SCOPUS 정보 검색 플랫폼

Journal of Law and Society

Volumn 35, Issue 2, 2008, Pages 214-239

Second-chance punitivism and the contractual governance of crime and incivility: New labour, old hobbes

(1) MacKenzie, Simon a

a UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 43649084109 PISSN: 0263323X EISSN: 14676478 Source Type: Journal
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-6478.2008.00436.x Document Type: Article

Times cited : (8)

References (32)

1
- 0344927026
- "contractual Governance" of Deviant Behaviour
- The Public Order Act 1986 has been taken elsewhere as 'an appropriate baseline for discussion of contemporary offence regulation', that is, a milestone in the development of the contemporary trends in the regulation of offensive behaviour discussed here: E. Burney, '"No Spitting": Regulation of Offensive Behaviour in England and Wales' in Incivilities: Regulating Offensive Behaviour, eds. A. von Hirsch and A.P. Simester (2006). T. Blair, The Third Way: New Politics for the New Century (1998).
- A. Crawford "Contractual Governance" of Deviant Behaviour 2003) 30 J. of Law and Society 479 505.
- (2003) J. of Law and Society , vol.30 , pp. 479-505
- Crawford, A.¹

2
- 0001920002
- Communitarianism and Law and Order
- The concept of the 'law-abiding majority' has become a very popular political reference point, the term appearing most recently in New Labour's commitment to 'deliver a justice system which focuses on meeting the needs of victims and the decent law-abiding majority': Labour Party, Labour in Government: Labour's Policies on Crime and Justice (2008) at < >. A. Etzioni, The Spirit of Community: Rights, Responsibilities and the Communitarian Agenda (1995). E. Burney, Making People Behave: Anti-social Behaviour, Politics and Policy (2005). A phrase coined in respect of a different target by A. Maclntyre, After Virtue: a Study in Moral Theory (1981) 10. S. Hale, Blair's Community: Communitarian Thought and New Labour (2006) is a good source for collected examples of this.
- G. Hughes Communitarianism and Law and Order 1996) 16 Critical Social Policy 17 41.
- (1996) Critical Social Policy , vol.16 , pp. 17-41
- Hughes, G.¹

3
- 0035542315
- The Politics of Life Itself
- N. Rose, The Politics of Life Itself (2001) 18 (6) Theory, Culture & Society 1 30
- (2001) Theory, Culture & Society , vol.18 , Issue.6 , pp. 1-30
- Rose, N.¹

4
- 34247121805
- Thatcher's Legacy
- id. Crawford, op. cit, n. 2; D. Osborne and T. Gaebler, Reinventing Government (1992);
- S. Jenkins Thatcher's Legacy 2007) 5 Political Studies Rev. 161 71.
- (2007) Political Studies Rev. , vol.5 , pp. 161-71
- Jenkins, S.¹

5
- 0030509474
- The Limits of the Sovereign State: Strategies of Crime Control in Contemporary Society
- ; D. Garland, The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society (2001). M. Moran, The British Regulatory State: High Modernism and Hyper Innovation (2003).
- D. Garland The Limits of the Sovereign State: Strategies of Crime Control in Contemporary Society 1996) 36 Brit. J. of Crim. 445 71
- (1996) Brit. J. of Crim. , vol.36 , pp. 445-71
- Garland, D.¹

6
- 33750080493
- Networked Governance and the Post-regulatory State? Steering, Rowing and Anchoring the Provision of Policing and Security
- at 455, 456. id, p. 457.
- A. Crawford Networked Governance and the Post-regulatory State? Steering, Rowing and Anchoring the Provision of Policing and Security 2006) 10 Theoretical Crim. 449 79
- (2006) Theoretical Crim. , vol.10 , pp. 449-79
- Crawford, A.¹

7
- 85050839142
- Performative Regulation: A Case Study in How Powerful People Avoid Criminal Labels
- and. N. Cohen, Pretty Straight Guys (2004). H. Blagg and D. Smith, Crime, Penal Policy and Social Work (1989); J. Muncie and G. Hughes, 'Modes of Youth Governance: Political Rationalities, Criminalization and Resistance' in Youth Justice: Critical Readings, eds. J. Muncie, G. Hughes, and E. McLaughlin (2002); G. Hughes, The Politics of Crime and Community (2006); J. Rodger, Criminalising Social Policy: Anti-social behaviour and welfare in a de-civilised society (2008). B. Goldson, 'New Punitiveness: The Politics of Child Incarceration' in Muncie, Hughes, and McLaughlin, id.; J. Pratt et al. (eds.), The New Punitiveness: Trends, Theories, Perspectives (2005).
- S. Mackenzie and P. Green Performative Regulation: a Case Study in How Powerful People Avoid Criminal Labels 2008) 48 Brit. J. of Crim. 138 53.
- (2008) Brit. J. of Crim. , vol.48 , pp. 138-53
- MacKenzie, S.¹ Green, P.²

8
- 85044799845
- Anti-social Behaviour, Crime Control and Social Control
- A.E. Bottoms, 'The Philosophy and Politics of Punishment and Sentencing' in The Politics of Sentencing Reform, eds. C.M.V. Clarkson and R. Morgan (1995). Garland, op. cit. (1996) and (2001), n. 24. N. Fairclough, New Labour, New Language? (2000). Rose, op. cit., n. 14, p. 200. Crawford, op. cit., n. 2, p. 479.
- A. P. Brown Anti-social Behaviour, Crime Control and Social Control 2004) 43 Howard J. of Crim. Justice 203 11.
- (2004) Howard J. of Crim. Justice , vol.43 , pp. 203-11
- Brown, A.P.¹

9
- 0031525774
- Home-school Relationships: The Swarming of Disciplinary Mechanisms?
- and. ; E. Burney, Crime and Banishment: Nuisance and Exclusion in Social Housing (1999); C. Hunter, J. Nixon, and S. Shayer, Neighbour Nuisance, Social Landlords and the Law (2000); R. Smith et al., Allocations and Exclusions: the Impact of New Approaches to Allocating Social Housing (2001);
- C. Vincent and S. Tomlinson Home-school Relationships: The Swarming of Disciplinary Mechanisms? 1997) 23 Brit. Educational Research J. 361 77
- (1997) Brit. Educational Research J. , vol.23 , pp. 361-77
- Vincent, C.¹ Tomlinson, S.²

10
- 0036772319
- Part of the Problem or Part of the Solution? Social Housing Allocation Policies and Social Exclusion in Britain
- and. ; Crawford, id.; T. Newburn et al., 'The Introduction of Referral Orders into the Youth Justice System: Final Report' (2002);
- H. Pawson and K. Kintrea Part of the Problem or Part of the Solution? Social Housing Allocation Policies and Social Exclusion in Britain 2002) 31 J. of Social Policy 643 67
- (2002) J. of Social Policy , vol.31 , pp. 643-67
- Pawson, H.¹ Kintrea, K.²

11
- 33646706878
- Governing Neighbours: Anti-social Behaviour Orders and New Forms of Regulating Conduct in the UK
- and. As Richard Ericson and colleagues have shown, the insurance industry exerts considerable behavioural influence over its customers and others through the contractual mechanism: R.V. Ericson, A. Doyle, and D. Barry, Insurance as Governance (2003). S.M. Low, Behind the Gates: Life, Security and the Pursuit of Happiness in Fortress America (2003). Crawford, op. cit., n. 2, p. 492, referring to I. Macneil, The New Social Contract: an Inquiry into Modern Contractual Relations (1980) 48. D. Nelken, 'The Use of "Contracts" as a Social Work Technique' in Current Legal Problems, eds. R. Rideout and J. Jowell (1987) 207-32; D. Nelken, 'Social Work Contracts and Social Control' in Informal Justice?, ed. R. Matthews (1988);
- J. Flint and J. Nixon Governing Neighbours: Anti-social Behaviour Orders and New Forms of Regulating Conduct in the UK 2006) 43 Urban Studies 939 55.
- (2006) Urban Studies , vol.43 , pp. 939-55
- Flint, J.¹ Nixon, J.²

12
- 84989634952
- Discipline and Punish: Some Notes on the Margin
- P. Raynor and M. Vanstone, Understanding Community Penalties: Probation, Policy and Social Change (2002); R. Moore et al., ISSP: The Initial Report (2004); S. Rex, Reforming Community Penalties (2005);
- D. Nelken Discipline and Punish: Some Notes on the Margin 1989) 28 Howard J. of Crim. Justice 245 54.
- (1989) Howard J. of Crim. Justice , vol.28 , pp. 245-54
- Nelken, D.¹

13
- 34247675016
- Reducing Child Imprisonment: A Systemic Challenge
- ; NACRO, A Better Alternative: Reducing Child Imprisonment (2005); E. Solomon and M. Rutherford, Community Sentences Digest (2007).
- T. Bateman Reducing Child Imprisonment: a Systemic Challenge 2005) 5 Youth Justice 91 105
- (2005) Youth Justice , vol.5 , pp. 91-105
- Bateman, T.¹

14
- 43649095520
- Twisting Arms or a Helping Hand? Assessing the Impact of "coerced" and Comparable "voluntary" Drug Treatment Options
- ; for a statement of the Scottish position on consent to treatment see Scottish Executive, National Objectives for Social Work Services in the Criminal Justice System: Standards - Social Enquiry Reports and Associated Court Services (2004) at < >.
- T. McSweeney et al. Twisting Arms or a Helping Hand? Assessing the Impact of "Coerced" and Comparable "Voluntary" Drug Treatment Options 2007) 47 Brit. J. of Crim. 470 90
- (2007) Brit. J. of Crim. , vol.47 , pp. 470-90
- McSweeney, T.¹

15
- 33745302148
- Compulsory Persuasion: A Problem for Correctional Social Work
- R.A. Duff, Punishment, Communication and Community (2000). The present analysis is therefore also a pragmatic critique of Duff s doctrinal support, with Marshall, for the specification of some categories of offensive conduct by way of injunctions such as warning notices under the Noise Act 1996. While such injunctions, in achieving the quasi-contractual effect discussed here, may add clarity to the prohibitions of the criminal law, unless these formalities can reasonably be argued to affect behaviour, their effects will accord with the second-chance punitivism raised here; R.A. Duff and S.E. Marshall, 'How Offensive Can You Get?' in von Hirsch and Simester, op. cit, n. 3.
- P. Raynor Compulsory Persuasion: a Problem for Correctional Social Work 1978) 8 Brit. J. of Social Work 411 24.
- (1978) Brit. J. of Social Work , vol.8 , pp. 411-24
- Raynor, P.¹

16
- 84900130100
- Controlling Letting Arrangements? Landlords and Surveillance in the Private Rented Sector
- ;
- D. Lister Controlling Letting Arrangements? Landlords and Surveillance in the Private Rented Sector 2004) 2 Surveillance and Society 513 28
- (2004) Surveillance and Society , vol.2 , pp. 513-28
- Lister, D.¹

17
- 16344367759
- Gated Communities: (Ne)gated Community Development?
- and. K. Bullock and B. Jones, Acceptable Behaviour Contracts: Addressing Antisocial Behaviour in the London Borough of Islington (2004). DTZ Pieda Consulting and Heriot Watt University, Use of Anti-social Behaviour Orders in Scotland (2005) at < >; DTZ Consulting & Research and Heriot-Watt University, Use of Antisocial Behaviour Orders in Scotland: Report of the 2005/06 Survey (2006) at < >. National Audit Office, The Home Office: Tackling Anti-social Behaviour HC (2006-07) 99. See, also, R. Matthews et al., Assessing the Use and Impact of Anti-social Behaviour Orders (2007). Burney, op. cit., n. 3. Perhaps most notably in criminology in the field of 'desistance studies'; for a summary, see
- S. Blandy and D. Lister Gated Communities: (Ne)gated Community Development? 2004) 20 Housing Studies 287 301.
- (2004) Housing Studies , vol.20 , pp. 287-301
- Blandy, S.¹ Lister, D.²

18
- 33745310512
- A desistance paradigm for offender management
- F. McNeill A Desistance Paradigm for Offender Management 2006) 6 Crim. and Criminal Justice 39 62
- (2006) Crim. and Criminal Justice , vol.6 , pp. 39-62
- McNeill, F.¹

19
- 0346422521
- "governmentality" and the Problem of Crime: Foucault, Criminology, Sociology
- ; M. Rutter, H. Giller, and A. Hagell, Antisocial Behaviour by Young People (1998); S. Maruna, Making Good: How Ex-convicts Reform and Rebuild their Lives (2003);
- D. Garland "Governmentality" and the Problem of Crime: Foucault, Criminology, Sociology 1997) 1 Theoretical Crim. 173 214
- (1997) Theoretical Crim. , vol.1 , pp. 173-214
- Garland, D.¹

20
- 0041759793
- Survey Article: Repentance Rituals and Restorative Justice
- J. Braithwaite Survey Article: Repentance Rituals and Restorative Justice 2000) 8 J. of Political Philosophy 115 31
- (2000) J. of Political Philosophy , vol.8 , pp. 115-31
- Braithwaite, J.¹

21
- 0141460121
- Housing and Ethopolitics: Constructing Identities of Active Consumption and Responsible Community
- citing
- J. Flint Housing and Ethopolitics: Constructing Identities of Active Consumption and Responsible Community 2003) 32 Economy and Society 611 29
- (2003) Economy and Society , vol.32 , pp. 611-29
- Flint, J.¹

22
- 0031428027
- The "active Society": New Designs for Social Policy
- and N. Rose, Powers of Freedom: Reframing Political Thought (1999). Crawford, op. cit, n. 2, p. 491. Social Exclusion Unit, Anti-social Behaviour (2000); C. Hunter, 'The Changing Legal Framework: From Landlords to Agents of Social Control' in Housing and Anti-social Behaviour: Perspectives, Policy and Practice, ed. J. Flint (2006). Even beyond the sphere of social housing, however, private landlords are being encouraged to take a greater interest in regulating the behavior of their tenants: N. Springings, 'Housing Policy and Social Justice' in Housing and Social Policy: Contemporary Themes and Critical Perspectives, eds. P. Somerville and N. Springings (2005) 43-68. DTZ et al., op. cit. (2005), n. 50.
- W. Walters The "Active Society": New Designs for Social Policy 1997) 25 Policy and Politics 221 34.
- (1997) Policy and Politics , vol.25 , pp. 221-34
- Walters, W.¹

23
- 0001814852
- Coercion and Distribution in a Supposedly Non-coercive State
- To pursue the implications of the contractual metaphor, coercion applied to ensure the less powerful party enters into the contract would tend to avoid the contract under most doctrines of duress, or force and fear. For the Scottish case, see J.E. du Plessis, 'Force and Fear' in A History of Private Law in Scotland, eds. R. Zimmermann and K.G.C. Reid (2000). In order to make this analogous contractual argument one must put to one side the state's legitimation of the punishment threatened, and imagine that the threat of force is made by a party not (self-)authorized to do so.
- R. Hale Coercion and Distribution in a Supposedly Non-coercive State 1923) 38 Political Science Q. 470.
- (1923) Political Science Q. , vol.38 , pp. 470
- Hale, R.¹

24
- 0040247251
- The Counterfeit Contract: Reform, Pretence and Muddled Principles in the New Referral Order
- C. Wonnacott The Counterfeit Contract: Reform, Pretence and Muddled Principles in the New Referral Order 1999) 11 Child and Family Law Q. 271 87.
- (1999) Child and Family Law Q. , vol.11 , pp. 271-87
- Wonnacott, C.¹

25
- 84936097157
- Legal Networks and Domestic Security
- ;
- P. O'Malley Legal Networks and Domestic Security 1991) 11 Studies in Law, Politics and Society 171 90
- (1991) Studies in Law, Politics and Society , vol.11 , pp. 171-90
- O'Malley, P.¹

26
- 43649092900
- Reinventing Prevention: Why Did "crime Prevention" Develop so Late?
- and. Duff and Marshall, op. cit, n. 47, p. 85. T. Blair, 'Values and the Power of Community' (speech, 30 June 2000), cited in Hale, op. cit., n. 10, my italics. T. Sorell (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Hobbes (1996); T. Hobbes, De Cive (1642); T. Hobbes, Leviathan (1651). P.T. King, Thomas Hobbes: Critical Assessments (1993). Hobbes, op. cit. (1651), n. 65, ch. 6. For example, Etzioni, op. cit., n. 7; A. Etzioni, The Third Way to a Good Society (2000); R.D. Putnam, Bowling Alone: the Collapse and Revival of American Community (2000); R.J. Sampson, 'Collective Efficacy Theory: Lessons Learned and Directions for Future Inquiry' in Advances in Criminological Theory (vol. 15): Taking Stock: the Status of Criminological Theory, eds. F.T. Cullen, J.P. Wright, and K.R. Blevins (2006). G. Delanty, Citizenship in a Global Age (2000). Burney, op. cit., n. 8. Sparks, op. cit., n. 53.
- P. O'Malley and S. Hutchinson Reinventing Prevention: Why Did "Crime Prevention" Develop So Late? 2007) 47 Brit. J. of Criminology 373 89.
- (2007) Brit. J. of Criminology , vol.47 , pp. 373-89
- O'Malley, P.¹ Hutchinson, S.²

27
- 4344598540
- Kant on Hobbes, Peace, and Obedience
- and. B. Gert, 'Thomas Hobbes' in The Philosophers: Introducing the Great Western Thinkers, ed. T. Honderich (1999) 55. J. Simon, Governing through Crime: How the War on Crime Transformed American Democracy and Created a Culture of Fear (2007). BBC News, 'Police Crack Down on Scavengers' (2007) BBC News < >; M. Hume, 'Devon's Dignity in Need of Salvage' Times, 9 July 2007 at < >. Z. Bauman, Intimations of Postmodernity (1992); Z. Bauman, Postmodern Ethics (1993); J. Young, The Vertigo of Late Modernity (2007);
- T. Airaksinen and A. Siitonen Kant on Hobbes, Peace, and Obedience 2004) 30 History of European Ideas 315 28.
- (2004) History of European Ideas , vol.30 , pp. 315-28
- Airaksinen, T.¹ Siitonen, A.²

28
- 33750877943
- Situationally Edited Empathy: An Effect of Socio-economic Structure on Individual Choice
- E. Durkheim, The Division of Labour in Society (1947). R. Reeves, 'Brown's Moral Compass' New Statesman, 27 November 2006. F. McNeill and B. Whyte, Reducing Reoffending: Social Work and Community Justice in Scotland (2007); G. Mclvor and F. McNeill, 'Probation in Scotland: Past, Present and Future' in The Probation Handbook: a Policy, Practice and Research Handbook, eds. L. Gelsthorpe and R. Morgan (2007). Home Office, Crime and Disorder Act 1998: Anti-social Behaviour Orders (1999) 11. Flint and Nixon, op. cit, n. 38, p. 945. Home Office, A Guide to Anti-social Behaviour Orders and Acceptable Behaviour Contracts (2002) 17. D.P. Farrington, 'Developmental Criminology and Risk-focussed Prevention' in The Oxford Handbook of Criminology, eds. M. Maguire, R. Morgan, and R. Reiner (2002, 3rd edn.).
- S. Mackenzie Situationally Edited Empathy: an Effect of Socio-economic Structure on Individual Choice 2006) 14 Critical Criminology 365 85.
- (2006) Critical Criminology , vol.14 , pp. 365-85
- MacKenzie, S.¹

29
- 0002244517
- New Right, New Left, New Challenges: Understanding and Responding to Neoconservatism in Contemporary Criminology
- at 81. Crawford, op. cit, n. 2. Duff and Marshall, op. cit., n. 47; Home Office, op. cit., n. 82, p. 34; and Lord Hope's remarks in McCann [2003] 1 A.C. 787, at 824. The justifying rhetoric for the war on Iraq is a headline example of this line of neo-liberal thought:
- G. S. Rigakos New Right, New Left, New Challenges: Understanding and Responding to Neoconservatism in Contemporary Criminology 1996) 7 (2) Critical Crim. 75 91
- (1996) Critical Crim. , vol.7 , Issue.2 , pp. 75-91
- Rigakos, G.S.¹

30
- 25144511941
- War, Aggression and State Crime: A Criminological Analysis of the Invasion and Occupation of Iraq
- and. See the debate between Lord Devlin and H.L.A. Hart: H.L.A. Hart, Law, Liberty and Morality (1963); P. Devlin, The Enforcement of Morals (1965). J. Gray, The Two Faces of Liberalism (2000). Crawford, op. cit., n. 2, p. 486. CD. Shearing and P. Stenning, 'From the Panopticon to Disney World: the Development of Discipline' in Perspectives in Criminal Law, eds. A. Doob and A. Greenspan (1985);
- R. C. Kramer and R. J. Michalowski War, Aggression and State Crime: a Criminological Analysis of the Invasion and Occupation of Iraq 2005) 45 Brit. J. of Crim. 446 69.
- (2005) Brit. J. of Crim. , vol.45 , pp. 446-69
- Kramer, R.C.¹ Michalowski, R.J.²

31
- 84933486345
- Risk, Power and Crime Prevention
- ;
- P. O'Malley Risk, Power and Crime Prevention 1992) 21 Economy and Society 252 75
- (1992) Economy and Society , vol.21 , pp. 252-75
- O'Malley, P.¹

32
- 84984351869
- The New Penology: Notes on the Emerging Strategy of Corrections and its Implications
- and. Crawford, op. cit., n. 2, p. 504. M. Foucault, Discipline and Punish (1977). G. Deleuze, 'Postscript on the Societies of Control' in Negotiations: 1972-1990(1995). id.
- M. Feeley and J. Simon The New Penology: Notes on the Emerging Strategy of Corrections and its Implications 1992) 30 Criminology 449 74.
- (1992) Criminology , vol.30 , pp. 449-74
- Feeley, M.¹ Simon, J.²

* 이 정보는 Elsevier사의 SCOPUS DB에서 KISTI가 분석하여 추출한 것입니다.