After paradim: Why mixing-methodology theorising fails and how to make it work again

Journal of the Operational Research Society

Volumn 62, Issue 4, 2011, Pages 784-798

  Zhu, Z ^a,b,c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF HULL   (United Kingdom)

^b JAPAN ADVANCED INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY   (Japan)

^c SOUTH CHINA NORMAL UNIVERSITY   (China)

Author keywords

methodology; ontological flexibility; paradigm; pragmatism

Indexed keywords

MIXING; PHILOSOPHICAL ASPECTS;

ACTION-ORIENTED; INTELLECTUAL INNOVATIONS; METHODOLOGY; ONTOLOGICAL FLEXIBILITY; PARADIGM; PRAGMATISM;

ONTOLOGY;

EID: 79952428889     PISSN: 01605682     EISSN: 14769360     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1057/jors.2010.31     Document Type: Article

References (128)

1. Alvesson M and Deetz S (1996). Critical theory and postmodernist approaches to organisational studies. In: Clegg SR, Hardy C and Nord WR (eds). Handbook of Organisation Studies. Wiley: New York, pp 191-217.
2. Alvesson M and Willmott H (1996). Making Sense of Management: A Critical Introduction. Sage: London.
3. Argyris C (1999). On Organisational Learning. Blackwell: Oxford.
4. Argyris C and Schon D (1974). Theories in Practice. Jossey-Bass: San Francisco, CA.
5. Bhaskar R (1978). A Realist Theory of Science. Harvester: Hemel Hempstead.
6. Bhaskar R (1979). The Possibility of Naturalism. Harvester Press: Sussex.
7. Bennett P, Ackermann F, Eden C and Williams T (1997). Analysing litigation and negotiation: Using combined methodology. In: Mingers J and Gill A (eds). Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies.Wiley: Chichester, pp 59-88.
8. Boothroyd H (1978). Articulate Intervention: The Interface of Science, Mathematics and Administration. Taylor and Francis: London.
9. Bowen K (1998). Some thoughts on multimethodology. Syst Pract Act Res 11: 169-177. (Pubitemid 128404999)
10. Brocklesby J (1995). Intervening in the cultural constitution of systems-methodological complementarism and other visions for systems research. J Opl Res Soc 46: 1285-1298.
11. Brocklesby J (1997). Becoming multimethodology literate: An assessment of the cognitive difficulties of working across paradigms. In: Mingers J and Gill A (eds). Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies. Wiley: Chichester, pp 189-216.
12. Burrell G and Morgan G (1979). Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis. Heinemann: London.
13. Callon M (1986). Some elements of a sociology of translation: Domestication of the scallops and fishermen of St. Brieuc Bay.Law J (ed). Power, Action and Belief: A New Sociology of Knowledge? Routledge: London, p. 196-233.
14. Checkland's PB (1981). Systems Thinking, Systems Practice. Wiley: Chichester.
15. Checkland PB and Holwell S (2004). 'Classic' OR and 'soft' OR - an asymmetric complementarity. In: Pidd M (ed). Systems Modelling: Theory and Practice. Wiley: Chichester, pp 43-60.
16. Chia R (1997). Thirty years on: From organisational structures to the organisation of thought. Org Stud 18: 685-707. (Pubitemid 127345468)
17. Chia R (2003). Ontology: Organisation as 'World-making'. In: Westwood R and Clegg S (eds). Debating Organisation: Point-Counterpoint in Organisation Studies. Blackwell: Oxford, pp 98-113.
18. Cohen MD, March JG and Olsen JP (1972). A garbage can model of organisational choice. Admin Sci Quart 17: 1-25.
19. Corbett CJ, Overmeer WJAM and Van Wassenhove LN (1995). Strands of practice in OR (The practitioner's dilemma). Eur J Opl Res 87: 484-499.
20. Czarniawska B (1998). Who is afraid of incommensurability? Organization 5: 273-275.
21. Czarniawska B (2003). Social constructionism and organisation studies. In:Westwood R and Clegg S (eds). Debating Organisation: Point-Counterpoint in Organisation Studies. Blackwell: Oxford, pp 128-139.
22. Deetz S (1996). Describing differences in approaches to organisation science: Rethinking Burrell and Morgan and their legacy. Org Sci 7: 191-207. (Pubitemid 126082423)
23. Dewey J (1925/1988). Experience and nature. In: Baydston JA (ed). The Later Works of John Dewey, 1925-53, Vol. 1: 1925. Southern Illinois University Press: Carbondale, IL.
24. Eden C and Sims D (1979). On the nature of problems in consulting practice. Omega 7: 119-127.
25. Eden C, Ackermann F, Bryson JM, Richardson GP, Andersen DF and Finn CB (2009). Integrating modes of policy analysis and strategic management practice: Requisite elements and dilemmas. J Opl Res Soc 60: 2-13.
26. Fine A (1986). The Shaky Game: Einstein, Realism, and the Quantum Theory. The University of Chicago Press: Chicago, IL.
27. Fine A (1991). Piecemeal realism. Philos Stud 61: 79-96.
28. Flood RL and Jackson MC (1991). Creative Problem Solving: Total Systems Intervention. Wiley: Chichester.
29. Foucault M (1977). Discipline and Punish. Pantheon: New York.
30. Foucault M (1980). Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972-1977. Gordon C (ed). Harvester Press: Brighton.
31. Gergen M (1998). Proliferating discourses: Resources for relationships. Organization 5: 277-280. (Pubitemid 128072912)
32. Gioia DA and Pitre E (1990). Multiparadigm perspectives on theory building. Acad Mngt Rev 15: 584-602.
33. Gomart E and Hennion A (1999). A sociology of attachment: Music amateurs drug users. In: Law J and Hassard J (eds). Actor Network Theory and After. Blackwell: Oxford.
34. Gregory WJ (1992). Critical systems thinking and pluralism: A new constellation. PhD thesis, City University, London.
35. Gregory WJ (1996). Discordant pluralism: A new strategy for critical systems thinking. Syst Pract 9: 605-625. (Pubitemid 126814787)
36. Habermas J (1972). Knowledge and Human Interests. Heinemann: London.
37. Habermas J (1984a). The Theory of Communicative Action, Volume One: Reason and the Rationalisation of Society. Polity Press: Cambridge.
38. Habermas J (1984b). The Theory of Communicative Action, Volume Two: The Critique of Foundationist Reason. Polity Press: Cambridge.
39. Hacking I (1999). The Social Construction of What? Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA.
40. Hassard J, Kelemen M and Cox JW (2008). Disorganisation Theory: Explorations in Alternative Organisational Analysis. Routledge: London.
41. Jackson MC (1987). Present positions and future prospects in management science. Omega 15: 455-466.
42. Jackson MC (1990). Beyond a system of systems methodologies. J Opl Res Soc 41: 657-668.
43. Jackson MC (1991). Systems Methodology for the Management Sciences. Plenum Press: New York.
44. Jackson MC (1993). Don't bite my finger: Haridimos Tsoukas' critical evaluation of total systems intervention. Syst Pract 6: 289-294.
45. Jackson MC (1999). Towards coherent pluralism in management science. J Opl Res Soc 50: 12-23.
46. Jackson MC (2000a). Systems Approaches to Management. Kluwer/Plenum: New York.
47. Jackson MC (2000b). A reply to Richard Ormerod. J Opl Res Soc 51: 884-886.
48. Jackson MC (2003). Systems Thinking: Creative Holism for Managers. Wiley: Chichester.
49. Jackson MC (2006a). John Mingers is a critical realist imperialist. J Opl Res Soc 57: 1370-1371. (Pubitemid 44652709)
50. Jackson MC (2006b). Creative holism: A critical systems approach to complex problem situations. Syst Res Behav Sci 23: 647-657.
51. Jackson MC (2006c). Beyond problem structuring methods: Reinventing the future of OR/MS. J Opl Res Soc 57: 868-878. (Pubitemid 43980374)
52. Jackson MC (2008). Evaluating systems thinking in housing. J Opl Res Soc 59: 186-197. (Pubitemid 351177309)
53. Jackson MC (2009). Managing the tensions created by mixing methods: Comments for Eden et al from a critical systems perspective. J Opl Res Soc 60: 1297-1299.
54. Jackson MC (2010). Reflections on the development and contribution of critical systems thinking and practice. Syst Res Behavl Sci 27: 133-139.
55. Jackson N and Carter P (1991). In defence of paradigm incommensurability. Org Stud 12: 109-127.
56. JamesW(1912/1967). A Pluralistic Universe. Peter Smith: Gloucester, MA.
57. James W (1912/1967). Essays in Radical Empiricism. Peter Smith: Gloucester, MA.
58. Kelemen M and Hassard J (2003). Paradigm plurality: Past, present, and future trends. In: Westwood R and Clegg S (eds). Debating Organisation: Point-Counterpoint in Organisation Studies. Blackwell: Oxford, pp 73-82.
59. Keys P (1997). Approaches to understanding the process of OR: Review, critique and extension. Omega 25: 1-13. (Pubitemid 127162900)
60. Keys P (1998). OR as technology revisited. J Opl Res Soc 49: 99-108.
61. Keys P (2006). On becoming expert in the use of problem structuring methods. J Opl Res Soc 57: 822-829. (Pubitemid 43980370)
62. Kotiadis K and Mingers J (2006). Combining PSMs with hard OR methods: The philosophical and practical challenges. J Opl Res Soc 57: 856-867. (Pubitemid 43980373)
63. Kuhn TS (1962). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. University of Chicago Press: Chicago.
64. Kuhn TS (1970). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 2nd edn. University of Chicago Press: Chicago.
65. Kukla A (2000). Social Constructivism and the Philosophy of Science. Routledge: London.
66. Latour B (1999). On recalling ANT. In: Law J and Hassard J (eds). Actor Network Theory and After. Blackwell: Oxford, pp 15-25.
67. Latour B (2002). Gabriel trade and the end of the social. In: Joyce PP (ed). The Social in Question: New Bearings in the History and the Social Sciences. Routledge: London, pp 117-132.
68. Latour B (2004). The Politics of Nature: How to Bring the Sciences into Democracy. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA.
69. Latour B (2005). Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor- Network-Theory. Oxford University Press: New York.
70. Law J (1991). A Sociology of Monsters: Essays on Power, Technology, and Domination. Routledge: London.
71. Law J (1992). Notes on the theory of the actor-network: Ordering, strategy, and heterogeneity. Syst Pract 5: 379-393.
72. Law J (1999). After ANT: Complexity, naming and topology. In: Law J and Hassard J (eds). Actor Network Theory and After. Blackwell: Oxford, pp 1-14.
73. Law J (2004). After Method: Mess in Social Science Research. Routledge: London.
74. Lee N and Stenner P (1999). Who pays? Can we pay them back? In: Law J and Hassard J (eds). Actor Network Theory and After. Blackwell: Oxford, pp 90-112.
75. Mahoney JT (1993). Strategic management and determinism: Sustaining the conversation. J Mngt Stud 30: 173-191.
76. Metcalfe M (2008). Pragmatic inquiry. J Opl Res Soc 59: 1091-1099.
77. Midgley G (1997a). Mixing methods: Developing systemic intervention. In: Mingers J and Gill A (eds). Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies. Wiley: Chichester, pp 249-290.
78. Midgley G (2000). Systemic Intervention: Philosophy, Methodology, and Practice. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers: New York.
79. Mingers J (1997a). Multi-paradigm mutlimethodology. In: Mingers J and Gill A (eds). Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies.Wiley: Chichester, pp 1-20.
80. Mingers J (1997b). Towards critical pluralism. In: Mingers J and Gill A (eds). Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies. Wiley: Chichester, pp 407-440.
81. Mingers J (2000). The contribution of critical realism as an underpinning philosophy for OR/MS and systems. J Opl Res Soc 51: 1256-1270. (Pubitemid 32017945)
82. Mingers J (2001). Multimethodology - mixing and matching methods. In: Rosenhead J and Mingers J (eds). Rational Analysis for a Problematic World Revisited. Wiley: Chichester, pp 289-309.
83. Mingers J (2003). A classification of the philosophical assumptions of management science methods. J Opl Res Soc 54: 559-570.
84. Mingers J (2005). 'More dangerous than an unanswered question is an unquestioned answer': A contribution to the Ulrich debate. J Opl Res Soc 56: 468-474. (Pubitemid 40424123)
85. Mingers J (2006). A critique of statistical modelling in management science from a critical realist perspective: Its role within multimethodology. J Opl Res Soc 57: 202-219. (Pubitemid 43149285)
86. Mingers J (2008). Management knowledge and knowledge management: Realism and forms of truth. Knowl Mngt Res Pract 6: 62-76.
87. Miser HJ (1988). Underlying concepts for systems and policy analysis. In: Miser HJ and Quade ES (eds). Handbook of Systems Analysis, Volume Two-Craft Issues and Procedural Choices. Wiley: Chichester, pp 467-525.
88. Mol A (1999). Ontological politics: A word and some questions. In: Law J and Hassard J (eds). Actor Network Theory and After. Blackwell: Oxford, pp 74-89.
89. Musgrave A (1980). Kuhn's second thoughts. In: Gutting G (ed). Paradigms and Revolutions: Applications and Appraisals of Thomas Kuhn's Philosophy of Science. University of Notre Dame Press: Notre Dame, pp 39-53.
90. Orlikowski W and Robey D (1991). Information technology and the structuring of organisations. Inf Syst Res 2(2): 143.
91. Ormerod RJ (1997). Mixing methods in practice: A transformationcompetence perspective. In: Mingers J and Gill A (eds) Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies, Wiley: Chichester, 29-58.
92. Ormerod RJ (2001). Mixing methods in practice. In: Rosenhead J and Mingers J (eds). Rational Analysis for a Problematic World Revisited: Problem Structuring Methods for Complexity, Uncertainty and Conflict. Wiley: Chichester, pp 311-336.
93. Ormerod RJ (2002). Should critical realism really be critical for OR? A comment on Mingers (2000): The contribution of critical realism as an underpinning philosophy for OR/MS and systems. J Opl Res Soc 53: 347-351. (Pubitemid 34434006)
94. Ormerod RJ (2006). The history and ideas of pragmatism. J Opl Res Soc 57: 892-909.
95. Ormerod RJ (2008). The transformation competence perspective. J Opl Res Soc 59: 1435-1448.
96. Ormerod RJ (2009). Articulate intervention revisited. J Opl Res Soc, advance online publication, 20 May, doi:10.1057/jors.2009.47.
97. Palmer I and Hardy C (2000). Thinking about Management. Sage: London.
98. Pidd M (2004a). Bringing it all together. In: Pidd M (ed). Systems Modelling: Theory and Practice. Wiley: Chichester, pp 197-207.
99. Pidd M (2004b). Complementarity in systems modelling. In: Pidd M (ed). Systems Modelling: Theory and Practice. Wiley: Chichester, pp 1-20.
100. Pollack J (2009). Multimethodology in series and parallel: Strategic planning using hard and soft OR. J Opl Res Soc 60: 156-167.
101. Reed M (1985). Redirections in Organisational Analysis. Routledge: London.
102. Rescher N (2000). Realistic Pragmatism: An Introduction to Pragmatic Philosophy. State University of New York Press: Albany, NY.
103. Rorty R (1979). Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature. Princeton University Press: Princeton.
104. Rorty R (1982). Consequences of Pragmatism. Harvester Press: Sussex.
105. Rouse J (1996). Engaging Science: How to Understand its Practices Philosophically. Cornell University Press: Ithaca, NY.
106. Scherer AG (1998). Pluralism and incommensurability in strategic management and organisation theory: A problem in search of a solution. Organisation 5: 147-168.
107. Scherer AG and Dowling MJ (1995). Towards a reconciliation of the theory-pluralism in strategic management - incommensurability and the constructivist approach of the Erlangen School. Adv in Strateg Mngt 12A: 195-247.
108. Scherer AG and Steinmann H (1999). Some remarks on the problem of incommensurability in organisation studies. Org Stud 20: 519-544.
109. Schon D (1983). The Reflective Practitioner. Temple Smith: London.
110. Schultz M and Hatch MJ (1996). Living with multiple paradigms: The case of paradigm interplay in organisational culture studies. Acad Mngt Rev 21: 529-557.
111. Stacey RD (2007). Strategic Management and Organisational Dynamics: The Challenge of Complexity. FT Prentice Hall: London.
112. Strathern M (1999). What is intellectual property after? In: Law J and Hassard J (eds). Actor Network Theory and After. Blackwell: Oxford, pp 156-180.
113. Sztompka P (1991). Society in Action: The Theory of Social Becoming. Polity Press: Cambridge.
114. Tsoukas H (1992). Panoptic reason and the search for totality: A critical assessment of the critical systems perspective. Hum Relat 45: 637-658.
115. Tsoukas H (1993a). 'By their fruits ye shall know them': A reply to Jackson, Green, and Midgley. Syst Pract 6: 311-317.
116. Tsoukas H (1993b). The road to emancipation is through organisational development: A critical evaluation of total systems intervention. Syst Pract 6: 53-70.
117. Tsoukas H (1998). The word and the world: A critique of representationalism in management research. Intl J Pub Admin 21: 781-817.
118. Ulrich W (2003). Beyond methodology choice: Critical systems thinking as critically systemic discourse. J Opl Res Soc 54: 325-342.
119. Ulrich W (2007). Philosophy for professionals: Towards critical pragmatism. J Opl Res Soc 58: 1109-1113. (Pubitemid 47150131)
120. Weaver G and Gioia D (1994). Paradigm lost: Incommensurability vs. structurationist inquiry. Org Sci 15: 590-655.
121. Westwood R and Clegg S (2003). The discourse of organisation studies: Dissensus, politics, and paradigms. In: Westwood R and Clegg S (eds). Debating Organisation: Point-Counterpoint in Organisation Studies. Blackwell: Oxford, pp 1-42.
122. White LA and Taket AR (1997). Critiquing multimethodology as metamethodology: Working towards pragmatic pluralism. In: Mingers J and Gill A (eds). Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies.Wiley: Chichester, pp 379-405.
123. Willmott H (1993). Breaking the paradigm mentality. Org Stud 14: 681-719.
124. Wittgenstein L (1953). Philosophical Investigations. Blackwell: Oxford, Basil.
125. Yolles M (1996). Critical systems thinking, paradigms, and the modelling space. Syst Pract 9: 549-570. (Pubitemid 126814784)
126. Yolles M (1999). Management Systems: A Viable Approach. Financial Times: London.
127. Zhu Z (2009). OR without ontology: A pragmatist critique of SSM. In: Cordoba-Pachon, J (ed). OR51 Keynote Papers. The OR Society: England, pp 90-112 (under review by J Opl Res Soc).
128. Zhu Z (2010). Knowledge of the natural and the social: How are they different and what do they have in common? Knowl Mngt Res Pract 8: 173-188.