Comparative study of different digitization techniques and their accuracy

CAD Computer Aided Design

Volumn 43, Issue 2, 2011, Pages 188-206

  Barbero, Basilio Ramos ^a   Ureta, Elena Santos ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BURGOS   (Spain)

Author keywords

3D CAD; 3D point cloud; Accuracy; CT; Laser scanner; Point cloud data reduction; Reconstruction mesh; Reverse engineering (RE); Surface mesh; Tomography

Indexed keywords

3D CAD; 3D POINT CLOUD; ACCURACY; CT; LASER SCANNER; POINT CLOUD DATA; RECONSTRUCTION MESH; SURFACE MESH;

COMPUTERIZED TOMOGRAPHY; COORDINATE MEASURING MACHINES; DATA REDUCTION; GAGES; KRYPTON; LASER APPLICATIONS; MESH GENERATION; PRECISION ENGINEERING; REVERSE ENGINEERING; SCANNING; SPHERES; STATISTICS;

THREE DIMENSIONAL;

EID: 78650601492     PISSN: 00104485     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cad.2010.11.005     Document Type: Article

References (44)

1. A.P. Mangan, and Ross T. Whitaker Partitioning 3D surface meshes using watershed segmentation IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics 5 4 1999 308 321
2. P. Benk, R.R. Martin, and T. Vrady Algorithms for reverse engineering boundary representation models Computer-Aided Design 33 11 2001 839 851
3. L.A. Piegl, and W. Tiller Parametrization for surface fitting in reverse engineering Computer-Aided Design 33 8 2001 593 603
4. B. Ramos The recovery of design intent in reverse engineering problems Computers and Industrial Engineering 56 4 2009 1265 1275
5. A. Razdan, and M. Bae A hybrid approach to feature segmentation of triangle meshes Computer-Aided Design 35 9 2003 783 789
6. W.B. Thompon, J.C. Owen, H.J. Germain, S.R. Stark Jr., and T.C. Henderson Feature-based reverse engineering of mechanical parts IEEE Transaction on Robotics and Automation 15 1 1999 57 66
7. T. Vrady, R.R. Martin, and J. Coxt Reverse engineering of geometric modelsan introduction Computer-Aided Design 29 4 1997 255 256
8. X. Ye, H. Liu, L. Chen, Z. Chen, X. Pan, and S. Zhang Reverse innovative designan integrated product design methodology Computer-Aided Design 40 7 2008 812 827
9. Y. Ke, S. Fan, W. Zhu, A. Li, F. Liu, and X. Shi Feature-based reverse modeling strategies Computer-Aided Design 38 5 2006 485 506
10. P. Benk, G. Ks, T. Vrady, L. Andor, and R. Martin Constrained fitting in reverse engineering Computer Aided Geometric Design 19 3 2002 173 205
11. V. Weiss, L. Andor, G. Renner, and T. Vrady Advanced surface fitting techniques Computer Aided Geometric Design 19 1 2002 19 42
12. V. Stamati, and I. Fudos On reconstructing 3D feature boundaries Computer-Aided Design and Applications 5 14 2008 316 324
13. Stamati V, Fudos I. A feature based approach to re-engineering objects of freeform design by exploiting point cloud morphology. In: ProceedingsSPM 2007: ACM symposium on solid and physical modeling. p. 34753.
14. C. Bradley, and B. Currie Advances in the field of reverse engineering Computer-Aided Design and Applications 2 5 2005 697 706
15. Dassault. http://www.3ds.com/ [August 2009].
16. R. Vinesh, and J.F. Kiran Reverse engineering. An industrial perspective Springer in advanced manufacturing 2008 978-1-84628-855-5 42 43
17. May S, Fuchs S, Droeschel D, Holz D, Nchter A. Robust 3D-mapping with time-of-flight cameras. In: The 2009 IEEE/RSJ international conference on intelligent robots and systems. 2009. p. 16738.
18. J.A. Beraldin Basic theory on surface measurement uncertainty of 3D imaging systems Proceedings of the SPIEThe International Society for Optical Engineering 7239 723902 2009 12
19. ISO/TC 14253-2. Guide to the estimation of uncertainty in geometrical product specifications (GPS) measurement, in calibration of measuring equipment and in product verification. 1999.
20. ISO/IEC Guide 98-3:2008. Uncertainty of measurementpart 3: guide to the expression of uncertainty in measurement. GUM. 1995.
21. R. Schwarte Principle of 3-D imaging techniques B. Jhne, H. Haussecker, P. Geissler, Handbook of computer vision and applications 1999 Academic Press
22. J. Santolaria, J.J. Pastor, F.J. Brosed, and J.J. Aguilar A one-step intrinsic and extrinsic calibration method for laser line scanner operation in coordinate measuring machines Measurement Science and Technology 20 4 2009 13
23. K.H. Lee, H. Woo, and T. Suk Data reduction methods for reverse engineering International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 17 10 2001 735 743
24. J.J. Aguilar, F. Torres, and M.A. Lope Stereo vision for 3D measurement: accuracy analysis, calibration and industrial applications Measurement 18 4 1996 193 200
25. R.J. Valkenburg, and A.M. McIvor Accurate 3D measurement using a structured light system Image and Vision Computing 16 2 1998 99 110
26. C. Rocchini, P. Cignoni, C. Montani, P. Pingi, and R. Scopigno A low cost 3D scanner based on structured light Computer Graphics Forum 20 3 2001 299 308
27. Ø. Skotheim, J.O. Nygaard, J. Thielemann, and T. Vollset A flexible 3D vision system based on structured light for in-line product inspection Proceedings of the SPIEThe International Society for Optical Engineering 6805 680505 2008
28. Iuliano L, Minetola P. Rapid manufacturing of sculptures replicas: a comparison between 3D optical scanners. In: CIPA 2005 XX international symposium. 2005. http://cipa.icomos.org/text%20files/TURIN/384.pdf [July 2010].
29. X. Chen, J. Xi, Y. Jin, and J. Sun Accurate calibration for a cameraprojector measurement system based on structured light projection Optics and Lasers in Engineering 47 34 2009 310 319
30. S. Son, H. Park, and K.H. Lee Automated laser scanning system for reverse engineering and inspection International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture 42 8 2002 889 897
31. W.A.R.W. Harun, Z.A. Rajion, I.A. Aziz, and A.R. Samsudin 3D CT imaging for craniofacial analysis based on anatomical regions Conference ProceedingsIEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society 7 14 2005 817 820
32. S. Adler Reverse engineering employing CT for CAD/CAM applications 3D Scanning Technologies Magazine 1 3 2008
33. K.H. Lee, and H. Woo Use of reverse engineering method for rapid product development Computers and Industrial Engineering 35 14 1998 21 24
34. R.A. Ketcham, and W.D. Carlson Acquisition, optimization and interpretation of X-ray computed tomographic imagery: applications to the geosciences Computers and Geosciences 27 4 2001 381 400
35. W.D. Carlson, T. Rowe, R.A. Ketcham, and M.W. Colbert Applications of high-resolution X-ray computed tomography in petrology, meteoritics and paleaontology Applications of X-ray computed tomography in geosciences Geological society 2003 Special Publication No. 215 London
36. F. Bernardini, and H. Rushmeier The 3D model acquisition pipeline Computer Graphics Forum 21 2 2002 149 172
37. UNE-EN ISO10360-2. Especificacin geomtrica de productos. GPS. Ensayos de aceptacin y de verificacin peridica para mquinas de medicin por coordenadas. MMC. Parte 2: MMC utilizadas para la medicin de tamao. 2002. ISO: 10360-2:2001.
38. V.H. Chan, C.H. Bradley, and G.W. Vickers Automating laser scanning of 3D surfaces for reverse engineering Three-dimensional imaging and laser-based systems for metrology and inspection III Proceedings vol. 3204 1997 156 164
39. UNE 82009-1. Exactitud (veracidad y precisin) de resultados y mtodos de medicin. Parte 1: principios generales y definiciones. 1998. ISO: 5725-1.
40. ISO/TS 15530-3: 2004(E). Geometrical product specifications (GPS)coordinate measuring machines (CMM): technique for determining the uncertainty of measurementpart 3: use of calibrated workpieces or standards. http://www.3dscanningtechnologies.com/pdfs/CTfor%20CADCAM.pdf [December 2009].
41. EA-4/02. Expression of the uncertainty of measurement in calibration. 1999.
42. A.F. Obrist, A. Flisch, and J. Hofman Point cloud reconstruction with sub-pixel accuracy by slice adaptive thresholding of X-ray computed tomography images NDT & E International 37 5 2004 373 380
43. J. Hofmann, A. Flisch, and A. Obrist Adaptive CT scanning-mesh based optimisation methods for industrial X-ray computed tomography applications NTD & E International 37 4 2004 271 278
44. Razdan A, Mongkolnam P, Farin G. Reverse engineering using a subdivision surface scheme. In: 3D modelling symposium, 8th ed. 2003. http://i3dea.asu.edu/ data/docspubs/reverseengineeringusingloopsubdivision.pdf [August 2009].