Using Cl/Br ratios and other indicators to assess potential impacts on groundwater quality from septic systems: A review and examples from principal aquifers in the United States

Journal of Hydrology

Volumn 397, Issue 3-4, 2011, Pages 151-166

  Katz, Brian G ^a   Eberts, Sandra M ^a   Kauffman, Leon J ^a  

^a U S GEOLOGICAL SURVEY   (United States)

Author keywords

Aquifers; Chloride bromide ratio; Groundwater quality; Septic tanks; United States

Indexed keywords

CENSUS DATA; CHEMICAL CONSTITUENTS; CHEMICAL DATA; CHLORIDE-BROMIDE RATIO; CL-CONCENTRATIONS; DISSOLVED ORGANIC CARBON; DISSOLVED OXYGEN CONCENTRATIONS; DOMESTIC WELLS; GLACIAL DEPOSITS; GROUNDWATER QUALITY; HIGH PERMEABILITY; HOUSING UNITS; HYDROGEOLOGIC UNIT; LAND SURFACE; LEACHATES; MASS RATIO; MONITORING WELLS; NITRATE-N; NON-TARGETED; OXIC CONDITIONS; POTENTIAL IMPACTS; SCREENING TOOL; SEPTIC SYSTEM; SHALLOW GROUNDWATER; SHALLOW WELLS; SOIL CHARACTERISTICS; STATISTICAL COMPARISONS; SULFATE CONCENTRATIONS; TEMPORAL VARIABILITY; UNITED STATES; WATER SAMPLES; WELL DEPTH;

AQUIFERS; BORON; BORON COMPOUNDS; BROMINE COMPOUNDS; CHLORINE; CHLORINE COMPOUNDS; CONCENTRATION (PROCESS); DISSOLVED OXYGEN; EFFLUENTS; HYDROGEOLOGY; INDICATORS (CHEMICAL); LEACHING; ORGANIC CARBON; POPULATION STATISTICS; POTASSIUM; RATING; SEPTIC TANKS; SURVEYS; WASTEWATER RECLAMATION; WATER QUALITY; WELLS;

GROUNDWATER RESOURCES;

BORON; BROMINE; CHLORINE; DISSOLVED ORGANIC CARBON; DISSOLVED OXYGEN; GLACIAL DEPOSIT; GROUNDWATER POLLUTION; LEACHATE; MONITORING; NITRATE; PERMEABILITY; POTASSIUM; SULFATE; TEMPORAL VARIATION; TOXICITY; WATER QUALITY;

GREAT PLAINS; UNITED STATES;

EID: 78651369510     PISSN: 00221694     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jhydrol.2010.11.017     Document Type: Article

References (104)

1. Alcalá F.J., Custodio E. Using the Cl/Br ratio as a tracer to identify the origin of salinity in aquifers in Spain and Portugal. Journal of Hydrology 2008, 359:189-207.
2. Alhajjar B.J., Chesters G., Harkin J.M. Indicators of chemical pollution from septic systems. Ground Water 1990, 28:559-568.
3. Andreasen D.C., Fleck W.B. Use of bromide:chloride ratios to differentiate potential sources of chloride in a shallow, unconfined aquifer affected by brackish-water intrusion. Hydrogeology Journal 1997, 5:17-26.
4. Aravena R., Robertson W.D. Use of multiple isotope tracers to evaluate denitrification in ground water: study of nitrate from a large-flux septic system plume. Ground Water 1998, 36:975-982.
5. Aravena R., Evans M.L., Cherry J.A. Stable isotopes of oxygen and nitrogen identification of nitrate from septic systems. Ground Water 1993, 31:180-186.
6. Arnade L.J. Seasonal correlation of well contamination and septic tank distance. Ground Water 1999, 37:920-923.
7. Barrett M.H., Hiscock K.M., Pedley S., Lerner D.N., Tellam J.H., French M.J. Marker species for identifying urban groundwater recharge sources: a review and case study in Nottingham, UK. Water Research 1999, 33(14):3083-3097.
8. Barringer J.L., Szabo Z., Schneider D., Atkinson W.D., Gallagher R.A. Mercury in ground water, septage, leach-field effluent, and soils in residential areas, New Jersey coastal Plain. Science of the Total Environment 2006, 361:144-162.
9. Behl E., Davis S.N., Goldowitz J. Cl/Br ratios as an environmental tracer of altered waters. Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs 1987, 19:686.
10. Beller M., Ellis A., Lee S.H., Drebot M.A., Jenkerson S.A., Funk E., Sobsey M.D., Simmons O.D., Monroe S.S., Ando T., Noel J., Petric M., Middaugh J.P., Spika J.S. Outbreak of viral gastroenteritis due to a contaminated well: International consequences. Journal of the American Medical Association 1997, 278(7):563-568.
11. Bicki T.J., Brown R.B. On-site sewage disposal: the influence of system density on water quality. Journal of Environmental Health 1991, 53(5):39-42.
12. Borchardt M.A., Bertz P.D., Spencer S.K., Battigelli D.A. Incidence of enteric viruses in groundwater from household wells in Wisconsin. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 2003, 69(2):1172-1180.
13. Borchardt M.A., Chyou P., DeVries E.O., Belongia E.A. Septic system density and infectious diarrhea in a defined population of children. Environmental Health Perspectives 2003, 111(5):742-748.
14. Brown, C.L., Starn, J.J., Stollenwerk, K., Mondazzi, R.A., Trombley, T.J., 2009. Aquifer Chemistry and Transport Processes in the Zone of Contribution to a Public-Supply Well in Woodbury, Connecticut, 2002-06. US Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2009-5051, 158pp.
15. Burston M.W., Nazari M.M., Bishop P.K., Lerner D.N. Pollution of groundwater in the Coventry region (UK) by chlorinated hydrocarbon solvents. Journal of Hydrology 1993, 149:137-161.
16. Carrara C., Ptacek C.J., Robertson W.D., Blowes D.W., Moncur M.C., Sverko E., Backus S. Fate of pharmaceutical and trace organic compounds in three septic system plumes. Environmental Science and Technology 2008, 42(8):2805-2811.
17. Carter, J.M., Delzer, G.C., Kingsbury, J.A., Hopple, J.A., 2007. Concentration data for anthropogenic organic compounds in ground water, surface water, and finished water of selected community water systems in the United States, 2002-2005. US Geological Survey Data Series 268, 30pp. <> (accessed 09.09.09). http://pubs.ursg.gov/ds/2007/268/.
18. Cartwright I., Weaver T.R., Fulton S., Nichol C., Reid M., Cheng X. Hydrogeochemical and isotopic constraints on the origins of dryland salinity, Murray Basin, Victoria, Australia. Applied Geochemistry 2004, 19:1233-1254.
19. Craun G.F. Waterborne disease - a status report emphasizing outbreaks in ground-water systems. Ground Water 1979, 17:183-191.
20. Craun G.F. Health aspects of groundwater pollution. Groundwater Pollution Microbiology 1984, 135-179. John Wiley and Sons, New York. G. Bitton, C.P. Gerba (Eds.).
21. Cronin A.A., Rueedi J., Morris B.L. The effectiveness of selected microbial and chemical indicators to detect sewer leakage impacts on urban groundwater quality. Water Science and Technology 2006, 54(6-7):145-152.
22. Davis S.N., Whittemore D.O., Fabryka-Martin J. Uses of chloride/bromide ratios in studies of potable water. Ground Water 1998, 36:338-350.
23. Davis S.N., Fabryka-Martin J.T., Wolfsberg L.E. Variations of bromide in potable groundwater in the United States. Ground Water 2004, 42(6):902-909.
24. DeBorde D.C., Woessner W.W., Lauerman B., Ball P.N. Virus occurrence and transport INA school septic system and unconfined aquifer. Ground Water 1998, 36(5):825-834.
25. Delzer, G.C., Hamilton, P.A., 2007. National Water-Quality Assessment Program-Source Water Quality Assessments. US Geological Survey Fact Sheet 2007-3069, 2pp.
26. DeSimone, L.A., 2009. Quality of Water from Domestic Wells in Principal Aquifers of the United States, 1991-2004. US Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2008-5227, 127pp.
27. DeWalle F.B. Failure analysis of large septic tank systems. Journal of the Environmental Engineering Division 1981, 107(1EE1):229-240.
28. Dumouchelle, D.H., 2006. Assessment of the Use of Selected Chemical and Microbiological Constituent as Indicators of Wastewater in Curtain Drains From Home-Sewage-Treatment Systems in Medina County, Ohio. US Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2006-5183, 20pp.
29. Eberts, S.M., Bair, E.S., de Roche, J.T., 1990. Geohydrology, Ground-Water Quality, and Simulated Ground-Water Flow, Geauga County, Ohio. US Geological Survey Water-Resources Investigations Report 90-4026, 117pp.
30. Fabryka-Martin J., Whittemore D.O., Davis S.N., Kubik P.W., Sharma P. Geochemistry of halogens in the Milk River aquifer, Alberta, Canada. Applied Geochemistry 1991, 6(4):447-464.
31. Fishman, M.J., Friedman, L.C., 1989. Methods for Determination of Inorganic Substances in Water and Fluvial Sediments. US Geological Survey Techniques of Water-Resources Investigations, book 5, 545pp (Chapter A1).
32. Fitzsimmons M.F., Abdul-Rashid K.M., Riley J.P., Wolff G.A. Aminopropanone as a marker for raw sewage in natural waters?. Marine Pollution Bulletin 1995, 30:306-312.
33. Francy, D.S., Bushon, R.N., Stopar, Julie, Luzano, E.J., Fout, G.S., 2004. Environmental Factors and Chemical and Microbiological Water-Quality Constituents Related to the Presence of Enteric Viruses in Ground Water from Small Public Water Supplies in Southeastern Michigan. US Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2004-5219, 54pp.
34. Gardner K.K., Vogel R.M. Predicting ground water nitrate concentration from land use. Ground Water 2005, 43:343-352.
35. Gerritse R.G., George R. The role of soil organic matter in the geochemical cycling of chloride and bromide. Journal of Hydrology 1988, 101(1-4):83-95.
36. Godfrey E., Woessner W.W., Benotti M.J. Pharmaceuticals in on-site sewage effluent and ground water, Western Montana. Ground Water 2007, 45(3):263-271.
37. Granato, G.E., 1996. Deicing Chemicals as a Source of Constituents in Highway Runoff. Washington, DC, Transportation Research Board, Transportation Research Record 1533, National Research Council, pp. 50-58.
38. Gross M., Thrasher D. Causes, correction, and prevention of septic tank-soil absorption system malfunctions 1985, ASAE Publication, pp. 260-264.
39. Ground Water Protection Council, 2007. Ground Water Report to the Nation: A Call to Action, Ground Water Protection Council, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, 156pp.
40. Hantzsche N.N., Finnemore E.J. Predicting ground-water nitrate-nitrogen impacts. Ground Water 1992, 30(4):490-499.
41. Harden H.S., Roeder E., Hooks M., Chanton J.P. Evaluation of onsite sewage treatment and disposal systems in shallow karst terrain. Water Research 2008, 42(10-11):2585-2597.
42. Harman J., Robertson W.D., Cherry J.A., Zanini L. Impacts on a sand aquifer from an old septic system: nitrate and phosphorus. Ground Water 1996, 34:1105-1114.
43. Helsel D.R., Hirsch R.M. Statistical methods in water resources 1992, Elsevier, New York, 522pp.
44. Hem, J.D., 1992, Study and Interpretation of the Chemical Characteristics of Natural water, third ed. US Geological Survey Water Supply Paper 2254, 263pp.
45. Hudak P.F. Chloride/bromide ratios in leachate derived from farm-animal waste. Environmental Pollution 2003, 121:23-25.
46. Jagucki, M.L., Darner, R.A., 2001, Ground-Water Quality in Geauga County, Ohio-Review of Previous Studies, Status in 1999, and Comparison of 1986 and 1999 Data. US Geological Survey Water-Resources Investigations Report 01-4160, 60p.
47. Jin Z., Chen Y., Wang F., Ogura N. Detection of nitrate sources in urban groundwater by isotopic and chemical indicators, Hangzhou City, China. Environmental Geology 2004, 45(7):1017-1024.
48. Jurgens, B.C., Burow, K.R., Dalgish, B.A., Shelton, J.L., 2008. Hydrogeology, Water Chemistry, and Factors Affecting the Transport of Contaminants in the Zone of Contribution of a Public-Supply Well in Modesto, Eastern San Joaquin Valley, California. US Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2008-5156, 78p.
49. Katz B.G., Lindner J.B., Ragone S.E. Comparison of nitrogen in shallow ground water beneath sewered and unsewered areas, Nassau County, New York, 1952 through 1976. Ground Water 1980, 18(6):607-616.
50. Katz, B.G., Crandall, C.A., Metz, P.A., McBride, W.S., Berndt, M.P., 2007. Chemical Characteristics, Water Sources and Pathways, and Age Distribution of Ground Water in the Contributing Area of a Public Supply well Near Tampa, Florida. US Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2007-5139, 85p.
51. Katz B.G., Griffin D.W., McMahon P.B., Harden H., Wade E., Hicks R.W., Chanton J. Fate of effluent-borne contaminants beneath septic tank drainfields overlying a karst aquifer. Journal of Environmental Quality 2010, 39:1181-1195.
52. 18 O of nitrate isotope: a study of the shallow Pleistocene aquifer in the Jericho area, Palestine. Acta Hydrochimica et Hydrobiologica 2006, 34:27-33.
53. Koterba, M.T., Wilde, F.D., Lapham, W.W., 1995. Ground-Water Data-Collection Protocols and Procedures for the National Water-Quality Assessment Program: Collection and Documentation of Water-Quality Samples and Related data. US Geological Survey Open-File Report 99-399, 113pp.
54. Krauskopf K.B. Introduction to Geochemistry 1979, McGraw-Hill, New York, 721pp.
55. Landon, M.K., Clark, B.R., McMahon, P.B., McGuire, V.L., Turco, M.J., 2008, Hydrogeology, Chemical-Characteristics, and Transport Processes in the Zone of Contribution of a Public-Supply Well in York, Nebraska. US Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2008-5050, 149pp.
56. Landon M.K., Jurgens B., Katz B.G., Eberts S.M., Burow K.R., Crandall C.A. Depth-dependent sampling to identify short-circuit pathways to public-supply wells in multiple aquifer settings in the United States. Hydrogeology Journal 2009, 18:577-593.
57. Lichtenberg E., Shapiro L. Agriculture and nitrate concentrations in Maryland community water system wells. Journal of Environmental Quality 1997, 26(1):145-153.
58. Lindsey, B.D., Berndt, M.P., Katz, B.G., Ardis, A.F., Skach, K.A., 2009. Water Quality in Carbonate Aquifers of the United States. US Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2008-5240, 117p.
59. Miller, L.D., Ortiz, R.F., 2007. Ground-Water Quality and Potential Effects of Individual Sewage Disposal System Effluent on Ground-Water Quality in Park County, Colorado, 2001-2004. US Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2007-5220, 48p.
60. Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, 1999. Effects of Septic Systems on Ground Water Quality, Baxter, Minnesota. Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, Ground Water Monitoring and Assessment Program, St. Paul, Minnesota, 37p.
61. Moran M.J., Lapham W.W., Rowe B.L., Zogorski J.S. Volatile organic compounds in ground water from rural private wells, 1986 to 1999. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 2004, 40(5):1141-1157.
62. Moran, M.J., Zogorski, J.S., Rowe, B.L., 2006. Approach to an Assessment of Volatile Organic Compounds in the Nation's Ground Water and Drinking-Water Supply Wells. US Geological Survey Open-File Report 2005-1452, 36p.
63. Moran M.J., Zogorski J.S., Squillace P.J. Chlorinated solvents in groundwater of the United States. Environmental Science and Technology 2007, 41(1):74-81.
64. Morrissey, D.J., 1989. Estimation of the Recharge Area Contributing Water to a Pumped Well in a Glacial-Drift, River-Valley Aquifer. US Geological Survey Water-Supply Paper 2338, 41p.
65. Mullaney, J.R., Grady, S.J., 1997. Hydrogeology and Water Quality in a Surficial Aquifer Underlying an Urban Area, Manchester, Connecticut. US Geological Survey Water-Resources Investigations Report 97-4195, 40p.
66. Nishikawa, T., Densmore, J.N., Martin, P., Matti, J., 2003. Evaluation of the Source and Transport of High Nitrate Concentrations in Ground Water, Warren Subbasin, California. US Geological Survey Water-Resources Investigations Report 03-4009, 118pp.
67. Nolan B.T., Hitt K.J. Vulnerability of shallow ground water and drinking water wells to nitrate in the United States. Environmental Science and Technology 2006, 40:7834-7840.
68. Panno S.V., Hackley K.C., Hwang H.H., Greenberg S.E., Krapac I.G., Landsberger S., O'Kelly D.J. Characterization and identification of Na-Cl sources in ground water. Ground Water 2006, 44:176-187.
69. Panno S.V., Kelley W.R., Hackley K.C., Weibel C.P. Chemical and bacterial quality of aeration-type wastewater treatment system discharge. Ground Water Monitoring and Remediation 2007, 27(2):71-76.
70. Paschke, S.S. (Ed.), 2007. Hydrogeologic Settings and Ground-Water Flow Simulations for Regional Studies of the Transport of Anthropogenic and Natural Contaminants to Public-Supply Wells-Studies Begun in 2001. US Geological Survey Professional Paper 1737-A, 244pp.
71. Peavy, H.S., 1978. Groundwater Pollution From Septic Tank Drainfields-A Report to the Blue Ribbons of the Big Sky Country Areawide Planning Organization. Bozeman, Mont., Dept. of Civil Engineering and Engineering Mechanics, Montana State University.
72. Perkins R.J. Septic tanks, lot size and pollution of water table aquifers. Journal of Environmental Health 1984, 46(6):298-304.
73. Persky, J.H., 1986. The Relation of Ground-Water Quality to Housing Density, Cape Cod, Massachusetts. US Geological Survey Water-Resources Investigations Report 86-4093, 28pp.
74. Postma F.B., Gold A.J., Loomis G.W. Nutrient and microbial movement from seasonally-used septic systems. Journal of Environmental Health 1992, 55(2):5-10.
75. Ptacek C.J. Geochemistry of a septic-system plume in a coastal barrier bar, Point Pelee, Ontario, Canada. Journal of Contaminant Hydrology 1998, 33:293-312.
76. Reilly, T.E., Pollock, D.W., 1993. Factors Affecting Area Contributing Recharge to Wells in Shallow Aquifers. US Geological Survey Water-Supply Paper 2412, 21pp.
77. Robertson W.D., Blowes D.W. Major ion and trace metal geochemistry of an acidic septic-system plume in silt. Ground Water 1995, 33:275-283.
78. Robertson W.D., Cherry J.A. Hydrogeology of an unconfined sand aquifer and its effect on the behavior of nitrogen from a large-flux septic system. Applied Hydrogeology 1992, 1:32-44.
79. Robertson W.D., Cherry J.A., Sudicky E.A. Ground-water contamination from two small septic systems on sand aquifers. Ground Water 1991, 29(1):82-92.
80. Robertson W.D., Schiff S.L., Ptacek C.J. Review of phosphate mobility and persistence in 10 septic system plumes. Ground Water 1998, 36:1000-1010.
81. Rule K.L., Ebbett V.R., Vikesland P.J. Formation of chloroform and chlorinated organics by free chlorine-mediated oxidation of triclosan. Environmental Science and Technology 2005, 39:3176-3185.
82. SAS Institute Inc., 1989a. SAS/STAT user's guide, vol. 1 (4th ed.). Cary, NC, SAS Institute Inc., 943pp.
83. SAS Institute Inc., 1989b. SAS/STAT user's guide, vol. 2 (4th ed.). Cary, NC, SAS Institute Inc., 846pp.
84. Schoonen M.A.A., Devoe V., Brown C.J. Bromide in Long Island ground waters and surface waters. Geology of Long Island and Metropolitan New York, April 22, 1995, Program with Abstracts 1995, 118-126. Stony Brook, New York, Long Island Geologists.
85. Seaman J.C., Bertsch P.M., Korom S.F., Miller W.P. Physiochemical controls on non-conservative anion migration in coarse-textured alluvial sediments. Ground Water 1996, 34(5):778-783.
86. 11B to evaluate nitrate contamination in groundwater. Applied Geochemistry 2005, 20:1626-1636.
87. Seiler R., Zaugg S.D., Thomas J.M., Howcroft D.L. Caffeine and pharmaceuticals as indicators of waste water contamination in wells. Ground Water 1999, 37(3):405-410.
88. Sophocleous M., Townsend M.A., Whittemore D.O. Movement and fate of atrazine and bromide in central Kansas croplands. Journal of Hydrology 1990, 115(1-4):115-137.
89. Spruill T.B., Showers W.J., Howe S.S. Application of classification-tree methods to identify nitrate sources in ground water. Journal of Environmental Quality 2002, 31:1538-1549.
90. Squillace, P.J., Moran, M.J., 2006. Factors Associated with Sources, Transport, and Fate of Volatile Organic Compounds in Aquifers of the United States and Implications for Ground-Water Management. US Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2005-5269, 40pp.
91. Squillace P.J., Moran M.J. Factors associated with sources, transport, and fate of volatile organic compounds and their mixtures in aquifers of the United States. Environmental Science and Technology 2007, 41(7):2123-2130.
92. Squillace P.J., Moran M.J., Price C.V. VOCs in shallow groundwater in new residential/commercial areas of the United States. Environmental Science and Technology 2004, 38:5338-5372.
93. Starr J.L., Glotfelty D.E. Atrazine and bromide movement through a silt loam soil. Journal of Environmental Quality 1990, 19(3):552-558.
94. Thomas M.A. The effect of residential development on ground-water quality near Detroit, Michigan. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 2000, 36:1023-1038.
95. Tinker J.R. An analysis of nitrate-nitrogen in ground water beneath unsewered subdivisions. Ground Water Monitoring Review, Winter 1991, 1991:141-150.
96. USEPA, 2002. Onsite Wastewater Treatment Systems Manual. Environmental Protection Agency Report EPA625/R-00/008, 175pp.
97. USGS, 2006a. National Water-Quality Assessment (NAWQA) Program. <>. http://water.usgs.gov/nawqa/index.html.
98. USGS, 2006b. National Water-Quality Assessment (NAWQA) Program Method, Sampling, and Analytical Protocols. <>. http://water.usgs.gov/nawqa/protocols/methodprotocols.html.
99. Vengosh A., Pankratov I. Chloride/bromide and chloride/fluoride ratios of domestic sewage effluents and associated contaminated ground water. Ground Water 1998, 36:815-824.
100. Verstraeten I.M., Fetterman G.S., Meyer M.J., Bullen T., Sebree S.K. Use of tracers and isotopes to evaluate vulnerability of water in domestic wells to septic waste. Ground Water Monitoring and Remediation 2005, 25:107-117.
101. Wallace J. Ground-water quality mapping for the valley-fill aquifers in the southern sanpete and central sevier valleys, central Utah. Abstracts with Programs, Geological Society of America 2007, 40(6):271.
102. Wallace J. Analysis of environmental tracer data to help determine sources of high nitrate ground water in Sanpete and Central Sevier Valleys, central Utah. Abstracts with Programs, Geological Society of America 2008, 39(6):476.
103. Whittemore D.O., Davis S.N. Patterns of Cl/Br with Cl concentration in the hydrosphere. Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs 1995, 27(6):465-466.
104. Wilson T.P., Long D.T. Geochemistry and isotope chemistry of Michigan Basin brines. Devonian formations. Applied Geochemistry 1993, 8:81-100.