The Role of Superficial Venous Surgery in the Management of Venous Ulcers: A Systematic Review

European Journal of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery

Volumn 36, Issue 4, 2008, Pages 458-465

  Howard, D P J ^a   Howard, A ^b   Kothari, A ^a   Wales, L ^c   Guest, M ^c   Davies, A H ^c  

^a OXFORD UNIVERSITY HOSPITALS NHS FOUNDATION TRUST   (United Kingdom)

^b O and G   (United Kingdom)

^c IMPERIAL COLLEGE HEALTHCARE NHS TRUST   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Compression therapy; Healing; Recurrence; Saphenous surgery; Superficial venous surgery; Venous incompetence; Venous ulcers

Indexed keywords

CLINICAL TRIAL; COMPRESSION THERAPY; CONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIAL; FOLLOW UP; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; PERIPHERAL VEIN; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL; RECURRENCE RISK; REVIEW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; ULCER; ULCER HEALING; VEIN INSUFFICIENCY; VEIN SURGERY;

HUMANS; RECURRENCE; VARICOSE ULCER; VASCULAR SURGICAL PROCEDURES; VENOUS INSUFFICIENCY; WOUND HEALING;

EID: 51349109534     PISSN: 10785884     EISSN: 15322165     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ejvs.2008.06.013     Document Type: Review

References (88)

1. Wilson E. Prevention and treatment of venous leg ulcers. Health Trends 21 (1989) 97
2. Nicholaides A.N., Zukoski A., Lewis R., Kyprianou P., and Malouf G.M. Venous pressure measurements in venous problems. In: Bergan J.J., and Yao J.S.T. (Eds). Surgery of the veins (1985), Grune and Startton, Orlando 111-118
3. Bradbury A.W., Brittenden J., Allan P.L., and Ruckley C.V. Comparison of venous reflux in the affected and non-affected leg in patients with unilateral venous ulceration. Br J Surg 83 (1996) 513-515
4. Welkie J.F., Comeraota A.J., Kerr R.P., Katz M.L., Jayheimer E.C., and Brigham R.A. The haemodynamics of venous ulceration. Ann Vasc Surg 6 (1992) 1-4
5. McEnroe C.S., O'Donnell T.F.J., and Mackey W.C. Correlation of clinical findings with venous haemodynamics in 386 patients with chronic venous insufficiency. AJS 156 (1988) 148-152
6. Nicholaides A.N., Hussein M.K., Szendro G., and Christopolos D. The relation of venous ulceration with ambulatory venous pressure measurement. J Vasc Surg 17 (1993) 414-419
7. Phillip D, Coleridge-Smith PD, Ruckley CV, Fowkes FGR, Bradbury AW (eds). Venous disease, Springer-Verlag. How does a leg ulcerate? 1999;51-68.
8. Homans J. The aetiology and treatment of varicose ulcers of the leg. Surg Gynecol Obstet 24 (1917) 300-311
9. Browse N.L., and Burnand K.G. The cause of venous ulceration. Lancet 2 (1982) 243-245
10. Coleridge-Smith P.D., Thomas P., Scurr J.H., and Dormandy J.A. Causes of venous ulceration: a new hypothesis. BMJ 296 (1988) 1726-1727
11. Rowe A., Guest M., Allerston A., Davies A.H., and Bunker C.B. Depletion of cutaneous innervation adjacent to venous ulcers. J Investig Dermatol 114 (2000) 821
12. Partsch H, Ruckley CV, Fowkes FGR, Bradbury AW (Eds). Venous Disease, Springer-Verlag. Compression therapy: is it worthwhile? 1999;117-125.
13. Effective Health Care Bulletin. Compression therapy for venous leg ulcers. EHCB 3 no.4 (1997)
14. Fletcher A., Cullum N., and Sheldon T.A. A systematic review of compression treatment for venous leg ulcers. BMJ 315 (1997) 576-580
15. Wright D.D.I., Franks P.J., Blair S.D., Backhouse C.M., Moffat C., and McCollum C.N. Operations in the prevention of recurrence in chronic venous ulceration: randomized controlled trial. Br J Surg 78 (1991) 1269-1270
16. Harper D.R., Ruckley C.V., Dale J.J., Calla M.C., Allan P., and Brown D. Prevention of recurrence in chronic leg ulcer: a randomized trial of different degrees of compression. In: Raymond-Martin beau P., Prescott R., and Summon M. (Eds). Phlebotomy '92 (1992), John Libby, London Paris 902-903
17. Porter J.M., and Moneta G.L. International Consensus Committee on Chronic Venous Disease. Reporting standards in venous disease: an update. J Vasc Surg 21 (1995) 635-645
18. Brittenden J., Bradbury A.W., Allan P.L., Prescott R.J., Harper D.R., and Ruckley C.V. Poplitial vein reflux reduces the healing of chronic venous ulcer. Br J Surg 85 (1998) 60-62
19. Callam M.J., Harper D.R., Dale J.J., Brown D., Gibson B., Prescott R.J., et al. Lothian and Forth Valley leg ulcer healing trial, part 1; elastic versus non-elastic bandaging in the treatment of chronic leg ulceration. Phlebotomy 7 (1992) 136-141
20. Cameron J., Hoffman D., Poore S., Duby T., Cherry G., and Ryan T. A retrospective trial in the treatment of venous leg ulcers. Wounds 8 3 (1996) 95-100
21. Coleridge-Smith P., Sarin S., Hasty J., and Scurr J.H. Sequential gradient pneumatic compression enhances venous ulcer healing: a randomized trial. Surgery 108 (1990) 871-875
22. Cordts P.R., Hanrahan L.M., Rodriguez A.A., Woodson J., LaMorte W.W., and Menzoian J.O. A prospective, randomized trial of Anna's boot versus Duoderm CGF hydro active dressing plus compression in the management of venous leg ulcers. J Vasc Surg 15 (1992) 480-486
23. Duby T., Hoffman D., Cameron J., Doblhoff-Brown D., Cherry G., and Ryan T. A randomised trial in the treatment of the venous leg ulcers comparing short stretch bandages, four layer system, and a long stretch-paste bandage system. Wounds 5 6 (1993) 276-279
24. Erickson C.A., Lanza D.J., Karp D.L., Edwards J.W., Seabrook G.R., Cambria R.A., et al. Healing of venous ulcers in an ambulatory care program: the roles of chronic venous insufficiency and patient compliance. J Vasc Surg 22 (2000) 629-636
25. Kikta M.J., Schuler J.J., Meyer J.P., Durham J.R., Eldrup-Jorgensen J., Schwarcz T.H., et al. A prospective, randomised trial of Unna's boots versus hydroactive dressing in the treatment of venous stasis ulcers. J Vasc Surg 7 3 (1988) 478-484
26. Mayberry J.C., Moneta G.L., Taylor L.M., and Porter J.M. Fifteen-year results of ambulatory compression therapy for chronic venous ulcers. Surgery 109 5 (1991) 575-581
27. Moffat C.J., Franks P.J., Oldroyd M., Bosanquet N., Brown P., Greenhalgh R.M., et al. Community clinics for leg ulcers and impact on healing. BMJ 305 (1992) 1389-1392
28. Moffat C.J., and Dorman M.C. Recurrence of leg ulcers within a community ulcer clinic. J Wound Care 4 (1995) 57-61
29. Moffat C.J. Randomised trial comparing two four-layer bandage systems in the management of chronic leg ulceration. Phlebology 14 (1999) 139-142
30. Morrell C.J., Walters S.J., Dixon S., Collins K.A., Brereton L.M.L., Peters J., et al. Cost effectiveness of community leg ulcer clinics: randomised controlled trial. BMJ 316 (1998) 1487-1491
31. Nelson E.A., Ruckley C.V., Harper D.R., Gibson B., Dale J.J., and Prescott R.J. A randomised trial of a knitted viscose dressing and a hydrocolloid dressing in the treatment of chronic venous ulceration. Phlebology 1 Suppl (1995) 913-914
32. Rubin J.R., Alexandra J., Plecha E.J., and Marman C. Unna's boot vs polyurethane foam dressings for the treatment of venous ulceration. Arch Surg 125 (2000) 489-490
33. Thomson B., Hooper P., Powell R., and Warin A.P. Four-layer bandaging and healing rates of venous ulcers. J Wound Care 5 (1996) 213-216
34. Wilkinson E., Buttfield S., Cooper S., and Young E. Trial of two bandaging systems for chronic venous leg ulcers. J Wound Care 6 (1997) 339-340
35. Bass A., Chayen D., Weinmann E., and Ziss M. Lateral venous ulcer and short saphenous vein insufficiency. J Vasc Surg 25 (1997) 654-657
36. Bello M., Scriven M., Hartshorne, Bell P.R.F., Naylor A.R., and London N.J.M. Role of superficial venous surgery in the treatment of venous ulceration. Br J Surg 86 (1999) 755-759
37. Bradbury A.W., Stonebridge P.A., Callam M.J., Ruckley C.V., and Allan P.L. Foot volumetry and duplex ultrasonagraphy after saphenous and subfascial perforating vein ligation for recurrent venous ulceration. Br J Surg 80 (1993) 845-848
38. Bradbury A.W., and Ruckley C.V. Foot volumetry can predict recurrent ulceration after subfascial ligation of perforators and saphenous ligation. J Vasc Surg 18 (1993) 789-795
39. Burnand K.G., Lea Thomas M., O'Donnel T., and Browse N.L. Relation between postphlebitic changes in the deep veins and results of surgical treatment of venous ulcers. Lancet 1 (1976) 936-938
40. Burnand K.G., Stacey M.C., Layer G.T., Lloyd K., deBeaux F., and Browse N.L. Fibrinolytic enhancement versus surgical ablation of superficial incompetence in the prevention of venous ulcer recurrence: a controlled medical trial. Br J Surg 76 (1989) 418
41. Cikrit D.F., Nichols W.K., and Silver D. Surgical management of refractory venous stasis ulceration. J Vasc Surg 7 (1988) 473-478
42. Darke S.G., and Penfold C. Venous ulceration and saphenous ligation. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg 6 (1992) 4-9
43. Gloviczki P., Cambria R.A., Rhee R.Y., Canton L.G., and McKusick M.A. Surgical technique and preliminary results of endoscopic subfascial division of perforating veins. J Vasc Surg 26 (1996) 517-523
44. Gloviczki P., Bergan J.J., Rhodes J.M., Canton L.G., and Harmsen S. Ilstrup DM and the North American study Group. Mid-term results of endoscopic perforator vein interruption for chronic venous insufficiency: lessons learned from the North American Surgery Registry. J Vasc Surg 29 (1999) 489-502
45. Hauer G., Bergan J.J., Werner A., Mitterhusen M., and Nasralla F. Development of endoscopic dissection of perforating veins and fasciotomy for treatment of chronic venous insufficiency. Ann Vasc Surg 13 (1999) 357-364
46. Iafrati M.D., Welch H.J., and O'Donnel T.F. Subfascial endoscopic perforator ligation: an analysis of early clinical outcomes and cost. J Vasc Surg 25 (1997) 995-1001
47. Johnson W.C., O'Hara E.T., Corey C., Widrich W.C., and Nabseth D.C. Venous stasis ulceration. Arch Surg 120 (1985) 797-823
48. Lim R.B., Blaisdell F.W., Zubrin J., Stallone R.J., and Hall A.D. Subfascial ligation of perforating veins in recurrent stasis ulceration. Am J Surg 119 (1970) 246-249
49. Nachbur B. Chirurgische therapie des ulcus cruris. Wien Med Wscchr 144 (1994) 264-268
50. Nash P.N. Venous ulceration: factors influencing recurrence after standard surgical procedures. Med J Aust 154 (1991) 48-50
51. Padberg F.T., Pappas P.J., Araki C.T., Back T.L., and Hobson R.W. Haemodynamic and clinical improvement after superficial vein ablation in primary combined insufficiency with ulceration. J Vasc Surg 24 (1996) 711-718
52. Pierik E.G.J.M., Wittens C.H.A., and van Urk H. Subfascial endoscopic ligation in the treatment of incompetent perforating veins. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg 9 (1995) 38-41
53. Pierik E.G.J.M., van Urk H., Hop W.C.J., and Wittens C.H.A. Endoscopic versus open subfascial division of incompetent perforator veins in the treatment of venous leg ulceration: a randomised trial. J Vasc Surg 26 (1997) 1049-1054
54. Queral L.A., and Criado F.J. Mini incisional ligation of incompetent perforating veins of the legs. J Vasc Surg 25 (1997) 437-441
55. Rhodes J.M., Gloviczki P., Canton L.G., Rooke T., Lewis B.D., and Lindsey J.R. Factors affecting clinical outcome following endoscopic perforator vein ablation. Am J Surg 176 (1998) 162-165
56. Rhodes J.M., Gloviczki P., Canton L.G., Heaser T.V., and Rooke T. Endoscopic perforator vein division with ablation of superficial reflux improves venous haemodynamics. J Vasc Surg 28 (1998) 839-847
57. Robinson J.G., Elliot B.M., and Kaplan A.J. Limitations of subfascial ligation for refractory chronic venous stasis ulceration. Ann Vasc Surg 6 (1992) 9-14
58. Scriven M., Hartshorne T., Thrush A.J., Bell P.R.F., Naylor A.R., and London N.J.M. Role of saphenous vein surgery in the treatment of venous ulceration. Br J Surg 85 (1998) 781-784
59. Stuart W.P., Adam D.J., Bradbury A.W., and Ruckley C.V. Subfascial endoscopic perforator surgery is associated with significantly less morbidity and shorter hospital stay than open surgery. Br J Surg 84 (1997) 1364-1365
60. Sottiurai V.S. Surgical correction of recurrent venous ulcer. J Cardiovasc Surg 32 (1991) 104-109
61. Warburg F.E. Vein surgery with or without skin grafting versus conservative treatment for leg ulcers. Acta Derm Venereol (Stockh) 74 (1994) 307-309
62. Wilkinson G.E., and Maclaren I.F. Long term review of procedures for venous perforator insufficiency. Surg Gynecol Obstet 163 (1986) 117-120
63. Shoab S.S., and Coleridge-Smith P.D. Role of superficial venous surgery in the treatment of venous ulceration (letter 2). Br J Surg 86 (1999) 1475
64. Dunn J.M., Kernick V.F.M., Cosford E.J., and Campbell W.B. Surgical treatment for venous ulcers: is it worthwhile?. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 77 (1995) 421-424
65. Ghauri A.S.K., Nyamekye I., Grabs A.J., Farndon J.R., Whyman M.R., and Poskitt K.R. Influence of a specialised leg ulcer service and venous surgery on the outcome of venous leg ulcers. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg 16 (1998) 238-244
66. Gloviczki P., Bergan J.J., Menawat S.S., Hobson R.W., Kistner R.L., Lawrence P.F., et al. Safety, feasibility, and early efficacy of subfascial endoscopic perforator surgery: a preliminary report from the North American registry. J Vasc Surg 25 (1997) 94-105
67. Pierik E.G.J.M., van Urk H., and Wittens C.H.A. Efficacy of subfascial endoscopy in eradicating perforating veins of the lower leg and its relation with venous ulcer healing. J Vasc Surg 26 (1997) 255-259
68. Thomas A., Tomlinson P.J., and Boggon R.P. Incompetent perforating vein ligation in the treatment of venous ulceration. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 68 4 (1986) 214-215
69. Sales C.M., Bilof M.L., Perillo K.A., and Luka N.L. Correction of lower extremity deep venous incompetence by ablation of superficial venous reflux. Ann Vasc Surg 10 2 (1996) 186-189
70. DePalma R.G., and Kowallek D.L. Venous ulceration: A cross-over study from nonoperative to operative treatment. J Vasc Surg 24 (1996) 788-792
71. Stacey M.C., Burnand K.G., Layer G.T., and Pattison M. Calf pump function in patients with healed venous ulcers is not improved by surgery to the communicating veins or by elastic stockings. Br J Surg 75 (1988) 436-439
72. Travers J.P., Dalziel K.L., and Makin G.S. Assessment of a new one-layer adhesive bandaging method in maintaining prolonged limb compression and effects on venous healing. Phlebology 7 7 (2000) 59-63
73. Guest M., Smith J.J., tripuraneni G., Howard A., Madden P., Greenhalgh R.M., et al. Randomised clinical trial of varicose vein surgery with compression versus compression alone for the treatment of venous ulceration. Phlebology 18 (2003) 130-136
74. Zamboni P., Cisno C., Marchetti F., Mazza P., Fogato L., Carandina S., et al. Minimally invasive surgical management of primary venous ulcers vs. compression treatment: a randomised clinical trial. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg 26 (2003) 337-338
75. van Gent W.B., Hop W.C., van Praag M.C., Mackaay A.J., de Boer E.M., and Wittens C.H. Conservative versus surgical treatment of venous leg ulcers: a prospective randomised multicenter trial. J Vasc Surg 44 (2006) 563-571
76. Barwell J.R., Davies C.E., Deacon J., Harvey K., Minor J., Sassano A., et al. Comparison of surgery and compression with compression alone in chronic venous ulceration (ESCHAR study): randomised controlled trial. Lancet 363 (2004) 1854-1859
77. Davies A.H., Hawdon A.J., and Greenhalgh R.M. Thompson S, on behalf of the USABLE trial participants. Failure of a trial evaluating the effect of venous surgery on healing and recurrence rates in venous ulcers? The USABLE trial: rationale, design and methodology, and reasons for failure. Phlebology 19 (2004) 137-142
78. Gohel M.S., Barwell J.R., Taylor M., Chant T., Foy C., Earnshaw J.J., et al. Long term results of compression therapy alone versus compression plus surgery in chronic venous ulceration (ESCHAR): randomised controlled trial. BMJ 335 (2007) 83-87
79. Blair S.D., Wright D.D.I., Backhouse C.M., Riddle E., and McCollum C.N. Sustained compression and healing of chronic venous ulcers. BMJ 297 (1999) 159-161
80. Freak L., McCollum C.N., and Simon D.A. Community leg ulcer clinics: a comparative study of 2 health authorities. BMJ 312 (1996) 1648-1651
81. El-hafez E.A., and Seleem M.I. Saphenofemoral ligation as a safe and effective alterantive for the treatment of chronic venous leg ulcer. Saudi Med J 25 (2004) 172-176
82. Jones J.E., and Nelson E.A. Skin grafting for venous leg ulcers. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 1 (2005 Jan 25) CD0011737
83. Gohel M.S., Barwell J.R., Earnshaw J.J., Heather B.P., Mitchell D.C., Whyman M.R., et al. Randomised clinical trial of compression plus surgery versus compression alone in chronic venous ulceration (ESCHAR study) -haemodynamic and anatomical changes. Br J Surg 92 (2005) 291-297
84. Sethia K.K., and Darke S.G. Long saphenous incompetence as a cause of venous ulceration. Br J Surg 71 (1984) 754-755
85. Phillips G.W., Paige J., and Molan M.P. A comparison of colour duplex ultrasound with venography and varicography in the assessment of varicose veins. Clin Radiol 50 (1995) 20-25
86. Dodd H., and Cockett F.B. The pathology and surgery of the veins of the lower limb (1976), Churchill Livingston, Edinburgh
87. Hoare M.C., Nicholaides A.N., Miles C.R., Shull K., Jury R.P., Needham T., et al. The role of primary varicose veins in venous ulceration. Surgery 92 (1982) 450-453
88. Labroupolos N., Leon M., Geroulakos G., Volteas N., Chan P., and Nicholaides A.N. Venous haemodynamic abnormalities in patients with leg ulceration. AJS 169 (1995) 572-574