Coordination within fragmentation: Governance in knowledge policy in the German federal system

Science and Public Policy

Volumn 35, Issue 4, 2008, Pages 265-276

  Edler, Jakob ^a   Kuhlmann, Stefan ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF TWENTE   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

FEDERAL SYSTEM; GOVERNANCE APPROACH; KNOWLEDGE;

CENTRAL EUROPE; EURASIA; EUROPE; GERMANY;

EID: 46649099665     PISSN: 03023427     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3152/030234208X310329     Document Type: Article

References (31)

1. Arnold, E and B Boekholt 2003 Research and Innovation Governance in Eight Countries: a Meta-Analysis of Work Funded by EZ (Netherlands) and RCN (Norway). Brighton and Amsterdam: Technopolis.
2. Arnold, E, S Kuhlmann and B van der Meulen 2001 A Singular Council: Evaluation of the Research Council of Norway. Oslo: Royal Norwegian Ministry for Education, Research. and Church Affairs (mimeo).
3. Benz, A 2006. Governance in connected arenas - political science analysis of coordination and control in complex control systems. In New Forms of Governance in Research Organizations: From Disciplinary Theories towards Interfaces and Integration, ed. D Jansen, pp. 3-22. Heidelberg and New York: Springer.
4. Biegelbauer, P and S Borras eds. 2003 Innovation Policies in Europe and the US, the New Agenda, Aldershot. UK: Ashgate.
5. BMWi (Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology) 2001) Results of the System Evaluation of Industry-integrating Research Assistance. Berlin: BMWi.
6. DFG, Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft 2007. Excellence Initiative. Available at , last accessed 22 December 2007.
7. Ebersberger, B and J Edler 2007 Die Europeäische Ebene. In Internationalisierung der deutschen Forschungs- und Wissenschaftslandschaft, ed. J Edler, pp. 199-216. Karlsruhe/Bonn: study on behalf of the German Federal Ministry for Education and Research.
8. Edler, J ed. 2007a Internationalisierung derdeutschen Forschungsund Wissenschaftslandschaft. Karlsruhe/Bonn: study on behalf of the German Federal Ministry for Education and Research.
9. Edler, J ed. 2007b Bedürfnisse als Innovationsmotor - Konzepte und Instrumente nachfrageorientiefter Innovationspolitik (Needs as Drivers for Innovation). Berlin: Sigma.
10. Edler, J and S Bührer 2007 [Nachfrageorientierte Innovationspolitilk in Deutschland. In Bedürfnisse als Innovationsmotor - Konzepte und Instrumente nachfrageorientierter Innovationspolitik (Needs as Drivers for Innovation), pp. 151-172, ad. J Edler. Berlin: Sigma.
11. Edler, J and S Kuhlmann 2008 Integration of European Research Systems: a Multi-Dimensional Phenomenon. In Towards a European Research Area, ed. D Jansen. Baden-Baden: Nomos (forthcoming).
12. Edler, J, S Kuhlmann and R Smits 2003 New Governance for Innovation: the Need for Horizontal and Systematic Policy Coordination. Karlsruhe: Fraunhofer ISI. Fraunhofer ISI Discussion Papers Innovation System and Policy Analysis No. 2/2003, available at , (318 KB) (ISI-A-4-03).
13. Edler, J, S Kuhlmann and S Ruhland 2006 Institutional Models of Organising Education, Science and Technology Policy: the Case of Germany. Report for the Swiss Science and Technology Council (mimeo).
14. Enders J 2007 Reform and change of German research universities. Higher Education Forum, 4, February, 19-31.
15. Heinze, T and S Kuhlmann 2007 Analysis of heterogeneous collaboration in the German research system with a focus on nanotechnology. In New Forms of Govemance in Research Organizations: from Disciplinary Theories towards Interfaces and Integration, ed. D Jansen, pp. 190-209. Heidelberg: Springer.
16. Hohn, H-W and U Schimank 1990 Konflikte und Gleichgewichte im Forschungssystem: Akteurkonstellationen und Entwicklungspfade in der staatlich finanzierten außeruniversitären Forschung. Frankfurt a. M. and New York: Campus.
17. Horvat, M, K Guy, V Demonte Barreto, J Engelbrecht and R Wilken 2006 ERA-NET Review (2006): The Report of the Expert Review Group. Brussels (mimeo).
18. Internationale Kommission 1999 Forschungsförderung in Deutschland. Bericht der internationalen Kommission zur Systemevaluation der Deutschen Forschungsgemeinschaft und der Max-Planck-Gesellschaft. Hannover: Volkswagen-Stiftung.
19. Jäkel, R and K Blind, eds. 2005 Innovationsfaktor Staat - Aktiver Promotor und intelligenter Rahmensetzer. Stuttgart and Berlin.
20. Jansen, D ed. 2007 New Forms of Governance in Research Organizations: from Disciplinary Theories towards Interfaces and Integration. Heidelberg: Springer.
21. Kuhlmann, S 2001 Governance of innovation policy in Europe - three scenarios. In Research Policy, 30(6), 953-976.
22. Kuhlmann, S and T Heinze 2004a Evaluation von Forschungsleistungen in Deutschland: Erzeuger und Bedarf; Teil I: Konzeptionelle Grundlagen. Wissenschaftsrecht, 37, 53-69.
23. Kuhlmann, S and T Heinze 2004b. Evaluation von Forschungsleistungen in Deutschland: Erzeuger und Bedarf; Teil II: Produktion und Verwendung evaluativer Information sowie Möglichkeiten ihrer künftigen Organisation. Wissenschaftsrecht, 37, 125-149.
24. Kuhlmann, S and P Shapira 2006 How is innovation influenced by science and technology policy governance? Transatlantic comparisons. In Innovation, Science, and Institutional Change: a Research Handbook, eds J Hage and M Meeus, pp. 232-255. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
25. Legler, H and B Gehrke 2006 Germany's Technological Performance 2005, Summary. Bonn and Berlin: BMBF.
26. Münch, R 2007 Die akademische Elite. Frankfurt a.M.: Suhrkamp.
27. Peters, B G 2005 Concepts and theories of horizontal policy management. X Congreso Internacional del CLAD sobre la Reforma del Estado y de la Administracion Publica, Santiago, Chile, 18-21 October 2005.
28. Research Europe 2007. The triangle shrinks. Research Europe, 245, 13 December, 2.
29. Scharpf, F 1994 Games real actors could play: positive and negative coordination in embedded negotiations. Journal of Theoretical Politics, 6, 27-53.
30. Smits, R and S Kuhlmann 2004 The rise of systemic instruments in innovation policy. International Journal of Foresight and Innovation Policy, 1(1/2), 4-32.
31. Wilson D and V Souitaris 2002 Do Germany's Federal and land governments (still) co-ordinate their innovation policies? Research Policy, 31(7), September, 1123-1140.