New nuclear energy, risk, and justice: Regulatory strategies for an Era of limited trust

Politics and Policy

Volumn 38, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 255-284

  Ash, John ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Justice; Nuclear Energy; Regulation; Risk; Trust

Indexed keywords

ENERGY POLICY; NUCLEAR POWER; REGULATORY APPROACH; RISK PERCEPTION; SOCIAL JUSTICE; STRATEGIC APPROACH;

EID: 77952230424     PISSN: 15555623     EISSN: 17471346     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1747-1346.2010.00237.x     Document Type: Article

References (99)

1. Alder John, Wilkinson David. Environmental Law and Ethics 1999, Basingstoke, UK, Macmillan
2. Arrow Kenneth J. Social Choice and Individual Values 1951, New York, John Wiley & Sons Inc
3. Arrow Kenneth J. Discounting, Morality, and Gaming. Discounting and Intergenerational Equity 1999, 13-21. Portney Paul RWeyant John P. In, edited by, Washington, DC, Resources for the Future
4. Ash John. The Management of Anthropogenic Environmental Risk Associated With Oil Development in the Arctic Littoral. 2007, Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Cambridge
5. Ash John. Another Man's Poison: Risk Management and Nuclear Power Generation. Forthcoming, Electricity Policy Research Group paper, Judge Business School, University of Cambridge
6. Bardach Eugene, Kagan Robert A. Going by the Book: The Problem of Unreasonableness 1982, Philadelphia, PA, Temple University Press
7. Barnes Michael. The Hinkley Point Public Inquiries 1990, London, Her Majesty's Stationery Office (HMSO)
8. Beck Ulrich. Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity 1992, London, Sage
9. Beckerman Wilfred. The Impossibility of a Theory of Intergenerational Justice. Handbook of Intergenerational Justice 2006, 53-71. Tremmel Joerg Chet. In, edited by, Cheltenham, UK, Edward Elgar Publishing
10. Björgvinsson Thrthomampersan, Wilde Gerard J S. Risky Health and Safety Habits Related to Perceived Value of the Future. Safety Science 1996, 22(1-3):27-33.
11. About British Energy: BE. 2007, http://www.british-energy.com/pagetemplate.php?pid=77, British Energy (BE), Accessed on February 28, 2008. Available online at
12. Brown-Weiss Edith. In Fairness to Future Generations 1989, Tokyo, United Nations University/Transnational Publishers
13. Burgess Jacqui, Harrison Carolyn, Filius Petra. Environmental Communication and the Cultural Politics of Environmental Citizenship. Environment and Planning A 1998, 30(1):1445-1460.
14. Campbell Tom D. Justice [1988] 2001, 2d, edition, Basingstoke, UK, MacMillan Press Ltd
15. Chapman Chris, Ward Stephen. Project Risk Management: Processes, Techniques, and Insights 1997, Chichester, UK, John Wiley & Sons
16. Managing our Radioactive Waste Safely: CoRWM's Recommendations to Government, November 2006, Committee on Radioactive Waste Management (Co RWM), London, CoRWM
17. 2007 Chapter 19. 2007, http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts2007/ukpga_20070019_en_1, Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act, Accessed on June 2007. Available online at
18. Cudmore Sarah. Engaging with Safety Culture: A Review of Current Thinking and: Practice: British Safety Council. 2008, http://www.britsafe.org/communications/positive-safety-culture/report.pdf, December). Accessed prior to December 11, 2009. Available online at
19. Cvetkovich George, Earle Timothy C. The Construction of Justice: A Case Study of Public Participation in Land Management. Journal of Social Issues 1994, 50(3):161-178.
20. Cvetkovich George, Löfstedt Ragnar. Social Trust and the Management of Risk 1999, London, Earthscan Publications Ltd
21. Cvetkovich George, Siegrist Michael, Murray Rachel, Tragesser Sarah. New Information and Social Trust: Asymmetry and Perseverance of Attributions about Hazard Managers. Risk Analysis 2002, 22(2):359-367.
22. Dake Karl. Orienting Dispositions in the Perception of Risk: An Analysis of Contemporary Worldviews and Cultural Biases. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 1991, 22(1):61-82.
23. Meeting the Energy Challenge: A White Paper on Nuclear Energy 2008, Department for Business, Enterprise & Regulatory Reform (BERR), CM 7296, January, London, The Stationery Office
24. Meeting the Energy Challenge: A White Paper on Energy 2007a, Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), CM 7124, London, The Stationery Office
25. The Future of Nuclear Power: The Role of Nuclear Power in a Low Carbon UK Economy: Consultation Document 2007b, Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), DTI/Pub 8577/2.5k/07/07/RP.URN 07/970, London, The Stationery Office
26. Dickson Captain Alexand. Navigation Problems (Tankers) 1971, London, International Tanker Safety Conference/International Chamber of Shipping
27. Government Invites New Nuclear Power into the Energy Mix: Press Release. 2008, http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/Nl1/Newsroom/DG_072058, Directgov, January 10). Accessed on December 22, 2009. Available online at
28. Dobson Andrew. Justice and the Environment: Conceptions of Environmental Sustainability and Dimensions of Social Justice 1998, Oxford, Clarendon
29. Douglas Mary. Risk and Blame: Essays in Cultural Theory 1992, London, Routledge
30. Douglas Mary, Wildavsky Aaron. Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technical and Environmental Dangers 1982, Berkeley, University of California Press
31. Drottz-Sjöberg Britt-Marie. Perceptions of Time and Long Time Intervals. 2006, Presented at the VALDOR (Values in Decisions on Risk) Conference, Stockholm, Sweden. May 14-18
32. Dunsire Andrew. Manipulating Social Tensions: Collibration as an Alternative Mode of Government Intervention. 1993, http://www.mpi-fg-koeln.mpg.de/pu/mpifg_dp/dp93-7.pdf, Max-Planck-Institut für Gesellschaftsforschung Discussion Paper 93/7. Accessed on December 14, 2009. Available online at
33. Earle Timothy C. Thinking Aloud about Trust: A Protocol Analysis of Trust in Risk Management. Risk Analysis 2004, 24(1):169-183.
34. Earle Timothy C, Cvetkovich George. Social Trust: Toward a Cosmopolitan Society 1995, Westport, CT, Praeger
35. Earle Timothy C, Cvetkovich George. Social Trust and Culture in Risk: Management. Social Trust and the Management of Risk 1999, 9-21. Cvetkovich George, Löfstedt Ragnar. In, edited by, London, Earthscan Publications Ltd
36. Eden Sally. Public Participation in Environmental Policy: Considering Scientific, Counter-Scientific, and Non-Scientific Contributions. Public Understanding of Science 1996, 5(3):183-203.
37. Erikson Kai T. Toxic Reckoning: Business Faces a New Kind of Fear. Harvard Business Review 1990, 68(1):118-126.
38. Erikson Kai T. A New Species of Trouble 1994, New York, WW Norton and Company Inc
39. Directive 2001/80/EC: On the Limitation of Emissions of Certain Pollutants into the Air from Large Combustion Plants: Official Journal of the European Communities. 2001, http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2001:309:0001:0001:EN:PDF, European Parliament and The Council of the European Union, October 23). Accessed on December 14, 2009. Available online at
40. Nuclear Power, Climate Policy, and Sustainability: An Assessment by the Austrian Nuclear Advisory Board: Austrian Nuclear Advisory Board, Vienna, AV + Astoria Druckzentrum GmbH. 2007, http://www.nirs.org/climate/background/austriangovtreport607.pdf, Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Environment and Water Management (ANAB), Accessed on November 14, 2007. Available online at
41. Fischhoff Baruch. Risk Perception and Communication Unplugged: Twenty Years of Process. Risk Analysis 1995, 15(2):137-145.
42. Flowers R H, Roberts L E J, Tymons B J. Characteristics and Quantities of Radioactive Wastes. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London A, Mathematical and Physical Sciences 1986, 319(1545):5-16.
43. Flynn James H. Final Report: Low Dose Risk, Decisions, and Risk Communication. 2002, U.S. Department of Energy, Report Number EMSP-69904-2002
44. Focht Will, Trachtenberg Zev. A Trust-Based Guide to Stakeholder Participation. Swimming Upstream: Collaborative Approaches to Watershed Management 2005, 85-135. Sabatier Paul A, Focht WillLubell MarkTrachtenberg ZevVedlitz ArnoldMatlock Marty. In, edited by, Cambridge, MA, MIT Press
45. Forlin Gerard. Corporate Killing and Health and Safety: Where Are We Now? 2001, http://www.rospa.com/occupationalsafety/info/corporate_killing_forlin.pdf, London Chamber of Commerce and Industry Conference on Accidents (October). Accessed on June 13, 2007. Available online at
46. Hardin Russell. Trust and Trustworthiness 2002, New York, Russell Sage Foundation
47. 1974, http://www.statutelaw.gov.uk/legResults.aspx?Legtype=All+Legislation&title=health+and+safety+at+work+etc+act+&Year=1974&searchEnacted=0&extentMatchOnly=0&confersPower=0&blanketAmendment=0&TYPE=QS&NavFrom=0&activeTextDocId=1316700&PageNumber=1&SortAlpha=0, Health and Safety at Work etc. Act, Accessed prior to December 11, 2009. Available online at
48. The Tolerability of Risk from Nuclear Power Stations [1988] 1992, Health and Safety Executive (HSE), London, HMSO
49. Guidance for Inspectors on the Management of Radioactive Materials and Radioactive Waste on Nuclear Licensed Sites, March 13 2001, Health and Safety Executive (HSE), London, Health and Safety Executive, Nuclear Safety Directorate/HMSO
50. Safety Assessment Principles for Nuclear Facilities 2006, Health and Safety Executive (HSE), Bootle, UK, Health and Safety Executive
51. Nuclear Directorate-Who We Are. 2007, http://www.hse.gov.uk/nuclear/nsd1.htm#staff, Health and Safety Executive (HSE), HSE (November 5). Accessed on February 28, 2008. Available online at
52. New Nuclear Power Stations Generic Design Assessment: A Guide to the Regulatory Processes. 2008, http://www.hse.gov.uk/newreactors/ngn01.pdf, Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and the Environment Agency (EA), Version 2, August 2008. Accessed February 12, 2010. Available online at
53. An Investigation into the Falsification of Pellet Diameter Data in the MOX Demonstration Facility at the BNFL Sellafield Site and the Effect of this on the Safety of MOX Fuel in Use. 2000, http://www.hse.gov.uk/nuclear/mox/mox1.htm, Health and Safety Executive-Nuclear Installations Inspectorate (HSE- NII), HSE-NII (February 18). Accessed on November 14, 2007. Available online at
54. 1999, http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si1999/19993232.htm, The Ionising Radiations Regulations, Statutory Instrument 1999 No. 3232. Accessed prior to December 11, 2009. Available online at
55. Kasperson Roger E, Golding Dominic, Tuler Seth. Social Distrust as a Factor in Siting Hazardous Facilities and Communicating Risks. Journal of Social Issues 1992, 48(4):161-187.
56. Löfstedt Ragnar E, Horlick-Jones Tom. Environmental Regulation in the UK: Politics, Institutional Change, and Public Trust. Social Trust and the Management of Risk 1999, 73-88. Cvetkovich George, Löfstedt Ragnar E. In, edited by, London, Earthscan Publications Ltd
57. McKee Kevin. Alternative Dispute Resolution. 2006, http://www.alway-associates.co.uk/alternative-dispute-resolution.asp, Alway Associates (February 8). Accessed on June 14 2007 and thereafter. Available online at
58. McKenzie-Mohr Doug. Promoting Sustainable Behaviour: An Introduction to Community-Based Social Marketing. Journal of Social Issues 2000, 56(3):543-554.
59. MacKerron Gordon, Colenutt Dennis, Spackman Michael, Robinson Alastair, Linton Essie. The Economics of Nuclear Power. 2006, http://www.sdcommission.org.uk/publications/downloads/Nuclear-paper4-Economics.pdf, Sustainable Development Commission, Science & Technology Policy Research (SPRU, University of Sussex), and NERA Economic Consulting (March). Accessed prior to December 11, 2009. Available online at
60. Maeda Yasunobu, Miyahara Makota. Determinants of Trust in Industry, Government, and Citizen's Groups in Japan. Risk Analysis 2003, 23(2):303-310.
61. Miller David. Social Justice 1976, Oxford, Clarendon Press
62. A Guide to the Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007. 2007, http://www.justice.gov.uk/about/docs/guidetomanslaughterhomicide07.pdf, Ministry of Justice (MJ), MJ (October). Accessed on February 12, 2010. Available online at
63. Monbiot George. The Business of Killing: The Guardian. 2005, http://www.monbiot.com/archives/2005/03/29/the-business-of-killing/, (April 27). Accessed prior to December 11, 2009. Available online at
64. Documents of the NRPB 4 (1) 1993, National Radiological Protection Board (NRPB), Didcot, UK, NRPB
65. Nordland Odd. A Discussion of Risk Tolerance Principles. Safety Systems Newsletter 1999, 8(3):1-4.
66. 1965 Chapter 57. 1965, http://www.opsi.gov.uk/RevisedStatutes/Acts/ukpga/1965/cukpga_19650057_en_1, Nuclear Installations Act, Accessed prior to December 11, 2009. Available online at
67. Low-Level Radioactive Waste Classification, Characterization, and Assessment: Waste Streams and Neutron-Activated Metals 2000, Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), NUREG/CR-6567, Washington, DC, U.S. NRC, Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research
68. Nuttall William J. Nuclear Renaissance: Technologies and Policies for the Future of Nuclear Power 2005, Bristol, UK, Institute of Physics Publishing
69. Dispute Resolution Guidance. 2002, http://www.ogc.gov.uk/documents/dispute_resolution.pdf, Office of Government Commerce (OGC), Accessed on October 24, 2007. Available online at
70. Owens Susan, Driffill Louise. How to Change Attitudes and Behaviours in the Context of Energy. Energy Policy 2008, 36:4412-4418.
71. Carbon Footprint of Electricity Generation. 2006, http://www.parliament.uk/documents/upload/postpn268.pdf, Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology (POST), POST Report 268 (October). Accessed on February 12, 2010. Available online at
72. Electricity in the UK. 2007, http://www.iop.org/activity/policy/Publications/file_21079.pdf, Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology (POST), POST Report 280 (February). Accessed on February 12, 2010. Available online at
73. Perrow Charles. Normal Accidents: Living with High Risk Technologies [1984] 1999, New York, Basic Books, Reprinted, Princeton: Princeton University Press
74. Phillips Ceri, Thompson Guy. What Is a QALY? 2001, http://meds.queensu.ca/medicine/obgyn/pdf/what_is/WhatisaQALY.pdf, ONC 195058. Accessed prior to December 11, 2009. Available online at
75. Pritchard Paul. Environmental Risk Management 2000, London, Earthscan Publications Ltd
76. Renn Ortwin. Analytic-Deliberative Processes of Decision Making: Linking Expertise, Stakeholder Experience, and Public Values. 2004, http://www.corwm.org.uk/Pages/Archived%20Publications/Introduction/Top%20level%20key%20documents/847%20-%20Analytic-deliberative%20processes%20of%20decision%20making%20(Ortwin%20Renn).pdf, CoRWM Document 847. Accessed on May 8 2007. Available online at
77. Roulstone Tony. Accelerating UK Nuclear New Build: Acumen7. 2006, http://bracchium.net/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderfiles/modularbuild.ppt, (July). Accessed prior to December 11, 2009. Available online at
78. Sandman Peter M. Responding to Community Outrage: Strategies for Effective Risk Communication 1993, Fairfax, VA, American Industrial Hygiene Association Press
79. Siegrist Michael, Cvetkovich George. Perception of Hazards: The Role of Social Trust and Knowledge. Risk Analysis 2000, 20(5):713-719.
80. Siegrist Michael, Cvetkovich George, Roth Claudia. Salient Value Similarity, Social Trust, and Risk/Benefit Perception. Risk Analysis 2000, 20(3):353-362.
81. Slovic Paul. Perception of Risk. Science 1987, 236(4799):280-285.
82. Slovic Paul. Perceived Risk, Trust, and Democracy. Risk Analysis 1993, 13(6):675-681.
83. Slovic Paul. Terrorism as Hazard: A New Species of Trouble. Risk Analysis 2002, 22(3):425-426.
84. Slovic Paul, Fischhoff Baruch, Lichtenstein Sarah. Perceived Risk: Psychological Factors and Social Implications. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A, Mathematical and Physical Sciences 1981, 376(1764):17-34.
85. Slovic Paul, Layman Mark, Flynn James H. Perceived Risk, Trust, and Nuclear Waste: Lessons from Yucca Mountain. Public Reactions to Nuclear Waste: Citizens' Views of Repository Siting 1993, 64-86. Dunlap Riley E, Kraft Michael E, Rosa Eugene A. In, edited by, Durham, NC, Duke University Press
86. Smith Keith. Environmental Hazards: Assessing Risk and Reducing Disaster 1996, 2d, edition, London, Routledge
87. Starr Chauncey. Social Benefit versus Technological Risk: What is our Society Willing to Pay for Safety? Science 1969, 165(3899):1232-1238.
88. Starr Chauncey. Risk Management, Assessment, and Acceptability. Risk Analysis 1985, 5(2):97-102.
89. Understanding Risk: Informing Decisions in a Democratic Society 1996, Stern Paul CFineberg Harvey V. eds., Washington, DC, Committee on Risk Characterization, Commission on Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education, National Research Council/National Academy Press
90. Stone Deborah. Equity. Policy Paradox: The Art of Political Decision Making 1997, 39-60. Stone Deborah. In, edited by, New York, WW Norton and Company
91. Svenson O, Nilsson G. Psychological Aspects of Nuclear technology: Time Perception, Planning Horizons and Perceptions Related to Nuclear Waste Disposal, Preliminary Report 1986, Stockholm, Department of Psychology, Stockholm University
92. Thomas Philip J, Stupples David W, Alghaffar M A. The Extent of Regulatory Consensus on Health and Safety Expenditure. Part 1: Development of the J-Value Technique and Evaluation of Regulators' Recommendations. Process Safety and Environmental Protection, Institution of Chemical Engineers 2006a, 84(B5-September):329-336.
93. Thomas Philip J, Stupples David W, Alghaffar M A. The Extent of Regulatory Consensus on Health and Safety Expenditure. Part 2: Applying the J-Value Technique to Case Studies across Industries. Process Safety and Environmental Protection, Institution of Chemical Engineers 2006b, 84(B5-September):337-343.
94. Tremmel Joerg Chet. Establishing Intergenerational Justice in National Constitutions. Handbook of Intergenerational Justice 2006, 187-214. Tremmel Joerg Chet. In, edited by, Cheltenham, UK, Edward Elgar Publishing
95. Walls John, Pidgeon Nick, Weyman Andrew, Horlick-Jones Tom. Critical Trust: Understanding Lay Perceptions of Health and Safety Risk Regulation. Health, Risk & Society 2004, 6(2):133-150.
96. Warren Linda. Intergenerational Equity. 2004, http://www.corwm.org.uk/Pages/Archived%20Publications/Tier%202%20(1)%20-%20Planning/Tier%203%20-%20CoRWM%20modus%20operandi/Ethical%20workshop%20(background%20papers)1.pdf, Committee on Radioactive Waste Management, Archive Document (August 31). Accessed on June 18, 2007 at This document was created as part of the CoRWM decision process and is no longer available on the web
97. Weick Karl E. Organizational Culture as a Source of High Reliability. California Management Review 1987, 29(2):112-127.
98. Weinstein Neil D, Kolb Kathryn, Goldstein Bernard D. Using Time Intervals between Expected Events to Communicate Risk Magnitudes. Risk Analysis 1996, 16(3):305-308.
99. Wilde Gerald J S. Risk Homeostasis Theory: An Overview. Injury Prevention 1998, 4(2):89-91.