Analysis of some direct and indirect methods for estimating root biomass and production of forests at an ecosystem level

Plant and Soil

Volumn 200, Issue 1, 1998, Pages 71-89

  Vogt, Kristiina A ^a   Vogt, Daniel J ^a   Bloomfield, Janine ^b  

^a Yale University   (United States)

^b ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND   (United States)

Author keywords

Calculations; Carbon flux method; Fine root biomass methods; Forests; Indirect methods; Ingrowth cores; Minirhizotrons; Net primary production; Nitrogen budget method; Nutrients; Sequential soil coring

Indexed keywords

BIOMASS ESTIAMTION; FOREST; PRODUCTION ESTIMATION; ROOT BIOMASS; ROOT PRODUCTION;

EID: 0031982453     PISSN: 0032079X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1023/A:1004313515294     Document Type: Article

References (114)

1. Aber J D, Mellilo J M, Nadelhoffer K J, McClaugherty C A and Pastor J 1985 Fine root turnover in forest ecosystems in relation to quantity and form of nitrogen availability: a comparison of two methods. Oecol. (Berl.) 66, 317-321.
2. Aber J D and Federer C A 1992 A generalized, lumped-parameter model of photosynthesis, evapotranspiration and net primary production in temperate and boreal forest ecosystems. Oecol. 92, 463-474.
3. Adams C M and Hutchinson T C 1992 Fine-root growth and chemical composition in declining central Ontario sugar maple stands. Can. J. For. Res. 22, 1489-1503.
4. Ågren G I, Axelsson B, Flower-Ellis J G K, Linder S, Persson H, Staaf H and Troeng E 1980 Annual carbon budget for a young Scots pine. In Structure and Function of Northern Coniferous Forests - An Ecosystem Study. Ed. T Persson. pp 307-313. Ecol. Bull. (Stockholm) 32.
5. Ballard R 1979 Use of fertilizers to maintain productivity of intensively managed forest plantations. In Proceedings Impact of Intensive Harvesting on Forest Nutrient Cycling, pp. 321-342. Northeast For. Exp. Sta. USDA For. Serv. Pennsylvania. College of Environmental Science and Forestry, State University of New York.
6. Barber S A 1984 Soil Nutrient Bioavailability. A Mechanistic Approach. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York. 398 p.
7. Benzing DH 1991 Aerial roots and their environment. In The Hidden Half. Eds. Y Waisel, A Eshel and U Kafkafi. pp 867-886. Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York.
8. Binkley D and Hart S C 1989 The components of nitrogen availability assessments in forest soils. In Advances in Soil Science, Vol. 10. pp 57-112. Springer-Verlag, New York.
9. Bloomfield J, Vogt K A and Vogt D J 1993 Decay rate and substrate quality of fine roots and foliage of two tropical tree species in the Luquillo Experimental Forest, Puerto Rico. Plant Soil 150, 233-245.
10. Böhm W 1979 Methods of Studying Root Systems. Ecological Studies 33. Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
11. Bormann F H and Graham B F Jr 1958 Translocation of silvicides through root grafts. Forestry 58, 402-403.
12. Boul S W, Hole F D and McCracken R J 1980 Soil Genesis and Classification. 2nd ed. The Iowa State University Press, Ames, Iowa, USA. 404 p.
13. Bray J R and Gorham E 1964 Litter production in forests of the world. Adv. Ecol. Res. 2, 101-157.
14. Brown D A and Upchurch D R 1987 Minirhizotrons: A summary of methods and instruments in current use. In Minirhizotron Observation Tubes: Methods and Applications for Measuring Rhizosphere Dynamics. Ed. H M Taylor. pp 15-30. ASA Spec. Publ. no. 50. ASA, CSSA, SSSA, Inc., Madison, WI.
15. Burke M K and Raynal D J 1995 Fine root growth phenology, production, and turnover in a northern hardwood forest ecosystems. Plant and Soil 162, 135-146.
16. Caldwell M M 1979 Root structure: the considerable cost of belowground functions. In Topics in Plant Population Biology. Eds. O T Solbrig, S Jain, G B Johnson and P H Raven, pp 408-427. Columbia University Press, New York.
17. Clemensson-Lindell A 1994 Triphenyltetrazolium chloride as an indicator of fine-root vitality and environmental stress in coniferous forest stands: applications and limitations. Plant Soil 159, 297-300.
18. Clemensson-Lindell A and Persson H 1995 Fine-root vitality in a Norway spruce stand subjected to various nutrient supplies. Plant Soil 168-169, 167-172.
19. Cuevas E and Medina E 1983 Root production and organic matter decomposition in a Tierra Firme forest of the Upper Rio Negro Basin. In Wurzelokologie und Ihre Nutzanwendung. Eds. W Böhm, L Kutschera and E Lichtenegger. pp 653-666. BVA Gumpenstein, Irdning, Austria 775 p.
20. Dixon R K, Meldahl R S, Ruark G A and Warren W G (Eds.) 1990 Process Modeling of Forest Growth Responses to Environmental Stress. Timber Press, Portland, Oregon. 441 p.
21. Dixon R K, Brown S, Houghton R A, Solomon A M, Trexler M C and Wisniewski J 1994 Carbon pools and flux of global forest ecosystems. Science 263, 185-190.
22. Eissenstat D M and Caldwell M M 1988 Seasonal timing of root growth in favorable microsites. Ecology 69, 870-873.
23. Eissenstat D M and Van Rees K C J 1994 The growth and function of pine roots. In Environmental Constraints on the Structure and Productivity of Pine Forest Ecosystems: A Comparative Analysis. Eds. H L Gholz, S Linder and R E McMurtrie. pp. 76-91. Ecol. Bull. (Copenhagen) 43.
24. Ericsson A and Persson H 1980 Seasonal changes in starch reserves and growth of fine roots of 20-year-old scots pine. In Structure and Function of Northern Coniferous Forests - An Ecosystem Study, pp 239-250. Ecol. Bull. (Stockholm) 32.
25. 2 evolution in Florida slash pine plantations. II. Importance of root respiration. Can. J. For. Res. 17, 330-333.
26. Fabiao A, Persson H A and Steen E 1985 Growth dynamics of superficial roots in Portuguese plantations of Eucalyptus globulus Labill. studied with a mesh bag technique. Plant Soil 83, 233-242.
27. Ferguson J C and Smucker A J M 1989 Modifications of the minirhizotron video camera system for measuring spatial and temporal root dynamics. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 53, 1601-1605.
28. Flower-Ellis J G K and Persson H 1980 Investigations of structural properties and dynamics of Scots pine stands. In Structure and Function of Northern Coniferous Forests - An Ecosystem Study. Ed. T Persson. pp 125-138. Ecol. Bull. (Stockholm) 32.
29. Fogel R and Hunt G 1983 Contribution of mycorrhizae and soil fungi to nutrient cycling in a Douglas-fir ecosystem. Can. J. For. Res. 13, 219-232.
30. Freckman D W and Virginia R A 1989 Plant-feeding nematodes in deep-rooting desert ecosystems. Ecology 70, 1665-1678.
31. Friend A L, Eide M R and Hinckley T M 1990 Nitrogen stress alters root proliferation in Douglas-fir seedling. Can. J. For. Res. 20, 1524-1529.
32. Gholz H L, Hendry L C and Cropper W P Jr 1986 Organic matter dynamics of fine roots in plantations of slash pine (Pinus elliotti) in north Florida. Can. J. For. Res., 16, 529-538.
33. Gower S T, Vogt K A and Grier C C 1992 Carbon dynamics of Rocky Mountain Douglas-fir: influence of water and nutrient availability. Ecol. Monogr. 62, 43-65.
34. Gower S T, Gholz H L, Nakane K and Baldwin V C 1994 Production and carbon allocation patterns of pine forests. In Environmental Constraints on the Structure and Productivity of Pine Forest Ecosystems: A Comparative Analysis. Eds. H L Gholz, S Linder and R E McMurtrie. pp 115-135. Ecol. Bull. (Copenhagen) 43.
35. Gower S T, Running S W, Gholz H L, Haynes B E, Hunt J E R, Ryan M G, Waring R H and Cropper J W P 1996 Influence of climate and nutrition on carbon allocation and net primary production of four conifer forests. Tree Physiol. (In press).
36. Graham B F Jr and Bormann F H 1966 Natural root grafts. Bot. Rev. 32, 255-292.
37. Grier C C, Vogt K A, Keyes M R, and Edmonds R L 1981 Biomass distribution and above- and below-ground production in young and mature Abies amabilis zone ecosystems of the Washington Cascades. Can J. For. Res. 11, 155-167.
38. Haynes B E and Gower S T 1995 Belowground carbon allocation in unfertilized and fertilizied red pine plantations in northern Wisconsin. Tree Physiol. 15, 317-325.
39. Hendrick R L and Pregitzer K S 1992 Spatial variation in root distribution and growth associated with minirhizotrons. Plant Soil 143, 283-288.
40. Hendrick R L and Pregitzer K S 1993 The dynamics of fine root length, biomass, and nitrogen content in two northern hardwood ecosystems. Can. J. For. Res. 23, 2507-2520.
41. Henderson R, Ford E D, Renshaw E and Deans J D 1988 Morphology of the structural root system of Sitka spruce. 1. Analysis and quantitative description. Forestry 56, 121-135.
42. Ingestad T and Ågren G 1992 Theories and methods on plant nutrition and growth. Physiol. Plant. 84, 177-184.
43. Jackson R B, Canadell J, Ehleringer J R, Mooney H A, Sala O E and Schulze E D 1996 A global analysis of root distribution for terrestrial biomes. Oecologia 108, 389-411.
44. Jackson R B, Mooney H A and Schulze E-D 1997 A global budget for fine root biomass, surface area, and nutrient contents. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94, 7362-7366.
45. Joslin J D and Henderson G S 1984 The determination of percentages of living tissue in woody fine root samples using triphenyltetrazolium chloride. Forest Sci. 30, 965-970.
46. Keyes M R 1982 Ecosystem Development in Abies amabilis Stands of the Washington Cascades: Root Growth and its Role in Net Primary Production. Dissertation. University of Washington. Seattle, Washington, USA. 110 p.
47. Keyes M R and Grier C C 1981 Below- and above-ground biomass and net production in two contrasting Douglas-fir stands. Can. J. For. Res. 11, 599-605.
48. Kurz W A and Kimmins J P 1987 Analysis of some sources of error in methods used to determine fine root production in forest ecosystems: a simulation approach. Can. J. For. Res. 17, 909-912.
49. Lambers H and Poorter H 1992 Inherent variation in growth rate between higher plants: A search for physiological causes and ecological consequences. Adv. Ecol. Res. 23, 187-261.
50. Landsberg J J, Linder S and McMurtrie R E 1995 A strategic plan for research on managed forest ecosystems in a globally changing environment. Global change and Terrestrial Ecosystems GCTE Report No. 4. GCTE Activity 3.5: Effects of Global Change on Managed Forests. Implementation Plan, pp 1-17.
51. Lussenhop J, Fogel R and Pregitzer K 1991 A new dawn for soil biology: video analysis of root-soil-microbial faunal interactions. Agric. Ecosys. and Environ. 34, 235-249.
52. Lyr H and Hoffmann G 1967 Growth rates and growth periodicity of tree roots. In International Review of Forestry Research, Vol. 2. Eds. J A Romberger and P Mikola. pp 181-236. Academic Press, New York.
53. Majdi H, Smucker A J M and Persson H 1992 A comparison between minirhizotron and monolith sampling methods for measuring root growth of maize (Zea mays L.). Plant Soil 147, 127-134.
54. Marshall J D and Waring R H 1985 Predicting fine root production and turnover by monitoring root starch and soil temperature. Can. J. For. Res. 15, 791-800.
55. McClaugherty C A, Aber J D and Melillo J M 1982 The role of fine roots in the organic matter and nitrogen budgets of two forested ecosystems. Ecology 63, 1481-1490.
56. McMichael B L and Taylor H M 1987 Applications and limitations of rhizotrons and minirhizotrons. In Minirhizotron Observation Tubes: Methods and Applications for Measuring Rhizosphere Dynamics. Ed. H M Taylor. pp 1-13. ASA Spec. Publ. no. 50. ASA, CSSA, SSSA, Madison, WI.
57. McQueen D R 1968 The quantitative distribution of absorbing roots of Pinus silvestris and Fagus sylvatica in a forest succession. Oecol. Plant. 3, 83-99.
58. Meier C E, Grier C C and Cole D W 1985 Below- and above-ground N and P used by young and mature Abies amabilis stands. Ecology 66, 1928-1942.
59. 14C turnover. Ecology 73, 593-607.
60. Mooney H A 1972 The carbon balance of plants. Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 3, 315-346.
61. Muller R N, Kalisz P J and Luken J O 1989 Fine root production of astringent phenolics. Oecol. 79, 563-565.
62. Nadelhoffer K J, Aber J D and Mellilo J M 1985 Fine roots, net primary production, and soil nitrogen availability: A new hypothesis. Ecology 66, 1377-1390.
63. Nadkarni N M 1981 Canopy roots: convergent evolution in rainforest nutrient cycles. Science 214, 1023-1024.
64. Nambiar E K S 1987 Do nutrients retranslocate from fine roots? Can. J. For. Res. 17, 913-918.
65. Neill C 1992 Comparison of soil coring and ingrowth methods for measuring belowground production. Ecology 73, 1918-1921.
66. Nepstad D C, Carvalho C R de, Davidson E A, Jipp P H, Lefebvre P A, Negreiros G H, Silva E D da, Stone T A, Trumbore S E and Vieira S 1994 The role of deep roots in the hydrological and carbon cycles of Amazonian forests and pastures. Nature 372, 666-669.
67. Persson H 1978 Root dynamics in a young Scots pine stand in central Sweden. OIKOS 30, 508-519.
68. Persson H 1983 The distribution and productivity of fine roots in boreal forests. Plant Soil 71, 87-101.
69. Persson H 1984 The dynamic fine roots of forest trees. In State and Change of Forest Ecosystems - Indicators in Current Research. Ed. G I Ågren. pp 193-204. Swed. Univ. Agric. Sci. Dept Ecology and Environmental Research Report no. 13.
70. Persson H, Von Fircks Y, Majdi H and Nilsson L O 1995 Root distribution in a Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.) stand subjected to drought and ammonium-sulphate application. Plant Soil 168-169, 161-165.
71. Persson H and Baitulin I (Eds.) 1996 Plant Root Systems and Natural Vegetation. Acta Phytogeogr. Suec. 81. 131 p. Uppsala, Sweden.
72. 2, soil nitrogen and turnover of fine roots. New Phytol. 129, 579-585.
73. Publicover D and Vogt K A 1992 Belowground ecology of forests. In McGraw-Hill Yearbook of Science and Technology. Ed. S P Parker, pp 427-429. McGraw-Hill Inc., New York.
74. Publicover D A and Vogt K A 1993 A comparison of methods for estimating forest fine root production with respect to sources of error. Can. J. For. Res. 23, 1179-1186.
75. Raich J W and Nadelhoffer K J 1989 Belowground carbon allocation in forest ecosystems: Global trends. Ecology 70, 1346-1354.
76. Rendig V V and Taylor H M 1989 Principles of Soil-Plant Interrelationships. McGraw-Hill Publishing Co., New York. 275 p.
77. Roy S and Singh J S 1995 Seasonal and spatial dynamics of plant-available N and P pools and N-mineralization in relation to fine roots in a dry tropical forest habitat. Soil Biol. Biochem. 27, 33-40.
78. Ruark G A and Bockheim J G 1987 Below-ground biomass of 10-, 20-, and 32-year-old Populus tremuloides in Wisconsin. Pedobiologia 30, 207-217.
79. Ruark G A, Mader D L and Tattar T A 1982 The influence of soil compaction and aeration on the root growth and vigour of trees - a literature review. Part 1. Arboricultural J. 6, 251-265.
80. Rygiewicz P T and Andersen C P 1994 Mycorrhizae alter quality and quantity of carbon allocated below ground. Nature 369, 58-60.
81. Sala O E, Biondini M E and Lauenroth W K 1988 Bias in estimates of primary production: an analytical solution. Ecol. Modelling 44, 43-55.
82. Sanford R L Jr 1987 Apogeotropic roots in an Amazon rain forest. Science 235, 1062-1064.
83. Santantonio D and Grace J C 1987 Estimating fine-root production and turnover from biomass and decomposition data: a compartment-flow model. Can. J. For. Res. 17, 900-908.
84. Santantonio D and Hermann R K 1985 Standing crop, production, and turnover of fine roots on dry, moderate, and wet sites of mature Douglas-fir in western Oregon. Ann. Sci. For. 42, 113-142.
85. Santantonio D 1990 Modeling growth and production of tree roots. In Process Modeling of Forest Growth Responses to Environmental Stress. Eds. R K Dixon, R S Meldahl, G A Ruark and W G Warren, pp 124-141. Timber Press, Portland, Oregon.
86. Schwab S M, Menge J A and Leonard R T 1983 Quantitative and qualitative effects of phosphorus on extracts and exudates of sudangrass in relation to vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhiza formation. Plant Physiol. 73, 761-765.
87. Singh J S, Lauenroth W K, Hunt H W, and Swift D M 1984 Bias and random errors in estimators of net root production: A simulation approach. Ecology 65, 1760-1764.
88. Smucker A J M, Ferguson J C, DeBruyn W P, Belford R L and Ritchie J T 1987 Image analysis of video-recorded plant root systems. In Minirhizotron Observation Tubes: Methods and Applications for Measuring Rhizosphere Dynamics. Ed. H M Taylor. pp 67-80. ASA Spec. Publ. no. 50. ASA, CSSA, SSSA, Inc., Madison, WI.
89. Sprugel D G, Ryan M G, Brooks J R, Vogt K A, and Martin T A 1995 Respiration from the organ level to the stand. In Resource Physiology of Conifers-Acquisition, Allocation, and Utilization. Eds. W K Smith and T M Hinckley. pp 255-299. Academic Press, San Diego.
90. St. John T V, Coleman D C and Reid C P P 1983 Growth and spatial distribution of nutrient-absorbing organs: selective exploitation of soil heterogeneity. Plant Soil 71, 487-493.
91. Stone E L and Kalisz P J 1991 On the maximum extent of tree roots. For. Ecol. Manage. 46, 59-102.
92. Taylor H M 1987 Minirhizotron Observation Tubes: Methods and Applications for Measuring Rhizosphere Dynamics. ASA Spec. Publ. no. 50. ASA, CSSA, SSSA, Inc., Madison, WI. 143 p.
93. Taylor J 1993 The mutable carbon sink. Nature 366, 515-516.
94. Upchurch D R and Richie J T 1983 Root observations using a video recording system in minirhizotrons. Agron. J. 75, 1009-1015.
95. Van der Werf A, Poorter H and Lambers H 1994 Respiration as dependent on a species inherent growth rate and on the nitrogen supply to the plant. In A Whole Plant Perspective on Carbon-Nitrogen Interactions. Eds. J Roy and E Garnier. pp 91-110. SPB Academic Publishing bv, The Hague, The Netherlands.
96. Van Noordwijk M 1983 Functional interpretation of root densities in the field for nutrient and water uptake. In Wurzelokologie und Ihre Nutzanwendung. Eds. W Böhm, L Kutschera and E Lichtenegger. pp 207-226. BVA Gumpenstein, Irdning, Austria.
97. Van Praag H J, Sougnez-Remy S, Weissen F and Carletti G 1988 Root turnover in a beech and a spruce stand of the Belgian Ardennes. Plant Soil 105, 87-103.
98. Vogt K A and Staffeldt E E 1977 Fungal degradation of pure and mixed carbon substrates. Develop. in Industr. Micro. 18, 571-580.
99. Vogt K A, Grier C C, Edmonds R L and Meier C E 1982 Mycorrhizal role in net primary production and nutrient cycling in Abies amabilis [Dougl.] Forbes ecosystems in western Washington. Ecology 63, 370-380.
100. Vogt K A, Vogt D J, Moore E E, Littke W, Grier C C, and Leney L 1985 Estimating Douglas-fir fine root biomass and production from living bark and starch. Can. J. For. Res. 15, 177-179.
101. Vogt K A, Grier C C, Gower S T, Sprugel D G, and Vogt D J 1986a Overestimation of net root production: A real or imaginary problem? Ecology 67, 577-579.
102. Vogt K A, Grier C C and Vogt D J 1986b Production, turnover, and nutrient dynamics of above- and belowground detritus of world forests. Adv. Ecol. Res., 15, 303-377.
103. Vogt K A, Vogt D J, Moore E E, Fatuga B A, Redlin M R and Edmonds R L 1987 Conifer and angiosperm fine-root biomass in relation to stand age and site productivity in Douglas-fir forests. Ecology 75, 857-870.
104. Vogt K A, Vogt D J, Moore E E and Sprugel D G 1989 Methodological considerations in measuring biomass, production, respiration and nutrient resorption for tree roots in natural ecosystems. In Applications of Continuous and Steady-State Methods to Root Biology. Eds. J G Torrey and L J Winship. pp 217-232. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht.
105. Vogt K A, Vogt D J, Gower S T and Grier C C 1990 Carbon and nitrogen interactions for forest ecosystems. In Above- and Below-ground Interactions in Forest Trees in Acidified Soils. Ed. H Persson. pp 203-235. Air pollution Report 32. Commission of the European Communities. Directorate-General for Science, Research and Development. Environment Research Programme, Brussels.
106. Vogt K A and Bloomfield J 1991 Root turnover and senescence. In Plant Roots: The Hidden Half. Eds. Y Waisel, A Eschel and U Kafkafi. pp 287-306. Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York.
107. Vogt K A and Persson H 1991 Root methods. In Techniques and Approaches in Forest Tree Ecophysiology. Eds. J P Lassoie and T M Hinckley. pp 477-502. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida.
108. Vogt K A, Vogt D J and Bloomfield J 1991 Input of organic matter to the soil by tree roots. In Plant Roots and Their Environment. Eds. H Persson and B L McMichael. pp 171-190. Elsevier Publications, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
109. Vogt K A, Bloomfield J, Perez J M, Vogt D J and Silver W L 1993 Belowground responses as indicators of environmental change. Environ. Experimental Bot. 33, 189-205.
110. Vogt K A, Vogt D J, Asbjornsen H and Dahlgren R A 1995 Roots, nutrients and their relationship to spatial patterns. Plant Soil 168-169, 113-123.
111. Vogt K A, Vogt D J, Palmiotto P A, Boon P, O'Hara J and Asbjornsen H 1996 Review of root dynamics in forest ecosystems grouped by climate, climatic forest type and species. Plant Soil 187, 159-219.
112. Waisel Y 1972 Biology of Halophytes. Academic Press, New York. 395 p.
113. Waisel Y, Eshel A and Kafkafi U 1991 Plant Roots. The Hidden Half. Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York. 948 p.
114. Waring R H and Schlesinger W H 1985 Forest Ecosystems: Concepts and Management. Academic Press, Orlando, Florida. 340 p.