The slippery slope - Critical perspectives on in vitro research methodologies

Dental Materials

Volumn 28, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 41-51

  Kelly, J Robert ^a   Benetti, Paula ^b   Rungruanganunt, Patchanee ^a   Bona, Alvaro Della ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT HEALTH CENTER   (United States)

^b SÃO PAULO STATE UNIVERSITY UNESP   (Brazil)

^c UNIVERSITY OF PASSO FUNDO   (Brazil)

Author keywords

Bond; Clinical relevance; Failure testing; In vitro; Shear

Indexed keywords

BONDING; FINITE ELEMENT METHOD; LOAD TESTING; PUBLISHING; SHEAR STRESS; SHEARING;

CLINICAL CONDITIONS; CLINICAL PERFORMANCE; CLINICAL RELEVANCE; CRITICAL PERSPECTIVES; FAILURE TESTING; IN-VITRO; RESEARCH METHODOLOGIES; SIMULATION PROTOCOLS;

FAILURE (MECHANICAL);

BIOMEDICAL AND DENTAL MATERIALS;

COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH; DENTAL BONDING; DENTAL PROCEDURE; DENTAL SURGERY; FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS; MATERIALS TESTING; METHODOLOGY; REPRODUCIBILITY; REVIEW; SHEAR STRENGTH; STANDARD; SURVIVAL; TENSILE STRENGTH;

COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH; DENTAL BONDING; DENTAL MATERIALS; DENTAL RESTORATION WEAR; DENTAL STRESS ANALYSIS; FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS; MATERIALS TESTING; REFERENCE STANDARDS; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; SHEAR STRENGTH; SURVIVAL ANALYSIS; TENSILE STRENGTH;

EID: 84255187111     PISSN: 01095641     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.dental.2011.09.001     Document Type: Article

References (46)

1. W. Souder Dental research at the National Bureau of Standards - reminiscences National Bureau of Standards Special Publication 354. Dental materials research proceedings of the 50th anniversary symposium, October 6-8, 1968 1972 U.S. Department of Commerce 7 11
2. W. Souder Measurement and application of certain physical properties of dental amalgam J Dent Res 7 1927 173
3. W. Souder, and C.G. Peters An investigation of the physical properties of dental materials Dental Cosmos 62 1920 305
4. R.L. Coleman Physical properties of dental materials (wrought gold alloys) J Am Dent Assoc 12 1925 520
5. R.L. Coleman Physical properties of dental materials (III). Progress report on the dental casting process Dental Cosmos 68 1926 743
6. R.L. Coleman Physical properties of dental materials (gold alloys and accessory materials) Bureau Standards J Res, RP32 1 1928 867
7. B. Hedegrd Need for correlation between laboratory testing and clinical research National Bureau of Standards Special Publication 354. Dental materials research proceedings of the 50th anniversary symposium, October 6-8, 1968 1972 U.S. Department of Commerce 187 189
8. R.R. Braga, J.B.C. Meira, L.C.C. Boaro, and T.A. Xavier Adhesion to tooth structure: a critical review of "macro" test methods Dent Mater 26 2010 e38 e49
9. P.H. DeHoff, K.J. Anusavice, and Z. Wang Three-dimensional finite element analysis of the shear bond test Dent Mater 11 1995 126 131
10. S.S. Scherrer, P.F. Cesar, and M.V. Swain Direct comparison of the bond strength results of the different test methods: a critical literature review Dent Mater 26 2010 e78 e93
11. K.S. Alfredsson, and J.L. Hogberg Energy release rate and mode-mixity of adhesive joint specimens Int J Fract 144 2007 267 283
12. M.T. Tilbrook, M. Hoffman, and I.E. Reimanis Finite-element simulations of cracks near interfaces: effects of thermal, elastic and plastic mismatch J Am Ceram Soc 88 10 2005 2833 2838 (Pubitemid 41557739)
13. B. Van Meerbeek, M. Peumans, A. Poitevin, A. Mine, A. Van Ende, and A. Neves Relationship between bond-strength tests and clinical outcomes Dent Mater 26 2010 e100 e121
14. K.A. Malament, and S.S. Socransky Survival of Dicor glass-ceramic dental restorations over 16 years. Part III: Effect of luting agent and tooth or tooth-substitute core structure J Prosthet Dent 86 2001 511 519 (Pubitemid 33624189)
15. J.W.V. van Dijken, C. Hoglund-Aberg, and A.-L. Olofson Fired ceramic inlays: a 6-year follow up J Dent 26 3 1998 219 225 (Pubitemid 128394277)
16. Rungruanganunt P, Kelly JR. Insights into "bonding" of all-ceramics influenced by cement, sandblasting and water storage time. Dent Mater; submitted for publication.
17. K.A. Malament, and S.S. Socransky Survival of Dicor glass-ceramic dental restorations over 14 years: part I. Survival of Dicor complete coverage restorations and effect of internal surface acid etching, tooth position, gender and age J Prosthet Dent 81 1999 23 32
18. A. Della Bona, and J.R. Kelly The clinical success of all-ceramic restorations J Am Dent Assoc 139 Suppl. 2008 8S 13S
19. A. Ekfeldt, and G. Øilo Occlusal contact wear of prosthetic materials. An in vivo study Acta Odontol Scand 46 3 1988 159 169
20. J.A. Mahalick, F.J. Knap, and E.J. Weiter Occlusal wear in prosthodontics J Am Dent Assoc 82 1971 154 159
21. G.E. Monasky Studies on the wear of porcelain, enamel and gold J Prosthet Dent 25 1971 299 306
22. R. DeLong, W.H. Douglas, R.L. Sakaguchi, and M.R. Pintado The wear of dental porcelain in an artificial mouth Dent Mater 2 1986 214 219
23. R.R. Seghi, S.F. Rosenstiel, and P. Bauer Abrasion of human enamel by different dental ceramics in vitro J Dent Res 70 1991 221 225
24. I. Krejci, F. Lutz, and M. Reimer Wear of CAD/CAM ceramic inlays: restorations, opposing cusps, and luting cements Quintessence Int 25 3 1994 199 207
25. S.N. White Mechanical fatigue of a feldspathic dental porcelain Dent Mater 9 1993 260 264
26. C.H. Hacker, W.C. Wagner, and M.E. Razzoog An in vitro investigation of the wear of enamel on porcelain and gold in saliva J Prosthet Dent 75 1996 14 17 (Pubitemid 126654377)
27. A.G. Evans, and D.B. Marshall Wear mechanisms in ceramics D.A. Rigney, Fundamentals of friction and wear of materials 1981 American Society for Metals Metals Park, OH 439 452
28. B.R. Lawn, S.M. Wiederhorn, and D.E. Roberts Effect of sliding friction forces on the strength of brittle materials J Mater Sci 19 1984 2561 2569 (Pubitemid 14626068)
29. T.E. Fischer, M.P. Anderson, and S. Jahanmir Influence of fracture toughness on the wear resistance of yttria-doped zirconium oxide J Am Ceram Soc 72 1989 252 257
30. S. Jahanmir, and T.E. Fischer Friction and wear of ceramics E.R. Booser, CRC handbook of lubrication and tribology, vol. III, Monitoring, materials, synthetic lubricants and applications 1994 CRC Press Boca Raton, FL 103 120
31. J.R. Condon, and J.L. Ferracane Evaluation of composite wear with a new multi-mode oral wear simulator Dent Mater 12 4 1966 218 226
32. ISO TS 14569-2. Dental materials - guidance on testing of wear - part 2: methods simulating occlusal wear, 2001.
33. D. Grossman Structure and physical properties of DICO/MGC glass-ceramic W.H. Mörmann, International symposium on computer restorations 1991 Quintessence Publ. Co. Chicago 103 115
34. W.H. Douglass DICOR MGC report 1991 Caulk/Dentsply York, PA
35. K.-H. Zum Gahr Classification of wear processes Microstructure and Wear of Materials 1987 Elsevier Amsterdam p. 80-131 [chapter 4]
36. I. Krejci, F. Lutz, and C. Zedler Effect of contact area size on enamel and composite wear J Dent Res 71 7 1992 1413 1416
37. B. Lawn Fracture of brittle solids 1993 Cambridge University Press Cambridge, England p. 254-5
38. O. Hidaka, M. Iwasaki, M. Saito, and T. Morimoto Influence of clenching intensity on bite force balance, occlusal contact area, and average bite pressure J Dent Res 78 7 1999 1336 1344 (Pubitemid 32489295)
39. J.R. Kelly, S.D. Campbell, and H.K. Bowen Fracture-surface analysis of dental ceramics J Prosthet Dent 62 1989 536 541
40. J.R. Kelly, R. Giordano, R. Pober, and H.K. Bowen Fracture surface analysis of dental ceramics: clinically failed restorations Int J Prosthodont 3 1990 430 440
41. J.Y. Thompson, K.J. Anusavice, A. Naman, and H.F. Morris Fracture surface characterization of clinically failed all-ceramic crowns J Dent Res 73 1994 1824 1832
42. S.S. Scherrer, J.B. Quinn, G.D. Quinn, and J.R. Kelly Failure analysis of ceramic clinical cases using qualitative fractography Int J Prosthodont 19 2006 185 192 (Pubitemid 43534190)
43. J.B. Quinn, G.D. Quinn, J.R. Kelly, and S.S. Scherrer Fractographic analysis of three ceramic whole crown restoration failures Dent Mater 21 2005 920 929 (Pubitemid 41336634)
44. J.R. Kelly, P. Rungruanganunt, B. Hunter, and F. Vailati Development of a clinically validated bulk failure test for ceramic crowns J Prosthet Dent 104 4 2010 228 238
45. J.R. Kelly Evidence-based decision making: guide to reading the dental materials literature J Prosthet Dent 95 2 2006 152 160 (Pubitemid 43213182)
46. Editorial. Wanted: a base of evidence JOE 33 12 2007 1401 1402