Noise in open plan classrooms in primary schools: A review

Noise and Health

Volumn 12, Issue 49, 2010, Pages 225-234

  Shield, Bridget ^a   Greenland, Emma ^b   Dockrell, Julie ^c  

^a LONDON SOUTH BANK UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^b WSP   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Acoustics; classrooms; noise; open plan; schools; speech intelligibility

Indexed keywords

ACOUSTICS; ATTENTION; CHILD; CONSTRUCTION WORK AND ARCHITECTURAL PHENOMENA; HUMAN; NOISE; REVIEW; SCHOOL; SPEECH INTELLIGIBILITY;

ACOUSTICS; ATTENTION; CHILD; FACILITY DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION; HUMANS; NOISE; SCHOOLS; SPEECH INTELLIGIBILITY;

EID: 77957586800     PISSN: 14631741     EISSN: 19984030     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.4103/1463-1741.70501     Document Type: Article

References (124)

1. Department for Education and Skills. Schools for the Future - Exemplar Designs: Concepts and Ideas. Available from: http://www.partnershipsforschools. org.uk.
2. Mikkelsen A. Hellerup School - A novel teaching paradigm in Denmark. International Congress for School Effectiveness and Improvement (ISCEI), Sydney, Australia. Available from: http://www.ankermikkelsen. dk/dokumenter/ ICSEI%202003II.doc.
3. Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment - Creating Excellent Primary Schools - A Guide for Clients. London, UK: CABE; 2010.
4. Wilson O, Dodd G, Valentine J. Classroom Acoustics - A New Zealand Perspective. Wellington, NZ: The Oticon Foundation in New Zealand; 2002.
5. Martinho M, de Silva S. Open plan schools in Portugal: Failure or innovation? PEB Exchange 2008/12, OECD; 2008.
6. Greenland E. Acoustics of open plan classrooms in primary schools. PhD thesis. London, UK: London South Bank University; 2009.
7. Shield B, Greenland E, Dockrell J, Rigby K. Children's perceptions of speech and hearing in open plan and enclosed classrooms. Proc Inst Acoust 2008;30:10-9.
8. Pearson E. British Primary Schools Today: Trends in School Design. London: Macmillan Education Ltd; 1972.
9. Maclure S. Educational Development and School Building: Aspects of public policy 1945-73. Essex: Longman Group Ltd; 1984.
10. Dudek M. Architecture of Schools: The new learning environments. Essex: Longman Group Ltd; 2000.
11. Brogdan M. Open Plan Primary Schools: Rhetoric and Reality. Sch Organ 1983;3:27-42.
12. Baines G. Some Trends in British Education. London, UK: Institute of Education; c1962-1966.
13. Medd D. The influence of education on the design of school furniture. In: McNicholas J, editor. Aspects of Education no. 21: Open Plan Primary Schools. Hull, UK: University of Hull; 1978.
14. Corrie M. Space for Learning: Teaching and learning in some Scottish open plan primary schools. Edinburgh, UK: Scottish Council for Research in Education; 1974.
15. McNicholas J. Schoolroom to Open Plan: The development of primary school design. In: McNicholas J, editor. Aspects of Education no. 21: Open Plan Primary Schools. Hull, UK: University of Hull; 1978.
16. Bennett N. Open Plan Schools: Teaching, Curriculum, Design. Windsor, UK: NFER Publishing Company Ltd; 1980.
17. Bennett N, Andreae J, Hegarty P, Wade, B. Open Plan Schools: Teaching, Curriculum, Design. Windsor, UK: Schools Council Publications (NFER); 1980.
18. Bennett N. The organisation of teaching and curriculum in open plan schools. In: McNicholas J, editor. Aspects of Education no. 21: Open Plan Primary Schools. Hull, UK: University of Hull; 1978.
19. Walsh D. Noise levels and annoyance in open plan educational facilities. J Archit Res 1975;4:5-16.
20. Heppell S, Chapman C, Millwood R, Constable M, Furness J. Building learning futures. Available from: http://www.rubble.heppell.net/cabe/final- reportpdf.
21. Washnor E. Innovative Pedagogy and School Facilities. Minneapolis, USA: DesignShare.com; 2003.
22. Spring M. Bexley Academy: Qualified Success. Building 13 June 2008.
23. Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF). Schools for the Future. Project Faraday, Exemplar Designs for Science. Available from: https://www.mail.lsbu.ac.uk/exchweb/bin/redir.asp? URL=http://www.teachernet. gov. uk/docbank/index.cfm?id=12523.
24. Costa M. Teacher adaptations to an open area teaching and learning environment. Educ Insights. Available from http://www.ccfi.educ.ubc. ca/publication/insights/v08n03/articles/costa.html.
25. Bennett N. Open plan primary schools: Findings and implications. Educ 1980;8:45-50.
26. National Union of Teachers (NUT). Open planning with special reference to primary schools. London, UK: NUT Publications; 1975.
27. Bennett N, Batley D. Pupils' reactions to open plan. Educ 1977;5:20-3.
28. Irish National Teachers' Organisation. Co-operative teaching in shared area classrooms. 1984.
29. Stern C, Keislar E. Teacher attitudes and attitude change: A research review. J Res Dev Educ 1997;10:63-76.
30. Weinstein C. Noise and reading performance in an open space school. J Educ Res 1977;72:210-3.
31. Jarman C. The organisation of primary schools: The oxfordshire experience. In: Bell S, editor. The Organisation of Open Plan Primary Schools: A National Course. Glasgow, UK: Jordanhill College of Education; 1978.
32. Kyzar BL. Comparison of instructional practices in classrooms of different design. Final Report. USA: Northwestern State University; 1971.
33. Galton M. Inside the primary classroom. London, UK: Routledge; 1980.
34. Kingsbury H, Taylor D. Acoustical conditions in open plan classrooms. Sound Vib 1970;4:19-24.
35. Yerges JF, Bollinger JG. Development and utilization of open plan educational facilities. Sound Vib 1972;6:19-24.
36. Schellenberg B. Noise and sound control in open plan schools. Available from: US Dept. of Health Education and Welfare; 1975. http://www.eric.ed.gov/ PDFS/ED109801pdf.
37. California State Department for Education USA. School sound level study. School Facilities and Transportation Division; 1986.
38. Schneider M. Do school facilities affect academic outcomes? Washington DC, USA: National Clearinghouse for Educational Facilities; 2002.
39. Earthman GI. Where children learn: A discussion of how a facility affects learning. Annual meeting of Virginia Educational Facility Planners (ED419368); February 1998.
40. Crandell C, Smaldino J, Flexer C. Sound field FM amplification: Theory and practical applications. Los Angeles, USA: Singular Press; 1995.
41. Nabelek A. Room acoustics and speech perception. In: Katz J, editor. Handbook of Clinical Audiology. Baltimore, USA: Williams and Wilkins; 1994.
42. Shield BM, Dockrell JE. The effects of noise on children at school: A review. J Build Acoust 2003;10:97-116.
43. Shield B, Dockrell J, Asker R, Tachmatzidis I. The effects of noise on the attainments and cognitive development of primary school children. Final report for Department of Health and DETR; 2002.
44. Shield B, Dockrell J. The effects of environmental and classroom noise on the academic attainments of primary school children. J Acoust Soc Am 2008;123:133-44.
45. Hygge S. Classroom experiments on the effects of difference noise sources and sound levels on long-term recall and recognition in children. Appl Cogn Psychol 2003;17:895-914.
46. Lercher P, Evans GW, Meiss M. Ambient noise and cognitive processes among primary school children. Environ Behav 2003;35:725-35.
47. Dockrell J, Shield B. Acoustical barriers in classrooms: The impact of noise on performance in the classroom. Br Educ Res J 2006;32:509-25.
48. Evans GW, Maxwell L. Chronic noise exposure and reading deficits: The mediating effects of language acquisition. Environ Behav 1997;29:638-57.
49. Lukas JS, DuPree RB, Swing JW. Effects of noise on academic achievement and classroom behavior. Office of Noise Control, California Dept. of Health Services. Report no. FHWA/CA/DOHS-81/01. Sept 1981.
50. Bronzaft AL, McCarthy DP. The effect of elevated train noise on reading ability. Environ Behav 1975;7:517-27.
51. Bronzaft AL. The effect of a noise abatement program on reading ability. J Environ Psychol 1981;1:215-22.
52. Haines MM, Stansfeld SA, Brentall S, Head J, Berry B, Jiggins M, et al. West London schools study: The effects of chronic aircraft noise exposure on child health. Psychol Med 2001;31:1385-96. (Pubitemid 33040362)
53. Maxwell LE, Evans GW. The effects of noise on pre-school children's prereading skills. J Environ Psychol 2000;20:91-7.
54. Evans GW, Lepore SJ. Non-auditory effects of noise on children: A critical review. Child Environ 1993;10:31-51.
55. Hetu R, Truchon-Gagnon C. Problems of noise in school settings: A review of literature and the results of an exploratory study. J Speech Lang Pathol Audiol 1990;14:31-8.
56. Sanz S, Garcia AM. Road traffic noise around schools: A risk for pupil's performance? Int Arch Occup Environ Health 1993;65:205-7.
57. Barnett DL, Nichols AC, Gould DG. The effects of open space versus traditional on the auditory selective attending skills of elementary schools children. Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch 1982;13:138-43.
58. Fisher K. A critical pedagogy of space. PhD Thesis. University of South Australia; 2000.
59. Cohen S, Evans GW, Krantz DS. Physiological, motivational and cognitive effects of aircraft noise on children moving from the laboratory to the field. Am Psychol 1980;35:231-43.
60. Dockrell JE, Shield BM. Children's perceptions of their acoustic environment at school and at home. J Acoust Soc Am 2004;115:2964-73.
61. Alcantara JI, Weisblatt EJ, Moore BC, Bolton PF. Speech in noise perception in high-functioning individuals with autism or Asperger's Syndrome. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 2004;45:1107-14.
62. Byrne C, Dillon H, Khann T. An international comparison of long-term average speech spectra. J Acoust Soc Am 1994;96:2108-20.
63. Nelson PB. Sound in the classroom: Why children need quiet. ASHRAE J February 2003. p. 22-5.
64. Mayo L, Florentine M, Buus S. Age of secondary language acquisition and perception of speech in noise. J Speech Lang Hear Res 1997;40:686-93.
65. Nelson PB, Soli S. Acoustical barriers to learning: Children at risk in every classroom. Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch 2000;31:356-61.
66. Nelson PB. Classroom noise and children learning through a second language: Double Jeopardy? Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch 2005;36:219-29.
67. Nabelek AK, Donahue AM. Perception of consonants in reverberation by native and non-native listeners. J Acoust Soc Am 1984;75:632-4.
68. Bovo R, Ciorba A, Abenante L, Busi M, Martini A. Effects of classroom noise and reverberation on the speech perception of bilingual children learning in their second language. Proc Inst Acoust 2008;30:662-6.
69. Department of Education and Science (DES). Children and their Primary Schools: A report of the Central Advisory Council for Education (England). Vol. 1: The Report. ('Plowden Report'). HMSO, London, UK; 1967.
70. Bradlow AR, Kraus N, Hayes E. Speaking clearly for children with learning disabilities: Sentence perception in noise. J Speech Lang Hear Res 2003;46:80-97.
71. Breier JL. Dissociation of sensitivity and response bias in children with attention defcit/hyperactivity disorder during central auditory masking. Neuropsychology 2002;16:28-34.
72. Bess FH, Dodd-Murphy J, Parker RA. Children with minimal sensorineural hearing loss: Prevalence educational performance and functional status. Ear Hear 1998;19:339-54.
73. Metropolitan Toronto School Board (Ontario). E6: Academic Evaluation. A Report on SEF Open Plan Schools; 1975.
74. Yerges LF. The open plan school revisited. Noise Control Engl 1976;6:22-9.
75. Knez I, Hygge S. Irrelevant speech and indoor lighting: Effects on cognitive performance and self-reported affect. Appl Cogn Psychol 2002;16:709-18.
76. Finitzo-Hieber T, Roeser R, Downs D. Classroom Acoustics. In: Roeser RJ, Downs MP, editors. Auditory disorders in school children. San Diego: Thieme; 1988. p. 221-33.
77. Krutchen PM. Survey of teachers' perceptions in open area schools. USA: University of Calgary; 1971.
78. Murray NE. The opinions of teachers teaching in open space elementary schools in the Windsor Separate School Board. Michigan, USA: Wayne State University; 1971.
79. Justus JE. An educator views open spaces and the planning process. CEFP J 1971;9:12-4.
80. Ledbetter TA. A study of open spaces for teaching. USA: University of Tenessee; 1969.
81. Kingsbury H. Acoustics in the changing classroom. Educ Technol March 1973. p. 62-4.
82. Shield BM, Dockrell JE. External and internal noise surveys of London Primary Schools. J Acoust Soc Am 2004;115:730-8.
83. Picard M, Bradley JS. Revisiting speech interference in classrooms. Audiology 2001;40:221-44.
84. MacKenzie D. Noise sources and levels in UK schools. Proc Int Symp on Noise Control and Acoustics for Ed Buildings. Istanbul, Turkey: Proc Turkish Acoust Soc; 2000. p. 97-106.
85. Airey S. A survey of acoustical standards in UK classrooms and their effect on pupils and teachers. Proc Inst Acoust 1998;20:14-21.
86. Hay B. A pilot study of classroom noise levels and teachers' reactions. Voice 1995;4:127-34.
87. Moodley A. Acoustic conditions in mainstream classrooms. J Br Assoc Teach Deaf (BATOD) 1989;13:48-54.
88. Sato H, Bradley JS. Evaluation of acoustical conditions for speech communication in working elementary school classrooms. J Acoust Soc Am 2008;123:2064-77.
89. Charlton Smith Partnership. Design for educationally appropriate acoustic characteristics in open plan schools. Research Report to The Scottish Executive; 2005.
90. Charlton-Smith N. Some acoustic issues in open plan schools. Proc Inst Acoust 2003;25:141-7.
91. Department for Education and Skills. Building Bulletin 93 Acoustic Design of Schools. TSO, London. Available from: http://www.teachernet.gov. uk/acoustics.
92. Mackenzie DJ, Airey S. Classroom Acoustics: A research project (Summary Report). Heriott-Watt University; 1999.
93. Kyzar BL. Comparison of instructional practices in classrooms of different design. Final Report. Northwestern State University, USA; 1971.
94. Fitzroy D, Reid JL. Acoustical environment of school buildings. Technical Report 1. Educational Facilities Laboratories. New York; 1963.
95. Airey SL, MacKenzie DJ, Craik RJ. Can you hear me at the back? Effective communication in classrooms. In: Carter N, Job RF, editors. Proc 7th Int Congress on Noise as a Public Health Problem. Vol. 1. Sydney: Noise Effects'98; 1998. p. 195-9.
96. Hamman S. Sound polluted schools. Sch Manage 1970;14:14-5.
97. Choudhury NK. Sound diffraction around moveable partitions in teaching spaces. Educational Building Report 1, Bangkok; 1973.
98. Durlak JT, Lehman J. User awareness and sensitivity to open space: A study of traditional and open plan schools. In: Canter DV, Lee T, editors. Psychology and the Built Environment. London, UK: Architectural Press; 1974.
99. Brunetti FA. Open Space: A status report. Memo No. 1 School Environment Study, Stanford University, California, USA; 1971.
100. Greenland E, Shield B, Dockrell J. Control of noise for speech intelligibility in open plan classrooms. Proc Euronoise 2009. Scotland, UK: Edinburgh; 2009.
101. Miller JD. Effects of noise on people. J Acoust Soc Am 1974;56:729-64.
102. Houtgast T. The effect of ambient noise on speech intelligibility in classrooms. Appl Acoust 1981;14:15-25.
103. American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. Acoustics in educational settings: Position statement. Available from: http//www.asha.org.
104. Bradley JS. Speech intelligibility studies in classrooms. J Acoust Soc Am 1986;80:846-54.
105. Bradley JS, Sato H. The intelligibility of speech in elementary school classrooms. J Acoust Soc Am 2008;123:2078-86.
106. Yang W, Bradley JS. Effects of room acoustics on the intelligibility of speech in classrooms for young children. J Acoust Soc Am 2009;125:922-33.
107. Petersen CM. Children and noise - prevention of adverse effects. Denmark: National Institute of Public Health; 2002.
108. Greenland E, Shield B, Dockrell J. Speech transmission index criteria for open plan classrooms in British primary schools. Proc. Internoise 2009: Innovations in Practical Noise Control. Ottawa, Canada; 2009
109. Greenland E, Shield B, Dockrell J. Acoustics in open plan classrooms - towards revised speech intelligibility criteria. Proc Inst Acoust 2009;31.
110. Bradley JS. From speech privacy to speech security. Revista de Acustica 2007;38:103-27.
111. Erhvervs-og Boligstyrelsen. Vejledning om lydforhold i undervisningsog daginstitutionsbyggeri. (Guidance on acoustics in teaching and day-care centre construction). Available from: http://www.ebst.dk/file/1920/vejledning-om- lydforhold-institutionerpdf.
112. Swedish Standards Institute SIS. SS 25268:2007 Acoustics - Sound classification of spaces in buildings - Institutional premises, rooms for education, preschools and leisure-time centres, rooms for office work and hotels; 2007.
113. American National Standards Institute. Standard S12.60-2002. Acoustical Performance Criteria, Design Requirements, and Guidelines for Schools; 2002.
114. School Facilities and Transportation Division. School sound level study, California State Department for Education USA; 1986.
115. Department for Education and Science (DES). Architects and Building Branch Paper No. 3: Delf Hill Middle School (an appraisal). London: HMSO; 1978.
116. Smith N. Some acoustic problems of open plan schools. Nottingham, UK: University of Nottingham; 1974.
117. Metropolitan Toronto School Board (Ontario). Toronto, Canada: Hints for survival in open plan schools; 1973.
118. Frese CW. Give your school the silent treatment. American Sch Univ 1973;46:47-52.
119. Webb R, Vulliamy G. The impact of New Labour's education policy on Teachers and Teaching at Key Stage 2. FORUM 2006;48:145-58.
120. Pake J, Harlen W, Powney J. Teachers' and Pupils' days in the primary classroom, SCRE Research Report No. 93. The Scottish Council for Research in Education; 1999.
121. Department for Education and Science (DfES). Building Bulletin 99: Briefing Framework for Primary School Projects. Incorporating primary school revision to BB82: Area Guidelines for Schools. London: HMSO; 2004.
122. Wall K, Dockrell J, Peacey N. Research Survey 6/1 Primary schools: The built environment. The Primary Review. Cambridge, UK: University of Cambridge; 2008.
123. Crandell C, Smaldino J. An update of classroom acoustics for children with hearing impairment. Volta Rev 1995;96:291-306.
124. Dockrell J, Shield B, Rigby K. Acoustic guidelines and teacher strategies for optimising learning conditions in classrooms for children with hearing problems. In: Fabry DA, Johnson CD, editors. Access: Achieving Clear Communication Employing Sound Solutions 2003. Proceedings of the First International Conference. Phonak AG; 2004.