Validity of rorschach inkblot scores for discriminating psychopaths from nonpsychopaths in forensic populations: a meta-analysis

Psychological Assessment

Volumn 22, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 336-349

  Wood, James M ^a   Lilienfeld, Scott O ^b   Nezworski, M Teresa ^c   Garb, Howard N ^c   Allen, Keli Holloway ^a   Wildermuth, Jessica L ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT EL PASO   (United States)

^b EMORY UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c WILFORD HALL MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

Author keywords

Comprehensive system; Forensics; Meta analysis; Psychopathy; Rorschach

Indexed keywords

AGGRESSION; ARTICLE; DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS; FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY; HARE PSYCHOPATHY CHECKLIST; HUMAN; NAMED INVENTORIES, QUESTIONNAIRES AND RATING SCALES; PERSONALITY TEST; PSYCHOPATHY; SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS; VALIDITY;

ADULT; ANTISOCIAL PERSONALITY DISORDER; CONFOUNDING FACTORS (EPIDEMIOLOGY); DECEPTION; DIAGNOSIS, DIFFERENTIAL; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MALINGERING; MIDDLE AGED; PRISONERS; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; RESEARCH DESIGN; RORSCHACH TEST;

EID: 77953908637     PISSN: 10403590     EISSN: 1939134X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1037/a0018998     Document Type: Article

References (107)

1. Diagnostic and statistical manual of psychiatric disorders 2000, American Psychiatric Association, Author, Washington, DC. 4th ed., text rev.
2. Aronow E., Reznikoff M. Rorschach content interpretation 1976, Grune & Stratton, New York, NY.
3. Ballard D.W. Rorschach aggression variables of male juvenile offenders. Dissertation Abstracts International 2006, 66:5076B.
4. Begg C.B. Publication bias. The handbook of research synthesis 1994, 399-409. Russell Sage Foundation, New York, NY. H. Cooper, L.V. Hedges (Eds.).
5. Borum R., Grisso T. Psychological test use in criminal forensic evaluation. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 1995, 26:465-473.
6. Cleckley H. The mask of sanity 1982, Mosby, St Louis, MO, (Original work published in 1941). 6th ed.
7. Cooke D.J., Michie C. Refining the construct of psychopathy: Toward a hierarchical model. Psychological Assessment 2001, 13:171-188.
8. Cunliffe T. A Rorschach investigation of incarcerated female psychopaths. Dissertation Abstracts International 2002, 63:1058B.
9. Cunliffe T., Gacono C. A Rorschach investigation of incarcerated antisocial personality disordered female offenders. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology 2005, 49:530-547.
10. Dansie K.R. The relationship between Rorschach aggressive indices and level of violence in juvenile delinquents. Dissertation Abstracts International 2004, 64:2380A.
11. Darcangelo S.M. Psychological and personality correlates of the Massachusetts Treatment Center classification system for rapists. Dissertation Abstracts International 1997, 58:2115B.
12. Edens J.F., Buffington J.K., Tomicic T.L. An investigation of the relationship between psychopathic traits and malingering on the Psychopathic Personality Inventory. Assessment 2000, 7:281-296.
13. Edens J.F., Marcus D.K., Lilienfeld S.O., Poythress N.G. Psychopathic, not psychopath: Taxometric evidence for the dimensional structure of psychopathy. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 2006, 115:131-144.
14. Egozi-Profeta V.L. A comparison of the Roemer and the Rorschach tests as tools for distinguishing characteristics of psychopathy. Dissertation Abstracts International 1999, 60:1345B.
15. Exner J.E. Rorschach responses as an index of narcissism. Journal of Projective Techniques and Personality Assessment 1969, 33:324-330.
16. Exner J.E. The Rorschach: A comprehensive system: Vol. 1. Basic foundations 1986, Wiley, New York, NY. 2nd ed.
17. Exner J.E. The Rorschach: A comprehensive system: Vol. 1. Basic foundations and principles of interpretation 2003, Wiley, Hoboken, NJ. 4th ed.
18. Exner J.E. A new U.S. adult nonpatient sample. Journal of Personality Assessment 2007, 89:S154-S158.
19. Exner J.E., Erdberg P. The Rorschach: A comprehensive system: Vol. 2. Interpretation 2005, Wiley, Oxford, England. 3rd ed.
20. Forth A. Psychopathy and young offenders: Prevalence, family background, and violence 1995, Ministry of the Solicitor General of Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
21. Gacono C.B. A Rorschach analysis of object relations and defensive structure and their relationship to narcissism and psychopathy in a group of antisocial offenders. Dissertation Abstracts International 1989, 49:4536B.
22. Gacono C.B. An empirical study of object relations and defensive operations in antisocial personality disorder. Journal of Personality Assessment 1990, 54:589-600.
23. Gacono C.B., Evans F.B., Viglione D.J. Essential issues in the forensic use of the Rorschach. The handbook of forensic Rorschach assessment 2008, 3-20. Routledge, New York, NY. C.B. Gacono, F.B. Evans, N. Kaser-Boyd, L.A. Gacono (Eds.).
24. Gacono C.B., Gacono L.A., Evans F.B. The Rorschach and antisocial personality disorder. The handbook of forensic Rorschach assessment 2008, 323-359. Routledge, New York, NY. C.B. Gacono, F.B. Evans, N. Kaser-Boyd, L.A. Gacono (Eds.).
25. Gacono C.B., Loving J.L., Bodholdt R.H. The Rorschach and psychopathy: Toward a more accurate understanding of the research findings. Journal of Personality Assessment 2001, 77:16-38.
26. Gacono C.B., Meloy J.R. A Rorschach investigation of attachment and anxiety in antisocial personality disorder. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 1991, 179:546-552.
27. Gacono C.B., Meloy J.R. The Rorschach and the DSM-III-R antisocial personality: A tribute to Robert Lindner. Journal of Clinical Psychology 1992, 48:393-406.
28. Gacono C.B., Meloy J.R. The Rorschach assessment of aggressive and psychopathic personalities 1994, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ.
29. Gacono C.B., Meloy J.R. Assessing antisocial and psychopathic personalities. Oxford handbook of personality assessment 2009, 567-581. Oxford University Press, New York, NY. J.N. Butcher (Ed.).
30. Gacono C.B., Meloy J.R., Berg J.L. Object relations, defensive operations, and affective states in narcissistic, borderline, and antisocial personality disorder. Journal of Personality Assessment 1992, 59:32-49.
31. Gacono C.B., Meloy J.R., Bridges M.R. A Rorschach comparison of psychopaths, sexual homicide perpetrators, and nonviolent pedophiles: Where angels fear to tread. Journal of Clinical Psychology 2000, 56:757-777.
32. Gacono C.B., Meloy J.R., Heaven T.R. A Rorschach investigation of narcissism and hysteria in antisocial personality. Journal of Personality Assessment 1990, 55:270-279.
33. Garb H.N. Incremental validity and the assessment of psychopathology in adults. Psychological Assessment 2003, 15:508-520.
34. Giel G.A. The similarity in Rorschach patterns of adult criminal psychopaths and pre-adolescent boys. Rorschach Research Exchange 1945, 9:201-207.
35. Guay J.P., Ruscio J., Knight R.A., Hare R.D. A taxometric analysis of the latent structure of psychopathy: Evidence for dimensionality. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 2007, 116:701-716.
36. Hare R.D. A research scale for the assessment of psychopathy in criminal populations. Personality and Individual Differences 1980, 1:111-119.
37. Hare R.D. Manual for the Revised Psychopathy Checklist 1991, Multihealth Systems, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
38. Hare R.D. Without conscience: The disturbing world of the psychopaths among us 1993, Pocket Books, New York, NY.
39. Hare R.D. Manual for the Revised Psychopathy Checklist 2003, Multihealth Systems, Toronto, Ontario, Canada. 2nd ed.
40. Hare R.D., Neumann C.S. The PCL-R assessment of psychopathy: Development, structural properties, and new directions. Handbook of psychopathy 2007, 58-88. Guilford, New York, NY. C.J. Patrick (Ed.).
41. Harpur T.J., Hare R.D., Hakstian R. A two-factor conceptualization of psychopathy: Construct validity and implications for assessment. Psychological Assessment: A Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1989, 1:6-17.
42. Hart S.D., Cox D.R., Hare R.D. Checklist: Screening version 1997, Multihealth System, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
43. Hart S.D., Hare R.D., Forth A.E. Psychopathy as a risk marker for violence: Development and validation of a screening version of the Revised Psychopathy Checklist. Violence and mental disorder: Developments in risk assessment 1994, 81-98. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL. J. Monahan, H. Steadman (Eds.).
44. Hartmann E., Nørbech P.B., Grønnerød C. Psychopathic and nonpsychopathic violent offenders on the Rorschach: Discriminative features and comparisons with schizophrenic inpatient and university student samples. Journal of Personality Assessment 2006, 86:291-305.
45. Heaven T.R. The relationship between Hare's Psychopathy Checklist scores and selected Exner Rorschach variables in an inmate population. Dissertation Abstracts International 1989, 49:3442B.
46. Hiller J.B., Rosenthal R., Bornstein R.F., Berry D.T.R., Brunell-Neuleib S. A comparative meta-analysis of Rorschach and MMPI validity. Psychological Assessment 1999, 11:278-296.
47. Hunter J.E., Schmidt F.L. Fixed effects vs. random effects meta-analysis models: Implications for cumulative research knowledge. International Journal of Selection and Assessment 2000, 8:275-292.
48. Huprich S.K., Gacono C.B., Schneider R.B., Bridges M.R. Rorschach oral dependency in psychopaths, sexual homicide perpetrators, and nonviolent pedophiles. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 2004, 22:345-356.
49. Kane M.R. The psychological profile of the psychopathic female. Dissertation Abstracts International 2004, 64:4042B.
50. Kosson D.S., Cyterski T.D., Steuerwald B.L., Neumann C.S., Walker-Matthews S. The reliability and validity of the Psychopathy Checklist: Youth Version (PCL:YV) in nonincarcerated adolescent males. Psychological Assessment 2002, 14:97-109.
51. Kosson D.S., Steuerwald B.L., Forth A.E., Kirkhart K.J. A new method for assessing interpersonal behavior of psychopathic individuals: Preliminary validation studies. Psychological Assessment 1997, 9:89-101.
52. Lilienfeld S.O. Conceptual problems in the assessment of psychopathy. Clinical Psychology Review 1994, 14:17-38.
53. Lilienfeld S.O. Methodological advances and developments in the assessment of psychopathy. Behaviour Research and Therapy 1998, 36:99-125.
54. Lilienfeld S.O., Fowler K.A. The self-report assessment of psychopathy: Problems, pitfalls, and promises. Handbook of psychopathy 2006, 107-132. Guilford, New York, NY. C.J. Patrick (Ed.).
55. Lilienfeld S.O., Wood J.M., Garb H.N. Why questionable psychological tests remain popular. The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine 2006, 10:6-15.
56. Lindner R.M. The Rorschach test and the diagnosis of psychopathic personality. Journal of Criminal Psychopathology 1943, 5:69-93.
57. Lindner R.M. Rebel without a cause: The hypnoanalysis of a criminal psychopath 1944, Grune and Stratton, New York, NY.
58. Lindner R.M. Content analysis in Rorschach work. Rorschach Research Exchange 1946, 10:121-129.
59. Lindner R.M. The content analysis of the Rorschach protocol. Projective psychology 1950, 75-90. Knopf, New York, NY. L.E. Abt, L. Bellak (Eds.).
60. Lipsey M.W., Wilison D.B. Practical meta-analysis 2001, Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA.
61. Loving J.L. Selected Rorschach variables of psychopathic male juvenile offenders. Dissertation Abstracts International 1998, 59:878B.
62. Loving J.L., Lee A.J. Rorschach assessment of antisocial personality disorder and psychopathy. Rorschach assessment of the personality disorders 2006, 139-168. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ. S.K. Huprich (Ed.).
63. Loving J.L., Russell W.F. Selected Rorschach variables of psychopathic juvenile offenders. Journal of Personality Assessment 2000, 75:126-142.
64. Marcus D.K., John S.L., Edens J.F. A taxometric analysis of psychopathic personality. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 2004, 113:626-635.
65. Meloy J.R. Some reflection on What's Wrong With the Rorschach?. Journal of Personality Assessment 2005, 85:344-346.
66. Meloy J.R., Gacono C.B. The aggression response and the Rorschach. Journal of Clinical Psychology 1992, 48:104-114.
67. Meloy J.R., Gacono C.B. Assessing psychopathy: Psychological testing and report writing. The clinical and forensic assessment of psychopathy 2000, 231-249. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ. C.B. Gacono (Ed.).
68. Meloy J.R., Gacono C.B., Kenney L. A Rorschach investigation of sexual homicide. Journal of Personality Assessment 1994, 62:58-67.
69. Meyer G.J., Erdberg P., Shaffer T.W. Toward international normative reference data for the comprehensive system. Journal of Personality Assessment 2007, 89:S201-S216.
70. Meyer G.J., Finn S.E., Eyde L.D., Kay G.G., Moreland K.L., Dies R.R., Reed G.M. Psychological testing and psychological assessment: A review of evidence and issues. American Psychologist 2001, 56:128-165.
71. Muntz A. Object relations and defense mechanisms of psychopathic and nonpsychopathic female offenders: A descriptive study. Dissertation Abstracts International 1999, 60:2954B.
72. Murphy-Peaslee D.M. An investigation of incarcerated females: Rorschach indices and Psychopathy Checklist scores. Dissertation Abstracts International 1995, 56:531B.
73. Murrie D.C., Cornell D.G. Psychopathy screening of incarcerated juveniles: A comparison of measures. Psychological Assessment 2002, 14:390-396.
74. Nassen N.N. Rorschach predictors of psychopathy in violent male offenders. Dissertation Abstracts International 2008, 69:1963B.
75. Nezworski M.T., Wood J.M. Narcissism in the Comprehensive System for the Rorschach. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 1995, 2:179-199.
76. Nunez J. The relationship between object relations and psychopathy among juveniles charged with homicide. Dissertation Abstracts International 1996, 57:4037B.
77. Paulhus D.L., Williams K. The dark triad of personality: Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy. Journal of Research in Personality 2002, 36:556-563.
78. Pointkowski S.R. The Rorschach aggressive categories of Meloy and Gacono in a nonpatient sample: An exploratory study. Dissertation Abstracts International 2001, 62:1593B.
79. Ponder J.I. An investigation of psychopathy in a sample of violent juvenile offenders. Dissertation Abstracts International 1999, 59:5105B.
80. Porter S., Woodworth M. Psychopathy and aggression. Handbook of psychiatry 2007, 481-494. Guilford, New York, NY. C.J. Patrick (Ed.).
81. Poythress N.G., Edens J.F., Watkins M.M. The relationship between psychopathic personality features and malingering symptoms of major mental illness. Law and Human Behavior 2001, 25:567-582.
82. Raychaudhuri M., Mukerji K. Homosexual-narcissistic "reflections"in the Rorschach: An examination of Exner's diagnostic Rorschach signs. Rorschachiana Japonica 1971, 12:119-126.
83. Richards H.J., McCamant K. Narcissism and psychopathy: Concurrent validity of the PCL-R, the Rorschach, and the MCMI. Issues in Criminological and Legal Psychology 1995, 24:131-135.
84. Rogers R., Cruise K.R. Malingering and deception among psychopaths. The clinical and forensic assessment of psychopathy: A practitioner's guide 2000, 269-284. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ. C.B. Gacono (Ed.).
85. Rogers R., Vitacco M.J., Jackson R.L., Martin M., Collins M., Sewell K.W. Faking psychopathy? An examination of response styles with antisocial youth. Journal of Personality Assessment 2002, 78:31-46.
86. Rorschach, H. (1921). Psychodiagnostik (Hans Huber Verlag, Trans.). Bern, Switzerland: Bircher.
87. Salekin R.T. Psychopathy in children and adolescents. Handbook of psychopathy 2007, 389-414. Guilford Press, New York, NY. C.J. Patrick (Ed.).
88. Schafer R. The clinical application of psychological tests: Diagnostic summaries and case studies 1948, International Universities Press, New York, NY.
89. Schmitt W.A., Newman J.P. Are all psychopaths low-anxious?. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1999, 108:353-358.
90. Shaffer T.W., Erdberg P., Haroian J. Current nonpatient data for the Rorschach, WAIS-R, and MMPI-2. Journal of Personality Assessment 1999, 73:305-316.
91. Siegel L.J. Executive functioning characteristics associated with psychopathy in incarcerated females. Dissertation Abstracts International 1999, 59:6112B.
92. Siemsen R.A. Relationships of Rorschach and MMPI-2 variables to the Hare Psychopathy Checklist-Revised among mentally-ill incarcerated felons. Dissertation Abstracts International 1999, 60:2367B.
93. Smith A.M. Juvenile psychopathy: Rorschach assessment of narcissistic traits in conduct disordered adolescents. Dissertation Abstracts International 1995, 55:5088B.
94. Smith A.M., Gacono C.B., Kaufman L. A Rorschach comparison of nonpsychopathic conduct disordered adolescents. Journal of Clinical Psychology 1997, 53:289-300.
95. Smith A.M., Gacono C.B., Kaufman L. Erratum: A Rorschach comparison of psychopathic and nonpsychopathic conduct disordered adolescents. Journal of Clinical Psychology 1998, 54:1151.
96. Vasey M.W., Kotov R., Frick P.J., Loney B.R. The latent structure of psychopathy in youth: A taxometric investigation. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology 2005, 33:411-429.
97. Vitale J.E., Newman J.P., Serin R.C., Bolt D.M. Hostile attributions in incarcerated adult male offenders: An exploration of diverse pathways. Aggressive Behavior 2005, 31:99-115.
98. Walters G.D. Predicting institutional adjustment and recidivism with the Psychopathy Checklist factor scores: A meta-analysis. Law and Human Behavior 2003, 27:541-558.
99. Walters G.D., Gray N.S., Jackson R.L., Sewell K.W., Rogers R., Taylor J., Snowden R.J. A taxometric analysis of the Psychopathy Checklist: Screening Version (PCL:SV): Further evidence of dimensionality. Psychological Assessment 2007, 19:330-339.
100. Weizmann-Henelius G. Violent female perpetrators in Finland: Personality and life events. Nordic Psychology 2006, 58:280-297.
101. Welsh R.K. Psychopathy and psychological risk markers of violent recidivism. Dissertation Abstracts International 1999, 60:2968B.
102. Widiger T.A. Psychopathy and DSM-IV psychopathology. Handbook of psychopathy 2007, 156-171. Guilford, New York, NY. C.J. Patrick (Ed.).
103. Wood J.M., Lilienfeld S.O., Garb H.N., Nezworski M.T. The Rorschach test in clinical diagnosis: A critical review, with a backward look at Garfield (1947). Journal of Clinical Psychology 2000, 56:395-430.
104. Wood J.M., Lilienfeld S.O., Nezworski M.T., Garb H.N. Coming to grips with negative evidence for the Comprehensive System for the Rorschach: A comment on Gacono, Loving, and Bodholdt; Ganellen; and Bornstein. Journal of Personality Assessment 2001, 77:48-70.
105. Wood J.M., Nezworski M.T., Lilienfeld S.O., Garb H.N. What's wrong with the Rorschach? Science confronts the controversial inkblot test 2003, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA.
106. Young M.H., Justice J.V., Erdberg P.S. Risk factors for violent behavior among incarcerated male psychiatric patients: A multimethod approach. Assessment 1999, 6:243-258.
107. Young M.H., Justice J.V., Erdberg P.S., Gacono C.B. The incarcerated psychopath in psychiatric treatment: Management or treatment. The clinical and forensic assessment of psychopathy: A practitioner's guide 2000, 313-331. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ. C.B. Gacono (Ed.).