Australian public-sector outsourcing in the 'Golden Era': Cost savings evidence or anecdote?

Australian Accounting Review

Volumn 18, Issue 2, 2008, Pages 108-122

  Bisman, Jayne Elizabeth ^a  

^a CHARLES STURT UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 68949108623     PISSN: 10356908     EISSN: 18352561     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1835-2561.2008.0013.x     Document Type: Article

References (122)

1. Abelson, P., 2005 Outsourcing of Public Services in Australia: Seven Case Studies Department of Economics Research Paper No. 3/2005, Macquarie University, Sydney.
2. ACC (Australian Chamber of Commerce), 1988a Contracting Out as a Form of Privatisation: A Study of Victorian Local Government ACC Research Paper No. 1: 1988, ACC, Canberra.
3. ACC (Australian Chamber of Commerce) 1988b ACC 1988 Privatisation Survey: Local Government in South Australia and Tasmania ACC Research Paper No. 1: 1988-1989, ACC, Canberra.
4. ACLAEW (Audit Commission for Local Authorities in England and Wales), 1987 Competitiveness and Contracting Out of Local Authorities' Services HMSO, London.
5. Albin, S., 1992 Bureau-Shaping and Contracting Out: The Case of Australian Local Government Graduate Program in Public Policy Discussion Paper No. 29, Australian National University, Canberra.
6. ANAO (Australian National Audit Office), 1998 Costing of Services Financial Control and Administration Audit, Audit Report No. 21, ANAO, Canberra.
7. ANAO, 1999 Management of Contracted Business Support Processes ANAO Financial Control and Administration Audit, Audit Report No. 12, 1999-2000, ANAO, Canberra.
8. ANAO, 2000 Implementation of Whole-of-Government Information Technology Infrastructure Consolidation and Outsourcing Initiative ANAO Performance Audit, Audit Report No. 9, 2000 2001, ANAO, Canberra.
9. Anthony, R.N., and D.W. Young, 1999, Management Control in Nonprofit Organizations, 6th edn, Irwin/McGraw-Hill, Boston.
10. Aulich, C., and J. Hine, 2005 Whole-of-Government Approaches to Outsourcing and Market Testing by the Commonwealth Government Australian Journal of Public Administration 64, 3 : 35 45.
11. Baiman, S., 1982 Agency Research in Managerial Accounting: A Survey Journal of Accounting Literature 1 : 154 213.
12. Barrett, P., 1997 Corporate Governance - PS Style Australian Accountant 67, 7 : 30 31.
13. Bel, G., and A. Costas, 2006 Do Public Sector Reforms Get Rusty? Local Privatization in Spain Journal of Economic Policy Reform 9, 1 : 1 24.
14. Berenyi, E.B., and B.J. Stevens, 1988 Does Privatisation Work? A Study of the Delivery of Eight Local Services State and Local Government Review 20, 1 : 11 20.
15. Bisman, J.E., 1999, Costing for Outsourcing Decisions: Public Sector Perspectives, Australian Society of Certified Practising Accountants, Melbourne.
16. Bisman, J.E., 2005 Beneath the "Beyond Beancounting" Reports: Research, Professional Practice and Politics in the Public Sector Accounting, Accountability and Performance, 11, 1 : 25 48.
17. Borcherding, T.E., 1988 Some Revisionist Thoughts on the Theory of Public Bureaucracy European Journal of Political Economy 4 : 47 64.
18. Borcherding, T.E., W.W. Pommerehne and F. Schneider, 1982 Comparing the Efficiency of Public and Private Production: The Evidence from Five Countries Journal of Economics Supp. 2 : 127 56.
19. Botsman, P., 1995, An Appraisal of Contracting Out in Local Government, Evatt Foundation, Sydney.
20. Boyd, L., 1994, Managing Competitive Services, Municipal Association of Victoria, Melbourne.
21. Carlin, T.M., 2000 Measurement Challenges and Consequences in the Australian Public Sector Australian Accounting Review 10, 2 : 63 72.
22. Catanzariti, J., 2005 Industrial Relations: High Court Severs Employee's Rights to Redundancy Pay Law Society Journal, May : 42.
23. Chalos, P., 1995 Costing, Control and Strategic Analysis in Outsourcing Decisions Cost Management, Winter : 31 7.
24. Chandler, T., and P. Feuille, 1991 Municipal Unions and Privatisation Public Administration Review 51, 1 : 15 22.
25. CJPF and RPRC (Craig Johnston Policy Futures and RPR Consulting), 1997, Implementation of Service Purchasing Arrangements in the Australian Capital Territory, ACT Government, Canberra.
26. Coase, R.H., 1937 The Nature of the Firm Economica 4, November : 386 405.
27. Commonwealth Government Entry Point, 1999 Alphanumerical Government Site Listings (online) http://www.fedy.gov.au Domberger and S.A. Meadowcroft, 1987 Competitive Tendering and Refuse Collection: Identifying the Sources of Efficiency Gains', Fiscal Studies 8, 3 : 49 58.
28. D'Aveni, R., and D. Ravenscraft, 1994 Economies of Integration vs. Bureaucracy Costs: Does Vertical Integration Improve Performance? Academy of Management Journal 37, 5 : 1167 206.
29. Domberger, S., 1988 Competitive Tendering and Contracting Out in Competitive Tendering and Contracting Out - Towards a Policy Agenda Conference, University of Sydney, October.
30. Domberger, S., 1989 Competitive Tendering: How Much Can be Saved? Business Council Bulletin, June.
31. Domberger, S., 1993a Competitive Tendering Can Raise Efficiency The Australian, 31 March.
32. Domberger, S., 1993b Making Contractors Work to Save the Taxpayers' Money Australian Financial Review, 28 October.
33. Domberger, S., 1994 Contractual Advances Australian Financial Review, 20 May.
34. Domberger, S., 1998, The Contracting Organization: A Strategic Guide to Outsourcing, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
35. Domberger, S., and S. Farago, 1994 Competitive Tendering and the Performance of Government Trading Enterprises in NSW Economic Papers 13, 3 : 40 52.
36. Domberger, S., S. Farago, C. Hall and E. Li, 1993 Competitive Tendering and Contracts in the NSW Budget Sector: The 1993 Survey Findings Graduate School of Business Working Paper No. 11-93, University of Sydney.
37. Domberger, S., and C. Hall, 1995 An Introduction to Contracting in Action in S. Domberger and C. Hall (eds), The Contracting Casebook: Competitive Tendering in Action, AGPS, Canberra.
38. Domberger, S., C. Hall and M. Jeffries, 1995 Competitive Tendering in Commonwealth Government Agencies: The 1995 Survey Findings Graduate School of Business, University of Sydney.
39. Domberger, S., and P. Jensen, 1997 Contracting Out by the Public Sector: Theory, Evidence, Prospects Oxford Review of Economic Policy 13, 4 : 67 78.
40. Domberger, S., S.A. Meadowcroft and D.J. Thompson, 1986 Competitive Tendering and Efficiency: The Case of Refuse Collection Fiscal Studies 7, 4 : 69 87.
41. Domberger, S., S.A. Meadowcroft and D. Thompson, 1987 The Impact of Competitive Tendering on the Costs of Hospital Domestic Services Fiscal Studies 8, 4 : 39 54.
42. Dunsire, A., K. Hartley and D. Parker, 1991 Organisational Status and Performance: Summary of Findings Public Administration 69, 1 : 21 40.
43. East and Partners, 2001 The Canberra Report: Federal Markets IT Vendor Relationship Performance Southport, Qld.
44. English, L., 2007 Performance Audit of Australian Public Private Partnerships: Legitimising Government Policies or Providing Independent Oversight? Financial Accountability & Management 23, 3 : 313 36.
45. Ernst, J., 1994 Contracting Communities! Issues in the Privatisation and Contracting Out of Local Government Community Services in J. Ernst (ed. The Privatisation Papers, Victoria University of Technology, Melbourne.
46. Fahey, J., 1996, Media Release, Minister for Finance 37/96, Canberra, 11 December.
47. Fahey, J., 2000, Media Release, Minister for Finance and Administration Government Initiative in Competitive Tendering and Contracting in the Australian Public Sector 11 May.
48. Ferris, J.M., and E. Graddy, 1986 Contracting Out: For What, With Whom? Public Administration Review 46, 4 : 332 44.
49. Fixler, P.E., R.W. Poole and L. Scarlett, 1987, Privatisation 1987: Second Annual Report on Privatisation, Reason Foundation, Santa Monica, CA.
50. Funnell, W., and K. Cooper, 1998, Public Sector Accounting and Accountability in Australia, UNSW Press, Sydney.
51. Ganley, J., and J. Grahl, 1988 Competition and Efficiency in Refuse Collection: A Critical Comment Fiscal Studies 9, 1 : 80 5.
52. Granof, M.H., 1998, Government and Not-for-Profit Accounting, John Wiley, New York.
53. Grayson, L., M. Hobson and K. Walsh (eds 1990, INLOGOV Informs on Competition, Institute of Local Government Studies, University of Birmingham, UK.
54. Hayward, D., 1994 Contracting Out: Problem or Solution? in J. Coulter (ed. Doing More with Less? Contracting Out and Efficiency in the Public Sector, PSRC Collected Papers No. 1, University of New South Wales, Kensington, NSW.
55. Hefetz, A., and M. Warner, 2007 Beyond the Market versus Planning Dichotomy: Understanding Privatisation and its Reverse in US Cities Local Government Studies 33, 4 : 555 72.
56. Herbert, B., 1994 Managing Compulsory Competitive Tendering: Critical Decisions in Implementation in J. Ernst, B. Herbert, L. Glanville and M. Williams (eds Competitive Tendering with a Purpose: An Equity Driven Approach to Compulsory Competitive Tendering, Victoria University of Technology, Melbourne.
57. Hilmer Report 1993 National Competition Policy: Report by the Independent Committee of Inquiry AGPS, Canberra.
58. Hilvert, J., 1994 Government's IT Outsourcing Saves Money, Keeps Quality The Australian, 4 October : 22.
59. Hodge, G., 1996, Contracting Out Government Services: A Review of International Evidence, Montech, Melbourne.
60. Hodge, G., 1998 Contracting Public Sector Services: A Meta-analytical Perspective of the International Evidence Australian Journal of Public Administration 75, 4 : 98 109.
61. Hodge, G., 1999 Competitive Tendering and Contracting Out Public Productivity and Management Review 22, 4 : 455 69.
62. Hodge, G.A., and C. Greve, 2007 Public-private Partnerships: An International Performance Review Public Administration Review 67, 3 : 545 58.
63. Houghton, K.A., and C.A. Jubb, 1998 The Function of the Auditor-General: Independence, Competence and Outsourcing - The Policy Implications Australian Accounting Review 8, 1 : 30 5.
64. ICMA (International City Management Association), 1989, Service Delivery in the 90s: Alternative Approaches for Local Governments, ICMA, Washington D.C.
65. Industry Commission, 1996 Competitive Tendering and Contracting by Public Sector Agencies: Overview AGPS : Melbourne.
66. Jensen, P.H., and R.E. Stonecash, 2005 Incentives and the Efficiency of Public Sector Outsourcing Contracts Journal of Economic Surveys 19, 5 : 767 87.
67. Johnstone, D., 1999 Public Sector Outsourcing and Charging In-house Bidders for their Use of Capital Australian Accounting Review 9, 1 : 33 41.
68. Kavanagh, I., and D. Parker, 2000 Managing the Contract: A Transaction Cost Analysis of Externalization Local Government Studies 26, 4 : 1 22.
69. Kennedy, S., 1995 Outsourcing: A Cautionary Note Return on Information 1, 5 : 6.
70. Kulmala, H.I., M. Ojala, L. Ahoniemi and E. Uusi-Rauva, 2006 Unit Cost Behaviour in Public Sector Outsourcing International Journal of Public Sector Management 19, 2 : 130 49.
71. LGIU (Local Government Information Unit), 1994, CCT on the Record: A Review of Experience of Compulsory Competitive Tendering under the Local Government Act 1988, LGIU, London.
72. Long, S., 1999 Outsourcing: How the Cheap Option has Turned Nasty Australian Financial Review, 18 19 September: 27.
73. MAB (Management Advisory Board and Management Improvement Advisory Committee), 1992 Contracting for the Provision of Services in Commonwealth Agencies AGPS, Canberra.
74. MAGLGR (Ministerial Advisory Group on Local Government Reform), 1995 Reform of Local Government in South Australia: Councils of the Future SA Department of Housing, Urban Development and Local Government, Adelaide.
75. Manchester City Council, 1990, The Price of Winning: Contractors Audit, Vol. 3, Manchester City Council, Manchester, UK.
76. Marlin, J.T. (ed 1984, Contracting Municipal Services: A Guide to Purchase from the Private Sector, Wiley, New York.
77. McCarrey Report, 1993 Agenda for Reform: Report of the Independent Commission to Review Public Sector Finances Vol. 2, WA Government Printer, Perth.
78. Mitchell, A., 1999 Outsourcing No Cure for Costs Australian Financial Review, 24 March : 21.
79. Moore, S., 1987 Contracting Out: A Painless Alternative to the Budget Cutter's Knife Prospects for Privatisation: Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science 36, 3 : 60 73.
80. Morkel, A., 1993 Industry Clusters and Value-system Strategies for Australia in G. Lewis, A. Morkel, and G. Hubbard (eds Australian Strategic Management: Concepts, Context and Cases, Prentice Hall, Sydney.
81. Murfitt, P., L. Glanville and J. Ernst, 1996 Due Consideration? The Implementation of Compulsory Competitive Tendering Policy in Victoria Victoria University of Technology, Melbourne.
82. Murphy, K., 2000 Outsourcing IT Flawed, Says Auditor Australian Financial Review, 7 September.
83. National Guide to Government, 1988-2000, Information Australia, Melbourne.
84. Ni, A.Y., and S. Bretschneider, 2005 Why Does State Government Contract Out Their E-Government Services? Proceedings of the 38th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, Hawaii, January.
85. NSW Government, 1991 Reform of Local Government in New South Wales: Legislative Proposals NSW Government, Sydney.
86. NSW Government, 1996 Policy Statement on the Application of National Competition Policy to Local Government NSW Government, Sydney.
87. NSW Premier's Department, 1995 Procurement and Disposal Guidelines: A Guide to Inviting, Assessing and Selecting Tenders and Other Offers NSW Premier's Department, Sydney.
88. O'Faircheallaigh, C., J. Wanna and O. Weller, 1999, Public Sector Management in Australia: New Challenges, New Directions, 2nd edn., Macmillan, South Yarra, Vic.
89. Oppenheim, A.N., 1966, Questionnaire Design and Attitude Measurement, Heinemann, London.
90. OSOE (Office of State Owned Enterprises), 1994 Contracting Out Guidelines Victorian Department of the Treasury and Finance, Melbourne.
91. Ouchi, W.G., 1980 Markets, Bureaucracies and Clans Administrative Science Quarterly 25, March : 129 41.
92. Paddon, M., 1991 Competitive Tendering and Contracting Out in Local Government: Some Reflections on UK Experience Centre for Local Government Studies, Charles Sturt University, Bathurst, NSW.
93. Paddon, M., and R. Thanki (eds 1995, Australia's Contracting Public Services: Critical Reviews of Contracting-out by the Public Sector, PSRC Collected Papers No. 2, University of New South Wales, Kensington, NSW.
94. Paice, R., 1999 GST and the Public Sector: Change to the Fundamentals Australian CPA 69, 8 : 28 9.
95. Prager, J., 1994 Contracting Out Government Services: Lessons from the Private Sector Public Administration Review 54, 2 : 176 84.
96. PSRC (Public Sector Research Centre), 1996 Contracting Out by Local Government in NSW Contract Monitor 5, August : 1.
97. Queensland Government, 1996 National Competition Policy and Queensland Local Government: A Queensland Government Policy Statement July.
98. Quiggin, J., 1998 National Competition Policy and Human Services Northern Radius 5, 3 : 3 4.
99. Quinn, J.B., and F.G. Hilmer, 1994 Strategic Outsourcing Sloan Management Review 35, 4 : 43 55.
100. Rehfuss, J., 1989, Contracting Out in Government: A Guide to Working with Outside Contractors to Provide Public Services, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA.
101. Rehfuss, J., 1990 Contracting Out and Accountability in State and Local Governments: The Importance of Contract Monitoring State and Local Government Review 22, 1 : 44 8.
102. Richards, R., 1999 Taxing Times: GST Compliance Australian CPA 69, 1 : 50 1.
103. Rimmer, S., 1991 Evaluating the Cost Benefits of Contracting Out IIR Contracting Out Conference, Sydney, October.
104. Rimmer, S., 1994 Competitive Tendering and Contracting: Theory and Research Australian Economic Review, 3rd Quarter, University of Melbourne.
105. Rimmer, S., 1998 Competitive Tendering and Outsourcing: Initiatives and Methods Australian Journal of Public Administration 57, 4 : 75 84.
106. Schwartz, R., 2005 The Contracting Quandary: Managing Local Authority-VNPO Relations Local Government Studies 31, 1 : 69 83.
107. SCPAC (Service Competition Policy Advisory Committee), 1997 Service Competition Guidelines: New South Wales Government NSW Council on the Cost of Government.
108. Seal, W., 2004 Towards an Enabling Research Agenda for the Accounting/Contracting Nexus Accounting Forum 28, 4 : 329 48.
109. Smith, J.M., 1990 Out-sourcing Thrives in Lean Times Government Computer News 9, 16 : 1 2.
110. Spoehr, J., J. Quiggin, L. Wilson and K. Purse, 2002 State of Secrecy - Outsourcing: Promise and Performance Public Service Association of South Australia, Adelaide.
111. Stevens, B.J., 1984 Comparing Public- and Private-sector Privatization Efficiency: An Analysis of Eight Activities National Productivity Review, Autumn.
112. Touche Ross and Co., 1987, Privatization in America, Touche Ross and Co., New York.
113. Vining, A., and D. Weimer, 1990 Government Supply and Government Production Failure: A Framework Based on Contestability Journal of Public Policy 10, 1 : 1 22.
114. WA Government, 1995 Costing Government Activities - Guidelines for Use by Agencies WA Government, Perth.
115. Walker, B., and B.C. Walker, 2000, Privatisation Sell Off or Sell Out: The Australian Experience, ABC Books, Sydney.
116. Walsh, K., 1991, Competitive Tendering for Local Authority Services: Initial Experiences, HMSO, London.
117. Walsh, K., 1995, Public Services and Market Mechanisms: Competition, Contracting and the New Public Management, Macmillan, Houndmills, Hampshire.
118. Williamson, O.E., 1973 Markets and Hierarchies: Some Elementary Considerations American Economic Review 63, 2 : 316 25.
119. Williamson, O.E., 1985, The Economic Institutions of Capitalism: Firms, Markets, Relational Contracting, Free Press, New York.
120. Williamson, O.E., 1996 Economics and Organization: A Primer California Management Review 38, 2 : 131 46.
121. Wise, V., and N. Sciulli, 2004 The Use of Contracting Out: A Case Study of Decision-Making and Organisational Learning in Local Government Symposium on Accountability, Governance and Performance in Transition, Griffith University, Brisbane, February.
122. Young, S., 2005 Outsourcing in the Australian Health Sector: The Interplay of Economics and Politics International Journal of Public Sector Management 18, 1 : 25 36.