Narrating the postcolonial landscape: Archaeologies of race at Hadrian's Wall

Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers

Volumn 36, Issue 1, 2011, Pages 71-88

  Tolia Kelly, Divya P ^a  

^a DURHAM UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Archaeology; Exhibition; Hadrian's Wall; Heritage; Landscape narrative; Race

Indexed keywords

ARCHAEOLOGY; CRITICAL ANALYSIS; GEOGRAPHICAL RESEARCH; INTERDISCIPLINARY APPROACH; LITERATURE REVIEW; PERCEPTION; RACE;

EID: 78649784771     PISSN: 00202754     EISSN: 14755661     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1475-5661.2010.00414.x     Document Type: Article

References (125)

1. Ahmed S 2000 Strange encounters: embodied others in post-coloniality Routledge, London
2. Ahmed S, Castañeda C, Fortier A-M and Sheller M 2003 Uprootings/regroundings: questions of home and migration Berg, Oxford
3. Allason-Jones L 1989 A guide to the inscriptions and sculptured stones in the Museum of Antiquities Museum of Antiquities of the University and Society of Antiquaries of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne
4. Allason-Jones L 2001 Material culture and identity in James S and Millett M eds Britons and Romans: advancing an archaeological agenda Council for British Archaeology, London 19-25
5. Allason-Jones L 2005 Women in Roman Britain The British Museum, London
6. Anderson K 2007 Race and the crisis of humanism Routledge, London
7. Araeen R 2000 A new beginning: beyond postcolonial cultural theory and identity politics Third Text 14 3-20
8. Ashcroft B, Griffiths G and Tiffin H 1989 The empire writes back Routledge, London
9. Beck U and Sznaider N 2006 Unpacking cosmopolitanism for the social sciences British Journal of Sociology 57 1-23
10. Bennett T 2004 Pasts beyond memory: evolution, museums, colonialism Museum meanings series Routledge, London
11. Bernal M 1987 Black Athena: Afroasiatic roots of classical civilization, volume I: the fabrication of ancient Greece, 1785-1985 Rutgers University Press, New Jersey
12. Bhabha H K 1983 The other question... Screen 246 18-36
13. Birley E 1961 Research on Hadrian's Wall Titus Wilson, Kendal
14. Birley A R 2008 [1988] The African Emperor Septimius Severus Batsford, London
15. Bonnett A 1997 Geography, 'race' and Whiteness: invisible traditions, current challenges Area 29 193-9
16. Breeze D J 2006a Hadrian's Wall English Heritage, London
17. Breeze D 2006b J. Colingwood Bruce's handbook to the Roman Wall Society of Antiquaries, Newcastle-Upon-Tyne
18. Breeze D and Dobson B 2000 Hadrian's Wall Penguin, Oxford
19. Bruce J C 1879 Description of the monuments of Roman rule in the north of England Society and Antiquaries Newcastle-Upon-Tyne
20. Bruce J C 1886 Pilgrimage of 1849 Overprint from the proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Newcastle (II) G. Nicholson, South Shields
21. Bruce J C 1996 Handbook to the Roman wall 13th edn William Sang, Newcastle
22. Camden W 1806 [1586] Britannia Gough R trans J Nichols, London
23. Channel 4 2010 Black Britain Accessed July 2010
24. Code L 1996 Ecological thinking: the politics of epistemic location Oxford University Press, Oxford
25. Crampton A 2003 The art of nation-building: (re)presenting political transition at the South Africa National Gallery Cultural Geographies 10 218-42
26. Crang M 1994 Spacing times, telling times and narrating the past Time and Society 3 29-45
27. Croom A 2007 Roman furniture and fashion The History Press, Stroud
28. Daniels S 1993 Fields of vision: landscape imagery and national identity in England and the United States Polity Press, Princeton NJ
29. Daniels S and Lorimer H 2009 Narrating landscape and environment AHRC sponsored session RGS/IBG annual conference, Manchester
30. Darby W J 2000 Landscape and identity: geographies of nation and class in England Berg, Oxford
31. DCMS 2005 Understanding the future: museums and 21st century life Department for Culture, Media and Sport, London
32. De Certeau M 1988 The writing of history Columbia University Press, Columbia
33. Díaz-Andreu M 2007 A world history of nineteenth-century archaeology. Nationalism, colonialism, and the past Oxford University Press, Oxford
34. Dobson B and Mann J C 1973 The Roman Army in Britain and Britons in the Roman Army Britannia 4 191-205
35. Dyer R 1997 White Routledge, London
36. Echols E 1961 Herodian of Antioch's history of the Roman Empire (English translation) UCLA Press, Berkeley CA
37. Eckhardt H 2010a The African Queen Mail Online Accessed 3 April 2010
38. Eckhardt H ed 2010b Roman diasporas - archaeological approaches to mobility and diversity Journal of Roman Archaeology 18 161-79
39. El-Haj N A 2001 Facts on the ground: archaeological practice and territorial self-fashioning in Israeli society University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
40. Fitzjohn M 2007 Equality in the Colonies: concepts of equality in Sicily during the eight to sixth centuries bc World Archaeology 39 215-28
41. Foucault M 1980 Power/knowledge Harvester, Brighton
42. Freeman P W M 1997 From Momsen to Haverfield in Mattingly D ed Dialogues in Roman imperialism: power, discourse, and discrepant experience in the Roman Empire Journal of Roman Archaeology Supplementary Series 23 27-50
43. Fuller D 2008 Public geographies: taking stock Progress in Human Geography 6 1-11
44. Fuller D and Askins K 2007 The discomforting rise of public geographies Antipode 39 579-601
45. Fullwilley D 2008 The molecularisation of race: institutionalising human difference in pharmacogenetics practice Science as Culture 16 1-30
46. Gandhi L 1998 Postcolonial theory: an introduction Columbia University Press, Columbia NY
47. Gardner A 2007 An archaeology of identity: soldiers and society in later Roman Britain University College London Press, Walnut Creek
48. Gidley L 1870 Bede's ecclesiastical history of the English nation Parker, Oxford
49. Gilroy P 1991 'There ain't no black in the Union Jack': the cultural politics of race and nation University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
50. Gilroy P 1993 The Black Atlantic: modernity and double consciousness Harvard University Press/Verso, Cambridge MA
51. Gilroy P 2000 Against race: imagining political culture beyond the colour line Belnap Press, Harvard MA
52. Gosden C 2004 Archaeology and colonialism: cultural contact from 5000 bc to the present Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
53. Gosden C 2006 Race and racism in archaeology: introduction World Archaeology 38 1-7
54. Hall S 1990 Culture, identity and diaspora in Rutherford J ed Identity: community, culture, difference Lawrence and Wishart London
55. Hall S 1997 Representation: cultural representations and signifying practices Sage/The Open University Press, London
56. Hall S 1999 Un-settling the heritage, re-imagining the post-nation. Whose heritage? Third Text 13 3-13
57. Harris R 2009 Black British, brown British and British cultural studies Cultural Studies 23 483-512
58. Harrison F V 1998 Introduction: expanding the discourse on race American Anthropologist NS 100 609-31
59. Harvey D 2003 National identities and the politics of ancient heritage: continuity and change at ancient monuments in Britain and Irelc. 1675-1850 Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 4 473-87
60. Harvey D 2007 Cultures of antiquity and the practice of archaeology in Britain and Ireland (c. 1700-1850): a postcolonial perspective in McAtackney L, Paulus M and Piccini A eds Contemporary and historical archaeology in theory Archaeopress, Oxford 55-61
61. Haverfield F 1905 The Romanisation of Roman Britain 4th edn Clarendon, Oxford
62. Hazbun W 2008 Beaches, ruins, resorts: the politics of tourism in the Arab world University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis MN
63. Hingley R 1997 Resistance and domination: social change in Roman Britain in Mattingly D ed Dialogues in Roman imperialism: power, discourse, and discrepant experience in the Roman Empire Journal of Roman Archaeology Supplementary Series 23
64. Hingley R 2000 Roman officers and English gentlemen: the imperial origins of Roman archaeology Routledge, London
65. Hingley R 2005 Globalising Roman culture: unity, diversity, empire Routledge, London
66. Hingley R and Unwin C 2005 Boudica: Iron Age warrior queen Continuum, New York
67. Huntley J and Stallibrass H 1995 Regional review of plant and animal bones from excavations in northern England Durham Mimeo available from the author
68. Hutton W 1802 The history of the Roman wall John Nichols and Son, London
69. Isaac B 2004 The invention of racism in classical antiquity Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ
70. Jameson F 1981 The political unconscious: narratives as a socially symbolic act Cornell University Press, Ithaca NY
71. Jazeel T and McFarlane C 2010 The limits to responsibility: a postcolonial politics of academic knowledge production Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS 35 109-24
72. Kant I 1991 Of national characteristics, so far as they depend upon the distinct feeling of the beautiful and sublime Observations on the feeling of the beautiful and the sublime University of California Press, Berkeley CA
73. Kong L 1999 Cemeteries and columbaria, memorials and mausoleums: narrative and interpretation in the study of deathscapes in geography Australian Geographical Studies 37 1-10
74. Livingstone D 2002 Tropical hermeneutics: fragments for a historical narrative: an afterword Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 21 76-91
75. Longley P 2009 Accessed June 2010
76. Loomba A 1998 Colonialism/post-colonialism Routledge, London
77. Madge C, Raghuram P and Noxolo P 2009 Engaged pedagogy and responsibility Geoforum 40 34-45
78. Magie D 1922 The Scriptores Historiae Augustae English translation vol 1 Heinemann, London xxxvii
79. Mann J 1983 Legionary recruitment and veteran settlement during the principate Institute of Archaeology occasional paper 7 University of London, London
80. Mattingly D 1994 Tripolitania University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor MI
81. Mattingly D ed 1997 Dialogues in Roman imperialism: power, discourse, and discrepant experience in the Roman Empire Journal of Roman Archaeology Supplementary Series 23
82. Millet M 1990 The Romanisation of Britain Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
83. Moralee J 2008 Maximinus Thrax and the politics of race in late antiquity Greece & Rome 1 55-82
84. Morrison T 1990 The site of memory in Ferguson R, Gever M, Minh-ha T and West C eds Out there: marginalisation and contemporary cultures MIT Press, Cambridge 299-305
85. Nash C 2005 Geographies of relatedness Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 30 449-62
86. Noxolo P 2009 My paper, my paper: reflections on the embodied production of postcolonial geographical responsibility in academic writing Geoforum 40 55-65
87. Orser C ed 2001 Race and the archaeology of identity University of Utah Press, Utah
88. Raghuram P, Madge C and Noxolo P 2009 Rethinking responsibility and care for a postcolonial world Geoforum 40 34-45
89. Roth R E 2003 Towards a ceramic approach to social identity in the Roman world: some theoretical considerations in Romanisation? Digressus Supplement 1 35-45
90. Rowlands M J and Kristiansen K 1998 Social transformations in archaeology: global and local perspectives Routledge, London
91. Said E 1979 Orientalism Vintage, New York
92. Said E 1983 The world, the text and the critic Faber and Faber, London
93. Said E 1990 Narrative, geography and interpretation New Left Review I 180 March-April
94. Said E 1993 Culture and imperialism Alfred Knopf, New York
95. Shanks M and Tilley C 1987 Social theory and archaeology Polity Press, Cambridge
96. Sherwin-White A N 1967 Racial prejudice in ancient Rome Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
97. Skinner J 1978 [1801] Hadrian's Wall in 1801: observations on the Roman wall Kingsmead, Bath
98. Snowden F M 1970 Blacks in antiquity: Ethiopians in the Greco-Roman experience Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA
99. Snowden F M 1983 Before colour prejudice: an ancient view of blacks Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA
100. Spielvogel J 2003 Western civilisation: volume 4, to 1500 Thompson Learning, Belmont
101. Spielvogel J 2006 Septimius Severus WBG, Darmstadt
102. Spivak G C 1988 Can the subaltern speak? in Nelson C and Grossberg L eds Marxism and the interpretation of culture University of Illinois Press, Urbana 271-313
103. Stone P and MacKenzie R 1994 The excluded past: archaeology in education Routledge, London
104. Swan V and Monaghan J 1993 Head-pots: a North African tradition in Roman York The Yorkshire Archaeological Journal 65 21-38
105. Tenney F 1916 Race mixture in the Roman Empire The American Historical Review 21 689-708
106. Thatcher G 1921 The Roman Wall [of Hadrian] Truslove and Bray, London
107. The Guardian 2008 Weekend magazine 2 August 2
108. Thompson L A 1989 Romans and blacks Routledge, London
109. Tolia-Kelly D 2004a Landscape, race and memory: biographical mapping of the routes of British Asian landscape values Landscape Research 29 277-92
110. Tolia-Kelly D 2004b Locating processes of identification: studying the precipitates of re-memory through artefacts in the British Asian home Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 29 314-29
111. Tolia-Kelly D 2004c Materializing post-colonial geographies: examining the textural landscapes of migration in the South Asian home Geoforum 35 675-88
112. Tolia-Kelly D P 2010 The geographies of cultural geography I: identities, bodies and race Progress in Human Geography 34 358-67
113. Tolia-Kelly D P and Crang M 2010 Nation, race and affect: senses and sensibilities at national heritage sites Environment and Planning A doi.
114. Tuan Y-F 1991 Language and the making of place: a narrative-descriptive approach Annals of the Association of American Geographers 81 684-96
115. Ward K 2007 'Public intellectuals', geography, its representations and its publics Geoforum 38 1058-64
116. Webster J 1996 Roman imperialism and the post imperial in Webster J and Cooper N ed Roman Imperialism: post-colonial perspectives University of Leicester, Leicester 1-17
117. Webster J 1997 A negotiated syncretism: readings on the development of Romano-Celtic religion in Mattingly D ed Dialogues in Roman Imperialism: power, discourse, and discrepant experience in the Roman Empire Journal of Roman Archaeology 23 165-84
118. Webster J 2001 Creolizing the Roman provinces American Journal of Archaeology 105 209-25
119. Webster J 2007 Rome and the 'Barbarians' in Alcock S E and Osborne R eds Classical archaeology Blackwell, London 401-24
120. White H 1978 The tropics of discourse: essays in cultural criticism John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore MD
121. Winlow H 2001 Anthropometric cartography: constructing Scottish racial identity in the early twentieth century Journal of Historical Geography 27 507-28
122. Winlow H 2009 Mapping, race and ethnicity in Thrift N and Kitchen R eds International encyclopedia of human geography Elsevier, Oxford
123. Witcher R, Tolia-Kelly D P and Hingley R 2010 Archaeologies of landscape: excavating the materialities of Hadrian's Wall Journal of Material Culture 15 105-28
124. Writing on the Wall 2006 An international writing project for Hadrian's Wall 2001-2006 ARTS UK, Newcastle-Upon-Tyne
125. Young R J C 2007 The idea of English ethnicity Blackwell, Oxford