Death revisited: Rethinking death and the dead donor rule

Journal of Medicine and Philosophy

Volumn 35, Issue 3, 2010, Pages 223-241

  Iltis, Ana Smith ^a   Cherry, Mark J ^b  

^a SAINT LOUIS UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b ST EDWARD'S UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Brain death; Dead donor rule; Death; Neurological criteria; Organ transplantation

Indexed keywords

BRAIN DEATH; CLASSIFICATION; DEATH; DONOR; ETHICS; HUMAN; INTENSIVE CARE UNIT; LEGAL ASPECT; MEDICAL ETHICS; MICROCLIMATE; PATHOPHYSIOLOGY; REVIEW; TRANSPLANTATION; TREATMENT WITHDRAWAL;

BRAIN DEATH; DEATH; ETHICS, MEDICAL; HUMANS; INTENSIVE CARE UNITS; LIFE SUPPORT SYSTEMS; TISSUE AND ORGAN HARVESTING; TISSUE AND ORGAN PROCUREMENT; TISSUE DONORS; WITHHOLDING TREATMENT;

EID: 77952915037     PISSN: 03605310     EISSN: 17445019     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/jmp/jhq017     Document Type: Article

References (68)

1. Beecher, H. K., and H. I. Dorr. 1971. The new definition of death: Some opposing views. Internationale Zeitschrift für klinische Pharmakologie, Therapie, und Toxikologie 5(2): 120-4.
2. Beecher, H. K. and Harvard Ad Hoc Committee. 1968. A definition of irreversible coma: Report of the ad hoc committee of the Harvard Medical School to examine the definition of brain death. Journal of the American Medical Association 205:337-40.
3. Belkin, G. S. 2003. Brain death and the historical understanding of bioethics. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 58:325-61.
4. Bernat, J. L. 1998. A defense of the whole-brain concept of death. Hastings Center Report 28(2): 14-23.
5. -. 2008. The boundaries of organ donation after circulatory death. New England Journal of Medicine 359:669-671.
6. -. 2010. How the distinction between "irreversible" and "permanent" illuminates circulatory-respiratory death determination. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35:242-255.
7. Boucek, M. M., C. Mashburn, S. M. Dunn, R. Frizell, L. Edwards, B. Pietra, and D. Campbell. 2008. Pediatric heart transplantation after declaration of cardiocirculatory death. New England Journal of Medicine 359:709-14.
8. Campbell, C. S. 2004. Harvesting the living? Separating "brain death" and organ transplantation. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 14:301-18.
9. Cherry, M. J. 2005. Kidney for sale by owner: Human organs, transplantation, and the market. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
10. Dorff, E. 2005. End of life: Jewish perspectives. The Lancet 366:862-5.
11. DuBois, J. M. 1999. Non-heart-beating organ donation: A defense of the required determination of death. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 27:126-36.
12. -. 2010. The ethics of creating and responding to doubts about death criteria. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35:365-80.
13. Engelhardt, H. T., Jr. 1996. The foundations of bioethics, 2nd ed. New York: Oxford University Press.
14. Engelhardt, H. T., Jr., and A. Iltis. 2005. End of life: The traditional Christian view. The Lancet 366:1045-9.
15. Fost, N. 2004. Reconsidering the dead donor rule: Is it important that organ donors be dead? Kennedy Lnstitute of Ethics Journal 14:249-60.
16. Fox, R., and J. Swazey. 1992. Spare parts: Organ replacement in American society. New York: Oxford University Press.
17. Fuchs, T. 1998. The notion killing: Causality, intention, and motivation in active and passive euthanasia. Medicine, Healthcare and Philosophy 1:245-53.
18. Gateau, V. 2009. The ethics of organ salvaging on deceased persons. HEC Forum 21:135-49.
19. Gert, B., and C. Culver. 1986. Distinguishing between active and passive euthanasia. Clinics in Geriatric Medicine 2:19-36.
20. Greer, D. M., P. N. Varelas, S. Haque, and E. F M. Wijdicks. 2008. Variability of brain death determination guidelines in leading US neurologic institutions. Neurology 70:284-9.
21. Halevy, A., and B. A. Brody. 1993. Brain death: Reconciling definitions, criteria, and tests. Annals of Lnternal Medicine 119:519-25.
22. Hausman, D. M. 2004. Polling and public policy. Kennedy Lnstitute of Ethics Journal 14:241-7.
23. Institute of Medicine. 1997. Non-heart-beating organ transplantation: Medical and ethical issues in procurement. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
24. -. 2000. Non-heart-beating organ transplantation: Practice and protocols. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
25. -. 2006. Organ donation: Opportunities for action. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
26. Kant, I. 1991 [1797]. The metaphysics of morals. (trans. M. Gregor). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
27. Karakatsanis, K. G., and J. N. Tsanakas. 2002. A critique on the concept of "brain death." Lssues in Law & Medicine 18:127-41.
28. Khushf, G. 2010. A matter of respect: A defense of the dead donor rule and of "whole brain" criteria for determinations of death. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35:330-64.
29. Light, J. A. 2008. The Washington, DC experience with uncontrolled donation after circulatory determination of death: Promises and pitfalls. Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics 36:735-40.
30. Locke, J. 1977. [1690]. An essay concerning human understanding. In Classics of western philosophy, 2nd ed. (pp. 479-574), ed. S. Calm. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett.
31. Machado, C. 1994. Death on neurological grounds. Journal of Neurosurgical Sciences 38:209-22.
32. Machado, C, J. Kerein, Y Ferrer, L. Portela, M. de la C. Garcia, and J. M. Manero. 2007. The concept of brain death did not evolve to benefit organ transplants. Journal of Medical Ethics 33:197-200.
33. Menikoff, J. 2002. The importance of being dead: Non-heart-beating organ donation. Lssues in Law & Medicine 18:3-20.
34. Miller, F, R. Truog, and D. Brock. 2010. The dead donor rule: Can it withstand critical scrutiny? Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35:299-312.
35. Mollaret, P., and M. Goulon. 1959. Le coma depassé: Memoire préliminaire. Rev Neurologique (Paris) 101:3-15.
36. New Jersey Declaration of Death Act. 1991. New Jersey Statutes Annotated, Title 26, secs. 6A-1 to 6A-8.
37. New York. 1987. Official Compilation Codes, Rules and Regulations of the State of New York, 1987. Title 10(Vol. C) - Health, Part 400 Medical Facilities - minimum standards, Section 400.16 Determination of death, [Online]. Available: http://w3.health.state.ny.us/dbspace/NYCRR10.nsf/ 56cf2e25d626f9f785256538006c3ed7/. (Accessed October 17, 2009).
38. Olick, R. S. 1991. Brain death, religious freedom, and public policy: New Jersey's landmark legislative initiative. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 1:275-88.
39. O'Neill, F. K. 2009. Giving from our bodily belongings: Is donation an appropriate paradigm for the giving of bodies and body parts? HEC Forum 21:151-74.
40. O'Rourke, K. O. P. (ed.). 2000. A primer for health care ethics: Essays for a pluralistic society. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
41. Potts, M., and D. W. Evans. 2005. Does it matter that organ donors are not dead? Ethical and policy implications. Journal of Medical Ethics 31:406-9.
42. President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. 1981. Defining death: Medical, legal and ethical issues in the determination of death. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
43. In re Quinlan 70NJ10, 355 A2d 647 (1976).
44. Rady, M. Y, J. L. Verheijde, and M. S. Ali. 2009. Islam and end-of-life practices in organ donation for transplantation: New questions and serious sociocultural consequences. HEC Forum 21:175-205.
45. Rady, M. Y, J. L. Verheijde, and J. McGregor. 2006. Organ donation after circulatory death: The forgotten donor? Critical Care 10:166-8.
46. Rie, M. 2002. Respect for human life in the world of intensive care units secular and reform Jewish reflections on the Roman Catholic view. In Allocating scarce medical resources: Roman Catholic perspectives (pp. 43-52), ed. H. T. Engelhardt, Jr., and M. J. Cherry. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
47. Shewmon, D. A. 1998. "Brainstem death," "brain death" and death: A critical re-evaluation of the purported equivalence. Issues in Law and Medicine 14:125-45.
48. -. 2001. The brain and somatic integration: Insights into the standard biological rationale for equating "brain death" with death. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 26:457-78.
49. -. 2010. Constructing the death elephant: A synthetic paradigm shift for the definition, criteria, and tests for death. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35:256-98.
50. Society of Critical Care Medicine Ethics Committee. 1994. Consensus statement on the triage of critically ill patients. Journal of the American Medical Association 271:1200-3.
51. Siminoff, L. A., C. Burant, and S. J. Youngner. 2004. Death and organ procurement: Public beliefs and attitudes. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 14:217-34.
52. Siminoff, L. A., M. B. Mercer, and R. Arnold. 2003. Families' understanding of brain death. Progress in Transplantation 13:218-24.
53. Taboada, P. 2002. What is appropriate intensive care? A Roman Catholic perspective. In Allocating scarce medical resources: Roman Catholic perspectives (pp. 53-73), eds H. T. Engelhardt, Jr, and M. J. Cherry. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
54. Taylor, J. S. 2009. The unjustified assumptions of organ conscripters. HEC Forum 21:115-33.
55. Truog, R. D. 1997. Is it time to abandon brain death? Hastings Center Report 27(1):29-37.
56. -. 2007. Brain death - too flawed to endure, too ingrained to abandon. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 35(2):273-81.
57. Truog, R. D., and J. C. Fackler. 1992. Rethinking brain death. Critical Care Medicine 20:1705-13.
58. Truog, R. D., and F. G. Miller. 2008. The dead donor rule and organ transplantation. New England Journal of Medicine 359:674-5.
59. Uniform Determination of Death Act (UDDA). 1981. National Conference on Commissioners of Uniform State Laws [Online]. Available: http://www.law.upenn. edu/bll/archives/ulc /fnact99/1980s/udda80.htm (Accessed October 23, 2009).
60. University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. 1992. Policy and Procedure Manual: Management of Terminally 111 Patients who May Become Organ Donors after Death. Reprinted in Kennedy Lnstitute of Ethics Journal 3:A1-A15.
61. Veatch, R. M. 1993. The impending collapse of the whole-brain definition of death. Hastings Center Report 23(4): 18-24.
62. -. 2004. Abandon the dead donor rule or change the definition of death? Kennedy Lnstitute of Ethics Journal 14:261-76.
63. -. 2005. The death of whole-brain death: The plague of the disaggregators, somaticists, and mentalists. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 30:353-78.
64. -. 2008. Donating hearts after cardiac death - reversing the irreversible. New England Journal of Medicine 359:672-3.
65. -. 2010. Transplanting hearts after death measured by cardiac criteria: The challenge to the dead donor rule. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35:313-29.
66. Vincent, J.-L. 2001. Cultural differences in end-of-life care. Critical Care Medicine 29(2): N52-5.
67. Wijdicks, E. 2001. The diagnosis of brain death. New England Journal of Medicine 344: 1215-21.
68. -. 2002. Brain death worldwide: Accepted fact but no global consensus in diagnostic criteria. Neurology 58:20-5.