Are tradable green certificates a cost-efficient policy driving technical change or a rent-generating machine? Lessons from Sweden 2003-2008

Energy Policy

Volumn 38, Issue 3, 2010, Pages 1255-1271

  Bergek, Anna ^a   Jacobsson, Staffan ^b  

^a LINKÖPING UNIVERSITY   (Sweden)

^b CHALMERS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY   (Sweden)

Author keywords

Rents; Technical change; Tradable green certificates

Indexed keywords

COST EFFECTIVE; COST-EFFICIENT; COSTS AND BENEFITS; POLICY DEBATES; REGULATORY FRAMEWORKS; RENEWABLE ELECTRICITY; SHORT TERM; SOCIAL COST; TECHNICAL CHANGE; TRADABLE GREEN CERTIFICATES;

COST EFFECTIVENESS; COSTS; ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL EFFECTS; LAWS AND LEGISLATION;

ELECTRIC GENERATORS;

CERTIFICATION; CONSUMPTION BEHAVIOR; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; ELECTRICITY; ENERGY POLICY; REGULATORY FRAMEWORK; RENEWABLE RESOURCE; TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE; TECHNOLOGY DIFFUSION;

SWEDEN;

EID: 76449100082     PISSN: 03014215     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.enpol.2009.11.001     Document Type: Article

References (74)

1. Alpman M. Produktionen igång av Solibros solceller. Ny Teknik 2008, 2008-06-17.
2. Andersson B., Jacobsson S. Monitoring and assessing technology choice: the case of solar cells. Energy Policy 2000, 28:1037-1049.
3. Åstrand K. Examining influences of EU policy on instrument choice: the selection of a green certificate trading scheme in Sweden. Policy and Society 2005, 24(2):100-128.
4. Bengtsson V Solibro välkomnar tysk räddningsinsats. Miljöaktuellt 2007, 2007-01-19.
5. Bergek A., Jacobsson S. The emergence of a growth industry: a comparative analysis of the german, dutch and swedish wind turbine industries. Change, Transformation and Development 2003, 197-228. Physica/Springer, Heidelberg. S. Metcalfe, U. Cantner (Eds.).
6. BMU, 2007.: Renewable energy sources in figures - national and international development, Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety, Environental Policy Series, Public Relations Division, Berlin.
7. BWE, 2009. Die Entwicklung der Windenergie in Deutschland. URL: (Acc. 090403). http://www.wind-energie.de/de/statistiken/.
8. Contaldi M., Gracceva F., Tosato G. Evaluation of green-certificates policies using the MARKAL-MACRO-Italy model. Energy Policy 2007, 35(2):797-808.
9. Diekman, J., co-ordinator, 2008. Economic Analysis and Evaluation of the Effects of the Renewable Energy Act, Report prepared on behalf of the German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature-Conservation and Nuclear Safety, DIW Berlin/DLR/ZSW/IZES, Berlin/Stuttgart, Saarbrücken.
10. European Commission, 1997. Communication from the Commission. Energy for the Future: Renewable Sources of Energy, White Paper for a Community Strategy and Action Plan. COM (97) 599 final, 26 November 1997.
11. European Commission, 1998. Commission report to the Council and the European Parliament on Harmonization requirements. Directive 96/92/EC concerning rules for the internal market in Electricity, COM (1998) 167, 16 March 1998.
12. European Commission, 1999. Electricity from Renewable Energy Sources and the Internal Electricity market, Commission Working Paper, SEC (99) 470, 13 April 1999.
13. European Commission, 2000. Proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the promotion of electricity from renewable energy sources in the internal electricity market, COM (2000) 279 final, 10 May 2000.
14. European Parliament, 2007. European Parliament resolution on climate change", B6-0045-2007, 7 February 2007.
15. European Parliament, 2008. European Parliament resolution on the scientific facts of climate change: findings and recommendations for decision-making (2008/2001 (INI))", P6_TA PROV (2008) 0223, 21 May 2008.
16. European Parliament and Council, 2001. Directive 2001/77/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on the promotion of electricity produced from renewable energy sources in the internal electricity market (OJ L 283, 27.10.2001, p. 33).
17. EWEA Wind Energy the Facts 2009, European Wind Energy Association, Brussels.
18. EWEA, 2009b. Wind energy and the job market, fact sheet from European Wind Energy Association, Brussels.
19. Finon D., Perez Y. The social efficiency of instruments for the promotion of renewables in the electricity industry: a transaction cost perspective. Ecological Economics 2007, 62(1):77-92.
20. Fouquet D., Johansson T. European renewable energy policy at crossroads - Focus on electricity support mechanisms. Energy Policy 2008, 36:4079-4092.
21. Hirsmark, J.,Larsson, E., 2005. Rapport om kraftvärme, och dess koppling till elcertifikatsystemet, Svenska Bioenergiföreningen och Svensk Fjärrvärme, Stockholm.
22. Jacobsson S. The emergence and troubled growth of a 'bio power' innovation system in Sweden. Energy Policy 2008, 36(4):1491-1508.
23. Jacobsson S., Bergek A. Transforming the energy sector: the evolution of technological systems in renewable energy technology. Industrial and Corporate Change 2004, 13(5):815-849.
24. Jacobsson S., Bergek A., Finon D., Lauber D., Mitchell C., Toke D., Verbruggen A. EU renewable energy support policy: Faith or facts?. Energy Policy 2009, 37(6):2143-2146.
25. Kemp R., Schot J., Hoogma R. Regime shifts to sustainability through processes of niche formation: the approach of strategic niche management. Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 1998, 10(2):175-195.
26. Klepper S. Industry life cycles. Industrial and Corporate Change 1997, 6(1):145-182.
27. Kline S.J., Rosenberg N. An overview of innovation. The Positive Sum Strategy. Harnessing Technology for Economic Growth 1986, National Academy Press, Washington DC. R. Landau, N. Rosenberg (Eds.).
28. Kåberger T., Sterner T., Zamanian M., Jurgensson A. Economic efficiency of compulsory green electricity quotas in Sweden. Energy and Environment 2004, 15(4):675-698.
29. Lauber V. The politics of european union policy on support schemes for electricity from renewable energy sources. Green Power Markets: Support Schemes, Case Studies and Perspectives 2007, Multi-Science Publishing, Essex. L. Mez (Ed.).
30. Madlener R., Stagl S. Sustainability-guided promotion of renewable electricity generation. Ecological Economics 2005, 53(2):147-167.
31. Malmqvist, L., 2000. Interview with Lennart Malmqvist, Director Ångström Solar Center, 11 November 2000.
32. Markard, J., Petersen, R., 2009. The offshore trend: Structural changes in the wind power sector, Energy Policy 37 (9), 3545-3556.
33. Menanteau P., Finon D., Lamy M.-L. Prices versus quantities: choosing policies for promoting the development of renewable energy. Energy Policy 2003, 31(8):799-812.
34. Meyer N.I. European schemes for promoting renewables in liberalised markets. Energy Policy 2003, 31(7):665-676.
35. Michanek, G., Söderholm, P., 2006. Medvind i uppförsbacke. En studie av den svenska vindkraftspolitiken ("Fair wind in an uphill slope. A study of Swedish wind power policy"), Report to the Expert group for environmental studies, Swedish Ministry of Finance, Stockholm.
36. Midtun A., Gautesen K. Feed in or certificates, competition or complementarity? Combining a static efficiency and a dynamic innovation perspective on the greening of the energy industry. Energy Policy 2007, 35:1419-1422.
37. Morthorst P.E. The development of a green certificate market. Energy Policy 2000, 28(15):1085-1094.
38. Neij, L., Andersen, P. D., Durstewitz, M., Helby, P., Hoppe-Kilpper, M., Morthorst, P. E., 2003. Experience curves: a tool for energy policy programmes assessment, final report from the EXTOOL project. Department of environment and energy systems, Lund University, Lund.
39. Ragwitz M., Huber C. Feed-In Systems in Germany and Spain: a comparison 2005, Fraunhofer Institut für Systemtechnik und Innovationsforschung, Karlsruhe.
40. Rickerson W.H., Sawin J.L., Grace R.C. If the Shoe FITs: using feed-in tariffs to meet U.S. renewable electricity targets. The Electricity Journal 2007, 20(4):73-86.
41. Ringel M. Fostering the use of renewable energies in the European Union: the race between feed-in tariffs and green certificates. Renewable Energy 2006, 31(1):1-17.
42. del Río P., Gual M.A. An integrated assessment of the feed-in tariff system in Spain. Energy Policy 2007, 35(2):994-1012.
43. Rowlands I.H. Envisaging feed-in tariffs for solar photovoltaic electricity: European lessons for Canada. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2005, 9(1):51-68.
44. Sandén B.A., Azar C. Near term technology policies for long-term climate targets: economy wide versus technology specific approaches. Energy Policy 2005, 33:1557-1576.
45. Schaeffer, G. J., Boots, M. G., Martens, J. W., Voogt, M. H., 1999. Tradable Green Certificates. A new market-based incentive scheme for renewable energy: Introduction and analysis, ECN-I-99-004 (March 1999), ECN, Petten.
46. Sáenz de Miera G., del Rio González P., Vizcaíno I. Analysing the impact of renewable electricity support schemes on power prices: the case of wind electricity in Spain. Energy Policy 2008, 36(9):3345-3359.
47. Smith A. The wealth of Nations 1776/2003, Random House, New York.
48. Stern N. The economics of climate change - the Stern review 2006, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
49. Suurs, R. A. A., 2009. Motors of Sustainable Innovation. Towards a theory on the dynamics of technological innovation systems, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Utrecht, Utrecht.
50. Svenska Kraftnät, 2008. Official statistics on the Swedish TGC system collected from Svenska Kraftnät's Cesar database (URL: )(Acc. 2008-07-17). https://elcertifikat.svk.se/.
51. Svenska Kraftnät, 2009. Official statistics on the Swedish TGC system collected from Svenska Kraftnät's Cesar database (URL: )(Acc. 2009-04-06). https://elcertifikat.svk.se/.
52. Swedish Energy Agency, 2005a. Översyn av elcertifikatsystemet (delrapport etapp 2) ("Review of the electricity certificate system step 2"), ER 2005:09. Energimyndighetens förlag, Eskilstuna (in Swedish).
53. Swedish Energy Agency, 2005b. Översyn av elcertifikatsystemet (delrapport etapp 1) ("Review of the electricity certificate system step 1"). ER 2005:08. Energimyndighetens förlag, Eskilstuna (in Swedish).
54. Swedish Energy Agency, 2007a. Energiförsörjningen i Sverige. Kortsiktsprognos 2007-08-15 ("Energy supply i Sweden. Short-term prognosis"), ER 2007:25. Energimyndigheten, Eskilstuna (in Swedish).
55. Swedish Energy Agency, 2007b. Elcertifikatsystemet 2007 ("The electricity certificate system 2007"), ET 2007:26. Swedish Energy Agency, Eskilstuna (in Swedish).
56. Swedish Energy Agency, 2007c. Nytt planeringsmål för vindkraften år 2020 ("New planning target for wind power in 2020"), ER 2007:45. Swedish Energy Agency, Eskilstuna (in Swedish).
57. Swedish Energy Agency, 2008. The electricity certificate system 2008, ET2008:09. Swedish Energy Agency, Eskilstuna.
58. Swedish Energy Agency, 2009. Elcertifikatsystemet 2009, ET2009: 31, Swedish Energy Agency, Eskilstuna.
59. Swedish Government, 2000. Ekonomiska förutsättningar för elproduktion från förnybara energikällor ("Economic conditions for electricity production from renewable energy sources"), Government Bill (prop. 1999/2000:134), 20 May 2000, Stockholm (in Swedish).
60. Swedish Government. 2002a. Samverkan för en trygg, effektiv och miljövänlig energiförsörjning ("Collaboration for a safe, efficient and environment-friendly energy supply"), Government bill (prop. 2001/02:143), 14 March 2002, Stockholm (in Swedish).
61. Swedish Government, 2002b. Elcertifikat för att främja förnybara energikällor ("Electricity certificates to support renewable energy sources"), Government Bill (prop. 2002/03:40), 16 January 2002, Stockholm (in Swedish).
62. Swedish Government, 2006a. Förnybar el med gröna certifikat ("Renewable electricity with green certificates"), Government Bill (prop. 2005/06:154), 22 March 2006, Stockholm (in Swedish).
63. Swedish Government, 2006b. Budgetpropositionen för 2007. Utgiftsområde 21 Energi. ("Government budget bill for 2007. Expense area 21 Energy"), Government Bill (prop. 2006/07:1), chapter 21, 16 October 2006, Stockholm (in Swedish).
64. Swedish Government, 2009. "A sustainable energy and climate policy for the environment, competitiveness and long-term stability", information from the Prime Minister's Office, 6 February 2009, Stockholm.
65. Swedish Ministry of Industry, 2002. Law about electricity certificates, Ministry publications Ds 2002:40, Stockholm.
66. SOU 2001:77: Handelmed elcertifikat. Ett nytt sätt att främja el från förnybara energikällor ("Trade with electricity certificates. A new way of inducing electricity from renewable energy sources"), final report by the government committee of inquiry on electricity certificates, Swedish Government Official Reports (SOU) 2001:77, Stockholm, 2001.
67. Söderholm P. The political economy of international green certificate markets. Energy Policy 2008, 36(6):2051-2062.
68. Thornström E. Interview with Erik Thornström 2005, Swedish Ministry of Industry, Stockholm, 2 February 2005.
69. Ürge-Vorsatz D., Rezessy S., Antypas A. Renewable electricity support schemes in Central Europé: a case of incomplete policy transfer. Energy & Environment 2004, 15(4):699-721.
70. Van der Linden, N.H., Uyterlinde, M.A., Vrolijk, C., Nilsson, L., Khan, J., Åstrand, K., Ericsson, K.Wiser, R., 2005. Review of international experience with renewable energy obligation support mechanisms. ECNC-05-025.
71. Verbruggen A. Tradable green certificates in Flanders (Belgium). Energy Policy 2004, 32(2):165-176.
72. Verbruggen A. Windfalls and other profits. Energy Policy 2008, 36(9):3249-3251.
73. Verbruggen A Performance evaluation of renewable energy support policies, applied on Flander's tradable certificate system. Energy Policy 2009, 37:1385-1394.
74. Verhaegen K., Meeus L., Belmans R. Towards an international tradable green certificate system - The challenging example of Belgium. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2009, 13(1):208-215.