Union renewal, postheroic leadership, and women's organizing: Crossing discourses, reframing debates

Labor Studies Journal

Volumn 36, Issue 4, 2011, Pages 508-537

  Briskin, Linda ^a  

^a YORK UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

constituency organizing; cross constituency organizing; informal and local union leadership; postheroic leadership; transformational outcomes; union renewal; women union leaders

Indexed keywords

EID: 81855226990     PISSN: 0160449X     EISSN: 15389758     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0160449X11422608     Document Type: Article

References (119)

1. Adamson Nancy, Briskin Linda, McPhail Margaret Feminist Organizing for Change. Toronto: Oxford ; 1988 :
2. Report to the AFL-CIO Executive Council ; 2004:
3. Report to the AFL-CIO Executive Council ; 2005:
4. Arsenault Paul. Validating Generational Differences: A Legitimate Diversity and Leadership Issue. The Leadership & Organization Development Journal. 2004 ; 25: 124-41
5. Bail Marg. Getting the Girls to the Top. Canadian Dimension. 1985 ; 19: 8-9
6. Bradley Harriet, Healy Geraldine Ethnicity and Gender at Work: Inequalities, Careers, and Employment Relations. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave/Macmillan ; 2008 :
7. Braithwaite Mary, Byrne Catherine Women in Decision-Making in Trade Unions. Brussels: European Trade Union Confederation ; 1995 :
8. Brigden Cathy. Exploring Gender in Peak Union Bodies. Reworking Work: Proceedings of the 19th Conference of the Association of Industrial Relations Academies of Australia and New Zealand ; ;. 67.
9. Brigden Cathy. Analyzing Internal Power Dynamics in Peak Unions: A Conceptual Framework. Journal of Industrial Relations. 2007a ; 49: 483-96
10. Brigden Cathy. A Woman's Place? Women in the Victorian Trades Hall Council from the 1880s to the 1990s. Australian Feminist Studies. 2007b ; 22: 369-84
11. Briskin Linda. Women, Unions, and Leadership. Canadian Dimension. 1990 ; 24: 38-41
12. Briskin Linda Women Challenging Unions: Feminism, Democracy, and Militancy. Briskin Linda McDermott Patricia, ed. Toronto: University of Toronto Press ; 1993: 89-108.
13. Briskin Linda. Autonomy, Diversity, and Integration: Union Women's Separate Organizing in North America and Western Europe in the Context of Restructuring and Globalization. Women's Studies International Forum. 1999a ; 22: 543-54
14. Briskin Linda Women's Organizing and Public Policy in Canada and Sweden. Briskin Linda Eliasson Mona, ed. Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press ; 1999b: 147-83.
15. Briskin Linda Feminist Success Stories/Célébrons nos réussites féministes. Blackford Karen Garceau M. Kirby Sandra, ed. Ottawa: University of Ottawa Press ; 1999c: 73-92.
16. Briskin Linda Gender, Diversity, and Trade Unions: International Perspectives. Colgan Fiona Ledwith Sue, ed. London: Routledge ; 2002: 28-47.
17. Briskin Linda. Victimization and Agency: The Social Construction of Union Women's Leadership. Industrial Relations Journal. 2006a ; 374: 359-78
18. Briskin Linda Equity Bargaining/Bargaining Equity. Toronto: Centre for Research on Work and Society, York University ; 2006b :
19. Briskin Linda. Cross-Constituency Organizing in Canadian Unions. British Journal of Industrial Relations. 2008 ; 46: 221-47
20. Briskin Linda Leaders, Leadership, And Change in Trade Unions: Gender and Diversity, New Trajectories. Ledwith Sue Hansen Lise Lotte, ed. London: Routledge ;
21. Calveley Moira, Healy Geraldine. Political Activism and Workplace Industrial Relations in a UK 'Failing' School. British Journal of Industrial Relations. 2003 ; 41: 97-113
22. Caiazza Amy I Knew I Could Do This Work: Seven Strategies That Promote Women's Activism and Leadership in Unions. Washington, DC: Institute for Women's Policy Research ; 2007 :
23. Canadian Auto Workers. 2010. "Women in Collective Bargaining: Discussion Leader Manual."
24. Chaison Gary, Andiappan P.. An Analysis of the Barriers to Women Becoming Local Union Officers. Journal of Labour Research. 1989 ; 10: 149-62
25. Chen May, Wong Kent A New Labor Movement for the New Century. Mantsios Gregory, ed. New York: Garland Publishing Inc ; 1998: 213-31.
26. Clawson Dan The Next Upsurge: Labor and the New Social Movements. Ithaca: ILR Press ; 2003 :
27. Colgan Fiona. Recognizing the Lesbian and Gay Constituency in UK Trade Unions: Moving Forward in UNISON?. Industrial Relations Journal. 1999 ; 30: 444-63
28. Colgan Fiona, Ledwith Sue Women in Organisations: Challenging Gender Politics. Ledwith Sue Colgan Fiona, ed. Houndmills, UK: Macmillan ; 1996: 32-48.
29. Colgan Fiona, Ledwith Sue. Diversity, Identities, and Strategies of Women Trade Union Activists. Gender, Work and Organization. 2000 ; 7: 242-57
30. Collins Patricia Hill. Learning from the Outsider-Within: The Sociological Significance of Black Feminist Thought. Social Problems. 1986 ; 33: S14 - S32
31. Collins Patricia Hill Fighting Words: Black Women and the Search for Justice. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press ; 1998 :
32. Cregan Christina, Bartram Timothy, Stanton Pauline. Union Organizing as a Mobilizing Strategy: The Impact of Social Identity and Transformational Leadership on the Collectivism of Union Members. British Journal of Industrial Relations. 2009 ; 47: 701-22
33. Crenshaw Kimberle. Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and the Violence against Women of Color. Stanford Law Review. 1991 ; 43: 1241-99
34. Cuneo Carl Women Challenging Unions: Feminism, Democracy, and Militancy. Briskin Linda McDermott Patricia, ed. Toronto: University of Toronto Press ; 1993: 109-36.
35. Dachler Peter Relational Practices, Participative Organizing. Steyaert Chris Van Looy Bart, ed. Brighton, UK: Emerald ; 2010: 41-53.
36. Das Gupta Tania Racism and Social Inequality in Canada. Satzewich Vic, ed. Toronto: Thompson Educational ; 1998: 315-34.
37. Das Gupta Tania Equity, Diversity, and Canadian Labour. Hunt Gerald Rayside David, ed. Toronto: University of Toronto Press ; 2007: 181-207.
38. Dickerson Niki T.. We Are a Force to be Reckoned With: Black and Latina Women's Leadership in the Contemporary US Labor Movement. Working USA. 2006 ; 93: 239-313
39. Edelson Miriam Unions, Equity, and the Path to Renewal. Foley Janice A. Baker Patricia L., ed. Vancouver: UBC Press ; 2009: 61-77.
40. European Commission. 2007. "Tackling Multiple Discrimination: Practices, Policies, and Laws." Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Equal Opportunities Unit. http://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId= 738&langId=en&pubId=51&type=2&furtherPubs=no (accessed August 1, 2011).
41. European Trade Union Confederation (ETUC). 2003. Women in Trade Unions: Making the Difference. Brussels: European Trade Union Confederation. http://www.etuc.org/IMG/pdf/genre-an-080403.pdf (accessed August 1, 2011).
42. Fletcher Bill, Hurd Richard W. Which Direction for Organized Labor? Essays on Organizing, Outreach, and Internal Transformation. Nissen Bruce, ed. Detroit: Wayne State University Press ; 1999: 191-216.
43. FletcherJoyce K.2002. "The Greatly Exaggerated Demise of Heroic Leadership: Gender, Power, and the Myth of the Female Advantage." Briefing Note #13. Boston: Center for Gender in Organizations (CGO), 1-4. http://www.simmons.edu/som/docs/Insights-13.pdf (accessed August 1, 2011).
44. Fletcher Joyce K. Boston: Center for Gender in Organizations, Simmons School of Management ; 2003 :
45. Fletcher Joyce K., Käufer Katrin Shared Leadership: Reframing the Hows and Whys of Leadership. Pearce Craig L. Conger Jay A., ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage ; 2003: 21-47.
46. Unions, Equity, and the Path to Renewal. Foley Janice Baker Patricia, ed. Vancouver: UBC Press ; 2009 :
47. FoleyLinda. 2010. Stepping Up Stepping Back. Women Activists 'Talk Union' across Generations. Berger-Marks Foundation. http://www.bergermarks.org/ resources/SteppingUpSteppingBack.pdf (accessed August 1, 2011).
48. Varieties of Unionism: Strategies for Union Revitalization in a Globalizing Economy. Frege Carola Heery Edmund Turner Lowell Kelly John Frege Carola, ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press ; 2004: 137-58.
49. GlassnerVera. 2010. "Social Partner Responses to the Economic Crisis in Europe: Why Collective Bargaining Makes a Difference." Global Labour Column21:1-2. http://www.global-labour-university.org/fileadmin/GLU-Column/ papers/no-21-Glassner.pdf (accessed August 1, 2011).
50. Greene Ann-Marie, Kirton Gill. Advancing Gender Equality: The Role of Women-Only Trade Union Education. Gender, Work, and Organization. 2002 ; 9: 39-59
51. Hansen Lise Lotte. Does the Future of Unions Depend on the Integration of Diversity?. Industrielle Beziehungen. 2004 ; 11: 129-42
52. Hansen Lise Lotte Challenges of European Employment Relations: Employment Regulation; Trade Union Organization; Equality, Flexicurity, Training, and New Approaches to Pay. Blanpain Roger Dickens Linda, ed. The Netherlands: Kluwer Law International BV ; 2008: 155-79.
53. Harriford Diane Women and Unions: Forging a Partnership. Cobble Dorothy Sue, ed. Ithaca, NY: ILR Press ; 1993: 402-05.
54. Healy Geraldine, Bradley Harriet, Mukherjee Nupur The Future of Worker Representation. Healy Geraldine Heery Edmund Taylor Phil Brown William, ed. New York: Palgrave Macmillan ; 2004: 103-26.
55. Healy Geraldine, Kirton Gill. Women, Power, and Trade Union Government in the UK. British Journal of Industrial Relations. 2000 ; 38: 343-60
56. Heery Edmund, Kelly John. Do Female Representatives Make a Difference? Women Full Time Officials and Trade Union Work. Work, Employment, and Society. 1988 ; 2: 487-505
57. Hickey Robert, Kuruvilla Sarosh, Lakhani Tashlin. No Panacea for Success: Member Activism, Organizing, and Union Renewal. British Journal of Industrial Relations. 2010 ; 48: 53-83
58. Hogan Robert, Benson Michael J. Advances in Global Leadership. Mobley William Wang Ying Li Ming, ed. Brighton, UK: Emerald ; 2009: 11-34.
59. Holgate Jane, Hebson Gail, McBride Anne. Why Gender and Difference Matters: A Critical Appraisal of Industrial Relations Research. Industrial Relations Journal. 2006 ; 37: 310-28
60. hooks bell Feminist Theory: From Margin to Centre. Boston: South End Press ; 1984 :
61. Hopkins Lekkie, Roarty Lynn, Saggers Sherry. Pat Giles as Critical Actor within the Trade Union Movement of the 1970s. Women's Studies International Forum. 2008 ; 31: 400-12
62. Hosking Dian Marie Follower-Centered Perspectives on Leadership: A Tribute to the Memory of James R. Meindl. Shamir Boas Pillai Rajnandini Bligh Michelle Uhl-Bien Mary, ed. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing ; 2007: 243-63.
63. Hoyman Michele, Stallworth Lamont. Participation in Local Unions: A Comparison of Black and White Members. Industrial and Labour Relations Review. 1987 ; 40: 323-35
64. Humphrey Jane. Self-Organization and Trade Union Democracy. The Sociological Review. 2000 ; 48: 262-82
65. Laboring for Rights: Unions and Sexual Diversity across Nations. Hunt Gerald, ed. Philadelphia: Temple University Press ; 1999 :
66. Hunt Gerald, Eaton Jonathan Equity, Diversity, and Canadian Labour. Hunt Gerald Rayside David, ed. Toronto: University of Toronto Press ; 2007: 130-55.
67. Kainer Jan Unions, Equity, and the Path to Renewal. Foley Janice A. Baker Patricia L., ed. Vancouver: UBC Press ; 2009: 15-38.
68. Kaminski Michelle, Yakura Elaine K.. Women's Union Leadership: Closing the Gender Gap. WorkingUSA: The Journal of Labor and Society. 2008 ; 114: 459-75
69. Kirton Gill. The Influences on Women Joining and Participating in Unions. Industrial Relations. 2005 ; 36: 386-401
70. Kirton Gill. Alternative and Parallel Career Paths for Women: The Case of Trade Union Participation. Work, Employment, and Society. 2006 ; 20: 47-65
71. Kirton Gill, Healy Geraldine. Transforming Union Women: The Role of Women Trade Union Officials in Union Renewal. Industrial Relations Journal. 1999 ; 30: 31-45
72. KirtonGillHealyGeraldine. 2008. "Women and Trade Union Leadership: Key Theoretical Concepts from UK-Based Literature." Paper posted at the Women and Trade Union Leadership Development in Comparative Context Project. http://hosted.busman.qmul.ac.uk/wtul/Files/17173.pdf (accessed August 1, 2011).
73. Kirton Gil, Healy Geraldine, Gatta Mary, Alvarez Sally, Lieberwitz Risa. Mobilizing and Globalizing Women's Trade Union Leadership. Paper presented at the International Labor Process Conference, Rutgers University ; New Jersey ;..
74. Kishi Roger, Ahn Jenny. Baksh Mohamed, Sanghere Bhupinder, Nair Jay, Saptel Frank. Part of the Movement: The Asian Canadian Labour Alliance. Our Times. 2002 ; 214: 20-27
75. Paths to Union Renewal: Canadian Experiences. Kumar Pradeep Schenk Chris, ed. Peterborough, Ontario: Broadview, Garamond and Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives ; 2006 :
76. Kurtz Shannon Workplace Justice: Organizing Multi-identity Movements. Minneapolis: Minnesota University Press ; 2002 :
77. Ledwith Sue, Colgan Fiona, Joyce Paul, Hayes Mike. The Making of Women Trade Union Leaders. Industrial Relations Journal. 1990 ; 212: 112-25
78. Lévesque Christian, Murray Gregor. Local versus Global: Activating Local Union Power in the Global Economy. Labor Studies Journal. 2002 ; 273: 39-65
79. Lévesque Christian, Murray Gregor. Union Involvement in Workplace Change: A Comparative Study of Local Unions in Canada and Mexico. British Journal of Industrial Relations. 2005 ; 43: 489-514
80. Lévesque Christian, Murray Gregor. Local Union Strategies in Cross-Border Alliances: From Defensive Isolation to Proactive Solidarity. Labor Studies Journal. 2010 ; 352: 222-45
81. Lukas Salome, Persad Judy Vashti Through the Eyes of Workers of Colour: Linking Struggles for Social Justice. Toronto: Women Working with Immigrant Women/Toronto & York Region Labour Council ; 2004 :
82. Mann Marian, Ledwith Sue, Colgan Fiona Strife: Sex and Politics in Labour Unions. Pocock Barbara, ed. New South Wales, Australia: Allen and Unwin ; 1997: 194-221.
83. McBride Anne Gender Democracy in Trade Unions. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate ; 2001 :
84. McBride Anne, Waddington Jeremy Unions, Equity, and the Path to Renewal. Foley Janice A. Baker Patricia L., ed. Vancouver: UBC Press ; 2009: 192-218.
85. McCrimmonMitch. 2010. "Is Heroic Leadership All Bad?" Ivy Business Journal. January/February. http://www.refresher.com/mindfulnetwork/ articlelive/articles/468/1/Is-Heroic-Leadership-All-Bad/Page1.html (accessed August 1, 2011).
86. McLaughlinMundy Yvette. 2000. "Universal Solidarity: Recognition of Minority Communities in the Canadian Labour Union Movement." M.Law thesis, York University, Toronto, Canada.
87. Merrill Associates. 2004. "Five Generational Differences Shaping Leadership." http://merrillassociates.com/topic/2004/08/five-generational- differences-shaping-leadership/ (accessed August 1, 2011).
88. Moody Kim US Labor in Trouble and Transition-The Failure of Reform from Above, the Promise of Revival from Below. London: Verso ; 2007 :
89. Nichols-HeppnerBarbara. 1984. "Women in Public Sector Unions in Quebec: Organizing for Equality." Unpublished PhD diss., McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
90. Ontario Human Rights Commission. 2001. "An Intersectional Approach to Discrimination: Addressing Multiple Grounds in Human Rights Claims." http://www.ohrc.on.ca/en/resources/discussion-consultation/ DissIntersectionalityFtnts/view (accessed August 1, 2011).
91. Parker Jane. We're on a Road to Somewhere: Women's Groups in Unions. Industrial Relations Journal. 2003 ; 34: 164-85
92. Parker Jane. Towards Equality and Renewal: Women's Groups, Diversity, and Democracy in British Unions. Economic and Industrial Democracy. 2006 ; 27: 425-62
93. Parker Jane, Douglas Julie. Can Women's Structures Help New Zealand and UK Trade Unions' Revival?. Journal of Industrial Relations. 2010 ; 52: 439-58
94. Peetz David, Pocock Barbara. An Analysis of Workplace Representatives, Union Power, and Democracy in Australia. British Journal of Industrial Relations. 2009 ; 474: 623-52
95. Pielstick Dean. Formal vs. Informal Leading: A Comparative Analysis. Journal of Leadership Studies. 2000 ; 7: 99-114
96. Pocock Barbara. Women in Unions: What Progress in South Australia?. Journal of Industrial Relations. 1995 ; 37: 3-23
97. Rayside David, Valentine Fraser Equity, Diversity, and Canadian Labour. Hunt Gerald Rayside David, ed. Toronto: University of Toronto Press ; 2007: 156-80.
98. Roby Pamela. Becoming Shop Stewards: Perspectives on Gender and Race in Ten Trade Unions. Labor Studies Journal. 1995 ; 203: 65-82
99. Roth Silke Building Movement Bridges: The Coalition of Labour Union Women. Westport, CT: Praeger ; 2003 :
100. Sacks Karen Women and the Politics of Empowerment. Bookman Ann Morgan Sandra, ed. Philadelphia: Temple ; 1988: 77-94.
101. Salahuddi Mecca. Generational Differences Impact on Leadership Style and Organizational Success. Journal of Diversity Management. 2010 ; 5: 1-6
102. Sandmann Lorilee, Vandenberg Lela. A Framework for Twenty-First-Century Leadership. Journal of Extension. 1995 ; 33: 1-6
103. Sechi Cinzia Women in Trade Unions in Europe: Bridging the Gaps. Brussels: European Trade Union Confederation ; 2007 :
104. Seers Alan, Keller Tiffany, Wilkerson James Shared Leadership: Reframing the Hows and Whys of Leadership. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage ; 2003: 77-102.
105. Sessa Valerie I., Kabacoff Robert I., Deal Jennifer, Brown Heather. Generational Differences in Leader Values and Leadership Behaviors. The Psychologist-Manager Journal. 2007 ; 10: 47-74
106. Shanahan Noreen. Where Have All the Women Gone? Searching for Sisters in Union Leadership. Our Times. 2006 ; 25: 30-35
107. Sinclair Amanda Doing Leadership Differently: Gender, Power, and Sexuality in a Changing Business Culture. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press ; 1998 :
108. Sudano Leena Strife: Sex and Politics in Labour Unions. Pocock Barbara, ed. New South Wales, Australia: Allen and Unwin ; 1997: 149-71.
109. Timoshkina Natalya. Nonhierarchical organizing and international women's NGOs: An exploratory study.. 2008 ;:
110. London: Trades Union Congress ; 2007 :
111. Trades Union Congress. 2009. "TUC Equality Reps Project Extension Report." London: TUC. http://www.tuc.org.uk/extras/equalityrepssurvey.pdf (accessed August 1, 2011).
112. Uhl-Bien Mary, Pillai Rajnandini Follower-Centred Perspectives on Leadership. Shamir Boas Pillai Rajnandini Bligh Michelle Uhl-Bien Mary, ed. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing ; 2007: 187-209.
113. Voss Kim. Democratic Dilemmas: Union Democracy and Union Renewal. Transfer. 2010 ; 16: 369-82
114. Voss Kim, Sherman Rachel. Breaking the Iron Law of Oligarchy: Union Revitalization in the American Labor Movement. American Journal of Sociology. 2000 ; 106: 303-49
115. Waddington Jeremy Globalization and Patterns of Labour Resistance. Waddington Jeremy, ed. London: Mansell Publishing ; 1999: 1-28.
116. Waddington Jeremy, Kerr Allan. Transforming a Trade Union? An Assessment of the Introduction of an Organizing Initiative. British Journal of Industrial Relations. 2009 ; 4: 27-54
117. Wells Don. Labour Markets, Flexible Specialization and the New Microcorporatism: The Case of Canada's Major Appliance Industry. Relations industrielles. 2001 ; 56: 279-305
118. WhitefieldPamAlvarezSallyEmraniYasmin. 2009. "Is There a Women's Way of Organizing? Genders, Unions, and Effective Organizing." Research Studies and Reports. Cornell University ILR SchoolPaper 26. http:// digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/reports/26 (accessed August 1, 2011).
119. Women's Union Profile Is on the Rise. Labour Research. 2008 ; 97: 10-13