Dialectical behavior therapy for borderline personality disorder: A meta-analysis using mixed-effects modeling

Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology

Volumn 78, Issue 6, 2010, Pages 936-951

  Kliem, Sören ^a   Kröger, Christoph ^a   Kosfelder, Joachim ^b  

^a TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY OF BRAUNSCHWEIG   (Germany)

^b UNIVERSITY OF APPLIED SCIENCES   (Germany)

Author keywords

borderline personality disorder; dialectical behavior therapy; effectiveness study; meta analyses

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; AUTOMUTILATION; BEHAVIOR THERAPY; BORDERLINE STATE; CLINICAL TRIAL; CONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIAL; FOLLOW UP; HUMAN; LANGUAGE; LONG TERM CARE; PERSONALITY DISORDER; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL; SUICIDAL BEHAVIOR;

BEHAVIOR THERAPY; BORDERLINE PERSONALITY DISORDER; DIAGNOSTIC AND STATISTICAL MANUAL OF MENTAL DISORDERS; HUMANS; MODELS, PSYCHOLOGICAL; SELF-INJURIOUS BEHAVIOR; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 78650112867     PISSN: 0022006X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1037/a0021015     Document Type: Article

References (89)

1. A. Arntz, M. van den Hoorn, J. Cornelis, R. Verheul, W.M.C. van den Bosch, A.J.H.T. de Bie Reliability and validity of the Borderline Personality Disorder Severity Index Journal of Personality Disorders 17 2003 45 59
2. D.H. Barlow Health care policy, psychotherapy research, and the future of psychotherapy American Psychologist 51 1996 1050 1058
3. A. Bateman, P. Fonagy Effectiveness of partial hospitalization in the treatment of borderline personality disorder: A randomized controlled trial American Journal of Psychiatry 156 1999 1563 1569
4. A. Bateman, P. Fonagy 8-year follow-up of patients treated for borderline personality disorder: Mentalization-based treatment versus treatment as usual American Journal of Psychiatry 165 2008 631 638
5. B.J. Becker Synthesizing standardized mean-change measures British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology 41 1988 257 278
6. C.B. Begg, J.A. Berlin Publication bias: A problem in interpreting medical data Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A. Statistics in Society 151 1988 419 463
7. D.S. Bender, R.T. Dolan, A.E. Skodol, C.A. Sanislow, I.R. Dyck, T.H. McGlashan, J.G. Gunderson Treatment utilization by patients with personality disorders American Journal of Psychiatry 158 2001 295 302
8. T.H.A. Bijmold, R.G.M. Pieters Meta-analysis in marketing when studies contain multiple measurements Marketing Letters 12 2001 157 169
9. C.A. Binks, M. Fenton, L. McCarthy, T. Lee, C.E. Adams, C. Duggan Psychological therapies for people with borderline personality disorder Cochrane Database Systematic Reviews 2006 (1, Article CD005652). doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005652
10. D.W. Black, N. Blum, B. Pfohl, N. Hale Suicidal behavior in borderline personality disorder: Prevalence, risk factors, prediction, and prevention Journal of Personality Disorders 18 2004 226 239
11. M. Bohus, B. Haaf, T. Simms, M.F. Limberger, C. Schmahl, C. Unckel, K. Lieb, M.M. Linehan Effectiveness of inpatient dialectical behavioral therapy for borderline personality disorder: A controlled trial Behaviour Research and Therapy 42 2004 487 499
12. M. Bohus, B. Haaf, C.H. Stiglmayr, U. Pohl, R. Böhme, M.M. Linehan Evaluation of inpatient dialectical-behavioral therapy for borderline personality disorder - A prospective study Behaviour Research and Therapy 38 2000 875 887
13. J.F. Clarkin, K.N. Levy, M.F. Lenzenweger, O.F. Kernberg The Personality Disorders Institute/Borderline Personality Disorder Research Foundation randomized control trial for borderline personality disorder: Rationale, methods, and patient characteristics Journal of Personality Disorders 18 2004 52 72
14. J.F. Clarkin, K.N. Levy, M.F. Lenzenweger, O.F. Kernberg Evaluating three treatments for borderline personality disorder: A multiwave study American Journal of Psychiatry 164 2007 922 928
15. E.F. Coccaro, P.D. Harvey, E. Kupsaw-Lawrence, J.L. Herbert, D.P. Bernstein Development of neuropharmacologically based behavioral assessment of impulsive aggressive behavior Journal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences 3 1991 S44 S51
16. J. Cohen Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences 1988 Erlbaum Hillsdale, NJ
17. K.A. Comtois, L. Elwood, L.C. Holdcraft, W.R. Smith, T.L. Simpson Effectiveness of dialectical behavior therapy in a community mental health center Cognitive and Behavioral Practice 14 2007 406 414
18. J. DeCoster Meta-analysis notes 2009 Retrieved from http://www.stat-help. com/notes.html
19. S. Downs, N. Black The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomised and non-randomised studies of health care interventions Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 52 1998 377 384
20. W. DuMouchel Hierarchical Bayes linear models for meta-analysis (Tech. Rep. No. 27) 1994 National Institute of Statistical Sciences Research Triangle Park, NC
21. J.A. Durlak How to evaluate a meta-analysis D. Drotar Handbook of research in pediatric and clinical child psychology: Practical strategies and methods 2000 Kluwer Academic/Plenum New York, NY 395 407
22. M. Egger, P. Jüni, C. Bartlett, F. Holenstein, J. Sterne How important are comprehensive literature searches and the assessment of trial quality in systematic reviews? Empirical study Health Technology Assessment 7 2003 1 76
23. E. Fassbinder, S. Rudolf, A. Bussiek, C. Kröger, R. Arnold, W. Greggersen, U. Schweiger Effektivität der dialektischen Verhaltenstherapie bei Patienten mit Borderline-Persönlichkeitsstörung im Langzeitverlauf. Eine 30-Monats-Katamnese nach stationärer Behandlug [Effectiveness of dialectical behavior therapy for patients with borderline personality disorder in the long-term course: A 30-month-follow-up after inpatient treatment] Psychotherapie, Psychosomatik, Medizinische Psychologie 57 2007 1 9
24. J.L. Fleiss Measures of effect size for categorical data H. Cooper L.V. Hedges The handbook of research synthesis 1994 Russell Sage Foundation New York, NY 245 260
25. J. Friedrich, H. Gunia, M. Huppertz Evaluation eines ambulanten Netzwerks für Dialektisch Behaviorale Therapie [Evaluation of an outpatient dialectical behavioral therapy network] Verhaltenstherapie und Verhaltensmedizin 24 2003 289 306
26. R.D. Gibbons, D.R. Hedecker, J.M. Davis Estimation of effect size from a series of experiments involving paired comparisons Journal of Educational Statistics 18 1993 271 279
27. J.G. Giesen-Bloo, R. van Dyck, P. Spinhoven, W. van Tilburg, C. Dirksen, T. van Asselt, A. Arntz Outpatient psychotherapy for borderline personality disorder: Randomized trial of schema-focused therapy vs. transference-focused psychotherapy Archives of General Psychiatry 63 2006 649 658
28. J.B. Greenhouse, S. Iyengar Sensitivity analysis and diagnostics H. Cooper L.V. Hedges The handbook of research synthesis 1994 Russell Sage Foundation New York, NY 383 398
29. C.K. Haddock, D. Rindskopf, W.R. Shadish Using odds ratios as effect sizes for meta-analysis of dichotomous data: A primer on methods and issues Psychological Methods 3 1998 339 353
30. M.S. Harned, A.L. Chapman, E.T. Dexter-Mazza, A. Murray, K.A. Comtois, M.M. Linehan Treating co-occurring Axis I disorders in recurrently suicidal women with borderline personality disorder: A 2-year randomized trial of dialectical behavior therapy versus community treatment by experts Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 76 2008 1068 1075
31. M.S. Harned, M.M. Linehan Integrating dialectical behavior therapy and prolonged exposure to treat co-occurring borderline personality disorder and PTSD: Two case studies Cognitive and Behavioral Practice 15 2008 263 276
32. A. Hartmann, T. Herzog Varianten der Effektstärkenberechnung in Meta-Analysen: Kommt es zu variablen Ergebnissen? [Calculating effect size by varying formulas: Are there varying results?] Zeitschrift für Klinische Psychologie und Psychotherapie 24 1995 337 343
33. V. Hasselblad, L.V. Hedges Meta-analysis of screening and diagnostic tests Psychological Bulletin 117 1995 167 178
34. L.V. Hedges Distribution theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimators Journal of Educational Statistics 6 1981 107 128
35. L.V. Hedges, H. Cooper, B.J. Bushman Testing the null hypothesis in meta-analysis: A comparison of combined probability and confidence interval procedures Psychological Bulletin 111 1998 188 194
36. L.V. Hedges, I. Olkin Statistical methods for meta-analysis 1985 Academic Press San Diego, CA
37. C.J. Hopwood, L.C. Morey, M.O. Edelen, M.T. Shea, C.M. Grilo, C.A. Sanislow, A.E. Skodol Comparison of interview and self-report methods for the assessment of borderline personality disorder criteria Psychological Assessment 20 2008 81 85
38. K. Höschel Dialektisch Behaviorale Therapie der Borderline Persönlichkeitsstörung in der Regelversorgung - Das Saarbrücker DBT-Modell [Dialectic behavioral therapy for borderline personality disorder in standard medical care: The Saarbrücken Treatment Program] Verhaltenstherapie 16 2006 17 24
39. J.E. Hunter, F.L. Schmidt Correcting for sources of artificial variation across studies H. Cooper L.V. Hedges The handbook of research synthesis 1994 Russell Sage Foundation New York, NY 323 336
40. B.T. Johnson Dstat: Software for the meta-analytic review of research literatures 1989 Erlbaum Hillsdale, NJ
41. N. Kleindienst, M.F. Limberger, C. Schmahl, R. Steil, U.W. Ebner-Priemer, M. Bohus Do improvements after inpatient dialectical behavioral therapy persist in the long term? A naturalistic follow-up in patients with borderline personality disorder Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 196 2008 847 851
42. N.J. Kolla, P.S. Links, S. McMain, D.L. Streiner, R. Cardish, M. Cook Demonstrating adherence to guidelines for the treatment of patients with borderline personality disorder Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 54 2009 181 189
43. S. Konstantopoulos Fixed and mixed effects models in meta-analysis (Discussion Paper No. 2198) 2006 Institute for the Study of Labor Bonn, Germany
44. C.R. Koons, C.J. Robins, J.L. Tweed, T.R. Lynch, A.M. Gonzales, J.Q. Morse, L.A. Bastian Efficacy of dialectical behavior therapy in women veterans with borderline personality disorder Behavior Therapy 32 2001 371 390
45. I. Kreft, J. de Leeuw Introducing multilevel modeling 1998 Sage Newbury Park, CA
46. C. Kröger, U. Schweiger, V. Sipos, R. Arnold, K.G. Kahl, T. Schunert, H. Reinecker Effectiveness of dialectical behaviour therapy for borderline personality disorder in an inpatient setting Behaviour Research and Therapy 44 2006 1211 1217
47. K. Lieb, M.C. Zanarini, C. Schmahl, M.M. Linehan, M. Bohus Borderline personality disorder Lancet 364 2004 453 461
48. M.M. Linehan Cognitive-behavioral treatment of borderline personality disorder 1993 Guilford Press New York, NY
49. M.M. Linehan Skills training manual for treating borderline personality disorder 1993 Guilford Press New York, NY
50. M.M. Linehan, H.E. Armstrong, A. Suarez, D. Allmon, H.L. Heard Cognitive-behavioral treatment of chronically parasuicidal borderline patients Archives of General Psychiatry 48 1991 1060 1064
51. Linehan, M. M., & Comtois, K. A. (1996). Lifetime parasuicide count. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Psychology, University of Washington, Seattle.
52. M.M. Linehan, K.A. Comtois, M.Z. Brown, H.L. Heard, A. Wagner Suicide Attempt Self-Injury Interview (SASII): Development, reliability, and validity of a scale to assess suicide attempts and intentional self-injury Psychological Assessment 18 2006 303 312
53. M.M. Linehan, K.A. Comtois, A.M. Murray, M.Z. Brown, R.J. Gallop, H.L. Heard, N. Lindenboim Two-year randomized controlled trial and follow-up of dialectical behavior therapy vs therapy by experts for suicidal behaviors and borderline personality disorder Archives of General Psychiatry 63 2006 757 766
54. M.M. Linehan, L.A. Dimeff, S.K. Reynolds, K.A. Comtois, S. Shaw-Welch, P. Heagerty, D.R. Kivlahan Dialectical behavior therapy versus comprehensive validation therapy plus 12-step for the treatment of opioid dependent women meeting criteria for borderline personality disorder Drug and Alcohol Dependence 67 2002 13 26
55. M.M. Linehan, H.L. Heard, H.E. Armstrong Naturalistic follow-up of a behavioral treatment for chronically parasuicidal borderline patients Archives of General Psychiatry 50 1993 971 974
56. M.M. Linehan, J.D. McDavid, M.Z. Brown, J.H.R. Sayrs, R.J. Gallop Olanzapine plus dialectical behavior therapy for women with high irritability who meet criteria for borderline personality disorder: A double-blind, placebo-controlled pilot study Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 69 2008 999 1005
57. M.M. Linehan, H. Schmidt III, L.A. Dimeff, J.C. Craft, J. Kanter, K.A. Comtois Dialectical behavior therapy for patients with borderline personality disorder and drug-dependence American Journal on Addictions 8 1999 279 292
58. M.M. Linehan, D.A. Tutek, H.L. Heard, H.E. Armstrong Interpersonal outcome of cognitive behavioral treatment for chronically suicidal borderline patients American Journal of Psychiatry 151 1994 1771 1776
59. R. MacLehose, B.C. Reeves, I.M. Harvey, T.A. Sheldon, I.T. Russell, A.M. Black A systematic review of comparisons of effect sizes derived from randomised and nonrandomised studies Health Technology Assessment 4 2000 1 154
60. G.E. Matt, T.D. Cook Threats to the validity of research syntheses H. Cooper L.V. Hedges The handbook of research synthesis 1994 Russell Sage Foundation New York, NY 503 520
61. S.F. McMain, P.S. Links, W.H. Gnam, T. Guimond, R.J. Cardish, L. Kormann, D.L. Streiner A randomized trial of dialectical behavior therapy versus general psychiatric management for borderline personality disorder American Journal of Psychiatry 166 2009 1365 1374
62. D. Moher, A. Liberati, J. Tetzlaff, D.G. Altman the PRISMA Group Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement Open Medicine 3 2009 123 130
63. D. Moher, B. Pham, A. Jones, D.J. Cook, A.R. Jadad, M. Moher, P. Tugwell, T.P. Klassen Does quality of reports of randomised trials affect estimates of intervention efficacy reported in meta-analyses? Lancet 352 1998 609 613 (Pubitemid 28380142)
64. S.B. Morris, R.P. DeShon Combining effect size estimates in meta-analysis with repeated measures and independent-groups designs Psychological Methods 7 2002 105 125
65. J.M. Oldham Borderline personality disorder and suicidality American Journal of Psychiatry 163 2006 20 26
66. L.-G. Öst Efficacy of the third wave of behavioral therapies: A systematic review and meta-analysis Behaviour Research and Therapy 46 2008 296 321
67. N. Prendergast, J. McCausland Dialectical behaviour therapy: A 12-month collaborative program in a local community setting Behaviour Change 24 2007 25 35
68. S.W. Raudenbush, A.S. Bryk Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods 2nd ed. 2002 Sage Thousand Oaks, CA
69. S. Raudenbush, A. Bryk, Y.F. Cheong, R.J. Congdon, M. du Toit HLM 6: Hierarchical linear and nonlinear modeling 2004 Scientific Software International Lincolnwood, IL
70. R. Rosenthal The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results Psychological Bulletin 86 1979 638 641
71. R. Rosenthal Meta-analytic procedures for social research 1991 Sage Newbury Park, CA
72. R. Rosenthal Parameter measures of effect size H. Cooper L.V. Hedges The handbook of research synthesis 1994 Russell Sage Foundation New York, NY 231 244
73. N. Rüsch, S. Schiel, P.W. Corrigan, F. Leihener, G.A. Jacob, M. Olschewski, M. Bohus Predictors of dropout from inpatient dialectical behavior therapy among women with borderline personality disorder Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 39 2008 497 503
74. J.S. Rustenbach Metaanalyse. Eine anwendungsorientierte Einführung [Meta-Analysis: A user-oriented introduction] 2003 Huber Bern, Germany
75. M.E.P. Seligman The effectiveness of psychotherapy. The Consumer Reports study American Psychologist 50 1995 956 974
76. W.R. Shadish, C.K. Haddock Combining estimates of effect size H. Cooper L.V. Hedges The handbook of research synthesis 1994 Russell Sage Foundation New York, NY 261 281
77. E.N. Shearin, M.M. Linehan Patient-therapist ratings and relationship to progress in dialectical behavior therapy for borderline personality disorder Behavior Therapy 23 1992 730 741
78. G.T. Sica Bias in research studies Radiology 238 2006 780 789
79. E.B. Simpson, S. Yen, E. Costello, K. Rosen, A. Begin, J. Pistorello, T. Pearlstein Combined dialectical behavior therapy and fluoxetine in the treatment of borderline personality disorder Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 65 2004 379 385
80. H.H. Strupp, L.M. Horowitz, M.J. Lambert Measuring patient changes in mood, anxiety, and personality disorders: Toward a core battery 1997 American Psychological Association Washington, DC
81. C.R. Swenson, C. Sanderson, R. Dulit, M.M. Linehan The application of dialectical behavior therapy for patients with borderline personality disorder on inpatient units Psychiatric Quarterly 72 2001 307 324
82. R.M. Turner Naturalistic evaluation of dialectical behavior therapy-oriented treatment for borderline personality disorder Cognitive and Behavioral Practice 7 2000 413 419
83. L.M.C. van den Bosch, M.W.J. Koeter, T. Stijnen, R. Verheul, W. van den Brink Sustained efficacy of dialectical behaviour therapy for borderline personality disorder Behaviour Research and Therapy 43 2005 1231 1241
84. L.M.C. van den Bosch, R. Verheul, G.M. Schippers, W. van den Brink Dialectical behavior therapy of borderline patients with and without substance use problems. Implementation and long-term effects Addictive Behaviors 27 2002 911 923
85. L.M.C. van den Bosch, R. Verheul, W. van den Brink Substance abuse in borderline personality disorder: Clinical and etiological correlates Journal of Personality Disorders 15 2001 416 424
86. R. Verheul, L.M.C. van den Bosch, M.W.J. Koeter, M.A.J. de Ridder, T. Stijnen, W. van den Brink Dialectical behaviour therapy for women with borderline personality disorder: 12-month, randomised clinical trial in the Netherlands British Journal of Psychiatry 182 2003 135 140
87. D. Westen, C.M. Novotny, H. Thompson-Brenner The empirical status of empirically supported psychotherapies: Assumptions, findings, and reporting in controlled clinical trials Psychological Bulletin 130 2004 631 663
88. M.C. Zanarini, F.R. Frankenburg, E.D. Dubo, A.E. Sickel, A. Trikha, A. Levin, V. Reynolds Axis I comorbidity of borderline personality disorder American Journal of Psychiatry 155 1998 1733 1739 (Pubitemid 28547499)
89. M. Zimmerman, J.I. Mattia Is posttraumatic stress disorder underdiagnosed in routine clinical settings? Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 187 1999 420 428