Comprehension strategies and difficulties in maintaining object-oriented systems: An explorative study

Journal of Systems and Software

Volumn 80, Issue 9, 2007, Pages 1541-1559

  Karahasanović, Amela ^a   Levine, Annette Kristin ^b   Thomas, Richard ^c  

^a SIMULA RESEARCH LABORATORY   (Norway)

^b Software Innovation ASA   (Norway)

^c UNIVERSITY OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA   (Australia)

Author keywords

Experiment; Maintenance; Object oriented; Program comprehension

Indexed keywords

COGNITIVE SYSTEMS; COMPUTER SCIENCE; GRAPHICAL USER INTERFACES; KNOWLEDGE ACQUISITION; OBJECT ORIENTED PROGRAMMING;

APPLICATION STRUCTURE; PROGRAM COMPREHENSION; STRATEGIC KNOWLEDGE;

COMPUTER SOFTWARE MAINTENANCE;

EID: 34547838203     PISSN: 01641212     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jss.2006.10.041     Document Type: Article

References (63)

1. Arisholm E., and Sjøberg D. Evaluating the effect of a delegated versus centralized control style on the maintainability of object-oriented software. IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering 30 8 (2004) 521-534
2. Arisholm E., Sjøberg D.I.K., and Jørgensen M. Assessing the changeability of two object-oriented design alternatives - a controlled experiment. Empirical Software Engineering 6 3 (2001) 231-277
3. Arisholm E., Sjøberg D.I.K., Carelius G., and Lindsjørn Y. A web-based support environment for software engineering experiments. Nordic Journal of Computing 9 4 (2002) 231-247
4. Briand L.C., Bunse C., Daly J.W., and Differding C. An experimental comparison of the maintenability of object-oriented and structured design documents. Empirical Software Engineering 2 (1997) 291-312
5. Brooks R.E. Towards a theory of the comprehension of computer programs. International Journal of Man-Machine Studies (1983) 543-554
6. Burkhardt, J.-M., Détienne, F., Wiedenbeck, S., 1998. The effect of object-oriented programming expertise in several dimensions of comprehension strategies. In: 6th International Workshop on Program Comprehension (IWPC'98), pp. 82-89.
7. Burkhardt J.M., Detienee F., and Wiedenbeck S. Object-oriented program comprehension: effect of expertise, task and phase. Empirical Software Engineering 7 (2002) 115-156
8. Chi M.T. Quantifying qualitative analyses of verbal data: a practical guide. The Journal of the Learning Sciences 6 3 (1997) 271-315
9. Coleman D., Ash D., Lowther B., and Oman P. Using metrics to evaluate software system maintainability. IEEE Computer August 1994 (1994) 44-49
10. Corritore C.L., and Wiedenbeck S. Mental representations of expert procedural and object-oriented programmers in a software maintenance task. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies (1999) 61-83
11. Corritore, C.L., Wiedenbeck, S., 2000. Direction and scope of comprehension-related activities by procedural and object-oriented programmers: an empirical study. In: 8th International Workshop on Program Comprehension.
12. Corritore C.L., and Wiedenbeck S. An exploratory study of program comprehension strategies of procedural and object-oriented programmers. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 54 (2001) 1-23
13. Dale, N., 2005a. SIGCSE members survey. (accessed September 2006).
14. Dale, N., 2005b. Non SIGCSE members survey. (accessed September 2006).
15. Daly J., Brooks A., Miller J., Roper M., and Wood M. Evaluating inheritance depth on the maintenability of object-oriented software. Empirical Software Engineering 1 (1996) 31-48
16. Davies S.P. International Journal of Man-Machine Studies 39 (1993) 237-267
17. De Lucia, A., Fasolino, A.R., Munro, M., 1996. Understanding function behaviours through program slicing. In: 4th Workshop on Program Comprehension (IWPC'96), pp. 9-18.
18. Détienne F. Assessing the cognitive consequences of the object-oriented approach: a survey of empirical research on object-oriented design by individuals and teams. Interacting with Computers 9 (1997) 47-72
19. Détienne F. Software Design - Cognitive Aspects (2002), Springer, London
20. Dreyfus H.L., and Dreyfus S.E. Mind over Machine (1986), The Free Press, New York
21. Dunsmore A., Roper M., and Wood M. The role of comprehension in software inspection. Journal of Systems and Software 52 (2000) 121-129
22. Ericsson K.A., and Simon H.A. Protocol Analysis: Verbal Reports as Data (1993), A Bradford Book, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts
23. Eriksson, H.E., Penker, M., 1998. "Case Study". In: UML Toolkit (Ed.), New York, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
24. Henry S., and Humphrey M. Object-oriented vs. procedural programming languages: effectiveness in program maintenance. Journal of Object-Oriented Programming 6 3 (1993) 41-49
25. Holgeid K.K., Krogstie J., and Sjøberg D.I.K. A study of development and maintenance in Norway: assessing the efficiency of information systems support using functional maintenance. Information and Software Technology 42 10 (2000) 687-700
26. Hughes J., and Parkes S. Trends in the use of verbal protocol analysis in software engineering research. Behaviour and Information Technology 22 2 (2003) 127-140
27. Johnson R., and Foote B. Designing reusable classes. Journal of Object-Oriented Programming 1-2 (1988) 22-35
28. Karahasanovic A., Anda B., Arisholm E., Hove S.E., Jørgensen M., Sjøberg D.I.K., and Welland R. Collecting feedback during software engineering experiments. Empirical Software Engineering 10 2 (2005) 113-147
29. Karahasanovic, A., Hinkel, U.N., Sjøberg, D.I.K., Thomas, R., in press. Comparing of feedback collection and think-aloud methods in program comprehension studies. Behaviour and IT.
30. Khazaei B., and Jackson M. Is there any difference in novice comprehension of a small program written in the event-driven and object-oriented styles?. IEEE 2002 Symposia on Human Centric Computing Languages and Environments (2002) 19-26
31. Ko, A.J., Uttl, B., 2003. Individual differences in program comprehension strategies in unfamiliar programming systems. In: 11th IEEE International Workshop on Program Comprehension, pp. 175-184.
32. Koenemann J., and Robertson S.P. Expert problem solving strategies for program comprehension. SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems: Reaching Through Technology (1991), New Orleans, Louisiana, ACM Press, New York, NY, USA 125-130
33. Lehman M., and Belady L.A. Program Evolution - Processes of Software Change (1985), Academic Press, London
34. Lientz B.P. Issues in Software Maintenance. Computing Surveys 15 3 (1983) 271-278
35. Littman, D.C., Pinto, J., Letovski, S., Soloway, E., 1986a. Mental models and software maintenance. In: First Workshop on Empirical Studies of Programmers, Norwood, NJ, Ablex, pp. 80-98.
36. Littman D.C., Pinto J., Letovski S., and Soloway E. Mental models and software maintenance. In: Soloway E., and Iyengar S. (Eds). Empirical Studies of Programmers (1986), Norwood, NJ, Ablex 80-98
37. Mayer B. Object-Oriented Software Construction (1988), Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
38. Mosemann, R., Wiedenbeck, S., 2001. Navigation and comprehension of programs by novice programmers. In: IEEE 9th International Workshop on Program Comprehension (IWPC 2001), pp. 79-88.
39. Nosek J.T., and Prashant P. Software maintenance management: change in the last decade. Journal of Software Maintenance Research and Practice 2 3 (1990) 157-174
40. O'Brien, M.P., Buckley, J., 2001. Inference-based and expectation-based processing in program comprehension. In: 9th International Workshop on Program Comprehension, 2001, IWPC 2001, pp. 71-78.
41. Parkin P. An exploratory study of code and document interaction during task-directed program comprehension. Australian Software Engineering Conference (2004) 221-231
42. Pennington, N., 1987a. Comprehension strategies in programming. In: Empirical studies of programmers, Second Workshop, Ablex Publishing Corporation, pp. 100-113.
43. Pennington N. Stimulus structures and mental representations in experts comprehension of computer programs. Cognitive Psychology 19 (1987) 295-341
44. Pfleeger S.L. Software Engineering - The Production of Quality Software (1987), Macmillan
45. Rosson M.B., and Alpert S.R. The cognitive consequences of object-oriented design. Human-Computer Interaction 5 (1990) 345-379
46. Sheetz S.D. Identifying the difficulties of object-oriented development. The Journal of Systems and Software 64 (2002) 23-36
47. Shneiderman B., and Mayer R. Syntactic/semantic interactions in program behaviour: a model and experimental results. International Journal of Computer and Information Sciences 8 3 (1979) 219-238
48. Soloway, E., Adelson, B., Ehrlich, B., 1988. Knowledge and processes in the comprehension of computer programs". In: Chi, M. et al. (Ed.). The Nature of Expertise, pp. 129-152.
49. Storey, M.A., 2005. Theories, models and tools in program comprehension: past, present and future. In: 13th International Workshop on Program Comprehension, pp. 181-191.
50. Storey M.A., Fracchia F.D., and Muller H.A. Cognitive design elements to support the construction of a mental model during software exploration. Journal of Systems and Software 44 (1999) 171-185
51. Tegarden D.P., and Sheetz S.D. Cognitive activities in OO development. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 54 (2001) 779-798
52. Thomas, R., Kennedy, G., Draper, S., Mancy, R., Crease, M., Evans, H., Gray, P., 2003. Generic usage monitoring of programming students. In: ASCILITE 2003 Conference, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia, ASCILITE, pp. 715-719.
53. Torchiano, M., 2004. Empirical investigation of a non-intrusive approach to study comprehension cognitive models. In: Eighth European Conference on Software Maintenance and Reengineering, pp. 184-192.
54. Upchurch, R., 2002. Code reading and program comprehension: annotated bibliography. (accessed September 2006).
55. Von Mayrhauser, A., Vans, A.M., 1993. From code understanding needs to reverse engineering tool capabilities. In: Sixth International Workshop on Computer-Aided Software Engineering CASE'93, Singapore, pp. 230-239.
56. Von Mayrhauser A., and Vans A.M. Industrial experience with an integrated comprehension model. Software Engineering Journal (1995) 171-182
57. Von Mayrhauser A., and Vans A.M. Program comprehension during software maintenance and evolution. Computer 28 8 (1995) 44-55
58. Von Mayrhauser A., and Vans A.M. Identification of dynamic comprehension processes during large scale maintenance. IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering 22 6 (1996) 424-437
59. Von Mayrhauser, A., Vans, A.M., 1997. Hypothesis-driven understanding processes during corrective maintenance of large scale software. In: International Conference on Software Maintenance, pp. 12-20.
60. Van Someren M.W., Barnard Y.F., and Sandberg J.A.C. The Thinking Aloud Method: A Practical Guide to Model Cognitive Processes (1994), Academic Press, London
61. Wiedenbeck S., and Ramalingam V. Novice comprehension of small programs written in the procedural and object-oriented styles. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 51 (1999) 71-87
62. Wiedenbeck S., Ramalingam V., Sarasamma S., and Corritore C.L. A comparison of the comprehension of object-oriented and procedural programs by novice programmers. Interacting with Computers 11 (1999) 255-282
63. Zelkowitz M.V. Perspectives on software engineering. ACM Computing Surveys 10 2 (1978) 197-216