The use of fixatives for response to a radiation dispersal devise attack - a review of the current (2009) state-of-the-art

Journal of Environmental Radioactivity

Volumn 100, Issue 11, 2009, Pages 923-934

  Parra, R R ^a   Medina, V F ^b   Conca, J L ^c  

^a NEW MEXICO STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b U S ARMY ENGINEER RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT CENTER   (United States)

^c New Mexico State Univ   (United States)

Author keywords

Asphalt pitch emulsions; Containment; Dirty bomb; Environmental; Radioactive contaminant; Terrorism

Indexed keywords

CONTAINMENT; DIRTY BOMB; ENVIRONMENTAL; RADIOACTIVE CONTAMINANT; TERRORISM;

ASPHALT; BOMBING; BOMBS (ORDNANCE); CONTAMINATION; IMPURITIES; RADIOACTIVE MATERIALS; RADIOACTIVITY;

HEALTH RISKS;

ACRYLIC ACID; ALUMINUM SILICATE; ASPHALT; ATTAPULGITE; BIOPOLYMER; CALCIUM CHLORIDE; EPOXIDE; EPOXY RESIN; FIXATIVE; FUEL OIL; LIGNIN; MAGNESIUM CHLORIDE; NIOBIUM; PETROLEUM; POLYMER; POLYVINYL ALCOHOL; ZEOLITE;

ASPHALT; CLEANUP; CONTAINMENT; EMULSION; FIXATION; LITERATURE REVIEW; RADIOACTIVE POLLUTION; TERRORISM;

ATOMIC BOMB; CLAY; EMULSION; ENCAPSULATION; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; FOAM; GEL; MATERIAL COATING; POLLUTION CONTROL; POLLUTION TRANSPORT; RADIOACTIVE CONTAMINATION; REVIEW; TERRORISM; WASTE MANAGEMENT;

AEROSOLS; ALUMINUM SILICATES; BOMBS; ENVIRONMENTAL REMEDIATION; HYDROCARBONS; KINETICS; LIGNIN; RADIATION MONITORING; RADIATION PROTECTION; RADIATION-PROTECTIVE AGENTS; RADIOACTIVE HAZARD RELEASE; TERRORISM; ZEOLITES;

EID: 69849090944     PISSN: 0265931X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jenvrad.2009.07.006     Document Type: Review

References (88)

1. Ali A., Rashid F., and Orfi S.D. Globule formation of a clay mineral and a rapid method for the treatment of liquid radioactive waste. Radiochimica Acta 91 5 (2003) 305
2. Andersson K. The Characterization and Removal of Chernobyl Debris in Garden Soils. Riso-M-2912 (1991), Risø Library, Risø National Laboratory, Roskilde, Denmark
3. Andersson K.G., and Roed J. Removal of radioactive fallout from surface of soil and grassed surfaces using peelable coatings. Journal of Environmental Radioactivity 22 3 (1994) 197-204
4. ANL. "Supergel" System Cleans Radioactively Contaminated Structures. Available at: (2006), Argonne National Laboratory (ANL), National Security, Oct 2006. http://www.anl.gov/National_Security/docs/factsheet_supergel.pdf
5. ANL. "Supergel" System for Cleaning Radioactively Contaminated Structures Nears Deployment. Available at: (2007), Argonne National Laboratories, Chemical Sciences and Engineering Department. http://www.cmt.anl.gov/Science_and_Technology/National_Security/supergel .shtml
6. Archibald K., Demmer R., Argyle M., Lauerhass L., and Tripp J. Cleaning and Decontamination using Strippable and Protective Coatings at the Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Laboratory. Report No. INEEL/CON-98-00797. Available at: (1999), Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Lab., Idaho Falls, ID. http://www.osti.gov/energycitations/servlets/purl/8239-A64q4z/webviewabl e/
7. ASTM. ASTM Standard WK5394, "New Standard Specification for Materials to Mitigate the Spread of Radioactive Contamination after a Radiological Dispersion Event" (2008), ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA
8. Atapattu, K., 2005. Use of Emulsions for Immobilizing and Capturing Airborne Radioactive Contaminants from a Dirty Bomb. Honors College Thesis. University of Mississippi, Oxford, MS.
9. Baehr W. The management of radioactive wastes in developing countries: technical issues and solutions. Kernforschungszentrum Karlsruhe (1987)
10. Bartlett, Inc. Stripcoat TLC Free™ Data Sheet and MSDS. Available at: (2008), Bartlett, Inc, Plymouth, MA. http://www.bartlettinc.com/sp.cfm?pageid=1759
11. ®9300A Isocyanate Material Safety Data Sheet. Available at: (2002), BASF Corporation, Wyandotte, MI. http://www.instacote.com/documents/MSDS-Autofroth.pdf
12. Belfiore A., Panciatici G., and Moro L. Removal of thorium and uranium from surfaces by attapulgus clay suspensions. Inorganica Chimica Acta 94 (1984) 159-160
13. Buelt J.L., and Barnes S.M. Aging Test Results of an Asphalt Membrane Liner. PNL-4752 (1983), Pacific Northwest Laboratory, Richland, Washington
14. Bulkeley J.C. Decontamination and remediation after a dirty bomb attack. The Nonproliferation Review 14 1 (2007) 113-138
15. Bunnell L.R. Irradiation Testing of an Asphalt-based Grout Vault Sealant. PNL-7732 (1993), Pacific Northwest Laboratory, Richland, Washington
16. Bussiness Wire. Eurotech's Radiation-Resistant EKOR Demonstrated at Department of Energy Hanford Site. Available at: (2000). http://www.allbusiness.com/company-activities-management/company-structu res-ownership/6433483-1.html
17. Chang M. Nanoparticles, Super-absorbent Gel Clean Radioactivity from Porous Structures. Available at: (2004), Argonne National Laboratories, Media Center, News. http://www.anl.gov/Media_Center/News/2004/news040702.htm
18. Conca J.L., and Reynolds M.H. Dirty bombs, practical plans. Homeland Protection Professional 5 4 (2006) 18-22
19. Conca J.L., and Testa S.M. Chemical aspects of environmentally processed asphalt. In: Sharma M.K., and Yen T.F. (Eds). Asphaltene Particles in Fossil Fuel Exploration, Recovery, Refining, and Production Processes (1994), Plenum, New York
20. CRTI. Performance of Chemical, Biological, and Radiological Decontamination Foam Keeps Getting Better. CRTI Bulletin, CRTI B-2006-08, CRTI 02-0043TA. Available at: (2006), The Chemical, Biological, Radiological-Nuclear, and Explosives (CBRNE) Research and Technology Initiative (CRTI), Defence Research, Canada. http://www.css.drdc-rddc.gc.ca/crti/invest/stories-exemplaires/pdf/02_00 43ta-eng.pdf
21. Davison B. Peeling off contamination. Initiatives in Environmental Technology Investment 7 Fall (2000) 12
22. Davison B., Kuritz T., Vercruysse K.P., and McKeown C.K. "Green" Biopolymers for Improved Decontamination of Metals from Surfaces: Sorptive Characterization and Coating Properties. Final Report (2002), U.S. Department of Energy, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
23. DOE. Structural Foam/Encapsulant for Leaded Gloveboxes Cuts Worker Risk and Project Cost. Demonstration and Deployment Summary (2003), Technology at Rocky Flats, US Department of Energy and Kaiser-Hill Company, Rocky Flats, CO. http://rockyflats.apps.em.doe.gov/references/117-RFETS_Leaded_GB_FoamEnc aps.pdf Available at
24. Elcock D., Klemic G.A., and Taboas A.L. Establishing remediation levels in response to a radiological dispersal event (or "dirty bomb"). Environmental Science and Technology 38 9 (2004) 2505-2513
25. Eraker E. Cleanup after a radiological attack. U.S. prepares guidance. The Nonproliferation Review Fall/Winter (2004) 167
26. Farrell W.E., May C.G., and Howell R.S. Decontamination Techniques and Fixative Coatings Evaluated in the Building 235-F Legacy Source Term Removal Study. OBU-NMM-2005-0123 (2005), Westinghouse Savannah River Co., Savannah River Site, Aiken, SC
27. Ferguson C.D., and Potter W.C. The Four Faces of Nuclear Terrorism. Chapter 6: Dispersing Radiation (2005), Routledge, New York, NY
28. Ferguson C.D., Kazi T., and Perera J. Commercial Radioactive Sources. Surveying the Security Risks (2003), The Monterey Institute of International Studies Occasional Paper No. 11
29. Ford J. Radiological Dispersal Devices: Assessing the Transnational Threat (1998), National Defense University, Institute for National Strategic Studies, Washington, DC
30. Fox G.A., and Medina V.F. Evaluating factors affecting the permeability of emulsions used to stabilize radioactive contamination from a radiological dispersal device. Environmental Science and Technology 39 10 (2005) 3762-3769
31. Fox G.A., Fuchs J.W., Medina V.F., and Atapattu K. Capture of airborne particulate using surface applied emulsions: potential for postdetonation dirty bomb cleanup. Journal of Environmental Engineering 133 3 (2007) 255-262
32. Freeman H.D., and Gee G.W. Hanford Protective Barriers Program Asphalt Barrier Studies - FY 1988. PNL-6874 (1989), Pacific Northwest Laboratory, Richland, Washington
33. Freeman H.D., and Romine R.A. Hanford Permanent Isolation Barrier Program: Asphalt Technology Test Plan. PNL-9336 (1994), Pacific Northwest Laboratory, Richland, Washington
34. Freeman H.D., Romine R.A., and Zacher A.H. Hanford Permanent Isolation Barrier Program: Asphalt Technology Data and Status Report - FY 1994 (1994), Pacific Northwest Laboratory, Richland, Washington
35. Fricke V. ALARA™ 1146 Strippable Coating. Innovative Technology Summary Report WSRC-TR-99-O0458, DOE Office of Science and Technology (OST) No. 2314. Available at: (1999), Westinghouse Savannah River Company, Savannah River Site, Aiken, SC. http://www.doe.gov/bridge
36. Gates T.E. Physical Stability of Asphalt Emulsion Admix Seal Radon Barrier for Uranium Mill Tailings. DOE/UMT-0215, PNL-4846 (1983), Pacific Northwest Laboratory, Richland, Washington
37. Global Matrechs, Inc. NuCap™, Formerly Known as EKOR™, Nuclear and Hazardous Waste Encapsulation Technology. Available at: (2005), Product brochure, Global Matrechs, Inc., Ridgefield, CT. http://www.globalmatrechs.com/pdf/NuCap_Brochure.pdf
38. Gray H.N., and Bergbreiter D.E. Applications of polymeri smart materials to environmental problems. Environmental Heath Perspectives Supplements 105 S1 (1997) 55-63
39. Hanson T.A. Spray-on coating detects and removes radioactive contaminants. DOE Pulse, Number 142, September 29, 2003 (2003). http://www.ornl.gov/info/news/pulse/pulse_v142_03.htm Available at:
40. Hartley J.N., Koehmstedt P.L., Esterl D.J., and Freeman H.D. Asphalt Emulsion Sealing of Uranium Mill Tailings 1979 Annual Report. PNL-3290 (1980), Pacific Northwest Laboratory, Richland, Washington
41. Hoffman D.M., and Mitchell A.R. Development of Defoamers for Confinement Foam. Final Report Project #: LLNL-02-010, Preprint UCRL-CONF-214716. Available at (2003), High Explosives Appliction Facility, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA. https://e-reports-ext.llnl.gov/pdf/323770.pdf
42. International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). Environmental Consequences of the Chernobyl Accident and their Remediation: Twenty Years of Experience. Report of the Chernobyl Forum Expert Group "Environment" (2006), Radiological Assessment Reports Series, International Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna, Austria
43. IAEA. Annual Report 2006 (2006) Vienna, Austria
44. InstaCote, Inc. Technical Data Sheet: CC Epoxy 609. Available at (2002), InstaCote, Inc., Erie, MI. http://www.instacote.com/documents/DataSheetCCEpoxy609.pdf
45. InstaCote, Inc. CC Epoxy 609, Part A-Resin Material Safety Data Sheet. Available at: (2006), InstaCote, Inc, Erie, MI. http://instacote.com/msds/CCEpoxyA.pdf
46. InstaCote, Inc. CC Epoxy 609, Part B-Curing Agent Material Safety Data Sheet. Available at: (2006), InstaCote, Inc, Erie, MI. http://instacote.com/msds/CCEpoxyB.pdf
47. Isotron. RADBlock Material Safety Data Sheet (Revision No. 2). Available at: (2007), Isotron Corporation, Seattle, WA. http://www.isotron.net/pdf/RADBlockMSDS.pdf
48. Isotron. RADBLOCK™ Technical Data Sheet. Available at: (2007), Isotron Corporation, Seattle, WA. http://www.isotron.net/pdf/RADBLOCK_Data_Sheet.pdf
49. Isotron. Seattle-Based Isotron Featured on BBC Evening News and BBC World Program for "Dirty Bomb" Countermeasure Technologies. Available at: (2007), Isotron Press Release - BBC News, Isotron Corporation, Seattle, WA. http://www.isotron.net/pdf/PRBBC.pdf
50. Jones J., McRoberts M., and Martell M. Equipment Compatibility and Logistics Assessment for Containment Foam Deployment. Sandia Report SAND2005-5793. Available at: (2005), Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM. http://www.prod.sandia.gov/cgi-bin/techlib/access-control.pl/2005/055793 .pdf
51. Karam P.A. Radiological terrorism. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment 11 (2005) 501-523
52. Koehmstedt P.L., Hartley J.N., and Davis D.K. Use of asphalt emulsion sealants to contain radon and radium in uranium tailings. BNWL-2190 (1977), Pacific Northwest Laboratories, Richland, WA
53. Koonin, S.E., 2002. Statement delivered before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee on Radiological Terrorism, March 6, 2002.
54. LaGuardia T.S. Decommissioning methods and equipment. In: Osterhout M.M. (Ed). Decontamination and Decommissioning of Nuclear Facilities (1980), Plenum Press, New York 427-441
55. Lonin A.Y., and Krasnopyorova A.P. Use of zeolites for decontamination of radioactively contaminated working surfaces. Problems of atomic science and technology. Series: Nuclear Physics Investigations N5 48 (2007) 122-125
56. Mahler B.J., Van Metre P.C., Bashara T.J., Wilson J.T., and Johns D.A. Parking lot sealcoat: an unrecognized source of urban polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Environmental Science and Technology 39 (2005) 5560-5566
57. McGehee T.L., Medina V.F., Martino R.M., Bednar A.J., Weiss Jr. C.A., and Abraham D. Fixation of heavy contaminants of a dirty bomb attack: studies with uranium and metal stimulants. Environmental Progress 26 1 (2007) 94-103
58. Moring M., and Markkula M.L. Cleanup Techniques for Finnish Urban Environments and External Doses from 137Cs - Modelling and Calculations. STUK-A140 (1997), Finnish Centre for Radiation and Nuclear Safety, Helsinki, Finland
59. Musolino S.V., and Harper F.T. Emergency response guidance for the first 48 h after the outdoor detonation of an explosive radiological dispersion device. Health Physics 90 4 (2006) 377-385
60. NEI. Westinghouse unveils WES strip. Nuclear Engineering International 41 502 (1996) 42
61. NEI. EKOR set to 'cover' chernobyl shelter. Nuclear Engineering International 44 544 (1999) 23
62. Nenoff T.M. New Sandia radiation waste cleanup technology. Materials Technology 18 1 (2003) 15-18
63. IV-substituted (M = Ti, Zr) niobate framework. Available at:. Journal of the American Chemical Society 124 8 (2002) 1704-1713. http://pubs.acs.org/cgi-bin/article.cgi/jacsat/2002/124/i08/pdf/ja017081 z.pdf
64. Ohrbach K.-H., Matuschek G., Kettrup A., and Henning K. Thermoanalytical investigations on decontaminating agents for use in nuclear plants. Thermochimica Acta 108 (1986) 175-180
65. Osmanlioglu A.E. Treatment of radioactive liquid waste by sorption on natural zeolite in Turkey. Journal of Hazardous Materials 137 1 (2006) 332-335
66. Patel G.N. Full written testimony before the United States House of Representatives Committee on Government Reform, Subcommittee on National Security, Emerging Threats and International Relations on "Counterterrorism Technology: Picking Winners and Losers", September 29, 2003. Rayborn Health Building, Rm 215. Available at: (2003). http://reform.house.gov/UploadedFiles/Patel%20Testimony.pdf
67. ® on Waste Tank Tops. WSRC-TR-98-00101 (1998), Westinghouse Savannah River Company, Savannah River Site, Aiken, SC
68. Roberts L. Radiation accident grips Goiania. Science 238 (1987) 1028-1031
69. Robev S.K., Sumerska T.B., Todorov S.L., Kistanov D.K., and Marinova I. A method of decontaminating radioactively contaminated surfaces by film. Proc. Symp. on Practices in the Treatment of Low and Intermediate Level Radioactive Waste (1966), IAEA, Vienna 751-757
70. Roed J. Dry deposition in rural and in urban areas in Denmark. Radiation Protection Dosimetry 21 1/3 (1987) 33-36
71. Rogers J.V., Richter W.R., Choi Y.W., Fleming E.J., Shesky A.M., Cui J., Taylor M.L., Riggs K.B., Willenberg Z.J., and Stone H.J. Evaluation of Spray-applied Sporicidal Decontamination Technologies. Technology Evaluation Report, EPA 600/R-06/146, September 2006. Available at: (2006), National Homeland Security Research Center, Office of Research and Development, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Cincinnati, OH. http://www.epa.gov/nhsrc/pubs/erSporicidal012407.pdf
72. Said F.I., and Hafez M.B. Fixation of radioactive isotopes on bentonite as radioactive waste treatment step. Journal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry 241 3 (1999) 643-645
73. Schweers W.H.M., and Vorher W. Possibilities of an economic and non-polluting utilization of lignin. Proc. IAEA Symp. On Soil Organic Matter Studies, Braunschweig, 6-10 Sept. 1976. IAEA Proceedings Series (1977), IAEA, Vienna 85-89
74. Shelton J. Polymer technologies for the lockdown and removal of radioactive contamination. Available at:. USSOCOM Chemical, Biological, Radiological Conference & Exhibition, Responding to the Terrorist CBRN Threat: "Preparation or Panic", Event #6630, December 6-8, 2005, Tampa, FL (2005). http://www.dtic.mil/ndia/2005ussocom/wednesday/shelton.pdf
75. Sild M., Vondruska M., Loutny M., and Bednarik V. Stabilization/solidification of nonconbustible industrial waste by asphalt emulsions. Practice Periodical of Hazardous, Toxic, and Radioactive Waste Management 8 1 (2004) 2-6
76. Sparrow, C.A., Rogers, D.M., Medina, V.F., 2005. Reduction of β-particle Transmission using Emulsions. American Nuclear Society National Annual Meeting, June 5-9, 2005, San Diego, California.
77. Steevens J., Suedel B., Gibson A., Kennedy A., Blackburn W., Splichal D., and Pierce J.T. Environmental Evaluation of Dust Stabilizer Products (2007), U.S. Army Engineer Research and Development Center Report. ERDC/EL TR-07-03
78. In: Strand P., Skuterud L., and Melin J. (Eds). Reclamation of Contaminated Urban and Rural Environments Following a Severe Nuclear Accident. Nordic Nuclear Safety Research, BER 6. NKS(97)18 (1997), Norwegian Radiation Protection Authority, Oslo, Norway
79. Tawil J.J., and Bold F.C. A Guide to Radiation Fixatives (1983), Pacific Northwest Laboratory, Richland, WA 99352, PNL-4903
80. Testa S.M., Patton D.L., and Conca J.L. The use of environmentally processed asphalt as a contaminated soils remediation method. In: Kostecki P.T., and Edward J.C. (Eds). Hydrocarbon Contaminated Soils and Groundwater: Analysis, Fate, Environmental, and Public Health Effects, Remediation (1992), Lewis, Chelsea, Mich
81. USDOE. ALARA™ 1146 Strippable Coating. OST/TMS ID 2314. Innovative Technology Summary Report. DOE/EM-0533 (2000), U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Environment Management, Office of Science and Technology
82. Van Tuyle G.J., Strub T., O'Brien H., Mason C.F.V., and Gitomer S. Reducing RDD Concerns Related to Large Radiological Source Applications. Report LA-UR-03-6664 (2003), Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM
83. Webb P.S. Nuclear Criticality Safety Evaluation of Capture Coating and Instacote-Stripcoat Material for Application Inside Rocky Flats Environmental Technology Site Gloveboxes (1998), M.H. Chew & Associates, Inc. for Encapsulation Technologies, L.L.C. and Master Lee Hanford Corp, Richland, WA
84. Weiss P. Ghost town busters: after a dirty-bomb attack, special formulations could counter radioactive contamination. Science News 168 18 (2005) 282
85. Went W.B. Unconventional Nuclear Warfare Defense (UNWD) Containment and Mitigation Subtask. Sandia Report, SAND2005-2859 (2005), Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, New Mexico
86. Zagorin A., and Shannon E. London's dirty bomb plot. Time Magazine online. Available at: (2004). http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1101041011-708959,00.ht ml
87. Zimmerman P.D., and Lewis J.G. The Bomb in the Backyard. November/December (2006), Foreign Policy 33-39
88. Zimmerman P.D., and Loeb C. Dirty Bombs: the Threat Revisited. Defense Horizons, No. 38. Available at: (2004), Center for Technology and National Security Policy, National Defense University, Washington, D.C. http://hps.org/documents/RDD_report.pdf_