On the danger and necessity of democratisation: Trade-offs between short-term stability and long-term peace in post-genocide Rwanda

Third World Quarterly

Volumn 29, Issue 8, 2008, Pages 1601-1620

  Silva Leander, Sebastian ^a  

^a HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

DEMOCRATIZATION; ETHNICITY; GENOCIDE; PEACEKEEPING; POLITICAL REFORM; TRADE-OFF;

AFRICA; CENTRAL AFRICA; RWANDA; SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA;

EID: 58149377128     PISSN: 01436597     EISSN: 13602241     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/01436590802528754     Document Type: Article

References (94)

1. Jeannette Ayinkamiye (genocide survivor), interviewed by Jean Hatzfeld, in Hatzfeld, La Strategie des Antilopes, Paris: Seuil, 2007.
2. M Bratton & N van de Walle, Democratic Experiments in Africa: Regime Transitions in Comparative Perspective, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997, p 135.
3. P Uvin, Aiding Violence: The Development Enterprise in Rwanda, West Hartford, CT: Kumarian Press, 1998.
4. G Prunier, The Rwanda Crisis: History of a Genocide, London: Hurst, 1995, p 122.
5. African Rights, Rwanda: Death, Despair and Defiance, London: African Rights, 1995.
6. Prunier, The Rwanda Crisis, p 13.
7. F Reyntjens, 'Rwanda: Genocide and beyond', Journal of Refugee Studies, 9 (3), 1996.
8. R Lemarchand, 'Managing transition anarchies: Rwanda, Burundi, and South Africa in contemporary perspective', Journal of Modern African Studies, 32 (4), 1994, pp 581-604.
9. L Kirschke, 'Informal repression, zero-sum politics and late third wave transitions', Journal of Modern African Studies, 38 (3), 2000, pp 383-405.
10. H Adelman & A Suhrke, 'Early warning and conflict management: Genocide in Rwanda', in Evaluation of Emergency Assistance to Rwanda, Second Study, Chr Michelsen Institute, Development Studies and Human Rights, Norway, 1995, p 13.
11. CP Scherrer, 'Genocide and genocide prevention: General outlines exemplified with the cataclysm in Rwanda 1994', COPRI Working Papers 14, 1999, Copenhagen Peace Research Institute.
12. In a survey of rural dwellers, conducted at the beginning of the democratisation process in 1991, less than half of the respondents expressed support for multiparty politics. Dialogue, 1991, cited in Reyntjens, 'Rwanda'.
13. See Reyntjens, 'Rwanda'.
14. P Verwimp, 'Development ideology, the peasantry and genocide: Rwanda represented in Habyarimana's speeches', Journal of Genocide Research 2 (3), 2000, pp 325-361.
15. G Austin, 'The effects of government policy on the ethnic distribution of income and wealth in Rwanda: A review of the published sources', mimeo, Department of Economic History, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1996, p 4.
16. See J Adekanye, 'Rwanda/Burundi: "uni-ethnic" dominance and the cycle of armed ethnic formations', Social Identities: Journal for the Study of Race, Nation and Culture, 2 (1), 1996, p 39.
17. J MacDermott, 'The livelihood conflicts approach on trial in Rwanda: towards a political critique', DESTIN Working Paper Series 01-21, Development Studies Institute, London School of Economics, 2001.
18. P Uvin, 'Prejudice, crisis, and genocide in Rwanda', African Studies Review, 40 (2), 1997, p 101.
19. T Longman, 'Democratization and civil society: The case of Rwanda', in The Democratic Challenge in Africa: Discussion Papers from a Seminar on Democratization, Atlanta, GA: Carter Center of Emory University, 1994, pp 61-69.
20. Uvin, Aiding Violence, p 163.
21. Ibid, p 170.
22. Adelman & Suhrke, 'Early warning and conflict management', p 16.
23. JP Chretien, Rwanda: Les medias du génocide, Paris: Karthala, 1995.
24. Prunier, the Rwanda Crisis, pp 188-189
25. and Uvin, 'Prejudice, crisis, and genocide in Rwanda', p 110.
26. R Andersen, 'How multilateral development assistance triggered the conflict in Rwanda', Third World Quarterly, 21 (3), 2000, p 446.
27. Adelman & Suhrke, 'Early warnng and conflict management', p 17.
28. J Snyder, From Voting to Violence: Democratisation and Nationalist Conflict, New York: WW Norton, 2000.
29. See Reyntjens, 'Rwanda', p 244.
30. J Gasana, 'Factors of ethnic conflict in Rwanda and instruments for a durable peace', mimeo, 1996.
31. C Andre & J-P Plateau, 'Land relations under unbearable stress: Rwanda caught in the Malthusian trap', Centre de Recherche en Economie de Développement, Namur, Belgium, 1995.
32. Médecins sans Frontières, 'Report on events in Kibeho camp', April 1995.
33. United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (UNHCR), Field Operation in Rwanda, 'Update on the Human Rights Situation', 1996.
34. Rwanda. Civilians Trapped in Armed Conflict: 'The Dead can no longer be Counted', London: Amnesty International, 19 December 1997
35. and '"Our brothers who help kill us" - economic exploitation and human rights abuses in the east', Amnesty International, Index AFR 62/010/2003, 1 April 2003.
36. UNHCR, The State of the World's Refugees, New York: Oxford University Press, 1998.
37. 'Rwanda chapter', World Report 2007, Events of 2006, New York: Human Rights Watch, 2007.
38. '"Our brothers who help kill us"'.
39. P Verwimp, 'Testing the double genocide thesis for central and southern Rwanda', Journal of Conflict Resolution, 47, 2003, pp 423-442.
40. P Pean, Noires fureurs, blancs menteurs - Rwanda 1990-1994, Paris: Mille et une nuits, 2005.
41. Report of Special Representative Moussalli, Fifty-fifth session Item 116(c) of the provisional agenda human rights questions: Human rights situations and reports of special rapporteurs and representatives, United Nations, 4 August 2000.
42. C Mgbako, 'Ingando solidarity camps: Reconciliation and political indoctrination in post-genocide Rwanda', Harvard Human Rights Journal 8, 2005, p 209.
43. As A Storey, 'Structural adjustment, state power & genocide: The World Bank & Rwanda', Review of African Political Economy, 28 (89), pp 365-385, points out, it is the strength of the Rwandan state, not its weakness, that enabled the genocide.
44. See also Uvin, 'Prejudice, crisis, and genocide in Rwanda', p 97. The tradition of a strong central state and efficient administrative system in Rwanda dates back to pre-colonial times.
45. J Vansina, L'evolution du royaume rwanda des origines à 1900, Brussels: Royal Academy of Overseas Sciences, 1962, pp 57-73. As Uvin notes, however, the 'relations between the administrative and technical state system and the population in Rwanda were vertical and authoritarian'.
46. P Uvin, 'Development aid and structural violence: The case of Rwanda', in Uvin, The Society for International Development, London: Sage, p 53. In spite of the colossal social disruption caused by the genocide and the subsequent refugee crises, the basic structure of the Rwandan administrative system has remained almost intact since the war.
47. See LH Piron & A McKay, 'Aid in difficult environments: Rwanda case study', Background Paper 4, ODI Study on Poor Performing Countries, London: Overseas Development Institute, March 2004, p 20. The recent administrative decentralisation has not been accompanied by a political decentralisation, and may even have enabled the RPF to strengthen its control over rural areas by placing mid-level public servants in rural areas.
48. M Hertefel, Les clans du Rwanda ancien, Tervuren: Royal Museum for Central Africa, 1971.
49. Reyntjens, 'Rwanda', p 243.
50. C Young, 'The heart of the African conflict zone: Democratization, ethnicity, civil conflict, and the Great Lakes crisis', Annual Review of Political Science, 9, 2006, pp 301-328.
51. P Uvin, 'Ethnicity and power in Burundi and Rwanda: Different paths to mass violence', Comparative Politics, 31 (3), 1999, p 259.
52. International Crisis Group, 'Rwanda at the end of the transition: A necessary political transition', 13 November 2002.
53. MacDermott, 'The livelihood conflicts approach on trial in Rwanda', p 13.
54. F Reyntjens, 'Post-1994 politics in Rwanda: Problematising "liberation" and "democratisation"', Third World Quarterly, 27 (6), 2006, pp 1103-1117.
55. UNHCR, 'Background Paper on the Human Rights Situation in Rwanda', UNHCR Centre for Documentation and Research, Geneva, January 2000.
56. See also European Platform for Conflict Prevention and Transformation, Rwanda Country Survey, The Hague, The Netherlands, 1999.
57. A Gakusi & F Mouzer, De la Révolution Rwandaise à la contre-révolution: Contraintes structurelles et gouvernance 1960-2003 Paris: L'Harmattan, 2003.
58. J Sarkin, 'The tension between justice and reconciliation in Rwanda: politics, human rights, due process and the role of the Gacaca courts in dealing with the genocide', Journal of African Law, 45 (2), 2001, pp 143-172.
59. www.inkiko-gacaca.gov.rw.
60. African Rights, 'Gacaca justice: A shared responsibility', African Rights Report, January 2003.
61. Organisation of African Unity (OAU), Report of the Seven-member International Panel, assembled by the OAU, 2000.
62. E Zorbas, 'Reconciliation in post-genocide Rwanda', African Journal of Legal Studies, 1, 2004, pp 29-52.
63. A Wierzynska, 'Consolidating democracy through transitional justice: Rwanda's Gacaca courts', New York University, 2004, at http://www.law.nyu.edu/journals/lawreview/issues/vol79/no5/NYU508.pdf.
64. M Mamdani, 'When does a settler become a native? Reflections on the colonial roots of citizenship in Equatorial and South Africa', Inaugural Lecture, University of Cape Town, New Series, No 208, May 1998, p 11.
65. Mgbako, 'Ingando solidarity camps', p 223.
66. P Uvin, 'Wake up. Some policy proposals for the international community in Rwanda', unpublished manuscript, Tufts University, 2003.
67. OAU, Report of the Seven-member international panel.
68. Freedom House, Country Report Rwanda, Washington, DC: Freedom House, 2006.
69. According to the organic law governing political organisations, stated objectives of the Forum of Political Parties are to 'reinforc[e] the principle of power sharing; ... educat[e] politicians and other citizens in the culture of considering an opponent not as an enemy but as one to collaborate with through constructive ideas;' and 'allow political organizations' members to restore and strengthen the citizens' confidence in political organizations and politicians.' 'National Democratic Institute Assessment of Rwanda's Pre-Election Political Environment and the Role of Political Parties', 3-11 August 2003.
70. International Crisis Group, 'Rwanda at the end of transition'.
71. Amnesty International, 'Rwanda: Run-up to presidential elections marred by threats and harassment', London, 21 August 2003.
72. NEPAD, 'African peer review mechanism: Country review report on the Republic of Rwanda', November 2005.
73. Human Rights Watch, 'Preparing for the elections: Tightening control in the name of unity', Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, May 2003.
74. Reyntjens, 'Post-1994 politics in Rwanda', p 1107.
75. Human Rights Watch, 'Preparing for the elections'.
76. C Tertsakian, 'Postscript: What future for the defence of human rights in Rwanda?', in André Sibomana (ed), Hope for Rwanda: Conversations with Laure Guilbert and Herve Deguine, Sterling: Pluto Press, 1999.
77. International Crisis Group, 'Rwanda at the end of transition', p 10.
78. Human Rights Watch, 'Rwanda chapter', Human Rights Watch World Report New York: Human Rights Watch, 2007 and previous years.
79. UNDP, 'From recovery to sustainable human development', National Human Development Report Rwanda, New York: United Nations Development Programme, 2007.
80. Reporters Sans Frontières, 2007 Annual Report, Paris: Reporters Sans Frontières, 2007.
81. Swisspeace, 'Rwanda: Trends in conflict and cooperation', Fast Update Rwanda, 5, September-October 2007.
82. HMusahara & C Huggins, 'Land reform, land scarcity and post conflict reconstruction: A case study of Rwanda', Eco-conflicts (African Centre for Technology Studies), 3, (3), 2004, p 279.
83. Mission d'Observation Electoral de l'Union Européenne au Rwanda, 'Rapport final sur l'élection présidentielle et les élections législatives', 2003.
84. Piron & McKay, 'Aid in difficult environments', p 19.
85. Prunier, The Rwanda Crisis.
86. Human Rights Watch, 'Rwanda: Investigate "disappeared" businessman: confer due process rights to arrested generals', press release, New York, 14 August 2007.
87. BBC, 'Concern over Rwanda arrests', 23 February 2000, at http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/653136.stm
88. and BBC, 'Rwanda's former king eyes return', 17 August 2007, at http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/6952304.stm.
89. Gakusi & Mouzer, De la Révolution Rwandaise à la contre-révolution.
90. United Nations Security Council, 'Report of the Panel of Experts on the Illegal Exploitation of Natural Resources and Other Forms of Wealth of the Democratic Republic of the Congo', S/2001/357.
91. See Uvin, Aiding Violence.
92. United Nations Security Council, 'Report of the Panel of Experts on the Illegal Exploitation of Natural Resources and Other Forms of Wealth of the Democratic Republic of the Congo'.
93. Human Rights Watch, 'Renewed crisis in North Kivu', Human Rights Watch, 19 (17), 2007.
94. BBC, 'Behind DR Congo's war games', 19 October 2007, at http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/7053567.stm. This statement echoes a warning professed in 1996 by Adekany: 'for these latest refugee warriors from Rwanda, Goma is a convenient base for training and making preparations for a possible resumption of the civil war, but more appropriately for staging their own "violent homecoming" at a later date. Memories may be short, but it would not be the first time that ethnic refugee guerrillas would be training and preparing for, if not found actually involved in, armed attacks against their home-country.' Adekany, 'Rwanda/Burundi', p 50.