Effects of strength vs aerobic exercise on pain severity in adults with fibromyalgia: A randomized equivalence trial

Pain

Volumn 153, Issue 4, 2012, Pages 915-923

  Hooten, W Michael ^a   Qu, Wenchun ^b   Townsend, Cynthia O ^a   Judd, Jeffrey W ^b  

^a Mayo Clinic College of Medicine   (United States)

^b MAYO CLINIC COLLEGE OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

Aerobic; Equivalence; Exercise; Fibromyalgia; Randomized; Strength; Trial

Indexed keywords

ADULT; AEROBIC EXERCISE; ARTICLE; CONFIDENCE INTERVAL; CONTROLLED STUDY; DISEASE SEVERITY; FEMALE; FIBROMYALGIA; HEALTH PROGRAM; HUMAN; INTENTION TO TREAT ANALYSIS; MAJOR CLINICAL STUDY; MALE; MULTIDIMENSIONAL SCALING; MUSCLE STRENGTH; OXYGEN CONSUMPTION; PAIN ASSESSMENT; PAIN THRESHOLD; PATIENT PREFERENCE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL; RESISTANCE TRAINING;

ADULT; EXERCISE; EXERCISE THERAPY; FEMALE; FIBROMYALGIA; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; PAIN; PAIN MANAGEMENT; PAIN MEASUREMENT; RESISTANCE TRAINING; SEVERITY OF ILLNESS INDEX; THERAPEUTIC EQUIVALENCY;

EID: 84858707117     PISSN: 03043959     EISSN: 18726623     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.pain.2012.01.020     Document Type: Article

References (73)

1. L. Altan, N. Korkmaz, U. Bingol, and B. Gunay Effect of pilates training on people with fibromyalgia syndrome: a pilot study Arch Phys Med Rehabil 90 2009 1983 1988
2. D.G. Altman, and J.M. Bland Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence BMJ 311 1995 485
3. E.M. Bartels, and B. Danneskiold-Samsoe Histological abnormalities in muscle from patients with certain types of fibrositis Lancet 1 1986 755 757 (Pubitemid 16075646)
4. I.H. Bernstein, M.E. Jaremko, and B.S. Hinkley On the utility of the West Haven-Yale multidimensional pain inventory Spine 20 1995 956 963
5. C. Bircan, S.A. Karasel, B. Akgun, O. El, and S. Alper Effects of muscle strengthening versus aerobic exercise program in fibromyalgia Rheumatol Int 28 2008 527 532
6. B.K. Bruce, C.O. Townsend, W.M. Hooten, J.D. Rome, J.S. Moon, and J.W. Swanson Chronic pain rehabilitation in chronic headache disorders Curr Neurol Neurosci Rep 8 2008 94 99 (Pubitemid 351460242)
7. J. Cohen Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences 1988 Lawrence Earlbaum Associates Hillsdale, NJ
8. M.D. Cordero, M. De Miguel, A.M. Moreno Fernandez, I.M. Carmona Lopez, J. Garrido Maraver, D. Cotan, L. Gomez Izquierdo, P. Bonal, F. Campa, P. Bullon, P. Navas, and J.A. Sanchez Alcazar Mitochondrial dysfunction and mitophagy activation in blood mononuclear cells of fibromyalgia patients: implications in the pathogenesis of the disease Arthritis Res Ther 12 2010 R17
9. J.L. Cunningham, J.D. Rome, J.L. Kerkvliet, and C.O. Townsend Reduction in medication costs for patients with chronic nonmalignant pain completing a pain rehabilitation program: a prospective analysis of admission, discharge, and 6-month follow-up medication costs Pain Med 10 2009 787 796
10. D. Da Costa, M. Abrahamowicz, I. Lowensteyn, S. Bernatsky, M. Dritsa, M.A. Fitzcharles, and P.L. Dobkin A randomized clinical trial of an individualized home-based exercise programme for women with fibromyalgia Rheumatology (Oxford) 44 2005 1422 1427 (Pubitemid 41631867)
11. K.M. Darchuk, C.O. Townsend, J.D. Rome, B.K. Bruce, and W.M. Hooten Longitudinal treatment outcomes for geriatric patients with chronic non-cancer pain at an interdisciplinary pain rehabilitation program Pain Med 11 2010 1352 1364
12. M. Dinler, D. Diracoglu, E. Kasikcioglu, O. Sayli, A. Akin, C. Aksoy, A. Oncel, and E. Berker Effect of aerobic exercise training on oxygen uptake and kinetics in patients with fibromyalgia Rheumatol Int 30 2009 281 284
13. M. Dinler, E. Kasikcioglu, A. Akin, O. Sayli, C. Aksoy, A. Oncel, and E. Berker Exercise capacity and oxygen recovery half times of skeletal muscle in patients with fibromyalgia Rheumatol Int 27 2007 311 313 (Pubitemid 46088266)
14. A.M. Drewes, A. Andreasen, H.D. Schroder, B. Hogsaa, and P. Jennum Pathology of skeletal muscle in fibromyalgia: a histo-immuno-chemical and ultrastructural study Br J Rheumatol 32 1993 479 483 (Pubitemid 23193404)
15. S. DuPen, and A. DuPen Opioid conversion calculator 2000 Cynergy Group Poulsbo, WA
16. M.E. Geisser, R.S. Roth, and M.E. Robinson Assessing depression among persons with chronic pain using the center for epidemiological studies-depression scale and the beck depression inventory: a comparative analysis Clin J Pain 13 1997 163 170 (Pubitemid 27251111)
17. S.E. Gowans, A. DeHueck, S. Voss, A. Silaj, S.E. Abbey, and W.J. Reynolds Effect of a randomized, controlled trial of exercise on mood and physical function in individuals with fibromyalgia Arthritis Rheum 45 2001 519 529 (Pubitemid 33140587)
18. R.H. Gracely, F. Petzke, J.M. Wolf, and D.J. Clauw Functional magnetic resonance imaging evidence of augmented pain processing in fibromyalgia Arthritis Rheum 46 2002 1333 1343 (Pubitemid 34525843)
19. A. Hakkinen, K. Hakkinen, P. Hannonen, and M. Alen Strength training induced adaptations in neuromuscular function of premenopausal women with fibromyalgia: comparison with healthy women Ann Rheum Dis 60 2001 21 26 (Pubitemid 32038948)
20. R.N. Harden, G. Revivo, S. Song, D. Nampiaparampil, G. Golden, M. Kirincic, and T.T. Houle A critical analysis of the tender points in fibromyalgia Pain Med 8 2007 147 156
21. W.M. Hooten, P. Sandroni, C.B. Mantilla, and C.O. Townsend Associations between heat pain perception and pain severity among patients with chronic pain Pain Med 11 2010 1554 1563
22. W.M. Hooten, C.O. Townsend, B.K. Bruce, Y. Shi, and D.O. Warner Sex differences in characteristics of smokers with chronic pain undergoing multidisciplinary pain rehabilitation Pain Med 10 2009 1416 1425
23. W.M. Hooten, C.O. Townsend, B.K. Bruce, and D.O. Warner The effects of smoking status on opioid tapering among patients with chronic pain Anesth Analg 108 2009 308 315
24. W.M. Hooten, C.O. Townsend, and P.A. Decker Gender differences among patients with fibromyalgia undergoing multidisciplinary pain rehabilitation Pain Med 8 2007 624 632 (Pubitemid 350142909)
25. W.M. Hooten, C.O. Townsend, C.D. Sletten, B.K. Bruce, and J.D. Rome Treatment outcomes after multidisciplinary pain rehabilitation with analgesic medication withdrawal for patients with fibromyalgia Pain Med 8 2007 8 16 (Pubitemid 46128762)
26. H. Imamura, S. Shibuya, K. Uchida, K. Teshima, R. Masuda, and N. Miyamoto Effect of moderate exercise on excess post-exercise oxygen consumption and catecholamines in young women J Sports Med Phys Fitness 44 2004 23 29 (Pubitemid 38506517)
27. M. Jeschonneck, G. Grohmann, G. Hein, and H. Sprott Abnormal microcirculation and temperature in skin above tender points in patients with fibromyalgia Rheumatology (Oxford) 39 2000 917 921 (Pubitemid 30649522)
28. B. Jones, P. Jarvis, J.A. Lewis, and A.F. Ebbutt Trials to assess equivalence. The importance of rigorous methods BMJ 313 1996 36 39 (Pubitemid 26229889)
29. K.D. Jones, C.S. Burckhardt, S.R. Clark, R.M. Bennett, and K.M. Potempa A randomized controlled trial of muscle strengthening versus flexibility training in fibromyalgia J Rheumatol 29 2002 1041 1048 (Pubitemid 34493512)
30. D. Kadetoff, and E. Kosek The effects of static muscular contraction on blood pressure, heart rate, pain ratings and pressure pain thresholds in healthy individuals and patients with fibromyalgia Eur J Pain 11 2007 39 47 (Pubitemid 44636278)
31. L. Karavirta, K. Hakkinen, A. Kauhanen, A. Arija-Blazquez, E. Sillanpaa, N. Rinkinen, and A. Hakkinen Individual responses to combined endurance and strength training in older adults Med Sci Sports Exerc 43 2011 484 490
32. E. Kasikcioglu, M. Dinler, and E. Berker Reduced tolerance of exercise in fibromyalgia may be a consequence of impaired microcirculation initiated by deficient action of nitric oxide Med Hypotheses 66 2006 950 952 (Pubitemid 43207653)
33. D.L. Katz, L. Greene, A. Ali, and Z. Faridi The pain of fibromyalgia syndrome is due to muscle hypoperfusion induced by regional vasomotor dysregulation Med Hypotheses 69 2007 517 525 (Pubitemid 47043280)
34. R.D. Kerns, D.C. Turk, and T.E. Rudy The West Haven-Yale Multidimensional Pain Inventory (WHYMPI) Pain 23 1985 345 356 (Pubitemid 16212847)
35. J.D. Kingsley, V. McMillan, and A. Figueroa The effects of 12 weeks of resistance exercise training on disease severity and autonomic modulation at rest and after acute leg resistance exercise in women with fibromyalgia Arch Phys Med Rehabil 91 2010 1551 1557
36. J.D. Kingsley, L.B. Panton, T. Toole, P. Sirithienthad, R. Mathis, and V. McMillan The effects of a 12-week strength-training program on strength and functionality in women with fibromyalgia Arch Phys Med Rehabil 86 2005 1713 1721 (Pubitemid 41354180)
37. E. Kosek, J. Ekholm, and P. Hansson Modulation of pressure pain thresholds during and following isometric contraction in patients with fibromyalgia and in healthy controls Pain 64 1996 415 423 (Pubitemid 26180148)
38. J. Larose, R.J. Sigal, N.G. Boule, G.A. Wells, D. Prud'homme, M.S. Fortier, R.D. Reid, H. Tulloch, D. Coyle, P. Phillips, A. Jennings, F. Khandwala, and G.P. Kenny Effect of exercise training on physical fitness in type II diabetes mellitus Med Sci Sports Exerc 42 2010 1439 1447
39. F. Liu, L. Carlson, and H.K. Watson Quantitative abductor pollicis brevis strength testing: reliability and normative values J Hand Surg Am 25 2000 752 759 (Pubitemid 30602582)
40. L.M. McCracken, and L. Dhingra A short version of the Pain Anxiety Symptoms Scale (PASS-20): preliminary development and validity Pain Res Manag 7 2002 45 50 (Pubitemid 34552285)
41. K.L. McIver, C. Evans, R.M. Kraus, L. Ispas, V.M. Sciotti, and R.C. Hickner NO-mediated alterations in skeletal muscle nutritive blood flow and lactate metabolism in fibromyalgia Pain 120 2006 161 169 (Pubitemid 43077179)
42. S. Morf, B. Amann-Vesti, A. Forster, U.K. Franzeck, R. Koppensteiner, D. Uebelhart, and H. Sprott Microcirculation abnormalities in patients with fibromyalgia - measured by capillary microscopy and laser fluxmetry Arthritis Res Ther 7 2005 R209 R216
43. J.H. Park, P. Phothimat, C.T. Oates, M. Hernanz-Schulman, and N.J. Olsen Use of P-31 magnetic resonance spectroscopy to detect metabolic abnormalities in muscles of patients with fibromyalgia Arthritis Rheum 41 1998 406 413 (Pubitemid 28128764)
44. D.D. Price, R. Staud, M.E. Robinson, A.P. Mauderli, R. Cannon, and C.J. Vierck Enhanced temporal summation of second pain and its central modulation in fibromyalgia patients Pain 99 2002 49 59 (Pubitemid 35251868)
45. J.R. Redondo, C.M. Justo, F.V. Moraleda, Y.G. Velayos, J.J. Puche, J.R. Zubero, T.G. Hernandez, L.C. Ortells, and M.A. Pareja Long-term efficacy of therapy in patients with fibromyalgia: a physical exercise-based program and a cognitive-behavioral approach Arthritis Rheum 51 2004 184 192 (Pubitemid 38468700)
46. S.C. Richards, and D.L. Scott Prescribed exercise in people with fibromyalgia: parallel group randomised controlled trial BMJ 325 2002 185
47. J.D. Rome, C.O. Townsend, B.K. Bruce, C.D. Sletten, C.A. Luedtke, and J.E. Hodgson Chronic noncancer pain rehabilitation with opioid withdrawal: comparison of treatment outcomes based on opioid use status at admission Mayo Clin Proc 79 2004 759 768 (Pubitemid 38691827)
48. D.S. Rooks, S. Gautam, M. Romeling, M.L. Cross, D. Stratigakis, B. Evans, D.L. Goldenberg, M.D. Iversen, and J.N. Katz Group exercise, education, and combination self-management in women with fibromyalgia: a randomized trial Arch Intern Med 167 2007 2192 2200 (Pubitemid 350106738)
49. T.E. Rudy Multiaxial assessment of multidimensional pain inventory: computer program user's manual 1989 University of Pittsburgh Pittsburgh, PA
50. D.A. Sedlock, M.G. Lee, M.G. Flynn, K.S. Park, and G.H. Kamimori Excess postexercise oxygen consumption after aerobic exercise training Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab 20 2010 336 349
51. K.R. Short, J.L. Vittone, M.L. Bigelow, D.N. Proctor, J.M. Coenen-Schimke, P. Rys, and K.S. Nair Changes in myosin heavy chain mRNA and protein expression in human skeletal muscle with age and endurance exercise training J Appl Physiol 99 2005 95 102 (Pubitemid 40934469)
52. H. Sprott, R. Rzanny, J.R. Reichenbach, W.A. Kaiser, G. Hein, and G. Stein 31P magnetic resonance spectroscopy in fibromyalgic muscle Rheumatology (Oxford) 39 2000 1121 1125
53. H. Sprott, S. Salemi, R.E. Gay, L.A. Bradley, G.S. Alarcon, S.J. Oh, B.A. Michel, and S. Gay Increased DNA fragmentation and ultrastructural changes in fibromyalgic muscle fibres Ann Rheum Dis 63 2004 245 251 (Pubitemid 38250665)
54. R. Staud, S. Nagel, M.E. Robinson, and D.D. Price Enhanced central pain processing of fibromyalgia patients is maintained by muscle afferent input: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study Pain 145 2009 96 104
55. R. Staud, M.E. Robinson, E.E. Weyl, and D.D. Price Pain variability in fibromyalgia is related to activity and rest: role of peripheral tissue impulse input J Pain 11 2010 1376 1383
56. R. Staud, C.J. Vierck, R.L. Cannon, A.P. Mauderli, and D.D. Price Abnormal sensitization and temporal summation of second pain (wind-up) in patients with fibromyalgia syndrome Pain 91 2001 165 175 (Pubitemid 32274185)
57. M. Sullivan, and J. Pivik The Pain Catastrophizing Scale: development and validation Psychol Assess 7 1995 524 532 (Pubitemid 26017352)
58. A.L. Suman, B. Biagi, G. Biasi, G. Carli, M. Gradi, E. Prati, and M. Bonifazi One-year efficacy of a 3-week intensive multidisciplinary non-pharmacological treatment program for fibromyalgia patients Clin Exp Rheumatol 27 2009 7 14
59. P. Tomas-Carus, N. Gusi, A. Hakkinen, K. Hakkinen, A. Raimundo, and A. Ortega-Alonso Improvements of muscle strength predicted benefits in HRQOL and postural balance in women with fibromyalgia: an 8-month randomized controlled trial Rheumatology (Oxford) 48 2009 1147 1151
60. C.O. Townsend, B.K. Bruce, W.M. Hooten, and J.D. Rome The role of mental health professionals in multidisciplinary pain rehabilitation programs J Clin Psychol 62 2006 1433 1443 (Pubitemid 44727411)
61. C.O. Townsend, J.L. Kerkvliet, B.K. Bruce, J.D. Rome, W. Michael Hooten, C.A. Luedtke, and J.E. Hodgson A longitudinal study of the efficacy of a comprehensive pain rehabilitation program with opioid withdrawal: comparison of treatment outcomes based on opioid use status at admission Pain 140 2008 177 189
62. V. Valim, L. Oliveira, A. Suda, L. Silva, M. de Assis, T. Barros Neto, D. Feldman, and J. Natour Aerobic fitness effects in fibromyalgia J Rheumatol 30 2003 1060 1069 (Pubitemid 36529632)
63. H. Valkeinen, M. Alen, A. Hakkinen, P. Hannonen, K. Kukkonen-Harjula, and K. Hakkinen Effects of concurrent strength and endurance training on physical fitness and symptoms in postmenopausal women with fibromyalgia: a randomized controlled trial Arch Phys Med Rehabil 89 2008 1660 1666
64. H. Valkeinen, M. Alen, P. Hannonen, A. Hakkinen, O. Airaksinen, and K. Hakkinen Changes in knee extension and flexion force, EMG and functional capacity during strength training in older females with fibromyalgia and healthy controls Rheumatology (Oxford) 43 2004 225 228 (Pubitemid 38219680)
65. H. Valkeinen, A. Hakkinen, P. Hannonen, K. Hakkinen, and M. Alen Acute heavy-resistance exercise-induced pain and neuromuscular fatigue in elderly women with fibromyalgia and in healthy controls: effects of strength training Arthritis Rheum 54 2006 1334 1339 (Pubitemid 43672947)
66. H. Valkeinen, K. Hakkinen, A. Pakarinen, P. Hannonen, A. Hakkinen, O. Airaksinen, L. Niemitukia, W.J. Kraemer, and M. Alen Muscle hypertrophy, strength development, and serum hormones during strength training in elderly women with fibromyalgia Scand J Rheumatol 34 2005 309 314 (Pubitemid 41215666)
67. S. van Koulil, W. van Lankveld, F.W. Kraaimaat, T. van Helmond, A. Vedder, H. van Hoorn, R. Donders, A.J. de Jong, J.F. Haverman, K.J. Korff, P.L. van Riel, H.A. Cats, and A.W. Evers Tailored cognitive-behavioral therapy and exercise training for high-risk patients with fibromyalgia Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken) 62 2010 1377 1385
68. R.S. Van Zant, and L.E. Bouillon Strength cycle training: effects on muscular strength and aerobic conditioning J Strength Cond Res 21 2007 178 182
69. C. Wang, C.H. Schmid, R. Rones, R. Kalish, J. Yinh, D.L. Goldenberg, Y. Lee, and T. McAlindon A randomized trial of tai chi for fibromyalgia N Engl J Med 363 2010 743 754
70. E.A. Watkins, P.C. Wollan, L.J. Melton 3rd, and B.P. Yawn A population in pain: report from the Olmsted County health study Pain Med 9 2008 166 174 (Pubitemid 351285411)
71. M.M. Weissman, D. Sholomskas, M. Pottenger, B.A. Prusoff, and B.Z. Locke Assessing depressive symptoms in five psychiatric populations: a validation study Am J Epidemiol 106 1977 203 214 (Pubitemid 8190169)
72. J.H. Wilmore, and D.L. Costill Physiology of sport and exercise 2005 Human Kinetics Champaign, IL
73. F. Wolfe, H.A. Smythe, M.B. Yunus, R.M. Bennett, C. Bombardier, D.L. Goldenberg, P. Tugwell, S.M. Campbell, M. Abeles, P. Clark, A.G. Fam, S.J. Farber, J.J. Fiechtner, M.C. Franklin, R.A. Gatter, D. Hamaty, J. Lessard, A.S. Lichtbroun, A.T. Masi, G.A. Mccain, W.J. Reynolds, T.J. Romano, I.J. Russell, and R.P. Sheon The American college of rheumatology 1990 criteria for the classification of fibromyalgia. Report of the multicenter criteria committee Arthritis Rheum 33 1990 160 172 (Pubitemid 20098653)