Evaluation and application of the RD50 for determining acceptable exposure levels of airborne sensory irritants for the general public

Environmental Health Perspectives

Volumn 115, Issue 11, 2007, Pages 1609-1616

  Kuwabara, Yu ^a   Alexeeff, George V ^a   Broadwin, Rachel ^a   Salmon, Andrew G ^a  

^a CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY   (United States)

Author keywords

Alarie test; Exposure levels; LOAEL; RD50; REL; Sensory irritation; TLV

Indexed keywords

IRRITANT AGENT;

AIR POLLUTANT; ANIMAL; ARTICLE; BREATHING; CHEMICALLY INDUCED DISORDER; CHEMISTRY; CLASSIFICATION; DANGEROUS GOODS; DOSE RESPONSE; DRUG EFFECT; ENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURE; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; GOVERNMENT; HUMAN; LUNG FUNCTION TEST; MALE; MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE CONCENTRATION; METHODOLOGY; MOUSE; PUBLIC HEALTH; RISK ASSESSMENT; SENSORY DYSFUNCTION; STANDARD; UNITED STATES;

AIR POLLUTANTS; ANIMALS; CALIFORNIA; DOSE-RESPONSE RELATIONSHIP, DRUG; ENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURE; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES; HUMANS; IRRITANTS; MALE; MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE CONCENTRATION; MICE; PUBLIC HEALTH; RESPIRATION; RESPIRATORY FUNCTION TESTS; RISK ASSESSMENT; SENSATION DISORDERS; UNITED STATES; UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY;

EID: 38449093040     PISSN: 00916765     EISSN: 15529924     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1289/ehp.9848     Document Type: Article

References (95)

1. ACGIH. 2006. TLVs and BEIs, Based on the Documentation of the Threshold Limit Values for Chemical Substances and Physical Agents and Biological Exposure Indices. Cincinnati, OH:American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists.
2. Akesson B, Bengtsson M, Floren I.1986. Visual disturbances after industrial triethylamine exposure. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 57(4):297-302.
3. Alarie Y. 1966. Irritating properties of airborne materials to the upper respiratory tract. Arch Environ Health 13(4):433-449.
4. Alarie Y. 1973a. Sensory irritation by airborne chemicals. CRC Crit Rev Toxicol 2(3):299-363.
5. Alarie Y. 1973b. Sensory irritation of the upper airways by airborne chemicals. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 24(2):279-297.
6. Alarie Y. 1981a. Bioassay for evaluating the potency of airborne sensory irritants and predicting acceptable levels of exposure in man. Food Cosmet Toxicol 19(5):623-626.
7. Alarie Y. 1981b. Dose-response analysis in animal studies: prediction of human responses. Environ Health Perspect 42:9-13.
8. Alarie Y. 1981c. Toxicological evaluation of airborne cemical irritants and allergens using respiratory reflex reactions. In: Proceedings of the Inhalation Toxicology and Technology Symposium (Leong BKJ, ed). Ann Arbor, MI:Ann Arbor Science Publications, 207-231.
9. Alarie Y. 1998. Computer-based bioassay for evaluation of sensory irritation of airborne chemicals and its limit of detection. Arch Toxicol 72(5):277-282.
10. Alarie Y. 2000. Computerized animal bioassay to evaluate the effects of airborne chemicals on the respiratory tract. In: Indoor Air Quality Handbook (Spengler JD, Samet JM, McCarthy JF, eds). New York:McGraw-Hill, 24.1-24.25.
11. Alarie Y, Luo JE. 1986. Sensory irritation by airborne chemicals: a basis to establish acceptable levels of exposure. In: Toxicology of the Nasal Passages (Barrow CS, ed). New York:Hemisphere Publishing, 91-100.
12. Alarie Y, Nielsen GD, Schaper MM. 2000. Animal bioassays for evaluation of indoor air quality. In: Indoor Air Quality Handbook (Spengler JD, Samet JM, McCarthy JF, eds). New York:McGraw-Hill, 23.1-23.49.
13. Alexeeff GV, Broadwin R, Liaw J, Dawson SV. 2002. Characterization of the LOAEL-to-NOAEL uncertainty factor for mild adverse effects from acute inhalation exposures. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 36(1):96-105.
14. Andersen I, Molhave L. 1983. Controlled human studies with formaldehyde. In: Formaldehyde Toxicity (Gibson JE, ed). Washington, DC:Hemisphere, 154-164.
15. Andersen I, Molhave L, Proctor DF. 1981. Human responses to controlled levels of combinations of sulfur dioxide and inert dust. Scand J Environ Health 7:1-7.
16. Anglen DM. 1981. Sensory Response of Human Subjects to Chlorine in Air [PhD Thesis]. Ann Arbor, MI:University of Michigan.
17. Apol A. 1981. Health Hazard Evaluation Report. Seattle, WA:National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Hazard Evaluation and Technical Assistance Branch.
18. ASTM. 2004. Standard Test Method for Estimating Sensory Irritancy of Airborne Chemicals. West Conshohocken, PA:ASTM International.
19. Baelum J, Lundqvist GR, Molhave L, Andersen NT. 1990. Human response to varying concentrations of toluene. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 62(1):65-71.
20. Barrow CS, Alarie Y, Stock MF. 1978. Sensory irritation and incapacitation evoked by thermal decomposition products of polymers and comparisons with known sensory irritants. Arch Environ Health 33(2):79-88.
21. Barrow CS, Alarie Y, Warrick JC, Stock MF. 1977. Comparison of the sensory irritation response in mice to chlorine and hydrogen chloride. Arch Environ Health 32:68-76.
22. Barrow CS, Buckley LA, James RA, Steinhagen WH, Chang JCF. 1986. Sensory irritation: studies on correlation to pathology, structure-activity, tolerance development, and prediction of species differences to nasal injury. In: Toxicology of Nasal Passages (Barrow CS, ed). Washington, DC:Hemisphere, 101-122.
23. Baur X. 1985. Isocyanate Hypersensitivity: Final Report to the International Isocyanate Insititute Project E-AB-19, File 10349. Munich, West Germany:University of Munich.
24. 2 in workroom concentrations on respiratory mechanics and bronchial susceptibility to acetylcholine in normal persons [in German]. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 38(1):31-44.
25. Bender JR, Mullin LS, Graepel GJ, Wilson WE. 1983. Eye irritation response of humans to formaldehyde. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 44(6):463-465.
26. Bos PM, Busschers M, Arts JH. 2002. Evaluation of the sensory irritation test (Alarie test) for the assessment of respiratory tract irritation. J Occup Environ Med 44(10):968-976.
27. Bos PM, Busschers M, Arts JH. 2003. Reply to: Sensory irritation testing. J Occup Environ Med 45(5):467.
28. Bos PM, Zwart A, Reuzel PG, Bragt PC. 1992. Evaluation of the sensory irritation test for the assessment of occupational health risk. Crit Rev Toxicol 21(6):423-450.
29. Boylstein LA, Luo J, Stock MF, Alarie Y. An attempt to define a just detectable effect for airborne chemicals on the respiratory tract in mice. Arch Toxicol 70(9):567-578.
30. Carpenter CP, Shaffer B, Weil CS, Smyth J, H.F. 1944. Studies on the inhalation of 1:3-butadiene; with a comparison of its narcotic effect with benzol, toluol, and styrene, and a note on the elimination of styrene by the human. J Ind Hyg Toxic 26(3):69-78.
31. Chang JC, Steinhagen WH, Barrow CS. 1981. Effect of single or repeated formaldehyde exposure on minute volume of B6C3F1 mice and F-344 rats. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 61(3):451-459.
32. Collins JF, Alexeeff GV, Lewis DC, Dodge DE, Marty MA, Parker TR, et al. 2004. Development of acute inhalation reference exposure levels (RELs) to protect the public from predictable excursions of airborne toxicants. J Appl Toxicol 24(2):155-166.
33. D'Alessandro A, Kuschner W, Wong H, Boushey HA, Blanc PD. 1996. Exaggerated responses to chlorine inhalation among persons with nonspecific airway hyperreactivity. Chest 109(2):331-337.
34. Dalton P, Wysocki CJ, Brody MJ, Lawley HJ. 1997. Perceived odor, irritation, and health symptoms following short-term exposure to acetone. Am J Ind Med 31(5):558-569.
35. Day JH, Lees RE, Clark RH, Pattee PL.1984. Respiratory response to formaldehyde and off-gas of urea formaldehyde foam insulation. Can Med Assoc J 131(9):1061-1065.
36. de Ceaurriz JC, Micillino JC, Bonnet P, Guenier JP. 1981. Sensory irritation caused by various industrial airborne chemicals. Toxicol Lett 9(2):137-143.
37. Dudek B, Gralewicz K, Jakubowski M, Kostrzewski P, Sokal J. 1990. Neurobehavioral effects of experimental exposure to toluene, xylene and their mixture. Pol J Occup Med 3(1):109-116.
38. Dunlap MK, Kodama JK, Wellington JS, Anderson HH, Hine CH. 1958. The toxicity of allyl alcohol. AMA Arch Ind Health 4:303-311.
39. Ferguson JS, Schaper M, Stock MF, Weyel DA, Alarie Y. 1986. Sensory and pulmonary irritation with exposure to methyl isocyanate. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 82(2):329-335.
40. Frampton MW, Morrow PE, Cox C, Gibb FR, Speers DM, Utell MJ. 1991. Effects of nitrogen dioxide exposure on pulmonary function and airway reactivity in normal humans. Am Rev Respir Dis 143(3):522-527.
41. Gagnaire F, Azim S, Bonnet P, Hecht G, Hery M. 1994. Comparison of the sensory irritation response in mice to chlorine and nitrogen trichloride. J Appl Toxicol 14(6):405-409.
42. Gagnaire F, Azim S, Bonnet P, Simon P, Guenier JP, de Ceaurriz J. 1989. Nasal irritation and pulmonary toxicity of aliphatic amines in mice. J Appl Toxicol 9(5):301-304.
43. Green DJ, Bascom R, Healey EM, Hebel JR, Sauder LR, Kulle TJ. 1989. Acute pulmonary response in healthy, nonsmoking adults to inhalation of formaldehyde and carbon. J Toxicol Environ Health 28(3):261-275.
44. Hake CL, Stewart RD, Wu A, Graff SA, Forster HV, Keeler WH, et al. 1981. p-Xylene: Development of a Biologic Standard for the Industrial Worker by Breath Analysis. Cincinnati, OH:National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health.
45. Hansen LF, Knudsen A, Nielsen GD. 1992. Sensory irritation effects of methyl ethyl ketone and its receptor activation mechanism. Pharmacol Toxicol 71(3 Pt 1):201-208.
46. Hine CH, Meyers F, Ivanhoe F, Walker S, Takahashi GH. 1961. Simple tests of respiratory function and study of sensory response in human subjects exposed to respiratory tract irritants. In: Proceedings of The Fifth Air Pollution Medical Research Conference: Symposium on Human Exposures to Air Pollutants 1961. Berkeley, CA:California State Department of Health, 20-38.
47. Horvath EP Jr, Anderson H Jr, Pierce WE, Hanrahan L, Wendlick JD. 1988. Effects of formaldehyde on the mucous membranes and lungs. A study of an industrial population. JAMA 259(5):701-707.
48. James JT, Buettner LC, Hsu SS. 1987. Sensory irritation of methylisocyanate vapor. J Appl Toxicol 7(2):147-148.
49. Joosting PE, Verberk MM. 1975. Emergency population exposure: a methodological approach (with a report on a human experiment with chlorine). In: International Symposium on the Recent Advances in the Assessment of the Health Effects of Environmental Pollution, Paris, France, 1974. Luxembourg:Commission of the European Communities, WHO, 2005-2029.
50. Kane LE, Alarie Y. 1977. Sensory irritation to formaldehyde and acrolein during single and repeated exposures in mice. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 38(10):509-522.
51. Kane LE, Barrow CS, Alarie Y. 1979. A short-term test to predict acceptable levels of exposure to airborne sensory irritants. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 40:207-229.
52. Kane LE, Dombroske R, Alarie Y. 1980. Evaluation of sensory irritation from some common industrial solvents. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 41(6):451-455.
53. Kimmerle G, Eben A. 1964. On the toxicity of methylisocyanate and its quantitative determination in the air [in German]. Arch Toxicol 20:235-241.
54. Krakowiak A, Gorski P, Pazdrak K, Ruta U. 1998. Airway response to formaldehyde inhalation in asthmatic subjects with suspected respiratory formaldehyde sensitization. Am J Ind Med 33(3):274-281.
55. Kristiansen U, Vinggaard AM, Nielsen GD. 1988. The effects of n-butanol vapour on respiratory rate and tidal volume. Arch Toxicol 61(3):229-236.
56. Kulle TJ, Sauder LR, Hebel JR, Green DJ, Chatham MD. 1987. Formaldehyde dose-response in healthy nonsmokers. JAPCA 37(8):919-924.
57. MacEwen J, Vernot E. 1972. Annual Technical Report. Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, OH:Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory, Toxic Hazards Research Unit.
58. Mohsenin V. 1988. Airway responses to 2.0 ppm nitrogen dioxide in normal subjects. Arch Environ Health 43(3):242-246.
59. Moscato G, Biscaldi G, Cottica D, Pugliese F, Candura S, Candura F. 1987. Occupational asthma due to styrene: two case reports. J Occup Med 29(12):957-960.
60. Muller J, Greff G. 1984. Relation between the toxicity of molecules of industrial value and their physico-chemical properties: test of upper airway irritation applied to 4 chemical groups [in French]. Food Chem Toxicol 22(8):661-664.
61. Muttray A, Jung D, Klimek L, Kreiner C. 2002. Effects of an external exposure to 200 ppm methyl ethyl ketone on nasal mucosa in healthy volunteers. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 75(3):197-200.
62. Myou S, Fujimura M, Nishi K, Matsuda M, Ohka T, Matsuda T. 1994. Potentiating effect of inhaled acetaldehyde on bronchial responsiveness to methacholine in asthmatic subjects. Thorax 49(7):644-648.
63. Nelson KW, Ege J, J.F., Morwick R, Woodman LE, Silverman L. 1943. Sensory response to certain industrial solvent vapors. J Ind Hyg Toxic 25(7):282-285.
64. Nielsen GD, Alarie Y. 1982. Sensory irritation, pulmonary irritation, and respiratory stimulation by airborne benzene and alkylbenzenes: prediction of safe industrial exposure levels and correlation with their thermodynamic properties. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 65(3):459-477.
65. Nielsen GD, Alarie Y, Poulsen OM, Nexo BA. 1995. Possible mechanisms for the respiratory tract effects of noncarcinogenic indoor-climate pollutants and bases for their risk assessment. Scand J Work Environ Health 21:165-178.
66. Nielsen GD, Bakbo JC, Holst E. 1984. Sensory irritation and pulmonary irritation by airborne allyl acetate, allyl alcohol, and allyl ether compared to acrolein. Acta Pharmacol Toxicol (Copenh) 54(4):292-298.
67. Nielsen GD, Hougaard KS, Larsen ST, Hammer M, Wolkoff P, Clausen PA, et al. 1999. Acute airway effects of formaldehyde and ozone in BALB/c mice. Hum Exp Toxicol 18:400-409.
68. Nielsen GD, Yamagiwa M. 1989. Structure-activity relationships of airway irritating aliphatic amines. Receptor activation mechanisms and predicted industrial exposure limits. Chem Biol Interact 71(2-3):223-244.
69. Pazdrak K, Gorski P, Krakowiak A, Ruta U. 1993. Changes in nasal lavage fluid due to formaldehyde inhalation. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 64(7):515-519.
70. Plotnikova MM. 1960. Basic Investigations for the Determination of the Limit of Allowable Acrolein Concentration in Atmospheric Air. Washington, DC:U.S. Department of Commerce.
71. Pozzani UC, Carpenter CP. 1963. Methyl Isocyanate, Special Report 26-23. Pittsburgh, PA:Mellon Institute.
72. Rotman HH, Fliegelman MJ, Moore T, Smith RG, Anglen DM, Kowalski CJ, et al. 1983. Effects of low concentrations of chlorine on pulmonary function in humans. J Appl Physiol 54(4):1120-1124.
73. Sangha GK, Alarie Y. 1979. Sensory irritation by toluene diisocyanate in single and repeated exposures. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 50(3):533-547.
74. Sauder LR, Chatham MD, Green DJ, Kulle TJ. 1986. Acute pulmonary response to formaldehyde exposure in healthy nonsmokers. J Occup Med 28(6):420-424.
75. Sauder LR, Green DJ, Chatham MD, Kulle TJ. 1987. Acute pulmonary response of asthmatics to 3.0 ppm formaldehyde. Toxicol Ind Health 3(4):569-578.
76. Schachter EN, Witek TJ Jr., Brody DJ, Tosun T, Beck GJ, Leaderer BP. 1987. A study of respiratory effects from exposure to 2.0 ppm formaldehyde in occupationally exposed workers. Environ Res 44(2):188-205.
77. Schachter EN, Witek TJ Jr., Tosun T, Leaderer BP, Beck GJ. 1986. A study of respiratory effects from exposure to 2 ppm formaldehyde in healthy subjects. Arch Environ Health 41(4):229-239.
78. Schaper M. 1993. Development of a database for sensory irritants and its use in establishing occupational exposure limits. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 54(9):488-544.
79. Seeber A, Kiesswetter E, Vangala RR, Blaszkewicz M, Golka K. 1992. Combined exposure to organic solvents: an experimental approach using acetone and ethyl acetate. Appl Psychol Int Rev 41(3):281-292.
80. Shusterman D, Matovinovic E, Salmon AG. 2006. Does Haber's Law apply to human sensory irritation? Inhal Toxicol 18:457-471.
81. Silverman L, Schulte HF, First MW. 1946. Further studies on sensory response to certain industrial solvent vapors. J Ind Hyg Toxic 28(6):262-266.
82. Smyth HF Jr, Kinkead ER, Pozzani UCS. 1970. Methyl isocyanate: acute inhalation toxicity humans responses to low concentrations, guinea pig sensitization and cross sensitization to other isocyanates. In: Compilation of Toxicology on Methyl Isocyanate (Browning JB, ed). Pittsburgh, PA:Mellon Institute, 21-28.
83. Steinhagen WH, Barrow CS. 1984. Sensory irritation structureactivity study of inhaled aldehydes in B6C3F1 and Swiss-Webster mice. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 72(3):495-503.
84. Stephens ER, Darley EF, Taylor OC, Scott WE. 1961. Photochemical reaction products in air pollution. Int J Air and Water Poll 4(1/2):79-100.
85. Stewart RD, Dodd HC, Baretta ED, Schaffer AW. 1968. Human exposure to styrene vapor. Arch Environ Health 16(5): 656-662.
86. Stewart RD, Hake CL, Wu A, Graff SA, Forster HV, Keeler WH, et al. 1975. Acetone: Development of a Biologic Standard for the Industrial Worker by Breath Analysis. NTIS PB82172917. Milwaukee, WI:Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee Department of Environmental Medicine, U.S. Department of Commerce.
87. Stone LC, Lawhorne GT, McKinney JC, McCracken MS. 1981. Upper respiratory tract sensory responses to volatile chemicals. Toxicologist 1:134.
88. Sundblad BM, Larsson BM, Acevedo F, Ernstgard L, Johanson G, Larsson K, et al. 2004. Acute respiratory effects of exposure to ammonia on healthy persons. Scand J Work Environ Health 30(4):313-321.
89. Tomas T, Oliskiewicz W, Czerczak S, Sokal J. 1985. Decrease in the respiration rate in mice as an indicator of the irritating effects of chemical substances on the upper respiratory tract [in Polish]. Med Pr 36(5):295-302.
90. U.S. EPA. 2007. Benchmark Dose Software (BMDS): Benchmark Dose Methodology. Washington, DC:U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Available: http://www.epa.gov/ncea/bmds/bmds_training/methodology/intro.htm [accessed 10 October 2007].
91. Verberk MM. 1977. Effects of ammonia in volunteers. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 39(2):73-81.
92. Vijayaraghavan R, Schaper M, Thompson R, Stock MF, Boylstein LA, Luo JE, et al. 1994. Computer assisted recognition and quantitation of the effects of airborne chemicals acting at differing areas of the respiratory tract. Arch Toxicol 68:490-499.
93. 2 alone and in combination. In: Proceedings of the Fourth International Clean Air Conference (Kasuga S, Suzuki N, Yamada T, Kimura G, Inagaki K, Onoe K, eds). Tokyo, Japan:Japanese Union of Air Pollution Prevention Associations, 5-8.
94. Weber-Tschopp A, Fischer T, Grandjean E. 1977. Irritating effects of formaldehyde on man [in German]. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 39(4):207-218.
95. Wolf MA, Rowe VK, McCollister DD, Hollingsworth RL, Oyen F. 1956. Toxicological studies of certain alkylated benzenes and benzene; experiments on laboratory animals. AMA Arch Ind Health 14(4):387-398.