A process for creating multimetric indices for large-scale aquatic surveys

Journal of the North American Benthological Society

Volumn 27, Issue 4, 2008, Pages 878-891

  Stoddard, John L ^a   Herlihy, Alan T ^b   Peck, David V ^a   Hughes, Robert M ^b   Whittier, Thomas R ^b   Tarquinio, Ellen ^c  

^a U S ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY   (United States)

^b OREGON STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c U S ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY   (United States)

Author keywords

Aquatic resource surveys; Benthic macroinvertebrate assemblage; Bioassessment; Ecological indicators; EMAP; IBI; Large scale; Metric evaluation process; Multimetric index; Wadeable Streams Assessment

Indexed keywords

AQUATIC ECOSYSTEM; BIOINDICATOR; CALIBRATION; ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL GRADIENT; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; MACROINVERTEBRATE; PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT; STREAM; TAXONOMY;

NORTH AMERICA; UNITED STATES;

EID: 57649136892     PISSN: 08873593     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1899/08-053.1     Document Type: Article

References (65)

1. ANGERMEIER, P. L., R. A. SMOGOR, AND J. R. STAUFFER. 2000. Regional frameworks and candidate metrics for assessing biotic integrity in Mid-Atlantic Highland streams. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 129:962-981.
2. BAILEY, R. C., R. H. NORRIS, AND T. B. REYNOLDSON. 2004. Bioassessment of freshwater ecosystems: using the reference condition approach. Kluwer Academic Publishers, New York.
3. BARBOUR, M. T., J. GERRITSEN, B. D. SNYDER, AND J. B. STRIBLING. 1999. Rapid bioassessment protocols for use in streams and wadeable rivers. EPA 841/B-99/002. Office of Water, US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC.
4. BARBOUR, M. T., J. B. STRIBLING, AND J. R. KARR. 1995. Multimetric approach for establishing biocriteria and measuring biological condition. Pages 63-77 in W. S. Davis and T. P. Simon (editors). Biological assessment and criteria: tools for water resource planning and decision making. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, Florida.
5. BATES PRINS, S. C., AND E. P. SMITH. 2007. Using biological metrics to score and evaluate sites: a nearest-neighbour reference condition approach. Freshwater Biology 52:98-111.
6. BLOCKSOM, K. A. 2003. A performance comparison of metric scoring methods for a multimetric index for Mid-Atlantic Highlands streams. Environmental Management 31:670-682.
7. BÖHMER, J., C. RAWER-JOST, AND A. ZENKER. 2004. Multimetric assessment of data provided by water managers from Germany: assessment of several different types of stressors with macrozoobenthos communities. Hydrobiologia 516:215-228.
8. BRAMBLETT, R. G., T. R. JOHNSON, A. V. ZALE, AND D. G. HEGGEM. 2005. Development and evaluation of a fish assemblage index of biotic integrity for northwestern Great Plains streams. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 134:624-640.
9. CAO, Y., C. P. HAWKINS, J. OLSON, AND M. A. KOSTERMAN. 2007. Modeling natural environmental gradients improves the accuracy and precision of diatom-based indicators. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 26:566-585.
10. CARLISLE, D. M., M. R. MEADOR, S. R. MOULTON, AND P. M. RUHL. 2007. Estimation and application of indicator values for common macroinvertebrate genera and families of the United States. Ecological Indicators 7:22-23.
11. CHESSMAN, B., S. WILLIAMS, AND C. BESLEY. 2007. Bioassessment of streams with macroinvertebrates: effect of sampled habitat and taxonomic resolution. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 26:546-565.
12. CUFFNEY, T. E., M. D. BILGER, AND A. M. HAIGLER. 2007. Ambiguous taxa: effects on the characterization and interpretation of invertebrate assemblages. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 26:286-307.
13. EUROPEAN COMMISSION. 2000. Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and the Council establishing a framework for the community action in the field of water policy. Directive 2000/60/EC. Official Journal of the European Communities L 327:1-72. (Available from: http://ec.europa.eu/ environment/water/water-framework/index_en.html)
14. FORE, L. S., AND C. GRAFE. 2002. Using diatoms to assess the biological condition of large rivers in Idaho (U.S.A.). Freshwater Biology 47:2015-2037.
15. FORE, L. S., J. R. KARR, AND R. W. WISSEMAN. 1996. Assessing invertebrate responses to human activities: evaluating alternative approaches. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 15:212-231.
16. GANASAN, V., AND R. M. HUGHES. 1998. Application of an index of biological integrity (IBI) to fish assemblages of the rivers Khan and Kshipra (Madhya Pradesh), India. Freshwater Biology 40:367-383.
17. GERTH, W. J., AND A. T. HERLIHY. 2006. Effect of sampling different habitat types in regional macroinvertebrate bioassessment surveys. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 25:501-512.
18. HARRIS, J. H., AND R. SILVEIRA. 1999. Large-scale assessments of river health using an index of biotic integrity with low-diversity fish communities. Freshwater Biology 41:235-252.
19. HERBST, D. B., AND E. L. SILLDORFF. 2006. Comparison of the performance of different bioassessment methods: similar evaluations of biotic integrity from separate programs and procedures. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 25:513-530.
20. HERING, D., C. K. FELD, O. MOOG, AND T. OFENBÖCK. 2006. Cook book for the development of a multimetric index for biological condition of aquatic ecosystems: experiences from the European AQEM and STAR projects and related initiatives. Hydrobiologia 566:311-324.
21. HERING, D., O. MOOG, L. SANDIN, AND P. F. M. VERDONSCHOT. 2004. Overview and application of the AQEM assessment system. Hydrobiologia 516:1-20.
22. HERLIHY, A. T., D. P. LARSEN, S. G. PAULSEN, N. S. URQUHART, AND B. J. ROSENBAUM. 2000. Designing a spatially balanced, randomized site selection process for regional stream surveys: the EMAP Mid-Atlantic Pilot Study. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 63:95-113.
23. HERLIHY, A. T., S. G. PAULSEN, J. VAN SICKLE, J. L. STODDARD, C. P. HAWKINS, AND L. L. YUAN. 2008. Striving for consistency in a national assessment: the challenges of applying a reference condition approach at a continental scale. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27:860-877.
24. HERRICKS, E. E., AND D. J. SCHAEFFER. 1985. Can we optimize biomonitoring? Environmental Management 9:487-492.
25. HILSENHOFF, W. L. 1987. An improved biotic index of organic stream pollution. Great Lakes Entomologist 20:31-40.
26. HUGHES, R. M., P. R. KAUFMANN, A. T. HERLIHY, T. M. KINCAID, L. REYNOLDS, AND D. P. LARSEN. 1998. A process for developing and evaluating indices of fish assemblage integrity. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 55:1618-1631.
27. HUGHES, R. M., AND T. OBERDORFF. 1999. Applications of IBI concepts and metrics to waters outside the United States and Canada. Pages 79-93 in T. P. Simon (editor). Assessing the sustainability and biological integrity of water resources using fish assemblages. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, Florida.
28. HUGHES, R. M., AND D. V. PECK. 2008. Acquiring data for large aquatic resources surveys: the art of compromise among science, logistics, and reality. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27:837-859.
29. HUGHES, R. M., J. L. STODDARD, AND S. G. PAULSEN. 2000. A national, multiassemblage, probability survey of ecological integrity. Hydrobiologia 422/423:429-443.
30. KARR, J. R. 1981. Assessment of biotic integrity using fish communities. Fisheries 6(6):21-27.
31. KARR, J. R., AND E. W. CHU. 2000. Sustaining living rivers. Hydrobiologia 422/423:1-14.
32. KARR, J. R., AND D. R. DUDLEY. 1981. Ecological perspective on water quality goals. Environmental Management 5:55-68.
33. KAUFMANN, P. R., AND R. M. HUGHES. 2006. Geomorphic and anthropogenic influences on fish and amphibians in Pacific Northwest coastal streams. Pages 429-455 in R. M. Hughes, L. Wang, and P. W. Seelbach (editors). Landscape influences on stream habitat and biological assemblages. Symposium 48. American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, Maryland.
34. KAUFMANN, P. R., P. LEVINE, E. G. ROBISON, C. SEELIGER, AND D. PECK. 1999. Quantifying physical habitat in wadeable streams. EPA/620/R-99/003. Office of Research and Development, US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC.
35. KLEMM, D. J., K. A. BLOCKSOM, F. A. FULK, A. T. HERLIHY, R. M. HUGHES, P. R. KAUFMANN, D. V. PECK, J. L. STODDARD, AND W. T. THOENY. 2003. Development and evaluation of a macroinvertebrate biotic integrity index (MBII) for regionally assessing Mid-Atlantic Highlands streams. Environmental Management 31:656-669.
36. KLEMM, D. J., K. A. BLOCKSOM, W. T. THEONY, F. A. FULK, A. T. HERLIHY, P. R. KAUFMANN, AND S. M. CORMIER. 2002. Methods development and use of macroinvertebrates as indicators of ecological conditions for streams in the Mid-Atlantic Highlands region. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 1:49-60.
37. KURTZ, J. C., L. E. JACKSON, AND W. S. FISHER. 2001. Strategies for evaluating indicators based on guidelines from the Environmental Protection Agency's Office of Research and Development. Ecologial Indicators 1:49-60.
38. LARSEN, D. P., AND A. T. HERLIHY. 1998. The dilemma of sampling streams for macroinvertebrate richness. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 17:359-366.
39. MCCORMICK, F. H., R. M. HUGHES, P. R. KAUFMANN, D. V. PECK, J. L. STODDARD, AND A. T. HERLIHY. 2001. Development of an index of biotic integrity for the Mid-Atlantic Highlands region. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 130:857-877.
40. MEADOR, M. R., T. R. WHITTIER, R. M. GOLDSTEIN, R. M. HUGHES, AND D. V. PECK. 2008. Evaluation of an index of biotic integrity approach used to assess biological condition in western U.S. streams. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 137:13-22.
41. MEBANE, C. A., T. R. MARET, AND R. M. HUGHES. 2003. An index of biological integrity (IBI) for Pacific Northwest rivers. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 132:239-261.
42. rd edition. Kendall/Hunt, Dubuque, Iowa.
43. OBERDORFF, T. D., D. PONT, B. HUGUENY, AND J. P. PORCHER. 2002. Development and validation of a fish-based index (FBI) for the assessment of "river health" in France. Freshwater Biology 47:1720-1734.
44. ODE, P. R., C. P. HAWKINS, AND R. D. MAZOR. 2008. Comparability of biological assessments derived from predictive models and multimetric indices of increasing geographic scope. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27:967-985.
45. OFENBÖCK, T., O. MOOG, J. GERRITSEN, AND M. T. BARBOUR. 2004. A stressor specific multimetric approach for monitoring running waters in Austria using benthic macro-invertebrates. Hydrobiologia 516:251-268.
46. OLSEN, A. R., AND D. V. PECK. 2008. Survey design and extent estimates for the Wadeable Stream Assessment. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27:822-836.
47. OMERNIK, J. M. 1987. Ecoregions of the conterminous United States. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 77:118-125.
48. PAULSEN, S. G., A. MAYIO, D. V. PECK, J. L. STODDARD, E. TARQUINIO, S. M. HOLDSWORTH, J. VAN SICKLE, L. L. YUAN, C. P. HAWKINS, A. T. HERLIHY, P. R. KAUFMANN, M. T. BARBOUR, D. P. LARSEN, AND A. R. OLSEN. 2008. Condition of stream ecosystems in the US: an overview of the first national assessment. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27:812-821.
49. PECK, D. V., A. T. HERLIHY, B. H. HILL, R. M. HUGHES, P. R. KAUFMANN, D. J. KLEMM, J. M. LAZORCHAK, R H. MCCORMICK, S. A. PETERSON, P. L. RINGOLD, T. MAGEE, AND M. R. CAPPAERT. 2006. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program - Surface Waters Western Pilot Study: field operations manual for wadeable streams. EPA 600/R-06/003. Office of Research and Development, US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC.
50. PONT, D., R. M. HUGHES, T. R. WHITTIER, AND S. SCHMUTZ. A predictive IBI model for fish assemblages of western USA streams. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society (in press).
51. PONT, D., B. HUGUENY, U. BEIER, D. GOFFAUX, A. MELCHER, R. NOBLE, C. M. ROGERS, N. G. ROSET, AND S. SCHMUTZ. 2006. Assessing river biotic condition at the continental scale: a European approach using functional metrics and fish assemblages. Journal of Applied Ecology 43:70-80.
52. RANKIN, E. T., AND C. O. YODER. 1999. Methods for deriving maximum species richness lines and other threshold relationships in biological field data. Pages 611-624 in T. P. Simon (editor). Assessing the sustainability and biological integrity of water resources using fish communities. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida.
53. REHN, A. C., P. R. ODE, AND C. P. HAWKINS. 2007. Comparisons of targeted-riffle and reach-wide benthic macroinvertebrate samples: implications for data sharing in stream-condition assessments. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 26:332-348.
54. ROSET, N., G. GRENOUILLET, D. GOFFAUX, D. PONT, AND P. KESTEMONT. 2007. A review of existing fish assemblage indicators and methodologies. Fisheries Management and Ecology 14:393-405.
55. ROTH, N. E., M. T. SOUTHERLAND, J. C. CHAILLOU, R. J. KLAUDA, P. F. KAZYAK, S. A. STRANKO, S. B. WEISBERG, L. W. HALL, AND R. P. MORGAN. 1998. Maryland biological stream survey: development of a fish index of biotic integrity. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 51:89-106.
56. SIMON, T. P., AND J. LYONS. 1995. Application of the index of biotic integrity to evaluate water resource integrity in freshwater ecosystems. Pages 245-262 in W. S. Davis and T. P. Simon (editors). Biological assessment and criteria: tools for water resource planning and decision making. Lewis Publishers, Chelsea, Michigan.
57. SNOOK, H., S. P. DAVIES, J. GERRITSEN, B. K. JESSUP, R. LANGDON, D. NEILS, AND E. PIZZUTO. 2007. The New England Wadeable Stream Survey (NEWS): development of common assessments in the framework of the biological condition gradient. New England Regional Laboratory, US Environmental Protection Agency, Chelmsford, Massachusetts. (Available from: http://www.epa.gov/NE/lab/pdfs/ NEWSfinalReport_August2007.pdf)
58. SOUTHERLAND, M. T., G. M. ROGERS, M. J. KLINE, R. P. MORGAN, P. F. KAZYAK, R. J. KLAUDA, AND S. A. STRANKO. 2007. Improving biological indicators to better assess the condition of streams. Ecological Indicators 7:751-767.
59. STODDARD, J. L., D. P. LARSEN, C. P. HAWKINS, R. K. JOHNSON, AND R. H. NORRIS. 2006. Setting expectations for the ecological condition of running waters: the concept of reference condition. Ecological Applications 16:1267-1276.
60. STODDARD, J. L., D. V. PECK, A. R. OLSEN, D. P. LARSEN, J. VAN SICKLE, C. P. HAWKINS, R. M. HUGHES, T. R. WHITTIER, G. LOMNICKY, A. T. HERLIHY, P. R. KAUFMANN, S. A. PETERSON, P. L. RINGOLD, S. G. PAULSEN, AND R. BLAIR. 2005a. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program (EMAP): western streams and rivers statistical summary. EPA 620/R-05/006. Office of Research and Development, US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC.
61. STODDARD, J. L., D. V. PECK, S. G. PAULSEN, J. VAN SICKLE, C. P. HAWKINS, A. T. HERLIHY, R. M. HUGHES, P. R. KAUFMANN, D. P. LARSEN, G. LOMNICKY, A. R. OLSEN, S. A. PETERSON, P. L. RINGOLD, AND T. R. WHITTIER. 2005b. An ecological assessment of western streams and rivers. EPA 620/R-05/005. Office of Research and Development, US Environmental Protection Agency Washington, DC.
62. USEPA (US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY). 2006. Wadeable Streams Assessment: a collaborative survey of the Nation's streams. EPA 841/B-06/002. Office of Water, US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC.
63. VINSON, M. R., AND C. P. HAWKINS. 1996. Effects of sampling area and subsampling procedure on comparisons of taxa richness among streams. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 15:392-399.
64. WAITE, I. R., A. T. HERLIHY, D. P. LARSEN, N. S. URQUHART, AND D. J. KLEMM. 2004. The effects of macroinvertebrate taxonomic resolution in large landscape bioassessments: an example from the Mid-Atlantic Highlands, U.S.A. Freshwater Biology 49:474-489.
65. WHITTIER, T. R., R. M. HUGHES, J. L. STODDARD, G. A. LOMNICKY, D. V. PECK, AND A. T. HERLIHY. 2007. A structured approach for developing indices of biotic integrity: three examples from streams and rivers in the western USA. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 136:718-735.