Estimating root production: Comparison of 11 methods in shortgrass steppe and review of biases

Ecosystems

Volumn 12, Issue 8, 2009, Pages 1381-1402

  Milchunas, Daniel G ^a  

^a Veterinary Dentistry and Oral Surgery   (United States)

Author keywords

Belowground net primary production (BNPP); Carbon flux; Excavation window; Isotope decay; Minirhizotron; Nitrogen budget; Root coring; Root decomposition; Root ingrowth cores and donuts; Root longevity; Root turnover

Indexed keywords

BELOWGROUND BIOMASS; CARBON FLUX; CARBON ISOTOPE; COMPARATIVE STUDY; DECOMPOSITION; ISOTOPIC ANALYSIS; NET PRIMARY PRODUCTION; NUMERICAL MODEL; ROOT SYSTEM; STEPPE;

EID: 77949775882     PISSN: 14329840     EISSN: 14350629     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s10021-009-9295-8     Document Type: Article

References (87)

1. Aber JD, Melillo JM, Nadelhoffer JK, McClaugherty CA, Pastor J. 1985. Fine root turnover in forest ecosystems in relation to quality and form of nitrogen availability: a comparison of two methods. Oecologia 66: 317-21.
2. Ares J. 1976. Dynamics of the root system of blue grama. J Range Manage 29: 208-13.
3. 2. New Phytol 147: 73-85.
4. Biondini ME, Lauenroth WK, Sala OE. 1991. Correcting estimates of net primary production: are we overestimating plant production in rangelands? J Range Manage 44: 194-8.
5. Burke IC, Mosier AR, Hook PB, Milchunas DG, Barrett JE, Vinton MA, McCulley RL, Kaye JP, Gill RA, Epstein HE, Kelly RH, Parton WJ, Yonker CM, Lowe P, Lauenroth WK. 2008. Biogeochemistry of soil organic matter and nutrient dynamics of shortgrass steppe ecosystems. In: Lauenroth WK, Burke IC, Eds. Ecology of the shortgrass steppe: a long-term perspective. New York: Oxford University Press. p 306-41.
6. Caldwell MM, Camp LB. 1974. Belowground productivity of two cool desert communities. Oecologia 17: 123-30.
7. 15Nitrogen in a short-grass prairie. Ecology 58: 1322-32.
8. Coffin DP, Lauenroth WK. 1991. Effects of competition on spatial distribution of roots of blue grama. J Range Manage 44: 68-71.
9. Dahlman RC, Kucera CL. 1965. Root productivity and turnover in native prairie. Ecology 46: 84-9.
10. Dahlman, RC, Kucera CL. 1967. Carbon-14 cycling in the root and soil components of a prairie ecosystem. In: Nelson DJ, Evans FC, Eds. Symposium on radioecology. Publication Number 272, U. S. Atomic Energy Commission, Radiation Ecology Section, and Clearinghouse for Federal Scientific and Technical Information. p 652-60.
11. Dahlman RC, Kucera CL. 1968. Tagging native grassland vegetation with carbon-14. Ecology 49: 1199-203.
12. Eissenstat DM, Caldwell MM. 1988. Seasonal timing of root growth in favorable microsites. Ecology 69: 870-3.
13. Eissenstat DM, Yanai RD. 1997. The ecology of root lifespan. Adv Ecol Res 27: 1-60.
14. Fahey TJ, Bledsoe CS, Day FP, Ruess RW, Smucker AM. 1999. Fine root production and demography. In: Robertson GP, Bledsoe CS, Coleman D, Sollins P, Eds. Standard soil methods for long-term ecological research. New York: Oxford University Press. p 437-55.
15. Fahey TJ, Hughs JW. 1994. Fine root dynamics in a northern hardwood forest ecosystem, Hubbard Brook Experimental Forest, NH. J Ecol 82: 533-48.
16. Fitter AH. 1976. Effects of nutrient supply and competition from other species on root growth of Lolium perenne in soil. Plant Soil 45: 177-89.
17. Fogel R. 1990. Root turnover and production in forest trees. Hortscience 25: 270-3.
18. Hansson AL, Andrén O. 1986. Below-ground plant production in a perennial grass ley (Festuca pratensis Huds.) assessed with different methods. J Appl Ecol 23: 657-66.
19. Kurz WA, Kimmins JP. 1987. Analysis of some sources of error in methods used to determine fine root production in forest ecosystems: a simulation approach. Can J For Res 17: 909-12.
20. Gaudinski JB, Trumbore SE, Davidson EA, Cook AC, Markewitz D, Richter DD. 2001. The age of fine-root carbon in three forests of the eastern United States measured by radiocarbon. Oecologia 129: 420-9.
21. Geisler D, Ferree DC. 1984. Response of plants to root pruning. Hort Rev 6: 155-88.
22. Gill RA, Kelly RH, Parton WJ, Day KA, Jackson RB, Morgan JA, Scurlock JMO, Tieszen LL, Castle JV, Ojima DS, Zhang XS. 2002. Using simple environmental variables to estimate belowground productivity in grasslands. Global Ecol Biogeogr 11: 79-86.
23. Hendrick RL, Pergitzer KS. 1993. Applications of minirhizotrons to understand root function in forests and other natural ecosystems. Plant Soil 185: 293-304.
24. Hendricks JJ, Hendrick RL, Wilson CA, Mitchell RJ, Pecot SD, Guo D. 2006. Assessing the patterns and controls of fine root dynamics: an empirical test and methodological review. J Ecol 94: 40-57.
25. Hendricks JJ, Nadelhoffer KJ, Aber JD. 1993. Assessing the role of fine roots in carbon and nitrogen cycling. Trends Ecol Evol 8: 174-8.
26. Hendrickson AH, Veihmeyer FJ. 1931. Influence of dry soil on root extension. Plant Physiol 6: 567-76.
27. Hertel D, Leuschner C. 2002. A comparison of four different fine root production estimates with ecosystem carbon balance data in a Fagus-Quercus mixed forest. Plant Soil 239: 237-51.
28. Higgens PAT, Jackson RB, Des Rosiers JM, Field CB. 2002. Root production and demography in a California annual grassland under elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide. Global Change Biol 8: 841-50.
29. Jordan CF, Escalante G. 1980. Root productivity in an Amazonian rain forest. Ecology 61: 14-18.
30. Joslin JD, Wolfe MH. 1999. Disturbance during minirhizotron installation can affect root observation data. Soil Sci Soc Am J 63: 218-21.
31. King JY, Mosier AR, Morgan JA, LeCain DR, Milchunas DG, Parton WJ. 2004. Plant nitrogen dynamics in shortgrass steppe under elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide. Ecosystems 7: 147-60.
32. Lauenroth WK. 2000. Methods of estimating belowground net primary production. In: Sala OE, Jackson RB, Mooney HA, Howarth RW, Eds. Methods in ecosystem science. New York: Springer-Verlag. p 58-71.
33. Lauenroth WK, Hunt HW, Swift DM, Singh JS. 1986. Estimating aboveground net primary production in grasslands: a simulation approach. Ecol Model 33: 297-314.
34. Lauenroth WK, Milchunas DG. 1991. The shortgrass steppe. In: Coupland RT, Ed. Natural grasslands, introduction and western hemisphere. Ecosystems of the World 8A. Amsterdam: Elsevier. p 183-226.
35. 2 enrichment on native shortgrass steppe. Plant Soil 279: 219-28.
36. Leetham JW, Milchunas DG. 1985. The composition and distribution of soil microarthropods in the shortgrass steppe in relation to the soil water, root biomass, and grazing by cattle. Pedobiologia 28: 311-25.
37. Litton CM, Raich JW, Ryan MG. 2007. Carbon allocation in forest ecosystems. Global Change Biol 13: 2089-109.
38. Litton CM, Giardina CP. 2008. Below-ground carbon flux and partitioning: global patterns and response to temperature. Functional Ecol 22: 941-54.
39. Lund ZF, Pearson RW, Buchanan GA. 1970. An implanted soil mass technique to study herbicide effects on root growth. Weed Sci 18: 279-81.
40. Luo Y. 2003. Uncertainties in interpretation of isotope signals for estimation of fine root longevity: theoretical considerations. Global Change Biol 9: 1118-29.
41. Matamala R, Gonzalez-Meler MA, Jastrow JD, Norby RJ, Schlesinger WH. 2003. Impact of fine root turnover on forest NPP and soil C sequestration potential. Science 302: 1385-7.
42. McCulley RL, Burke IC, Nelson JA, Lauenroth WK, Knapp AK, Kelly EF. 2005. Regional patterns in carbon cycling across the Great Plains of North America. Ecosystems 8: 106-21.
43. McNaughton SJ, Milchunas DG, Frank DA. 1996. How can primary productivity be measured in grazing ecosystems? Ecology 77: 974-7.
44. 14 turnover. Ecology 73: 593-607.
45. Milchunas DG, Lauenroth WK. 2001. Belowground primary production by carbon isotope decay and long-term root biomass dynamics. Ecosystems 4: 139-50.
46. 14C dilution: implications of carbon partitioning in plants. Plant Soil 88: 353-65.
47. 2: Using a new ingrowth method. Plant Soil 268: 111-22.
48. 2, and comments on minirhizotron methodology. Global Change Biol 11: 1837-55.
49. 2 enhances productivity but alters species composition and reduces forage quality in the Colorado shortgrass steppe. Ecol Appl 14: 208-19.
50. Mosier AR, Parton WJ, Martin RE, Valentine DW, Ojima DS, Schimel DS, Burke IC. 2008. Soil-atmosphere exchange of trace gases in the Colorado Shortgrass Steppe. In: Lauenroth WK, Burke IC, Eds. Ecology of the shortgrass steppe: a long-term perspective. New York: Oxford University Press. p 342-72.
51. Nadelhoffer KJ. 2000. The potential effects of N deposition on fine root-production in forest ecosystems. New Phytol 147: 131-9.
52. Nadelhoffer KJ, Aber JD, Melillo JM. 1985. Fine roots, net primary production, and soil nitrogen availability: a new hypothesis. Ecology 66: 1377-90.
53. Nadelhoffer KJ, Raich JW. 1992. Fine root production estimates and belowground carbon allocation in forest ecosystems. Ecology 73: 1139-47.
54. Nadelhoffer KJ, Raich JW, Aber JD. 1998. A global trend in belowground carbon allocation: comment. Ecology 79: 1822-5.
55. Neill C. 1992. Comparison of soil coring and ingrowth methods for measuring belowground production. Ecology 73: 1918-21.
56. Norby RJ, Jackson RB. 2000. Root dynamics and global change: seeking an ecosystem perspective. New Phytol 147: 3-12.
57. Pages L, Bengough AG. 1997. Modeling minirhizotron observations to test experimental procedures. Plant Soil 189: 81-9.
58. Parton WJ, Schimel DS, Cole CV, Ojima DS. 1987. Analysis of factors controlling soil organic matter levels in Great Plains grasslands. Soil Sci Soc Am J 51: 1173-9.
59. Parton WJ, Stewart JWB, Cole CV. 1988. Dynamics of C, N, P and S in grassland soils: a model. Biogeochemistry 5: 109-31.
60. Parton WJ, Singh JS, Coleman DC. 1978. A model of production and turnover of roots in shortgrass prairie. J Appl Ecol 15: 515-41.
61. 2 effects and soil water feedbacks on soil respiration components in a Colorado grassland. Global Biogeochem Cycles 17: 15-1-13.
62. Persson HA. 1978. Root dynamics in a young Scots pine stand in central Sweden. Oikos 30: 508-19.
63. Persson HA. 1979. Fine-root production, decomposition and mortality in forest ecosystems. Vegetation 41: 101-9.
64. Raich JW, Nadelhoffer KJ. 1989. Belowground carbon allocation in forest ecosystems: global trends. Ecology 70: 1346-54.
65. Ruess RW, Hendrick RL, Burton AJ, Pregitzer KS, Sveinbjornssön B, Allen MF, Maurer GE. 2003. Coupling fine root dynamics with ecosystem carbon cycling in black spruce forests of interior Alaska. Ecol Monogr 73: 643-62.
66. Ruess RW, Hendrick RL, Vogel JG, Sveinbjörnsson B. 2006. The role of fine roots in the functioning of Alaskan boreal forests. In: Chapin FSIII, Oswood MW, van Cleve K, Viereck LA, Verbyla DL, Eds. Alaska's changing boreal forest. New York: Oxford University Press. p 189-210.
67. Ruess RW, van Cleve K, Yarie J, Viereck LA. 1996. Contributions of fine root production and turnover to carbon and nitrogen cycling in taiga forests of the Alaskan interior. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 26: 1326-36.
68. Sala OE, Biondini ME, Lauenroth WK. 1988. Bias in estimates of primary production: an analytical solution. Ecol Model 44: 43-55.
69. Schimel DS, Stillwell MA, Woodmansee RG. 1985. Biogeochemistry of C, N, and P in a soil catena of the shortgrass steppe. Ecology 66: 276-82.
70. Senft RL. 1983. The redistribution of nitrogen by cattle. Ph. D. dissertation, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, 198 pp.
71. Sims PL, Singh JS. 1978. The structure and function of ten western North American grasslands. III. Net primary production, turnover and efficiency of energy capture and water use. J Ecol 66: 573-97.
72. Singh JS, Lauenroth WK, Hunt HW, Swift DM. 1984. Bias and random errors in estimators of net root production: a simulation approach. Ecology 65: 1760-4.
73. Steele SJ, Gower ST, Vogel JG, Norman JM. 1997. Root mass, net primary production and turnover in aspen, jack pine and black spruce forests in Saskatchewan and Manitoba, Canada. Tree Physiol 17: 577-87.
74. Steen E. 1983. Usefulness of the mesh bag method in quantitative root studies. In: Atkinson D, Ed. Plant root growth, an ecological perspective Brit Ecol Soc Special Publ No 10. London: Blackwell Scientific Publications. p 75-86.
75. Steen E. 1991. Variation of root growth in a grass ley studied with a mesh bag technique. Swedish J Agric Res 14: 93-7.
76. Steingrobe B, Schmid H, Claassen N. 2000. The use of the ingrowth core method for measuring root production of arable crops B influence of soil conditions inside the ingrowth core on root growth. J Plant Nutr Soil Sci 163: 612-22.
77. Steingrobe B, Schmid H, Claassen N. 2001. The use of the ingrowth core method for measuring root production of arable crops B influence of soil and root disturbance during installation of the bags on root ingrowth into the cores. Eur J Agron 15: 143-51.
78. 14C from roots of pulse-labeled wheat and barley during washing from soil. Plant Soil 166: 93-9.
79. 14C pulse-labeling of field-grown spring wheat: an evaluation of its use in rhizosphere carbon budget estimations. Soil Biol Biochem 26: 161-70.
80. 14C partitioning after pulse-labeling. Soil Biol Biochem 26: 171-82.
81. 14C pulse labeling. Soil Biol Biochem 27: 211-17.
82. Tierney GL, Fahey TJ. 2001. Evaluating minirhizotron estimates of fine root longevity and production in the forest floor of a temperate broadleaf forest. Plant Soil 229: 167-76.
83. Tierney GL, Fahey TJ. 2002. Fine root turnover in a northern hardwood forest: a direct comparison of the radiocarbon and minirhizotron methods. Can J For Res 32: 1692-7.
84. Trumbore SE, Gaudinski JB. 2003. The secret lives of roots. Science 302: 1344-5.
85. Vogt KA, Vogt DJ, Bloomfield J. 1998. Analysis of some direct and indirect methods for estimating root biomass and production of forests at an ecosystem level. Plant Soil 200: 71-89.
86. Weaver JE. 1958. Classification of root systems of forbs of grassland and a comparison of their significance. Ecology 39: 393-401.
87. Withington JM, Elkin AD, Bułlaj B, Olesińnski J, Tracy KN, Bouma TJ, Oleksyn J, Anderson LJ, Modrzyńnski J, Reich PB, Eissenstat DM. 2003. The impact of material used for minirhizotron tubes for root research. New Phytol 160: 533-44.