JUDGING THE CREDIBILITY OF HISTORIC CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE COMPLAINANTS: How Judges Describe Their Decisions

Psychology, Public Policy, and Law

Volumn 15, Issue 2, 2009, Pages 102-123

  Connolly, Deborah A ^a   Price, Heather L ^b   Gordon, Heidi M ^a  

^a SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b UNIVERSITY OF REGINA   (Canada)

Author keywords

credibility assessment; historic child sexual abuse complaints; recent complaint warning

Indexed keywords

EID: 67549130297     PISSN: 10768971     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1037/a0015339     Document Type: Article

References (66)

1. Bala N. Child witnesses in the Canadian criminal courts. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 5 (1999) 323-354
2. Bala N., Ramakrishnan K., Lindsay R., and Lee K. The judicial assessment of the credibility of child witnesses. Alberta Law Review 42 (2005) 995-1017
3. Bell B.E., and Loftus E.F. Trivial persuasion in the courtroom: The power of (a few) minor details. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 56 (1989) 669-679
4. Berman G.L., and Cutler B.L. Effects of inconsistencies in eyewitness testimony and mock-juror judgments. Journal of Applied Psychology 81 (1996) 170-177
5. Berman G.L., Narby D.J., and Cutler B.L. Effects of inconsistent eyewitness statements on mock-jurors' evaluations of the eyewitness, perceptions of defendant culpability and verdicts. Law and Human Behavior 19 (1995) 79-88
6. Borckardt J.J., Sprohge E., and Nash M. Effects of the inclusion and refutation of peripheral details on eyewitness credibility. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 33 (2003) 2187-2197
7. Bornstein B.H., and Muller S.L. The credibility of recovered memory testimony: Exploring the effects of alleged victim and perpetrator gender. Child Abuse & Neglect 25 (2001) 1415-1426
8. Bottoms B.L., Golding J.M., Stevenson M.C., Wiley T.R.A., and Yozwiak J.A. A review of factors affecting jurors' decisions in child sexual abuse cases. In: Toglia M.P., Read J.D., Ross D.F., and Lindsay R.C.L. (Eds). The handbook of eyewitness psychology, Vol. I: Memory for events (2007), Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ 509-543
9. Brewer N., Potter B., Fisher R.P., Bond N., and Luszcz M.A. Beliefs and data on the relationships between consistency and accuracy on eyewitness testimony. Applied Cognitive Psychology 13 (1999) 297-313
10. Brewer W.P. What is autobiographical memory?. In: Rubin D.C. (Ed). Autobiographical memory (1986), Cambridge University Press, New York 25-49
11. Brilleslijper-Kater S.N., Friedrich W.N., and Corwin D.L. Sexual knowledge and emotional reaction as indicators of sexual abuse in young children: Theory and research challenges. Child Abuse & Neglect 28 (2004) 1007-1017
12. Brodie v. The King, [1936] S.C.R. 188.
13. Bruck M., Ceci S.J., and Hembrooke H. Reliability and credibility of young children's reports: From research to policy and practice. In: Bull R. (Ed). Children and the law: The essential readings (2001), Blackwell, Boston 87-123
14. Charmaz K. Constructing grounded theory (2006), Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA
15. Coghlan v. Cumberland, 1 Ch. 704 (1898).
16. Connolly D.A., Price H.L., Lavoie J.A., and Gordon H.M. Perceptions and predictors of children's credibility of a unique event and an instance of a repeated event. Law and Human Behavior 32 (2008) 92-112
17. Connolly D.A., and Read J.D. Remembering historical child sexual abuse. Criminal Law Quarterly 47 (2003) 438-480
18. Connolly D.A., and Read J.D. Delayed prosecutions of historic child sexual abuse: Analyses of 2064 Canadian criminal complaints. Law and Human Behavior 30 (2006) 409-434
19. Conte J.R., Sorenson E., Fogarty L., and Rosa J.D. Evaluating children's reports of sexual abuse: Results from a survey of professionals. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 78 (1991) 428-437
20. Cossins A. The hearsay rule and delayed complaints of child sexual abuse: The law and the evidence. Psychiatry, Psychology, and Law 9 (2002) 163-176
21. Desmarais, S. L., Read, J. D., Rojas, E., & Vander Veen, S. (2005, June). Juror knowledge of memory processes in forensic contexts: Which topics require expert opinion evidence? Paper presented at the meeting of the Canadian Psychological Association, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
22. Fisher R.P., and Cutler B.L. The relation between consistency and accuracy of eyewitness testimony. In: Davies G., Lloyd-Bostock S., McMurran M., and Wilson C. (Eds). Psychology, law, and criminal justice: International developments in research and practice (1995), De Gruyter, Berlin, Germany 21-28
23. Fivush R. Event memory in early childhood. In: Cowan N. (Ed). The development of memory in childhood (1997), United Kingdom Psychology Press, Hove, England 139-161
24. Fivush R. Scripts, schemas, and memory of trauma. In: Stein N.L., Bauer P.J., and Rabinowitz M. (Eds). Representation, memory, and development: Essays in honor of Jean Mandler (2002), Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ 53-74
25. Golding J.M., Fryman H.M., Marshall D.F., and Yozwiak J.A. Big girls don't cry: The effect of child witness demeanor on juror decisions in a child sexual abuse trial. Child Abuse & Neglect 27 (2003) 1311-1321
26. Golding J.M., Sego R.P., and Sanchez S.A. The effect of multiple childhood sexual assaults on mock-jurors' perceptions of repressed memories. Behavioral Sciences & the Law 17 (1999) 483-493
27. Goodman G.S., Batterman-Faunce J.M., and Schaaf J.M. Nearly 4 years after an event: Children's eyewitness memory and adults' perceptions of children's accuracy. Child Abuse & Neglect 26 (2002) 849-884
28. Guadagno B.L., Powell M., and Wright R. Police officers' and legal professionals' perceptions regarding how children are, and should be, questioned about repeated abuse. Psychiatry, Psychology, and Law 13 (2006) 251-260
29. Guthrie C., Rachlinski J.J., and Wistrich A.J. Inside the judicial mind. Cornell Law Review 86 (2001) 777-830
30. Home Affairs Committee. The conduct of investigations into past cases of abuse in children's homes: Fourth report of Session 2001-02 (2002), Author, London. http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200102/cmselect/cmhaff/cmhaff.htm Retrieved May 1, 2008, from http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200102/cmselect/cmhaff/cmhaff.htm
31. Hudson J., and Nelson K. Effects of script structure on children's story recall. Developmental Psychology 19 (1983) 625-635
32. Kahneman D. Maps of bounded rationality: A perspective on intuitive judgment and choice (2002), Department of Psychology, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ
33. Retrieved October 17, 2008, from http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economics/laureates/2002/kahnemann-lecture.pdf
34. Kassin S.M., and Sukel H. Coerced confessions and the jury: An experimental test of the "harmless error" rule. Law and Human Behavior 21 (1997) 27-46
35. Kaufman G., Drevland G.C.B., Wessel E., Overskeid G., and Magnussen S. The importance of being earnest: Displayed emotions and witness credibility. Applied Cognitive Psychology 17 (2003) 21-34
36. Kendall-Tackett K.A., Williams L.M., and Finkelhor D. Impact of sexual abuse on children: A review and synthesis of recent empirical studies. Psychological Bulletin 113 (1993) 164-180
37. Lamb M.E. Child witnesses: Recent research on children's accounts of forensically relevant experiences. Applied Developmental Science 3 (1999) 2-5
38. Lewis P. Delayed prosecution for childhood sexual abuse (2006), Oxford University Press, New York
39. London K., Bruck M., Ceci S.J., and Shuman D.W. Disclosure of child sexual abuse: What does the research tell us about the ways that children tell?. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 11 (2005) 194-226
40. Malloy L.C., Lyon T.D., and Quas J.A. Filial dependency and recantation of child sexual abuse allegations. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 46 (2007) 162-170
41. McCarron A.L., Ridgway S., and Williams A. The truth and lie story: Developing a tool for assessing child witnesses' ability to differentiate between truth and lies. Child Abuse Review 13 (2004) 42-50
42. Meyers J.E.B. A decade of international reform to accommodate child witnesses. Criminal Justice and Behavior 23 (1996) 402-422
43. Myles-Worsley M., Cromer C.C., and Dodd D.H. Children's preschool script reconstruction: Reliance on general knowledge as memory fades. Developmental Psychology 22 (1986) 22-30
44. Ogloff J.R.P., and Rose V.G. The comprehension of judicial instructions. In: Brewer N., and Williams K.D. (Eds). Psychology and law: An empirical perspective (2005), Guilford Press, New York 407-444
45. Pezdek K., Morrow A., Blandon-Gitlin I., Goodman G.S., Quas J.A., Saywitz K.J., et al. Deception detection in children: Event familiarity affects criterion-based content analysis ratings. Journal of Applied Psychology 89 (2004) 119-126
46. Platt D. Threshold decisions: How social workers prioritize referrals of child concern. Child Abuse Review 15 (2006) 4-18
47. R. v. Ay (1994) B.C.J. No. 2024. (B.C.C.A.)
48. R. v. B.(G) (1990) 2 S.C.R. 30.
49. R. v. D.(D) (2000) S.C.C. 43 S.C.R. 275.
50. R. v. D.R.E. (2002) B.C.J. No. 2879. (B.C.C.A.)
51. R. v. Gagnon (2006) 1 S.C.R. 621, 2006 SCC 17.
52. R. v. King (2005) O.J. No. 3546. (Ont. C.A.)
53. R. v. Marquard (1993) 4 S.C.R. 223.
54. R. v. R. (J. W.) (2001) 151 C.C.C. (3d) 236; BCJ No. 39.
55. R. v. Tzarfin (2005) O.J. No. 3531. (Ont. C.A.)
56. R. v. W.(R.) (1992) 2 S.C.R. 122.
57. Regan P.C., and Baker S.J. The impact of child witness demeanor on perceived credibility and trial outcome in sexual abuse cases. Journal of Family Violence 13 (1998) 187-195
58. Rennie D.L., Phillips J.R., and Quartaro J.K. Grounded theory: A promising approach for conceptualization in psychology?. Canadian Psychology 29 (1988) 139-150
59. Rose M., Nadler J., and Clark J. Appropriately upset? Emotion norms and perceptions of crime victims. Law and Human Behavior 30 (2006) 203-219
60. Salekin R.T., Ogloff J.R., McFarland C., and Rogers R. Influencing jurors' perceptions of guilt: Expression of emotionality during testimony. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 13 (1995) 293-305
61. Slackman E., and Nelson K. Acquisition of an unfamiliar script story form by young children. Child Development 55 (1984) 329-340
62. Sugarman D.B., and Boney-McCoy S. Impact of expert testimony on the believability of repressed memories. Violence and Victims 12 (1997) 115-126
63. Summit R.C. The child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome. Child Abuse & Neglect 7 (1983) 177-193
64. Tabachnick B.G., and Pope K.S. Therapist responses to recovered and never-forgotten memories of child sex abuse. Violence Against Women 3 (1997) 348-360
65. Wessel E., Drevland G.C.B., Eilertsen D.E., and Magnussen S. Credibility of the emotional witness: A study of ratings by court judges. Law and Human Behavior 30 (2006) 221-230
66. Wiener R.L., Bornstein B.H., and Voss A. Emotion and the law: A framework for inquiry. Law and Human Behavior 30 (2006) 231-248