SCOPUS 정보 검색 플랫폼

Journal of Law and Society

Volumn 36, Issue 1, 2009, Pages 55-74

Environmental justice imperatives for an era of climate change

(1) Stallworthy, Mark a

a SWANSEA UNIVERSITY (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 60949088571 PISSN: 0263323X EISSN: 14676478 Source Type: Journal
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-6478.2009.00456.x Document Type: Article

Times cited : (18)

References (34)

1
- 60949089133
- See N. Stern, Economic Impacts of Climate Change (2006). World Commission for Environment and Development (WCED), Our Common Future (The Brundtland Report) (1987). For a contextual treatment of a national vulnerability within, and responsibility beyond, see K. Dunion and E. Scandreth, 'The Campaign for Environmental Justice in Scotland as a Response to Poverty in a Northern Nation' in Just Sustainabilities - Development in an Unequal World, eds. J. Agyeman et al. (2003).
- J. Diamond, Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Survive (2006) 433, 509.
- (2006) Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Survive , vol.433 , pp. 509
- Diamond, J.¹

2
- 85055295502
- Pursuing "environmental Justice": The Distributional Effects of Environmental Protection
- 847. A. Dobson, Justice and the Environment - Conceptions of Environmental Sustainability and Theories of Distributional Justice (1998) 13. D. Schlosberg, Defining Environmental Justice: Theories, Movements, and Nature (2007) ch. 2. For a discussion of such 'next generation' discourse in respect of disadvantaged communities in the face of climate change, see
- R.J. Lazarus Pursuing "Environmental Justice": the Distributional Effects of Environmental Protection 1993) 87 Northwestern University Law Rev. 787, 847.
- (1993) Northwestern University Law Rev. , vol.87 , pp. 787
- Lazarus, R.J.¹

3
- 44949199183
- Just Solutions and Climate Change: A Climate Justice Proposal for a Domestic Clean Development Mechanism
- Elaborated in Beck's exposition of reflexive modernization: U. Beck, World Risk Society (1998); also, in the present context, What is Globalization? (2000) 38-42. B. Barry, 'The Ethics of Resource Depletion' in Liberty and Justice: Essays in Political Theory, ed. B. Barry (1991). A key theme of Stern, op. cit., n. 4, who concluded the need for a nominal (0.1 per cent) discount rate; compare more traditional approaches, for example
- M. Burkett Just Solutions and Climate Change: a Climate Justice Proposal for a Domestic Clean Development Mechanism 2008) 52 Buffalo Law Rev 169.
- (2008) Buffalo Law Rev , vol.52 , pp. 169
- Burkett, M.¹

4
- 35348986834
- Ethics of the Discount Rate in the Stern Review of the Economics of Climate Change
- and., emphasizing the ethics of maximizing of preferences by social institutions.
- W. Beckerman and C. Hepburn Ethics of the Discount Rate in the Stern Review of the Economics of Climate Change 2007) 8 World Economics 187
- (2007) World Economics , vol.8 , pp. 187
- Beckerman, W.¹ Hepburn, C.²

5
- 78650940694
- The Case for Climate Compensation: Justice for Climate Change Victims in a Complex World
- T. Athanasiou and P. Bayer, Dead Heat - Global Justice and Global Warming (2002) 73-5. For example
- D. A. Farber The Case for Climate Compensation: Justice for Climate Change Victims in a Complex World 2008) Utah Law Rev. 11, 393 7.
- (2008) Utah Law Rev. , vol.11 , pp. 393-7
- Farber, D.A.¹

6
- 84951419547
- The Shallow and the Deep, Long-range Ecology Movement: A Summary
- ; C.D. Stone, Earth and Other Ethics: The Case for Moral Pluralism (1987). D.A. Farber, Eco-Pragmatism: Making Sensible Environmental Decisions in an Uncertain World (1999).
- A. Naess The Shallow and the Deep, Long-range Ecology Movement: a Summary 1973) 16 Inquiry 95
- (1973) Inquiry , vol.16 , pp. 95
- Naess, A.¹

7
- 0000036035
- Technology Assessment and the Fourth Discontinuity: The Limits of Instrumental Rationality
- Dividing lines may however be blurring: James Lovelock's Gaia theory posits the earth as an organic functioning self-regulating system, in which all species, whilst they survive, play a part, and is a fundamentally ecological perspective: Gaia: a New Look at Life on Earth (1979); he has more recently called for investment in nuclear power, on grounds of urgency and lack of alternative: The Revenge of Gaia: Why the Earth is Fighting Back - and How We Can Still Save Humanity (2006). For instance, K. Shrader-Frechette, Environmental Justice: Creating Equality, Reclaiming Democracy (2002); note that distinctions with substantive review are not always clear-cut
- L. Tribe Technology Assessment and the Fourth Discontinuity: the Limits of Instrumental Rationality 1973) 46 Southern California Law Rev. 617.
- (1973) Southern California Law Rev. , vol.46 , pp. 617
- Tribe, L.¹

8
- 34247608574
- Is There a There in Environmental Law?
- 239. See T. Prosser, 'Democratisation, Accountability and Institutional Design: Reflections on Public Law' in Law, Legitimacy and the Constitution, eds. P. McAuslan and J. McEldowney (1985). For a critique of purportedly 'neutral' processes within environmental policy and rule making, see R. Kuehn, 'The Environmental Justice Implications of Qualitative Risk Assessment' (1996) University of Illinois Law Rev. 103. Where public interest outcomes are also not guaranteed: see
- A. Dan Tarlock Is There a There in Environmental Law? 2004) 19 Land Use and Environmental Law Rev. 213
- (2004) Land Use and Environmental Law Rev. , vol.19 , pp. 213
- Dan Tarlock, A.¹

9
- 0003311064
- The Environmental Justice Misfit and the Paradigm Paradox
- Such as the effect of sea level rise on vulnerable populations on low-lying territories, such as Bangladesh (Bay of Bengal) and the Tuvalu and other island communities (Southern Pacific and elsewhere): see M. Lynas, High Tide (2005) especially ch. 3. For instance under the dispute settlement process of the World Trade Organization: see EC - Biotech Products (DS291/292/293, 26 September 2006), where questions arose as to the compatibility with WTO rules of localized precautionary approaches to the regulation of genetically modified organisms. M. Sagoff, The Economy of the Earth: Philosophy, Law and Economics (1998) 16-17.
- E. Gauna The Environmental Justice Misfit and the Paradigm Paradox 1998) 17 Stanford Environmental Law J. 3.
- (1998) Stanford Environmental Law J. , vol.17 , pp. 3
- Gauna, E.¹

10
- 0005997121
- Levelling the Playing Field through Environmental Justice
- R.D. Bullard Levelling the Playing Field through Environmental Justice 1999) 23 Vermont Law Rev. 453.
- (1999) Vermont Law Rev. , vol.23 , pp. 453
- Bullard, R.D.¹

11
- 0348195613
- Justice from the Ground Up: Distributive Inequities, Grassroots Resistance, and the Transformative Politics of the Environmental Justice Movement
- D. Pellow and R.J. Brulle, 'Power, Justice, and the Environment: Toward Critical Environmental Justice Studies' in Power, Justice, and the Environment: a Critical Appraisal of the Environmental Justice Movement, eds. D. Pellow and R.J. Brulle (2005) ch. 1. As expressed in the need for ecological communication in seeking sustainable solutions
- S. Foster Justice from the Ground Up: Distributive Inequities, Grassroots Resistance, and the Transformative Politics of the Environmental Justice Movement 1998) 86 California Law Rev. 115, 835.
- (1998) California Law Rev. , vol.86 , Issue.115 , pp. 835
- Foster, S.¹

12
- 84937298225
- Political and Ecological Communication
- ; similarly, 'practical engagement with the world we inhabit': T. Benton, 'Ecology, Community and Justice' in Justice, Property and the Environment, eds. T. Hayward and J. O'Neill (1997). M. Bookchin, Toward an Ecological Society (1980). B. Lomborg, The Skeptical Environmentalist: Measuring the State of the World (2001). Stern, op. cit., n. 4, p. 211, concluding that immediate, effective action might involve annual global costs at around 1 per cent of GDP, in default of which such figure would shortly rise to 5-20 per cent. D.A. Farber and D. McCarthy, 'Neoliberalism, Globalization, and the Struggle for Ecological Democracy: Linking Sustainability and Environmental Justice' in Agyeman, op. cit., n. 6.
- J. Dryzeck Political and Ecological Communication 1995) 4 Environmental Politics 13
- (1995) Environmental Politics , vol.4 , pp. 13
- Dryzeck, J.¹

13
- 84925053118
- 'Reclaiming" Environmental Law: A Normative Critique of Comparative Risk Analysis
- D.T. Hornstein 'Reclaiming" Environmental Law: a Normative Critique of Comparative Risk Analysis 1992) 92 Colorado Law Rev. 562.
- (1992) Colorado Law Rev. , vol.92 , pp. 562
- Hornstein, D.T.¹

14
- 33645299546
- Debiasing through Law
- and., seeking to limit 'boundedly rational' behaviour without 'aggressive regulation', by altering people's 'perceptions of the world around them'. Such as projection bias (relating future expectations to the here and now), unrealistic optimism (the future will take care of itself) or simple myopia (with judgement on hold).
- C. Jolls and C. R. Sunstein Debiasing through Law 2006) 35 J. of Legal Studies 199, 202 03, 234
- (2006) J. of Legal Studies , vol.35 , Issue.199 , pp. 202-203
- Jolls, C.¹ Sunstein, C.R.²

15
- 44849130548
- Willingness to Pay versus Welfare
- With reference to 'choice architecture': R.H. Thaler and C.R. Sunstein, Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness (2008). 31 ILM 851 (1992). 37 ILM 22 (1998). Based upon commitments to emissions reductions by developed (Annex I) states, these enable markets to generate credits, earned as Emissions Reduction Units under Joint Implementation ('purchasing' emissions reductions in other developed states) and Certified Emission Reductions under the Clean Development Mechanism (in respect of reductions in developing states).
- C.R. Sunstein Willingness to Pay versus Welfare 2007) 1 Harvard Law & Policy Rev. 303, 324 30.
- (2007) Harvard Law & Policy Rev. , vol.1 , Issue.303 , pp. 324-30
- Sunstein, C.R.¹

16
- 52949151964
- Reframing the Climate Change Challenge in Light of post-2000 Emission Trends
- and. For a discussion of the EU's nascent regional steps toward furthering 'international environmental equity', see P.G. Harris, 'The European Union and Environmental Change: Sharing the Burdens of Global Warming' (2006) Colorado J. of International Environmental Law and Policy 309. R. Eckersley, The Green State: Rethinking Democracy and Sovereignty (2004). For example, the United Kingdom's Climate Change Act 2008, purporting to impose legally binding domestic targets, supported by transparent budgeting and reporting processes. For a discussion of the role of developing states, see Stern, op. cit., n. 54, ch. 3.
- K. Anderson and A. Bows Reframing the Climate Change Challenge in Light of post-2000 Emission Trends 2008) 366 Philosophical Transactions 3863.
- (2008) Philosophical Transactions , vol.366 , pp. 3863
- Anderson, K.¹ Bows, A.²

17
- 60949091109
- Self Control, Individual Choice, and Climate Change
- Schlosberg, op. cit., n. 9. J. Barry, Green Political Thought (1999). For example, A. Sen, 'Capacity and Well-Being' in The Quality of Life, eds. M. Nussbaum and A. Sen (1992). See Massachusetts et al. v. Environmental Protection Agency, 127 S.Ct. 1438, U.S. (2007). See, further, J. Holder, Environmental Assessment - The Regulation of Decision-Making (2004). UN Economic Commission for Europe, Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in Decision-Making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters, DOC. ECE-CEP-43 (1998).
- A. Green Self Control, Individual Choice, and Climate Change 2008) 26 Virginia Environmental Law J. 77.
- (2008) Virginia Environmental Law J. , vol.26 , pp. 77
- Green, A.¹

18
- 33748746038
- The Usual Suspects? Public Participation under the Aarhus Convention
- and. who also discern 'little to encourage more general public involvement'. R (on the application of Greenpeace) v. Secretary of State for Trade and Industry [2007] EWHC 311. See Office for Science and Technology, Foresight Flood and Coastal Defence Project: Future Flooding (2004).
- M. Lee and C. Abbot The Usual Suspects? Public Participation under the Aarhus Convention 2003) 61 Modern Law Rev. 80.
- (2003) Modern Law Rev. , vol.61 , pp. 80
- Lee, M.¹ Abbot, C.²

19
- 60949084375
- Pursuing Substantial Environmental Justice: The Aarhus Convention as a Pillar of Empowerment
- Compare an acknowledgement of 'an issue of distributional equity where a few individuals lose their home and all their security whilst others elsewhere are protected': Defra, Flood Management Division, Background Paper, Payment of Compensation, Relocation, and Other Issues in relation to Flood and Coastal Erosion Risk Management (2004) para. 35; note that the Chancellor's Autumn 2007 pre-budget statement contained an ex gratia Treasury allocation (£10m) for assisting in adaptation to climate change on the part of vulnerable communities.
- C. Nadal Pursuing Substantial Environmental Justice: the Aarhus Convention as a Pillar of Empowerment 2008) 10 Environmental Law Rev. 28.
- (2008) Environmental Law Rev. , vol.10 , pp. 28
- Nadal, C.¹

20
- 84937385463
- Participation and Deliberation in Environmental Law - Exploring a Problem-Solving Approach
- J. Steele Participation and Deliberation in Environmental Law - Exploring a Problem-Solving Approach 2001) 21 Oxford J. of Legal Studies 415.
- (2001) Oxford J. of Legal Studies , vol.21 , pp. 415
- Steele, J.¹

21
- 33750479005
- Sustainability, Coastal Erosion and Climate Change: An Environmental Justice Analysis
- R.D. Bullard, Environmental Justice for All (1994) ch. 1. J. Steele, Risks and Legal Theory (2004) 203, referring to geographical 'hotspots'. In the context of the underlying conflict between control and expropriation (compensable and non-compensable forms of acquisition): see R (Trailer and Marine (Leven) Ltd) v. Secretary of State for the Environment [2005] 1 WLR 1267. See
- M. Stallworthy Sustainability, Coastal Erosion and Climate Change: an Environmental Justice Analysis 2006) 18 J. of Environmental Law 357.
- (2006) J. of Environmental Law , vol.18 , pp. 357
- Stallworthy, M.¹

22
- 0001656306
- Property, Utility and Fairness: Comments on the Ethical Foundations of "just Compensation" Law
- F.I. Michaelman Property, Utility and Fairness: Comments on the Ethical Foundations of "Just Compensation" Law 1967) 80 Harvard Law Rev. 1165.
- (1967) Harvard Law Rev. , vol.80 , pp. 1165
- Michaelman, F.I.¹

23
- 84917293747
- National Preservation and the Race to Develop
- 670 ; W. Howarth, Flood Defence Law (2002) 512 describes the dilemma of determining 'when, if ever, a failure to provide' defence involves expropriation. In particular, conditional rights to respect for home and private life (Art. 8), a fair and impartial public hearing to determine rights and obligations (Art. 6), and peaceful enjoyment of property (Art. 1 of the First Protocol). Any such finding could lead to an award of compensation reasonably relating to property value: see Holy Monasteries v. Greece, judgment of 9 December 2004, Series A no. 301-A, 34-35.
- D.A. Dana National Preservation and the Race to Develop 1995) 143 University of Pennsylvania Law Rev. 655, 670
- (1995) University of Pennsylvania Law Rev. , vol.143 , pp. 655
- Dana, D.A.¹

24
- 0010874996
- Sea Level Rise and Coastal Wetlands: Opportunities for a Peaceful Migration
- points to an aspiration that the public discussion process be complete before threats materialize. A number of eastern seaboard states have adopted a structured approach to equitable discounting of property values, reflecting differential risks, by state legislation placing communities on formal notice as to expectation of realignment: see
- L.A. St Amand Sea Level Rise and Coastal Wetlands: Opportunities for a Peaceful Migration 1991) 19 Boston College Environmental Affairs Law Rev. 1.
- (1991) Boston College Environmental Affairs Law Rev. , vol.19 , pp. 1
- St Amand, L.A.¹

25
- 0347537373
- Coastal Natural Hazards Mitigation: The Erosion of Regulatory Retreat in South Carolina
- E.P. Hawes Coastal Natural Hazards Mitigation: the Erosion of Regulatory Retreat in South Carolina 1998) 7 South Carolina Environmental Law J. 55.
- (1998) South Carolina Environmental Law J. , vol.7 , pp. 55
- Hawes, E.P.¹

26
- 84928839770
- Progressive Law and Economics - And the New Administrative Law
- See E. Fisher, Risk Regulation and Administrative Constitutionalism (2007).
- C. Rose-Ackerman Progressive Law and Economics - and the New Administrative Law 1988) 98 Yale Law J. 341.
- (1988) Yale Law J. , vol.98 , pp. 341
- Rose-Ackerman, C.¹

27
- 30444451274
- Global Warming and Property Interests: Preserving Coastal Wetlands as Sea Levels Rise
- 602.
- R.L. Fischman Global Warming and Property Interests: Preserving Coastal Wetlands as Sea Levels Rise 1991) 19 Hofstra Law Rev. 565, 602.
- (1991) Hofstra Law Rev. , vol.19 , pp. 565
- Fischman, R.L.¹

28
- 53349144705
- Climate Change and the Limits of the Possible
- illustrates by reference to low-density housing and inefficiencies in transport patterns and architecture. Elaborated in a seminal article by
- J. Purdy Climate Change and the Limits of the Possible 2008) 18 Duke Environmental Law & Policy Forum. 289.
- (2008) Duke Environmental Law & Policy Forum. , vol.18 , pp. 289
- Purdy, J.¹

29
- 84935618810
- Reforming Environmental Law
- and. L. Lohmann, 'Carry on Polluting' New Scientist, 2 December 2006; for similar conclusions applied to a domestic stage, G. Monbiot, 'Don't be Fooled by the Climate Change Bill - Carbon Trading Torpedoes It' Guardian, 24 July 2008. For example, Commission Communication, Bringing Our Needs and Responsibilities Together: Integrating Environmental Issues with Economic Policy, COM(2000) 576 final, 20 September 2000. Despite recent events in global financial markets, there continues to be an expectation of growth in secondary markets, and related development of securitized instruments and derivatives, in respect of emissions credits (under the EU Emissions Trading Scheme and CDM): see Financial Services Authority, The Emissions Trading Market: Risks and Challenges (2008).
- B. A. Ackerman and R. B. Stewart Reforming Environmental Law 1985) 37 Stanford Law Rev. 1333.
- (1985) Stanford Law Rev. , vol.37 , pp. 1333
- Ackerman, B.A.¹ Stewart, R.B.²

30
- 38049170960
- The Carbon Neutral Individual
- and. >). D.R. Bell, 'The Case against a Universal Right to Equal Carbon Emissions' in Seeking Environmental Justice, ed. S. Wilkes (2008) 254-5. Either by surrendering transaction by transaction or in a single transaction, in which latter event regulated purchases would thereafter be subject to the equivalent premium at point of sale. Environmental Audit Committee, op. cit., n. 121, paras. 43-5. Defra Synthesis Report, op. cit., n. 122
- M. Vandenbergh and A. C. Steinemann The Carbon Neutral Individual 2007) 82 New York University Law Rev. 1673.
- (2007) New York University Law Rev. , vol.82 , pp. 1673
- Vandenbergh, M.¹ Steinemann, A.C.²

31
- 60949087272
- Using Emissions Trading to Combat Climate Change: Programs and Key Issues
- 10379.
- D. Harrison et al. Using Emissions Trading to Combat Climate Change: Programs and Key Issues 2008) 38 Environmental Law Reporter 10367, 10379.
- (2008) Environmental Law Reporter , vol.38 , pp. 10367
- Harrison, D.¹

32
- 85048771749
- Climate Change and Individual Behaviour: The Equity Problem
- and. Burkett, op. cit., n. 10. R. Starkey and K. Anderson, Domestic Tradable Quotas: A Policy Instrument for Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Energy Use (2005). Environmental Audit Committee, op. cit., n. 121, paras. 84-89.
- M. Vandenbergh and B. Ackerly Climate Change and Individual Behaviour: the Equity Problem 2008) 26 Virginia Environmental Law J. 55.
- (2008) Virginia Environmental Law J. , vol.26 , pp. 55
- Vandenbergh, M.¹ Ackerly, B.²

33
- 0042715443
- Global Environmental Regulation Investment Choice in Legal Context
- D. McLaren, 'Environmental Space, Equity and the Ecological Debt' in Agyeman, op. cit., n. 6, pp. 22-5.
- J.B. Wiener Global Environmental Regulation Investment Choice in Legal Context 1999) 108 Yale Law J. 677.
- (1999) Yale Law J. , vol.108 , pp. 677
- Wiener, J.B.¹

34
- 60949090766
- Is Environmentalism Dead?
- C.D. Stone Is Environmentalism Dead? 2008) 38 Environmental Law 19.
- (2008) Environmental Law , vol.38 , pp. 19
- Stone, C.D.¹

* 이 정보는 Elsevier사의 SCOPUS DB에서 KISTI가 분석하여 추출한 것입니다.