Mechanisms as miracle makers? The rise and inconsistencies of the "mechanismic approach" in social science and history

History and Theory

Volumn 44, Issue 3, 2005, Pages 348-372

  Norkus, Zenonas ^a  

^a VILNIUS UNIVERSITY   (Lithuania)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 36049032316     PISSN: 00182656     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-2303.2005.00329.x     Document Type: Review

References (123)

1. Jon Elster, Explaining Technical Change (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 1983)
2. Social Mechanisms: An Analytical Approach to Social Theory, ed. P. Hedström and R. Swedberg (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 1998)
3. Charles Tilly, "Means and Ends of Comparison in Macrosociology, " Comparative Social Research 16 (1997), 43-53
4. Tilly, Durable Inequality (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998)
5. Tilly, "Historical Analysis of Political Processes," in Handbook of Sociological Theory, ed. Jonathan H. Turner (New York: Kluwer, 2001), 567-588
6. Tilly, "Mechanisms in Political Processes," Annual Review of Political Science 4 (2001), 21-41
7. Tilly, Stories, Identities, and Political Changes (Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 2002)
8. Tilly, The Politics of Collective Violence (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 2003)
9. Jon Elster, Alchemies of the Mind: Rationality and Emotions (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 1999)
10. Elster, Ulysses Unbound: Studies in Rationality, Precommitment, and Constraints (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 2000)
11. J. Rule, Theory and Progress in Social Science (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 1997), 45-48
12. A. Bennett, "Beyond Hempel and Back to Hume: Causal Mechanisms and Causal Explanations," http://www.asu.edu/clas/polisci/cqrm/APSA2003/ Bennett-APSA-2003.pdf
13. J. Gerring, "Causation: A Unified Framework for the Social Sciences," http://www.asu.edu/clas/polisci/cqrm/APSA2003/Gerring-APSA-2003. pdf
14. J. Mahoney, "Tentative Answers to Questions about Causal Mechanisms," http://www.asu.edu/clas/polisci/cqrm/APSA2003/Mahoney-APSA- 2003.pdf. All three papers were presented at the American Political Science Association annual conference, Philadelphia, August 28, 2003, and were accessed online on April 18, 2004
15. Mario Bunge, '"How Does It Work?: The Search for Explanatory Mechanisms," Philosophy of the Social Sciences 34:2 (2004), 182-210
16. Patrick James, "Systemism, Social Mechanisms, and Scientific Progress: A Case Study of the International Crisis Behavior Project," Philosophy of the Social Sciences 34:3 (2004), 352-370
17. Renate Mayntz, "Mechanisms in the Analysis of Social Macro-Phenomena," Philosophy of the Social Sciences 34:2 (2004), 237-259
18. R. Keith Sawyer, "The Mechanisms of Emergence," Philosophy of the Social Sciences 34:2 (2004), 260-282
19. Colin Wight, "Theorizing the Mechanisms of Conceptual and Semiotic Space," Philosophy of the Social Sciences 34:2 (2004), 283-299
20. Stefan Berger, "Social History vs. Cultural History: A German Debate," Theory, Culture & Society 18:1 (2001), 145-153
21. Jürgen Kocka, "Losses, Gains and Opportunities: Social History Today," Journal of Social History 37:1 (2003), 21-28
22. William H. Sewell, Jr., "Whatever Happened to the 'Social' in Social History?," in Schools of Thought: Twenty Five Years of Interpretive Social Science, ed. Joan W. Scott and Debra Keates (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2001)
23. Thomas Welskopp, "Social History," in Writing History: Theory & Practice, ed. Stefan Berger, Hans Feldner, and Kevin Passmore (London: Arnold, 2003), 203-222
24. R. Biernacki, "Language and the Shift from Signs to Practices in Cultural Inquiry," History and Theory 39 ( 2000), 289-310
25. Kocka, "Losses, Gains and Opportunities"
26. Welskopp, "Social History."
27. Tilly, "Means and Ends of Comparison in Macrosociology"
28. Tilly, Durable Inequality
29. Tilly, "Mechanisms in Political Processes"
30. Tilly, Stories, Identities, and Political Changes
31. Tilly, The Politics of Collective Violence
32. Doug McAdam, Sidney G. Tarrow, and Charles Tilly, Dynamics of Contention (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 2001)
33. Tilly, "Historical Analysis of Political Processes"
34. McAdam et al., Dynamics of Contention
35. Mahoney, "Tentative Answers to Questions about Causal Mechanisms."
36. R. Boudon, "Social Mechanisms without Black Boxes," in Hedström and Swedberg, eds., Social Mechanisms, 172
37. T. Cowen, "Do Economists Use Social Mechanisms to Explain?' in Hedström and Swedberg, eds., Social Mechanisms, 125-146
38. Mahoney, "Tentative Answers to Questions about Causal Mechanisms, " 13
39. A. Bennett and A. L. George, "Process Tracing and Case Study Research," paper presented at the MacArthur Foundation Workshop on Case Study Methods, Harvard University (October 17-19, 1997), 1 (http://www. georgetown.edu/faculty/bennetta/PROTCG.htm, accessed April 18, 2004)
40. Hedström and Swedberg, eds., Social Mechanisms
41. D. Little, Varieties of Social Explanation: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Social Science (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1991), 15
42. Mahoney, "Tentative Answers to Questions about Causal Mechanisms, " 4
43. Elster, Alchemies of the Mind, 1
44. Mahoney, "Tentative Answers to Questions about Causal Mechanisms, " 14
45. Cf. A. Abbott, The Chaos of Disciplines (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2001), 3-33
46. D. Gambetta, "Concatenations of Mechanisms," in Hedström and Swedberg, eds., Social Mechanisms, 102-124
47. For example, J. H. Goldthorpe, On Sociology: Numbers, Narratives, and the Integration of Research and Theory (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000)
48. For example, Bennett and George, "Process Tracing and Case Study Research."
49. P. K. MacDonald, "Useful Fiction or Miracle Maker: The Competing Epistemological Foundations of Rational Choice Theory," American Political Science Review 97:4 (2003), 551-565
50. T. Mayer, Analytical Marxism (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 1994)
51. Analytical Marxism, ed. J. Roemer (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 1986)
52. Elster, Explaining Technical Change, 24
53. Jon Elster, Nuts and Bolts for the Social Sciences (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 1989)
54. Jon Elster, Political Psychology (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1993), 2
55. Cf. Jon Elster, Ulysses and the Sirens: Studies in Rationality and Irrationality (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 1984)
56. Elster, Ulysses Unbound
57. Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, ed. D. Kahneman, P. Slovic, and A. Tversky (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 1982)
58. Choices, Values, and Frames, ed. D. Kahneman and A. Tversky (New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 2000)
59. K. F. Schaffner, "Approaches to Reduction," Philosophy of Science 34 (1967), 137-147
60. P. M. Churchland, "Eliminative Materialism and Prepositional Attitudes," Journal of Philosophy 78:2 (1981), 67-90
61. S. P. Stich, From Folk Psychology to Cognitive Science (Cambridge, Mass.: Bradford, 1983)
62. Cf. Elster, Alchemies of the Mind, 6-7
63. Little, Varieties of Social Explanation, 24-25
64. D. Steel, "Social Mechanisms and Causal Inference," Philosophy of the Social Sciences 34:1 (2004), 61
65. Steel, "Social Mechanisms and Causal Inference," 61
66. Goldthorpe, On Sociology, 149
67. J. Woodward, "Causal Models, Probabilities, and Invariance," in Causality in Crisis? Statistical Methods and the Search for Causal Knowledge in the Social Sciences, ed. Vaughn R. McKim and Stephen P. Turner (Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 1997), 285-286
68. Donald B. Rubin, "Estimating Causal Effects of Treatments in Randomized and Nonrandomized Samples," Journal of Educational Psychology 66 (1974), 688-701
69. Paul Holland, "Statistics and Causal Inference," Journal of the American Statistical Association 81 (1986), 945-960
70. Gary King, Robert O. Keohane, and Sidney Verba, Designing Social Inquiry: Scientific Inference in Qualitative Research (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1994)
71. King, Keohane, and Verba, Designing Social Inquiry, 81-82
72. James Woodward, Making Things Happen: A Theory of Causal Explanation (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003)
73. See, for example, S. Goldenberg, "Rediscovering and Confronting Critical Ambiguities in the Determination of Causality," Quality and Quantity 32 (1998), 181
74. C. Glymour, "Representations and Misrepresentations: Reply to Humphreys and Woodward," in McKim and Turner, eds., Causality in Crisis?, 317
75. D. K. Henderson, "Accounting for Macro-Level Causation," Synthese 101 (1994), 129-154
76. H. Kineaid, Philosophical Foundations of the Social Sciences: Analyzing Controversies in Social Research (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 1996), 142-190
77. L. Udehn, Methodological Individualism: Background, History and Meaning (London: Routledge, 2001), 320-356
78. Woodward, Making Things Happen, 25-93; 350-373
79. W. V. O. Quine, From a Logical Point of View (Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1953), 42-46
80. J. Williamson, "Learning Causal Relationships," paper presented at the Causality: Metaphysics and Methods Conference, London School of Economics (June 20-21, 2002), 5. http://www.lse.ac.uk/Depts/cpnss/pdf/pdfcaus/ CTR%2002-02.pdf, accessed April 29, 2004
81. P. Spirtes, C. Glymour, and R. Scheines, Causation, Prediction, and Search (New York: Springer, 1993)
82. R. Scheines, "An Introduction to Causal Inference," in McKim and Turner, eds., Causality in Crisis?
83. C. Glymour, "A Review of Recent Work on the Foundations of Causal Inference," in McKim and Turner, eds., Causality in Crisis?
84. J. Pearl, "Graphs, Structural Models, and Causality," in Computation, Causation, and Discovery, ed. Clark Glymour and Gregory F. Cooper (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 1999), 95-138
85. J. Pearl, Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press 2000)
86. See Williamson, "Learning Causal Relationships," 4
87. For criticisms, see P. Humphreys, "A Critical Appraisal of Causal Discovery Algorithms," in McKim and Turner, eds., Causality in Crisis?
88. P. Humphreys and D. Freedman, "The Grand Leap," British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 47 (1996), 113-123
89. Charles Ragin, The Comparative Method: Moving beyond Qualitative and Quantitative Strategies (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1987)
90. A. Bennett and A. L. George, "Case Studies and Process Tracing in History and Political Science: Similar Strokes for Different Foci," in Bridges and Boundaries: Historians, Political Scientists, and the Study of International Relations, ed. Colin Elman and Miriam Fendius Elman (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 2001), 137-166
91. J. Mahoney, "Strategies of Causal Inference in Small-N Analysis," Sociological Methods & Research 28:4 (2000), 409-417
92. J. Mahoney, "Nominal, Ordinal, and Narrative Appraisal in Macrocausal Analysis," American Journal of Sociology 104:4 (1999), 1164-1169
93. Theda Skocpol, States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia, and China (Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge University Press, 1979), 33
94. Mahoney, "Strategies of Causal Inference," 413, 416) reconstruct the "logic-in-use" of Skocpol's famous causal argument, criticizing her account of this logic as inadequate
95. Clayton Roberts, The Logic of Historical Explanation (University Park, PA: The Pennsylvania State University Press, 1996)
96. Roberts, The Logic of Historical Explanation, 105-118
97. G. Genette, Narrative Discourse: An Essay in Method [1972] (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1980), 27-29
98. Tilly, "Historical Analysis of Political Processes," 569
99. Tilly, "Historical Analysis of Political Processes," 572
100. Tilly, "Means and Ends of Comparison in Macrosociology," 47
101. W. Bechtel and R. C.Richardson, Discovering Complexity: Decomposition and Localization as Strategies in Scientific Research (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1993)
102. C. F. Craver, "Role Functions, Mechanisms, and Hierarchy," Philosophy of Science 68:1 (2001), 53-74
103. C. F Craver, "Interlevel Experiments, Multilevel Mechanisms in the Neuroscience of Memory," Philosophy of Science (Supplement) 69 (2002), S83-S97
104. C. F. Craver, "The Making of a Memory Mechanism," Journal of the History of Biology 36 ( 2003), 153-195
105. C. F. Craver and L. Darden, "Discovering Mechanisms in Neurobiology: The Case of Spatial Memory," in Theory and Method in the Neurosciences, ed. P. Machamer, R. Grush, and P. McLaughlin (Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 2001), 112-137
106. L. Darden, "Strategies for Discovering Mechanisms: Schema Instantiation, Modular Subassembly, Forward/Backward Chaining," Philosophy of Science (Supplement) 69 ( 2002), S354-S365
107. L. Darden and C. F Craver, "Strategies in the Interfield Discovery of the Mechanism of Protein Synthesis," Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 33 (2002), 1-28
108. S. S. Glennan, "Mechanisms and the Nature of Causation," Erkenntnis 44:1 (1996), 49-71
109. S. S. Glennan, "Rethinking Mechanistic Explanation," Philosophy of Science (Supplement) 69 (2002), S342-S353
110. P. K. Machamer, L. Darden, and C. F. Craver, "Thinking about Mechanisms," Philosophy of Science 67:1 (2000), 1-25
111. J. G. Tabery, "Synthesizing Activities and Interactions in the Concept of a Mechanism," Philosophy of Science 71:1 ( 2004), 1-15
112. P. Thagard, How Scientists Explain Disease (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1999)
113. J. Woodward, "What is a Mechanism? A Counterfactual Account," Philosophy of Science (Supplement) 69 (2002), S366-S377
114. Machamer et al., "Thinking about Mechanisms," 3
115. Darden, "Strategies for Discovering Mechanisms," S360
116. Louis O. Mink, Historical Understanding (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1987), 182-203
117. J. L. Gaddis, The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002), 35-70
118. P. Abell, "Narrative Explanation: An Alternative to Variable-Centered Explanation," Annual Review of Sociology 30 (2004), 287-310
119. G. F. Schueler, Reasons and Purposes: Human Rationality and the Teleologicai Explanation of Action (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2003)
120. Charles Taylor, The Explanation of Behaviour (London: Routledge, 1964)
121. G. H. Von Wright, Explanation and Understanding (London: Routledge, 1971)
122. Charles C. Ragin, "Case Oriented Research and the Study of Social Action," in Rational Choice Theory and Large Scale Data Analysis, ed. H.-P. Blossfeld and G. Prein (Boulder, CO: West-view Press, 1997), 158-168
123. P. Abell, "Causality and Low-Frequency Complex Events: The Role of Comparative Narratives," Sociological Methods and Research 30:1 (2001), 67