Towards institutional symbiosis: Business and the United Nations in environmental governance

Review of European Community and International Environmental Law

Volumn 16, Issue 2, 2007, Pages 123-134

  Ivanova, Maria ^a   Gordon, David ^a   Roy, Jennifer ^a  

^a Dept of Economics and Thomas Jefferson Program in Public Policy at the College of William and Mary

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

BUSINESS; COMMUNITY ORGANIZATION; ENVIRONMENTAL LEGISLATION; ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY; UNITED NATIONS;

EID: 34548501538     PISSN: 09628797     EISSN: 14679388     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-9388.2007.00558.x     Document Type: Article

References (101)

1. International Chamber of Commerce, ICC Comment on 'Delivering as One', Report of the UN Secretary-General's High-Level Panel on System-Wide Coherence (ICC, 2007).
2. J.G. Speth, Red Sky at Morning: America and the Crisis of the Global Environment (Yale University Press, 2004), at 82-83 and 88.
3. United Nations, United Nations Global Compact: The Ten Principles (UN, 2007), availabe at .
4. J.P. Therien and V. Pouliot, 'The Global Compact: Shifting the Politics of International Development?', 12:1 Global Governance (2006), 55
5. G. Kell, 'The Global Compact - Origins, Operations, Progress and Challenges', 11:1 Journal of Corporate Citizenship (2003), 35
6. D.C. Esty, and A. Winston, Green to Gold: How Smart Companies Use Environmental Strategy to Innovate, Create Value, and Build Competitive Advantage (Yale University Press, 2006)
7. J. Bendell, 'Flags of Inconvenience? The Global Compact and the Future of the United Nations', 22 ICCSR Research Paper Series (2004)
8. P. Utting, 'The Global Compact and Civil Society: Averting a Collision Course', 12:5 Development in Practice (2002), 644
9. P. Utting, 'The Global Compact: Why All the Fuss?', 11:1 United Nations Chronicle (2003), 65.
10. W. Laufer, 'Social Accountability and Corporate Greenwashing', 43:3 Journal of Business Ethics (2003), 253.
11. R. Falkner, 'Private Environmental Governance and International Relations: Exploring the Links', 3:2 Global Environmental Politics (2003), 72.
12. C. Gregoratti, The UN Global Compact's Growing Sustainable Business Initiative: A Critical Assessment, paper presented at Conference on World Orders and Global Governance: New Perspectives and Challenges (University of Manchester, 19 January 2007).
13. See D.C. Esty and A. Winston, n. 4 above.
14. The Holy See, which holds the sovereignty over the Vatican, is the only non-Member State and holds observer status since 1964.
15. J. Clapp, 'Global Environmental Governance for Corporate Responsibility', 5:3 Global Environmental Politics (2005), 23.
16. SAM Group and Price Waterhouse Coopers, The Sustainability Yearbook 2007 (SAM Group, 2007).
17. Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, Ecosystems and Human Well-Being: Opportunities and Challenges for Business and Industry (Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 2005), available at .
18. For a discussion of international organizations as autonomous actors, see, e.g., M. Barnett, and M. Finnemore, Rules for the World: International Organizations in Global Politics (Cornell University Press, 2004).
19. Reuters, 'Indian Air is Highly Polluted, Study Finds', New York Times (4 June 2006), at 14.
20. E. Morgera, 'The UN and Corporate Environmental Responsibility: Between International Regulation and Partnerships', 15:1 RECIEL (2006), 93.
21. P. Newell, 'Business and International Environmental Governance: The State of the Art', in D. Levy and P. Newell, The Business of Global Environmental Governance (MIT Press, 2005), 21.
22. See J. Clapp, n. 10 above, at 24.
23. C. Dean, 'Executive on a Mission: Saving the Planet', New York Times (22 May 2007), section F, at 1.
24. See M. Barnett, and M. Finnemore, n. 13 above.
25. M. Ivanova and J. Roy, 'The Architecture of Global Environmental Governance: The Pros and Cons of Multiplicity', in L. Swart and E. Perry, Global Environmental Governance: Perspectives on the Current Debate (Center for UN Reform Education, 2007).
26. See Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, n. 12 above.
27. Ibid.
28. J. Lin, 'Tackling Southeast Asia's Illegal Wildlife Trade', Singapore Year Book of International Law and Contributors (2005), 191.
29. See M. Karns and K. Mingst, International Organizations: The Politics and Processes of Global Governance (Lynne Rienner Publishers, 2004).
30. United Nations High-Level Panel on System Wide Coherence, Delivering as One: Report of the Secretary General's High Level Panel on System-Wide Coherence (UN, 2006), available at
31. Report of the Secretary-General of the United Nations, In Larger Freedom: Towards Development, Security, and Human Rights for All (A/59/2005, September 2005).
32. World Trade Organization, Trade and Environment: Special Studies 4 (WTO, 1999).
33. M. Ivanova, Can the Anchor Hold? Rethinking the United Nations Environment Programme for the 21st Century (Yale School of Forestry & Environmental Studies, 2005).
34. S. Charnovitz, 'Toward a World Environment Organization: Reflections upon a Vital Debate', in F. Biermann and S. Bauer, A World Environment Organization (Ashgate, 2005), 87
35. M. Ivanova and J. Roy, n. 14 above
36. E. Nowotny, Opening Statement of Ambassador Eva Nowotny at UNEO Seminar (Georgetown University, 29 June 2006)
37. E. Berruga, and P. Maurer, Co-Chair's Summary of the Informal Consultative Process on the Institutional Framework for the UN's Environmental Activities (27 June 2006).
38. S. Oberthur and T. Gehring, 'Reforming International Environmental Governance: An Institutionalist Critique of the Proposal for a World Environment Organization', 4:4 International Environmental Agreements (2007), 359
39. A. Najam, 'The Case Against GEO, WEO, or Whatever-else-EO', in D. Brack and J. Hyvarinen, Global Environmental Institutions: Perspectives on Reform (Royal Institute of International Affairs, 2002)
40. A. Najam, 'The Case Against a New International Environmental Organization', 9:3 Global Governance 2003), 367.
41. See S. Charnovitz, n. 28 above; D.C. Esty, 'The Case for a Global Environmental Organization', in P. Kenen, Managing the World Economy: Fifty Years After Bretton Woods (Institute for International Economics, 1994), 287.
42. Global Environmental Governance Project, Issue Area Involvement Database (GEG Project, 2006), available at .
43. See ICC, n. 1 above, at 1.
44. See S. Oberthur and T. Gehring, n. 29 above.
45. Please see table 3 at the end of this article for a key to all of abbreviations in table 2.
46. K. Raustiala and D.G. Victor, 'The Regime Complex for Plant Genetic Resources', 58:2 International Organization (2004), 277
47. S. Andresen, 'Global Environmental Governance: UN Fragmentation and Co-ordination', in O.S. Stokke and O.B. Thommessen, Yearbook of International Co-operation on Environment and Development (Earthscan Publications, 2001).
48. Meridian Institute, Comparative Analysis of the Forest Stewardship Council and Sustainable Forestry Initiative Certification Programs (Meridian Institute, 2001), available at .
49. See P. Newell, n. 20 above.
50. Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer to the Vienna Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer (Montreal, 16 September 1987).
51. See P. Newell, n. 20 above.
52. See R. Falkner, n. 6 above.
53. World Resources Institute, 'Are Business and Industry Taking Sustainability Seriously', in WRI,World Resources 1998-1999 (World Resources Institute, 1999), at 4.
54. UNEP, Guidelines on Co-operation Between the United Nations Environment Programme and Business (UNEP, 2004), available at .
55. United Nations, Secretary-General's address to meeting on 'The Business Contribution to the Millennium Development Goals' (14 June 2005), available at .
56. F. Mezzalama and L. Ouedraogo, Private Sector Involvement and Cooperation with the United Nations System: Report of the Joint Inspection Unit (UN, 1999).
57. See ICC, n. 1 above.
58. Ibid.
59. See P. Newell, n. 20 above.
60. See J. Clapp, n. 10 above.
61. A. Zammit, Development at Risk: Rethinking UN-Business Partnerships (UNRISD, 2003).
62. Ibid.
63. Ibid.
64. K. Buse and G. Walt, 'The World Health Organization and Global Public-Private Health Partnerships: In Search of "Good" Global Health Governance', in M.R. Reich, Public-Private Partnerships for Public Health (Harvard Center for Population and Development Studies, 2002).
65. See United Nations, n. 25 above.
66. K. Bäckstrand, 'Multi-Stakeholder Partnerships for Sustainable Development: Rethinking Legitimacy, Accountability and Effectiveness', 16:5 European Environment (2006), 290.
67. K. Bäckstrand, Accountability and Legitimacy of Governance, paper presented at the 2005 Berlin Conference Human Dimensions of Global Environmental Change (Berlin, December 2005), at 13-14.
68. Ibid.
69. L.B. Andonova, International Institutions, Inc: The Public-Private Partnerships in Global Governance, paper at the 2005 Berlin Conference on the Human Dimensions Global Environmental Change (Berlin, 2-3 December 2005).
70. M. Ivanova, 'Partnerships, International Organizations, and Environmental Governance', in J.M. Witte et al., Progress Partnerships and Networks in Global Environmental Governance: The Post-Johannesburg Agenda (Global Public Policy Institute,
71. See F. Mezzalama and L. Ouedraogo, n. 44 above.
72. J. Clapp, 'Transnational Corporations and Global Environmental Governance', in P. Dauvergne, Handbook of Global Environmental Politics (Edward Elgar, 2003).
73. See E. Morgera, n. 19 above.
74. L. Andonova, International Organizations as Entrepreneurs of Public-Private Cooperation, paper presented at the Forty-Eighth Annual ISA Convention (Chicago, 28 February-3 March 2007).
75. See D.C. Esty and A. Winston, n. 4 above, at 71.
76. See Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, n. 12 above
77. D. Levy, 'Business and the Evolution of the Climate Regime: The Dynamics of Corporate Strategies', in D. Levy and P. Newell, The Business of Global Environmental Governance (The MIT Press, 2004), 73.
78. See D. Levy, ibid.
79. See Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (Kyoto, 11 December 1997), Article 12.
80. R. Helmke and S. Tesner, Partnering with the Private Sector: The Return of the UN-Business Partnership, lecture at New York University (30 October 2000), available at .
81. 'Everybody's Green Now', 383:8531 The Economist (2 June 2007), at 6.
82. D. Vogel et al., 'Environmental Federalism in the European Union and the United States', in F. Wiken et al., Handbook of Globalization and National Environmental Policy: National Government Interventions in a Global Arena (Edward Elgar Publishing, 2003).
83. See 'Everybody's Green Now', n. 66 above.
84. See P. Newell, n. 20 above.
85. See A. Zammit, n. 49 above.
86. See United Nations, n. 25 above.
87. J. Richter, Engineering of Consent: Uncovering Corporate PR Strategies, Briefing No 6 (The Cornerhouse, 1998).
88. See D.C. Esty and A. Winston, n. 4 above, at 135-137.
89. Ibid.
90. Ibid., at 154.
91. See United Nations, n. 43 above.
92. Stakeholder Research Associates Canada Inc., The Stakeholder Engagement Manual Volume 1: The Guide to Practitioners' Perspectives on Stakeholder Engagement (Alcan Inc., 2005), at 18.
93. Schulich School of Business, Sustainable Enterprise Academy: Report on the Seventh Business Leader Seminar (Schulich School of Business at York University, 2004).
94. WBCSD, Policy Directions to 2050: A Business Contribution to the Dialogues of Cooperative Action (WBCSD, 2007).
95. See Stakeholder Research Associates Canada Inc., n. 77 above.
96. See WBCSD, n. 79 above, at 16.
97. WRI, UNEP and WBCSD, Tomorrow's Markets: Global Trends and their Implications for Business (WRI, 2006).
98. See WTO, n. 26 above, at 7.
99. WBCSD, From Challenge To Opportunity: The Role of Business in Tomorrow's Society (WBCSD, 2002).
100. See Global Environmental Governance (GEG) Project, International Organization Environmental Issue Area Involvement (GEG Project, undated), available at
101. E. Ligteringen and S. Zadek, Executive Briefing: The Future of Corporate Responsibility Codes, Standards and Frameworks (Global Reporting Initiative, 2005).