Non-specific physical symptoms and electromagnetic field exposure in the general population: Can we get more specific? A systematic review

Environment International

Volumn 41, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 15-28

  Baliatsas, Christos ^a,b   Van Kamp, Irene ^b   Bolte, John ^b   Schipper, Maarten ^b   Yzermans, Joris ^c   Lebret, Erik ^a,b  

^a UTRECHT UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

^b NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT   (Netherlands)

^c NETHERLANDS INSTITUTE FOR HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Electromagnetic fields; Meta analyses; Non specific physical symptoms; Observational studies; Systematic review

Indexed keywords

ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS;

ASSESSMENT METHODS; CONFIDENCE INTERVAL; ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELD EXPOSURE; EMF EXPOSURE; GENERAL POPULATION; LITERATURE DATABASE; MEDLINE; META ANALYSIS; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY; ODDS RATIOS; PHYSICAL SYMPTOMS; QUALITATIVE ASSESSMENTS; RANDOM EFFECTS; STRENGTH OF EVIDENCE; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

BIBLIOGRAPHIC RETRIEVAL SYSTEMS;

CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK; DATABASE; ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELD; EPIDEMIOLOGY; MAGNITUDE; OBSERVATIONAL METHOD; QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS; SYMPTOM;

ARTICLE; DIZZINESS; ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELD; ENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURE; FATIGUE; HEADACHE; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY; POPULATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS; RADIATION EXPOSURE; SLEEP DISORDER; SYMPTOMATOLOGY; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

EID: 84855810953     PISSN: 01604120     EISSN: 18736750     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.envint.2011.12.002     Document Type: Article

References (90)

1. Abelin T., Altpeter E., Röösli M. Sleep disturbances in the vicinity of the short-wave broadcast transmitter Schwarzenburg. Somnologie 2005, 9:203-209.
2. Abdel-Rassoul G., El-Fateh O.A., Salem M.A., Michael A., Farahat F., El-Batanouny M., Salem E. Neurobehavioral effects among inhabitants around mobile phone base stations. Neurotoxicology 2006, 28:434-440.
3. Al-Abduljawad K.A. Effects of the mobile phones on hearing function of the users. Bah Med Bull 2008, 30:72-74.
4. Al-Khamees N. A study in Kuwait of health risks associated with using cell phones. Coll Stud J 2007, 41:187-202.
5. Al Khamees N. What message should health educators give regarding electromagnetic fields?. Coll Stud J 2008, 42:730-737.
6. Al-Khlaiwi T., Meo S.A. Association of mobile phone radiation with fatigue, headache, dizziness, tension and sleep disturbance in Saudi population. Saudi Med J 2004, 25:732-736.
7. Altpeter E.S., Röösli M., Battaglia M., Pfluger D., Minder C.E., Abelin T. Effect of short-wave (6-22MHz) magnetic fields on sleep quality and melatonin cycle in humans: the Schwarzenburg shutdown study. Bioelectromagnetics 2006, 27:142-150.
8. Augner C., Hacker G.W. Are people living next to mobile phone base stations more strained relationship of health concerns, self-estimated distance to base station, and psychological parameters. Indian J Occup Environ Med 2009, 13:141-145.
9. Baliatsas C., Van Kamp I., Kelfkens G., Schipper M., Bolte J., Yzermans J., Lebret E. Non-specific physical symptoms in relation to actual and perceived proximity to mobile phone base stations and powerlines. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:421.
10. Balikci K., Ozcan I.C., Turgut-Balik D., Balik H.H. A survey study on some neurological symptoms and sensations experienced by long term users of mobile phones. Pathol Biol 2005, 53:30-34.
11. Balik H.H., Tutgut-Balik D., Balikci K., Ozcan I.C. Some ocular symptoms and sensations experienced by long term users of mobile phones. Pathol Biol 2005, 53:88-91.
12. Bax L., Yu L.M., Ikeda N., Tsuruta H., Moons K.G. Development and validation of MIX: comprehensive free software for meta-analysis of causal research data. BMC Med Res Methodol 2006, 6:50.
13. Berg-Beckhoff G., Blettner M., Kowall B., Breckenkamp J., Schlehofer B., Schmiedel S., Bornkessel C., Reis U., Potthoff P., Schüz J. Mobile phone base stations and adverse health effects: phase 2 of a cross-sectional study with measured radio frequency electromagnetic fields. Occup Environ Med 2009, 66:124-130.
14. Blettner M., Schlehofer B., Breckenkamp J., Kowall B., Schmiedel S., Reis U., Potthoff P., Schüz J., Berg-Beckhoff G. Mobile phone base stations and adverse health effects: phase 1 of a population-based, cross-sectional study in Germany. Occup Environ Med 2009, 66:118-123.
15. Bolte J., Van der Zande G., Kamer J. Calibration and uncertainties in personal exposure measurements of radiofrequency electromagnetic fields. Bioelectromagnetics 2011, 32:652-663.
16. Buysse D.J., Reynolds C.F., Monk T.H., Berman S.R., Kupfer D.J. The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index: a new instrument for psychiatric practice and research. Psychiatry Res 1989, 28:193-213.
17. Chia S.M., Chia H.P., Tan J.S. Prevalence of headache among handheld cellular telephone users in Singapore: a community study. Environ Health Perspect 2000, 108:1059-1062.
18. Davidson H.C., Lutman M.E. Survey of mobile phone use and their chronic effects on the hearing of a student population. Int J Audiol 2007, 46:113-118.
19. DerSimonian R., Laird N. Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Control Clin Trials 1986, 7:177-188.
20. Eger H., Jahn M. Specific health symptoms and cell phone radiation in Selbitz (Bavaria, Germany) - evidence of a dose response relationship. Umwelt-Medizin- Gesellschaft 2010, 23:130-139.
21. Egger M., Smith G.D., Phillips A.N. Meta-analyses: principles and procedures. BMJ 1997, 315:1533.
22. Emerson G.B., Warme W.J., Wolf F.M., Heckman J.D., Brand R.A., Leopold S.S. Testing for the presence of positive-outcome bias in peer review. A randomized controlled trial. Arch Intern Med 2010, 170(21):1934-1939.
23. Fahrenberg J. Die Freiburger Beschwerdenliste (FBL). Z Klin Psychol 1975, 4:79-100. [in Germann].
24. Frei P., Mohler E., Bürgi A., Fröhlich J., Neubauer G., Braun-Fahrländer C. Röösli M; QUALIFEX-team. A prediction model for personal radio frequency electromagnetic field exposure. Sci Total Environ 2009, 408:102-108.
25. Frei P., Mohler E., Bürgi A., Fröhlich J., Neubauer G., Braun-Fahrländer C., Röösli M. Classification of personal exposure to radio frequency electromagnetic fields (RF-EMF) for epidemiological research: evaluation of different exposure assessment methods. Environ Int 2010, 36:714-720. QUALIFEX-team.
26. Frick U., Mayer M., Hauser S., Binder H., Rosner R., Eichhammer P. Entwicklung eines deutschsprachigen messinstrumentes für "Elektrosmog-Beschwerden". Umweltmed Forsch Prax 2006, 11:103-113. [in German].
27. Grimes D.A., Schulz K.F. Bias and causal associations in observational research. Lancet 2002, 359:248-252.
28. Haugland S., Wold B. Subjective health complaints in adolescence - reliability and validity of survey methods. J Adolesc 2001, 24:611-624.
29. Heinrich S., Kühnlein A., Thomas S., Praml G., von Kries R., Radon K. Association between exposure to radiofrequency electromagnetic field exposure and acute well-being in children and adolescents. Environ Health 2010, 9:75.
30. Heinrich S., Thomas S., Praml G., von Kries R., Radon K. The impact of exposure to radio frequency electromagnetic fields on chronic well-being in young people - a cross sectional study based on personal dosimetry. Environ Int 2011, 37:26-30.
31. Herr C.E., Nieden A., Lindenstruth M., Stilianakis N.I., Seitz H., Eikmann T.F. Relating use of mobile phones to reported sleep quality. Somnologie 2005, 9:199-202.
32. Higgins J.P.T., Thompson S.G., Deeks J.J., Altman D.G. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ 2003, 327:557-560.
33. Hiller W., Goebel G., Schindelmann U. Systematische fremdbeurteilung von patienten mit chronischem tinnitus (Strukturiertes Tinnitus-Interview). Diagnostica 2000, 46:93-102. [in German].
34. Hutter H.P., Moshammer H., Wallner P., Kundi M. Public perception of risk concerning celltowers and mobile phones. Soz Praventivmed 2004, 49:62-66.
35. Hutter H.P., Moshammer H., Wallner P., Kundi M. Subjective symptoms, sleeping problems, and cognitive performance in subjects living near mobile phone base stations. J Occup Environ Med 2006, 63:307-313.
36. Hutter H.P., Moshammer H., Wallner P., Cartellieri M., Denk-Linnert D.M., Katzinger M., Ehrenberger K., Kundi M. Tinnitus and mobile phone use. Occup Environ Med 2010, 67:8048.
37. International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection Guidelines for limiting exposure to time-varying electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields (up to 300GHz). Health Phys 1998, 74:494-522.
38. Inyang I., Benke G., McKenzie R., Abramson M. Comparison of measuring instruments for radiofrequency radiation from mobile telephones in epidemiological studies: implications for exposure assessment. J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol 2008, 18:134-141.
39. Johansson A., Nordin S., Heiden M., Sandstrom M. Symptoms, personality traits, and stress in people with mobile phone-related symptoms and electromagnetic hypersensitivity. J Psychosom Res 2010, 68:37-45.
40. Johns M.W. A new method for measuring daytime sleepiness: the Epworth Sleepiness Scale. Sleep 1991, 14:540-545.
41. Kecklund G., Åkerstedt T. The psychometric properties of the Karolinska Sleep Questionnaire. J Sleep Res 1992, 1:113.
42. Khan M.M. Adverse effects of excessive mobile phone use. Int J Occup Med Environ Health 2008, 21:289-293.
43. King A., Wold B., Tudor-Smith C., Harel Y. The health of youth. A cross-national survey. WHO Reg Publ Eur Ser 1996, 69:1-222.
44. Koivusilta L., Lintonen T., Rimpelä A. Orientations in adolescent use of information and communication technology: a digital divide by sociodemographic background, educational career, and health. Scand J Public Health 2007, 35:95-103.
45. Kosinski M., Bayliss M.S., Bjorner J.B., Ware J.E., Garber W.H., Batenhorst A., Cady R., Dahlöf C.G.H., Dowson A., Tepper S. A six-item short-form survey for measuring headache impact: the HIT-6. Qual Life Res 2003, 12:963-974.
46. Kucer N. Some ocular symptoms experienced by users of mobile phones. Electromagn Biol Med 2008, 27:205-209.
47. Landgrebe M., Frick U., Hauser S., Langguth B., Rosner R., Hajak G., Eichhammer P. Cognitive and neurobiological alterations in electromagnetic hypersensitive patients: results of a case-control study. Psychol Med 2008, 38:1781-1791.
48. Mann S. Assessing personal exposures to environmental radiofrequency electromagnetic fields. CR Phys 2010, 11:541-555.
49. Meo S.A., Al-Drees Do mobile phones cause hearing and vision complaints? A preliminary report. Saudi Med J 2005, 26:882-883.
50. Meo S.A., Al-Drees A. Mobile phone related-hazards and subjective hearing and vision symptoms in the Saudi population. Int J Occup Med Environ Health 2005, 18:45-49.
51. Electromagnetic hypersensitivity. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Electromagnetic Field Hypersensitivity 2006, 25. World Health Organization, Prague, Czech Republic.
52. Milde-Busch A., von Kries R., Thomas S., Heinrich S., Straube A., Radon K. The association between use of electronic media and prevalence of headache in adolescents: results from a population-based cross-sectional study. BMC Neurol 2010, 10:12.
53. Mohler E., Frei P., Fahrländer C.B., Fröhlich J., Neubauer G., Röösli M. Effects of everyday radiofrequency electromagnetic-field exposure on sleep quality: a cross-sectional study. Radiat Res 2010, 174:347-356.
54. Mortazavi S.M.J., Ahmadi J., Shariati M. Prevalence of subjective poor health symptoms associated with exposure to electromagnetic fields among university students. Bioelectromagnetics 2007, 28:326-330.
55. Navarro E.A., Segura J., Portoles M., Gomez-Perretta C. The microwave syndrome: a preliminary study in Spain. Electromagn Biol Med 2003, 22:161-169.
56. Neubauer G., Feychting M., Hamnerius Y., Kheifets L., Kuster N., Ruiz I., Schüz J., Uberbacher R., Wiart J., Röösli M. Feasibility of future epidemiological studies on possible health effects of mobile phone base stations. Bioelectromagnetics 2007, 28:224-230.
57. Osterberg K., Persson R., Karlson B., Carlsson E.F., Orbaek P. Personality, mental distress, and subjective health complaints among persons with environmental annoyance. Hum Exp Toxicol 2007, 26:231-241.
58. Ott H, Oswald I, Fichte K, Sastre M. VIS-A und VIS-M (in German). Collegium Internationale Psychiatrie Scalarum (eds). Internationale Skalen für Psychiatrie 1981, Weinheim.
59. Pennarola E., Barletta R., Quarto E., Pennarola R. Operation aspects of risk in the electromagnetic fields exposition (in Italian). G Ital Med Lav Ergon 2007, 23:785-787.
60. Persson R., Carlsson E.F., Osterberg K., Orbaek P., Karlson B. A two-week monitoring of self-reported arousal, worry and attribution among persons with annoyance attributed to electrical equipment and smells. Scand J Psychol 2008, 49:345-356.
61. Petrie K.J., Sivertsen B., Hysing M., Broadbent E., Moss-Morris R., Eriksen H.R., Ursin H. Thoroughly modern worries. The relationship of worries about modernity to reported symptoms, health and medical care utilization. J Psychosom Res 2001, 51:395-401.
62. Preece A.W., Georgiou A.G., Dunn E.J., Farrow S.C. Health response of two communities to military antennae in Cyprus. J Occup Environ Med 2007, 64:402-408.
63. Punamäki R., Wallenius M., Nygard C., Saarni L., Rimpelä A. Use of information and communication technology (ICT) and perceived health in adolescence: the role of sleeping habits and waking-time tiredness. J Adolesc 2007, 30:569-585.
64. Röösli M. Radiofrequency electromagnetic field exposure and non-specific symptoms of ill health: a systematic review. Environ Res 2008, 107:277-287.
65. Röösli M., Frei P., Mohler E., Hug K. Systematic review on the health effects of exposure to radiofrequency electromagnetic fields from mobile phone base stations. Bull World Health Organ 2010, 88:887-896.
66. Röösli M., Hug K. Wireless communication fields and non-specific symptoms of ill health: a literature review. Wien Med Wochenschr 2011, 9-10:240-250.
67. Rothman K.J. Health effects of mobile telephones. Epidemiology 2009, 20:653-655.
68. Rubin G.J., Das M.J., Wessely S. A systematic review of treatments for electromagnetic hypersensitivity. Psychother Psychosom 2006, 75:12-18.
69. Rubin G.J., Cleare A.J., Wessely S. Psychological factors associated with self-reported sensitivity to mobile phones. J Psychosom Res 2008, 64:1-9.
70. Rubin G.J., Nieto-Hernandez R., Wessely S. Idiopathic environmental intolerance attributed to electromagnetic fields (formerly 'electromagnetic hypersensitivity'): an updated systematic review of provocation studies. Bioelectromagnetics 2009, 31:1-11.
71. 2 in assessing heterogeneity may mislead. BMC Med Res Methodol 2008, 8:79.
72. Sandstrom M., Wilen J., Oftedal G., Mild-Hansson K. Mobile phone use and subjective symptoms. Comparison of symptoms experienced by users of analogue and digital mobile phones. Occup Med 2001, 51:25-35.
73. Santini R., Seigne M., Bonhomme-Faivre L., Bouffet S., Defrasne E., Sage M. Symptoms experienced by users of digital cellular phones: a study of a French engineering school. Electromagn Biol Med 2002, 21:81-88.
74. Santini R., Santini P., Danze J.M., Le Ruz P., Seigne M. Enquete sur la sante de riverains de stations relais de telephonie mobile: Incidences de l'age des sujets, de la duree de leur exposition et de leur position par rapport aux antennas et autres sources electromagnetiques. Pathol Biol 2003, 51:412-415. [in French].
75. Schmitt B.E., Gugger M., Augustiny K., Bassetti C., Radanov B.P. Prevalence of sleep disorders in an employed Swiss population: results of a questionnaire survey. Schweiz Med Wochenschr 2000, 130:772-778.
76. Schreier N., Huss A., Röösli M. The prevalence of symptoms attributed to electromagnetic field exposure: a cross-sectional representative survey in Switzerland. Soz Praventivmed 2006, 51:202-209.
77. Schrottner J., Leitgeb N. Sensitivity to electricity - temporal changes in Austria. BMC Public Health 2008, 8:310.
78. Schüz J., Waldemar G., Olsen J.H., Christoffer Johansen C. Risks for central nervous system diseases among mobile phone Subscribers: a Danish Retrospective Cohort Study. PloS ONE 2009, 4:e4389.
79. Soderqvist F., Carlberg M., Hardell L. Use of wireless telephones and self-reported health symptoms: a population-based study among Swedish adolescents aged 15-19years. Environ Health 2008, 7:18.
80. Sutton Aj, Abrams K.R., Jones D.R., Sheldon T.A., Song F. Methods for meta-analysis in medical research 2000, Wiley, Chichester.
81. Szyjkowska A., Bortkiewicz A., Szymczak W., Makowiec-Dabrowska T. Subiektywne dolegliwosci u osob korzystajacych z telefonow komorkowych - badanie pilotazowe. Pol Merk Lek 2005, 112:529-532. [in Polish].
82. Thomas S., Kuhnlein A., Heinrich S., Praml G., Nowak D., von Kries R., Radon K. Personal exposure to mobile phone frequencies and well-being in adults: a cross-sectional study based on dosimetry. Bioelectromagnetics 2008, 29:463-470.
83. Thomée S., Eklöf M., Gustafsson E., Nilsson R., Hagberg M. Prevalence of perceived stress, symptoms of depression and sleep disturbances in relation to information and communication technology (ICT) use among young adults - an explorative prospective study. Comput Hum Behav 2007, 23:1300-1321.
84. Thomée S., Härenstam A., Hagberg M. Mobile phone use and stress, sleep disturbances, and symptoms of depression among young adults - a prospective cohort study. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:66.
85. Vol Elm E., Altman D.G., Egger M., Pocock S.J., Gøtzsche P.C., Vandenbroucke J.P. The strengthening the reporting of observational studies in epidemiology (STROBE) statement: guidelines for reporting observational studies. Lancet 2007, 370:1453-1457.
86. Von Zerssen D. Complaint list. Manual 1976, Beltz, Weinheim.
87. Vrijheid M., Armstrong B.K., Bédard D., Brown J., Deltour I., Iavarone I., Krewski D., Lagorio S., Moore S., Richardson L., Giles G.G., McBride M., Parent M.E., Siemiatycki J., Cardis E. Recall bias in the assessment of exposure to mobile phones. J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol 2009, 19:369-381.
88. Yzermans CJ, Oskam SB. Clustering, continuiteit en comorbiditeit in de huisartsenpraktijk [In Dutch]. Doctoral Dissertation.University of Amsterdam, 1990.
89. Ware J.E., Snow K.K., Kosinski M., Gandek B. SF-36 health survey manual and interpretation guide 1993, New England Medical Center, The Health Institute, Boston, MA.
90. World Health Organization. Electromagnetic fields and public health, WHO Fact Sheet No. 296. 2005. Available at http://www.emfandhealth.com/WHO_EMSensitivity.pdf.