An evaluation of the policy and techno-economic factors affecting the potential for biogas upgrading for transport fuel use in the UK

Energy Policy

Volumn 39, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 1806-1816

  Patterson, Tim ^a   Esteves, Sandra ^a   Dinsdale, Richard ^a   Guwy, Alan ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF GLAMORGAN   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Biogas; Biomethane; Upgrading

Indexed keywords

ADDITIONAL COSTS; BIOMETHANE; CHEMICAL ABSORPTION; COMBINED HEAT AND POWER; CRYOGENIC DISTILLATIONS; ECONOMIC ADVANTAGES; FINANCIAL INCENTIVES; LIMITING FACTORS; LIQUID BIOFUELS; LONG TERM; MAXIMUM VALUES; MEMBRANE SEPARATION; ORGANIC WASTES; PRESSURE SWING ADSORPTION; RAPID EXPANSION; ROAD TRANSPORTS; TECHNO-ECONOMICS; TRANSPORT FUEL; UPGRADING; WATER SCRUBBING;

ADSORPTION; ANAEROBIC DIGESTION; BIOGAS; DISTILLATION; FOSSIL FUELS; LIQUIDS; MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGY; SEWAGE; WATER ABSORPTION;

BIOFUELS;

ALTERNATIVE ENERGY; BIOGAS; ENERGY POLICY; FUEL; METHANE; RENEWABLE RESOURCE; ROAD TRANSPORT;

UNITED KINGDOM;

EID: 79952073544     PISSN: 03014215     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.enpol.2011.01.017     Document Type: Article

References (75)

1. Ackley M.W., Rege S.U., Saxena H. Application of natural zeolites in the purification and separation of gases. Microporous and Mesoporous Materials 2003, 61:25-42.
2. Alpay E., Haq N., Kershenbaum L.S., Kirkby N.F. Adsorption parameters for strongly adsorbed hydrocarbon vapours on some commercial adsorbents. Gas Separation and Purification 1996, 10(1):23-33.
3. Angelidaki I., Heinfelt A., Ellegaard L. Enhanced biogas recovery by applying post-digestion in large-scale centralized biogas plants. Water Science Technology 2006, 54(2):237-244.
4. Auer, S., Haulio, M., Lekawska, L. Sonnleitner, M., 2006. Life cycle assessment study, ethanol vs. biogas used as car fuels, Institute of Environmental Strategies Research, Sweden. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 07.10.2009). http://www.infra.kth.se/fms/utbildning/lca/projects%202006/Group%2010%20(Biofuels%20in%20cars).pdf.
5. Beil, M., 2009. Overview on biogas upgrading technologies. European Biomethane Fuel Conference, Goteborg, Sweden, Biogasmax. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 06.10.2009). http://www.biogasmax.eu/media/3t3_overview_on_upgrading_iset__062510600_0654_30092009.pdf.
6. Benjaminsson, J., 2006. NYA Renings Och Uppgraderingstekniker for Biogas, Swedish Gas Centre, Report 163. Available from 〈〉 (accessed on 24.07.2008). http://www.sgc.se/rapporter/resources/SGC163.pdf.
7. Berndt, A., 2006. CarboTech Engineering GmbH, Intelligent Utilisation of Biogas-Upgrading and Adding to the Grid. Jonkoping, May 2006. Available from 〈〉 (accessed on 18.07.2008). http://www.german-renewable-energy.com/Renewables/Redaktion/PDF/es/es-World-Bioenergy-2006-Carbotech-schulte-biogas,property=pdf,bereich=renewables,sprache=es,rwb=true.pdf.
8. Bolton, P., 2009. Petrol and Diesel Prices: SN/SG/4712. House of Commons Library. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 08.10.2009). http://www.parliament.uk/commons/lib/research/briefings/snsg-04712.pdf.
9. BP, 2009. BP statistical review of world energy. BP. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 20.10.2009). http://www.bp.com/liveassets/bp_internet/globalbp/globalbp_uk_english/reports_and_publications/statistical_energy_review_2008/STAGING/local_assets/2009_downloads/statistical_review_of_world_energy_full_report_2009.pdf.
10. Brown L. Ethanol could leave the world hungry. Fortune 2006.
11. Cavenati S., Grande C., Rodrigues A. Upgrade of methane from landfill gas by pressure swing adsorption. Energy and Fuels 2005, 19:2545-2555.
12. Cruz P., Magalhães F.D., Mendes A. On the optimization of cyclic adsorption separation processes. American Institute of Chemical Engineers Journal 2005, 51(5):1377-1395.
13. de Hullu, J., Maassen, J., van Meel, P., Siamak, S., Vaessen, J., Bini, L., Reijenga, J., 2008. Biogas Upgrading: Comparing Different Techniques, Eindhoven University of Technology. Available at 〈students.chem.tue.nl/ifp24/Final%20presenation.pps〉. Accessed on 19th September 2009.
14. DECC, 2009a. UK energy in brief, 2009. Published by the National Statistics Office. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 04.01.2009., Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC)). http://www.decc.gov.uk/en/content/cms/statistics/publications/brief/brief.aspx.
15. DECC, 2009b. Consultation on Renewable Electricity Financial Incentives 2009, Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC). Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 16.11.2009). http://www.decc.gov.uk/en/content/cms/consultations/elec_financial/elec_financial.aspx.
16. DENA, 2009. Executive Report: The German Market for Biomethane, Deutsche Energie-Agentur GmbH (DENA), German Energy Agency.
17. DVGW, 2000a. Deutsche Vereinigung des Gas und Wasserfaches e. V. (DVGW) Standard G260 "Gas Quality".
18. DVGW, 2000b. Deutsche Vereinigung des Gas und Wasserfaches e. V. (DVGW) Standard G262 Usage of gases from renewable sources in the public gas distribution.
19. European Parliament, 2003. The promotion of the use of biofuels or other renewable fuels for transport. Directive 2003/30/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council, May 2003. Official Journal of the European Union.
20. European Parliament, 2009a. Directive 2009/28/EC On the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources and amending and subsequently repealing Directives 2001/77/EC and 2003/30/EC. Official Journal of the European Union. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 23.09.2009), The European Parliament and Council of the European Union. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2009:140:0016:0062:EN:PDF.
21. European Parliament, 2009b. Directive 2009/30/EC amending Directive 98/70/EC as regards the specification of petrol, diesel and gas-oil and introducing a mechanism to monitor and reduce greenhouse gas emissions and amending Council Directive 1999/32/EC as regards the specification of fuel used by inland waterway vessels and repealing Directive 93/12/EEC. Official Journal of the European Union, The European Parliament and the Council of the European Union.
22. Eyler, D., 2009. Biomethane in Germany, Injection into the NG grid and Vehicle Fuel. EIFER-Europäisches Institut für Energieforschung/European Institute for Energy Research, Biogasmax. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 06.10.2009). http://www.biogasmax.eu/media/eifer__biomethane_in_germany__023022200_1136_24062009.pdf.
23. Fravolini, D., Proietti, S., 2009. Biogas use as fuel in waste collector captive fleet: the experience in the city of Rome, future plans. European Biomethane Fuel Conference. Goteburg, September 2009, BiogasMax.
24. Gallagher, E., 2008. The Galagher Review of the indirect effect of biofuels production, The Renewable Fuels Agency. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 17.11.2009). http://www.renewablefuelsagency.org/_db/_documents/Report_of_the_Gallagher_review.pdf.
25. Gas de France, 2007. Prescriptions techniques du distributeur Gaz de France., Gas de France. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 07.01.2010). http://www.biogasmax.co.uk/media/prescriptions_gaz_de_france__055742400_1047_05112008.pdf.
26. Gladstone, R.W., 2007. High-BTU Projects Using Pressure Swing Adsorption (PSA) Technology, Green Gas Energy LLC.
27. Günther, L., 2007. DGE GmbH Presentation: Purification of biomethane using pressureless purification for the production of biomethane and carbon dioxide. INNOGAS, Available from 〈〉 (accessed on 22.07.2008). http://www.dge-wittenberg.com/english/vortraege/DGE%20Fachtagung%20WB%202006%20teil1-EN.pdf.
28. Håkansson, A., 2006. Preventing microbial growth on pall rings when upgrading biogas using absorption with water wash, Swedish Biogas Centre, Report SGC166. Report available from 〈〉 (accessed on 18.07.2008). http://www.sgc.se/rapporter/resources/SGC166.pdf.
29. Hammer, M., Pettersson, K. Svensen, B., 2007. Guide to developing a local biogas strategy, for sustainable large-scale consumption and production in collaboration between town and countryside. BiogasMax Report Biogas as vehicle fuel-Market Expansion to 2020 Air Quality, Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 14.09.2009). http://www.medcoast.org/download/18.726a005111ed95650fa80002283/Guide+to+developing+a+local+biogas+strategy.pdf.
30. Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs (2007). BN53: Hydrocarbon Oil Duty: Rates, Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 22.09.2009.). http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/budget2007/bn53.htm.
31. IEA, 2005. IEA Bioenergy Task 37 Summary: Injection of biogas into the natural gas grid in Laholm, Sweden, Document available from 〈 〉(accessed on 21.07.2008). http://www.iea-biogas.net/Dokumente/casestudies/sucess_laholm.pdf.
32. 2 adsorption behaviours in pressure swing adsorption operation. Industrial and Engineering Chemical Research 1988, 27:1103-1109.
33. Jönsson, O., 2009. Biogas upgrading-Technologies, framework and experience. MicrophiloxProject Workshop, Barcelona, Spain 26th March 2009. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 14.09.2009). http://www.microphilox.com/pdf/OJonsson%20Natural%20gas%20grid%20injection.pdf.
34. 2 recovery using styrenic polymers. Industrial and Engineering Chemical Research 1993, 32:2365-2372.
35. Kroes, N., 2007. 04:I 2007 C(2007)8 State aid no. N 418/2006-United Kingdom, Renewable Transport Fuel Obligation (RTFO). Brussels, European Commission. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 01.02. 2009). http://ec.europa.eu/community_law/state_aids/comp-2006/n418-06.pdf.
36. Lehtomäki A., Huttunen S., Rintala J. Laboratory investigations on co-digestion of energy crops and crop residues with cow manure for methane production: Effect of crop to manure ratio. Resources, Conservation and Recycling 2007, 51:591-609.
37. Linsbod, 2005. "fuchs'nhof"-Austrias first feeding of upgraded biogas to the natural gas grid. Available on the IEA Task 37 website at 〈〉 (accessed on 17.07.2008). http://www.iea-biogas.net/casestudiesoperators.htm.
38. López J.M., Gómez A., Aparicio F., Sánchez J.F. Comparison of GHG emissions from diesel, biodiesel and natural gas refuse trucks of the City of Madrid. Applied Energy 2009, 86:610-615.
39. López J.M., Gomez A., Aparicio F., Sanchez J. Comparison of GHG emissions from diesel, biodiesel and natural gas refuse trucks of the City of Madrid. Applied Energy 2009, 86:610-615.
40. Lou H., Miyajima H., Dong F., Kodama A., Goto M., Hirose T. Experimental study of thermal phenomenon in PSA air dehumidification. Separation and Purification Technology 1999, 17:65-75.
41. Miltner, M., Makaruk, A. Harasek, M., 2008. Application of gas permeation for biogas upgrade-Operational experiences of feeding biomethane into the Austrian gas grid. 16th European Biomass Conference and Exhibition. Valencia, Spain.
42. Monson, K.D., Esteves, S.R., Guwy, A.J. Dinsdale, R.M., 2007. Anaerobic Digestion of Biodegradable municipal wastes: A Review, The Sustainable Environment Research Centre, University of Glamorgan. ISBN 978-1-84054-156-5.
43. Montauk Energy, 2008. Montauk Energy, Case Study: LFG to high Btu pipeline quality gas, McCarty Road Landfill, Houston, Texas, Available from 〈〉 (accessed on 23.07.2008). http://www.montaukenergy.com/mccarty.asp.
44. Murphy J.D., Power N. Technical and economic analysis of biogas production in Ireland utilising three different crop rotations. Applied Energy 2009, 86:25-36.
45. NSCA, 2006. Biogas as a road transport fuel. ISBN 978 0 903 47461 1.
46. Paavola T., Rintala J. Effects of storage on characteristics and hygienic quality of digestates from four co-digestion concepts of manure and biowaste. Bioresource Technology 2008, 99:7041-7050.
47. Patterson T., Dinsdale R.M., Esteves S.R. Review of energy balances and emissions associated with biomass based transport fuels relevant to the United Kingdom context. Energy and Fuels 2008, 22:3506-3512.
48. Persson, M., 2007. Biogas upgrading and utilisation as a vehicle fuel. Proceedings of The Future of Biogas in Europe III, University of Southern Denmark. Available from 〈〉 (accessed on 17.07.2008). http://websrv5.sdu.dk/bio/Probiogas/down/work07/Proceedings.pdf.
49. Persson M., Jönsson O., Wellinger A. Biogas upgrading to vehicle fuel standards and grid injection, IEA Bioenergy. Task 2006, 24.
50. Persson, M., Wellinger, A., 2006. Biogas upgrading to vehicle fuel standard and grid introduction, IEA Bioenergy.
51. Persson, M., Wellinger, A, Rehnlund, B., Rahm, L., 2007. Report on technological applicability of existing biogas upgrading processes. Biogasmax report del_3.1_STO_v3_final, Available from 〈〉 (accessed on 21.07.2008). http://www.biogasmax.co.uk/media/report_on_technological_2007__041639600_1025_22052007.pdf.
52. Petersson, A., 2008. Biogas as a Transport Fuel-Upgrading Technique and Application. Central European Biomass Conference 2008. Graz, Austria. Presentation available from 〈〉 (accessed on 17.07.2008). http://www.biomasseverband.at/static/mediendatenbank/root01/3.%20Veranstaltungen/3.2%25.
53. Petersson, A., Wellinger, A., 2009. Biogas upgrading technologies-developments and innovations, IEA Bioenergy. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 14.04.2010). http://www.iea-biogas.net/Dokumente/upgrading_rz_low_final.pdf.
54. QuestAir Technologies Inc, 2006. QuestAir Technologies Inc. Press Release-QuestAir demonstration plant at City of Vancouver landfill recovers methane from landfill gas. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 18.07.2008). http://www.questairinc.com/investor_relations/press_releases/archived_releases/2006/03-13.htm.
55. QuestAir Technologies Inc, 2007. QuestAir Technologies Inc. press release-QuestAir to supply methane recovery system for New Hampshire landfill gas-to-energy project. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 18.07.2008). http://www.questairinc.com/investor_relations/press_releases/archived_releases/2007/pdf/070904.pdf.
56. Renewable Energy Agency, 2009. UK biofuels sector unsettled by "error" in legislation. Bioenergy Business. Environmental Finance Publications, Available at the Renewable Energy Association website 〈〉. http://www.r-e-a.net/info/rea-news/REAinthePress/090107BioenergyBusiness/?searchterm=RTFO.
57. Renewable Fuels Agency, 2009. Quartery Report no. 4 15th April 2008-14th April 2009, Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 09.09.2009). http://www.renewablefuelsagency.org/_db/_documents/RFA_quarterly_report_Apr_2008_Apr_2009.pdf.
58. Sachs, I. (2008). The biofuels controversy. The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development. UNCTAD/DITC/TED/2007/12.
59. Schmack Biogas, A.G., 2007. Case Study, Feeding biogas into the natural gas grid-using the Pliening biomethane plant as an example. Available from (accessed on 16.07.2008). http://www.schmack-biogas.com.
60. Sherman J.D. Syntheti zeolites and other microporous oxide molecular sieves. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 1999, 96:3471-3478.
61. Sircar S. Pressure Swing Adsorption. Industrial and Engineering Chemical Research 2002, 41:1389-1392.
62. Sircar S., Golden T.C., Rao M.B. Activated carbon for gas separation and storage. Carbon 1996, 34(1):1-12.
63. 2 on natural zeolites. Energy and Fuels 2003, 17:571-576.
64. 2 on molecular sieves and activated carbon. Energy and Fuels 2001, 15:279-284.
65. Smyth B.M., Murphy J.D., O'brien C.M. What is the energy balance of grass biomethane in Ireland and other temperate northern European climates?. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2009, 13:2349-2360.
66. Solomon, S., Qin, D., Manning, M., Chen, Z., Marquis, M., Averyt, K.B., Tignor, M., Miller, H.L., 2007. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Available at 〈〉. http://www.ipcc.ch/publications-and-data/publications-ipcc-ourth-assessment-reportwg1-report-the-physical-science-basis.htm.
67. SVGW, 2008. Schweizerischer Verein des Gas und Wasserfaches, Richtlinie G13, Entwurf vom 20.5.2008, SVGW.
68. Swedish Gas Centre, 2008a. Case Study: The biogas plant in Linköping; in biogas from manure and waste products-Swedish Case Studies, Available from 〈〉 (accessed on 21.07.2008). http://www.sbgf.info/_filer/Biogasinfo_english.pdf.
69. Swedish Gas Centre, 2008b. Case study of the biogas plant in Gothenburg; in biogas from manure and waste products-Swedish Case Studies, Available from 〈〉 (accessed on 22.07.2008). http://www.sbgf.info/_filer/Biogasinfo_english.pdf.
70. Swedish Government (1999). Swedish Standard, Motorbränslen-Biogas som bränsle till snabbgående ottomotorer, SS 15 54 38.
71. Thulin, P., 2009. LP Cooab, Commercial Experiences. European Biomethane Fuel Conference, 7-9 September 2009, Goteborg, Sweden.
72. UK Government, 2007. Statutory Instrument no. 3072 The Renewable Transport Fuel Obligations Order 2007. UK, Office of Public Sector Information. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 09.09.2009). http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2007/uksi_20073072_en_1.
73. UK Government, 2009a. Written Ministerial Statements, Wednesday 28th January 2009, RTFO Levels (Response to Consultation). UK Parliament. Available at 〈〉 (accessed on 09.09.2009). http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200809/cmhansrd/cm090128/wmstext/90128m0001.htm%23column_20WS.
74. Wellinger, A., Lindberg, A., 1999. Upgrading and utilisation of biogas, IEA Bioenergy, Task 24. Available from 〈〉 (accessed on 22.07.2008). http://www.iea-biogas.net/Dokumente/Biogas%20upgrading.pdf.
75. Ziegler, J., 2008. Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food. Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development.