Insightful or wishful: Lawyers' Ability to Predict Case Outcomes

Psychology, Public Policy, and Law

Volumn 16, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 133-157

  Goodman Delahunty, Jane ^a   Granhag, Pär Anders ^b   Hartwig, Maria ^c   Loftus, Elizabeth F ^d  

^a CHARLES STURT UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF GOTHENBURG   (Sweden)

^c JOHN JAY COLLEGE OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE   (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

Author keywords

Case predictions; Confidence judgments; Legal decision making; Metacognitive realism

Indexed keywords

EID: 77955017159     PISSN: 10768971     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1037/a0019060     Document Type: Article

References (70)

1. Allwood C.M., Granhag P.A. The effects of arguments on realism in confidence judgments. Acta Psychologica 1996, 91:99-119.
2. Allwood C.M., Granhag P.A. Feelings of confidence and the realism of confidence judgments in everyday life. Judgment and decision making: Neo-Brunswikian and process-tracing approaches 1999, 123-146. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ. P. Juslin, H. Montgomery (Eds.).
3. Babad E., Hills M., O'Driscoll M. Factors influencing wishful thinking and predictions of election outcomes. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 1992, 13:461-476.
4. Babcock L., Loewenstein G., Issacharoff S. Creating convergence: Debiasing biased litigants. Law & Social Inquiry 1997, 22:913-925.
5. Babcock L., Loewenstein G. Explaining bargaining impasse: The role of self-serving biases. Journal of Economic Perspectives 1997, 11:109-126.
6. Braun P.A., Yaniv L. A case study of expert judgment: Economists' probabilities versus base-rate model forecasts. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 1992, 5:217-231.
7. Brazil W.D. What lawyers want from judges in the settlement arena. Federal Rules 1985, December, 85-101.
8. Brazil W.D., Kahn M.A., Newman J.P., Gold J.Z. Early neutral evaluation: An experimental effort to expedite dispute resolution. Judicature 1986, 69:279-285.
9. Brehm J.W. Post-decision changes in desirability of alternatives. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 1956, 52:348-359.
10. Brenner L.A., Koehler D.J., Liberman V., Tversky A. Overconfidence in probability and frequency judgments: A critical examination. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 1996, 65:212-219.
11. Carroll J.S. The effect of imagining an event on expectations for the event: An interpretation in terms of the availability heuristic. Journal of Experimental Psychology 1978, 14:88-96.
12. Dollinger S. The illusion of control. Favorite activities for the teaching of psychology 2008, 201-202. American Psychological Association, Washington, DC. L.T. Benjamin (Ed.).
13. Dougherty M.R.P. Integration of the ecological and error models of overconfidence using a multiple trace memory model. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 2001, 130:579-599.
14. Dunning D., Griffin D.W., Milojkovic J.D., Ross L. The overconfidence effect in social predictions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1990, 58:568-581.
15. English P., Sales B. More than the law: Behavioral and social facts in legal decision making 2005, American Psychological Association, Washington, DC.
16. Fiske S.T., Taylor S.E. Social cognition, from brains to culture 2008, McGraw-Hill Higher Education, Columbus, OH.
17. Flavell J. Theory-of-mind development: Retrospect and prospect. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 2004, 50:274-290.
18. Gigerenzer G., Hoffrage U., Kleinbolting H. Probabilistic mental models: A Brunswikian theory of confidence. Psychological Review 1991, 98:506-528.
19. Gilbert D. Stumbling on happiness 2006, Alfred A. Knopf, New York.
20. Gilovich T., Kerr M., Husted Medvec V. Effect of temporal perspective on subjective confidence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1993, 4:552-560.
21. Gollwitzer P., Schaal B. Metacognition in action: The importance of implementation intentions. Personality and Social Psychology Review 1998, 2:124-136.
22. González-Vallejo C., Bonham A. Aligning confidence with accuracy: Revisiting the role of feedback. Acta Psychologica 2007, 125:221-239.
23. Griffin D., Tversky A. The weighing of evidence and the determinants of confidence. Cognitive Psychology 1992, 24:411-435.
24. Harley E. Hindsight bias in legal decision making. Social Cognition 2007, 25:48-63.
25. Hoch J.S. Availability and interference in predictive judgment. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition 1984, 10:649-662.
26. Hogarth R.M. Educating intuition 2001, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
27. Hogarth R.M., Gibbs B., McKenzie C., Marquis M. Learning from feedback: Exactingness and incentives. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 1991, 17:734-752.
28. Hogarth R.M., Makridakis S. Forecasting and planning: An evaluation. Management Science 1981, 27:115-138.
29. Horowitz I.A., Willging T.E. The psychology of law: Integrations and applications 1984, Little, Brown, Boston.
30. Jay S. The dilemmas of attorney contingent fees. The Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics 1989, 2:813-884.
31. Kahneman D. On the psychology of prediction. Psychological Review 1973, 80:237-251.
32. Kahneman D., Slovic P., Tversky A. Judgments under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases 1982, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
33. Keren G. Facing uncertainty in the game of bridge: A calibration study. Organizational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes 1987, 39:98-114.
34. Keren G., Raaijmakers J.G.W. On between-subjects versus within-subjects comparisons in testing utility theory. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 1988, 41:233-247.
35. Koriat A. Metacognition research: An interim report. Applied metacognition 2002, 261-286. Cambridge University Press, New York.
36. Koriat A., Lichtenstein S., Fischhoff B. Reasons for confidence. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 1980, 6:107-118.
37. Kunda Z. The case for motivated reasoning. Psychological Bulletin 1990, 108:480-498.
38. Langens T. Regulatory focus and illusions of control. Personality and SocialPsychology Bulletin 2007, 33:226-237.
39. Langer E.J. The illusion of control. Journal of Personality and Social psychology 1975, 32:311-328.
40. Levine D. Early neutral evaluation: A follow-up report. Judicature 1987, 70:236-240.
41. Lichtenstein S., Fischhoff B. Do those who know more also know more about how much they know?. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 1977, 20:159-183.
42. Loewenstein G., Issacharoff A., Camerer C., Babcock L. Self-serving assessments of fairness and pretrial bargaining. The Journal of Legal Studies 1993, 22:135-159.
43. Loftus E.F., Wagenaar W.A. Lawyers' predictions of success. Jurimetrics Journal 1988, 28:437-453.
44. Lord C.G., Lepper M.R., Preston E. Considering the opposite: A corrective strategy for social judgment. Journal and Personality and Social Psychology 1984, 47:1231-1243.
45. Malsch, M. (1989). Voorspellingen van rechterlijke beslissingen door advocaten. Nederlandse samenvatting van " Lawyers' predictions of judicial decisions: A study on calibration of experts." Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Rijksuniversiteit Leiden, Leiden, the Netherlands.
46. Malsch M. Advocaten voorspellen de uitkomst van hun zaken [Lawyers' predictions of judicial decisions: A study on calibration of experts] 1990, Swets & Zeitlinger, Lisse, the Netherlands.
47. Meeks J., Hicks J., Marsh R. Metacognitive awareness of event-based prospective memory. Consciousness and Cognition: An International Journal 2007, 16:997-1004.
48. Milburn M.A. Sources of bias in the prediction of future events. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 1978, 21:17-26.
49. Moore D., Healy P. The trouble with overconfidence. Psychological Review 2008, 115:502-517.
50. Moore D.A., Cain D.M. Overconfidence and unconfidence: When and why people underestimate (and overestimate) the competition. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2007, 103:197-213.
51. Murphy A.H., Winkler R.L. Forecasters and probability forecasts: Some current problems. Bulletin of American Meteorological Society 1971, 52:239-247.
52. Newby-Clark I.R., Ross M., Buehler R., Koehler D.J., Griffin D. People focus on optimistic scenarios and disregard pessimistic scenarios while predicting task completion times. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied 2000, 3:171-182.
53. Paese P.W., Feuer M.A. Decisions, actions, and the appropriateness of confidence in knowledge. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 1991, 4:1-16.
54. Pallier G. Gender differences in the self-assessment of accuracy on cognitive tasks. Sex Roles 2003, 48:265-276.
55. Perfect T., Schwartz B. Applied metacognition 2002, Cambridge University Press, New York.
56. Rehm J.T., Gadenne V. Intuitive predictions and professional forecasts: Cognitive processes and social consequences 1990, Pergamon Press, Oxford, England.
57. Ross H.L. Settled out of court 1970, Aldine, Chicago.
58. Schuck P.H. The role of judges in settling complex cases: The Agent Orange example. The University of Chicago Law Review 1986, 53:337-365.
59. Sherman J.S., Cialdini R.B., Schwartzman D.F., Reynolds K.D. Imagining an event can heighten or lower the perceived likelihood of contracting a disease: The mediating effect of ease of imagery. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 1985, 11:118-127.
60. Simon W.H. Ethical discretion in lawyering. Harvard Law Review 1988, 101:1083-1145.
61. Stone E.R., Opel R.B. Training to improve calibration and discrimination: The effects of performance and environmental feedback. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2000, 83(2):282-309.
62. Tversky A., Kahneman D. Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Science 1974, 185:1124-1131.
63. Vallone R.P., Griffin D.W., Lin S., Ross L. Overconfident predictions of future actions and outcomes by self and others. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1990, 58:582-592.
64. Von Winterfeldt D., Edwards W. Egocentrism as a source of unrealistic optimism. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1986, 53:421-430.
65. Vreugdenhil, H. (1993). Confidence in knowledge: Studies on the calibration of subjective probabilities. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
66. Weinstein N.D. Unrealistic optimism about future life events. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1980, 39:806-820.
67. Weinstein N.D. Unrealistic optimism about susceptibility for health problems. Journal of Behavioral Medicine 1982, 5:441-460.
68. Weinstein N.D. Reducing unrealistic optimism about illness susceptibility. Health Psychology 1983, 2:11-20.
69. Wissler R.L. When does familiarity breed content? A study of the role of different forms of ADR education and experience in attorneys' ADR recommendations. Pepperdine Dispute Resolution Law Journal 2002, 2:199-217.
70. Wittman D. Dispute resolution, bargaining, and the selection of cases for trial: A study of biased and unbiased data. The Journal of Legal Studies 1988, XVII:313-352.