A critical analysis of the utility and compatibility of motivation theories in psychiatric treatment

Current Psychiatry Reviews

Volumn 7, Issue 4, 2011, Pages 298-312

  Jochems, Eline C ^a   Mulder, Cornelis L ^a,b   van Dam, Arno ^c   Duivenvoorden, Hugo J ^d  

^a ERASMUS MEDICAL CENTER   (Netherlands)

^b BAVO Europoort   (Netherlands)

^c GGZ Westelijk Noord Brabant   (Netherlands)

^d NONE   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Motivation; Self determination; Theory; Transtheoretical; Treatment

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; COMPARATIVE STUDY; HUMAN; INTEGRAL MODEL OF TREATMENT MOTIVATION; MENTAL DISEASE; MOTIVATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PSYCHIATRIC TREATMENT; SELF DETERMINATION THEORY; THEORY; TRANSTHEORETICAL MODEL; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 80055122077     PISSN: 15734005     EISSN: 18756441     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2174/157340011797928204     Document Type: Article

References (85)

1. Noar SM, Zimmerman RS. Health behavior theory and cumulative knowledge regarding health behaviors: Are we moving in the right direction? Health Educ Res 2005;20(3):275-290.
2. Weinstein ND, Rothman AJ. Commentary: Revitalizing research on health behavior theories. Health Educ Res 2005;20(3):294-297.
3. Weinstein ND. Misleading tests of health behavior theories. Ann Behav Med 2007;33(1):1-10.
4. Lehner RK, Dopke CA, Cohen K, et al. Outpatient treatment adherence and serious mental illness: A review of interventions. Am J Psychiatr Rehabil 2007;10(4):245-274.
5. Centorrino F, Hernan MA, Drago-Ferrante G, et al. Factors associated with noncompliance with psychiatric outpatient visits. Psychiatr Serv 2001;52(3):378-380.
6. Barrett MS, Chua WJ, Crits Christoph P, Gibbons MB, Casiano D, Thompson D. Early withdrawal from mental health treatment: Implications for psychotherapy practice. Psychotherapy 2008;45(2):247-267.
7. McMurran M, Huband N, Overton E. Non-completion of personality disorder treatments: A systematic review of correlates, consequences, and interventions. Clin Psychol Rev 2010;30(3):277-287.
8. Prochaska JO, Di Clemente CC. Stages and processes of selfchange in smoking: Toward an integrative model of change. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1983;5:390-395.
9. Drieschner KH, Lammers SMM, van der Staak CPF. Treatment motivation: An attempt for clarification of an ambiguous concept. Clin Psychol Rev 2004;23(8):1115-11137.
10. Tierney DW, McCabe MP. The validity of the trans-theoretical model of behaviour change to investigate motivation to change among child molesters. Clin Psychol Psychot 2001;8:176-190.
11. Prochaska JO, DiClemente CC, Norcross JC. In search of how people change: Applications to addictive behaviors. J Addict Nurs 1992;5(1):2-16.
12. West R. Time for a change: Putting the trans theoretical (stages of change) model to rest. Addiction 2005;100(8):1036-1039.
13. Littell JH, Girvin H. Stages of change: A critique. Behav Modif 2002;26(2):223-273.
14. Guo B, Aveyard P, Fielding A, Sutton S. Do the transtheoretical model processes of change, decisional balance and temptation predict stage movement? Evidence from smoking cessation in adolescents. Addiction 2009;104(5):828-838.
15. Weinstein ND, Rothman AJ, Sutton S. Stage theories of health behavior: Conceptual and methodological issues. Health Psychol 1998;17(3):290-299.
16. Deci EL, Ryan RM. The What And Why Of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior. Psychol Inq 2000;11(4):227-268.
17. Deci EL, Eghrari H, Patrick BC, Leone DR. Facilitating internalization: The self-determination theory perspective. J Pers 1994;62(1):119-142.
18. Deci EL, Ryan RM. Self-determination theory: A macrotheory of human motivation, development, and health. Can Psychol 2008;49(3):182-185.
19. Prochaska JO, Velicer WF. The transtheoretical model of health behavior change. Am J Health Promot 1997;12(1):38-48.
20. Prochaska JO. Decision making in the transtheoretical model of behavior change. Med Decis Making 2008;28(6):845-849.
21. Buckley PF, Wirshing DA, Bhushan P, Pierre JM, Resnick SA, Wirshing WC. Lack of insight in schizophrenia: Impact on treatment adherence. CNS Drugs 2007;21(2):129-141.
22. Wright JA, Velicer WF, Prochaska JO. Testing the predictive power of the transtheoretical model of behavior change applied to dietary fat intake. Health Educ Res 2009;24(2):224-236.
23. Prochaska JO, Redding CA, Evers KE. The transtheoretical model and stages of change. In: Glanz K, Rimer BK, Lewis M, Eds. Health behavior and health education: Theory, research and practice. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 2002. p. 60-84.
24. Sutton S. Back to the drawing board? A review of applications of the transtheoretical model to substance use. Addiction 2001;96(1):175-186.
25. Wilson GT, Schlam TR. The transtheoretical model and motivational interviewing in the treatment of eating and weight disorders. Clin Psychol Rev 2004;24(3):361-378.
26. Sutton S. Can Stages of change Provide guidance in the treatment of addictions? A critical examination of prochaska and diclemente's model. In: Edwards G, Dare C, Eds. Psychotherapy, psychological treatments and the addictions. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 1996. p. 189-205.
27. Rollnick S, Heather N, Gold R, Hall W. Development of a short 'readiness to change' questionnaire for use in brief, opportunistic interventions among excessive drinkers. Brit J Addict 1992;87(5):743-754.
28. McConnaughy EA, Prochaska JO, Velices WF. Stages of change in psychotherapy: Measurement and sample profiles. Psychother- Theor Res 1983;20(3):368-375.
29. Simpson DD, Joe GW. Motivation as a predictor of early dropout from drug abuse treatment. Psychother 1993;30(2):357-368.
30. Hodgins D. Stages of change assessments in alcohol problems: Agreement across self- and clinician-reports. Subst Abuse 2001;22(2):87-96.
31. Nidecker M, DiClemente CC, Bennett ME, Bellack AS. Application of the transtheoretical model of change: Psychometric properties of leading measures in patients with co-occurring drug abuse and severe mental illness. Addict Behav 2008;33(8):1021-1030.
32. Prochaska JO. Moving beyond the transtheoretical model. Addiction 2006;101(6):768-774.
33. Velicer WF, DiClemente CC, Prochaska JO, Brandenburg N. Decisional balance measure for assessing and predicting smoking status. J Pers Soc Psychol 1985;48(5):1279-1289.
34. Prochaska JO, Velicer WF, DiClemente CC, Fava JL. Measuring processes of change: Applications to the cessation of smoking. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1988;56(4):520-528.
35. Dunlap SK. Internalization: A related process to stages-of-change among participants in a court-mandated substance abuse program. Diss Abstr Int 2010;70(7):4480
36. DiClemente CC. Conceptual models and applied research: The ongoing contribution of the transtheoretical model. J Addict Nurs 2005;16(1-2):5-12.
37. Hutchison AJ, Breckon JD, Johnston LH. Physical activity behavior change interventions based on the transtheoretical model: A systematic review. Health Educ Behav 2009;36(5):829-845.
38. Rogers E, Martin R, Anthony W, et al. Assessing readiness for change among persons with severe mental illness. Community Ment Health J 2001;37(2):97-112.
39. Pantalon MV, Swanson AJ. Use of the university of rhode island change assessment to measure motivational readiness to change in psychiatric and dually diagnosed individuals. Psychol Addict Behav 2003;17(2):91-97.
40. Gorczynski P, Faulkner G, Greening S, Cohn T. Exploring the construct validity of the transtheoretical model to structure physical activity interventions for individuals with serious mental illness. Psychiatr Rehabil J 2010;34(1):61-64.
41. Bezyak JL. Stages of change and physical activity among individuals with severe mental illness. Diss Abstr Int 2009;69(9-B):5766.
42. Tsang HW-h, Fung KM, Chung RC-k. Self-stigma and stages of change as predictors of treatment adherence of individuals with schizophrenia. Psychiatry Res 2010;180(1):10-15.
43. Velasquez MM, Carbonari JP, Diclemente CC. Psychiatric severity and behavior change in alcoholism: The relation of the transtheoretical model variables to psychiatric distress in dually diagnosed patients. Addictive Behaviors 1999;24(4):481-496.
44. Hagedorn HJ. Application of the transtheoretical model of behavior change to cessation of alcohol use in patients with schizophrenia. Diss Abstr Int 2000;61(3-B):1635.
45. Carey KB, Purnine DM, Maisto SA, Carey MP. Correlates of stages of change for substance abuse among psychiatricoutpatients. Psychol Addict Behav 2002;16(4):283-289.
46. Project MATCH Research Group A. Project match (matchingalcoholism treatment to client heterogeneity): Rationale and methods for a multisite clinical trial matching patients to alcoholism treatment. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 1993;17(6):1130-1145.
47. Project MATCH Research Group A. Matching alcoholism treatments to client heterogeneity: Project match three-yeardrinking outcomes. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 1998;22(6):1300.
48. Walters GD. Lessons learned from project match. Addictive Disorders & Their Treatment 2002;1(4):135-139.
49. Witkiewitz K, Hartzler B, Donovan D. Matching motivation enhancement treatment to client motivation: Re-examining the project match motivation matching hypothesis. Addiction 2010;105(8):1403-1413.
50. Bridle C, Riemsma RP, Pattenden J, et al. Systematic review of the effectiveness of health behavior interventions based on the transtheoretical model. Psychol Health 2005;20(3):283-301.
51. Brogan MM, Prochaska JO, Prochaska JM. Predicting terminationand continuation status in psychotherapy using the transtheoretical model. Psychother Theor Res Pract Train 1999;36(2):105-113.
52. Patterson DA, Wolf S, Buckingham SL. Does motivational interviewing stages of change increase treatment retention among persons who are alcohol and other drug dependent and hiv infected? J HIV AIDS Soc Serv 2010;9(1):45-57.
53. Drieschner KH, Verschuur J. Treatment engagement as a predictor of premature treatment termination and treatment outcome in a correctional outpatient sample. Crim Behav Ment Health 2010;20(2):86-99.
54. Conner M, Norman P. Comparing the health belief model and thetheory of planned behavior in health screening. In: Rutter DR,Quiine L, Eds. Social psychology and health: European perspectives. Brookfield: Avebury/Ashgate; 1994. p. 1-24.
55. Sutton S. How does the health action process approach (hapa) bridge the intention-behavior gap? An examination of the model's causal structure. App Psychol-Int Rev 2008;57(1):66-74.
56. Drieschner KH, Boomsma A. Validation of the treatment motivation scales for forensic outpatient treatment (tms-f). Assessment 2008;15(2):242-255.
57. Drieschner KH, Boomsma A. The treatment motivation scales for forensic outpatient treatment (tms-f): Construction and psychometric evaluation. Assessment 2008;15(2):224-241.
58. Drieschner KH, Boomsma A. The treatment engagement rating scale (ter) for forensic outpatient treatment: Description, psychometric properties, and norms. Psychol Crime Law 2008;14(4):299-315.
59. Burke BL, Arkowitz H, Menchola M. The efficacy of motivational interviewing: A meta-analysis of controlled clinical trials. J Consult Clin Psychol 2003;71(5):843-861.
60. Drymalski WM, Campbell TC. A review of motivational interviewing to enhance adherence to antipsychotic medication in patients with schizophrenia: Evidence and recommendations. J Ment Health 2009;18(1):6-15.
61. Martino S. Contemplating the use of motivational interviewing with patients who have schizophrenia and substance use disorders. Clin Psychol-Sci Pr 2007;14(1):58-63.
62. Ryan RM, Patrick H, Deci EL, Williams GC. Facilitating health behaviour change and its maintenance: Interventions based on selfdetermination theory. Europ Health Psychol 2008;10:2-5.
63. Ryan RM, Plant RW, O'Malley S. Initial motivations for alcoholtreatment: Relations with patient characteristics, treatment involvement, and dropout. Addict Behav 1995;20(3):279-297.
64. Zeldman A, Ryan RM, Fiscella K. Motivation, autonomy support, and entity beliefs: Their role in methadone maintenance treatment. J Soc Clin Psychol 2004;23(5):675-696.
65. Ferron JC. Psychological mechanisms to treatment adherence among people with severe mental illness: Validating treatment motivation and working alliance measures. Diss Abstr Int 2007;68(11-A):4863.
66. Wild T, Cunningham JA, Ryan RM. Social pressure, coercion, and client engagement at treatment entry: A self-determination theory perspective. Addict Behav 2006;31(10):1858-1872.
67. Kennedy K, Gregoire TK. Theories of motivation in addiction treatment: Testing the relationship of the transtheoretical model of change and self-determination theory. J Soc Work Pract Addict 2009;9(2):163-183.
68. Zuroff DC, Koestner R, Moskowitz D, McBride C, Marshall M, Bagby M. Autonomous motivation for therapy: A new common factor in brief treatments for depression. Psychother Res 2007;17(2):137-147.
69. Pelletier LG, Tuson KM, Haddad NK. Client motivation for therapy scale: A measure of intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation, and amotivation for therapy. J Pers Assess 1997;68(2):414-435.
70. Dwyer LA, Hornsey MJ, Smith LG, Oei TP, Dingle GA. Participant autonomy in cognitive behavioral group therapy: An integration of self-determination and cognitive behavioral theories. J Soc Clin Psychol 2011;30(1):24-46.
71. DiClemente CC, Nidecker M, Bellack AS. Motivation and the stages of change among individuals with severe mental illness and substance abuse disorders. J Subst Abuse Treat 2008;34(1):25-35.
72. Ryan RM, Deci EL. A self-determination theory approach to psychotherapy: The motivational basis for effective change. Can Psychol 2008;49(3):186-193.
73. Markland D, Ryan RM, Tobin VJ, Rollnick S. Motivational interviewing and self-determination theory. J Soc Clin Psychol 2005;24(6):811-831.
74. Williams GC, Deci EL. Activating patients for smoking cessation throiugh physician autonomy support. Med Care 2001;39(8):813-823.
75. Williams GC, Gagné M, Ryan RM, Deci EL. Facilitating autonomous motivation for smoking cessation. Health Psychol 2002;21(1):40-50.
76. Williams GC, Grow VM, Freedman ZR, Ryan RM, Deci EL. Motivational predictors of weight-loss and weight-loss maintenance. J Pers Soc Psychol 1996;70:115-126.
77. Williams GC, McGregor HA, Zeldman A, Freedman ZR, Deci EL. Testing a self-determination theory process model for promoting glycemic control through diabetes self-management. Health Psychol 2004;23:58-66
78. Williams GC, Rodin GC, Ryan RM, Grolnick WS, Deci EL. Autonomous motivation and long-term medication adherence in adult outpatients. Health Psychol 1998;17:269-276.
79. Prochaska JO, Wright JA, Velicer WF. Evaluating theories of health behavior change: A hierarchy of criteria applied to the transtheoretical model. Appl Psychol 2008;57(4):561-588.
80. Vansteenkiste M, Sierens E, Soenens B, Luyckx K, Lens W. Motivational profiles from a self-determination perspective: The quality of motivation matters. J Educ Psychol 2009;101(3):671-688.
81. Ryan RM, Lynch MF, Vansteenkiste M, Deci EL. Motivation and autonomy in counseling, psychotherapy, and behavior change: A look at theory and practice. Couns Psychol 2010;39(2):193-260.
82. Vansteenkiste M, Soenens B, Vandereycken W. Motivation to change in eating disorder patients: A conceptual clarification on thebasis of self-determination theory. Int J Eat Disord 2005;37(3):207-219.
83. Abblett MR. Motivation for change in psychotherapy: The relationship between the transtheoretical model and selfdetermination theory and prediction of clinical services utilization. Diss Abstr Int 2002;63(4-B):2047.
84. Mullan E, Markland D. Variations in self-determination across the stages of change for exercise in adults. Motiv Emot 1997;21(4):349-362.
85. Lippke S, Ziegelmann JP. Theory-based health behavior change: Developing, testing, and applying theories for evidence-based interventions. Appl Psychol 2008;57(4):698-716.