Frontier efficiency methodologies to measure performance in the insurance industry: Overview, systematization, and recent developments

Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance: Issues and Practice

Volumn 35, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 217-265

  Eling, Martin ^a   Luhnen, Michael ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ULM   (Germany)

^b UNIVERSITY OF ST GALLEN   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Data envelopment analysis; Efficiency; Stochastic frontier analysis

Indexed keywords

EID: 77951831968     PISSN: 10185895     EISSN: 14680440     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1057/gpp.2010.1     Document Type: Article

References (120)

1. Aigner, D.J., Lovell, C.A.K. and Schmidt, P. (1977) 'Formulation and estimation of stochastic frontier production function models', Journal of Econometrics 6(1): 21-37.
2. Badunenko, O., Grechanyuk, B. and Talavera, O. (2006) Development under regulation: The way of the Ukrainian insurance market, discussion papers of DIW Berlin 644, DIW Berlin, German Institute for Economic Research. Banker
3. Banker R.D. (1993) 'Maximum likelihood, consistency and data envelopment analysis: A statistical foundation', Management Science 39(10): 1265-1273.
4. Barros, C.P. and Obijiaku, E.L. (2007) Technical efficiency of Nigerian insurance companies, working papers no. 18, Department of Economics, Institute for Economics and Business Administration (ISEG), Technical University of Lisbon.
5. Barros, C.P., Barroso, N. and Borges, M.R. (2005) 'Evaluating the efficiency and productivity of insurance companies with a Malmquist Index: A case study for Portugal', The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issues and Practice 30(2): 244-267.
6. Berger, A.N. and Humphrey, D.B. (1997) 'Efficiency of financial institutions: International survey and directions for future research', European Journal of Operational Research 98(2): 175-212.
7. Berger, A.N., Cummins, J.D. and Weiss, M.A. (1997) 'The coexistence of multiple distribution systems for financial services: The case of property-liability insurance', Journal of Business 70(4): 515-546.
8. Berger, A.N., Cummins, J.D., Weiss, M.A. and Zi, H. (2000) 'Conglomeration versus strategic focus: Evidence from the insurance industry', Journal of Financial Intermediation 9(4): 323-362.
9. Bernstein, J.I. (1999) 'Total factor productivity growth in the Canadian life insurance industry: 1979-1989', Canadian Journal of Economics 32(2): 500-517.
10. Bikker, J.A. and van Leuvensteijn, M. (forthcoming) 'Competition and efficiency in the Dutch life insurance industry', Applied Economics 40(16): 2063-2084.
11. Boonyasai, T., Grace, M.F. and Skipper Jr., H.D. (2002) The effect of liberalization and deregulation on life insurer efficiency, working paper no. 02-12, Center for Risk Management and Insurance Research, Georgia State University, Atlanta.
12. Brockett, P.L., Cooper, W.W., Golden, L.L., Rousseau, J.J. and Wang, Y. (1998) 'DEA evaluations of the efficiency of organizational forms and distribution systems in the US property and liability insurance industry', International Journal of Systems Science 29(11): 1235-1247.
13. Brockett, P.L., Cooper, W.W., Golden, L.L., Rousseau, J.J. and Wang, Y. (2004a) 'Evaluating solvency versus efficiency performance and different forms of organization and marketing in US property-liability insurance companies', European Journal of Operational Research 154(2): 492-514.
14. Brockett, P.L., Chang, R.C., Rousseau, J.J., Semple, J.H. and Yang, C. (2004b) 'A comparison of HMO efficiencies as a function of provider autonomy', Journal of Risk and Insurance 71(1): 1-19.
15. Brockett, P.L., Cooper, W.W., Golden, L.L., Rousseau, J.J. and Wang, Y. (2005) 'Financial intermediary versus production approach to efficiency of marketing distribution systems and organizational structure of insurance companies', Journal of Risk and Insurance 72(3): 393-412.
16. Carr, R.M., Cummins, J.D. and Regan, L. (1999) 'Efficiency and competitiveness in the US life insurance industry: Corporate, product, and distribution strategies', in J.D. Cummins and A.M. Santomero (eds.) Changes in the Life Insurance Industry: Efficiency, Technology and Risk Management, Boston, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
17. Caves, D.W., Christensen, L.R. and Tretheway, M.W. (1980) 'Flexible cost functions for multiproduct firms', Review of Economics and Statistics 62(3): 477-482.
18. Chaffai, M.E. and Ouertani, M.N. (2002) Technical efficiency in the Tunisian insurance industry: A comparison of parametric and non parametric time variant models, working paper, Research Unit on Production Econometrics, Sfax University, Sfax.
19. Choi, P.B. and Weiss, M.A. (2005) 'An empirical investigation of market structure, efficiency, and performance in property-liability insurance', Journal of Risk and Insurance 72(4): 635-673.
20. Choi, P.B. and Weiss, M.A. (2008) 'State regulation and the structure, conduct, efficiency and performance of US auto insurers', Journal of Banking and Finance 32(1): 134-156.
21. Cooper, W.W., Seiford, L.M. and Tone, K. (2007) Data Envelopment Analysis: A Comprehensive Text with Models, Applications, References and DEA-solver Software, Boston, MA: Springer.
22. Cummins, J.D. (1999) 'Efficiency in the US life insurance industry: Are insurers minimizing costs and maximizing revenues?', in J.D. Cummins and A.M. Santomero (eds.) Changes in the Life Insurance Industry: Efficiency, Technology and Risk Management, Boston, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
23. Cummins, J.D. and Nini, G.P. (2002) 'Optimal capital utilization by financial firms: Evidence from the property-liability insurance industry', Journal of Financial Services Research 21(1-2): 15-53.
24. Cummins, J.D. and Rubio-Misas, M. (2006) 'Deregulation, consolidation, and efficiency: Evidence from the Spanish insurance industry', Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 38(2): 323-355.
25. Cummins, J.D. and Weiss, M.A. (1993) 'Measuring cost efficiency in the property-liability insurance industry', Journal of Banking and Finance 17(2-3): 463-481.
26. Cummins, J.D. and Weiss, M.A. (2000) 'Analyzing firm performance in the insurance industry using frontier efficiency methods', in G. Dionne (ed.) Handbook of Insurance Economics, Boston, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
27. Cummins, J.D. and Xie, X. (2008) 'Mergers and acquisitions in the US property-liability insurance industry: Productivity and efficiency effects', Journal of Banking and Finance 32(1): 30-55.
28. Cummins, J.D. and Zi, H. (1998) 'Comparison of frontier efficiency methods: An application to the U.S. life insurance industry', Journal of Productivity Analysis 10(2): 131-152.
29. Cummins, J.D., Rubio-Misas, M. and Zi, H. (2004) 'The effect of organizational structure on efficiency: Evidence from the Spanish insurance industry', Journal of Banking and Finance 28(12): 3113-3150.
30. Cummins, J.D., Tennyson, S. and Weiss, M.A. (1999a) 'Consolidation and efficiency in the U.S. life insurance industry', Journal of Banking and Finance 23(2-4): 325-357.
31. Cummins, J.D., Turchetti, G. and Weiss, M.A. (1996) Productivity and technical efficiency in the Italian insurance industry, working paper, Wharton Financial Institutions Center, University of Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania.
32. Cummins, J.D., Weiss, M.A. and Zi, H. (1999b) 'Organizational form and efficiency: The coexistence of stock and mutual property-liability insurers', Management Science 45(9): 1254-1269.
33. Cummins, J.D., Weiss, M.A. and Zi, H. (2007) Economics of scope in financial services: A DEA bootstrapping analysis of the US insurance industry, Working Paper, The Wharton School, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
34. Cummins, J.D., Dionne, G., Gagné, R. and Nouira, A. (2006) Efficiency of insurance firms with endogenous risk management and financial intermediation activities, Working Paper.
35. Davutyan, N. and Klumpes, P.J.M. (2008) Consolidation and efficiency in the major European insurance markets: A non discretionary inputs approach, Working Paper.
36. Delhausse, B., Fecher, F. and Pestieau, P. (1995) 'Measuring productive performance in the non-life insurance industry: The case of French and Belgian markets', Tijdschrift voor Economie en Management 40(1): 47-69.
37. Diacon, S.R. (2001) The efficiency of UK general insurance companies, working paper, Centre for Risk&Insurance Studies, University of Nottingham.
38. Diacon, S.R., Starkey, K. and O'Brien, C. (2002) 'Size and efficiency in European long-term insurance companies: An international comparison', The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issues and Practice 27(3): 444-466.
39. Diboky, F. and Ubl, E. (2007) Ownership and efficiency in the German life insurance market: A DEA bootstrap approach, working paper, University of Vienna.
40. Donni, O. and Fecher, F. (1997) 'Efficiency and productivity of the insurance industry in the OECD countries', The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issues and Practice 22(4): 523-535.
41. Donni, O. and Hamende, V. (1993) 'Performance des Sociétés Belges D'Assurance-Comparaison des formes institutionelles', Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics 64(3): 419-438, Université de Liège.
42. Eling, M. and Luhnen, M. (2008) Efficiency in the international insurance industry: A cross-country comparison, working paper, University of St. Gallen.
43. Eling, M., Schmeiser, H. and Schmit, J.T. (2007) 'The Solvency II process: Overview and critical analysis', Risk Management and Insurance Review 10(1): 69-85.
44. Ennsfellner, K.C., Lewis, D. and Anderson, R.I. (2004) 'Production efficiency in the Austrian insurance industry: A Bayesian examination', Journal of Risk and Insurance 71(1): 135-159.
45. Erhemjamts, O. and Leverty, J.T. (2007) The demise of the mutual organizational form: An investigation of the life insurance industry, Working Paper.
46. Fecher, F., Perelman, S. and Pestieau, P. (1991) 'Scale economics and performance in the French insurance industry', The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issues and Practice 16(3): 315-326.
47. Fecher, F., Kessler, D., Perelman, S. and Pestieau, P. (1993) 'Productive performance of the French insurance industry', Journal of Productivity Analysis 4(1-2): 77-93.
48. Fenn, P., Vencappa, D., Diacon, S., Klumpes, P. and O'Brien, C. (2008) 'Market structure and the efficiency of European insurance companies: A stochastic frontier analysis', Journal of Banking and Finance 32(1): 86-100.
49. Fuentes, H., Grifell-Tatjé, E. and Perelman, S. (2001) 'A parametric distance function approach for Malmquist productivity index estimation', Journal of Productivity Analysis 15(2): 79-94.
50. Fuentes, H., Grifell-Tatjé, E. and Perelman, S. (2005) Product specialization, efficiency and productivity change in the Spanish insurance industry, working paper, Université de Liège.
51. Fukuyama, H. (1997) 'Investigating productive efficiency and productivity changes of Japanese life insurance companies', Pacific-Basin Finance Journal 5(4): 481-509.
52. Fukuyama, H. and Weber, W.L. (2001) 'Efficiency and productivity change of non-life insurance companies in Japan', Pacific Economic Review 6(1): 129-146.
53. Gallant, A.R. (1982) 'Unbiased determination of production technologies', Journal of Econometrics 20(2): 285-323.
54. Gardner, L.A. and Grace, M.F. (1993) 'X-efficiency in the US life insurance industry', Journal of Banking and Finance 17(2-3): 497-510.
55. Grace, M.F. and Timme, S.G. (1992) 'An examination of cost economies in the United States life insurance industry', Journal of Risk and Insurance 59(1): 72-103.
56. Greene, W.H. and Segal, D. (2004) 'Profitability and efficiency in the US life insurance industry', Journal of Productivity Analysis 21(3): 229-247.
57. Grosskopf, S. (1993) 'Efficiency and productivity', in H.O. Fried, C.A.K. Lovell and S.S. Schmidt (eds.) The Measurement of Productive Efficiency: Techniques and Applications, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
58. Gründl, H. and Schmeiser, H. (2007) 'Capital allocation for insurance companies-what good is it?' Journal of Risk and Insurance 74(3): 301-317.
59. Hancock, D. (1985) 'The financial firm: Production with monetary and nonmonetary goods', Journal of Political Economy 93(5): 859-880.
60. Hao, J.C.J. (2007) 'Efficiency test on Taiwan's life insurance industry-using x-efficiency approach', Information and Management Sciences 18(1): 37-48.
61. Hao, J.C.J. and Chou, L.-Y. (2005) 'The estimation of efficiency for life insurance industry: The case in Taiwan', Journal of Asian Economics 16(5): 847-860.
62. Hardwick, P. (1997) 'Measuring cost inefficiency in the UK life insurance industry', Applied Financial Economics 7(1): 37-44.
63. Hardwick, P., Adams, M. and Zou, H. (2004) Corporate governance and cost efficiency in the United Kingdom life insurance industry, Working Paper.
64. Hirao, Y. and Inoue, T. (2004) 'On the cost structure of the Japanese property-casualty insurance industry', Journal of Risk and Insurance 71(3): 501-530.
65. Huang, W. (2007) Efficiency in the China insurance industry: 1999-2004, Working Paper.
66. Huang, C. and Liu, J. (1994) 'Estimation of a non-neutral stochastic frontier production function', Journal of Productivity Analysis 5(2): 171-180.
67. Hussels, S. and Ward, D.R. (2006) The impact of deregulation on the German and UK life insurance markets: An analysis of efficiency and productivity between 1991-2002, Working Paper, Cranfield Management Research Paper Series (4).
68. Hwang, S.N. and Kao, C. (2008a) 'Using two-stage DEA to measure managerial efficiency change of non-life insurance companies in Taiwan', International Journal of Management and Decision Making 9(4): 377-401.
69. Hwang, S.N. and Kao, C. (2008b) 'Efficiency decomposition in two-stage data envelopment analysis: An application to non-life insurance companies in Taiwan', European Journal of Operational Research 185(1): 418-429.
70. Hwang, T. and Gao, S.S. (2005) 'An empirical study of cost efficiency in the Irish life insurance industry', International Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Performance Evaluation 2(3): 264-280.
71. Jeng, V. and Lai, G.C. (2005) 'Ownership structure, agency costs, specialization, and efficiency: Analysis of Keiretsu and independent insurers in the Japanese nonlife insurance industry', Journal of Risk and Insurance 72(1): 105-158.
72. Jeng, V., Lai, G.C. and McNamara,M.J. (2007) 'Efficiency and demutualization: Evidence from the U.S. life insurance industry in the 1980s and 1990s', Journal of Risk and Insurance 74(3): 683-711.
73. Kessner, K. (2001a) 'Ein Effizienzvergleich deutscher und britischer Lebensversicherungen', In: Markttransparenz und Produktionseffizienz in der deutschen Lebensversicherung. Dissertation, Ludwig- Maximilians-Universität München.
74. Kessner, K. (2001b) 'Skaleneffizienz und Produktivitä tswachstum in der deutschen Lebensversicherung', In: Markttransparenz und Produktionseffizienz in der deutschen Lebensversicherung. Dissertation,Ludwig-Maximilians- Universität München.
75. Kessner, K. and Polborn, M. (1999) 'Eine Effizienzanalyse der deutschen Lebensversicherer-die Best Practice Methode', Zeitschrift für die gesamte Versicherungswissenschaft 88(2-3): 469-488.
76. Kim, H. and Grace, M.F. (1995) Potential ex post efficiency gains of insurance company mergers, working paper, Center for RMI Research 95-104, College of Business Administration, Georgia State University, Atlanta.
77. Klumpes, P.J.M. (2004) 'Performance benchmarking in financial services: Evidence from the UK life insurance industry', Journal of Business 77(2): 257-274.
78. Klumpes, P.J.M. (2007) Consolidation and efficiency in the major European insurance markets, Working Paper, Imperial College, London.
79. Kumbhakar, S.C. and Lovell, C.A.K. (2000) Stochastic Frontier Analysis, New York: Cambridge University Press.
80. Leverty, T.J. and Grace, M.F. (2008) Issues in measuring the efficiency of property-liability insurers,Working Paper.
81. Leverty, T., Lin, Y. and Zhou, H. (2004) Firm performance in the Chinese insurance industry, Wharton Working Paper.
82. Luhnen, M. (2008) Determinants of efficiency and productivity in German property-liability insurance: Evidence for 1995-2006, Working Paper, University of St. Gallen.
83. Mahlberg, B. (1999) 'Effizienzmessung ö sterreichischer und deutscher Versicherungen-Ein Vergleich', Wirtschaftspolitische Blätter 46(4): 400-406.
84. Mahlberg, B. (2000) 'Technischer Fortschritt und Produktivitä tsverä nderungen in der deutschen Versicherungswirtschaft', Jahrbücher für Nationalökonomik und Statistik 220(5): 565-591.
85. Mahlberg, B. and Url, T. (2000) The transition to the single market in the German insurance industry, Working Paper, Austrian Institute of Economic Research.
86. Mahlberg, B. and Url, T. (2003) 'Effects of the single market on the Austrian insurance industry', Empirical Economics 28(4): 813-838.
87. Mansor, S.A. and Radam, A. (2000) 'Productivity and efficiency performance of the Malaysian life insurance industry', Jurnal Ekonomi Malaysia 34(1): 93-105.
88. Mayers, D. and Smith, C.W. (1988) 'Ownership structure across lines of property-casualty insurance', Journal of Law and Economics 31(2): 351-378.
89. Meador, J.W., Ryan Jr., H.E. and Schellhorn, C.D. (2000) Product focus versus diversification: Estimates of x-efficiency for the US life insurance industry, Working Paper, Wharton Financial Institutions Center, University of Pennsylvania.
90. Mester, L.J. (1991) 'Agency costs among savings and loans', Journal of Financial Intermediation 1(3): 257-278.
91. Morrison, C.J. and Berndt, E.R. (1982) 'Short-run labor productivity in a dynamic model', Journal of Econometrics 16(3): 339-365.
92. Myers, S.C. and Read Jr., J.A. (2001) 'Capital allocation for insurance companies', Journal of Risk and Insurance 68(4): 545-580.
93. Noulas, A.G., Hatzigayios, T., Lazaridis, J. and Lyroudi, K. (2001) 'Non-parametric production frontier approach to the study of efficiency of non-life insurance companies in Greece', Journal of Financial Management and Analysis 14(1): 19-26.
94. Pulley, L.B. and Braunstein, Y. (1992) 'A composite cost function for multiproduct firms with an application to economies of scope in banking', Review of Economics and Statistics 74(2): 221-230.
95. Qiu, S. and Chen, B. (2006) Efficiencies of life insurers in China-An application of data envelopment analysis, working paper.
96. Rai, A. (1996) 'Cost efficiency of international insurance firms', Journal of Financial Services Research 10(3): 213-233.
97. Rees, R., Kessner, E., Klemperer, P. and Matutes, C. (1999) 'Regulation and efficiency in European insurance markets', Economic Policy 14(29): 363-397.
98. Ryan Jr., H.E. and Schellhorn, C.D. (2000) 'Life insurer cost efficiency before and after implementation of the NAIC risk-based capital standards', Journal of Insurance Regulation 18(3): 362-384.
99. Simar, L. and Wilson, P.W. (1998) 'Sensitivity analysis of efficiency scores: How to bootstrap in nonparametric frontier models', Management Science 44(1): 49-61.
100. Simar, L. and Wilson, P.W. (2007) 'Estimation and inference in two-stage, semi-parametric models of production processes', Journal of Econometrics 136(1): 31-64.
101. Toivanen, O. (1997) 'Economies of scale and scope in the Finnish non-life insurance industry', Journal of Banking and Finance 21(6): 759-779.
102. Tone, K. and Sahoo, B.K. (2005) 'Evaluating cost efficiency and returns to scale in the life insurance corporation of India using data envelopment analysis', Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 39(4): 261-285.
103. Trigo Gamarra, L. (2008) The effects of liberalization and deregulation on the performance of financial institutions: The case of the German life insurance market, Working Paper, University of Rostock. Trigo
104. Gamarra, L. and Growitsch, C. (2008) Single- versus multi-channel distribution strategies in the German life insurance market: A cost and profit efficiency analysis, Thünen-Series of Applied Economic Theory Working Paper no. 81, University of Rostock.
105. Turchtti, G. and Daraio, C. (2004) 'How deregulation shapes market structure and industry efficiency: The case of the Italian motor insurance industry', The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issues and Practice 29(2): 202-218.
106. Van den Broeck, J., Koop, G., Osiewalski, J. and Steel, M.F.J. (1994) 'Stochastic frontier models: A Bayesian perspective', Journal of Econometrics 61(2): 273-303.
107. Vencappa, D., Fenn, P. and Diacon, S. (2008) Parametric decomposition of total factor productivity growth in the European insurance industry: Evidence from life and non-life companies, Working Paper.
108. Ward, D. (2002) 'The costs of distribution in the UK life insurance market', Applied Economics 34(15): 1959-1968.
109. Weiss, M.A. (1986) 'Analysis of productivity at the firm level: An application to life insurers', Journal of Risk and Insurance 53(1): 49-84.
110. Weiss, M.A. (1991a) 'Efficiency in the property-liability insurance industry', Journal of Risk and Insurance 58(3): 452-479.
111. Weiss, M.A. (1991b) 'International P/L insurance output, input, and productivity comparisons', Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory 16(2): 179-200.
112. Wende, S., Berry-Stö lzle, T.R. and Lai, G.L. (2008) The effect of regulation on comparative advantages of different organizational forms: Evidence from the German property-liability insurance industry, Working Paper, University of Cologne.
113. Worthington, A.C. and Hurley, E.V. (2002) 'Cost efficiency in Australian general insurers: A non-parametric approach', British Accounting Review 34(1): 89-108.
114. Wu, D., Yang, Z., Vela, S. and Liang, L. (2007) 'Simultaneous analysis of production and investment performance of Canadian life and health insurance companies using data envelopment analysis', Computers&Operations Research 34(1): 180-198.
115. Xie, X. (2008) Are publicly held firms less efficient? Evidence from the U.S. property-liability insurance industry, Working Paper.
116. Yang, Z. (2006) 'A two-stage DEA model to evaluate the overall performance of Canadian life and health insurance companies and computer', Mathematical and Computer Modelling 43(7-8): 910-919.
117. Yao, S., Han, Z. and Feng, G. (2007) 'On technical efficiency of China's insurance industry after WTO accession', China Economic Review 18(1): 66-86.
118. Yuan, Y. and Phillips, R.D. (2008) Financial integration and scope efficiency in U.S. financial services post Gramm-Leach-Bliley, Working Paper.
119. Yuengert, A.M. (1993) 'The measurement of efficiency in life insurance: estimates of a mixed normal-gamma error model', Journal of Banking and Finance 17(2-3): 483-496.
120. Zanghieri, P. (2008) Efficiency of European insurance companies: Do local factors matter?, Working Paper, Association of Italian Insurers, Rome.