Can general practitioners identify people with distress and mild depression? A meta-analysis of clinical accuracy

Journal of Affective Disorders

Volumn 130, Issue 1-2, 2011, Pages 26-36

  Mitchell, Alex J ^a,b   Rao, Sanjay ^a   Vaze, Amol ^a  

^a LEICESTER GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

^b LEICESTER ROYAL INFIRMARY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Distress; Mild depression; Minor depression; Primary care; Recognition

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BAYES THEOREM; DATA ANALYSIS; DEPRESSION; DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY; DIAGNOSTIC TEST ACCURACY STUDY; DISEASE SEVERITY; DISTRESS SYNDROME; ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORD; GENERAL HEALTH QUESTIONNAIRE; GENERAL PRACTITIONER; HOSPITAL ANXIETY AND DEPRESSION SCALE; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; MOOD DISORDER; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PREDICTIVE VALUE; PREVALENCE; PRIMARY MEDICAL CARE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUESTIONNAIRE; RATING SCALE; RECEIVER OPERATING CHARACTERISTIC;

BAYES THEOREM; CLINICAL COMPETENCE; DEPRESSION; DEPRESSIVE DISORDER; DIAGNOSTIC ERRORS; GENERAL PRACTITIONERS; HUMANS; STRESS, PSYCHOLOGICAL;

EID: 79953215613     PISSN: 01650327     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jad.2010.07.028     Document Type: Article

References (107)

1. R.T. Ackermann, and J.W. Williams Rational treatment choices for non-major depressions in primary care: An evidence-based review J Gen Intern Med 17 2002 293 301 (Pubitemid 34415688)
2. American Psychiatric Association DSM-IV: Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 4th ed. 1994 Author Washington, DC
3. M. Backenstrass, A. Frank, K. Joest, S. Ingmann, C. Mundt, and K. Kronmüller A comparative study of nonspecific depressive symptoms and minor depression regarding functional impairment and associated characteristics in primary care Compr Psychiatry 47 1 2006 35 41 (Pubitemid 41736148)
4. M. Backenstrass, K. Joest, and T. Rosemann The care of patients with subthreshold depression in primary care: Is it all that bad? A qualitative study on the views of general practitioners and patients BMC Health Services Research 7 190 2007
5. T. Bell, M. Watson, and D. Sharp Factors associated with being a false positive on the General Health Questionnaire Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 40 5 2005 402 407 (Pubitemid 40753669)
6. J.E. Bosmans, M.L.M. Hennens, and M.C. de Bruijne Cost-effectiveness of usual general practitioner care with or without antidepressant medication for patients with minor or mild-major depression Journal of Affective Disorders 11 1 2008 106 112
7. D.S. Brody, A.A. Khaliq, and T.L. Thompson Patients' perspectives on the management of emotional distress in primary care settings J Gen Intern Med 12 7 1997 403 406 (Pubitemid 27300555)
8. E.P.M. Brouwers, B.G. Tiemens, and B. Terluin Effectiveness of an intervention to reduce sickness absence in patients with emotional distress or minor mental disorders: A randomized controlled effectiveness trial General Hospital Psychiatry 28 3 2006 223 229 (Pubitemid 44308093)
9. B.D. Bultz, B.C. Thomas, D.A. Stewart, and L.E. Carlson Distress-The sixth vital sign in cancer care: Implications for treating older adults undergoing chemotherapy Geriatrics and Aging 10 10 2007 647 653 (Pubitemid 350246511)
10. J. Bushnell Frequency of consultations and general practitioner recognition of psychological symptoms British Journal of General Practice 508 2004 838 842 (Pubitemid 40003833)
11. H. Chung, J. Teresi, and P. Guarnaccia Depressive symptoms and psychiatric distress in low income Asian and Latino primary care patients: Prevalence and recognition Community Mental Health Journal 39 1 2003 33 46 (Pubitemid 38084994)
12. J.C. Coyne, and T.L. Schwenk The relationship of distress to mood disturbance in primary care and psychiatric populations Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 65 1 1997 161 168 (Pubitemid 27086146)
13. P. Cuijpers, and F. Smit Subthreshold depression as a risk indicator for major depressive disorder: A systematic review of prospective studies Acta Psychiatr Scand 109 2004 325 331 (Pubitemid 38491278)
14. P. Cuijpers, R. De Graaf, and S. Van Dorsselaer Minor depression: Risk profiles, functional disability, health care use and risk of developing major depression J Affect Disord 79 2004 71 79 (Pubitemid 38340531)
15. P. Cuijpers, F. Smit, and A. van Straten Psychological treatments of subthreshold depression: A meta-analytic review Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 115 6 2007 434 441 (Pubitemid 46733702)
16. M.W.M. de Waal, I.A. Arnold, P. Spinhoven, J.A.H. Eekhof, and A.M. van Hemert The reporting of specific physical symptoms for mental distress in general practice Journal of Psychosomatic Research 59 2005 89 95 (Pubitemid 41375979)
17. L.R. Derogatis SCL-90-R, administration, scoring, and procedures manual for the revised version 1977 Johns Hopkins University, School of Medicine Baltimore
18. L.R. Derogatis Symptom Checklist-90-R: Administration, scoring, and procedures manual 3rd ed. 1994 Minneapolis (MN)7 National Computer Systems
19. Y. Forsell A three-year follow-up of major depression, dysthymia, minor depression and subsyndromal depression: Results from a population-based study Depress Anxiety 24 1 2007 62 65 (Pubitemid 46278681)
20. T.A. Furukawa, R. Yoshimura, H. Harai, T. Imaizumi, H. Takeuchi, T. Kitamura, and K. Takahashi How many well vs. unwell days can you expect over 10 years, once you become depressed? Acta Psychiatr Scand 119 4 2009 290 297 Apr
21. J. Gellatly, P. Bower, and S. Hennessy What makes self-help interventions effective in the management of depressive symptoms? Meta-analysis and meta-regression Psychological Medicine 37 9 2007 1217 1228 (Pubitemid 47244852)
22. D. Goldberg A classification of psychological distress for use in primary care settings Social Science & Medicine 35 2 1992 189 193
23. D.P. Goldberg, and P. Williams The User's Guide to the General Health Questionnaire 1 ed 1988 NFER-NELSON Windsor
24. D.P. Goldberg, R. Gater, N. Sartorius, T.B. Ustun, M. Piccinelli, O. Gureje, and C. Rutter The validity of two versions of the GHQ in the WHO study of mental illness in general health care Psychological Medicine 27 1997 191 197 (Pubitemid 27042731)
25. J. Greer, R. Halgin, and E. Harvey Global versus specific symptom attributions: Predicting the recognition and treatment of psychological distress in primary care Journal of Psychosomatic Research 57 6 2004 521 527 (Pubitemid 39642890)
26. R. Gross, S. Brammli-Greenberg, and H. Tabenkin Primary care physicians' discussion of emotional distress and patient satisfaction International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine 37 3 2007 331 345
27. R. Gross, H. Tabenkin, and S. Brammli-Greenberg The association between inquiry about emotional distress and women's satisfaction with their family physician: Findings from a national survey Women & Health 45 1 2007 51 67
28. D.M. Haller, L.A. Sanci, S.M. Sawyer, and G.C. Patton The identification of young people's emotional distress: a study in primary care Br J Gen Pract 2009 e61 e70
29. R.R. Hausam, M. Rigdon, and N.S. Anderson The psychological vital sign: Implementation of a computerized psychological distress assessment tool in primary care Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association 1998 1011-1011 Supplement: S
30. A. Hemmings Counselling in primary care: A randomised controlled trial Patient Education and Counseling 32 3 1997 219 230 (Pubitemid 27489363)
31. M.L. Hermens, H.P. van Hout, B. Terluin, D.A. van der Windt, A.T. Beekman, R. van Dyck, and M. de Haan The prognosis of minor depression in the general population: A systematic review Gen Hosp Psychiatry 26 6 2004 453 462 Nov-Dec (Pubitemid 39573323)
32. M.L.M. Hermens, H.P.J. Van Hout, and B. Terluin Clinical effectiveness of usual care with or without antidepressant medication for primary care patients with minor or mild-major depression: A randomized equivalence trial BMC Medicine 5 2007 36
33. R. Hirschfeld, M.B. Keller, and S. Panico The National Depressive and Manic-Depressive Association consensus statement on the undertreatment of depression JAMA 277 1997 333 340 (Pubitemid 27045015)
34. L. Irwig, P. Macaskill, P. Glasziou, and M. Fahey Meta-analytic methods for diagnostic test accuracy J Clin Epi 48 1995 119 130
35. J.L. Jackson, M. Passamonti, and K. Kroenke Outcome and impact of mental disorders in primary care at 5 years Psychosomatic Medicine 69 2007 270 276 (Pubitemid 46653080)
36. S.F. Jencks Recognition of mental distress and diagnosis of mental disorder in primary care JAMA 253 13 1985 1903 1907 (Pubitemid 15106541)
37. L.L. Judd, M.H. Rapaport, M.P. Paulus, and J.L. Brown Subsyndromal symptomatic depression: A new mood disorder? Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 55 Suppl. 1994 18 28 (Pubitemid 24135964)
38. D. Kessler, K. Lloyd, G. Lewis, and D. Pereira Gray Cross sectional study of symptom attribution and recognition of depression: An anxiety in primary care British Medical Journal 318 1999 436 440 (13 February) (Pubitemid 29192118)
39. R.C. Kessler, G. Andrews, L.J. Colpe, E. Hiripi, D.K. Mroczek, and S.L. Normand Short screening scales to monitor population prevalences and trends in non-specific psychological distress Psychological Medicine 32 2002 959 976
40. R.C. Kessler, K.R. Merikangas, and P. Berglund Mild disorders should not be eliminated from the DSM-V Arch Gen Psychiatry 60 2003 1117 1122 (Pubitemid 37429651)
41. R.C. Kessler, P.R. Barker, L.J. Colpe, J.F. Epstein, J.C. Gfroerer, E. Hiripi, M.J. Howes, S.L. Normand, R.W. Manderscheid, E.E. Walters, and A.M. Zaslavsky Screening for serious mental illness in the general population Arch Gen Psychiatry 60 2 2003 184 189 Feb (Pubitemid 36173125)
42. J. Klapow, K. Kroenke, and T. Horton Psychological disorders and distress in older primary care patients: A comparison of older and younger samples Psychosomatic Medicine 64 2002 635 643 (Pubitemid 34791167)
43. A.J. Lang Mental health treatment preferences of primary care patients Journal of Behavioral Medicine 28 6 2005 581 586 (Pubitemid 43289628)
44. C.-F. Liu, D.G. Campbell, and E.F. Chaney Depression diagnosis and antidepressant treatment among depressed VA primary care patients Administration and Policy in Mental Health 33 3 2006 331 341 (Pubitemid 43863388)
45. B. Löwe, U. Schulz, K. Gräfe, and S. Wilke Medical patients' attitudes toward emotional problems and their treatment: What do they really want? Journal of General Internal Medicine 21 1 2006 39 45
46. J.M. Lyness, M. Heo, and C.J. Datto Outcomes of minor and subsyndromal depression among elderly patients in primary care settings Ann Intern Med 144 2006 496 504 (Pubitemid 46780672)
47. Petra Macaskill, Paul Glasziou, and Les Irwig Meta-analysis of diagnostic tests Peter Armitage, Theodore Colton, Encyclopedia of biostatistics 2nd edition 2005
48. K.M. Magruder, and D.E. Yeager Screening for depression in primary care: Can it become more efficient? A. Mitchell, J Coyne, Screening for depression in clinical practice: A Practical guide to the detection and diagnosis of mood disorders in primary & secondary care 2009 Oxford University Press SBN13: 9780195380194ISBN10: 0195380193
49. Zofia Makowska, Dorota Merecz, and Agnieszka Moscicka The validity of general health questionnaires, GHQ-12 and GHQ-28, in mental health studies of working people Int J Occup Med Environ Health 15 4 2002 353 362 (Pubitemid 36055186)
50. L. McCall, D. Clarke, and T. Trauer Predictors of accuracy of recognition of emotional distress in genral practise Primary Care and Community Psychiatry 12 1 2007 1 5
51. L. McCall, D. Clarke, and T. Trauer Predictors of accuracy of recognition of emotional distress in general practice Primary Care and Community Psychiatry 12 1 2007 1 5
52. D.S. Memel, J.R. Kirwan, D.J. Sharp, and M. Hehir General practitioners miss disability and anxiety as well as depression in their patients with The British Journal of General Practice 50 2000 645 648 (Pubitemid 30628036)
53. T. Meyer, H. Klemme, and C. Herrmann Depression but not anxiety is a significant predictor of physicians' assessments of medical status in physically ill patients Psychother Psychosom 69 2000 147 154 (Pubitemid 30223585)
54. A.S. Midgette, T.A. Stukel, and B. Littenberg A Meta-analytic method for summarising diagnostic test performance: receiver operating characteristic summary point estimates Med Dec Making 13 1993 253 257 (Pubitemid 23199345)
55. A.J. Mitchell Reluctance to disclose difficult diagnoses: A narrative review comparing communication by psychiatrists and oncologists Supportive Care in Cancer 15 7 2007 819 828 JUL (Pubitemid 47387511)
56. A.J. Mitchell, A. Vaze, and S. Rao Clinical diagnosis of depression in primary care Lancet 374 9690 2009 609 619
57. R.T. Mulder An epidemic of depression or the medicalization of distress? Perspect Biol Med 51 2 2008 238 250 (Pubitemid 351669577)
58. NCCN Clinical Practice Guidelines in Oncology Distress Management V.1.2007. http://www.nccn.org/professionals/physician-gls/PDF/distress.pdf
59. NICE Depression (amended): Management of depression in primary and secondary care (NICE guideline CG90) 2009 National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence
60. A.C. Nielsen, and T.A. Williams Depression in ambulatory medical patients AGP 37 1980 999 1004
61. D.W. O'Conner, R. Rosewarne, and A. Bruce Depression in primary care 2: General practioners' recognition of major depression in elderly patients Int Psychogeratrics 13 3 2001 367 374 (Pubitemid 33101675)
62. M. Olfson, T. Gilbert, M. Weissman, R.S. Blacklow, and W.E. Broadhead Recognition of emotional distress in physically healthy primary care patients who perceive poor physical health General Hospital Psychiatry 17 1995 173 180
63. J. Ormel, W. Van Den Brink, and M.W.J. Koeter Recognition, management and outcome of psychological disorders in primary care: A naturalistic follow-up study Psychol Med 20 1990 909 923
64. K. Ostler, C. Thompson, A.L. Kinmonth, R.C. Peveler, L. Stevens, and A. Stevens Influence of socio-economic deprivation on the prevalence and outcome of depression in primary care: The Hampshire Depression Project Br J Psychiatry 178 2001 12 17 (Pubitemid 32055639)
65. M. Pai, M. McCulloch, W. Enanoria, and J.M. Colford Systematic reviews of diagnostic test evaluations: What's behind the scenes? Evidence-Based Medicine 9 2004 101 103 (Pubitemid 39144554)
66. S.C. Palmer, and J.C. Coyne Screening for depression in medical care-Pitfalls, alternatives, and revised priorities Journal of Psychosomatic Research 54 4 2003 279 287 (Pubitemid 38365989)
67. E. Perez Stable, J. Miranda, and R.F. Munoz Depression in medical outpatients: Underrecognition and misdiagnosis Archives of Internal Medicine 150 1990 1083 1088 (Pubitemid 20155335)
68. H.A. Pincus, W.W. Davis, and L. McQueen Subthreshold" mental disorders: A review and synthesis of studies on minor depression and other "brand names The British Journal of Psychiatry 174 1999 288 296 (Pubitemid 29179710)
69. M. Preisig, K.R. Merikangas, and J. Angst Clinical significance and comorbidity of subthreshold depression and anxiety in the community Acta Psychiatr Scand 104 2001 96 103 (Pubitemid 32656084)
70. M.A. Prins, P.F.M. Verhaak, J.M. Bensing, and K. van der Meer Health beliefs and perceived need for mental health care of anxiety and depression-The patients' perspective explored Clinical Psychology Review 28 6 2008 1038 1058
71. J.J. Prisciandaro, and J.E. Roberts A taxometric investigation of unipolar depression in the national comorbidity survey Journal of Abnormal Psychology 114 4 2005 718 728 (Pubitemid 41747007)
72. J. Rabinowitz, D. Shayevitz, and T. Hornik Primary care physicians' detection of psychological distress among elderly patients American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 13 9 2005 773 780
73. S. Redman, G.R. Webb, D.J. Hennrikus, J.J. Gordon, and R.W. Sanson-Fisher The effects of gender on diagnosis of psychological disturbance J Beh Med 14 1991 527 540
74. M. Ritsner, I. Modai, and A. Ponizovsky Assessing psychological distress in psychiatric patients: Validation of the Talbieh Brief Distress Inventory Comprehensive Psychiatry 43 3 2002 229 234 (Pubitemid 34507473)
75. P. Rocca, P. Calvarese, and F. Faggiano Citalopram versus sertraline in late-life nonmajor clinically significant depression: A 1-year follow-up clinical trial The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 66 3 2005 360 369 (Pubitemid 40476760)
76. E. Rosenberg, M.-T. Lussier, and C. Beaudoin Determinants of the diagnosis of psychological problems by primary care physicians in patients with normal GHQ-28 scores General Hospital Psychiatry 24 2002 322 327 (Pubitemid 36151668)
77. J.T. Ross, T. TenHave, and A.C. Eakin A randomized controlled trial of a close monitoring program for minor depression and distress Journal of General Internal Medicine 23 9 2008 1379 1385 SEP
78. J.T. Ross, T. TenHave, and A.C. Eakin A randomized controlled trial of a close monitoring program for minor depression and distress Journal of General Internal Medicine 23 9 2008 1379 1385
79. A.J. Roth, A.B. Kornblith, and L. Batel-Copel Rapid screening for psychologic distress in men with prostate carcinoma: A pilot study Cancer 82 1998 1904 1908 (Pubitemid 28208646)
80. K. Rudell, K. Bhui, and S. Priebe Do 'alternative' help-seeking strategies affect primary care service use? A survey of help-seeking for mental distress BMC Public Health 8 2008 207
81. A. Saltini, M.A. Mazzi, L. Del Piccolo, and C. Zimmermann Decisional strategies for the attribution of emotional distress in primary care Psychological Medicine 34 4 2004 729 739 (Pubitemid 38735466)
82. B. Saraceno, F. Laviola, and E. Sternai Consequences of mental distress recognition in general-practice in Italy-A follow-up-study Social Science & Medicine 39 6 1994 789 796 (Pubitemid 24241500)
83. N. Schmitz, J. Kruse, and W. Tress Psychometric properties of the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-12) in a German primary care sample Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 100 16 1999 462 468
84. N. Schmitz, J. Kruse, and C. Heckrath Diagnosing mental disorders in primary care: The General Health Questionnaire (GHQ) and the Symptom Check List (SCL-90-R) as screening instruments Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 34 7 1999 360 366 (Pubitemid 29396513)
85. N. Schmitz, J. Kruse, C. Heckrath, L. Alberti, and W. Tress Diagnosing mental disorders in primary care: The General Health Questionnaire (GHQ) and the Symptom Check List (SCL-90-R) as screening instruments Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 34 1999 360 366 (Pubitemid 29396513)
86. T.L. Schwenk, M.S. Klinkman, and J.C. Coyne Depression in the family physician's office: What the psychiatrist needs to know: The Michigan Depression Project The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 59 Suppl 20 1998 94 100 (Pubitemid 29001833)
87. K.R. Seelert, R.D. Hill, and M.A. Rigdon Measuring patient distress in primary care Fam Med 31 7 1999 483 487
88. G.E. Simon, and M. VonKorff Recognition, management, and outcomes of depression in primary care Arch Fam Med 4 2 1995 99 105 Feb
89. D. Skuse, and P. Williams Screening for psychiatric disorder in general practice Psychol Med 14 1984 365 377 (Pubitemid 14042396)
90. P. Smith The role of the general health questionnaire in general practice consultations The British Journal of General Practice 48 1998 1565 1569 (Pubitemid 28434762)
91. A.M. Stirling, P. Wilson, and A. McConnachie Deprivation, psychological distress, and consultation length in general practice The British Journal of General Practice 51 2001 456 460 (Pubitemid 32509646)
92. The Magpie Research Group General practitioner recognition of mental illness in the absence of a gold standard The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 38 2004 789 794
93. B.G. Tiemens, M. VonKorff, and E.H. Lin Diagnosis of depression by primary care physicians versus a structured diagnostic interview. Understanding discordance Gen Hosp Psychiatry 21 2 1999 87 96 (Pubitemid 29200429)
94. T.B. Ustun, and M. Von Korff Primary mental health services T.B. Ustun, N. Sartorius, Mental Illness in General Health Care: An International Study 1995 John Wiley & Sons Chichester, UK 347 360
95. M. Van der Pasch, and P.F.M. Veerhak Communication in general practice: Recognition and treatment of mental illness Patient Education and Counseling 33 1998 97 112 (Pubitemid 28090058)
96. D.J.F. Van Schaik, A.F.J. Klijn, H.P.J. Van Hout, H.W.J. Van Marwijk, A.T.F. Beekman, M. De Haan, and R. Van Dyck Patients' preferences in the treatment of depressive disorder in primary care General Hospital Psychiatry 26 3 2004 184 189 (Pubitemid 38581923)
97. E. van't Hof, P. Cuijpers, and D.J. Stein Self-help and internet-guided interventions in depression and anxiety disorders: A systematic review of meta-analyses CNS Spectrums 14 2 2009 34 40
98. P.F.M. Verhaak, F.G. Schellevis, J. Nuijen, and A.C. Volkers Patients with a psychiatric disorder in general practice: Determinants of general practitioners' psychological diagnosis General Hospital Psychiatry 28 2 2006 125 132 (Pubitemid 43324674)
99. M. Von Korff, S. Shapiro, and J.D. Burke Anxiety and depression in a primary care clinic Arch Gen Psychiatry 44 1987 152 156
100. H.R. Wagner, B.J. Burns, W.E. Broadhead, K.S.H. Yarnall, A. Sigmon, and B.N. Gaynes Minor depression in family practice: Functional morbidity, co-morbidity, service utilization and outcomes Psychological Medicine 30 6 2000 1377 1390
101. K. Walters, M. Buszewicz, S. Weich, and M. King Help-seeking preferences for psychological distress in primary care: Effect of current mental state Br J Gen Pract 58 555 2008 694 698
102. R.B. Weisberg, I. Dyck, L. Culpepper, and M.B. Keller Psychiatric treatment in primary care patients with anxiety disorders: A comparison of care received from primary care providers and psychiatrists Am J Psychiatry 164 2007 276 282
103. M.M. Weissman, Y. Neria, and M.J. Gameroff Positive screens for psychiatric disorders in primary care: A long-term follow-up of patients who were not in treatment Psychiatr Serv 61 2 2010 151 159 February 1
104. K. Wells, C. Sherbourne, and N. Duan Quality improvement for depression in primary care: Do patients with subthreshold depression benefit in the long run? American Journal of Psychiatry 162 6 2005 1149 1157 (Pubitemid 40770698)
105. K.B. Wells, M. Schoenbaum, and N. Duan Cost-effectiveness of quality improvement programs for patients with subthreshold depression or depressive disorder Psychiatric Services 58 10 2007 1269 1278 (Pubitemid 350043576)
106. G. Wilkinson, and A.C. Markus Validation of a computerized assessment (PROQSY) of minor psychological morbidity by relative operating characteristic analysis Psychol Med 19 1989 225 231 (Pubitemid 19100283)
107. H.U. Wittchen, R.C. Kessler, and K. Beesdo Generalized anxiety and depression in primary care: Prevalence, recognition, and management J Clin Psychiatry 63 suppl 8 2002 24 34 (Pubitemid 34535254)