How trustworthy is a diagnosis in head and neck surgical pathology? A consideration of diagnostic discrepancies (errors)

European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology

Volumn 268, Issue 5, 2011, Pages 643-651

  Woolgar, Julia A ^a   Ferlito, Alfio ^b   Devaney, Kenneth O ^c   Rinaldo, Alessandra ^b   Barnes, Leon ^d  

^a UNIVERSITY OF LIVERPOOL   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF UDINE   (Italy)

^c Allegiance Health ^*  (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ASPIRATION BIOPSY; DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY; DIAGNOSTIC ERROR; DIAGNOSTIC VALUE; DISEASE MARKER; EDITORIAL; FROZEN SECTION; HEAD AND NECK DISEASE; HUMAN; LAW SUIT; MEDICAL ERROR; PEER REVIEW; PREDICTIVE VALUE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUALITY CONTROL; SAMPLING ERROR; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY;

BIOPSY; BIOPSY, FINE-NEEDLE; DIAGNOSTIC ERRORS; FROZEN SECTIONS; HEAD AND NECK NEOPLASMS; HUMANS; MALPRACTICE; PATHOLOGY, SURGICAL;

EID: 79956063257     PISSN: 09374477     EISSN: 14344726     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00405-011-1526-x     Document Type: Editorial

References (60)

1. Leong AS, Braye S, Bhagwandeen B (2006) Diagnostic "errors" in anatomical pathology: relevance to Australian laboratories. Pathology 38:490-497
2. Raab SS (2004) Improving patient safety by examining pathology errors. Clin Lab Med 24:849-863
3. Sirota RL (2006) Defining error in anatomic pathology. Arch Pathol Lab Med 130:604-606
4. Foucar E (1998) Error identification: a surgical pathology dilemma. Am J Surg Pathol 22:1-5
5. Coffin CS, Burak KW, Hart J, Gao ZH (2006) The impact of pathologist experience on liver transplant biopsy interpretation. Mod Pathol 19:832-838 (Pubitemid 43780453)
6. Renshaw AA (2006) Comparing methods to measure error in gynecologic cytology and surgical pathology. Arch Pathol Lab Med 130:626-629
7. Foucar E (2005) Classification of error in anatomic pathology: a proposal for an evidence-based standard. Semin Diagn Pathol 22:139-146
8. Renshaw AA, Cartagena N, Granter SR, Gould EW (2003) Agreement and error rates using blinded review to evaluate surgical pathology of biopsy material. Am J Clin Pathol 119:797-800 (Pubitemid 37047839)
9. Lind AC, Bewtra C, Healy JC, Sims KL (1995) Prospective peer review in surgical pathology. Am J Clin Pathol 104:560-566
10. Raab SS, Nakhleh RE, Ruby SG (2005) Patient safety in anatomic pathology: measuring discrepancy frequencies and causes. Arch Pathol Lab Med 129:459-466 (Pubitemid 40471190)
11. Troxel DB (2003) Pitfalls in the diagnosis of malignant melanoma: findings of a risk management panel study. Am J Surg Pathol 27:1278-1283
12. Zarbo RJ, Meier FA, Raab SS (2005) Error detection in anatomic pathology. Arch Pathol Lab Med 129:1237-1245 (Pubitemid 41407428)
13. Wakely SL, Baxendine-Jones JA, Gallagher PJ, Mullee M, Pickering R (1998) Aberrant diagnoses by individual surgical pathologists. Am J Surg Pathol 22:77-82 (Pubitemid 28016755)
14. Ramsay AD (1999) Errors in histopathology reporting: detection and avoidance. Histopathology 34:481-490
15. Kornstein MJ, Byrne SP (2007) The medicolegal aspect of error in pathology: a search of jury verdicts and settlements. Arch Pathol Lab Med 131:615-618 (Pubitemid 46564437)
16. Roy JE, Hunt JL (2010) Detection and classification of diagnostic discrepancies (errors) in surgical pathology. Adv Anat Pathol 17:359-365
17. Zarbo RJ, Hoffman GG, Howanitz PJ (1991) Interinstitutional comparison of frozen-section consultation. A College of American Pathologists Q-Probe study of 79,647 consultations in 297 North American institutions. Arch Pathol Lab Med 115:1187-1194
18. White VA, Trotter MJ (2008) Intraoperative consultation/final diagnosis correlation: relationship to tissue type and pathologic process. Arch Pathol Lab Med 132:29-36
19. Novis DA, Gephardt GN, Zarbo RJ (1996) Interinstitutional comparison of frozen section consultation in small hospitals. A College of American Pathologists Q-Probes study of 18,532 frozen section consultation diagnoses in 233 small hospitals. Arch Pathol Lab Med 120:1087-1093
20. Olson S, Cheema Y, Harter J, Starling J, Chen H (2006) Does frozen section alter surgical management of multinodular thyroid disease? J Surg Res 136:179-181
21. Basalo F, Ugolini C, Proietti A, Iacconi P, Berti P, Miccoli P (2007) Role of frozen section associated with intraoperative cytology in comparison to FNA and FS alone in the management of thyroid nodules. Eur J Surg Oncol 33:769-775 (Pubitemid 47029669)
22. DiNardo LJ, Lin J, Karageorge LS, Powers CN (2000) Accuracy, utility, and cost of frozen section margins in head and neck cancer surgery. Laryngoscope 110:1773-1776
23. Tschopp L, Nuyens M, Stauffer E, Krause T, Zbären P (2005) The value of frozen section analysis of the sentinel lymph node in clinically N0 squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity and oropharynx. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 132:99-102 (Pubitemid 40052679)
24. Terada A, Hasegawa Y, Yatabe Y, Hyodo I, Ogawa T, Hanai N, Ikeda A, Nagashima Y, Masui T, Hirakawa H, Nakashima T (2008) Intraoperative diagnosis of cancer metastasis in sentinel lymph node of oral cancer patients. Oral Oncol 44:838-843
25. Manion E, Cohen MB, Weydert J (2008) Mandatory second opinion in surgical pathology referral material: clinical consequences of major disagreements. Am J Surg Pathol 32:732-737 (Pubitemid 351600825)
26. Abt AB, Abt LG, Olt GJ (1995) The effect of interinstitution anatomic pathology consultation on patient care. Arch Pathol Lab Med 119:514-517
27. Kronz JD, Westra WH, Epstein JI (1999) Mandatory second opinion surgical pathology at a large referral hospital. Cancer 86:2426-2435 (Pubitemid 30010387)
28. Weir MM, Jan E, Colgan TJ (2003) Interinstitutional pathology consultations. A reassessment. Am J Clin Pathol 120:405-412
29. Tsung JS (2004) Institutional pathology consultation. Am J Surg Pathol 28:399-402
30. Nakhleh RE, Zarbo RJ (1998) Amended reports in surgical pathology and implications for diagnostic error detection and avoidance: a College of American Pathologist's Q-probes study of 1,667,547 accessioned cases in 359 laboratories. Arch Pathol Lab Med 122:303-309 (Pubitemid 28169372)
31. Howlett DC, Harper B, Quante M, Berresford A, Morley M, Grant J, Ramesar K, Barnes S (2007) Diagnostic adequacy and accuracy of fine needle aspiration cytology in neck lump assessment: results from a regional cancer network over a one year period. J Laryngol Otol 121:571-579 (Pubitemid 46800183)
32. Layfield LJ (2007) Fine-needle aspiration in the diagnosis of head and neck lesions: a review and discussion of problems in differential diagnosis. Diagn Cytopathol 35:798-805
33. Tandon S, Shahab R, Benton JI, Ghosh SK, Sheard J, Jones TM (2008) Fine-needle aspiration cytology in a regional head and neck cancer center: comparison with a systematic review and meta-analysis. Head Neck 30:1246-1252
34. Zhang S, Bao R, Bagby J, Abreo F (2009) Fine needle aspiration of salivary glands: 5-year experience from a single academic center. Acta Cytol 53:375-382
35. Wu M (2010) A comparative study of 200 head and neck FNAs performed by a cytopathologist with versus without ultrasound guidance: evidence for improved diagnostic value with ultrasound guidance. Diagn Cytopathol (in press)
36. Ganguly A, Giles TE, Smith PA, White FE, Nixon PP (2010) The benefits of on-site cytology with ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration cytology in a one-stop neck lump clinic. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 92:660-664
37. Ferlito A, Boccato P, Shaha AR, Carbone A, Noyek AM, Doglioni C, Bradley PJ, Rinaldo A (2001) The art of diagnosis in head and neck tumors. Acta Otolaryngol 121:324-328 (Pubitemid 32472984)
38. Raab SS, Grzybicki DM, Mahood LK, Parwani AV, Kuan SF, Rao UN (2008) Effectiveness of random and focused review in detecting surgical pathology error. Am J Clin Pathol 130:905-912
39. Trotter MJ, Bruecks AK (2003) Interpretation of skin biopsies by general pathologists: diagnostic discrepancy rate measured by blinded review. Arch Pathol Lab Med 127:1489-1492 (Pubitemid 37370398)
40. Layfield LJ, Anderson GM (2010) Specimen labeling errors in surgical pathology: an 18-month experience. Am J Clin Pathol 134:466-470
41. Woolgar JA, Triantafyllou A (2009) Pitfalls and procedures in the histological diagnosis of oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma and a review of the role of pathology in prognosis. Oral Oncol 45:361-385
42. Attanoos RL, Bull AD, Douglas-Jones AG, Fligelstone LJ, Semararo D (1996) Phraseology in pathology reports. A comparative study of interpretation among pathologists and surgeons. J Clin Pathol 49:79-81 (Pubitemid 26034151)
43. Powsner SM, Costa J, Homer RJ (2000) Clinicians are from Mars and pathologists are from Venus. Arch Pathol Lab Med 124:1040-1046
44. Silcocks P, Page M (2001) What constitutes a histological confirmation of cancer? A survey of terminology interpretation in two English regions. J Clin Pathol 54:246-248 (Pubitemid 32205050)
45. Partham DM (2005) Are external quality assurance (EQA) slide schemes a valid tool for the performance assessment of histopathologists? Pathol Res Pract 201:117-121
46. MacDonald N, Attaran A (2009) Medical errors, apologies and apology laws. CMAJ 180:11-13
47. Wei M (2007) Doctors, apologies, and the law: an analysis and critique of apology laws. J Health Law 40:107-159
48. Frable WI (2006) Surgical pathology - second reviews, institutional reviews, audits, and correlations. What's out there? Error or diagnostic variant? Arch Pathol Lab Med 30:620-625
49. Troxel DB (2006) Medicolegal aspects of error in pathology. Arch Pathol Lab Med 130:617-619
50. Wick MR (2007) Medicolegal liability in surgical pathology: a consideration of underlying causes and selected pertinent concepts. Semin Diagn Pathol 24:89-97
51. Epstein JI (2001) Pathologists and the judicial process: how to avoid it. Am J Surg Pathol 25:527-537
52. Martello J (1999) Basic medical legal principles. Clin Plast Surg 26:9-14
53. Gilbert FJ, Cordiner CM, Affleck IR, Hood DB, Mathieson D, Walker LG (1998) Breast screening: the psychological sequelae of false-positive recall in women with and without a family history of breast cancer. Eur J Cancer 34:2010-2014 (Pubitemid 28546933)
54. Aro AR, Pilvikki Absetz S, van Elderen TM, van der Ploeg E, van der Kamp LJ (2000) False-positive findings in mammography screening induces short-term distress - breast cancer-specific concern prevails longer. Eur J Cancer 36:1089-1097 (Pubitemid 30330906)
55. Brewer NT, Salz T, Lillie SE (2007) Systematic review: the long-term effects of false-positive mammograms. Ann Intern Med 146:502-510 (Pubitemid 351650559)
56. Felton JS (1998) Burnout as a clinical entity - its importance in health care workers. Occup Med (Lond) 48:237-250
57. Sharma A, Sharp DM, Walker LG, Monson JR (2008) Stress and burnout in colorectal and vascular surgical consultants working in the UK National Health Service. Psychooncology 17:570-576
58. Demirci S, Yildirim YK, Ozsaran Z, Uslu R, Yalman D, Aras AB (2010) Evaluation of burnout syndrome in oncology employees. Med Oncol 27:968-974
59. Raab SS, Grzybicki DM (2010) Quality in cancer diagnosis. CA Cancer J Clin 60:139-165
60. Novis DA (2004) Detecting and preventing the occurrence of errors in the practices of laboratory medicine and anatomic pathology: 15 years' experience with the College of American Pathologists' Q-PROBES and Q-TRACKS programs. Clin Lab Med 24:965-978