Do different disparity proxies converge on a common signal? Insights from the cranial morphometrics and evolutionary history of Pterosauria (Diapsida: Archosauria)

Journal of Evolutionary Biology

Volumn 25, Issue 5, 2012, Pages 904-915

  Foth, C ^a   Brusatte, S L ^b,c   Butler, R J ^a,d  

^a BAYERISCHE STAATSSAMMLUNG FÜR PALÄONTOLOGIE UND GEOLOGIE   (Germany)

^b DIVISION OF INVERTEBRATE ZOOLOGY   (United States)

^c Och Spine at New York Presbyterian Hospitals   (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF MUNICH   (Germany)

Author keywords

Disparity; Geometric morphometrics; Macroevolution; Mesozoic; Monofenestrata; Phylogenetic comparative methods; Phylogeny; Pterosauria; Skull shape

Indexed keywords

ANATOMY; CLADISTICS; CRETACEOUS; EXTINCTION; FOSSIL RECORD; FUNCTIONAL MORPHOLOGY; GEOMETRY; MEASUREMENT METHOD; MORPHOMETRY; PALEOENVIRONMENT; PHYLOGENETICS; PHYLOGENY; REPTILE; SIGNAL; SKELETON; SKULL; TAXONOMY; TIMESCALE;

ANIMAL; ARTICLE; BODY SIZE; CLASSIFICATION; EVOLUTION; FACTUAL DATABASE; FOSSIL; GROWTH, DEVELOPMENT AND AGING; HISTOLOGY; MORPHOGENESIS; PHYLOGENY; PHYSIOLOGY; REPTILE; SKULL; SPECIES DIFFERENCE; TIME;

ANIMALS; BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION; BODY SIZE; DATABASES, FACTUAL; FOSSILS; MORPHOGENESIS; PHYLOGENY; REPTILES; SKULL; SPECIES SPECIFICITY; TIME FACTORS;

ANUROGNATHIDAE; ARCHOSAURIA; PTEROSAURIA; REPTILIA; SAURIA;

EID: 84859438425     PISSN: 1010061X     EISSN: 14209101     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1420-9101.2012.02479.x     Document Type: Article

References (74)

1. Adams, D.C., Rohlf, F.J. & Slice, D.E. 2004. Geometric morphometrics: ten years of progress following the 'revolution'. Ital. J. Zool. 71: 5-16.
2. Andres, B. 2009. The quality of the pterosaur fossil record. J. Vert. Paleontol. 29(Suppl. 3): 55A.
3. Andres, B. 2010. Systematics of the Pterosauria. PhD thesis, Department of Geology and Geophysics, Yale University, New Haven. 347 pp.
4. Andres, B. & Ji, Q. 2008. A new pterosaur from the Liaoning Province of China, the phylogeny of Pterodactyloidea, and convergence in their cervical vertebrae. Palaeontology 51: 453-469.
5. Andres, B., Clark, J. & Xu, X. 2010. A new rhamphorhynchid pterosaur from the Upper Jurassic of Xinjiang, China, and the phylogenetic relationships of basal pterosaurs. J. Vert. Paleontol. 30: 163-187.
6. Barrett, P.M., Butler, R.J., Edwards, N.P. & Milner, A.R. 2008. Pterosaur distribution in time and space: an atlas. Zitteliana B 28: 61-107.
7. Bennett, S.C. 2003. New crested specimens of the Late Cretaceous pterosaur Nyctosaurus. Pal. Zeit. 77: 61-75.
8. Bennett, S.C. 2007. A second specimen of the pterosaur Anurognathus ammoni. Pal. Zeit. 81: 376-398.
9. Benton, M.J., Dunhill, A.M., Lloyd, G.T. & Marx, F.G. 2011. Assessing the quality of the fossil record: insights from vertebrates. In: Comparing the Geological and Fossil Records: Implications for Biodiversity (A.J. McGowan & A.B. Smith, eds), pp. 63-94. Geological Society, London, Special Publication 358.
10. Bonaparte, J.F. 1970. Pterodaustro guinazui gen. et sp. nov. Pterosaurio de la Formación Lagarcito, Provincia de San Luis, Argentina y su significado en la geología regional (Pterodactylidae). Acta Geol. Lill. 10: 207-226.
11. Bookstein, F.L. 1991. Morphometric Tools for Landmark Data. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
12. Brusatte, S.L. 2011. Calculating the tempo of morphological evolution: rates of discrete character change in a phylogenetic context. In: Computational Paleontology (A.M.T. Elewa, ed.), pp. 53-74. Springer-Verlag Publishers, Heidelberg, Germany.
13. Brusatte, S.L., Benton, M.J., Ruta, M. & Lloyd, G.T. 2008. Superiority, competition, and opportunism in the evolutionary radiation of dinosaurs. Science 321: 1485-1488.
14. Brusatte, S.L., Sakamoto, M., Montanari, S. & Harcourt-Smith, W.E.H. 2012. The evolution of cranial form and function in theropod dinosaurs: insights from geometric morphometrics. J. Evol. Biol. 25: 365-377.
15. Butler, R.J. & Goswami, A. 2008. Body size evolution in Mesozoic birds: little evidence for Cope's rule. J. Evol. Biol. 26: 1673-1682.
16. Butler, R.J., Barrett, P.M. & Gower, D.J. 2009a. Postcranial skeletal pneumaticity and air-sacs in the earliest pterosaurs. Biol. Lett. 5: 557-560.
17. Butler, R.J., Barrett, P.M., Nowbath, S. & Upchurch, P. 2009b. Estimating the effects of the rock record on pterosaur diversity patterns: implications for hypotheses of bird/pterosaur competitive replacement. Paleobiology 35: 432-446.
18. Butler, R.J., Barrett, P.M., Benson, R.B.J., Brusatte, S.L. & Andres, B. 2011. The taxonomic diversity and morphological disparity of pterosaurs: untangling sampling biases, the impact of Lagerstätten, and diversification trajectories. Ann. Meeting Soc. Vert. Paleontol. Abstr. 2011: 81.
19. Butler, R.J., Brusatte, S.L., Andres, B. & Benson, R.B.J. 2012. How do rock record biases affect studies of disparity in deep time? A case study of the Pterosauria (Reptilia: Archosauria) Evolution 66: 147-162.
20. Ciampaglio, C.N., Kemp, M. & McShea, D.W. 2001. Detecting changes in morphospace occupation patterns in the fossil record: characterization and analysis of measures of disparity. Paleobiology 27: 695-715.
21. Claessens, L.P.A.M., O'Connor, P.M. & Unwin, D.M. 2009. Respiratory evolution facilitated the origin of pterosaur flight and aerial gigantism. PLoS ONE 4: e4497.
22. Dyke, G.J., Nudds, R.L. & Rayner, J.M. 2006. Limb disparity and wing shape in pterosaurs. J. Evol. Biol. 19: 1339-1342.
23. Dyke, G.J., McGowan, A.J., Nudds, R.L. & Smith, D. 2009. The shape of pterosaur evolution: evidence from the fossil record. J. Evol. Biol. 22: 890-898.
24. Elewa, A.M.T. 2004. Morphometrics: Applications in Biology and Paleontology. Springer-Verlag, Heidelberg.
25. Elgin, R.A., Grau, C.A., Palmer, C., Hone, D.W.E., Greenwell, D. & Benton, M.J. 2008. Aerodynamic characters of the cranial crest in Pteranodon. Zitteliana B 28: 167-174.
26. Erwin, D.H. 2007. Disparity: morphological pattern and developmental context. Palaeontology 50: 57-73.
27. Foote, M. 1993. Discordance and concordance between morphological and taxonomic diversity. Paleobiology 20: 185-204.
28. Foote, M. 1994. Morphological disparity in Ordovician-Devonian crinoids and the early saturation of morphological space. Paleobiology 20: 320-344.
29. Frey, E., Tischlinger, H., Buchy, M.-C. & Martill, D.M. 2003. New specimens of Pterosauria (Reptilia) with soft parts with implications for pterosaurian anatomy and locomotion. In: Evolution and Palaeobiology of Pterosaurs (E. Buffetaut & J.-M. Mazin, eds), pp. 233-266. The Geological Society, London.
30. Friedman, M. 2010. Explosive morphological diversification of spiny-finned teleost fishes in the aftermath of the end-Cretaceous extinction. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 277: 1675-1683.
31. Gould, S.J. 1991. The disparity of the Burgess Shale arthropod fauna and the limits of cladistic analysis: why we must strive to quantify morphospace. Paleobiology 17: 411-423.
32. Hammer, Ø. & Harper, D. 2006. Paleontological Data Analysis. Blackwell Publishing, Malden.
33. Henderson, D.M. 2010. Pterosaur body mass estimates from three-dimensional mathematical slicing. J. Vert. Paleontol. 30: 768-785.
34. Hone, D.W.E., Naish, D. & Cuthill, I.C. 2011. Does mutual sexual selection explain the evolution of head crests in pterosaurs and dinosaurs? Lethaia DOI: .
35. Jones, K.E. & Goswami, A. 2010. Quantitative analysis of the influences of phylogeny and ecology on phocid and otariid pinniped (Mammalia; Carnivora) cranial morphology. J. Zool. 280: 297-308.
36. Klingenberg, C.P. 2011. MorphoJ: an integrated software package for geometric morphometrics. Mol. Ecol. Resour. 11: 353-357.
37. Klingenberg, C.P. & Gidaszewski, N.A. 2010. Testing and quantifying phylogenetic signals and homoplasy in morphometric data. Syst. Biol. 59: 245-261.
38. Laurin, M. 2004. The evolution of body size, Cope's rule and the origin of amniotes. Syst. Biol. 53: 594-622.
39. Lefebvre, B., Eble, G.J., Navarro, N. & David, B. 2006. Diversification of atypical Paleozoic echinoderms: a quantitative survey of patterns of stylophoran disparity, diversity, and geography. Paleobiology 32: 483-510.
40. Lü, J. & Ji, Q. 2006. Preliminary results of a phylogenetic analysis of the pterosaurs from western Liaoning and surrounding areas. J. Paleont. Soc. Korea 22: 239-261.
41. Lü, J., Unwin, D.M., Jin, X., Liu, Y. & Ji, Q. 2010. Evidence for modular evolution in a long-tailed pterosaur with a pterodactyloid skull. Proc. Biol. Sci. 277: 383-389.
42. Lü, J., Unwin, D.M., Deeming, D.C., Ji, X., Liu, J. & Ji, Q. 2011. An egg-adult association, gender, and reproduction in pterosaurs. Science 331: 321-324.
43. Lupia, R. 1999. Discordant morphological disparity and taxonomic diversity during the Cretaceous angiosperm radiation: North American pollen record. Paleobiology 25: 1-28.
44. Maddison, W.P. 1991. Squared-change parsimony reconstructions of ancestral states for continuous-valued characters on a phylogenetic tree. Syst. Zool. 40: 304-314.
45. Maddison, W.P. & Maddison, D.R. 2009. Mesquite: a modular system of evolutionary analysis. Version 2.72.
46. Maisey, J.G. 1991. Santana Fossils. TFH Publications, Neptune City, New Jersey.
47. Martill, D.M. & Naish, D. 2006. Cranial crest development in the azhdarchoid pterosaur Tupuxuara, with a review of the genus and tapejarid monophyly. Palaeontology 49: 925-941.
48. McGowan, A.J. & Dyke, G.J. 2007. A morphospace-based test for competitive exclusion among flying vertebrates: did birds, bats and pterosaurs get in each other's space? J. Evol. Biol. 20: 1230-1236.
49. O'Higgins, P. 2000. The study of morphological variation in the hominid fossil record: biology, landmarks and geometry. J. Anat. 197: 103-120.
50. O{double acute}si, A. 2010. Feeding-related characters in basal pterosaurs: implications for jaw mechanism, dental function and diet. Lethaia 44: 136-152.
51. O{double acute}si, A., Weishampel, D.B. & Jianu, C.M. 2005. First evidence of azhdarchid pterosaurs from the Late Cretaceous of Hungary. Acta Palaeontol. Pol. 50: 777-787.
52. Padian, K. 1983. A functional analysis of flying and walking in pterosaurs. Paleobiology 9: 218-239.
53. Padian, K. 1985. The origins and aerodynamics of flight in extinct vertebrates. Palaeontology 28: 413-433.
54. Palmer, C. & Dyke, G.J. 2010. Biomechanics of the unique pterosaur pteroid. Proc. Biol. Sci. 277: 1121-1127.
55. Paradis, E., Claude, J. & Strimmer, K. 2004. APE: analyses of phylogenetics and evolution in R language. Bioinformatics 20: 289-290. .
56. Prentice, K.C., Ruta, M. & Benton, M.J. 2011. Evolution of morphological disparity in pterosaurs. J. Syst. Palaeontol. 9: 337-353.
57. R Development Core Team 2011. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna. .
58. Rohlf, F.J. 2000. Statistical power comparisons among alternative morphometric methods. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 111: 463-478.
59. Rohlf, F.J. 2010. TpsDig 2. Department of Ecology and Evolution, State University of New York, Stony Brook, NY.
60. Ruta, M. 2009. Patterns of morphological evolution in major groups of Palaeozoic Temnospondyli (Amphibia: Tetrapoda). Spec. Pap. Palaeontol. 81: 91-120.
61. Ruta, M., Wagner, P.J. & Coates, M.I. 2006. Evolutionary patterns in early tetrapods. I. Rapid initial diversification followed by decrease in rates of character change. Proc. Biol. Sci. 273: 2107-2111.
62. Smith, L.H. & Lieberman, B.S. 1999. Disparity and constraint in olenelloid trilobites and the Cambrian radiation. Paleobiology 25: 459-470.
63. Tomkins, J.L., LeBas, N.R., Witton, M.P., Martill, D.M. & Humphries, S. 2010. Positive allometry and the prehistory of sexual selection. Am. Nat. 176: 141-148.
64. Unwin, D.M. 2006. The Pterosaurs from Deep Time. Pi Press, New York.
65. Villier, L. & Eble, G.J. 2004. Assessing the robustness of disparity estimates: the impact of morphometric scheme, temporal scale, and taxonomic level in spatangoid echinoids. Paleobiology 30: 652-665.
66. Wang, X., Kellner, A.W.A., Zhou, Z. & Campos, D.D.A. 2005. Pterosaur diversity and faunal turnover in Cretaceous terrestrial ecosystems in China. Nature 437: 875-879.
67. Wellnhofer, P. 1991. The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Pterosaurs. Salamander Books Ltd., London.
68. Wilkinson, M.T., Unwin, D.M. & Ellington, C.P. 2006. High lift function of the pteroid bone and forewing of pterosaurs. Proc. Biol. Sci. 273: 119-126.
69. Wills, M.A. 1998. Crustacean disparity through the Phanerozoic: comparing morphological and stratigraphic data. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 65: 455-500.
70. Wills, M.A., Briggs, D.E.G. & Fortey, R.A. 1994. Disparity as an evolutionary index: a comparison of Cambrian and Recent arthropods. Paleobiology 20: 93-130.
71. Witton, M.P. 2008. A new approach to determining pterosaur body mass and its implications for pterosaur flight. Zitteliana B 28: 143-158.
72. Witton, M.P. & Habib, M.B. 2010. On the size and flight diversity of giant pterosaurs, the use of birds as pterosaur analogues and comments on the pterosaur flightlessness. PLoS ONE 5: e13982.
73. Witton, M.P. & Naish, D. 2008. A reappraisal of azhdarchid pterosaur functional morphology and paleoecology. PLoS ONE 3: e2271.
74. Zelditch, M.L., Swiderski, D.L., Sheets, H.D. & Fink, W.L. 2004. Geometric Morphometrics for Biologists: A Primer. Elsevier Academic Press, San Diego.