Psychiatric advance directives and the role of autonomy;Les directives psychiatriques anticipées (DPA) et le rôle de l'autonomie

Sante Mentale au Quebec

Volumn 34, Issue 2, 2009, Pages 51-74

  Ambrosini, Daniel L ^a   Crocker, Anne G ^a  

^a DOUGLAS MENTAL HEALTH UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE   (Canada)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 77949359363     PISSN: 03836320     EISSN: 17083923     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.7202/039126ar     Document Type: Article

References (80)

1. AMBROSINI, D. L., CROCKER, A. G., ISRAEL, M., PERREAULT, M., 2008, Attitudes towards psychiatric advance directives among legal and mental health professionals in Ontario and Quebec, (under review).
2. AMBROSINI, D. L., CROCKER, A. G., PERREAULT, M., ISRAEL, M., 2008, Perceptions of psychiatric advance directives among legal and mental health professionals in Ontario and Quebec, Journal Ethics in Mental Health, 31, 1, 1-12.
3. AMERING, M., DENK, E., GRIENGL, H., SIBITZ, I., STASTNY, P., 1999, Psychiatric wills of mental health professionals: a survey of opinions regarding advance directives in psychiatry, Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 34, 1, 30-34.
4. AMERING, M., STASTNY, P., HOPPER, K., 2005, Psychiatric advance directives: qualitative study of informed deliberations by mental health service users, British Journal of Psychiatry, 186, 247-252.
5. APPELBAUM, P.S., GRISSO, T., 2001, MacCAT-CR MacArthur Competence Assessment Tool for Clinical Research, Professional Resource Press, Sarasota FL.
6. APPELBAUM, P. S., REDLICH, A., 2006, Impact of decisional capacity on the use of leverage to encourage treatment adherence, Community Mental Health Journal, 42, 2, 121-130.
7. ASHCRAFT, L., ANTHONY, W. A., 2006, A treatment planning reality check, Behavioral Healthcare, 26, 2, 7-8.
8. ATKINSON, J. M., GARNER, H. C., GILMOUR, W. H., 2004, Models of advance directives in mental health care: stakeholder views, Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 39, 8, 673-680.
9. BACKLAR, P., MCFARLAND, B. H., SWANSON, J. W., MAHLER, J., 2001, Consumer, provider, and informal caregiver opinions on psychiatric advance directives, Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 28, 6, 427-441.
10. BAZELON CENTER FOR MENTAL HEALTH LAW, 2002 http://www.bazelon.org/issues/ advancedirectives/hargrave.html.
11. BRAVO, G., DUBOIS, M. F., PAQUET, M., 2003, Advance directives for health care and research: prevalence and correlates, Alzheimer Disease and Associated Disorders, 17, 4, 215-222.
12. BRAVO, G., DUBOIS, M. F., WAGNEUR, B., 2008, Assessing the effectiveness of interventions to promote advance directives among older adults: a systematic review and multi-level analysis, Social Science and Medicine, 67, 7, 1122-1132.
13. CALSYN, R. J., WINTER, J. P., MORSE, G. A., 2000, Do consumers who have a choice of treatment have better outcomes ? Community Mental Health Journal, 36, 2, 149-160.
14. CANTOR, N. L., 1992a, Advance directives and the pursuit of death with dignity: New Jersey's new legislation, Rutgers Law Review, 44, 2, 335-403.
15. CANTOR, N. L., 1992b, Prospective autonomy: on the limits of shaping one's postcompetence medical fate, The Journal of Contemporary Health Law Policy, 8, 13-48.
16. CASTELEIN, S., VAN DER GAAG, M., BRUGGEMAN, R., VAN BUSSCHBACH, J. T., WIERSMA, D., 2008, Measuring empowerment among people with psychotic disorders: a comparison of three instruments, Psychiatric Services, 59, 11, 1338-1342.
17. Civil Code of Québec, 1991 (CCQ).
18. Code of Ethics, 2005, Montreal, Douglas Mental Health University Institute.
19. DAVIDSON, L., TONDORA, J., O'CONNELL, M. J., KIRK, T. JR., ROCKHOLZ, P., EVANS, A. C., 2007, Creating a recovery-oriented system of behavioral health care: moving from concept to reality, Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 31, 1, 23-31.
20. DAVIS, J. K., 2004, Precedent autonomy and subsequent consent, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice: an International Forum, 7, 3, 267-291.
21. DAVIS, J. K., 2008, How to justify enforcing a Ulysses contract when Ulysses is competent to refuse, Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 18, 1, 87-106.
22. DEWOLF BOSEK, M. S., RING, M. E., CADY, R. F., 2008, Do psychiatric advance directives protect autonomy ? JONAS Healthcare Law, Ethics and Regulation, 10, 1, 17-24.
23. DUNBRACK, J., 2006, Advance Care Planning: the Glossary Project, Ottawa, Health Canada.
24. ELLS, C., 2001, Shifting the autonomy debate to theory as ideology, The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 26, 4, 417-430.
25. GELLER, J. L., 2000, The use of advance directives by persons with serious mental illness for psychiatric treatment, Psychiatric Quarterly, 71, 1, 1-13.
26. GOSS, C., MORETTI, F., MAZZI, M. A., DEL PICCOLO, L., RIMONDINI, M., ZIMMERMANN, C., 2008, Involving patients in decisions during psychiatric consultations, The British Journal of Psychiatry, 193, 5, 416-421.
27. GRAY, J. E., SHONE, M. A., LIDDLE, P. F., 2008, Canadian Mental Health Law and Policy, LexisNexis, Markham, Ontario.
28. GROSSE HOLTFORTH, M., REUBI, I., RUCKSTUHL, L., BERKING, M., GRAWE, K., 2004, The value of treatment-goal themes for treatment planning and outcome evaluation of psychiatric inpatients, The International Journal of Social Impact of Decisional Capacity Psychiatry, 50, 1, 80-91.
29. HARGRAVE V. VERMONT, -- F.3d --, 2003 WL 21770957 (2nd Cir. 2003).
30. HEALTH CARE CONSENT ACT, 1996 S.O. 1996, c. 2 Schedule A (HCCA).
31. HENDERSON, C., SWANSON, J. W., SZMUKLER, G., THORNICROFT, G., ZINKLER, M., 2008, A typology of advance statements in mental health care, Psychiatric Services, 59, 1, 63-71.
32. HO, A., 2008, Relational autonomy or undue pressure ? Family's role in medical decision-making, Scandinavian Journal of Caring Science, 22, 1, 128- 135.
33. JOSHI, K. G., 2003, Psychiatric advance directives, JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRIC PRACTICE, 9, 4, 303-306.
34. KALIS, A., MOJZISCH, A., SCHWEIZER, T. S., KAISER, S., 2008, Weakness of will, akrasia, and the neuropsychiatry of decision making: An interdisciplinary perspective. Cognitive, Affective and Behavioral Neuroscience, 8, 4, 402-417.
35. KIM, M. M., SCHEYETT, A. M., ELBOGEN, E. B., VAN DORN, R. A., MCDANIEL, L. A., SWARTZ, M. S., SWANSON, J.W., FERRON, J., 2008, Front Line Workers'Attitudes towards Psychiatric Advance Directives, Community Mental Health Journal, 44, 1, 28-46.
36. KIRBY, M., 2004, Mental Health, Mental Illness and Addiction: Issues and Options for Canada, Report 3.
37. LINHORST, D. M., HAMILTON, G., YOUNG, E., ECKERT, A., 2002, Opportunities and barriers to empowering people with severe mental illness through participation in treatment planning, Social Work, 47, 4, 425-434.
38. MAZZEI V. BRITISH COLUMBIA (DIRECTOR OF ADULT FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC SERVICES), 2006, 1 S.C.R. 326 (Supreme Court of Canada).
39. MENTAL HEALTH COMMISSION OF CANADA, 2009, available at: http://www.mentalhealthcommission.ca/english/pages/default.aspx.
40. MOLLOY, D.W., GUYATT, G. H., RUSSO, R., GOEREE, R., O'BRIEN, B. J., BEDARD, M., 2000, Systematic implementation of an advance directive program in nursing homes: a randomized controlled trial, Jama, 283, 11, 1437-1444.
41. MUESER, K. T., CORRIGAN, P. W., HILTON, D. W., TANZMAN, B., SCHAUB, A., GINGERICH, S., et al., 2002, Illness management and recovery: a review of the research, Psychiatric Services, 53, 10, 1272-1284.
42. MUESER, K. T., MEYER, P. S., PENN, D. L., CLANCY, R., CLANCY, D. M., SALYERS, M. P., 2006, The Illness Management and Recovery program: rationale, development, and preliminary findings, Schizophrenia Bulletin, 32, Suppl 1, S32-S43.
43. NELSON, W. A., 2007, The ethics of patient preferences. Autonomy has limitations when contrary to medical judgment, illegal or unethical, Healthcare Executive, 22, 5, 34, 36-37.
44. O'CONNELL, M. J., STEIN, C. H., 2005, Psychiatric advance directives: perspectives of community stakeholders, Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 32, 3, 241-265.
45. O'REILLY, R. L., 2008, The capacity to execute an advance directive for psychiatric treatment, International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 31, 1, 66-71.
46. PAPAGEORGIOU, A., JANMOHAMED, A., KING, M., DAVIDSON, O., DAWSON, J., 2004, Advance directives for patients compulsorily admitted to hospital with serious mental disorders: Directive content and feedback from patients and professionals, Journal of Mental Health, 13, 4, 379-388.
47. PATTERSON, C., MOLLOY, D. W., GUYATT, G. H., BEDARD, M., NORTH, J., HASSARD, J., et al., 1997, Systematic implementation of an advance health care directive in the community, Canadian Journal of Nursing Administration, 10, 2, 96-108.
48. PINEL, P., 1806, A Treatise on Insanity, London, United Kingdom, Messers Cadell and Davies, Strand.
49. PREFERENCE COLLABORATIVE REVIEW GROUP, 2008, Patients'preferences within randomised trials: systematic review and patient level meta-analysis, British Medical Journal, 337, a1864.
50. RE C (ADULT: REFUSAL OF TREATMENT), [1994] 1 WLR 290, Family Division, England.
51. RITCHIE, J., SKLAR, R., STEINER, W., 1998, Advance directives in psychiatry: Resolving issues of autonomy and competence, International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 21, 3, 245-260.
52. ROGERS, E. S., CHAMBERLIN, J., ELLISON, M. L., CREAN, T., 1997, A consumerconstructed scale to measure empowerment among users of mental health services, Psychiatric Services, 48, 8, 1042-1047.
53. ROGERS, A., DAY, J., RANDALL, F., BENTALL, R. P., 2003, Patients'understanding and participation in a trial designed to improve the management of antipsychotic medication: a qualitative study, Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 38, 12, 720-727.
54. SAMANTA, A., SAMANTA, J., 2006, Advance directives, best interests and clinical judgement: shifting sands at the end of life, Clinical Medicine, 6, 3, 274-278.
55. SCHEYETT A., 2008, Psychiatric advance directives: benefits and barriers, Current Psychiatry Reviews, 4, 3, 137-144.
56. SCHEYETT, A. M., KIM, M. M., SWANSON, J. W., SWARTZ, M. S., 2007, Psychiatric advance directives: a tool for consumer empowerment and recovery, Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 31, 1, 70-75.
57. SCHURHOFER, M., PESCHL, M., 2005, Autonomy: starting point and goal of personal and social change: A constructivist perspective on knowledge management in empowerment processes, Kybernetes, 34, 1/2, 261.
58. SINGER, P. A., CHOUDRY, S., ARMSTRONG, J., 1993, Public opinion regarding consent to treatment, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 41, 2, 112-116.
59. SINGER, P. A., CHOUDRY, S., ARMSTRONG, J., MESLIN, E. M., LOWY, F. H., 1995, Public opinion regarding end-of-life decisions: influence of prognosis, practice and process, Social Science and Medicine, 41, 11, 1517-1521.
60. SKLAR, R., 2007, Starson v. Swayze: The Supreme Court speaks out (not all that clearly) on the question of "capacity", Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 52, 6, 390-395.
61. SOMERVILLE, M. A., 1994, Labels versus contents: variance between philosophy, psychiatry and law in concepts governing decision-making, McGill Law Journal, 39, 179.
62. SREBNIK, D., BRODOFF, L., 2003, Implementing psychiatric advance directives: service provider issues and answers, The Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research, 30, 3, 253-268.
63. SREBNIK, D., KIM, S. Y., 2006, Competency for creation, use, and revocation of psychiatric advance directives, The Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and Law, 34, 4, 501-510.
64. SREBNIK, D., RUSSO, J., 2007, Consistency of psychiatric crisis care with advance directive instructions, Psychiatric Services, 58, 9, 1157-1163.
65. STARSON V. SWAYZE, 2003, 1 S.C.R. 722 (Supreme Court of Canada).
66. STIGGELBOUT, A. M., MOLEWIJK, A. C., OTTEN, W., TIMMERMANS, D. R., VAN BOCKEL, J. H., KIEVIT, J., 2004, Ideals of patient autonomy in clinical decision making: a study on the development of a scale to assess patients' and physicians' views, Journal of Medical Ethics, 30, 3, 268-274.
67. SWANSON, J.W., SWARTZ, M., FERRON, J., ELBOGEN, E., VAN DORN, R., 2006, Psychiatric advance directives among public mental health consumers in five U.S. cities: prevalence, demand, and correlates, The Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and Law, 34, 1, 43-57.
68. SWANSON, J.W., SWARTZ, M. S., ELBOGEN, E. B., VAN DORN, R. A., FERRON, J., WAGNER, H. R., 2006, Facilitated psychiatric advance directives: a randomized trial of an intervention to foster advance treatment planning among persons with severe mental illness, American Journal of Psychiatry, 163, 11, 1943-1951.
69. SWANSON, J.W., SWARTZ, M. S., HANNON, M. J., ELBOGEN, E. B., WAGNER, H. R., MCCAULEY, B. J., et al., 2003, Psychiatric advance directives: a survey of persons with schizophrenia, family members, and treatment providers, International Journal of Forensic Mental Health, 2, 1, 73-86.
70. SWANSON, J.W., VAN MCCRARY, S., SWARTZ, M. S., VAN DORN, R. A., ELBOGEN, E. B., 2007, Overriding psychiatric advance directives: factors associated with psychiatrists' decisions to preempt patients' advance refusal of hospitalization and medication, Law and Human Behavior, 31, 1, 77-90.
71. SWARTZ, M. S., SWANSON, J. W., 2007, Commentary: psychiatric advance directives and recovery-oriented care, Psychiatric Services, 58, 9, 1164.
72. SWARTZ, M. S., SWANSON, J. W., FERRON, J., ELBOGEN, E. B., VAN DORN, R., KIM, M., 2005, Psychiatrists'views and attitudes about psychiatric advance directives, International Journal of Forensic Mental Health, 4, 2, 107-117.
73. SUTHERBY, K., SZMUKLER, G. I., HALPERN, A., ALEXANDER, M., THORNICROFT, G., JOHNSON, C., 1999, A study of 'crisis cards' in a community psychiatric service, Acta Psychiatra Scandinavica, 100, 1, 56-61.
74. SZASZ, T. S., 1982, The psychiatric will - A new mechanism for protecting persons against "psychosis" and psychiatry, American Psychologist, 37, 7, 762-770.
75. VAN DORN, R. A., SWANSON, J. W., SWARTZ, M. S., ELBOGEN, E., FERRON, J., 2008, Reducing barriers to completing psychiatric advance directives, Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 35, 6, 440-448.
76. VAN DORN, R. A., SWARTZ, M. S., ELBOGEN, E. B., SWANSON, J. W., KIM, M., FERRON, J., 2006, Clinicians'attitudes regarding barriers to the implementation of psychiatric advance directives, Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 33, 4, 449-460.
77. VAN WILLIGENBURG, T., DELAERE, P., 2005, Protecting autonomy as authenticity using Ulysses contracts, The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 30, 4, 395-409.
78. WAGNER, L. C., FLECK, M. P., WAGNER, M., DIAS, M. T., 2006, Autonomy of longstay psychiatric inpatients, Revisita de Saude Publica, 40, 4, 699-705.
79. WIDDERSHOVEN, G., 2007, Empirical Ethics in Psychiatry, Oxford University, Oxford.
80. WILDER, C. M., ELBOGEN, E. B., SWARTZ, M. S., SWANSON, J.W., VAN DORN, R.A., 2007, Effect of patients' reasons for refusing treatment on implementing psychiatric advance directives, Psychiatric Services, 58, 10, 1348-1350.