Comparison of fat mass and fat-free mass between anthropometry, BIA and DEXA in young females: Are methods really interchangeable?

European Journal of Anatomy

Volumn 14, Issue 3, 2010, Pages 133-141

  Alburquerque Sendín, Francisco ^a   Martín Vallejo, Francisco J ^a   García Talavera, Paloma ^b   Martín Gómez, María E ^b   del Rey, Miguel Santos ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SALAMANCA   (Spain)

^b HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO DE SALAMANCA   (Spain)

Author keywords

Anthropometry; Bioelectric impedance; Body composition; Levels of agreement; X ray densitometry

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ANALYSIS; ANTHROPOMETRY; ARTICLE; BIOELECTRICAL IMPEDANCE ANALYSIS; BODY COMPOSITION; BODY MASS; DUAL ENERGY X RAY ABSORPTIOMETRY; FAT FREE MASS; FAT MASS; FEMALE; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY;

EID: 84856027303     PISSN: 11364890     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Article

References (53)

1. AASEN G, FAGERTUN H, HALSE J (2006). Body composition analysis by dual X-ray absorptiometry: in vivo and in vitro comparison of three different fan-beam instruments. Scand J Clin Lab Invest, 66: 659-666.
2. ALBANESE CV, DIESSEL E, GENANT HK (2003). Clinical applications of body composition measurements using DXA. J Clin Densitom, 6: 75-85.
3. BARRERA MG, SALAZAR G, GAJARDO H, GATTÁS V, COWARD A (1997). Comparative analysis of body composition assessment methods in healthy adult men. Revista Médica de Chile, 125: 1335-1342.
4. BLAND JM, ALTMAN DG (1986). Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement. Lancet, 1: 307-310.
5. BLAND JM, ALTMAN DG (2003). Applying the right statistics: analyses of measurement studies. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol, 22: 85-93.
6. CARLYON RG, BRYANT RW, GORE CJ, WALKER RE (1998). Apparatus for precision calibration of skinfold calipers. Am J Hum Biol, 10: 689-697.
7. CASANOVA M, RODRÍGUEZ I, RICO S, CASANOVA M (2004). Análisis de la composición corporal por parámetros antropométricos y bioeléctricos. An Pediatría, 61: 23-31.
8. CORCORAN C, ANDERSON EJ, BURROWS B, STANLEY T, WALSH M, POULOS AM, GRINSPOON S (2000). Comparison of total body potassium with other techniques for measuring lean body mass in men and women with AIDS wasting. Am J Clin Nutrit, 72: 1053-1058.
9. CRONBACH LJ (1951). Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests. Psychometrika, 16: 297-234.
10. DE LORENZO A, BERTINI I, IACOPINO L, PAGLIATO E, TESTOLIN C, TESTOLIN G (2000). Body composition measurement in highly trained male athletes. A comparison of three methods. J Sports Med Phys Fitness, 40: 178-183.
11. DE ROSE E, GUIMARAES AC (1980). A model for optimization of somatotype in young athletes. In: Ostin MB, Buenen G, Simons J (eds). Kinanthropometry II. University Park Press, Baltimore.
12. DEURENBERG P, ANDREOLI A, BORG J, KUKKONENHARJULA K, DE LORENZO A, VAN MARCKEN LICHTENBELT WD, TESTOLIN G, VIGANO R, VOLLAARD N (2001). The validity of predicted body fat percentage from body mass index and from impedance in samples of five European populations. Eur J Clin Nutrit, 55: 973-979.
13. DURNIN JV, WOMERSLEY J (1974). Body fat assessed from total body density and its estimation from skinfold thickness: measurements on 481 men and women aged from 16 to 72 years. Brit J Nutrit, 32: 77-97.
14. ERSELCAN T, CANDAN F, SARUHAN S, AYCA T (2000). Comparison of body composition analysis methods in clinical routine. Ann Nutr Metab, 44: 243-248.
15. FAKHRAWI DH, BEESON L, LIBANATI C, FELEKE D, KIM H, QUANSAH A, DARNELL A, LAMMI-KEEFE CJ, CORDEROMACINTYRE ZR (2009). Comparison of Body Composition by bioelectrical impedance and dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry in overweight/obese postmenopausal women. J Clin Densitom, 12: 238-244.
16. FOGLI JJ (2005). Measuring body composition: keeping up with an increasingly obese population. Obesity Res, 13: 1134.
17. FORTE I, RUPP SA, DE GODOY I, SMAILI SM, CAMPANA AO (2005). Análise comparativa de métodos de avaliação da composição corporal em homens sadios e em pacientes com doença pulmonar obstrutiva crônica: antropometria, impedância bioelétrica e absortiometria de raios-X de dupla energia. Archivos Latinoamericanos de Nutrición, 55: 124-131.
18. GENTON LD, DIDIER H, KYLE UG, PICHARD C (2002). Dual-Energy X-ray absorptiometry and body composition: differences between devices and comparison with reference methods. Nutrition, 18: 66-70.
19. GOODPASTER BH (2002). Measuring body fat distribution and content in humans. Curr Opin Clin Nutrit Metab Care, 5: 481-487.
20. GUO SS, SIERVOGEL RM, CHUMLEA WC (2000). Epidemiological applications of body composition. The effects and adjustment of measurement errors. Ann New York Acad Sci, 904: 312-316.
21. GUTIN B, LITAKER M, ISLAM S, MANOS T, SMITH C, TREIBER F (1996). Body-composition measurement in 9-11-y-old children by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry, skinfoldthickness measurements, and bioimpedance analysis. Am J Clin Nutrit, 63: 287-292.
22. HEWITT G, WITHERS RT, BROODS AG (2002). Improved rig for dynamically calibrating skinfold clippers: comparison between Harpenden and Slim Guide instruments. Am J Hum Biol, 14: 721-727.
23. HULL H, HE Q, THORNTON J, JAVED F, ALLEN L, WANG J, PIERSON RNJ, GALLAGHER D (2009). iDXA, Prodigy, and DPXL dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry wholebody scans: a cross-calibration study. J Clin Densitom, 12: 95-102.
24. JOHNSON MS, LANDY NM, POTTER EP, NAGY TR (2005). Comparison of software versions for body composition analysis using the PIXImus dual-energy X-ray absorptiometer. Int J Body Composit Res, 3: 3-76.
25. JÜRIMÄE T, SUDI K, JÜRIMÄE J, PAYERL D, MÖLLER R, TAFEIT E (2005). Validity of optical device lipometer and bioelectric impedance analysis for body fat assessment in men and women. Collegium antropologicum, 29: 499-502.
26. KERR DA, PAPALIA S, MORTON A, DICK I, DHALIWAL S, PRINCE RL (2007). Bone mass in young women is dependent on Lean Body Mass. J Clin Densitom, 10: 319-326.
27. KITANO T, KITANO N, INOMOTO T, FUTATSUKA M (2001). Evaluation of body composition using dual-energy Xray absorptiometry, skinfold thickness and bioelectrical impedance analysis in Japanese female college students. J Nutrit Sci Vitamins, 47: 122-125.
28. LASKEY MA (1996). Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry and body composition. Nutrition, 12: 45-51.
29. LITAKER M, BARBEAU P, HUMPHRIES MC, GUTIN B (2003). Comparison of hologic QDR-1000/W and 4500W DXA scanners in 13- to 18-year olds. Obesity Res, 11: 1545-1552.
30. LIU L, ROBERTS R, MOYER-MILEUR L, SAMSON-FANG L (2005). Determination of body composition in children with cerebral palsy: Bioelectrical impedance analysis and anthropometry vs dual-energy X-Ray absorptiometry. J Amer Dietetic Assoc, 105: 794-797.
31. MALINAUSKAS BM, RAEDEKE TD, AEBY VG, SMITH JL, DALLAS MG (2006). Dieting practices, weight perceptions, and body composition: a comparison of normal weight, overweight, and obese college females. Nutrition J, 31: 11-20.
32. MANTHA S, ROIZEN MF, FLEISHER LA, ET A (2000). Comparing methods of clinical measurement: reporting standards for Bland and Altman analysis. Anesthesia Analgesia, 90: 593-602.
33. MARTÍN V, GÓMEZ B, ANTORANZ MJ, GÓMEZ A, DE OYA M (2001). Validación del monitor de medición de la grasa corporal por impedancia bioeléctrica OMRON BF 300. Atención Primaria, 28: 174-181.
34. MAST M, SONNICHSEN A, LANGNASE K, LABITZKE K, BRUSE U, PREUB U, MULLER MJ (2002). Inconsistencies in bioelectrical impedance and anthropometric measurements of fat mass in a field study of prepubertal children. Brit J Nutrit, 87: 163-175.
35. NAKATA Y, TANAKA K, MIZUKI T, YOSHIDA T (2004). Body composition measurements by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry differ between two analysis modes. J Clin Densitom, 7: 443-447.
36. NÚÑEZ C, CARVAJAL A, TURRERO E, MOREIRAS O (1994). Contribución al estudio de la composición corporal de un grupo de mujeres jóvenes mediante análisis de impedancia bioeléctrica. Nutrición Hospitalaria, 9: 262-267.
37. PIETROBELLI A, RUBIANO F, ST-ONGE MP, HEYMSFIELD SB (2004). New bioimpedance analysis system: improved phenotyping with whole-body analysis. Eur J Clin Nutrit, 58: 1479-1484.
38. PINEAU JC, GUIHARD-COSTA AM, BOCQUET M (2007). Validation of ultrasound techniques applied to body fat measurement. Ann Nutr Metab, 51: 421-427.
39. PONGCHAIYAKUL C, KOSULWAT V, ROJROONGWASINKUL N, CHAROENKIATKUL S, THEPSUTHAMMARAT K, LAOPAIBOOM M, NGUYEN TV, RAJATANAVIN R (2005). Prediction of percentage body fat in rural Thai population using simple anthropometric measurements. Obesity Res, 13: 729-738.
40. REZENDE F, ROSADO L, FRANCESCHINNI S, ROSADO G, RIBEIRO R, BOUZAS MARINS JC (2007). Revisão crítica dos métodos disponíveis para avaliar a composição corporal em grandes estudos populacionais e clínicos. Archivos Latinoamericanos de Nutrición, 57: 327-334.
41. ROCHE AF, HEYMSFIELD SB, LOHMAN TG (1996). Human body composition, Champaign, Human kinetics.
42. ROUBENOFF R, KEHAYIAS JJ, DAWSON-HUGHES B, HEYMSFIELD SB (1993). Use of dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry in body composition studies: not yet a "gold standard". Amer J Clin Nutrit, 58: 589-591.
43. SÁEZ P (2004). Errores conceptuales en estudios antropométricos que buscan estimar la composición corporal. PubliCE Standard.
44. SAKAI Y, ITO H, MENO T, NUMATA M, JINGU S (2006). Comparison of Body Composition measurements obtained by two fan-beam DXA instruments. J Clin Densitom, 9: 191-197.
45. SALAMONE LM, FUERST T, VISSER M, KERN M, LANG T, DOCKRELL M, CAULEY JA, NEVITT M, TYLAVSKY F, LOHMAN TG (2000). Measurement of fat mass using DEXA: a validation study in elderly adults. J Appl Physiol, 89: 345-352.
46. SCHOELLER DA, TYLAVSKY F, BAER DJ, CHUMLEA WC, EARTHMAN CP, FUERST T, HARRIS M, HEYMSFIELD SB, HORLICK M, LOHMAN TG, LUKASKI HC, SHEPHERD J, SIERVOGEL RM, BORRUD LG (2005). QDR 4500A dual X-ray absorptiometer underestimates fat mass in comparison with criterion methods in adults. Amer J Clin Nutrit, 81: 1018-1025.
47. SUN SS, CHUMLEA WC, HEYMSFIELD SB, LUKASKI H, DA S, FRIEDL K, KUCZMARSKI RJ, FLEGAL KM, JOHNSON CL, HUBBARD V (2003). Development of bioelectrical impedance analysis prediction equations for body composition with the use of a multicomponent model for use in epidemiologic surveys. Amer J Clin Nutrit, 77: 331-340.
48. TYLAVSKY F, LOHMAN TG, DOCKRELL M, LANG T, SCHOELLER D, WAN JY, FUERST T, CAULEY JA, NEVITT M, HARRIS TB (2003). Comparison of the effectiveness of 2 dual-energy X-ray absorptiometers with that of total body water and computed tomography in assessing changes in body composition during weight change. Amer J Clin Nutrit, 77: 356-363.
49. VALERO MA, LEÓN SANZ M, GÓMEZ I, MARTÍNEZ G, HAWKINS F (1994). Comparación entre absorciometría de doble fotón (DEXA), impedancia y antropometría en el estudio de la composición corporal en personas obesas. Nutrición Hospitalaria, 9: 12-17.
50. WANG J, THOMRON JC, KOLESNICK S, PIERSON RJ (2000). Anthropometry in body composition. An overview. Ann New York Acad Sci, 904: 317-326.
51. WANG J, THORNTON JC, IOANNIDOU E, SORIANO JM, GALLAGHER D, HEYMSFIELD SB, HORLICK M, PIERSON RN, ALLEN LR (2005) Four commonly used dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry scanners do not identically classify subjects for osteopenia or osteoporosis by T-score in four bone regions BIz11.5. J Clin Densitom, 8: 191-198.
52. WARD LC, DYER JM, BYRNE NM, SHARPE KK, HILLS AP (2007). Validation of a three-frequency bioimpedance spectroscopic method for body composition analysis. Nutrition, 23: 756-664.
53. XIE X, KOLTHOFF N, BÄRENHOLT O, NIELSEN SP (1999). Validation of a leg-to-leg bioimpedance analysis system in assessing body composition in postmenopausal women. Intl J Obesity Rel Metab Dis, 23: 1079-1084.