Modelling protein crystallisation using morphological population balance models

Chemical Engineering Research and Design

Volumn 88, Issue 4, 2010, Pages 437-446

  Liu, Jing J ^a,b   Ma, Cai Y ^b   Hu, Yang D ^a   Wang, Xue Z ^b  

^a OCEAN UNIVERSITY OF CHINA   (China)

^b UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Crystal morphology and shape; Crystal shape control; Morphological population balance; Multi dimensional population balance; Protein crystallisation; Tetragonal Hen Egg White lysozyme

Indexed keywords

CRYSTAL MORPHOLOGIES; CRYSTAL SHAPES; CRYSTALLISATION; MULTIDIMENSIONAL POPULATION BALANCE; POPULATION BALANCES;

CRYSTALLIZATION; ENZYMES; GRAIN BOUNDARIES; GROWTH KINETICS; MORPHOLOGY; SINGLE CRYSTALS; STAINLESS STEEL;

POPULATION STATISTICS;

EID: 77951298660     PISSN: 02638762     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cherd.2009.08.015     Document Type: Article

References (66)

1. Agena S.M., Pusey M.L. Protein solubility modeling. Biotechnology and Bioengineering 1999, 64.
2. Bennema P. Theory of growth and morphology applied to organic-crystals-possible applications to protein crystals. Journal of Crystal Growth 1992, 122:110-119.
3. Berthou J., Jolles P. A phase transition in a protein crystal: the example of hen lysozyme. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA)-Protein Structure 1974, 336:222-227.
4. Briesen H. Simulation of crystal size and shape by means of a reduced two-dimensional population balance model. Chemical Engineering Science 2006, 61:104-112.
5. Cacioppo E., Munson S., Pusey M.L. Protein solubilities determined by a rapid technique and modification of that technique to a micro-method. Journal of Crystal Growth 1991, 110:66-71.
6. Cacioppo E., Pusey M.L. The solubility of the tetragonal form of hen egg white lysozyme from pH 4.0 to 5.4. Journal of Crystal Growth 1991, 114:286-292.
7. Carbone M.N., Etzel M.R. Seeded isothermal batch crystallisation of lysozyme. Biotechnology and Bioengineering 2005, 93:1221-1224.
8. Chiu T., El-Farra N.H., Christofides P.D. Nonlinear control of particulate processes with input constraints. Proceedings of the 2000 American Control Conference, vols. 1-6 2000, 1752-1759.
9. Christofides P.D., Ei-Farrac N., Li M., Mhaskar P. Model-based control of particulate processes. Chemical Engineering Science 2008, 63:1156-1172.
10. Christofides P.D., Li M., Madler L. Control of particulate processes: recent results and future challenges. Powder Technology 2007, 175:1-7.
11. Darcy P.A., Wiencek J.M. Eastimating lysozyme crystallisation growth rates and solubility from isothermal microcalorimetry. Acta Crystallographica 1998, D54:1387-1394.
12. Doraiswami R. Population Balances-Theory and Applications to Particulate Systems in Engineering 2000, A Harcourt Science and Technology Company, USA.
13. Dorao C.A., Jakobsen H.A. Numerical calculation of the moments of the population balance equation. Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics 2006, 196:619-633.
14. Durbin S.D., Carlson W.E., Saros M.T. In situ studies of protein crystal growth by atomic force microscopy. Applied Physics 1993, 2(6):B128-132.
15. Durbin S.D., Feher G. Crystal growth studies of lysozyme as a model for protein crystallisation. Journal of Crystal Growth 1986, 76:583-592.
16. Durbin S.D., Feher G. Studies of crystal growth mechanisms of proteins by electron microscopy. Journal of Molecular Biology 1990, 212:763-774.
17. Durbin S.D., Feher G. Simulation of lysozyme crystal growth by the Monte Carlo method. Journal of Crystal Growth 1991, 110:41-51.
18. Forsythe, Ewing F., Pusey M.L. Studies on tetragonal lysozyme crystal growth rates. Acta Crystallographica 1994, D50:614-619.
19. Forsythe E.F., Pusey M.L. Studies on tetragonal lysozyme crystal growth rates. Acta Crystallographica 1994, D50:614-619.
20. Forsythe E.L., Judge R.A., Pusey M.L. Tetragonal chicken egg white lysozyme solubility in sodium chloride solutions. Journal of Chemical and Engineering Data 1999, 44:637-640.
21. Gadewar S.B., Doherty M.F. A dynamic model for evolution of crystal shape. Journal of Crystal Growth 2004, 267:239-250.
22. Gerstlauer A., Gahn C., Zhou H., Rauls M., Schreiber M. Application of population balances in the chemical industry-current status and future needs. Chemical Engineering Science 2006, 61:205-217.
23. Gerstlauer A., Mitrovic A., Motz S., Gilles E.D. A population model for crystallisation processes using two independent particle properties. Chemical Engineering Science 2001, 56:2553-2565.
24. Gerstlauer A., Motz S., Mitrovic A., Gilles E.D. Development, analysis and validation of population models for continuous and batch crystallizers. Chemical Engineering Science 2002, 57:4311-4327.
25. Gunawan R., Fusman I., Braatz R.D. High resolution algorithms for multidimensional population balance equations. AIChE Journal 2004, 50:2738-2749.
26. Hojjati H., Rohani S. Cooling and seeding effect on supersaturation and final crystal size distribution (CSD) of ammonium sulphate in a batch crystallizer. Chemical Engineering and Processing 2005, 44:949-957.
27. Howard S.B., Twigg P.J., Baird J.K., Meehan E.J. The solubility of hen egg-white lysozyme. Journal of Crystal Growth 1988, 90:94-104.
28. Kurihara K., Miyashita S., Sazaki G., Nakada T., Suzuki Y., Komatsu H. Interferometric study on the crystal growth of tetragonal lysozyme crystal. Journal of Crystal Growth 1996, 166:904-908.
29. Lin Y., Lee K., Matsoukas T. Solution of the population balance equation using constant-number Monte Carlo. Chemical Engineering Science 2002, 57:2241-2252.
30. Liu, J.J., Ma, C.Y., Hu, Y.D. and Wang, X.Z., 2009. Morphological population balance models for the dynamic evolution of particle shape and size distribution in protein crystallisation. Rita Maria de Brito Alves, Claudio Augusto Oller do Nascimento and Evaristo Chalbaud Biscaia Jr., eds. Proceedings of 10th International Symposium on Process Systems Engineering-PSE2009, Salvador, Brazil, 16-20, August, pp. 1911-1916.
31. Ma C.Y., Wang X.Z. Crystal growth rate dispersion modelling using morphological population balance. AIChE Journal 2008, 54:2321-2334.
32. Ma C.Y., Wang X.Z., Roberts K.J. Morphological population balance for modeling crystal growth in face directions. AIChE Journal 2008, 54:209-222.
33. Ma C.Y., Wang X.Z. Multi-dimensional population balance modeling of the growth of rod-like l-glutamic acid crystals using growth rates estimated from in-process imaging. Advanced Powder Technology 2007, 18:707-723.
34. Ma, C.Y. and Wang, X.Z., 2009. Development of a morphological population balance model in principal component space. Rita Maria de Brito Alves, Claudio Augusto Oller do Nascimento and Evaristo Chalbaud Biscaia Jr., eds. Proceedings of 10th International Symposium on Process Systems Engineering-PSE2009, Salvador, Brazil, 16-20, August, pp. 723-728.
35. Ma D.L., Tafti D.K., Braatz R.D. High-resolution simulation of multidimensional crystal growth. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 2002, 41:6217-6223.
36. Ma D.L., Tafti D.K., Braatz R.D. Optimal control and simulation of multidimensional crystallisation processes. Computers & Chemical Engineering 2002, 26:1103-1116.
37. Monaco L.A., Rosenberger F. Growth and etching kinetics of tetragonal lysozyme. Journal of Crystal Growth 1993, 129:465-484.
38. Nadarajah A., Forsythe E.L., Pusey M.L. The averaged face growth rates of lysozyme crystals: the effect of temperature. Journal of Crystal Growth 1995, 151:163-172.
39. Nadarajah A., Li M.R., Pusey M.L. Growth mechanism of the (110) face of tetragonal lysozyme crystals. Acta Crystallographica Section D-Biological Crystallography 1997, 53:524-534.
40. Nadarajah A., Pusey M.L. Growth mechanism and morphology of tetragonal lysozyme crystals. Acta Crystallographica Section D 1996, 52:983-996.
41. Nowee S.M., Abbas A., Romagnoli J.A. Modelling and Development of Optimal Operational Policies for Batch Seeded Crystallisation 2004, Chemeca, Sydney, Australia, pp. 26-29.
42. Oullion M., Puel F., Fevotte G., Righini S., Carvin P. Industrial batch crystallisation of a plate-like organic product. In situ monitoring and 2D-CSD modelling. Part 2: Kinetic modelling and identification. Chemical Engineering Science 2007, 62:833-845.
43. Puel F., Fevotte G., Klein J.P. Simulation and analysis of industrial crystallisation processes through multidimensional population balance equations. Part 1: a resolution algorithm based on the method of classes. Chemical Engineering Science 2003, 58:3715-3727.
44. Puel F., Fevotte G., Klein J.P. Simulation and analysis of industrial crystallisation processes through multidimensional population balance equations. Part 2: A study of semi-batch crystallisation. Chemical Engineering Science 2003, 58:3729-3740.
45. Pusey M.L., Gernert K. A method for rapid liquid-solid phase solubility measurements using the protein lysozyme. Journal of Crystal Growth 1988, 88:419-424.
46. Pusey M.L., Nadarajah A. A model for tetragonal lysozyme crystal nucleation and growth. Crystal Growth & Design 2002, 2:475-483.
47. Pusey M.L., Snyder R.S., Naumann R. Protein crystal growth. The Journal of Biological Chemistry 1986, 261:6524-6529.
48. Qamar S., Warnecke G. Numerical solution of population balance equations for nucleation, growth and aggregation processes. Computers & Chemical Engineering 2007, 31:1576-1589.
49. Ramkrishna D. The framework of population balance. Population Balances 2000, Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 7-45.
50. Ramkrishna D., Mahoney A.W. Population balance modelling. Promise for the future. Chemical Engineering Science 2002, 57:595-606.
51. Rosenberger F., Howard S.B., Sowers J.W., Nyce T.A. Temperature dependence of protein solubility-determination and application to crystallisation in X-ray capillaries. Journal of Crystal Growth 1993, 129:1-12.
52. Sato K., Nagaib H., Hasegawab K., Tomorib K., Kramer H.J.M., Jansensa P.J. Two-dimensional population balance model with breakage of high aspect ratio crystals for batch crystallisation. Chemical Engineering Science 2008, 63:3271-3278.
53. Sazaki G., Kurihara K., Nakada T., Miyashita S., Komatsu H. A novel approach to the solubility measurement of protein crystals by two-beam interferometry. Journal of Crystal Growth 1996, 169:355-360.
54. Shi D., Mhaskar P., El-Farra N.H., Christofides P.D. Predictive control of crystal size distribution in protein crystallisation. Nanotechnology 2005, 16:S562-S574.
55. Sotowa K.I., Naito K., Kano M., Hasebe S., Hashimoto I. Application of the method of characteristics to crystallizer simulation and comparison with finite difference for controller performance evaluation. Journal of Process Control 2000, 10:203-208.
56. Sridhar Gorti, Forsythe E.L., Pusey M.L. Kinetic roughening and energetics of tetragonal lysozyme crystal growth. Crystal Growth and Design 2004, 4:691-699.
57. Vekilov P.G., Rosenberger F. Dependence of lysozyme growth kinetics on step sources and impurities. Journal of Crystal Growth 1996, 158:540-551.
58. Villadsen J. On the use of population balances. Journal of Biotechnology 1999, 71:251-253.
59. Wan J., Wang X.Z., Ma C.Y. Model-based optimisation and closed-loop control of crystal shape in cooling crystallisation. 19th European Symposium on Computer Aided Process Engineering-ESCAPE 19 2009, 483-488. J. Jezowski, J. Thullie (Eds.).
60. Wan J., Wang X.Z., Ma C.Y. Particle shape manipulation and optimisation in cooling crystallisation involving multiple crystal morphological forms. AIChE Journal 2009, 55:2049-2061.
61. Wang X.Z., Calderon De Anda J., Roberts K.J. Real-time measurement of the growth rates of individual crystal facets using imaging and image analysis: a feasibility study on needle-shaped crystals of l-glutamic acid. Chemical Engineering Research and Design 2007, 85:921-927.
62. Wang X.Z., Ma C.Y. Morphological population balance model in principal component space. AIChE Journal 2009, 55:2370-2381.
63. Wang X.Z., Ma C.Y., Roberts K.J. Shape-the final frontier. Computer-Aided Chemical Engineering. 18th European Symposium on Computer Aided Process Engineering-ESCAPE 18, vol. 25 2008, 817-822. B. Braunschweig, X. Joulia (Eds.).
64. Wang X.Z., Roberts K.J., Ma C.Y. Crystal growth measurement using 2D and 3D imaging and the perspectives for shape control. Chemical Engineering Science 2008, 63:1173-1184.
65. 2O system with artificial neural network. Journal of Crystal Growth 2004, 264:409-416.
66. Zhu D.W., Garneau A., Mazumdar M., Zhou M., Xu G.J., Lin S.X. Attempts to rationalize protein crystallisation using relative crystallizability. Journal of Structural Biology 2006, 154:297-302.