The Akilia controversy: Field, structural and geochronological evidence questions interpretations of >3.8 Ga life in SW Greenland

Journal of the Geological Society

Volumn 166, Issue 2, 2009, Pages 335-348

  Whitehouse, Martin J ^a   Myers, John S ^b   Fedo, Christopher M ^c  

^a SWEDISH MUSEUM OF NATURAL HISTORY   (Sweden)

^b CURTIN UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

^c UNIVERSITY OF TENNESSEE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

APATITE; ARCHEAN; BIOGENIC DEPOSIT; DEFORMATION MECHANISM; GEOCHRONOLOGY; GNEISS; PROTOLITH; RECRYSTALLIZATION; TECTONIC SETTING; URANIUM-LEAD DATING; ZIRCON;

ARCTIC; GREENLAND;

EID: 66249105742     PISSN: 00167649     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1144/0016-76492008-070     Document Type: Article

References (61)

1. Appel, P.W.U., Fedo, C.M., Moorbath, S. & Myers, J.S. 1998. Recognizable primary volcanic and sedimentary features in a low-strain domain of the highly deformed, oldest known (~ 3.7-3.8 Gyr) Greenstone Belt, Isua: West Greenland. Terra Nova, 10, 57-62.
2. Baadsgaard, H. 1976. Further U-Pb dates on zircons from the Early Precambrian rocks of the Godthaabsfjord area, West Greenland. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 33, 261-267.
3. Baadsgaard, H., Lambert, R.S. & Krupicka, J. 1976. Mineral isotopic age relationships in the polymetamorphic Amîtsoq gneisses, Godthaab District, West Greenland. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 40, 513-527.
4. Bennett, V.C., Nutman, A.P. & McCulloch, M.T. 1993. Nd isotopic evidence for transient, highly depleted mantle reservoirs in the early history of the Earth. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 119, 299-317.
5. Black, L.P., Gale, N.H., Moorbath, S., Pankhurst, R.J. & McGregor, V.R. 1971. Isotopic dating of the very early Precambrian amphibolite gneisses from the Godthaab District, West Greenland. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 12, 245-249.
6. Bridgwater, D., Keto, L., McGregor, V.R. & Myers, J.S. 1976. Archaeangneiss complex of Greenland. In: Escher, A. & Watt, W.S. (eds) Geology of Greenland. Grønlands Geologiske Undersøgelse, Copenhagen, 18-75.
7. Bridgwater, D., Allaart, J.H., Schopf, J.W., et al. 1981. Microfossil-like objects from the Archaean of Greenland: a cautionary note. Nature, 289, 51-53.
8. Chadwick, B. & Coe, K. 1983. Descriptive text to the 1:100 000 sheet Buksefjorden 63V. 1 Nord. Grønlands Geologiske Undersøgelse, Copenhagen.
9. Cherniak, D.J., Lanford, W.A. & Ryerson, F.J. 1991. Lead diffusion in apatite and zircon using ion implantation and Rutherford backscattering techniques. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 55, 1663-1673.
10. Cliff, R.A. 1985. Isotopic dating in metamorphic belts. Journal of the Geological Society, London, 142, 97-110.
11. Corfu, F., Hanchar, J.H., Hoskin, P.W.O. & Kinny, P. 2003. Atlas of Zircon Textures. In: Hanchar, J.M. & Hoskin, P.W.O. (eds) Zircon. Mineralogical Society of America, Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry, 53, 469-500.
12. Dauphas, N., van Zuilen, M., Wadhwa, M., Davis, A.M., Marty, B. & Janney, P.E. 2004. Clues from Fe isotope variations on the origin of Early Archean BIFs from Greenland. Science, 306, 2077-2080.
13. Dauphas, N., van Zuilen, M., Busigny, V., Lepland, A., Wadhwa, M. & Janney, P.E. 2007. Iron isotope, major and trace element characterization of Early Archean supracrustal rocks from SW Greenland: Protolith identification and metamorphic overprint. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 71, 4745-4770.
14. Dymek, R.F. & Klein, C. 1988. Chemistry, petrology, and origin of banded iron formation lithologies from the 3800 Ma Isua Supracrustal Belt: West Green-land. Precambrian Research, 39, 247-302.
15. Fedo, C.M. & Whitehouse, M.J. 2002. Metasomatic origin of quartz-pyroxene rock, Akilia, Greenland, and implications for Earth's earliest life. Science, 296,1448-1452.
16. Fedo, C.M., Myers, J.S. & Appel, P.W.U. 2001. Depositional setting and paleogeographic implications of Earth's oldest supracrustal rocks, the >3.7 Ga Isua Greenstone Belt: West Greenland. Sedimentary Geology, 141-142, 61-78.
17. Fedo, C.M., Whitehouse, M.J. & Kamber, B.S. 2006. Geological constraints on detecting the earliest life on Earth: a perspective from the Early Archaean (>3.7 Ga) of Southwest Greenland. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B, 361, 851-867.
18. Frei, R., Bridgwater, D., Rosing, M. & Stecher, O. 1999. Controversial Pb-Pb and Sm-Nd isotope results in the early Archean Isua (West Greenland) oxide iron formation: Preservation of primary signatures versus secondary disturbances. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 63, 473-488.
19. Fries, M. & Steele, A. 2008. Graphite whiskers in CV3 meteorites. Science, 320, 91-93.
20. Garde, A.A. 1997. Accretion and evolution of an Archaean high-grade grey gneiss-amphibolite complex: the Fiskefjord area, southern West Greenland. Geology of Greenland Survey Bulletin, 177.
21. Griffin, W.L., McGregor, V.R., Nutman, A., Taylor, P.N. & Bridgwater, D. 1980. Early Archaean granulite-facies metamorphism south of Ameralik, West Greenland. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 50, 59-74.
22. 40Ar in hornblende. Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, 78, 324-331.
23. Kalsbeek, F., Bridgwater, D. & Boak, J. 1980. Evidence of mid-Proterozoic granite formation in the Isua area. Rapport Grønlands Geologiske Undersøgelse, 100, 73-75.
24. Kamber, B.S. & Moorbath, S. 1998. Initial Pb of the Amîtsoq gneiss revisited: implication for the timing of early Archaean crustal evolution in West Greenland. Chemical Geology, 150, 19-41.
25. Kramers, J.D. & Tolstikhin, I.N. 1997. Two major terrestrial Pb isotope paradoxes, forward transport modelling, core formation and the history of the continental crust. Chemical Geology, 139, 75-110.
26. Krogh, T.E., Kamo, S.L. & Kwok, Y.Y. 2002. An isotope dilution, etch abrasion solution to the Akilia Island U-Pb age controversy. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, Supplement 1, 64, A419.
27. Lepland, A., Arrhenius, G. & Cornell, D. 2002. Apatite in early Archean Isua supracrustal rocks, southern West Greenland: its origin, association with graphite and potential as a biomarker. Precambrian Research, 118, 221-241.
28. Lepland, A., van Zuilen, M.A., Arrhenius, G.A., Whitehouse, M.J. & Fedo, C.M. 2005. Questioning the evidence for Earth's earliest life: Akilia revisited. Geology, 33, 77-79.
29. Manning, C.E., Mojzsis, S.J. & Harrison, T.M. 2006. Geology, age and origin of supracrustal rocks, Akilia, Greenland. American Journal of Science, 306, 303-366.
30. McGregor, V.R. & Mason, B. 1977. Petrogenesis and geochemistry of metabasaltic and metasedimentary enclaves in the Amîtsoq gneisses, West Greenland. American Mineralogist, 62, 887-904.
31. McKeegan, K.D., Kudryavtsev, A.B. & Schopf, J.W. 2007. Raman and ion microscopic imagery of graphitic inclusions in apatite from older than 3830 Ma Akilia supracrustal rocks, west Greenland. Geology, 35, 591-594.
32. McKeegan, K.D., Kudryavtsev, A.B. & Schopf, J.W. 2008. Raman and ion microscopic imagery of graphitic inclusions in apatite from older than 3830 Ma Akilia supracrustal rocks, west Greenland: Reply. Geology, 36, doi:10.1130/G24987Y.1.
33. Mojzsis, S.J. & Harrison, T.M. 2000. Vestiges of a beginning: Clues to the emergent biosphere recorded in the oldest known sedimentary rocks. GSA Today, 10, 1-6.
34. Mojzsis, S.J. & Harrison, T.M. 2002. Establishment of a 3.83 Ga magmatic age for the Akilia tonalite (southern West Greenland). Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 202, 563-576.
35. Mojzsis, S.J., Arrhenius, G., McKeegan, K.D, Harrison, T.M., Nutman, A.P. & Friend, C.R.L. 1996. Evidence for life on Earth before 3800 million years ago. Nature, 384, 55-59.
36. Mojzsis, S.J., Harrison, T.M., Arrhenius, G., McKeegan, K.D. & Grove, M. 1999. Origin of life from apatite dating? Nature, 400, 127-128.
37. Moorbath, S. & Kamber, B.S. 1998. Re-appraisal of the age of the oldest water-lain sediments, West Greenland: Significance for the existence of life on the early Archaean Earth. In: Chela-Flores, J. & Raulin, F. (eds) Exobiology: Matter, Energy and Information in the Origin and Evolution of Life in the Universe. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 81-86.
38. Myers, J.S. 2001. Protoliths of the 3.8-3.7 Ga Isua Greenstone Belt, West Greenland. Precambrian Research, 105, 129-141.
39. Myers, J.S. 2004. Isua illusions: illusive tectonic, sedimentary, volcanic and organic features of the >3.8->3.7 Ga Isua greenstone belt, south-west Greenland. In: Eriksson, P., Altermann, W., Nelson, D., Mueller, W. & Catuneaunu, O. (eds) The Precambrian Earth: Tempos and Events. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 66-74.
40. Myers, J.S. & Crowley, J.L. 2000. Vestiges of life in the oldest Greenland rocks? A review of early Archaean geology of the Godthåbsfjord region, and reappraisal of field evidence for >3850 Ma life on Akilia. Precambrian Research, 103, 101-124.
41. Nutman, A.P. 2007. Apatite recrystallisation during prograde metamorphism, Cooma, southeast Australia: implications for using an apatite-graphite association as a biotracer in ancient metasedimentary rocks. Australian Journal of Earth Sciences, 54, 1023-1032.
42. Nutman, A.P. & Friend, C.R.L. 2006. Petrography and geochemistry of apatites in banded iron formation, Akilia, W. Greenland: Consequences for oldest life evidence. Precambrian Research, 147, 100-106.
43. Nutman, A.P. & Friend, C.R.L. 2007. Adjacent terranes with c. 2715 and 2650 Ma high-pressure metamorphic assemblages in the Nuuk region of the North Atlantic Craton, southern West Greenland: Complexities of Neoarchaean collisional orogeny. Precambrian Research, 155, 159-203.
44. Nutman, A.P., McGregor, V.R., Friend, C.R.L., Bennett, V.C. & Kinny, P.D. 1996. The Itsaq Gneiss Complex of southern West Greenland; the world's most extensive record of early crustal evolution 3900-3600 Ma. Precambrian Research, 78, 1-39.
45. Nutman, A.P., Mojzsis, S.J. & Friend, C.R.L. 1997. Recognition of ≥3850 Ma water-lain sediments in West Greenland and their significance for the early Archaean Earth. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 61, 2475-2484.
46. Nutman, A.P., Friend, C.R.L., Bennett, V.C. & McGregor, V.R. 2004. Dating of the Ameralik dyke swarms of the Nuuk district, southern West Greenland: mafic intrusion events starting from c. 3510 Ma. Journal of the Geological Society, London, 161, 421-430.
47. Pankhurst, R.J., Moorbath, S., Rex, D.C. & Turner, G. 1973. Mineral age patterns in c. 3700 My old rocks from West Greenland. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 20, 156-170.
48. Papineau, D., Fogel, M.L., Cody, G.D., et al. 2008. Graphite associated with apatite in the ~3.83 Ga quartz-pyroxene rock from Akilia, Southwest Greenland. Astrobiology, 8, 412.
49. Pflug, H.D. & Jaeschke-Boyer, H. 1979. Combined structural and chemical analysis of 3,800-Myr-old microfossils. Nature, 280, 483-486.
50. Rosholt, J.N., Zartman, R.E. & Nkomo, I.T. 1973. Lead isotope systematics and uranium depletion in the Granite Mountains, Wyoming. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 84, 989-1002.
51. 13C-depleted carbon microparticles in >3700 Ma sea-floor sedimentary rocks from West Greenland. Science, 283, 674-676.
52. Sano, Y., Terada, K., Takahasho, Y. & Nutman, A.P. 1999. Origin of life from apatite dating? Nature, 400, 127.
53. 9-yr-old Isua sediments, West Green-land: implications for the Archaean carbon and oxygen cycles. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 43, 189-199.
54. Söderlund, U., Möller, C., Andersson, J., Johansson, L. & Whitehouse, M. 2002. Zircon geochronology in polymetamorphic gneisses in the Sveconorwe-gian orogen, SW Sweden: ion microprobe evidence for 1.46-1.42 and 0.98-0.96 Ga reworking. Precambrian Research, 113, 193-225.
55. Spear, F.S. & Pyle, J.M. 2002. Apatite, monazite, and xenotime in metamorphic rocks. In: Kohn, M.J., et al. (eds) Phosphates-Geochemical, Geobiological, and Materials Importance. Mineralogical Society of America, Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry, 48, 293-335.
56. van Zuilen, M.A., Lepland, A. & Arrhenius, G. 2002. Reassessing the evidence for the earliest traces of life. Nature, 418, 627-630.
57. White, R.V., Crowley, J.L., Parrish, R. & David, K. 2000. Gate-crashing the billionth birthday party: intrusion of dyke swarms in the Isua region. EOS Transactions, AGU, 81(48), Abstract V51-05.
58. Whitehouse, M.J. & Fedo, C.M. 2003. Deformation features and critical field relationships of early Archaean rocks, Akilia, southwest Greenland. Precambrian Research, 126, 259-271.
59. Whitehouse, M.J. & Kamber, B. 2005. Assigning dates to thin gneissic veins in high-grade metamorphic terranes: a cautionary tale from Akilia, southwest Greenland. Journal of Petrology, 46, 291-318.
60. Whitehouse, M.J., Kamber, B.S. & Moorbath, S. 1999. Age significance of U-Th-Pb zircon data from early Archaean rocks of west Greenland-a reassessment based on combined ion-microprobe and imaging studies. Chemical Geology, 160, 201-224.
61. Whitehouse, M.J., Kamber, B.S., Fedo, C.M. & Lepland, A. 2005. Integrated Pb- and S-isotope investigation of sulphide minerals from the early Archaean of southwest Greenland. Chemical Geology, 222, 112-131.