve analysis. Sol. Energy 2003, 74:19-31.
101. van der Zwaan B.C.C., Gerlagh R., Klaassen G., Schrattenholzer L. Endogenous technological change in climate change modeling. Energy Econ. 2002, 24.
102. Watanabe C., Wakabayashi K., Miyazawa T. Industrial dynamism and the creation of a "virtuous cycle" between R&D, market growth and price reduction - The case of photovoltaic power generation (PV) development in Japan. Technovation 2000, 20:299-312.
103. Watanabe C., Nagamatsu A., Griffy-Brown C. Behavior of technology in reducing prices of innovative goods - an analysis of the governing factors of variance of PV module prices. Technovation 2003, 23:423-436.
104. Weiss M., Junginger M., Patel M.K., Blok K. A review of experience curve analyses for energy demand technologies. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Chang. 2010, 77:411-428.
105. Wene C.O. Energy technology learning through deployment in competitive markets. Eng. Econ. 2008, 53:340-364.
106. Wene C.O., Ellersdorfer I., Fahl U. Technology learning and investments needs for upstream oil and the LNG chain. Proceedings Ansätze zur Modellierung von Innovation in der Energiewirtschaft, Mensch und Buch Verlag, Berlin 2005.
107. Wright T.P. Factors affecting the cost of airplanes. J. Aeronaut. Sci. 1936, 3:122-128.
108. Yeh S., Rubin E.S. A centurial history of technological change and learning curves for pulverized coal-fired utility boilers. Energy 2007, 32:1996-2005.
109. Yeh S., Rubin E.S., Hounshell D.A., Taylor M.R. Technology innovations and experience curves for NOx control technologies. J. Air Waste Manage. Assoc. 2007, 55:1827-1838.
110. Yelle L.E. The Learning Curve: Historical Review and Comprehensive Survey. Decis. Sci. 1979, 10:302-328.