Balancing shifting cultivation and forest conservation: Lessons from a "sustainable landscape" in southeastern Mexico

Ecological Applications

Volumn 21, Issue 5, 2011, Pages 1557-1572

  Dalle, Sarah Paule ^a,c   Pulido, María T ^b   De Blois, Sylvie ^a  

^a MCGILL UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b UNIVERSIDAD AUTÓNOMA DEL ESTADO DE HIDALGO   (Mexico)

^c USC Canada   (Canada)

Author keywords

Accessibility; Agricultural expansion; Agricultural intensification; Community forestry; Forest conservation; Livelihoods; Milpa; Plan piloto forestal; Sustainability; Trade offs; Tropical deforestation; Yucatec Maya

Indexed keywords

ACCESSIBILITY; AGRICULTURAL INTENSIFICATION; AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION; ALTERNATIVE AGRICULTURE; DEFORESTATION; FALLOW; LAND COVER; LAND USE PLANNING; NATURE CONSERVATION; REMOTE SENSING; RESOURCE AVAILABILITY; SATELLITE DATA; SHIFTING CULTIVATION; TRADE-OFF;

AGRICULTURE; ARTICLE; ECOSYSTEM; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; METHODOLOGY; MEXICO; TIME; TREE;

AGRICULTURE; CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES; ECOSYSTEM; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; MEXICO; TIME FACTORS; TREES;

MEXICO [NORTH AMERICA]; QUINTANA ROO;

EID: 79960372149     PISSN: 10510761     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1890/10-0700.1     Document Type: Article

References (98)

1. Abizaid, C., and O. T. Coomes. 2004. Land use and forest fallowing dynamics in seasonally dry tropical forests of the southern Yucatan Peninsula, Mexico. Land Use Policy 21:71-84. (Pubitemid 38187839)
2. Agarwal, B. 2001. Participatory exclusions, community forestry, and gender: an analysis for South Asia and a conceptual framework. World Development 29:1623-1648. (Pubitemid 32931919)
3. Alcorn, J. B. 1981. Huastec noncrop resource management: implications for prehistoric rain forest management. Human Ecology 9:395-417.
4. Al-Sayed, M., and A. Al-Langawi. 2003. Biological resources conservation through ecotourism development. Journal of Arid Environments 54:225-236. (Pubitemid 36290151)
5. Anta Fonseca, S A. V. Areola Muñoz, M. A. Gonzalez Ortiz, and J. Acosta González, editors. 2006. Ordenamiento territorial comunitario. Instituto Nacional de Ecologia-Semarnat, México D. F, México.
6. Barrera-Bassols, N., and V. M. Toledo. 2005. Ethnoecology of the Yucatec Maya: symbolism, knowledge and management of natural resources. Journal of Latin American Geography 4:9-41. (Pubitemid 41195308)
7. Berkes, F J. Colding, and C. Folke. 2000. Rediscovery of traditional ecological knowledge as adaptive management. Ecological Applications 10:1251-1262. (Pubitemid 32139993)
8. Bocco, G A. Velázquez, and A. Torres. 2000. Ciencia, comunidades indígenas y manejo de recursos naturales. Un caso de investigación participativa en México. Interciencia 25:64-70.
9. Bray, D. B E. A. Ellis, N. Armijo-Canto, and C. T. Beck. 2004. The institutional drivers of sustainable landscapes: a case study of the "Mayan Zone" in Quintana Roo, Mexico. Land Use Policy 21:333-346. (Pubitemid 40533702)
10. Bray, D. B L. Merino-Perez, P. Negreros-Castillo, G. Segura-Warnholtz, J. M. Torres-Rojo, and H. F. M. Vester. 2003. Mexico's community-managed forests as a global model for sustainable landscapes. Conservation Biology 17:672-677. (Pubitemid 36695825)
11. Brookfield, H. 2001. Exploring agrodiversity. Columbia University Press, New York, New York, USA.
12. Caballero, J. 1994. Use and management of Sabal Palms among the Maya of Yucatan. Dissertation. University of California, Berkeley, California, USA.
13. Cairns, M. A P. K. Haggerty, R. Alvarez, B. H. J. de Jong, and I. Olmsted. 2000. Tropical Mexico's recent land-use change: a region's contribution to the global carbon cycle. Ecological Applications 10:1426-1441. (Pubitemid 32140008)
14. Colunga-GarciaMarín, P., and D. Zizumbo-Villarreal. 2004. Domestication of plants in Maya Lowlands. Economic Botany 58:S101-S110. (Pubitemid 40284949)
15. Cornelius, W. A., and D. Myhre, editors. 1998. The transformation of rural Mexico. reforming the ejido sector. University of California, San Diego, California, USA.
16. Dalle, S. P. 2006. Landscape dynamics and management of wild plant resources in shifting cultivation systems: a case study from a forest ejido in the Maya Zone of Quintana Roo, Mexico. Ph. D. thesis, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
17. Dalle, S. P., and S. de Blois. 2006. Shorter fallow cycles affect the availability of non-crop plant resources in a shifting cultivation system. Ecology and Society 11:2. (http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol11/iss12/art12/)
18. Dalle, S. P S. de Blois, J. Caballero, and T. Johns. 2006. Integrating analyses of local land-use regulations, cultural perceptions and land-use/land cover data for assessing the success of community-based conservation. Forest Ecology and Management 222:370-383. (Pubitemid 43151202)
19. D'Alonzo, K. T. 2004. The Johnson-Neyman procedure as an alternative to ANCOVA. Western Journal of Nursing Research 26:804-812. (Pubitemid 39434274)
20. DeFries, R J. A. Foley, and G. P. Asner. 2004. Land-use choices: balancing human needs and ecosystem function. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 2:249-257.
21. de Rouw, A. 1995. The fallow period as a weed-break in shifting cultivation (tropical wet forests) . Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 54:31-43. (Pubitemid 26450689)
22. Diemont, S. A. W., and J. F. Martin. 2009. Lacandon Maya ecological management: a sustainable design for subsistence and environmental restoration. Ecological Applications 19:245-266.
23. Dougill, A. J J. G. Soussan, E. Kiff, O. Springate-Baginski, N. P. Yadav, O. P. Dev, and A. P. Hurford. 2001. Impacts of community forestry on farming system sustainability in the Middle Hills of Nepal. Land Degradation and Development 12:261-276. (Pubitemid 32722862)
24. Duran, E J.-F. Mas, and A. Velázquez. 2005. Land use/land cover change in community forestry regions and protected areas in Mexico. Pages 215-240 in L. Merino-Perez, D. B. Bray, and D. Barry, editors. The community forests of Mexico: managing for sustainable landscapes. University of Texas Press, Austin, Texas, USA.
25. Eastmond, A., and B. Faust. 2006. Farmers, fires, and forests: a green alternative to shifting cultivation for conservation of the Maya forest? Landscape and Urban Planning 74:267-284. (Pubitemid 41563208)
26. Ellis, E. A., and L. Porter-Bolland. 2008. Is community-based forest management more effective than protected areas? A comparison of land use/land cover change in two neighboring study areas of the Central Yucatan Peninsula, Mexico. Forest Ecology and Management 256:1971-1983.
27. Finegan, B., and R. Nasi. 2004. The biodiversity and conservation potential of shifting cultivation landscapes. Pages 153-197 in G. Shchroth, G. A. B. da Fonseca, C. A. Harvey, C. Gascon, H. L. Vasconcelos, and A.-M. N. Izac, editors. Agroforestry and biodiversity conservation in tropical landscapes. Island Press, Washington, D. C., USA.
28. Fischer, J B. Brosi, G. C. Daily, P. R. Ehrlich, R. Goldman, J. Goldstein, D. B. Lindenmayer, A. D. Manning, H. A. Mooney, L. Pejchar, J. Ranganathan, and H. Tallis. 2008. Should agricultural policies encourage land sparing or wildlife-friendly farming? Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 6:382-387.
29. Flachsenberg, H., and H. A. Galletti. 1998. Forest management in Quintana Roo, Mexico. Pages 47-60 in R. B. Primack, D. Bray, H. A. Galletti, and I. Ponciano, editors. Timber, tourists, and temples: conservation and development in the Maya forest of Belize, Guatemala, and Mexico. Island Press, Washington, D. C., USA.
30. Flores, J. S., and I. Espejel Carvajal. 1994. Tipos de vegetacion de la península de Yucatán. Etnoflora Yucatense. No. 3. Universidad Autónoma de Yucatán, Mérida, México.
31. Foody, G. 2002. Status of land cover classification accuracy assessment. Remote Sensing of Environment 80:185-201. (Pubitemid 34271212)
32. Fujisaka, S G. Escobar, and E. J. Veneklaas. 2000. Weedy fields and forests: interactions between land use and the composition of plant communities in the Peruvian Amazon. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 78:175-186. (Pubitemid 30106698)
33. Galletti, H. A. 1998. The Maya forest of Quintana Roo: thirteen years of conservation and community development. Pages 33-46 in R. B. Primack, D. Bray, H. A. Galletti, and I. Ponciano, editors. Timber, tourists, and temples: conservation and development in the Maya forest of Belize, Guatemala, and Mexico. Island Press, Washington, D. C., USA.
34. Garcia-Frapolli, E B. Ayala-Orozco, M. Bonilla-Moheno, C. Espadas-Manrique, and G. Ramos-Fernandez. 2007. Biodiversity conservation, traditional agriculture and ecotourism: land cover/land use change projections for a natural protected area in the northeastern Yucatan Peninsula, Mexico. Landscape and Urban Planning 83:137-153. (Pubitemid 350010987)
35. Gautam, A. P E. L. Webb, and A. Eiumnoh. 2002. GIS assessment of land use/land cover changes associated with community forestry implementation in the Middle Hills of Nepal. Mountain Research and Development 22:63-69. (Pubitemid 34468352)
36. Geist, H. J., and E. F. Lambin. 2002. Proximate causes and underlying driving forces of tropical deforestation. BioScience 52:143-150. (Pubitemid 34140417)
37. Geoghegan, J S. Cortina Villar, P. Klepeis, P. Macario Mendoza, Y. Ogneva-Himmelberger, R. R. Chowdhury, B. L. Turner, and C. Vance. 2001. Modeling tropical deforestation in the southern Yucatan peninsular region: comparing the survey and satellite data. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 85:25-46. (Pubitemid 32480604)
38. Geoghegan, J L. Schneider, and C. Vance. 2005. Temporal dynamics and spatial scales: modeling deforestation in the Southern Yucatan Peninsular Region. GeoJournal 61:353-363. (Pubitemid 41127050)
39. Green, R. E S. J. Cornell, J. P. W. Scharlemann, and A. Balmford. 2005. Farming and the fate of wild nature. Science 307:550-555. (Pubitemid 40165674)
40. Gupte, M. 2004. Participation in a gendered environment: the case of community forestry in India. Human Ecology 32:365-382. (Pubitemid 38865566)
41. Hayes, D. J S. A. Sader, and N. B. Schwartz. 2002. Analyzing a forest conversion history database to explore the spatial and temporal characteristics of land cover change in Guatemala's Maya Biosphere Reserve. Landscape Ecology 17:299-314. (Pubitemid 35249924)
42. Hostettler, U. 1996. Milpa agriculture and economic diversification: socioeconomic change in a Maya peasant society of central Quintana Roo, 1900-1990s. Dissertation. University of Berne, Berne, Switzerland.
43. Humphries, S. 1993. The intensification of traditional agriculture among Yucatec Maya farmers: facing up to the dilemma of livelihood sustainability. Human Ecology 21:87-102. (Pubitemid 24387159)
44. INEGI. 2000. XII Censo General de Poblacion y Vivienda. 2000. Quintana Roo. Resultados difinitivos. Instituto Nacional de Estadistica Geografia e Informatica, Aguascalientes, Mexico.
45. Jackson, W. J R. M. Tamrakar, S. Hunt, and K. R. Shepherd. 1998. Land-use changes in two Middle Hills districts of Nepal. Mountain Research and Development 18:193-212. (Pubitemid 28508145)
46. Kates, R. W G. Hyden, and B. L. Tuner 1993. Theory, evidence, study design. Pages 1-40 in B. L. Turner II, G. Hyden, and R. W. Kates, editors. Population growth and agricultural change in Africa. University Press of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA.
47. Kellman, M., and R. Tackaberry. 1997. Tropical environments: the functioning and management of tropical ecosystems. Routledge, London, UK.
48. Keys, E., and W. J. McConnell. 2005. Global change and the intensification of agriculture in the tropics. Global Environmental Change Part A 15:320-337. (Pubitemid 41608731)
49. Kiernan, M. J., and C. H. Freese. 1997. Mexico's Plan Piloto Forestal: the search for balance between socioeconomic and ecological sustainability. Pages 93-131 in C. H. Freese, editors. Harvesting wild species: implications for biodiversity conservation. John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
50. Klepeis, P., and C. Vance. 2003. Neoliberal policy and deforestation in southeastern Mexico: an assessment of the PROCAMPO program. Economic Geography 79:221-240. (Pubitemid 37269277)
51. Klooster, D. J. 2005. Producing social nature in the Mexican countryside. Cultural Geographies 12:321-344. (Pubitemid 40923870)
52. Knoke, T B. Calvas, N. Aguirre, R. M. Roman-Cuesta, S. Gunter, B. Stimm, M. Weber, and R. Mosandl. 2009. Can tropical farmers reconcile subsistence needs with forest conservation? Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 7:548-554.
53. Laney, R. M. 2002. Disaggregating induced intensification for land-change analysis: a case study from Madagascar. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 92:702-726. (Pubitemid 41716690)
54. Laney, R. M. 2004. A process-led approach to modeling land change in agricultural landscapes: a case study from Madagascar. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 101:135-153. (Pubitemid 38215228)
55. Lawrence, D P. D'Odorico, L. Diekmann, M. DeLonge, R. Das, and J. Eaton. 2007. Ecological feedbacks following deforestation create the potential for a catastrophic ecosystem shift in tropical dry forest. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 104:20696-20701.
56. Lawrence, D V. Suma, and J. P. Mogea. 2005. Change in species composition with repeated shifting cultivation: limited role of soil nutrients. Ecological Applications 15:1952-1967. (Pubitemid 43112057)
57. Lawrence, D H. F. M. Vester, D. Perez-Salicrup, J. R. Eastman, B. L. Turner II, and J. Geoghegan. 2004. Integrated analysis of ecosystem interactions with land-use change: the Southern Yucatan Peninsular Region. Pages 277-292 in R. S. DeFries, G. P. Asner, and R. A. Houghton, editors. Ecosystems and land use change. American Geophysical Union, Washington, D. C., USA.
58. Legendre, P., and L. Legendre. 1998. Numerical ecology. Second edition. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
59. Mas, J. F. 1999. Monitoring land-cover changes: a comparison of change detection techniques. International Journal of Remote Sensing 20:139-152.
60. Matson, P. A W. J. Parton, A. G. Power, and M. J. Swift. 1997. Agricultural intensification and ecosystem properties. Science 277:504-509. (Pubitemid 27368988)
61. Mehta, J. N., and S. R. Kellert. 1998. Local attitudes toward community-based conservation policy and programmes in Nepal: a case study in the Makalu-Barun Conservation Area. Environmental Conservation 25:320-333. (Pubitemid 29015358)
62. Merino Perez, L. 1997. Revaloracion de la selva y manejo forestal: la experiencia de la Organizacion de Ejidos Productores Forestales de la Zona Maya de Quintana Roo. Dissertation. UNAM, Mexico, D. F Mexico.
63. Metzger, J. P. 2002. Landscape dynamics and equilibrium in areas of slash-and-burn agriculture with short and long fallow period (Bragantina region, NE Brazilian Amazon) . Landscape Ecology 17:419-431. (Pubitemid 36028938)
64. Metzger, J. P. 2003. Effects of slash-and-burn fallow periods on landscape structure. Environmental Conservation 30:325-333. (Pubitemid 38084019)
65. Moran, E. F E. Brondizio, P. Mausel, and Y. Wu. 1994. Integrating Amazonian vegetation, land-use, and satellite data. BioScience 44:329-338. (Pubitemid 2079658)
66. Murphy, J. 1990. Indigenous forest use and development in the Maya Zone of Quintana Roo, Mexico. Major Paper. York University, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
67. Nelson, E., et al. 2009. Modeling multiple ecosystem services, biodiversity conservation, commodity production, and tradeoffs at landscape scales. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 7:4-11.
68. Pascual, U. 2005. Land use intensification potential in slashand-burn farming through improvements in technical efficiency. Ecological Economics 52:497-511. (Pubitemid 40466097)
69. Pennington, T. D., and J. Sarukhan. 1998. Arboles Tropicales de Mexico. Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico, Mexico, D. F., Mexico.
70. Plummer, R., and J. Fitzgibbon. 2004. Co-management of natural resources: a proposed framework. Environmental Management 33:876-885. (Pubitemid 39121785)
71. Potthoff, R. F. 1964. On the Johnson-Neyman technique and some extensions thereof. Psychometrika 29:241-256.
72. Pulido, M. T. 2006. Uso y manejo de la palma de guano (Sabal yapa, Arecaeae) en zonas de vegetación natural del $AArea Maya de la Península de Yucatan. Ph. D. thesis. Universidad Nacional Autonóma de Mexico, Mexico, D. F., Mexico.
73. Pulido, M. T., and J. Caballero. 2006. The impact of shifting agriculture on the availability of non-timber forest products: the example of Sabal yapa in the Maya lowlands of Mexico. Forest Ecology and Management 222:399-409. (Pubitemid 43151205)
74. R Development Core Team. 2006. R version 2.3.1. R Project for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. (www.r-project.org)
75. Ramakrishnan, P. S. 1992. Shifting agriculture and sustainable development: an interdisciplinary study from north-eastern India. UNESCO, Paris, France.
76. Raquez, P., and E. F. Lambin. 2006. Conditions for a sustainable land use: case study evidence. Journal of Land Use Science 1:109-125.
77. Re Cruz, A. 1996. The two milpas of Chan Kom. State University of New York, Albany, New York, USA.
78. Remmers, G. G. A., and H. de Koeijer. 1992. The T'olche', a Maya system of communally managed forest belts: the causes and consequences of its disappearance. Agroforestry Systems 18:149-177.
79. Rogosa, D. 1980. Comparing nonparallel regression lines. Psychological Bulletin 88:307-321.
80. Salafsky, N J. Parks, C. Margoluis, S. Bhatt, C. Encarnacion, D. Russell, R. Margoluis, H. Cauley, G. Balachander, and B. Cordes. 2001. A systematic test of an enterprise strategy for community-based biodiversity conservation. Conservation Biology 15:1585-1595. (Pubitemid 34045724)
81. SAS Institute. 2002. SAS version 9.1. SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina, USA.
82. Secretaría de Industría y Comercio. 1971. IX Censo General de Poblacion. 1970. Territorio de Quintana Roo. Secretaria de Industria y Comercio, Direccion General de Estadistica, Mexico, D. F., Mexico.
83. Skole, D. L W. H. Chomentowski, W. A. Salas, and A. D. Nobre. 1994. Physical and human dimensions of deforestation in Amazonia. BioScience 44:314-322. (Pubitemid 2079656)
84. Smith, J. H. 2003. Land-cover assessment of conservation and buffer zones in the BOSAWAS Natural Resource Reserve of Nicaragua. Environmental Management 31:252-262. (Pubitemid 36959047)
85. Smith, J P. van de Kop, K. Reategui, I. Lombardi, C. Sabogal, and A. Diaz. 1999. Dynamics of secondary forests in slashand-burn farming: interactions among land use types in the Peruvian Amazon. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 76:85-98.
86. Staver, C. 1991. The role of weeds in the productivity of Amazonian bush fallow agriculture. Experimental Agriculture 27:287-304.
87. Teran, S., and C. H. Rasmussen. 1995. Genetic diversity and agricultural strategy in 16th century and present-day Yucatecan milpa agriculture. Biodiversity and Conservation 4:363-381. (Pubitemid 26429686)
88. Toledo, V. M N. Barrera-Bassols, E. Garcia-Frapolli, and P. Alarcon-Chaires. 2008. Uso multiple y biodiversidad entre los mayas yucatecos (México) . Interciencia 33:345-352. (Pubitemid 351945977)
89. Toledo, V. M B. Ortiz-Espejel, L. Cortes, P. Moguel, and M. d. J. Ordonez. 2003. The multiple use of tropical forests by indigenous peoples in Mexico: a case of adaptive management. Conservation Ecology 7:9. (http://www.consecol.org/vol7/iss3/art9/)
90. Turner, B. L II, and A. M. S. Ali. 1996. Induced intensification: agricultural change in Bangladesh with implications for Malthus and Boserup. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 93:14984-14991. (Pubitemid 26419082)
91. Turner, B. L., et al. 2001. Deforestation in the southern Yucatan peninsular region: an integrative approach. Forest Ecology and Management 154:353-370.
92. Turner, N. J I. J. Davidson-Hunt, and M. O'Flaherty. 2003. Living on the edge: ecological and cultural edges as sources of diversity for social-ecological resilience. Human Ecology 31:439-461.
93. Universidad Autónoma de Yucatán. 1999. Atlas de procesos territoriales de Yucátan. Universidad Autónoma de Yucatan, Mexico, D. F., Mexico.
94. Velazquez, A G. Bocco, and A. Torres. 2001. Turning scientific approaches into practical conservation actions: the case of Comunidad Indigena de Nuevo San Juan Parangaricutiro, Mexico. Environmental Management 27:655-665. (Pubitemid 32332560)
95. Vester, H. F. M D. Lawrence, J. R. Eastman, B. L. Turner, S. Calmé, R. Dickson, C. Pozo, and F. Sangermano. 2007. Land change in the southern Yucataìn and Calakmul biosphere reserve: effects on habitat and biodiversity. Ecological Applications 17:989-1003. (Pubitemid 351328139)
96. Walker, A. 2005. "Arborealisation" and the limitations of community forestry. International Forestry Review 7:358-362.
97. White, D. A., and S. P. Darwin. 1995. Woody vegetation of tropical lowland deciduous forests and Mayan ruins in the North-Central Yucatan peninsula, Mexico. Tulane Studies in Zoology and Botany 30:1-25.
98. Zurayk, R F. el-Awar, S. Hamadeh, S. Talhouk, C. Sayegh, A.-G. Chehab, and K. A. Shab. 2001. Using indigenous knowledge in land use investigations: a participatory study in a semi-arid mountainous region of Lebanon. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 86:247-262. (Pubitemid 32773993)