Trajectory of civil service development in kazakhstan: Nexus of politics and administration

Governance

Volumn 22, Issue 4, 2009, Pages 717-745

  Emrich Bakenova, Saule ^a  

^a KIMEP UNIVERSITY   (Kazakhstan)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 70349428452     PISSN: 09521895     EISSN: 14680491     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-0491.2009.01460.x     Document Type: Article

References (85)

1. Abazov, Rafis. 2006 Kazakhstan's Bolashak Program: Short Term Fix or Long Term Program Central Asia-Caucasus Analyst, October 4.
2. Abdrahmanov, Gabidulla. 2008 Message to Graduates and Scholarship Holders of the 'Bolashak' Program of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan January 15. 〈 http://www.kyzmet.kz 〉. (Russian). 〈 http://www.kyzmet.kz/?id-1=0&type=news&lang=ru&nid=200 〉. (February 1, 2008).
3. Aksutic, Alexandr. 2006 Security Council Meeting of RK Khabar September 21. 〈 http://www.kazembassy.ru/issue/?issueId=838 〉. (October 20, 2006).
4. Alternativa. 2008 President's Troopers Respublika, May 2: 8, June 6: 7 (Russian).
5. Ashimbayev, Daniyar. 2002 Staff Decides Everything Continent, March 20-April 2 (Russian).
6. Ashimbayev, Daniyar. 2007 Nur Otan Won Elections from Itself CentrAsia September 3. (Russian). 〈 http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=1188811920 〉. (October 1, 2007).
7. Baimenov, Alihan. 2000. Civil Service. International Experience: Kazakh Model. Astana : Akmola Polygraph (Russian).
8. Balogun, M.J. 2002 The Democratization and Development Agenda and the African Civil Service: Issues Resolved or Matters Arising? International Review of Administrative Sciences 68 : 533 556.
9. Baranov, Alexandr. 2008 Human Resource Politics of Local Nature Moya Respublika, November 28: 1-2 (Russian).
10. Bektiyarova, Irina. 2007 Exit Poll of Voters Turn Out on Average Around the Country Was 20% Panorama, August 24: 4 (Russian).
11. Benditsky, Gennady. 2008 Interview with Minister of Justice Zagipa Baliyeva Time. kz, November 13 (Russian).
12. Biekenov, M. 2007 Forming a Positive Image of the Civil Servant in Kazakhstan Sayasat-Policy 4 : 17 20 (Russian).
13. Chebotorev, Andrey. 2002 Kazakh Opposition in New Stage of Its Development Sayasat-Policy 2 : 31 36 (Russian).
14. Civil Service Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan (CSA). 2008a Model of Civil Service Human Resource Policy in Kazakhstan Round Table Discussion Held at Kazakhstan Institute of Management, Economics and Strategic Research (KIMEP) on April 4, Almaty.
15. Civil Service Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan (CSA). 2008b Information on Activities of Disciplinary Committees of the Civil Service Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan 〈 http://www.kyzmet.kz 〉. (Russian).
16. Civil Service Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan (CSA). 2006-2008c Monitoring of Civil Service Staff of the Republic of Kazakhstan 〈 http://www.kyzmet.kz Fuzzy Control Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 12 (2 191 216.
17. Disenbekova, S. 2006 Civil Service Human Resource Policy in Kazakhstan: Formation, Development and Problems Sayasat-Policy 6 : 34 36 Russian).
18. Dowdell, R.H. 1982 Public Personnel Administration in Canada In Public Administration in Canada: Selected Readings, 4th ed., ed. Kenneth Kernaghan. Toronto : Methuen.
19. Durant, Robert F. 1998 Rethinking the Unthinkable: A Cautionary Note Administration & Society 29 (6 643 652.
20. Gajduschek, György. 2007 Politization, Professionalization, or Both? Hungary's Civil Service System Communist and Post-Communist Studies 40 : 343 362.
21. Gallagher, Michael, Michael Laver Peter Mair. 2001. Representative Government in Modern Europe. Boston : McGraw-Hill.
22. Gazeta kz. 2007a New Akim of South Kazakhstan Is Not Planning Reorganization of Regional Akimat Staff 〈 http://www.gazeta 〉 (September 2, 2007). (Russian). 〈 http://www.gazeta.kz/art.asp?aid=95146 〉. (September 3 2007). (Russian).
23. Gazeta kz. 2007b Rotation among Ministers in the Ministry of Finance Should Not Affect Stability and Continuity of the Ministry 〈 http://www.gazeta 〉. (November 14, 2007). (Russian). 〈 http://www.gazeta.kz/art.asp?aid=99558 〉. (November 14, 2007). (Russian).
24. Gazeta kz. 2007c The Principle Criteria in Forming the Government that Won a Majority of the Seats in the Parliament Should Be Professionalism Rather Than Party Membership - The President of Kazakhstan July 4 (Russian).
25. Gazeta kz. 2008 In 2007 More Than Six Thousand People Were Laid Off from the Ministry of Interior Kazakhstan January 21 (Russian).
26. Goetz, Klaus H. 2001 Making Sense of Post-Communist Central Administration: Modernization, Europeanization or Latinization? Journal of European Public Policy 8 (6 1032 1051.
27. Grzymała-Busse, Anna. 2003 Political Competition and the Politization of the State in East Central Europe Comparative Political Studies 36 (10 1123 1147. (Pubitemid 37434304)
28. Grzymała-Busse, Anna. 2006 The Discreet Charm of Formal Institutions: Post Communist Party Competition and State Oversight Comparative Political Studies 39 (3 271 300.
29. Hashimov, Shukhrat. 2008 Why Does One Hand Slap the Other? Respublika, December 12: 8 (Russian).
30. Hojnacki, William. 1996 Politization as a Civil Service Dilemma In Civil Service Systems in Comparative Perspectives, ed. Hans A.G.M. Bekke, James L. Perry Theo A.J. Toonen. Bloomington, IN : Indiana University Press.
31. Igaliev, M D Igalieva. 2005 Major Development Trends among Kazakh Regional Elite in 2004 Analytic 1 (25 34 38 (Russian).
32. Ingraham, Patricia. 2006 Building Bridges over Troubled Waters: Merit as Guide Public Administration Review 66 (4 486 495.
33. Jakobson, Lev. 2001 Public Management in Russia: Changes and Inertia International Public Management Journal 4 : 27 48.
34. Kapanov, K.H. 2002 Post Nomenclatural Patronage between Traditions and Modernity Sayasat-Policy 2 : 27 30 (Russian).
35. Knott, Jack. 1998 A Return to Spoils: The Wrong Solution for the Right Problem Administration & Society 29 (6 660 669.
36. Knox, Colin. 2008 Kazakhstan: Modernizing Government in the Context of Political Inertia International Review of Administrative Sciences 74 (3 477 496.
37. König, Klaus. 2003 On the Typology of Public Administration International Review of Administrative Sciences 69 (4 449 462.
38. Kozhahmetov, Asylbek. 2007 Urgent Problems in Kazakhstan's Public Administration Reform KUB, March 19. (Russian). 〈 http://www.kub.info/ article.php?sid=16758 〉. (March 20, 2007).
39. Kozybaev, Iliyas. 2007 What Type of Human Resource Decides Everything? Mysl 4 : 53 59 (Russian).
40. Krepak, Petr. 2001 Monitoring Civil Service Reform in Kazakhstan: Achievements and Costs: In Search of Ways to Improve Civil Service Public Policy Initiative: Applied Policy Research. Alamty (Russian).
41. Lim, Veronika. 2008 Piece-Good Is Always in Shortage Jurist, March 13. 〈 http://base.zakon.kz 〉. (Russian).
42. Liter. Kz. 2005 Model of Kazakh Civil Service Is Almost Ideal January 29. 〈 http://www.liter.kz/print.php?Ian=rssian&id=151&pub=924 〉. (June 15, 2007). (Russian).
43. Makhmutova, Meruert. 2001 Local Government in Kazakhstan In Developing New Rules in the Old Environment, ed. Igor Munteanu Victor Popa. Budapest : Local Government and Public Reform Initiative.
44. Masanov, Nurbulat. 2000 Political Elite of Kazakhstan: the Changes of Kazakhstani Political Elite during the Period of Sovereignty International Eurasian Institute for Economic and Political Research. 〈 http://iicas.org/english/publ-22-11-00.htm 〉. (November 28, 2006).
45. Masanov, Nurbulat. 2002 Political Development of Sovereign Kazakhstan: Years 1992 through 2002 KUB, December 10. 〈 http://kubhost.com/∼kubkz/ article.php?sid=2851 〉 (November 28, 2006).
46. Meyer-Sahling, Jan-Hinrik. 2006 The Institutionalization of Political Discretion in Post-Communist Civil Service Systems: The Case of Hungary Public Administration 84 (3 693 716.
47. Meyer-Sahling, Jan-Hinrik. 2008 The Changing Colours of the Post-Communist State: The Politization of the Senior Civil Service in Hungary European Journal of Political Research 47 : 1 33.
48. Murphy, Jonathan. 2006 Illusory Transition? Elite Reconstitution in Kazakhstan, 1989-2002 Europe-Asia Studies 58 (4 June 523 554.
49. Nazarbayev, Nursultan. 2003 Speech by the President of Kazakhstan Nursultan Nazarbayev on 11th Business Forum October 31. Astana.
50. Nazarbayev, Nursultan. 2005. Kazakhstan-2030. Almaty : JURIST.
51. Nazarbayev, Nursultan. 2007 Speech by the President of Republic of Kazakhstan N.A. Nazarbayev during the Joint Session of the Parliament of the Republic of Kazakhstan May 16. Astana. 〈 http://www.akorda.kz/www/www- akorda-kz.nsf/sections?OpenForm&id-doc=A9F8632CF20A5F59462572DD00284098& lang=ru&L1=L2&L2=L2-15 〉. (May 25, 2007).
52. Nazarbayev, Nursultan. 2008a Speech by President of Republic of Kazakhstan during International Conference on Public Administration Issues June 17. Astana. 〈 http://www.akorda.kz/www/www-akorda-kz.nsf/sections? OpenForm&id-doc=DA4998A1AC0CE8D50625746B007660FF&lang=ru&L1= L2&L2=L2-15 〉. (June 20, 2008).
53. Nazarbayev, Nursultan. 2008b Speech by the President of Kazakhstan Nazarbayev N.A. during Anticorruption Forum of 'Nur Otan' Party November 6. Astana. 〈 http://www.akorda.kz/www/www-akorda-kz.nsf/sections? OpenForm&id-doc=018B974BE38C134B062574F900740061&lang=ru&L1= L2&L2=L2-15 〉. (November 10, 2008).
54. Nazarbayev, Nursultan. 2008c Message of the Head of the State to People of Kazakhstan February 7. Astana. 〈 http://www.akorda.kz/www/www-akorda-kz. nsf/sections?OpenForm&id-doc=0793D9432423DDE5062573EC0048005B&lang= ru&L1=L2&L2=L2-22 〉. (February 10, 2008).
55. Niyazbekov, Nurseit. 2005 Voting Behavior in Kazakhstan: Political Culture Perspective Unpublished MSc Thesis, University of Oxford.
56. O'Dwyer, Conor. 2004 Runaway State Building: How Political Parties Shape States in Postcommunist Eastern Europe World Politics 56 (July 520 553.
57. Olsen, Johan P. 2005 Maybe It Is Time to Rediscover Bureaucracy Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 16 : 1 24.
58. Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe Parliamentary Assembly (OSCE PA). 2007 Observations of the Extraordinary Parliamentary Elections in Kazakhstan (18 August 2007) 〈 http://assembly.coe.int/ Documents/WorkingDocs/Doc07/EDOC11385.pdf 〉. (October 1, 2007).
59. Osipov, N. I. 2002 Nomenclature Is Dead. Long Live Nomenclature?! Sayasat-Policy 2 : 22 26 Russian).
60. Panorama. 2008 Status of Civil Service Agency Could Increase September 19: 1 (Russian).
61. Perlman, Bruce J. Gregory Gleason. 2007 Cultural Determinism versus Administrative Logic: Asian Values and Administrative Reform in Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan International Journal of Public Administration 30 : 1327 1342.
62. Pfiffner, James. 1987 Political Appointees and Career Executives: The Democracy-Bureaucracy Nexus in the Third Century Public Administration Review (47 57 65.
63. Podolyak, Lybov. 2005 Civil Servant is a Profession Liter, January 29 (Russian).
64. Politt, Christopher Geert Bockaert. 2004. Public Management Reform: A Comparative Analysis, 2nd ed. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
65. Pomfret, Richard. 2005 Kazakhstan's Economy since Independence: Does the Oil Boom Offer a Second Chance for Sustainable Development? Europe-Asia Studies 57 (6 859 876.
66. Potvin, Maryse. 1994 The Election of Civil Servants and Partisan Behavior among Elected Representatives: A Comparative Study of Parliament and Governments in Five Liberal Democracies (1965 and 1985) International Review of Administrative Sciences 60 : 423 445.
67. Rohr, John A. 1991 Ethical Issues in French Public Administration: A Comparative Study Public Administration Review 51 (4 283 297.
68. Rouban, Luc. 2003 Politization of the Civil Service In Handbook of Public Administration, ed. Peters B. Guy Jon Pierre. London : Sage.
69. Sapargaliev, Gairat Petr Krepak. 2001 Syndrome of Temporary Workers. Problems of Civil Servants Who Are Not Sure about Tomorrow Jurist 〈 http://base.zakon.kz 〉. (Russian).
70. Sayasat-Policy. 2002 Nomenclature of Power 2: 4 (Russian).
71. Schatz, Edward. 2004. Modern Clan Politics: The Power of "Blood" in Kazakhstan and Beyond. Seattle, WA : University of Washington Press.
72. Seibel, Wolfgang. 1996 Administrative Sciences as Reform: German Public Administration Public Administration Review 56 (1 74 81.
73. Serikbaev, A 2002 Issues of Theory and Practice of Public Administration and Civil Service Development Sayasat-Policy 12 : 4 9 (Russian).
74. Stone, Deborah. 2002 Policy Paradox: The Art of Political Decision Making New York : Norton.
75. Transparency-Kazakhstan. 2002 Evaluation of National Anticorruption System of the Republic of Kazakhstan Almaty : Transparency-Kazakhstan.
76. Turisbekov, Zautbek. 2002 Recruitment of Business Representatives into the Public Administration Is the Issue for Many States Sayasat-Policy 2 : 6 13 (Russian).
77. Umirbekova, Zh. 2004 Civil Service: Kazakh Practice and International Experience Sayasat-Policy 9 : 10 11 (Russian).
78. United Nations Development Program (UNDP) - Kazakhstan. 2003 Perception of Corruption in Kazakhstan by Parliamentarians, Public Officials, Private Business and Civil Society Survey by Sange Research Center. Commissioned by the United Nations Development Program. Document No. UNDPKAZ 04.
79. Verheijen, A.J.G. 2003 Public Administration in Post-Communist States In Handbook of Public Administration, ed. Peters B. Guy Jon Pierre. London : Sage.
80. Weber, Max. 1958 Bureaucracy In From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, ed. H.H. Gerth C. Wright Mills. New York : Oxford University Press.
81. Wilson, John, David Gardner, Gulmira Kurganbayeva Elena Sakharchuk. 2002 The Changing Role of Local Government Managers in a Transitional Economy The International Journal of Public Sector Management 15 (4/5 399 411.
82. Wilson, Woodrow. 1992 The Study of Administration In Classics of Public Administration. 3rd ed., ed. Jay M. Shafritz Albert C. Hyde. Belmont, CA : Wadsworth.
83. World Bank. 1996 Republic of Kazakhstan: Transition of the State Report No. 15353-kz.
84. World Bank. 2002 Kazakhstan Governance and Service Delivery: A Diagnostic Report Report No. 23257-kz.
85. World Bank. 2005 Kazakhstan Reforming the Public Sector Wage System Policy Paper Report No. 31707-kz.