Ethanol versus Gasoline: The contestation and closure of a Socio-technical system in the USA

Social Studies of Science

Volumn 39, Issue 3, 2009, Pages 421-448

  Carolan, Michael S ^a  

^a Department of Environmental and Radiological Health Sciences   (United States)

Author keywords

Biofuel; Ethanol; Petroleum; Problem redefinition; Socio technical system

Indexed keywords

ALCOHOL; GASOLINE; PETROLEUM;

ARTICLE; HUMAN; POLICY; TECHNOLOGY; UNITED STATES;

ETHANOL; GASOLINE; HUMANS; PETROLEUM; PUBLIC POLICY; TECHNOLOGY; UNITED STATES;

EID: 66249106059     PISSN: 03063127     EISSN: 14603659     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0306312708101049     Document Type: Article

References (84)

1. Bailey, E.H.S. (1911) 'The Chemist as a Conservationist', Science 34 (883). 748-50.
2. Barnard, H.E. (1938) 'Prospects for Industrial Uses for Farm Products', Journal of Farm Economics 20 (1). 119-33.
3. Baskerville, Charles (1906) 'Free Alcohol in the Arts and as Fuel', in Albert Shaw (ed.), The American Monthly Review of Reviews (New York: The Review of Reviews Company). 211-14.
4. Beeman, Randal (1994) 'Chemivisions: The Forgotten Promise of the Chemurgy Movement', Agricultural History 68 (4). 23-45.
5. Berton, Hal, William Kovarik & Scott Sklar (1982) The Forbidden Fuel: Power Alcohol in the Twentieth Century ( New York: Boyd Griffin ).
6. Bijker, Wiebe (1995) Of Bicycles, Bakelites, and Bulbs: Toward a Theory of Sociotechnical Change ( Cambridge, MA: MIT Press ).
7. Borth, Christy (1943) Pioneer of Plenty: Modern Chemists and their Work ( New York: The New Home Library ).
8. Bowden, Gary (1982) 'Estimating US Crude Oil Resources: Organizational Interests, Political Economy, and Historical Change', Pacific Sociological Review 25 (4). 419-48.
9. Bowden, Gary (1985) 'The Social Construction of Validity in Estimates of US Crude Oil Reserves', Social Studies of Science 15: 207-40.
10. Boyd, T.A. (1921) 'Motor Fuel from Vegetation', Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 13 (9). 836.
11. Bringhurst, Bruce (1979) Antitrust and the Oil Monopoly: The Standard Oil Cases, 1890-1911 ( Westport, CN: Greenwood Press ).
12. Chemical Foundation & Farm Chemurgic Council (1936) Proceedings of the Second Dearborn Conference of Agriculture, Industry, and Science ( Dearborn, MI: Farm Chemurgic Council, Inc. and New York: Chemical Foundation ).
13. Christensen, L., R. Hixon & E. Fullmer (1934) Power Alcohol and Farm Relief ( New York: The Chemical Foundation ).
14. Clean Fuels Development Coalition (2007) The Ethanol Fact Book (Washington, DC: Clean Fuels Development Coalition). available at:
15. Clough, Albert. (1909) 'Comparison of Gasoline and Alcohol Motor Tests', The Horseless Age 24 (21). 607.
16. Corn Marketing Program of Michigan (2007) 'Ethanol - American's Renewable Fuel, 2007 Update', CORN - Check Off Report and Newsletter (DeWitt, MI, January). available at
17. Constant, Edward (1989) 'Cause or Consequence: Science, Technology, and Regulatory Change in the Oil Business in Texas, 1930-1975', Technology and Culture 30 (2). 426-55.
18. Cummins, Lyle (2002) Internal Fire: The Internal Combustion Engine, 1673-1900 ( New York: Carnot Press ).
19. Dennis, Michael (1985) 'Drilling for Dollars: The Making of US Petroleum Reserve Estimates, 1921-25', Social Studies of Science 15 (2). 241-65.
20. Doran, J.M. (1924) 'Some Recent Developments in Industrial Alcohol', Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 20 (2). 641-44.
21. Effland, Anne (1995) 'New Riches from the Soil: The Chemurgic Ideas of Wheller McMillen', Agricultural History 69 (2). 288-97.
22. Egloff, Gustav (1933) 'Alcohol-Gasoline Motor Fuels', Pew Papers, Box 52: pp. 1-6.
23. Finlay, Mark (2004) 'Old Efforts at New Uses: A Brief History of Chemurgy and the American Search for Biobased Material', Journal of Industrial Ecology 7 (3 / 4). 33-46.
24. Garvan, Francis (1936) 'Introduction', in F. Garvan (ed.), Proceedings of the Second Annual Dearborn Conference of Agriculture, Industry, and Science (New York: The Chemical Foundation). 2-8.
25. Geels, Frank (2005) 'Co-evolution of Technology and Society: The Transition in Water Supply and Personal Hygiene in the Netherlands (1850-1930) - A Case Study in Multi-level Perspective', Technology in Society 27: 363-97.
26. Giebelhaus, August (1979) 'Resistance to Long-term Energy Transition: The Case of Power Alcohol in the 1930s', in Lewis Perelman, August Giebelhaus & Michael Yokell (eds), Energy Transitions: Long-term Perspectives (Boulder, CO: Westview Press). 35-63.
27. Giebelhaus, August (1980 a) 'Farming for Fuel: The Alcohol Motor Fuel Movement of the 1930s', Agricultural History 54 (1). 173-84.
28. Giebelhaus, August (1980 b) Business and Government in the Oil Industry: A Case Study of Sun Oil, 1876-1945 ( Greenwich, CN: JAI Press ).
29. Gradenwitz, Alfred (1907) 'The Denatured Alcohol Situation', Scientific American Supplement S1 (1688). 393.
30. Hale, William (1934) The Farm Chemurgic: Forward the Star of Destiny Lights Our Way ( Boston, MA: Stratford ).
31. Hall, Tom (1973) 'Wilson and the Food Crisis: Agricultural Price Controls During World War I', Agricultural History 47 (1). 24-46.
32. Hamlin, M. (1915) 'Liquid Fuel for Internal Combustion Engines', Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 7 (7). 631-32.
33. Harbeson, Robert (1940) 'The Present Status of the Sherman Act', Michigan Law Review 39 (2). 189-212.
34. Hard, Mikael (1994) 'Technology as Practice: Local and Global Closure Processes in Diesel-engine Design', Social Studies of Science 24 (3). 549-85.
35. Hard Mikael & Andrew Jamison (1997) 'Alternative Cars: The Contrasting Stories of Steam and Diesel Automotive Engines', Technology in Society 19 (2). 145-60.
36. Hartline, Frederick (1979) 'Lowering the Cost of Alcohol', Science 206 (4414). 41-42.
37. Herrick, Rufus (1907) Denatured or Industrial Alcohol ( New York: John Wiley and Sons ).
38. Hixon, R.M. (1933) Use of Alcohol in Motor Fuels: Progress Report No. 6 ( Ames, IA: Iowa State College (1 May).
39. Hordeski, Michael (2007) Alternative Fuels: The Future of Hydrogen ( Lilburn, GA: The Fairmont Press ).
40. Hughes, Thomas (1987) 'The Evolution of Large Technological Systems', in W. Bijker, T. Hughes & T. Pinch (eds), The Social Constructions of Technological Systems (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press). 51-82.
41. Hughes, Thomas (1993) Networks of Power: Electrification in Western Society, 1880-1930 ( Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press ).
42. Jones, Gareth (1978) 'The Oil Fuel Market in Britain 1900-14 - A Lost Cause Revisited', Business History 20 (2). 131-52.
43. Kline, Ronald & Trevor Pinch (1996) 'Users as Agents of Technological Change: The Social Construction of the Automobile in the Rural United States', Technology and Culture 37 (4). 763-95.
44. Kovarik, Bill (1998) 'Henry Ford, Charles F. Kettering and the Fuel of the Future', Automotive History Review 32: 7-27.
45. Kovarik, Bill (2003) 'Ethyl: The 1920s Environmental Conflict over Leaded Gasoline and Alternative Fuels', Paper to the American Society for Environmental History, Annual Conference (26-30 March), Providence, RI, available at
46. Kovarik, Bill (2005) 'Ethyl-leaded Gasoline: How a Classic Occupational Disease Became an International Public Health Disaster', International Journal of Environmental Health 11 (4). 384-397.
47. Libecap, Gary (1989) 'The Political Economy of Crude Oil Cartelization in the United States, 1933-1972', Journal of Economic History 49 (4). 833-55.
48. Long, J.H. (1906) 'The Question of Tax-free Alcohol', Science 23 (580). 234-35.
49. McCarthy, Tom (2001) 'The Coming Wonder? Foresight and Early Concerns about the Automobile', Environmental History 6 (1). 46-74.
50. McMillen, Wheeler (1946) New Riches from the Soil: The Progress of Chemurgy ( New York: D. Van Nostrand ).
51. Meikle, Jeffrey (1995) American Plastic: A Cultural History ( New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press ).
52. Nelson, Derek (1995) Moonshiners Bootleggers and Rumrunners ( Osceola, WI: Motorbooks International ).
53. North, Sydney (1911) Oil Fuel: Its Supply, Composition and Application ( London: Griffin ).
54. Pahl, Greg (2005) Biodiesel: Growing a New Energy Economy ( White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green Publishing ).
55. Painter, David (1984) 'Oil and the Marshall Plan', Business History Review 58 (3). 359-83.
56. Pines, Clifton (1931) 'The Story of Alcohol', American Journal of Police Science 2 (6). 500-08.
57. Popular Mechanics (1933) 'Miracles from Test Tubes', Popular Mechanics 60 (October). 488-92.
58. Popular Mechanics (1934) 'The Miracles of Chemurgy', Popular Mechanics 61 (April). 506-09.
59. Robert, Joseph (1983) Ethyl: A History of the Corporation and the People Who Made It ( Charlottesville, VA: University Press of Virginia ).
60. Santos, Joseph (2006) 'Going Against the Grain: Why did Wheat Marketing in the United States and Canada Evolve so Differently?' unpublished manuscript, Department of Economics, South Dakota State University, available at
61. Schurr, Sam & Bruce Netschert (1960) Energy in the American Economy 1850-1975 ( Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press ).
62. Science News Letter (1928) 'Alcohol and Bitumen Sands for Power', Science News Letter 14 (391). 209-10.
63. Science News Letter (1933) 'Alcohol-Gasoline Mixture Suggested as Motor Fuel', Science News Letter 23 (620). 116.
64. Science News Letter (1936) 'Power-alcohol Plant Now in Commercial Production', Science News Letter 30 (809). 237.
65. Shah, Sonia (2004) Crude: The Story of Oil ( New York: Seven Stories Press ).
66. Shideler, James (1976) Farm Crisis, 1919-1923 ( New York: Greenwood Press ).
67. Sorel, Ernest (1907) Carbureting and Combustion in Alcohol Engines ( New York: John Wiley and Sons ).
68. Steen, Kathryn (2001) 'Patents, Patriotism, and "Skilled in the Art": USA v. The Chemical Foundation, Inc., 1923-26', Isis 92 (1). 91-122.
69. Taylor, Charles (1985) Internal Combustion Engine in Theory and Practice, vol. 2, revised edition ( Cambridge, MA: MIT Press ).
70. Terzian, Pierre (1991) 'The Gulf Crisis: The Oil Factor - An Interview with Pierre Terzian', Journal of Palestine Studies 20 (2). 100-05.
71. Thaysen, Aage, William Bakes & Brian Green (1929) 'On the Nature of the Carbohydrates Found in the Jerusalem Artichoke', Biochemical Journal 23 (3). 444-55.
72. Tunison, B. (1920) 'The Future of Industrial Alcohol', Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 12 (4). 370-76.
73. Whelpton, P.K. (1933) 'Alcoholized Gasoline Approved in Tests', Science News Letter 23: 631: 301-02.
74. Whitaker, M.C. (1925) 'Alcohol for Power', Lecture given to Chemists Club, New York (30 September).
75. White, David (1920) 'The Petroleum Resources of the World', Academy of Political and Social Science Annals 89: 111-34.
76. Williamson, H. & A. Daum (1959) The American Petroleum Industry: The Age of Illumination, 1859-1899 ( Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press ).
77. Wik, Reynold (1962) 'Henry Ford's Science and Technology for Rural America', Technology and Culture 3 (3). 247-58.
78. Winner, Langdon (1999) 'Do Artifacts have Politics?' in Donald MacKenzie & Judy Wajcman (eds), The Social Shaping of Technology, second edition (Philadelphia, PA: Open University Press). 28-41.
79. Winters, Paul (2007) 'Industrial Biotechnology Is Revolutionizing the Production of Ethanol Transportation Fuel', Biotechnology Industry Organization, Washington, DC, available at
80. Wright, David (1993) 'Alcohol Wrecks a Marriage: The Farm Chemurgic Movement and the USDA in the Alcohol Fuels Campaign in the Spring of 1933', Agricultural History 67 (1). 36-66.
81. Wright, David (1995) 'Agricultural Editors Wheeler McMillen and Clifford V. Gregory and the Farm Chemurgic Movement', Agricultural History 69 (2). 272-87.
82. Wright, F.B. (1907) A Practical Handbook on the Distillation of Alcohol from Farm Products, second edition ( New York: Camelot Press ).
83. Yale Law Journal (1939) 'A Possible Extension of the Scope of the Patent Monopoly', Yale Law Journal 48 (6). 1089-95.
84. Yergin, Daniel (1991) The Prize: The Epic Quest for Oil Money and Power ( New York: Simon and Schuster ).