A qualitative approach to upward evaluation of leadership performance: Pros and cons

Journal of Academic Librarianship

Volumn 30, Issue 4, 2004, Pages 304-313

  Turrentine, Cathryn G ^a   Lener, Edward F ^b   Young, Michelle L ^b   Kok, Victoria T ^b  

^a VIRGINIA POLYTECHNIC INSTITUTE AND STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 3442885233     PISSN: 00991333     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.acalib.2004.04.004     Document Type: Article

References (33)

1. Wells Susan J. "A New Road: Traveling Beyond 360-Degree Evaluation" HRMagazine 44 1999 82-88
2. Atwater Leanne Waldman David "Accountability in 360 Degree Feedback" HRMagazine 43 1998 96-102
3. Atwater Leanne E. et al. "An Upward Feedback Field Experiment: Supervisors; Cynicism, Reactions, and Commitment to Subordinates" Personnel Psychology 53 2000 275-297
4. deLeon Linda Ewen Ann J. "Multi-Source Performance Appraisals" Review of Public Personnel Administration 17 1997 22-36
5. Guinn Stephen L. "Executive Development-Why Successful Executives Continue to Change" Career Development International 4 1999 240-243
6. Johnson Jeff W. Ferstl Kerri L. "The Effects of Interrater and Self-Other Agreement on Performance Improvement Following Upward Feedback" Personnel Psychology 52 1999 271-303
7. Osborne J.E. "Upward Evaluations: What Happens When Staffers Evaluate Supervisors" Supervisory Management 35 1990 1-2
8. Rubin Richard "The Development of a Performance Evaluation Instrument for Upward Evaluation of Supervisors by Subordinates" Library - Information Science Research 16 1994 315-328
9. Rubin Richard "Upward Appraisal: What Do Subordinates Consider Important in Evaluating Their Supervisors?" Library - Information Science Research 17 1995 151-161
10. Smither James W. et al. "An Examination of the Effects of an Upward Feedback Program Over Time" Personnel Psychology 48 1995 1-34
11. Walker Alan G. Smither James W. "A Five-Year Study of Upward Feedback: What Managers Do With Their Results Matters" Personnel Psychology 52 1999 393-423
12. Martin Jess A. "Staff Evaluation of Supervisors" Special Libraries 70 1979 26-29
13. Linkins Germaine C. "Department Head Evaluations: The Virginia Tech Experience" Journal of Library Administration 5 1984 53-59
14. Jaffe Martin Elliot Ives Sheila "They Shoot Supervisors, Don't They?" Library Journal 112 1987 116-118
15. Rubin, 1994
16. Pyrczak Fred Making Sense of Statistics: A Conceptual Overview 2nd ed. 2001 66-67 Pyrczak Publishing Los Angeles
17. Suskie Linda A. Questionnaire Survey Research; What Works 2nd ed. 1996 33 Association for Institutional Research Tallahassee, FL
18. Hitchingham Eileen "Appraisal Team for Evaluating Leadership Performance of the Library Directors and the Associate Dean" 2001 University Libraries Virginia Tech
19. Eileen Hitchingham, meeting with the appraisal team, August 30, 2001
20. Ibid., Eileen Hitchingham, meeting with the appraisal team, August 30, 2001
21. Linkins Germaine C. "Department Head evaluations: The Virginia Tech Experience" Journal of Library Administration 5 1983 53-59
22. Hall James L. Leidecker Joel K. DiMarco Christopher "What We Know about Upward Appraisals of Management: Facilitating the Future Use of UPAs" Human Resource Development Quarterly 7 1996 209-226
23. LaMountain Dianne "Things Are Looking Up" Small Business Reports 17 1992 11-12
24. Kouzes James M. Posner Barry Z. The Leadership Challenge: How to Keep Getting Extraordinary Things Done in Organizations 2nd ed. 1995 Jossey-Bass San Francisco
25. Mary Jane Santos, "An Examination of Standardized Evaluation Forms Used in Public Libraries to Evaluate Professional Librarians" (master's thesis, Kent State University, 1992)
26. Rubin, 1995
27. Manning, "Giving Voice," pp. 24-25
28. Nowack Kenneth M. Hartley Jeanne Bradley William "How to Evaluate Your 360 Feedback Efforts" Training - Development 53 4 1999 48-53
29. Manning Kathleen (Ed.), Giving Voice to Critical Campus Issues: Qualitative Research in Student Affairs 1999 16-17 American College Personnel Association Alexandria, VA
30. Kiesler Sara Sproull Lee S. "Response Effects in the Electronic Survey" Public Opinion Quarterly 50 1986 402-413
31. Waterton J.J. Duffy J.C. "A Comparison of Computer Interviewing Techniques and Traditional Methods in the Collection of Self-Reported Alcohol Consumption Data in a Field Survey" International Statistical Review 52 1984 173-182
32. B.D. McBrien, "The Role of the Personal Computer in Data Collection, Data Analysis, and Data Presentation: A Case Study" (paper presented to the 82nd ESOMAR Seminar, Nice, France, November 7-10, 1984)
33. Synodinos Nicolaos E. Brennan Jerry M. "Computer Interactive Interviewing in Survey Research" Psychology - Marketing 5 1988 117-137