Do all psychological treatments really work the same in posttraumatic stress disorder?

Clinical Psychology Review

Volumn 30, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 269-276

  Ehlers, Anke ^a   Bisson, Jonathan ^b   Clark, David M ^c   Creamer, Mark ^d   Pilling, Steven ^e   Richards, David ^f   Schnurr, Paula P ^g   Turner, Stuart ^h   Yule, William ^a  

^a KING'S COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^b CARDIFF UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United Kingdom)

^c SOUTH LONDON AND MAUDSLEY NHS FOUNDATION TRUST   (United Kingdom)

^d Australian Centre for Posttraumatic Mental Health   (Australia)

^e UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^f UNIVERSITY OF EXETER   (United Kingdom)

^g DARTMOUTH MEDICAL SCHOOL   (United States)

^h Trauma Clinic   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Clinical trials; Cognitive behavior therapy; EMDR; Meta analysis; Posttraumatic stress disorder; Psychotherapy

Indexed keywords

BEHAVIOR THERAPY; CLINICAL TRIAL; COGNITIVE THERAPY; EFFECT SIZE; HUMAN; MEDICAL RESEARCH; MEMORY; META ANALYSIS; POSTTRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; PSYCHOTHERAPY; REVIEW;

CLINICAL TRIALS AS TOPIC; HUMANS; LIFE CHANGE EVENTS; META-ANALYSIS AS TOPIC; PSYCHOTHERAPY; SELECTION BIAS; STRESS DISORDERS, POST-TRAUMATIC;

EID: 74149094922     PISSN: 02727358     EISSN: 18737811     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cpr.2009.12.001     Document Type: Review

References (69)

1. American Psychiatric Association (2004). Treatment of patients with acute stress disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder. http://www.psychiatryonline.com/pracGuide/pracGuideTopic_11.aspx.
2. Australian Centre for Posttraumatic Mental Health (2007). Australian guidelines for the treatment of adults with acute stress disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder. http://www.acpmh.unimelb.edu.au.
3. Benish S.G., Imel Z.E., and Wampold B.E. The relative efficacy of bona fide psychotherapies for treating post-traumatic stress disorder: A meta-analysis of direct comparisons. Clinical Psychology Review 28 (2008) 746-758
4. Bisson, J., & Andrew, M. (2009). Psychological treatments of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (Review). The Cochrane Library, 2009 (2), http://www.thecochranelibrary.com.
5. Bisson J., Ehlers A., Matthews R., Pilling S., Richards D., and Turner S. Systematic review and metaanalysis of psychological treatments for posttraumatic stress disorder. British Journal of Psychiatry 190 (2007) 97-104
6. Bisson J.I., Jenkins P.L., Alexander J., and Bannister C. Randomised controlled trial of psychological debriefing for victims of acute burn trauma. British Journal of Psychiatry 171 (1997) 78-81
7. Blackwelder W.C. "Proving the null hypothesis" in clinical trials. Controlled Clinical Trials 3 (1982) 345-353
8. Blanchard E.B., Hickling E.J., Devineni T., Veazey C.H., Galovski T.E., Mundy E., et al. A controlled evaluation of cognitive behavioral therapy for posttraumatic stress in motor vehicle accident survivors. Behaviour Research and Therapy 41 (2003) 79-96
9. Bowers T.G., and Clum G.A. Relative contribution of specific and non-specific treatment effects: Meta-analysis of placebo-controlled behavior therapy research. Psychological Bulletin 103 (1988) 315-323
10. Bradley R., Greene J., Russ E., Dutra L., and Westen D. A multidimensional meta-analysis of psychotherapy for PTSD. American Journal of Psychiatry 162 (2005) 214-217
11. Brom D., Kleber R.J., and Defares P.B. Brief psychotherapy for posttraumatic stress disorders. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 57 (1989) 607-612
12. Bryant R.A., Moulds M.L., Guthrie R.M., Dang S.T., and Nixon R.D.V. Imaginal exposure alone and imaginal exposure with cognitive restructuring in the treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 71 (2003) 706-712
13. Bryant R.A., Moulds M.L., Guthrie R.M., Dang S.T., Mastrodomenico J., Nixon R.D.V., et al. A randomized controlled trial of exposure therapy and cognitive restructuring for posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 76 (2008) 695-703
14. Carlson J.G., Chemtob C.M., Resnka K., Hedlund N.L., and Muraoka M.Y. Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Traumatic Stress 11 (1998) 3-24
15. Cloitre M. Effective psychotherapies for posttraumatic stress disorder: A review and critique. CNS Spectrums 14 Suppl 1 (2009) 32-43
16. Committee on Treatment of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, Institute of Medicine of the National Academies. Treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder: Assessment of the evidence (2008), National Academies Press, Washington, D.C
17. Devilly G.J., and Spence S.H. The relative efficacy and treatment distress of EMDR and a cognitive-behavior trauma treatment protocol in the amelioration of posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 13 (1999) 131-157
18. Ehlers A., and Clark D.M. Early psychological interventions for survivors of trauma. Biological Psychiatry 53 (2003) 817-826
19. Ehlers A., Clark D.M., Hackmann A., McManus F., and Fennell M. Cognitive therapy for post-traumatic stress disorder: Development and evaluation. Behaviour Research and Therapy 43 (2005) 413-431
20. Ehlers A., Clark D.M., Hackmann A., McManus F., Fennell M., Herbert C., et al. A randomized controlled trial of cognitive therapy, a self-help booklet, and repeated assessments as early interventions for posttraumatic stress disorder. Archives of General Psychiatry 60 (2003) 1024-1032
21. Ehlers A., Gene-Cos N., and Perrin S. Low recognition of posttraumatic stress disorder in primary care. London Journal of Primary Care 2 (2009) 36-42
22. Ehlers, A., Clark, D. M., Hackmann, A., Grey, N., Wild, J., Deale, A., et al. (2009a). A randomized controlled trial of intensive and weekly cognitive therapy and emotion-focused supportive psychotherapy in the treatment of chronic PTSD. In preparation.
23. Fecteau G., and Nicki R. Cognitive behavioural treatment of post traumatic stress disorder after motor vehicle accident. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 27 (1999) 201-214
24. Foa E.B., Rothbaum B.O., Riggs D.S., and Murdock T.B. Treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder in rape victims: A comparison between cognitive-behavioral procedures and counseling. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 59 (1991) 715-723
25. Foa E.B., Dancu C.V., Hembree E.A., Jaycox L.H., Meadows E.A., and Street G.P. A comparison of exposure therapy, stress inoculation training, and their combination for reducing posttraumatic stress disorder in female assault victims. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 67 (1999) 194-200
26. Foa E.B., Keane T.M., Friedman M.J., and Cohen J.A. Effective treatments for PTSD. Practice guidelines from the International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies. 2nd ed (2005), Guilford Press, New York
27. Greene W.C., Concato J., and Feinstein A.R. Claims of equivalence in medical research: Are they supported by the evidence?. Annals of Internal Medicine 132 (2000) 715-722
28. Greene C.J., Morland L.A., Durkalski V.L., and Frueh B.C. Noninferiority and equivalence designs: Issues and implications for mental health research. Journal of Traumatic Stress 21 (2008) 433-439
29. Hofmann S.G., and Smits J.A.J. Cognitive-behavioral therapy for adult anxiety disorders: A meta-analysis of randomized placebo-controlled trials. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 69 (2008) 621-632
30. Ironson G., Freund B., Strauss J.L., and Williams J. Comparison of two treatments for traumatic stress: A community-based study of EMDR and prolonged exposure. Journal of Clinical Psychology 58 (2002) 113-128
31. Jones B., Jarvis P., Lewis J.A., and Elbutt A.F. Trials to assess equivalence: The importance of rigorous methods. British Medical Journal 313 (1996) 36-39
32. Kessler R.C., Sonnega A., Bromet E., Hughes M., and Nelson C.B. Posttraumatic stress disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey. Archives of General Psychiatry 52 (1995) 1048-1060
33. Krupnick J.L., Green B.L., Stockton P., Miranda J., Krause E., and Mete M. Group interpersonal psychotherapy for low-income women with posttraumatic stress disorder. Psychotherapy Research 18 (2008) 497-507
34. Kubany E.S., Hill E.E., and Owens J.A. Cognitive trauma therapy for battered women with PTSD: Preliminary findings. Journal of Traumatic Stress 16 (2003) 81-91
35. Le Henanff A.L., Giraudeau B., Baron G., and Ravaud P. Quality of reporting noninferiority and equivalence randomized trials. Journal of the American Medical Association 295 (2006) 1147-1151
36. Lee C., Gavriel H., Drummond P., Richards J., and Greenwald R. Treatment of PTSD: Stress inoculation training with prolonged exposure compared to EMDR. Journal of Clinical Psychology 58 (2002) 1071-1089
37. Marks I., Lovell K., Noshirvani H., Livanou M., and Thrasher S. Treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder by exposure and/or cognitive restructuring: A controlled study. Archives of General Psychiatry 55 (1998) 317-325
38. Mayou R.A., Ehlers A., and Hobbs M. Psychological debriefing for road traffic accident victims: Three-year follow-up of a randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry 176 (2000) 589-593
39. McDonagh A., Friedman M., McHugo G., Ford J., Sengupta A., Mueser K., et al. Randomized trial of cognitive-behavioral therapy for chronic posttraumatic stress disorder in adult female survivors of childhood sexual abuse. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 73 (2005) 515-524
40. Moher D., Cook D.J., Eastwood S., Olkin I., Rennie D., Stroup D.F., et al. Improving the quality of reports of meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials: The Quorom Statement. Lancet 354 (1999) 1896-1900
41. National Institute of Clinical Excellence (2005). Clinical guideline 26: Posttraumatic stress disorder: The management of PTSD in adults and children in primary and secondary care. London, UK: National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health. http://guidance.nice.org/CG26.
42. Neuner F., Schauer M., Klaschik C., Karunakara U., and Elbert T. A comparison of narrative exposure therapy, supportive counseling, and psychoeducation for treating posttraumatic stress disorder in an African refugee settlement. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 72 (2004) 579-587
43. Norton P.J., and Price E.C. A meta-analytic review of adult cognitive-behavioral treatment outcome across the anxiety disorders. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 195 (2007) 521-531
44. Öst L.G. Cognitive behaviour therapy for anxiety disorders: 40 years of progress. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry 62 S47 (2008) 5-10
45. Ozer E.J., Best S., Lipzey T.L., and Weiss D.S. Predictors of posttraumatic stress disorder and symptoms in adults: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin 129 (2003) 52-73
46. Paunovic N., and Öst L.G. Cognitive-behavior therapy vs exposure therapy in the treatment of PTSD in refugees. Behaviour Research and Therapy 39 (2001) 1183-1197
47. Perepletchikova F., and Kazdin A.E. Treatment integrity and therapeutic change; Issues and research recommendations. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 12 (2005) 365-383
48. Piaggio G., Elbourne D.R., Altman D.G., Pocock S.J., and Evans S.J.W. Reporting of noninferiority and equivalence randomized trials: An extension of the CONSORT statement. Journal of the American Medical Association 295 (2006) 1152-1160
49. Pingitore D., Scheffler R., Haley M., Sentell T., and Schwalm D. Professional psychology in a new era: Practice-based evidence from California. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 32 (2001) 585-596
50. Power K., McGoldrick T., Brown K., Buchanan R., Sharp D., Swanson V., et al. A controlled comparison of eye movement desensitization and reprocessing versus exposure plus cognitive restructuring versus waiting list in the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy 9 (2002) 299-318
51. Ramchandani P., and Jones D.P.H. Treating psychological symptoms in sexually abused children. British Journal of Psychiatry 183 (2003) 484-498
52. Resick P.A., Nishith P., Weaver T.L., Astin M.C., and Feuer C.A. A comparison of cognitive-processing therapy with prolonged exposure and a waiting condition for the treatment of chronic posttraumatic stress disorder in female rape victims. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 70 (2002) 867-879
53. Rose S., and Bisson J. Brief early psychological interventions following trauma: A systematic review of the literature. Journal of Traumatic Stress 11 (1998) 697-710
54. Rothbaum B.O., Astin M.C., and Marsteller F. Prolonged exposure versus eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) for PTSD rape victims. Journal of Traumatic Stress 18 (2005) 607-616
55. Schnurr P.P. The rocks and hard places in psychotherapy outcome research. Journal of Traumatic Stress 20 (2007) 779-792
56. Schnurr P.P., Friedman M.J., Engel C.C., Foa E.B., Shea M.T., Chow B.K., et al. Cognitive behavioral therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder in women: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Medical Association 297 (2007) 820-830
57. Schnurr P.P., Friedman M.J., Foy D.W., Shea M.T., Hsieh F.Y., Lavori P.W., et al. Randomized trial of trauma-focused group therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder. Archives of General Psychiatry 60 (2003) 481-489
58. Seidler G.H., and Wagner F.E. Comparing the efficacy of EMDR and trauma focused cognitive behavioural therapy in the treatment of PTSD: A meta-analytic study. Psychological Medicine 36 (2006) 1515-1522
59. Senn S.J. Overstating the evidence - Double counting in meta-analysis and related problems. BMC Medical Research Methodology 9 (2009) 10
60. Smits J.A.J., and Hofmann S.G. A meta-analytic review of the effects of psychotherapy control conditions in anxiety disorders. Psychological Medicine 39 (2009) 229-239
61. Stein D.J., Cloitre M., Nemeroff C.B., Nutt D.J., Seedat S., Shalev A.Y., et al. Cape Town consensus on posttraumatic stress disorder. CNS Spectrums 14 Suppl 1 (2009) 52-58
62. Stevens S.E., Hynan M.T., and Allen M. A meta-analysis of common factor and specific treatment effects across the outcome domains of the phase model of psychotherapy. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 7 (2000) 273-290
63. Tarrier N., Pilgrim H., Sommerfield C., Faragher B., Reynolds M., Graham E., et al. Cognitive and exposure therapy in the treatment of PTSD. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 67 (1999) 13-18
64. Taylor S., Thordarson D.S., Maxfield L., Fedoroff I.C., Lovell K., and Ogrodniczuk J. Comparative efficacy, speed, and adverse effects of three PTSD treatments: Exposure therapy, EMDR, and relaxation training. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 71 (2003) 330-338
65. Van Etten M.L., and Taylor S. Comparative efficacy of treatments for posttraumatic stress disorder: A meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy 5 (1998) 126-144
66. Vaughan K., Armstrong M.S., Gold R., O'Connor N., Jenneke W., and Tarrier N. A trial of eye movement desensitization compared to image habituation training and applied muscle relaxation in post-traumatic stress disorder. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 25 (1994) 283-291
67. Veterans Health Administration and Department of Defense (2004). VA/DoD clinical practice guideline for the management of post-traumatic stress. Version 1.0. Washington, DC: Veterans Health Administration, Department of Defense. http://www.guideline.gov/summary/summary.aspx?ss=15&doc_id=5187
68. Wampold, B. E. (2008). So it's good outcomes from me. And it's good outcomes from him. Is it the treatment or the therapist that works? Closing debate. Paper presented at the Savoy Conference on Psychological Therapies in the NHS, Science, Practice and Policy, London, 27th November 2008. http://www.newsavoypartnership.org/2008conference.htm
69. Wampold B.E., Mondin G.W., Moody M., Stich F., Benson K., and Ahn H. A meta-analysis of outcome studies comparing bona fide psychotherapies: Empirically, "all must have prizes". Psychological Bulletin 122 (1997) 203-215